Story, graphics, gameplay, everything is in there.
The content of the DLC is fucking amazing, and it's only worth 10 euros.
Is the Witcher the best game this generation offered us?
Witcherfags are so fucking annoying.
>>339935158
>storyfags
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>Story, graphics, gameplay, everything is in there.
They're in there, but they're not good.
>>339935158
Yes, OP just playing Blood and Wine, shits so colourful!
GOTYAY
I get it, casuals love their open world walking simulators with a babby mode option. I'm not surprised people overwhelmingly voted Skyrim, Dragon Age Inquisition, and Witcher 3 GOTY, with insane critic scores.
But let's not pretend they're actually good games. Casuals love their open world, and neckbeards love their nude and horsecock mods.
>>339935158
how many thread you gonna do to convince some poor bastards to buy your movie?
1000 more? 200000 more?
>>339936307
What games do you like anon?
>>339935158
What is up with all these witchershill threads?
>>339935158
>gameplay
>>339935158
It has issues but it is the best that could have been hoped for in terms of it's overall design. It's open world yet the combat is not a disaster, in fact in terms of open world games it could be argued that TW3's combat is one of if not the best there is, especially for sword combat.
Then you have side quests that predictably can be reduced to a few basic templates given the sheer amount of them and building the world around them, yet they still offer just enough slight variations and have a high quality of writing and voice acting that prevents them from becoming boring.
There's very little glitches, a huge, detailed and beautiful world, (haven't finished it yet) the story so far is decent but the writing and dialogue is mostly great, the combat has issues but it's still good enough, really with all the compromises devs have to make they somehow managed to get the balance just right in order to make the game work, I don't agree that it's the best game of 2015 but it's the best game they could realistically make.
>>339935158
>awkwardly swinging your sword and going through dialogue wheels
>great gameplay
>>339935158
Yes. Even more so because the fact is absolutely destroying FROMdrones sphincters. They just can't handle the truth.
>>339935158
>shit combat
>predictable story
>SHIT characters
>too many useless mini sidequests
>too long to finish
Are witcherfags the worst example of an AAA title fanbase so far?
Started the game this morning, met the emperor.
What to expect now?
>>339937598
This. It's hilarious how Bloodborne fags try so hard to shitpost in every thread. The butthurt is almost palpable.
>>339937598
>FROM games have superior story, better atmosphere, non-shit combat, better characters and more meaningful content though.
Witcher 3 is an overhyped piece of hot garbage that doesn't deserve 1% of its fame.
>>339938415
ahahahaha
>>339936307
here he is
here he goes again
I really like this video game and none of the /v/ shitposter will keep me from enjoying it
Blood & Wine is GOTY
Blood and Wine is legitimately the only DLC I've ever played that is on par with Shivering Isles.
Dark Arisen was good, but still not good enough.
open world was a mistake
i wish this meme would die already
>>339937592
>dialogue wheels
Actually, we just call it dialogue. No wheels to be found. But I can understand how someone that started playing games in the last few years could be confused.
Nah, it's bottom tier junk
>Is this game the best example of an AAA title so far?
These days? Eh, probably. Shallow gameplay and pretty trees.
No game is shitposted as much as Witcher 3. No fanbase shitposts as much as sonyggers and soulsbabbies. Witcher 3 stole the GOTY from Bloodborne
Coincidence? I think not
>>339935158
>gameplay
This game gets praising for it's utterly shit combat system while FF XV's more elaborate yet more complicated to master combat system is getting shat on.
Why can't Witcherfags make thread simply discussing their games without trying to attract shitposters?
Why do they sabotage their own threads and then blame "Fromsoft boogiemans" when people bite their bait?
>>339939279
Because when they try to discuss their """""""""""""game""""""""", the thread gets archived in a matter of minutes.
Nobody on /v/ unironically gives 2 shits about Witcher 3, even Witchershills got bored of it.
>Gamemplay
>Itemization is garbage
>Side quest are repetitive as fuck and play themselves
>BS... lol
Why do Witcherfriends always bring up Bloodborne?
>>339935158
>gameplay, everything is in there.
>>339935158
They are better than Bioware at making cutscene filled waifu sims with a save the world minigame.
To be fair that bar is pretty low.
>>339935158
>Is the Witcher the best game this generation offered us?
unfortunately yes
>>339939279
It's probably the same people.
We have Witcher threads every day and they always get derailed the same way
>'someone' makes a post or thread about how Witcher 3 is the best game ever made, everything else is worse etc
>gives autists like this :
>>339939042
>>339936307
>>339939368
the pretext they need to appear a few minutes later and start dumping all their webm's, shitty images and screenshots of their own posts
>most of the actual fanbase just wants to talk about Blood and Wine
>>339936559
GoG monies and cheap slav labor.
>>339935158
It's the best AAA title because it creates an experience a low budget game can't do but still has depth in the game. It's the Mad Max fury road of video games.
Seriously the game has the best and most consistent "cinematography" I have seen in video game cutscenes. Unlike most games like Uncharted where the flashy camera effects are used only on spectacle scenes. Witcher 3 has well thought out and well shot scenes in regular cutscenes where people just talk and manages to keep it up for dozens of hours. Not only that but the shots in the DLC are even better than the ones in the main game.
>>339939538
What makes Witcherfags from being devoid of having their own insufferable autists? Every fanbase has them
>>339935158
It's more an example of the heart that should be put into all games whether AAA or not. It's obvious CDPR wanted to feel their game was truly worth buying and the fact some autistic children hate on it regardless goes to show good business practices hardly get rewarded but the success of Witches also tells us optimistically sometimes it does
>>339935158
>that hair
>good
kek
>gameplay
>calling the garbage combat good
why storyfags are so fucking delusional
>>339939279
Seem reason there's no TLoU or Uncharted threads. When you make a movie instead of a game you leave no room for discussion.
Ironically, Withcer haters are the only people who keeps these threads relevant
>>339939042
Metascore reflects very poorly on the games actual quality. See: Fallout 3 receiving higher scores than New Vegas and Skyrim having a better score Oblivion and Morrowind. In other words, metascore counts for shit.
>>339939368
You fail to realize a large part of Witcher's playerbase are on GOG.
Is this the best Soulsbabbies can do?
>>339935158
why does every witcher thread start with a hyperbolic shit post like this?
>>339939484
Because the people who shitposts this game are butthurt Soulsbabies who are mad their shitty gook rolling simulator didn't get GOTY, why is this so hard to understand?
>>339935681
>go into a thread about a game you don't want to discuss
>OMG STOP LIKING THINGS I DONT LIKE REEE
You're so fucking autistic, the fact this board has zero shitposting Life Is Strange threads says everything you need to know about people on /v/
>>339939695
He doesn't have even have the hair options at max you moron, try harder
>>339939863
Why would Bloodbornefriends care? They own a PS4 and can play both?
Why does Bloodborne make you so mad, senpai?
>>339935158
everything is perfect except the combat, which is ass creed-tier easy.
>>339938415
The assravaged Fromtards are one of the best parts of Witches threads. Your doggie company doesn't deserve the 15 purchases they get every yearly rehash,
>>339939993
>Why would Bloodbornefriends care? They own a PS4 and can play both?
Because they are loyal to their gook masters and are mad they didn't receive GOTY, did you even read my post?
>>339939484
They don't, the only people who think about Fromshit is the whole 3 autistic lardasses that never get off /v/ and constantly false flag to make posts like yours.
Nobody even thinks about From games, they sell worse than PC exclusive strategy games
>>339940017
No it's pretty fucking hard. On hardest it's harder than souls games like 3 Neckers will wreck your shit. I just don't find it snappy or satisfying to play. Like in the DLC I had to kill something that's up a small ledge but I could jump over an obstacles so I had to go all the way around the obstacle while the monster spit acid at me.
