Archived threads in /his/ - History & Humanities - 482. page
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
Twenty pounds
Twenty pounds I paid on impulse for this thing
>pounds
Pounds of what? Please use US dollars instead of some monopoly money.
Here's the second page to get a feel for how this book analyzes history
>>1067879
oh fuck
Hello, /his/. I've been having a thought that I can't quite just put down, so I wanted to share it with you and ask what you think of it.
Suppose I have a device. This device is capable of taking an object, making a note of its qualities and quantities at the moment, and then later forcing the object in question back to that noted state. To visualize this, imagine a sink: it starts empty, you can fill it with all sorts of things, and then you can remove or drain those things to bring it back to how it was when you started.
Now, imagine this device is...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>1067233
>Is this not, in effect, time travel?
No.
So much text for such easy question.
>>1067250
Why not?
Everything is exactly as before, with no memories of anything happening. If someone were to prevent their memories from becoming tampered, would that not be the equivalent of traveling back through time?
>>1067260
The effect is not produced by "traveling through time", but by atomic reshuffling, therefore it isn't "time travel".
It isn't that difficult to comprehend.
Are foxes "domesticateable"? No?
Cuz Russians managed to domesticate them.
Jaredcucks btfo
I guess it's theoretically possible to achieve, by breeding those which are most tame and affectionate to humans for lots of generations.
But if you're really claiming they've domesticated foxes to a similar level as cats and dogs I'm going to need some proof.
>>1066811
Better question, why exactly would you want to domesticate a fox? They smell like piss and make everything around them smell like piss.
Oh wait, the piss bottles in your room probably have the same effect. Fuck off foxcuck.
>>1066840
>Better question, why exactly would you want to domesticate a fox?
This, they aren't pack animals like dogs, and if you have to feed them yourself, then they aren't as economical as a cat.
What are some /his/ approves Alternate history books?
>>1066172
>Alternate history
>Good
>Ever
>>1066172
Go to /lit/ for recommendations in the fiction genre.
This one tbqh.
The Indian Ocean is severely underrated. Let's have a thread about it. Discuss anything relevant, whether it's ancient Roman trade with India or 17th century American pirates.
Why do you the Portuguese were able to dominate this whole ocean so easily in just over a decade? Between 1497 and 1511 they took Hormuz, Goa, Sofala, Kilwa, and Malacca, which might sound like a bunch of random place names, but they were among the greatest ports in the world at the time.
Personally, I'd say it was because the Portuguese came from between the Atlantic and Mediterranean,...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
good post OP. I don't have enough knowledge to contribute, so here's a bump
>>1065660
Thank you friendo.
>>1065561
Another factor to consider is that Portugal had no real European competitor in the Indian Ocean. Portugal had a fantastic naval tradition built up by Henry the Navigator and more experience navigating around the african coast than any other country in the world really. Spain had set its focus on the Americas and it took several more decades for the other European powers to start competing.
The drive to conquer these places was immense. Literally the worlds riches were in Indonesia and India, so Portugal would...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
why are the mongols so based, /his/?
>tfw I'll never be born in the saddle
>tfw I'll never ride the plains of the steppes
>tfw I'll never meet my qt oneitis
>tfw she'll never be my top advisor
>tfw I'll never unite the warring tribes under one banner
>tfw I'll never erupt from the womb of nations and pacify the world with steel and blood
anyone...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>1063196
they did some pretty impressive military shit for sure, but i would never want to be born into mongolian """culture"""
>>1063196
>Wanting another man's sloppy seconds
>Raising his cuck child as your firstborn
Mongolian culture a shit.
>>1063249
tbf it's not like the kidnapper didn't get his sloppy seconds first
>Be Napoleon Bonaparte
>Tribunat, Senate, and Plebiscite decide I should be called Emperor instead of Consul for life
>lol what's the difference?
>some countrymen pissed they fought revolution for nothing
>suddenly get genius idea to appease revolutionaries
>illegally kidnap a random, distant Bourbon in another country and execute him for no reason
B R A V O N A P O L E O...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
Fuck the Bourbons tbqhwyf
>>1061531
>How did this man come up with this masterful political move??
Sprung forth from his realization that everyone else was retarded and gay
>>1061531
>for no reason
You mean aside from the fact he was organizing terrorist attacks?
![maxresdefault[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/Z3j5tZo.jpg "maxresdefault[1].jpg")
Was Cao Cao truly as brutal as people claimed him to be or was he just hated because he wasn't traditional leader?
Was Liu Bei only liked because he was pro-Han?
>>1054751
Liu Bei fapping is only prominent in Southern China.
Cao Cao meanwhile is a hero in the North. He is also remembered as a poet. Him and one of his sons, Cao Zhi (who was more famous as a poet.)
>>1054751
>Was Liu Bei only liked because he was pro-Han?
Lord Cao was more pro-Han than Liu Bei could ever hope to be. Lord Cao spent thirty of his life years fighting battle after battle, all for the sake of Han. He literally devoted his life to the cause of restoring Han.
He's hated because his reputation for deceptive maneuvers on the battlefield made it easy to slap his name onto the "evil trickster" stock character archetype in any random made-up story any common storyteller...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>1054751
Reminder that Cao Cao did not usurp the Han. Cao Pi did, because Cao Pi was worthless and became a puppet to Sima Yi, just like the Han emperor was a puppet to Cao Cao, and Sima Yi's son usurped Cao-Wei.
>>1054840
Also propaganda. Current ruling dynasties usually try to make the dynasty that ruled before bad, and the dynasty before that or opposition to it good.
Why are Vikings venerated so much?
