Archived threads in /his/ - History & Humanities - 990. page
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
God-Tier
- Scholagladiatoria
- Lindybeige
High-tier
- THFE(?) Productions - mostly gaming, but a few good historical stuff. Games surprisingly good for visuals.
Low tier
- Skallagrim - decent stuff, but a little too concerned with muh shaming. Seems like a good chap overall though.
Shit tier:
- John Green
Make additions pls
>>400042
What's so bad about John Meme?
>>400058
Mostly put him there as a meme, desu; realistically, he should go on low tier.
>viewing non-recent history through the lens of modern morality
The school of Life is pretty good in my opinion, but it's more about history of philosophy and political thought
Was Charlemagne a real person?
>>399902
It's a well known fact that most people who lived before the invention of history in 1823 are considered to be mythical and not real.
Define 'real'
>>400014
Define 'define 'real''.
>To say that life is nothing but a property of certain peculiar combinations of atoms is like saying Hamlet is nothing but a property of a peculiar combination of letters.
Where were you when scientism got BTFO?
>>399724
Both those statement are true
>>399724
>Hamlet isn't made up of letters.
What the fuck OP, that is exactly what Hamlet is.
Was the mutual population exchange a mistake?
I find the ethic cleansing in Anatolia to be a total tragedy. What would that region of the world look like today had Greece managed to secure this land before it was scrubbed of Greeks? What would a modern day Turkey look like with virtually no Western coast?
>tfw the city that straddles the Bosphorus isn't called Constantinople
Step aside gr**k
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SP3CF6YBU_8
>>399716
The greeks fucked up by invading anatolianif they didn't turkey would still have a sizable greek minority to this day.
>>399716
It wasn't a mistake. It was either that or continued extermination and neither the Greeks, the now communist Russia or the world would do anything about it, so you might as well salvage what you had left and get rid of muslims.
What actually was a mistake was thinking Turkey was civilized and would follow its treaties and thus exempting Greeks and muslims in Thrace and Imbros-Tenedos from the transfer, who the Turks pogrommed the shit up as soon as they got the chance.
>>400304
Just...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
I saw a news article which confused me and i need the help of some historians.
Do the native French exist or not?
>>399608
The "native" French would be white, and white people cannot be natives.
Ergo, no Native French exist.
>>399612
Yeah the French high court just dismissed the concept of native French people.
>>399608
This is actually interesting because It puts the question regarding the division in ethnicity and nationality under the lupp.
Take the UK. You have Englishmen, Scotsmen and so on, and you would be able to say "I'm ethnicity English".
But it would be odd to say "I'm ethnicity British", wouldn't it? British is a national identity, not an technical.
Someone please correct me if I'm completely off.
![ww1-minerva-armoured-car[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/AauIvGm.jpg "ww1-minerva-armoured-car[1].jpg")
How were armoured cars used and deployed in WW1? From what I imagine surely the terrain and the combat wouldn't really allow for these old cars to be driving around in.
>>398833
Hey fuck you, you weren't there man. We tried our best, alright?
>>398833
When Emperor Franz Josef was shown an armored car, he went "Such a thing would not have a military value."
Because
1) It was slower than a horse
2) It scared horses.
Early tanks mostly got bogged down, but they were used largely like they are today; as cover for infantry and clearing mg nests and other entrenched positions.
Later they used to carry large hay bales to help tanks cross trenches.
>ywn explore the world in the 15th century in your 9-mast, 440' treasure ship, giving and receiving extravagant gifts at all corners of the earth
>ywn be Zheng He or any of his 28,000-man crew
for what purpose
>>398815
holy shit that chink tub must have rolled in heavy seas, and the structure must have come under some strain. also: slow as fuck. i'd be interested to see if it could replicate the journey to north america against the gulf stream.
>>398841
they demolished everything in sight and travelled from Nanjing to Mogadishu and Mecca. The only reason the technology didn't spread is that they were only built for 30 years or so, until confucian ministers decided the money was better spent on agriculture. Not sure how the Indian Ocean compares to the Atlantic tho
Other gigantor ships incoming:
Thalamegos, 377' long and 66' high, an early catamaran (twin hull) commissioned by Ptolemy for him and his wife alone.
is the following statement true or false? why?
>Biblical Criticism has proven the bible to be a product of many different authors, most like not the ones named (Moses, Luke, Matthew etc), and many of the events of the OT and the NT are unlikely to have ever happened. Jesus was probably a very different figure from the one presented by tradition and Higher Criticism has proven false many claims of the established Christian tradition.
>proven
picture of sweaty fat young man with bad acne and pubes for facial hair dressed all in black and placing his hand on the brim of a 1940s style hat in preparation of a tipping action.jpg
>>398716
I don't get it.
>>398706
Different Men inspired with the Holy Spirit (God) wrote the Bible. Daniel wrote the book of Daniel, Isaiah wrote the book of Isaiah, the Apostle John wrote the book of John etc
* https://archive.org/details/AmericanCapitalism16071800
* https://archive.org/details/TheFirstAmericanRevolution
* https://archive.org/details/TheStruggleForAmericanFreedom
* https://archive.org/details/TheRiseOfTheAmericanNation
* https://archive.org/details/JosephWeydemeyerPioneerOfAmericanSocialism
* https://archive.org/details/WilliamHSylvisAndTheNationalLaborUnion
* https://archive.org/details/ThePopulistMovementInTheUnitedStates
* https://archive.org/details/GeneDebs
* https://archive.org/details/HistoryOfTheUSASinceWorldWarI
* https://archive.org/details/AmericanYouthToday
*...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
so many...