>>339935158
they really overdid it with the memes tho
>>339940237
I skip through all that shit.
I probably aren't missing much and I just enough time to read all that filler.
>>339939538
Well at least it's that way, anywhere else when someone posts about Witcher 3 being the best game ever everyone starts circlejerking with him over it.
>>339940202
>On hardest it's harder than souls games like 3 Neckers will wreck your shit
>>339940202
git gud
>>339940110
>>339940196
Hmm, seems to me you care about Souls games more than the Souls shills.
>>339940196
>Nobody even thinks about From games, they sell worse than PC exclusive strategy games
Like Witcher 3 then?
>>339940579
It probably is, maybe even if you play on hardest in skyrim everything one shots you, if not there is mod for it. You can play CoD on hardest and die like a 1000 times, that doesn't make it satisfying though
>>339940751
Hmm, seems to me you're a moron who makes non-arguments
>>339940875
>that doesn't make it satisfying though
Speak for yourself.
>>339935158
You missed piss poor optimisation.
>>339939904
Witcher threads hardly ever discuss the actual game.
They mostly revolve around how its "one of the greatest games of all time" while never going into why.
I say this having spent 100 hours in TW3 and enjoyed it for the most part.
>>339939581
the angles are crazy good. so much work and polish went into them.
blows everything out of the water desu
>>339940840
>owning the witcher on steam and not GOG.
Kek
>>339940840
>he is still posting this even though he has been BTFO many times as to why he is retarded
You truly are one of the dumbest person I have seen on 4chan.
>>339941004
>piss poor optimisation
good joke console kek
>>339940840
Nigga it's at #9 with 49.8k players as of right now.
>>339941137
>You truly are one of the dumbest person I have seen on 4chan.
I would give that honor to the people dumb enough to keep responding to him and encouraging him.
>>339940958
>non-arguments
What arguments have you provided? "Muh Souls boogeyman"?
>>339940237
>a reference to an old video is now a meme
>>339941226
I play on PC. And guess what, this game was optimised with Maxwell in mind.
>>339941276
>>339941137
>>339941092
>Expansion just released
Give it a week
>tfw have only played witcher 3 up til that bar where you ask after Tess or whatever her name was and then you get in a fight outside the bar.
Should i continue?
>>339939581
which fucking quest is that
>>339936307
>witcher 3
>steam
Full fucking retard
>>339941506
>Should i continue?
did you like it? if yes continue
if no dont continue.
unbelievably it really is that simple you fucking idiot.
>>339935158
>witcher
>gameplay
>>339941461
Skyrim
>a never ending mindless game where you can do a ton of useless shit
Witcher 3
>a game with a limited amount of level locked content that makes sure whatever you do keeps you heading towards the endgame. Once you reach the end you are finished and you contemplate on the wonderful experience
>>339941558
>GoG
>relevant
Full fucking retard
>>339941589
I know faggot, and i know other people often ask these questions too. It's not so much that i didn't enjoy it. It's just that im so lazy.
>>339940840
>>339941276
It also has a higher peak player number than Skyrim does. Fromdrones are retarded, not that it comes as any great surprise considering the entire 15 people that make their fanbase are all fat autistic virgins.
>>339941553
It's the beat up 3 pugilists and then fight the champion pugilist mission.
One of the 3 pugilists is a masked female, you can easily tell since she moans sexily when she throws a punch and gets hit.
>>339941630
Average Dark Souls fan right there, the sickdark aesthetic really fits his pathetic visage.
>>339941784
Why would I be mad that TW3 has higher peak players than Skyrim? Its a good game and rightfully deserves its appraisal.
i don't know what the fuck it is about witcher 3. i can say it's objectively a good game. but i don't enjoy it at all. it's so fucking boring.
>>339941695
>gog and steam are the only ways to get tw3 on pc.
Ultra retard
>>339941886
How what? Look at the Steamcharts you retarded faggot.
Fromfags need to seriously start trying to compare themselves to something that sells a little more in their range, like Ride to Hell Retribution or Sonic the Hedgehog which has a very similar fanbase to their own.
>>339938764
You think the witcher 3 is better than dragons dogma? I mean ok whatever your opinion man.
>>339941461
Why are you so fucking dumb, seriously?
You don't even realize just how retarded you are.
I will now explain yet again and BTFO yet again.Hopefully this time you will realize just how fucking dumb you are and that you are posting shit that has no merit.
The Eldar scrolls have a massive modding scene. There has been a massive modding scene of thousands of people since Morrowind.
The reason the playerbase is so high for Skyrim is because of the modding scene and mods.
TW3 doesn't have a huge modding scene and after finishing it, there is no reason for people to continue to keep playing it.
You are posting the Steam playerbase that does not account for the 1.5 million copies sold on GoG. You can take the Steam playerbase and double and that will give you an estimate to how many players for TW3 there actually are.
But as I said, it is a single player game and after finishing it, which people did a year ago there is no reason to continue to play it.
Unlike Skyrim it doesn't have a huge modding scene of thousands of players.
Now I hope that this will make you understand just how dumb you are posting these playerbase sats that have no fucking meaning. Most likely you wont though because you don't have the intelligence to understand, that is how dumb you are.
>>339939581
>IT'S THE CURRENT YEAR
>>339942151
>or Sonic the Hedgehog which has a very similar fanbase to their own.
If Fromtards disavowed Sonic then SEGA would retire the trademark forever.
>>339935158
>Story, graphics, gameplay, everything is in there.
You must be joking.
>>339942256
This guy has been shitposting W3 threads nonstop for 8 hours, this is without mentioning the months he's probably done it before these traceable posts
https://boards.fireden.net/v/search/filename/what%20happened/
The jealousy of Fromfags is so real right now.
>>339942151
Damn, that's pretty nutty.
How does From still have an audience that all 10 of their customers haven't killed themselves yet?
>>339935158
ive been spoiled by better examples of gameplay... much much better
like it goes skyrim < witcher < less than ass creed templer space invaders < arkham spin offs < darksiders or some shit < souls < dmc
i like the world they have built but at this point i can say it's riding off the nostalgia for the previous games how i can say there are marked improvements at each stage
but for story im going to say the previous two were better from clusterfuck political intrigue + timewarp magic templer that sword is for monsters to standard political intrigue and finally we are at find your not daughter
>>339939581
hope this is bait.
What happened to the cinematic shit? does w3 get a free pass?
>>339942504
>nonstop for 8 hours
He has been doing it non stop since before TW3 came out. He spent 14hrs a day for months before TW3 came out posting downgrade and hate threads.
He has obvious mental problems and is a very dumb person.
>>339940237
Even Dark Souls had Paladin Leeroy.
>>339942653
>only one person was upset about the witcher 3 downgrade
Yes I can see now how Witcher fanboys are intellectually honest and not at all deluded.
>>339942631
Well it tries to be cinematic and it succeedsits also nice that they don't just focus on the action segments but on the moments where people are just having small talk.
>>339941796
Can I tell her to go suck my thick, meaty dick. Anything besides pander to her tumblr shit?
>>339942653
I wouldn't be surprised if its the same guy, I really wouldn't. Mental handicaps that severe are not too common.
>You are posting the Steam playerbase that does not account for the 1.5 million copies sold on GoG
Even if you double the Steam figures (pre Expansion pack numbers, obviously the numbers are inflated now due to the new Expansion pack, give it a week as I said) as you can see here >>339941461
Witcher 3s average still ends up significantly lower than a 2012 RPG.
>Modding scene
Not Skyrims fault nobody gives enough of a shit to make mods for a shit game.
Now go on, give me another paragraph that's 99% insults and 1% "d-doesn't count".
>>339942813
It is him, there is no doubt.
>>339942843
meant for >>339942256
Witcher 3 is a kind 7/10 due to being fun to explore. The combat, enemy design, dialogue, story and characters are all budget-title tier. I explored the whole map, realized I had no need at all for a poorly written romance novel VN and sold it.
