Archived threads in /his/ - History & Humanities - 232. page
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
Is it still the ship of Theseus once all of its pieces are replaced?
If you replace piece by piece, then yes.
If you take the whole thing apart and built it again, then no.
>>1280986
Theseus and Greek Heroes- if they even existed- most likely sailed in Pre-Classical Greek Ships.
Remember: everything in Greek Myth supposedly happened in ancient times for the Classical Greeks
>>1280986
It stopped being Theseus' ship as soon as Theseus died
ok, let's settle this once and for all, which country performed more embarrassing in ww2, France or Italy?
>>1280979
Italy of course. Hands down.
They fucking turned tail and went AMERICA IS OF LIBERATORS! when the first American troops set foot in Italian Soil.
>>1280984
French did it twice.
>>1281050
In one case it was only the Govrnment and in the other it was someone who wanted to free them from German occupation.
On the topic of religion
when and how did the Islamic Golden Age end?
A lot of texts I've read made me infer that Al-Ghazali's anti-rationalism combined with the Mongol sacking of Baghdad were the coup the grâce to Islamic intellectualism.
But what preceded this death? And is my conclusion valid?
>>1280930
As far as I know the idea that Al-Ghazali caused the end of the era was first made by an amateur physics professor writing a book on the history of philosophy, but I haven't found any actual argument to support that. It seems unlikely.
What I believe happened was that the madrasa became increasingly standardized, patronage of which steadily replaced patronage of individual thinkers. The later madrasa had no place for advanced non-religious sciences, so these were pushed into the private homes of scholars...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>1280930
Wrongo.
It ended with the decline of the Abbasids in the 900's AD and the coming of the Turkics. The Abbasids tottered into a collection of Islamic Princedoms who were far more busy fighting each other than doing knowledge n shiet nigga.
>>1281227
>angry mobs of Sufi mystics
But aren't sufis supposed to be bro tier according to 4chan?
Jews had 4000 years to give legit arguments of why their god is real.
Christians had 2000 years to give legit arguments of why their god is real.
Muslims had 1400 years to give legit arguments of why their god is real.
Magic is the answer.
This thread shall doubtlessly be riveting.
>>1280737
In fact, it should.
>>1280718
Actually their arguments were and are even more stupid than that.
> Not stabbing the beast in the heart
> Not taking the centers of the Muslim world, Damascus, Baghdad, Alexandria, Cairo.
> Spooked into running after "the Holy Land"
We might have the the advantage of hindsight, but surely there were at least some people that knew Egypt was a power base for many Muslim dynasties?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusader_invasions_of_Egypt
Egypt was one of the first territories conquered by the Arabs.
How would've...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>1280385
Thats why Saint Louis marched to Egypt, cause he was told that taking Jersusalem was like "trying to hold a lion from the tail".
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seventh_Crusade
They only went on Crusade to save their soul because of all the killing they were doing in Europe.
>>1280385
Was already attempted as mentioned by the other anon
>How would've a successful invasion of Egypt changed history?
Same way the sack of baghdad did.
What was the legal basis for sentencing Pétain to death? How can signing an armistice be high treason?
>>1280362
Treason
>>1280362
Legally, he was condemned for endowing himself with the full powers that the French Assembly had voted on him, which is an unconstitutional act (I'm foreign to its true specifics, but that was the legal conjecture by which the french government absolved itself of the crimes of Vichy, by asserting that the rise of Vichy was unconstitutional) and he should've known better than to seize this power.
Also, on a symbolic side, him offering an armistice was perceived as traitorous because it doomed the french...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>1280362
The Gaullist narrative, mostly.
>We totally won the war ! Vichy was not France !
why did hitler spend resources and soldiers on jews , couldn't he have left them alone until he could capture some states? isnt that the rational thing to do?
Because he needed them as a scapegoat to be punished to further advance his goals.
> couldn't he have left them alone until he could capture some states
uh, that's what happened
>>1280253
Audio recordings of hitler speaking with his staff show that they greatly underestimated the USSR, as far as they new everything would go fine.