>>398679
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/An_Economic_Interpretation_of_the_Constitution_of_the_United_States
Not really Marxist per se but very "Marxoid".
>implying North-American academics can into dialectics anyway
>>398679
Thank you, OP, for not including Howard Zinn. Much appreciated.
Does she deserves all the praise she gets or she is just being pushed as an ancient feminist icon?
Does it really matter if the praise is warranted or not? This isn't even something that would be interesting to discuss, it's just lame gay subversive shit talk.
This will always devolve into two sides of the same retarded coin spouting shit.
>>398653
>Brings women and children to Sack London
>Has som 100,000 soldiers against the Romans 10,000
>"Lets attack in a frontal assault on an open field against an enemy who's entire military culture was built to counter such a scenario
>What could go wrong :DDDD
>Gets utterly rekt with the Romans barely suffering any casualties.
Seleucid tier leadership at best.
Ethiopia
>Slavery was fundamental to the social, political and economic order of medieval Ethiopia. Racism in the territory was traditionally mainly directed at the Nilotic ethnic minorities, as well as other individuals with similarly pronounced "Negroid" physical features. Collectively, these groups are locally known as Shanqella or barya, derogatory terms originally denoting slave descent, irrespective of the individual's family history.[4][5]
Slaves in Ethiopia, 19th century.
Historically, the Shanqella constituted...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>398580
source
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_Ethiopia#Legacy
Slave girl in Mali
>>398591
No one ever denied this and it doesn't justify colonisation
What are you doing my son?
>>398214
Mirin' those facial aesthetics brah
>>398221
He always looks so disapproving in statues. Like he silently judging you.
Didn't Marcus Aurelius fuck the empire over by taking the senate out of Rome and making it travel with him which in turn somehow allowed people later on to claim to be emperor and start civil wars much more easily?
Hi guys. I'd like to learn history through audiobooks. I want to have an overall knowledge of history from prehistory to the mid 20th century.
I don't really know where to start. What would be some good audiobooks that I could listen to? Thanks.
>Hi
>audiobooks
>I'd like to learn history through audiobooks.
>I don't really know where to start.
Here's a start: learn to read books like everyone else, because you're not going to learn anything just by listening. Reading entails the compulsion to read (which implies you actually care about the subject) and the pace you set, and you're probably not going to rewind that audiobook if you stop listening momentarily, whereas...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>I want to have an overall knowledge of history from prehistory to the mid 20th century.
is this the 'i listen to everything but country and rap' of history?
>>398258
You're an asshole
If you truly love the subject you should feel aroused that someone wants to get into it with his own means. This is a general board, learn some manners
>>398190
Librivox has few books related to history, I have started listening to "Geronimo's life" and it's petty good (even if I do it more like a listening exercise).
If you happen to know italian I would suggest you the historicast's collection.
Do christians put jesus over god?
muslims praise god all the time but christians seem to only praise jesus.
Why is that?
Shouldn't an omnipotent all powerful being be more important than any human.
>>398058
b8 thread I know
But as far as I know, to most major denominations of Christianity, Jesus = God.
>>398062
How is this a bait thread, does anything that doesn't fit your worldview automatically wrong? if so how do you learn?
Jesus wasn't god, he wasn't all powerful. He was superhuman for sure but if he was god he could easily will away all his problems.
>>398072
>posts le epic atheist picture
>pretends to be stupid in OP, asking obvious questions
>HOW IS THIS BAIT??????
Yeah.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trinity
>God as three consubstantial persons,[2] expressions, or hypostases:[3] the Father, the Son (Jesus Christ), and the Holy Spirit; "one God in three persons". The three persons are distinct, yet are one "substance, essence...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
It's that time again, /his/.
Ask and comment about Hesychasm, Theoria, Theosis, Essence-Energies, Liturgics, anything that comes to mind.
>>397494
Why aren't you a sufi or a zen buddhist?
Why does orthodox mysticism lack a riddle tradition like buddhism or islam?
God is supremely good. Of all creation that is capable of rational thought and free will, some are friends to God, some are His true servants, some are estranged, and there are others who, despite their weakness, take their stand against Him. We might imagine that God's friends are those angelic beings which surround him (Seraphim, Cherubim etc...). His true servants are those who sincerely attempt to do His will to the best of their ability. The estranged are those who have not yet met Christ. His opponents are those who go out of their way to attack Him and those who...
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
>>397512
The angelic friends of God live in a higher plane of existence which is uncorrupted by sin. These beings are capable of rational thought and attempt to influence our plane of existence when they can. Of course they are not omnipotent so their influence is limited to what God permits. The blessed man attempts to mirror his life to those angelic beings (who are themselves imitators of Christ). In his mind, the Christian attempts to spiritually raise himself up to heaven and perceive the world as Christ did, then act accordingly....
Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.