>>339942779
so the same shit people complain about tlou?
ok, w3 gets a free pass
Threadly reminder
>>339942958
God the missions are excruciating. The most you can hope for is some wedged-in combat to detract from the boring as fuck talking, talking, talking, but you've already had better fights just exploring anyway
>>339942969
no you don't understand, when TLOU and DAI won hundreds of goty awards it was because gaming journalism is shit.
when based cdpr accomplished such an amazing feat it was because the game is THE BEST EVER.
>>339942843
HOW CAN YOU BE THIS FUCKING DUMB?
HOW MANY TIMES DO YOU HAVE TO HAVE IT EXPLAINED TO YOU THAT THE REASON SKYRIM HAS A HIGH PLAYERBASE IS BECAUSE OF THE MODDING SCENE.
TW3 DOES NOT HAVE A MODDING SCENE AND AFTER PEOPLE FINISH THE GAME THERE IS NO REASON TO KEEP PLAYING IT.
THIS IS NOT EVEN FUNNY ANYMORE, HOW CAN SOMEONE BE THIS FUCKING DUMB?
PLEASE TELL ME, HOW DID YOU BECOME THIS DUMB?
>>339942958
please kys fromdrone
Anyone who says anything positive about TW3's; gameplay, quests, combat, movement controls, inventory, crafting system, exploration, or reward system, is trolling.
The only thing about the game that could possibly deserve any praise is the graphics (which were just barely decent, and shit in a lot of places) and maybe the actual open world itself which felt decently sized so that it was necessary to traverse on horse rather than walking.
Everything else? Generic, mediocre third-person ARPG garbage with no effort put into it at all.
So anyone defending these is either a troll, or someone who is intentionally anti-critical or without any sort of standards.
>>339935158
I like Witcher AND souls games.
What is wrong with me?
>>339942843
There are lots of mods for Witcher 3.
Just that everytime a patch comes out the mods just break and have to be recoded.
>Story, graphics, gameplay, everything is in there.
You left out combat, fucko.
No, the Witcher 3 has poor combat and thus is not that great of a game.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkFqn1TMeH4
posted in every TW3 thread for salty tears
>>339942843
Witcher 3 doesn't have the moddability or mod tools that Skyrim has fucking hell you're stupid
Who is the biggest cuck protag in AAA gaming?
>>339943110
Great retort, that really refutes every point made.
>>339943000
You're so fucking pathetic dude but I don't expect anything less but this degree of autism from a falseflagging Fromdrone.
https://boards.fireden.net/v/search/filename/1463574769998.jpg/
Nobody would even mention your shitty games because nobody even thinks about them or even buys them.
Lmfao
>>339838962
>Thread where Witcherfags don't have any shitpost or bait in the title.
>archived after 40 replies
>>339935158
>Witcher 3 thread with shitposting in OP
>Already 116 replies
>>339916017
>Witcher 3 thread with shitposting in OP
>400+ Replies
Post YFW the only people keeping Shitter 3 relevant on /v/ are people who hate the Witcher 3
>>339935158
>Witcher
>game
Glorified telltale movie with shit 'gameplay'.
>>339943254
>implying that post even deserves a proper retort
>>339943204
Its better than anything Japan has released in the last decade and those games get discussed regularly here. Calm down man, it's a good game.
>>339943285
hahahaha wow
You;re right though I'd far rather be a reddrone than a fromdrone, thats the right kind of drone to be
Every single Witcher thread, it's the same damn guy. Did someone at CDPR kill his family?
>>339943080
>TW3 DOES NOT HAVE A MODDING SCENE AND AFTER PEOPLE FINISH THE GAME THERE IS NO REASON TO KEEP PLAYING IT
The reason Witcher 3 has no modding scene is because the game is a piece of shit that nobody gives a fuck about
>>339943363
Well it has more GOTY awards than any other game and has put CDPR as a top brand company in the business. But yeah, haters do fuel the success they experience by getting it more exposure and they deserve exposure so thanks I guess.
>>339943373
Then why respond at all angry lil mane?
>>339943376
Keep repeating the mantra, keep repeating
>>339943376
No, the Witcher 3's combat is pretty bad and there are at least 50 games released in the past decade with better RPG combat.
>>339943363
>witchercucks make a normal thread
>Nobody shitposts in it
>dies out in a matter of minutes
>Witchercucks are forced to attract shitposters to even have a chance at discussing their shit game
>they get defensive when people bite their shit bait
Literally the worst fanbase on /v/
>>339943467
>It's popular so it's good!
Witcherdrones in a nutshell
>>339943495
Sure sure, that's why nobody makes any threads about them and TW3 has like 5 up right now fuelling your raging jealousy
>>339943243
Michael.
>Old
>Fat
>No friends
>A once successful heister, now failed
>His whole family hates him
At least Geralt can get away with fucking bitches from time to time and Yennefer will let it slide.
>Hey guys, I think The Witcher is a great game
>NUH UH IT HAS LASS PLAYEHS THEN SKAHRIM AND FAWWOWT FOWW ITS SHIT AND BETHESDA GAEMS ARE BETTR
God, can we just mass fucking ban Bethesdrones already?
>>339943556
Witcher 3 has pretty bad combat desu
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkFqn1TMeH4
hell, even a game like Kingdom Hearts 2 Final Mix blows it out of the water.
>>339943435
>piece of shit that nobody gives a fuck about
Yeah, no one gives a shit about it.
Have you ever considered leaving your basement and getting help for your mental condition and ?
>>339943467
Agreed, I just wish Witcher 3 was as good as any of From/Bethesda or Biowares games. Such a shame, I wanted CDPR to do well but I guess the Witcher series couldn't cut it
>>339943592
I thought the boogeymen were fromdrones?
>>339943592
see
>>339943363
Tell your Witcherbuddies to stop putting bait in the OP and maybe shitposters won't comewell to be fair, nobody will comeyou fucking anime degenerate.
>>339943652
They're literally not boogeymen. Every shitposter admits they're a fromdrone at one point or another.
>>339943618
>I wanted CDPR to do well
They've sold more with TW3 than From has their entire existence, not that its any metric of success considering nobody buys Fromshit.
>>339943592
But no one is actually saying "Hi, I thin The Witcher is a good game".
They're saying "LOLOLOL WITCHER GOTYAY BEST GAME SUCK IT HATERS U JELLY LLOOOOOOOOL".
I've yet to see a single person actually make an attempt at honest discussion about the game instead of trolling people into talking about why it's not good. EVERYONE who defends this game either does so ironically, or insincerely.
>>339939581
Although it got what on heavily by fans.
The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword has the best "cinematography" of any game. It's framing, blocking, and tonal presentation could be better than a lot of films. It nails the basics as well throwing in a lot of its own tricks in.
Witcher 3 has mostly standard shots. It's consistent, that's about it.
>>339943724
hahahaha actually boogeymanning, this post is bait right?
>>339943435
This is objectively, verifiably wrong.
>>339941884
>>339941886
>>339941985
>>339942069
>>339941461
>>339940840
>>339939368
>>339936307
>it's a 'thebull94' shitposting episode
Witcher 3 is a western action rpg done right.. Compared to shit like DA:I and so.. You may be right but Witcherfags overrate this game way too much. Its alright but far from perfect, the gameplay is mediocore at best, graphics are alright and it has decent writing. But still its partly boring and most of the optional content is just there to fill a map and has no actual value in the end.
>>339943435
No, witcher 3 has no worthwhile modding scene because BASED CDPR who NEVER LIE said they would give full mod support and then actually just released the shittiest mod tools ever.
>>339943703
>I haaave to click on threads and shitpost
>I-I caaaan't just use shift+click
Fuck off.
