Archived threads in /his/ - History & Humanities - 599. page
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
Was Khrushchev a villain or a hero?
On one hand, he's responsible for the de-Stalinization of the Soviet Union, thus saving the USSR from turning into a North Korea.
On the other hand, he's almost led the world into a new world war.
On one hand, he's responsible for igniting the Space Race, responsible for many of the technological leaps of the past century.
On the other hand, he considered avant-garde artists and musicians hacks and outright oppressed them and their art.
>>923657
>he considered avant-garde artists and musicians hacks and outright oppressed them and their art.
>actually using this as an example of something bad
>On the other hand, he's almost led the world into a new world war.
I don't think you can quite blame the old man for that as the reason he placed Missiles in Cuba to rach the east coast was that the USA placed missiles in Turkey to reach Moscow.
>>923657
PRO:
>Destalinization
>Liberalization
>Economic reforms attempt
>Serious quality of life improvements
>Spess and rokkits
CONTRA:
>Stupid Soviet grandiose projects
>Royally pissed off party elites
>Cuban missile crisis and shit
Pissed off elites...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
Can we get a serious, non-/pol/ thread about the Palestinian Exodus (Naqba) from what became Israel in 1948?
Efraim Karsh on the Arab armies inciting Palestinians to leave their homes: https://web.archive.org/web/20140224112045/http://www.kcl.ac.uk/artshums/depts/mems/people/staff/academic/karsh/articles/WerethePalestiniansExpelled.pdf
Ilan Pappé on ethnic cleansing by Zionist forces: http://www.bintjbeil.com/articles/en/021020_pappe.html
Benny Morris on the "four wave" analysis of Palestinian exodus: http://jeffweintraub.blogspot.ca/2008/02/benny-morris-on-fact-fiction-propaganda.html
Benny...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
As a Palestinian from the West Bank, I never really dealt with such things, although some here are mentally ready for another similar scenario.
It's sad when you're talking to some guy, and when asked where he's from, he says
>My family is originally from X village, but we live in Y town now.
These people don't forget their roots, and many people have names related to their original village.
I had a friend in school whose family name was "il-Yaseeni" from Deir Yassin.
I remember some Palestinian talking...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>924266
Had a Palenstinian friend who joked about how they'd only marry people on the same street as them.
THIS LAND IS MINE, GOD GAVE THIS LAND TO ME !!
Are there any good places to learn about how different societies reacted to each others' foods?
I'm talking about how the natives of America tasted beef for the first time, how western traders reacted to Chinese foods. How the British reacted to curries. About how when the Japanese gave up isolation and sent out diplomatic parties, how they reacted to the food they were given. How India grew to love the chili pepper. How Korea, the Hermit Kingdom, integrated peppers into their daily cuisine.
>>923334
>how western traders reacted to Chinese foods.
tl;dr
>DA SPICES???? WHERE U GET????
>>923356
Not the whole broad economic view of setting up the spice trade or whatever.
Individual reactions to the dishes they were eating.
>>923334
I heard that when the Spanish conquistadors first encountered the potato, they heard from the Incas that it was an edible plant, and tried eating the fruits (which are poisonous) and got sick. I can't find a source for this story, but I have read that the potato met some resistance in Europe, because people thought it was bad for you and caused disease.
It is completely impossible for you to prove me wrong.
>>923238
True, but we can still do science woth falsificationism, so the problem doesn't disturb our lives as much as one might think it does.
Is he as big of a asshole as he's made out to be /his/? Is his reputation as the demon king justified?
>>923156
Burning down a Monastery and slaughtering the peasant supporters was a dick move. But DESU the Buddhist Monasteries of Japan were Sectarian Feudal Lords of their own right and were dicks as well.
Japs did not like him due to bringing in Barbarian Euronig influences.
>>923156
He really wasn't different from other competing daimyo as far as I can tell. He was just a little more of an asshole about it.
>>923159
>Japs did not like him due to bringing in Barbarian Euronig influences.
I never fucking understood this.
>Ok with Chinkshit.
>Not Ok with Euroshit (Guns & some other gadgets b cool tho).
Why does /his/ like Plotinus so much?
>Why doesn't /his/ like Plotinus more?