Why don't western Europeans feel any sense of kinship with eastern Europeans? I see the west being really chummy with each other, but they seem to bully the east. And Europe's history is full of the west fucking over the east, especially with that Constantinople thing.
>that Constantinople thing
care to elaborate?
>>1279906
East has had to much turk and mongol couk to be considered european
>>1279912
It's difficult to imagine Constantinople falling if they didn't get sacked by their fellow Christians going on a Crusade. That incident weakened Byzantium making them easy prey for Ottomans.
Also, most of Europe didn't really help much as Constantinople was getting sieged by Ottomans.
Obviously the West had its reasons, but its still notable that a lot of the things that the West does in relation to the East tends to fuck the East over, intentional or not.
Christans of /his/, orthodox , catholic and protestants. How do you maintain your faith given all the contradictions and historical evidence that goes against the bible? How do you keep believing that Jesus was the son of god when, historically, he was most likely just an apoclitpic prophet and follower of John the Babtist who preached of end times in which Jews would reclaim their land from the Romans? How do you still believe you have free will despite god knowing your future? How does it make sense that Jesus died for things he already knew we were going to do?
tl;dr...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>1279818
a single bump.
>don't respond to retard threads
>>1279818
Well, I'm no longer a Christian due to completely unrelated circumstances, but let me try to address what I can from my upbringing and my current faith.
>How do you maintain your faith given all the contradictions and historical evidence that goes against the bible?
Faith is something stronger than evidence. I have faith in my gods because of what I've experienced and because of how I feel. I imagine the same goes for Christians. Also, if you take their doctrine...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
lets get going I want to see what you guys have
>>1279813
Historical as in drawn around the time period or just cool art relating to history?
>>1279825
Cool art relating to history
>>1279830
I'll post a few more then and come back later. If anybody has some cool WW2 shit willing to post please do.
FDR signing the declaration of war on Germany. Who are the people behind him?
You already know the answer OP
According to a description of this photo:
>Surrounded by congressional leaders president Roosevelt signed the declaration of war against Japan at his white house desk in Washington on Dec. 8, 1941, plunging the U.S. into its second war in 24 years soberly watching are (Left to right) : Rep. Luther Martin (D-tex), Rep. Harles A. Eaton (R-N.J.) Rep. Joseph E. Martin (R-Mass) : Vice- President Henry A. Wallace, speaker Sam Rayburn Rep. John McCormack Sen. Charles L. McNary (R-ORE) Sen. Alben W. Barkley (D-KY). (AP Photo)
>>1279808
Why were the others cropped out?
>Wovon man nicht sprechen kann, darüber muß man schweigen.
What did he mean by this?
Why did you abandon your blog, you piece of shit? No one wanted that stupid book about porn, and now we don't even get the articles.
Pp iwanted to read the porn book
What were his best posts?
Salve, my name is Meximedius.
I’m a 21 year old Ottoman Romanophile (Roman fan for you barbarians). I assemble mosaics and write poetry, and spend my days perfecting my art and reading superior Greco-Latin literature. (Julius Caesar, Cicero, Homer)
I train with my Paramerion every day, this superior weapon can cut clean through steel because it is folded over a thousand times, and is vastly superior to any other weapon on earth. I started getting tutored in the art of the sword 8 years ago, and I have been getting better every day.
I speak the languages...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
100%
That kid is gonna be a Roman emperor someday
>>1279604
It would have worked if turks converted to Orthodox Christianity. Then you'd have an Ottoman-led Roman Empire, which would have been the coolest thing ever, maybe able to land in Italy due to increased stability brought by having a population of the same religion.
TL;DR: Islam is cancer
>dude history lmao
How did anyone take this clown seriously?
>>1279210
Because this faggot right here.
Was surviving the black death the best thing that could possibly happen to a peasant?
>all this vacant land
>nobility can't push you around anymore
>qt's everywhere ready to be impregnated
not peasant but everyone
>tfw when no medieval gf
>>1279076
I fucked up