>>339943825
This guy
>>339936307
>>339941461
is just a full on retard and spends all day every day shitposting in TW3 threads and has done even before the game was released.
He has serious mental problems and is a very dumb person.
>if you say anything negative about Witcher's gameplay you're a DaS drone
Wew, but the gameplay is legitimately bland and generic. Like worse than AssCreed/BamHam boring.
The entire appeal of Witcher is the story/characters (i.e sitting through tons of unique conversations). Except you PCfags can't admit that because that would be defending 'movie games', you know, like the ones you shit on against consoles that focus on story over gameplay.
I've never heard anyone actually give a viable counter argument when someone says the Witcher's gameplay/combat is absolute tripe (which is legitimately is). This doesn't make it a bad game, it just means you have to admit you play the game for reasons other than gameplay, which goes against your other shitposting ways.
>>339943918
we're not entitled to mod tools, its completely optional.
>>339943363
Is there a more pathetic fanbase than Witcher?
Soulsbabby thread
>>339929513
>>339922402
>Pure discussion on the Souls series
>No shitty bait in the OP used to attract/call out other fanbases
>Active discussion
New Vegas fans
>>339927284
>Pure discussion on Fallout New Vegas
>No shitty bait in the OP used to attract/call out other fanbases
>Active discussion
Elder Scrolls fans
>>339924112
>Pure discussion on the Elder Scrolls franchise
>No shitty bait in the OP used to attract/call out other fanbases
>Active discussion
Witchercancer
>>339935158
>>339913201
>LEL, FUCKING GOTAY
>LEL, BETTER THAN DARK SOULS, HAHA FROMDRONES BTFO
>WHY ARE FROMDRONES SHITPOSTING OUR THREADS
Then when Witcherfriends try to actually discuss their game with no bait in the title:
>>339838795
>dead within 40 posts
>No Fromdrone/Bethesda boogeyman or shitposts to be found
Open and shut case, Witcherfags are the only thing fucking up their threads. I genuinely hope all you die irl.
Serious question:
Is anyone capable of rating or analyzing TW3 without looking at the graphics?
Are you capable of imagining the game with the same gameplay, same quests, same controls and systems, but WITHOUT the graphics?
Try it, and tell me what the closest game you can compare it to is. Because without it's graphical polish, TW3 is like, pretty much any shitty third-person RPG ever made.
>>339944046
Welcome to /v/.
If you say something good about X game you are an X shill.
If you say something bad about X games you are a X drone.
>>339944046
good post imo
>>339944110
>anime pic
>anyone is going to read that garbage even for a second
>>339944046
please, kys as well
>>339944046
You mean the role playing elements
It's not a 'movie game's, it's an RPG. Cod kiddies like you don't remember what those used to be like before Skyrim.
>>339935158
>gameplay
HAHAHAHAH
>>339935158
But the gameplay is garbage.
>>339936307
Notice how every single TW3 thread's OP is bait.
That's because there's no way to spawn legitimate discussion otherwise since it died about 11 months ago.
>>339943618
>witcher has higher user reception than every game on the left
Not even surprised. What fucking champs.
>>339944237
Sitting through 10 - 20 minutes of dialogue is exactly the same as sitting through 10 - 20 minutes of cutscene anon, sorry to break it to you, but it's still movie tier shit.
>>339943614
>"the combat is so shit"
>nearly dies three times
jeez
>>339944110
your autism has no power here
>>339944218
hahaha you get upset easily at posts that make you consider your decisions. Why do you think this is?
>>339944318
lol
>>339944110
>spam the same shit every Witcher 3 thread for hours every day for months on end
>don't even bother changing the images, so everyone can just go to the archives and see that that's the case
It amazes me that you can do what you do then turn around and say that discussion surrounding Witcher is bad.
I mean considering you've basically made it your lifes mission to stop people from liking a videogame that you don't like.
>>339944046
>he never actually played The Witcher
>>339944102
yes i agree based cdpr, i'm so glad they never misled us about mod support. :)
>>339944237
>2 dialogue choices on average
>varying responses of Neutral
Nah, when even your dialogue system is limiting then it's an overglorified cutscene. Not roleplaying depth like what is found in Planescape torment for example
>>339944110
inb4 this post gets ignored
>>339944126
be honest, you havent played it have you
>>339944110
More pathetic than W3? How about the first "example" you gave that's literally red.dit advertising their shit here?
>>339944318
>the only game that can even compare to TW3 is baldurs gate
how did that guy even not notice his bait made Witcher look fucking great
>>339944331
fromdrone detected.
your shitty chink devs are so behind the times you cant even distinguish between cutscenes and dialogues
>>339944472
Why don't you try arguing against his claim?
>>339944542
The burden of proof is on the person who made the claim.
>>339944454
>b-b-b-but you haven't play it stop lying ;_;
Anon that's the worst example of denial. Ironically I actually liked Witcher 1's combat much more than 2 and 3's, the rhythm shit was way more involving.
>>339944497
Shame about it's community constantly ruining the name of this franchise.
It's Rabi-Ribi.
>>339944318
Fromdrones on suicide watch
If you guys like a game, enjoy it, if you don't, don't play it. Simple.
>>339944419
Quality refute
>>339944382
Quality refute
>>339944203
Quality refute
I know nobody will refute what I posted (>>339944110) because you legitimately can't.
So respond with some meme insult but at least leave with this. Don't put bait in the OP and no shitposters will come. Here's a Bloodbornefag who put bait in their OP >>339934868 and he got nothing but shitposts in return whereas most Bloodborne threads that start out with say "Let's discuss muh lore", there's almost never any shitposting.
If you wanna discuss your game, then stop derailing your own threads.
>>339944617
>Someone who liked W1 combat over 2/3
I thought I was the only one...
>want to consider Witcher 3 a contender for GOTY
>3+ hours of cutscenes
And dropped.
>>339944542
because "he" didnt make any points worth arguing
its obvious to anyone who has played the game properly that nothing about it is like "pretty much any shitty third person rpg ever made"
>>339936307
teso is literally <5$ garbage with only porn and sonic mods keeping it alive
All discussion about this ''game'' died long time ago, both HoS and BaW failed to respark it, and now we are back to the phase where Witchercuckies have to make bait threads in order to have some sort of discussion, since their general is dead, of course.
>>339944318
>Userscore
I have more hours in TW3 than Dark Souls 3 but yet I enjoyed DS3 way more than I did TW3. Maybe it is cause of the sense of satisfaction DS3 gave me.
>>339944741
tesv*
>>339944710
Convenient how you glossed over >>339944493
You have to go back. The wall just got 10 feet higher.
>>339942653
>/v/ is one person
>>339944646
Nobody bought From games to begin with, being insufferable faggots in threads about other games doesn't really effect their sales
>>339944110
Judging only from the OPs you consider it bait to say The Witcher 3 is the best game?
But Soulsbabbies are supposed to be better?
>>339944534
>cutsene
>you're stuck in a static position where you're out of control of your character for the duration while you watch it play out
>sitting through dialogue options
>you're stuck in a static position where you're out of control of your character for the duration while you listen to what is essentially cutsene dialogue expect you can choose the direction the cutscene goes
It's the same shit, except with dialogue shit you get to shape where the glorified cutscene goes. It's better than purely sitting through a pre-determined movie, but you're still in a position where there's no gameplay for an extended period, hence movie.
Deal with it drone.
>>339944761
Of course, because of the DLC.
It's going to fall to the low thousands in a week.
Funny how, even then, it's losing against Football Manager and GTA V which came out a year ago.
>>339944761
>needs a newly released Expansion pack to be half as relevant as a 2012 RPG made by Betheshit
You're only insuring that i'm going to shitpost you into hell when WItcher 3 once again goes off the grid within a week
>>339944737
I'll say it is. I think if you take the graphics away you are left with laughably stiff and clunky movement, woeful combat and a vast world of tiresome cutscenes and arbitrary 'treasure'. How would you describe it?