FTFY
I see more Marx and Stirner more often. The right-wing seems to focus more on religious (Christian) debates, even though the Church owns a large chunk of its philosophy to Platonism.
Dionysus, for example, quoted Proclus verbatim without naming his source and was considered an authority by the Church for many centuries.
Augustine said in his confessions that "the books of the Platonists" played a part in his conversion. You would think, why not convert to paganism...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
Romefag here, got a shit ton of books on ancient Rome, and loved "The History of Rome Podcast".
After I finished that I looked for more history podcasts, and have greatly enjoyed the "History of China Podcast". Now I am looking for good recommendations on ancient Chinese history books, preferably something more over-arching to begin before getting anything on specific dynasties or eras.
>Pic related, saw these neat bastards when I went to the Chicago Field museum 2 weeks ago, They had a cool ancient Greek exhibit there too...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
Cambridge Illustrated History of China is fantastic.
Its a proper book but there are a tonne of high quality pictures.
>>922630
>reading
Are you some kind of nerd? Podcasts and documentaries are the only acceptable mediums of acquiring knowledge
>>922649
thanks, I'll pick that up for sure.
Why were the Mongols so destructive? How were they able to take on and essentially destroy the scientific capitals of the world in the middle east? How did they create such a dominant military presence in Asia, essentially forcing their presence in the gene pool in countries that are now the likes of Pakistan and India?
>>922436
The Mongs had 0 to do with the Mughal Dynasty.
The only thing "Mongol" about it was its founder, Babur, being descended from Genghis Khan via his great great grandmama's side. Babur himself did not think he was a Mongol, but a Muslim Prince. In fact he detested mongols as they were barbarians.
>>922436
Multiculturism and open border policies weakened those nations that promoted such liberal values. So its no surprise those are the nations that fell first to the mongols, even with all their "advanced" science and knowledge.
>>922455
Multiculturalism? As far as I know, the middle east , up to Iran, maybe even Afghanistan has for the most part of history been pretty multicultural. Multiculturalism has always been at the very heart of those societies, as race didn't make a difference in your social class. I am aware that slavery was obviously present in history, but race wasn't a factor, and darker skinned peoples weren't considered lower races on a pan-societal level. Over simplifying the situation and blaming "multiculturalism"...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
How could someone seriously claim that consumption isn't high enough? What an absolutely fucking disgusting thought.
Please educate me.
>>922316
Spending = income. If there's a sudden drop in spending, there will necessarily be a drop in income.
The problem is, wages are sticky, if the business loses money people don't all take a pay cut, they get fired.
More people getting fired -> even less spending -> more people getting fired.
The way out of this is to just step in and make sure spending doesn't drop (through government spending, typically).
Did the founding fathers of the USA ever say anything about government surveillance and privacy?
The issue of privacy was literally one of the driving forces of the American revolution.
"Those who would give up liberty to gain Security deserve neither, and will lose both" seems to be be quote most commonly tossed around.
![ayn_rand[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/oab5kCG.jpg "ayn_rand[1].jpg")
Was she right?
>>922159
objectivistly no
Do we have to have one of these daily?
Certainly wasn't left.
>And so, in conclusion, I believe I have amply demonstrated that "Your Mother", also sometimes referred to as "Yo momma" and "Dat Bitch" was not an actual, historic figure, but rather a composite character, formed from the melding of many mothers, and thus forming a non-human battery of traits such as excessive weight, sluttishness, and stupidity. Any questions?
what are you trying to say
>>922021
You've seen the evidence. We have gigabytes of data, transcribed onto thousands of pages, that refer to this figure of "Your mother". She was not an actual, living, breathing person. She was never a historic personage. She was a composite. All references to "Your mother" should be read carefully, in the proper historic context, and with the understanding that very likely, each of them refers to a different woman, if they even refer to a woman at all.
>>922013
JESUS WUZ HISTORICAL AND SHIT
Which was Trotsky and which was Stalin?
doesn't matter, would be a false equivalency either way
Philosophy feels thread
Pic related
>tfw transcendentalism feels like the answer and its being undermined "modern" nihilism
>>921972
Feels are overrated.
Become indifferent towards everything and you'll find true happiness.
>>921999
but happiness is a feeling, your statement contradicts itself
>>922080
Or does it?
ITT Death's Greatest Hits