They weren't nice, they weren't cultured, they weren't worth ANYTHING. Yet people focus on them with the same sort of puerile psychology found in Chad worship. Why?
They had culture. Look at forn seidr and all their skaldic poetry. Look at their wood, stone, and metalwork.
They're venerated because never has any group of people (who wasn't from rome) throughly subjugated europe, and objectively they were handsome. Compared to Non-germanic skulls, Scandinavia skulls exhibit a high level of facial symmetry. Plus, thanks to a warm period, the vikes grew taller than most continentals. And as their society was merit driven (yeah, the modern Scandinavian obsession with taking part in society goes back further than this); a rando...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>1061150
why do you make this thread every day?
literally nobody in history was nice and we love them all the more for it
You're Hitler. What next? Can you still win the war?
>>1058658
Okay I'll make defensive lines towards Russia but I mobilize most of my troops toward Western Yurop. I tell Norway to invade Iceland and if they're successful, move down against Scotland where the Germany Navy and Airforce will move upwards from the south, completely surrounding Britain.
Once Britain is surrounded completely, we invade, destroy Britain, conquer it, and then wait for the Americans and Canadians to arrive.
Meanwhile I put some of my other troops from the Western Front into...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>1058658
At this stage in the war, not even Hitler knew he could win. At best he was hoping for a white peace or a stalemate
>>1058680
With what navy do you invade with? Even if you somehow land a force massive enough to beat the British, how do you resupply them, dodging the fire of the superior RAF while at the same time avoiding the laughably superior RN?
Was there ever a way for Native Americans to prevent European colonization?
>no guns
>no metal tools / weapons
>no large scale organized military (except maybe the Incas?)
>hugely susceptible to European diseases
I've tried to think of ways that the NAs could have stopped the Europeans but just can't think of one
Maybe they could have fought off some of the initial settlers but if the Europeans started coming in greater...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>1037382
>Be mayan/Aztec
>Spaniards arrive
>Decide not to freak out as they insult your culture.
>Welcome them with open arms
>Show willingness to trade and consider allowing missionaries.
>Trade tonnes of gold for knowledge of metalworking, guns, other important shit.
>If Spain gets uppity invite Portugal...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>1037407
>welcome the Spanish
>contract various diseases
>Spanish decide that they would rather take your shit than trade with human sacrificing savages
>everyone who survived the new diseases is either killed outright or otherwise subjugated
>your wife is now choking on Spanish dick 24/7
>>1037407
>Welcome them with open arms
Isn't that what Montezuma did and the Spaniards ended up systematically killing most of the Aztec commanders while they were unarmed during a festival?
What are the most epic naval battles in history?
>>1064322
Salamis
>>1064322
Any naval battle in the 17th and 18th centuries was epic as it gets. Earlier sea vessels were comparatively small time, and later ones were so gigantic that they were used for support, intimidation and strategic bombardment, so ship-on-ship combat was somewhat more rare and less exciting.
>>1064322
The Spanish Armada.
Queen Elizabeth I of England had increasingly become a figurehead for the Protestant struggle in France and the Netherlands, where the Dutch were in revolt against Spanish rule. Her subjects had enraged the Spanish King by raiding his American possessions and even the coastline of Spain itself: Drake sacked Cadiz in 1587 and the Earl of Leicester was leading an English contingent assisting the Dutch revolt in the Netherlands.
The Pope excommunicated Elizabeth and issued an encyclical...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
So why didn't the vikings stick around in North America?
Because Injuns fucked their shit up.
>>1060562
I don't think that the Norse settlements that were found up in Newfoundland were permanent to begin with. More like temporary stops or warehouses than residences, if I remember correctly. Anyways, a combination of fighting with the skrælings, if the sagas are to be believed, and environmental pressures probably kept the small number of Norsemen who were sailing around the area from pitching their tents for the long haul.
>>1060562
Too far away and dangerous to set up trade.
Too cold and hostile maintain their lifestyle
What /his/'s opinion on Austria-Hungary? What can you tell me about it?
>>1060052
Neglected military and not a nation-state.
That's all I know, I really like the Hapsburgs but idk much in this period of their history except for WWI.
>>1060062
>/his/ opinion
When the board started there were numerous threads on the subject and people were kind of fucking maymaying it like it was 10/10 GOAT-tier. We then agreed it was fucking shit. There some /A-U/tists still lurking tho
>what can you tell me about it
Read A.J.P. Taylor's book on it, it's the best work I know on the subject
>>1060075
>We agreed it was fucking shit
Why? Why was it shit? Looked like it had pretty big lands to me.
> The Dutch politician Pim Fortuyn, killed in early May 2002, two weeks before he was expected to gain one-fifth of the vote, was a paradoxical figure: a right-wing populist whose personal attributes and opinions (for the most part) were almost perfectly “politically correct”: He was gay, had good personal relations with many immigrants and possessed an innate sense of irony, etc.—in short, he was a good, tolerant liberal with regard to everything except his basic political stance. He opposed fundamentalist immigrants because of their lack of tolerance...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
Fuck Milo Yiannopolis.
He's probably the most dangerous personality around right now.
Trying to normalize the Neo-Nazis and fascists on the Alt-Right detracts from both the true nature of the Alt-Right (i.e. it doesn't care about tolerance and people like Milo are only tolerated because "muh Jews, we need a gay man to say these things," not because anyone on the Alt-Right thinks he's cool). He's a piece of shit.
Perhaps he has to get AIDS.
>>1069844
Still doesn't convince me that Zizek isn't just a liberal trying to annoy other liberals.
>>1069865
Dude is a closeted tranny train wreck. He's gonna transition or kill himself soon