>>339944472
Of course I have (note, I didn't actually play for 200 hours, I have a habit of leaving games running when I go to work/go to sleep).
But yes, I played it, I completed it (on Death Marches). It's not a very good game, from a gameplay standpoint.
You're welcome to actually address my post now, instead of making shitty deflections.
>if you like souls games you're a fromdrone
>if you like bethesda games you're a bethesdrone
>if you like the witcher games you're a witcherdrone
Why can't you just enjoy these games by what they are? They all have their pros and cons, some might be better than the other in some aspect but that doesn't mean it sucks
>>339944318
I bet that guy is pretty butthurt right now. Saved.
>>339944879
No, i'm talking about The Witcher 3.
>>339944874
you can literally search the archives and its the exact same filename every time, dingus
When will it end?
>Story
No
>Graphics
Maybe. Geralt looks wonky sometimes and skipped leg day. About 4 character models per gender.
>Gameplay
You're drunk.
>>339944782
/thread
TW3 became Sonyggers 0.5, but with less relevancy.
>>339938415
>FROM games
>story and characters
>>339944957
>>339944793
>>339944690
>>339944497
>>339944414
>that desperate they try and use user score as proof of a game's quality
pahahahahaha
inb4 better than reviews, yeah, no shit
>>339944895
why do you hate witcher 3 so much?
it's a solid 6.5/10, gameplay/controls/loot/quest variety are a bit shitty, but its not too bad overall.
dialogues are well crafted.
not even ubisoft games are shitposted this much
>>339944926
>>339944927
>its bad cuz i dont like it!
you trolls arent even trying anymore.
Make it stop
>>339944925
Longevity =/= Quality
I enjoyed myself in the 6 hours of vanquish more than I did in my 23 hours playing FO4.
>>339945139
TESV is objectively better than TW3 tbqh.
my only issue with the witcher 3 is that the combat is too hard on the normal and hard difficulties but too easy on the easy.
that plus the game is kinda scary
>>339944963
>you will never spend all your free time being this obsessed with a piece of entertainment media that you don't actually like
Well I feel a bit better about myself now
>>339945098
>specific examples
>it's your fault my reading comprehension is that of a child!
makes sense you'd be into it. I bet you like the writing and characters too?
How do we end this bros?
>>339945090
>not even Ubisoft games are shitposter this much
That's because there aren't fifty threads a day for Far Cry.
>>339945175
>The combat is too hard
What the fuck?
>>339945085
>all this butthurt
let it flow through you anon
>>339945205
>waaah ur a child!
dang, really told me
go back to your fag souls and weeb games
>>339944925
Please tell us what it is like to be as dumb as you are anon. I really am interested in understanding how someone with such low intelligence operates on a daily basis.
Please explain to me why people would continue to play TW3 after they have finished it?
Why do you expect the game to have as many people playing it once they have finished it?
Please help us understand your retardation as to why you expect people to continue playing a game after finishing it and not to move on to playing something else?
I truly want to understand what it is like to be a person as dumb as you are.
>>339945218
>steam is the only PC game seller
by realizing most of sales were on gog
>>339945090
Because Ubisoft fanbases aren't constantly making bait threads in a desperate attempt at remaining relevant.
>>339944598
What? I didn't make a claim. I asked if you were capable of evaluating the game without taking it's graphics into account. Are you? Because right now, you're admitting that you're not capable of that.
If you can, I think you'll find that everything that isn't LOLGRAPHICS is pretty mediocre.
>>339944542
I asked if you were capable of doing something, By deflecting and choosing not to respond except to say "lol u didnt play it", you're telling me you can't answer the simple statement I made.
What points do you want? That the controls were horrible, the combat was button-mashy, inaccurate junk, the Witcher Sense was boring and one-note, the quests were largely dumb and simple, the rewards were worthless and insulting, the points of interest were a waste of time on the whole, and the inventory and leveling systems were badly designed. None of this is opinion, this is all easily verifiable.
JUST FUCKING DELETE THIS
>>339945261
it's flowing straight through me and into ur butt, nestling against a lost dragon dildo and your opinions of Witcher 3
>>339935158
>Gameplay
Stopped reading there. Witcher 3 has shit gameplay.
>>339935158
>Story, graphics, gameplay, everything is in there.
Story and graphics sure but the gameplay is rather meh. Combat sucks compared to something like dragon's dogma
>>339945098
>>its bad cuz i dont like it!
Yes, this is how rating things work. I don't like it BECAUSE it is a mediocre game. That's how it goes.
If it was a good game, I would obviously have liked it.
>>339945278
haha well you sure sound mad
>>339945391
Nice subjective opinion you have there m8.
>>339945298
see
>>339942843
>Now go on, give me another paragraph that's 99% insults and 1% "d-doesn't count".
>>339945348
>CDProjekt getting better with each game
>everyone else tumbling down
Interesting
best game ever
>>339944318
That guy probably spent an hour putting that together and didn't notice that TW3 has better reception than all of them
I never thought I'd live to see the day a game not only stole GOTY awards from Bethesda, but got the most GOTY awards of any game ever and actually deserved it.
What a time to be alive.
>>339936085
Then what would you consider good?
>>339945248
consider the wonky controls and the patience needed to defeat all the damage sponges on higher difficulties.
also, not autistic enough to make meme builds
>>339945457
Subjecitve
>>339945460
But anon, why are you so dumb?
Please explain why you expect the playerbase for a single player game to be so high after people have finished it?
Seriously, you are a dumb fucking twat.
>>339945467
Can't get any worse.
>>339945467
>there are people who will die before Cyberpunk comes out
>>339935158
>Is this game the best example of an AAA title so far?
>Is the Witcher the best game this generation offered us?
Yes and yes
witcher haters are pathetic
>>339945305
>What? I didn't make a claim.
Then you can stop putting words in my mouth because I was responding to him, not you. Or are you being obtuse on purpose?
>>339945457
It's impossible to have an objective opinion, this is something /v/ would do well to learn
>>339945460
Do we really have to get into why this is dumb?
>>339945476
Can't even beat Mass Effect 3 tbqh
>>339945415
>If it was a good game, I would obviously have liked it.
doubt it since you obviously have shit taste
bet you exclusively play jrpgs you fag
>>339945605
Can't wait to pirate it.
>>339945563
haahahaha just look at it in action, it's laughable. Was it bugging out (again) there or something?
>>339945595
Yeah CDPR definitely couldn't score below a 9/10 across the board. They really are just that good.
>>339945593
>Seriously, you are a dumb fucking twat.
>literally STILL this mad
>>339945627
Your game sucks
>>339945650
>74 Critics vs 12 critics
Haha, a game with over 6 times the reviews has a barely better score? wew lad
>>339945674
>doubt it since you obviously have shit taste
It doesn't matter. If the game did not appeal to me, by definition it cannot be a good game. If it was a good game, I would have enjoyed it. That's literally what the word means.
>>339942843
>>339943435
>Not Skyrims fault nobody gives enough of a shit to make mods for a shit game.
??
>entire argument is basically that a game is somehow better because people have to make mods that change the game into something else rather than enjoy it for what it actually is
Didn't you get btfo over this enough already?
>>339945746
Not really, they still have to deliver a game with remotely decent gameplay.
Witcher 3 is so average, it pains me to see drones falling for marketing and fake free DLC
>>339944110
I like how this went conveniently under the radar by most Witchershills.
Nobody cares about the Witcher 3, Witchershills know this and in turn literally try to bait other fanbases into their thread to stop it from getting archived too quickly.
It's humiliating to watch sometimes
>>339945650
It beats Mass Effect and all Fromshit games by a landslide when you look at the userscores
>>339945797
No it isn't you retard
Jesus, I'm not on Witcher 3s side at all but I'm capping that. Says a lot about this place
>>339945747
Anon, please. Explain to us why you expect a single player game to have a high playerbase a year after the game has been released and everyone has finished it and moved on to playing something else?
Keep posting your epic meme pictures anon, it wont change the fact that you are one of the dumbest people to ever post on this boar.
>>339945872
And I like how you conveniently didn't notice that half those threads linked were rebbit related.
You have to go back.
>>339945797
>If the game did not appeal to me, by definition it cannot be a good game
are you retarded
go and literally learn what the words objective and subjective mean
>>339945815
>Didn't you get btfo over this enough already
No, maybe 3 more reaction images and insults from you will finally blow my statistics the fuck out tho
>>339945650
How many GOTY awards does ME3 have?
TW3 has like 200.
>>339945823
I thinks that was the most disappointing thing about TW3.
Not that it was particularly bad, not that it was particularly insulting (some parts were), but that the product on the whole was just so painfully average. It innovated nothing, it brought nothing to the RPG genre, and somehow everyone just pays attention to the graphics and calls it a masterpiece.
>>339945872
What the fuck are you even talking about?
Here's an actual Witcher 3 thread that isn't just you responding to yourself a million times
>>339926027
>>339945508
Combat is shit at times but it certainly isn't by any means hard.
this thread is /v/ in a nutshell
>>339945885
>userscores are representative of quality
is this a new meme or something? When did this happen?
>>339945797
>If the game did not appeal to me,
Citizen Kane didn't appeal to me, so by definition that means it's a shit movie?
>>339945885
>userscores that literally anyone can make
>>339945816
>being this assravaged over a good game being released
You're cancer, desu
>>339945935
>>339945978
I think you're taking things too seriously.
Obviously, I'm talking to a troll who's succeeded in dragging the conversation to shit, so I'm responding to him with shit.
If you want to actually discuss my REAL argument against the game, it's right here >>339944126
Skyrim blows
>>339946098
The only cancer here is the gameplay of these games.
>>339946074
I like how you replied to him even after this post >>339945785
Wewest of lads
>>339945938
>Anon, please
>literally begging
>literally this mad
>literally calls out my reaction pic while posting one of his own
It's ok senpai, i'm sure Cyberpunk 2077 will have playable gameplay and not chase away even the most hardcore of Witcher fans within a matter of weeksor not
>>339946074
If anybody bothered to buy From games or if From made any good games then maybe it'd score higher. Sorry kid.
>>339945983
Statistics aren't much good when you don't have a coherent central argument.
In months of doing this you've never managed to explain why lots of people changing a game to make it something else, is somehow meant to show that that game is superior to one where people don't feel the need to change it.
>>339945415
If your argument was good I would obviously have agreed with it.
>>339946115
why would anyone want to discuss your "real argument" when you have proven yourself to be tarded
>>339946023
Step asidefags, Sony exclusive is here to say a few words
>>339946238
Sounds like deflection to me. Why respond if you're just going to dodge?
>>339946189
>he actually thinks userscores are representative of quality
holy cats
>>339946225
>Statistics aren't much good when you don't have a coherent central argument.
The central argument is Skyrim > Witcher 3 in:
>Sales
>Concurrent player count averages
>Metacritic
Based Todd God always wins
>>339946074
How many years until we get a game that looks like the first picture
Damn the reflections on the silver armored parts look so good
>>339946052
>>339946074
You two are stupid beyond redemption.
User scores are obviously more relevant than the opinions of a small bunch of critics, most of whom have shit taste or are bribed
Even looking at the critics scores W3 is among top tier games and better than your precious fromshit
>>339946165
Please explain to us why you are such a fucking dumb shit and why you think a single player game a year after release and everyone has finished it and moved on to playing something else would have a high playerbase?
Anyone else get burned out on it? I put in 90 hours and just stopped caring, even before finishing the story. There was TOO MUCH going on, very much quantity over quality despite there being a lot of quality overall in the game, I just feel like they could have cut out some of the game and refined it after having to kill the same bandit or nekker for the 10,000th time.
There are too many samey side quests that all blend in with one another, talk to lowly person about issue, they want you to find / investigate, use super vision, tracks lead to cave, find item wanted by lowly person, kill ghosts / other enemies, bring back item, repeat for 30 hours.
There are parts that I loved but it was too much for me overall. A certain point clicked where I understood all the mechanics and combat and inventory and pacing and quest types and I min/maxed for damage and HP and it was satisfying at first being able to kill everything in sight but got boring quick when I didn't even feel the need to upgrade or loot anymore.
I feel like starting a new game again since it's been so long since I played it, but I'm pretty sure I'll just reach that same point again where I lose interest. Witcher 3 was the perfect game to test out my new IPS monitor though, it still is nice to load it up and just trot around a forest and check out the scenery and listen to the ambiance and music.
>>339939581
I agree with this, but best cinematography? Most of the scenes are just shot reverse shot conversations with fairly well done animation loops.
>>339946331
>STILL ignoring >>339945785
Were you born grasping at straws?
>>339946316
you mean like you just did with your last post?
>If the game did not appeal to me, by definition it cannot be a good game
as if im gonna be serious with you after you say downie shit like that. lmfao
>>339941985
I never understood posting this trying to shit on W3, it just shows how good the hitboxes are
>>339946361
Sorry, you seem to think aggregated reviews of ANY kind hold relevance? Why do you think that is the case?
>>339946339
>Sales
>Concurrent player count averages
>Metacritic
We were talking about modding though. Are you capable of discussing anything without deflecting to something else?
>Leave pornkino to me.
>>339946361
>user scores more relevant
>literally don't need to even own the game to review it
Tell me more about this "stupid"?
>>339946378
pro tip: take breaks and skip quests you don't feel like doing at the moment
>>339946402
>assuming laughing at you seeing value in userscores means I'm into paid reviews
see:
>>339946440
>>339946410
I dunno man, I think you're just making excuses. Better to stay silent than pipe up with "Hey I could totally BTFO you but I won't because lol".
>>339946254
>lower user score
TW3 also has more GOTY awards than TLOU
CDPR really are the best in the business.
>>339946460
>We were talking about modding though.
Oh yea, thanks for reminding me.
Let me reiterate
The central argument is Skyrim > Witcher 3 in:
>Sales
>Concurrent player count averages
>Metacritic
>Mods
>>339946468
woah look this good game has 2 points less than this other good game in metacritic, it must REALLY suck
>>339946503
>There's a "right" way to play the game
Why not just make all the content fun, instead of making all of it so bad that you have to skip it regularly to not get burned on how shit it all is?
>>339946512
Are you implying /v/ isn't an aggregate?
>>339946468
>MGSV doesn't even have a tenth of the accolades of TW3
Though the real number is about 251 for TW3. MGSV lost so hard it became a pinball game.
>>339946528
>only 2 more GoTYs than an EXCLUSIVE
>literally stomped in Metacritic
MAKE IT STOP LADS
>>339946468
>W3 steam reviews: 95% positive
>DS3 steam reviews: 78% positive
How's it feel to get BTFO?
>>339946515
more deflection, yawn
stop replying to me, because i wont read it
>>339935158
>Great graphics.
>Good story.
>Okay atmosphere.
>Piss poor gameplay.
>Panders to casuals, Redditors, normies, etc.
It's no different than TLoU, Inquisition, Skyrim, etc, but it does have superb production it least. Just another casual game for the masses, but I guess it's pieced together better than Inquisition/Skyrim.
>>339945482
Not him but it's comparative reviewing is absolutely the one thing you never want to do. If you can't judge X on X's merits/demerits and have to compare it to Y, you've lost the illusion that you were maybe at one point able to think critically.
TW3's story isn't inherently bad by any means, it's just incredibly poorly paced, goes for the ol' SSJ2 Gohan cliche, and has all of the exposition in flashbacks, and I'm not just talking about Dandelion.
Graphics are just your standard realism. No real art design, no inspiration beyond the books. I personally didn't see a single aspect that really stood out to me. The monsters were the most uninteresting facet of the game, and that's a damn crime.
Let's be real here, TW3 has four major elements of gameplay...
>Combat
>Horse Riding
>Gwent
>Witcher Senses
Can't say much about the combat. It just wasn't good. It didn't play right, none of the skills felt like they really added anything, leveling up felt pointless beyond the arbitrary gear requirements.
Horse Riding would be neat if a) it didn't control like ass and b) if there was anything worth riding to. This really fails because there is essentially no exploration. The map is already there, the points of interest ironically has nothing of interest, and the world only looks good from afar. Once you actually ride up to something, it loses it's stature.
Gwent is great. AI is retarded. Gwent Online was amazing. CDPR shut down Gwent Online. Endpoint.
Witcher Senses is the most despicable thing I've ever seen in an RPG. Sure, everybody complained about Skyrim's compass markers, but nobody cares when Polacks put a yellow brick road from cutscene to cutscene in place of puzzles, of which there is only ONE in the entire game.
All in all, TW3 is a shitty game, but a hell of an experience. It's an awful game, and a B-tier fantasy movie. Wouldn't ever let it near my top 10 of either medium.
>>339946627
No you fucking idiot
/v/ is a bunch of individuals speaking their mind.
I don't see any web code gathering people's written number scores and displaying an average of them, you inbred shit.
>>339946654
GTA V is technologically the best game out there, really. It doesn't have the accolades or the reception of the GOAT that is TW3 though.
>>339946339
>sales
Skyrim has been out for 5 years and has been on sale for $3 4 times a year for at least 3 of them.
TW3 has been out for just over a year and has yet to see a significant price drop.
>Concurrent player count averages
Again, why do you expect a single player game that everyone finished playing a year ago to have a high playerbase?
>Metacritic
No one takes Metacritic seriously and there is hardly anything between the score. The score aren't that far apart to mean anything.
You truly are one of the dumbest people to have ever posted on this board. I just wish you could see how stupid you look.
>>339946627
It isn't, there's no aggregated score or result, if you read conclusions in your discussions with several individuals in order to draw a score or result that's up to you
But more to the point
>Putting any stock in /v/s opinion
desperate times
>>339946590
I don't know what to tell you dude, the game is plenty of fun but there's an unusual amount of content so sure it can get overwhelming if you do nothing else but monster hunts for example
>>339946705
>This post
>Literally this is the people defending TW3
You guys sure are a quality group.
>>339946464
>this will never actually be Elizabeth Olsen
>>339946763
Oh right, thanks for Redkit and that """FREE""" DLC. Remember, Poland a friend.
>>339946701
>less Steam review score than Mass Effect 2
>Lower metacritic as well
Embarrassing
>>339946189
people buy FROM games
two times, since they actually managed to convince dumb asses to pay for a DX11 version--AT FULL PRICE---and get this, the 'Enhanced" dx11 prepare to die harder version didn't even look better! ha ha holy shit no wonder there are so many shitty chinese devs churning out garbage "Remaster" ports of older games these days.
also at least 3/4 of the skyrim players still playing are doing it only because of waifu mods and porn mods from loverslab. W3 doesn't have that since you can't drag and drop some mods in to turn Geralt into Ciri and go on an erotic adventure with her.
>>339946651
>MGSV lost so hard it became a pinball game.
>>339946627
wow, can't wait to hear your explanation for this...
>>339946759
i dont see the problem here apart from the person playing being absolute shit
>>339935681
right now theres about 3 or 4 overwatch threads , LoL threads and other equally shitty games and you come to this thread just to say that?
>>339946763
Please tell me how many "major elements of gameplay" your favorite game has
Bloodborne?
>combat
that's it
>>339946538
Ok so you're admitting that you can't actually address this?
>In months of doing this you've never managed to explain why lots of people changing a game to make it something else, is somehow meant to show that that game is superior to one where people don't feel the need to change it.
>>339946759
This can't be typical...
>>339946793
why is that? don't tell me people preferred IV.
>>339946764
>/v/ is a bunch of individuals speaking their mind.
You are severely underestimating group think, and you are retarded if you think people here aren't contrarian for the sake of it, and therefore group thinking.
>insults
Ah, you aren't actually here to hold discourse, nice.
>>339946809
>>Putting any stock in /v/s opinion
Glad we got that sorted.
Cheers, enjoy posting in the shitpost general.
>>339935158
Yes, best game of the generarion so far.
>>339946874
And?
>>339946825
Literal shilling.
>the game is plenty of fun but there's an unusual amount of content so sure it can get overwhelming if you do nothing else but monster hunts for example
That's the fucking point, it's NOT fun. There's a shitload of content, but none of it is interesting. Every quest is the same, every quest reward is terrible, and the shitty Witcher Sense you use in 95% of the fucking quests doesn't add anything to the game, actually making it worse because every bit of content relies so heavily on such shitty mechanics. Plus there's the boring combat and the lack of reward. The content is inherently not fun, and the fact that there's so much of it just makes everything worse.
>>339946804
>Skyrim has been out for 5 years and has been on sale for $3 4 times a year for at least 3 of them.
Is that why Skyrim sold more within 1 month than Witcher 3 has sold to this day?
>>339946793
Nah, GTA Vs metacritic (only thing that matters) is considerably higher m8. It's too GOAT for Witcher 3 "Literally lower than Mass Effect 3"
- Wild Hunt
>>339946763
Best post in thread
>>339935158
Its dope.
Fuck the haters.
>>339935158
>gameplay
HAHAHAAHAHAaAAHAHAHAHHHAHAHA HA HA HA HA HAHA HA HA HAA HAAAAA
witcher fags are so obnoxious
>>339946907
>Being blind and retarded in 2016.
>>339946951
At least it did it's one element right.
>>339946804
>d-doesn't count
>d-doesn't count
>d-doesn't count
>f-fucking dumb piece of shit. Delete this now!
>>339946951
If that were his favorite game at least it would focus one doing one thing incredibly well rather than offer up mediocre gameplay in every department it attempts
>>339946987
>you are retarded if you think people here aren't contrarian for the sake of it
>>339947008
If you just wanted to shit on the game you could have said so so I wouldn't have wasted time reading the literal shit coming out of your brain
>>339947067
>not being able togit gudin the current year
>>339946987
>You are severely underestimating group think,
I don't care if you call every opinion that disagrees with you "contrarian" or "group think". It doesn't change the fact that it's INDIVIDUALS posting OPINIONS, not fucking aggregating review scores. You literally said /v/ is somehow an aggregate like Metacritic. That's what you said.
You're an idiot.
>>339947152
Oh, sorry I forced you to read an opinion you don't share.
Do you have to close the tab and go to your safe space when you accidentally read something you don't agree with?
>>339946951
>b-but Bloodborne
Every. Single. Time
>>339947084
>mfw
>>339947118
Epic m8. You just got BTFO and all you can do is post an epic meme pic and green txt.
Seriously, why are you so fucking dumb?
>>339946987
>You are severely underestimating group think, and you are retarded if you think people here aren't contrarian for the sake of it, and therefore group thinking.
What does that have to do with the fact that /v/ does not offer aggregated results of any sort?
You might actually be developmentally challenged
>>339945048
>>339936307
>>339939042
Is this dude the barneyfag of The Witcher 3?
>>339946969
There are some hipsters out there, but I think GTA V - while being the best technological videogame for mayhem ever created, lacks some of the charm that existed in pre-IV GTA, though it certainly returns more to it in V.
I'm not hating on it, its a well made game and aside from Rockstar's shitty business practices regarding Online I don't think it deserves an 8.7.
>>339947019
>these couple of critics are the only ones that matter
>(ignores the number of GOTY awards given by critics)
>>339947185
Witcher 1 is so bad at the start, then it suddenly gets very good
I like it a lot, I think it's better than 2
>>339947153
Nigga' I stomped through DM without dying, kek. This isn't Bayo: Climax or DMD. It sure as fuck doesn't excuse the collisions either.
>>339947305
He truly is retarded.
Have you guys heard about the Warcarft movie? I hear it's like someone made a movie out of a AAA game. thought u my buds would enjoy it too fk the critics klol
>>339947261
Watch out we got a tough guy over here
>>339946590
>>339946503
I get what you guys are both saying, it's a good game, it's just a lot to take in, and certain people have OCD with shit like I do, once I initiate a quest I almost HAVE to do it to completion with few interuptions and I always do a lot of side stuff before the main quest(s), and the way W3 is setup with the sheer amount of quests but not enough loot and well paced upgrades to dole out I just lost interest.
When I get my new CPU and GPU in a month I'll be able to play it on very high / ultra at 60fps instead of medium and locked at 30 and often dipping into the mid 20's, so I'll start a new game and dive in with much better visuals and twice the performance so that might help keep me sucked in for longer.
>>339944110
>>339946763
Best posts ITT.
Both of which don't have a single legit refute. Interesting.
Why, Witcherfriends, do you insist on shitting up your own threads and then playing victim?
>>339935681
first post best post as always
>>339947305
How is it possible for one game to trigger one person so hard though
>>339947305
>Witcher 3 fags think this is good, they like pretending to be a tough guy that says stuff like 'Sorry. Can't let that happen.' Before punching someone, they consider that good writing
>>339947437
He has serious mental problems.
>>339947381
You just told me you don't feel comfortable reading opinions that aren't aligned with yours. Did I miss something?
>>339947357
sure champ. that kernun fucked you up though. bet you savescummed before every fight
>>339947405
This first post is meta-thread shit that isn't about the game, the second one is well thought out though
>>339947276
>You just got BTFO because my insults and reaction pics >>>>> your observable factsIf you really thought I got BTFO you wouldn't be writing paragraph after paragraph that says nothing more than "b-but", "w-well maybe it's because", "d-doesn't count" and "F-F-FUCKING RETARD, DELETE THIS REEEEEEEEEEEEE"
I don't think I"ve ever gotten involved in a minor NPC's storyline like I did with the bloody baron, shit was surprisingly intense
>>339946951
Do you have anything to say about The Witcher 3?
>>339947382
>>When I get my new CPU and GPU in a month I'll be able to play it on very high / ultra at 60fps instead of medium and locked at 30 and often dipping into the mid 20's, so I'll start a new game and dive in with much better visuals and twice the performance so that might help keep me sucked in for longer.
It won't. The graphics don't magically make the game better.
>>339947449
who are you quoting
>>339947305
>Shove djikstra
>breaks his leg
Literally ok when WItcher 3 does it
>>339947524
You got BTFO with facts. You can keep trying to refute them but it will never change the fact you are one of the dumbest motherfuckers to have ever posted on this board.
Chapter 1 of Witcher 1 was so bad
it was a big circle you lapped around a few times
if the fields had been open in the middle, I bet a lot more people would've been blown the fuck away by it instead of going MEEEEEEH.
of course then you got into Vizima and W1 picked up a lot.
also the Hellhound boss of act 1 being such a fucking binary fight. Either you stunned it with Aard and 1-shot it and that was that, or you got fucked devoured by the Hellhound and its pack of wolves.
>>339947437
Probably a bookfag who doesn't like the way they handled something so spergs out in a massive way.
I don't really see what the end goal is though. There are plenty of games where everyone likes them apart from /v/, but with a year of obsessive shitposting he still hasn't even managed to achieve that
>>339947449
When I see people praising the writing and characters I think maybe I am remembering them wrong, but now I don't think so...I think they really were just shit. Theres many better examples within video games, let alone culture in general
>>339947326
>(ignores the number of GOTY awards given by critics)
Witcher 3 didn't release in the same year as SKyrim/GTA V senpai. Incomparable, what is comparable is the metacritic/sales which has Witcher 3 being BLOWN THE FUCK OUT
>>339947543
this
best questline ever
>>339947558
What else is there to say
Back-to-Back GOTY Champion
>>339947574
The synapse forming in your mind connecting 'Witcher 3 writing' to 'shit' that is helping you develop as a human being
>>339947626
>p-p-people don't give two shits about the Witcher series and refuse to make mods for the game, b-b-b-btfo
>>339947504
>He hasn't beaten Climax.
>He hasn't gone above Son of Sparda.
>He's never even beat a modern Ninja Gaiden game.
Deathmarch is easy once you pass Baron. Case-in-point one part I almost bit it actually was Baron's.
>>339947750
Is it your GOTY?
I'm not asking about metascore or IGN. I want your honest opinion of what you liked.
You did like the game, right?
>>339947382
I feel you anon, I've always had these problems in games, but it gets better if you just force yourself to let go. You'll have more fun too once you stop being controlled by OCD. That applies to almost everything, really
>>339947496
Your multi-post whine and over-exaggeration is hardly what I'd consider a sensible opinion
>>339947517
Both posts highlighted the Witcher fanbase as the biggest pieces of shit on /v/. And rightfully so
They're so cancerous that they literally shit up their own threads
>>339947562
They do if you're an asshole like me, I spent more time in Skyrim testing out ENB's and mods than anything else.
guys............... i found the real reason most people here are mad at people who enjoy this game
because their hardware is too shit to even run it at 50fps 1080p on max settings LOL
daily reminder that thebull only started his shitposting crusade because Triss got the short end of the stick in the game
>tfw a vidya character makes you mad for a full fucking year because you only got to see her tits once
>>339947687
>TW Attila not even on the list
>Life is Strange
Why are Fromcucks so damn salty?
>>339947703
newsflash: review scores of games released several years apart and reviewed by different people are also incomparable
>>339947847
>but it gets better if you just force yourself to let go.
This is it. This is the summation of TW3's defense;
"It's good if you stop thinking"
>>339947867
Who gives a shit about a fanbase, we are talking about game quality. The second post doesn't mention the fanbase at all in any context, it focuses completely on game content. That's what makes it a good post and the first one a shitpost
>>339947984
I wasn't even talking about Witcher specifically, idiot
>trying to argue that "too much content" is a problem for a game
This is how retarded witcher haters are
>this is the game /v/ praises
Seriously. A lot of self hatred or outright weebs ITT. Wouldn't be surprised if a lot of them are cucks.
>>339948127
>>trying to argue that "too much content" is a problem for a game
Too much content isn't a problem.
Too much content, when all of it is mediocre or feels like a waste of time afterwards is a problem.
>over a year later
>Fromcucks still mad as fuck
>>339947984
Witcher 3's defense is that a videogame can be much better than the sum total of its parts
Spending months breaking the game down into individual chunks then autistically nitpicking each one doesn't really change that.
The amusing thing is the way you way you people do it.
>break a game down to it's component parts
>compare each individual part against another game and say that game does it better
Pro tip: you can do this with literally any game. It says a lot that people can't actually provide a single, individual game that's better than W3. They have use Skyrim, Souls, etc depending on which direction they're trying to deflect in.
>>339947919
Can't address what? CDPR admitted that they didn't make a modkit because when they gave one for Witcher 2 nobody did jack shit with it.
All of your arguments are "b-but"
>Skyrim has more sales
"b-b-but"
>Skyrim has a higher metacritic
"b-b-but"
>Skyrim is played more to this day
"b-b-but"
It's cringe worthy and your blatant booty bothered nature (excessive insults) only further makes this back and fourth more sweet
Took me 7 hours to get the hang of this game. The two different dodge techniques fucked me up
>>339948263
>Too much content, when all of it is mediocre or feels like a waste of time afterwards is a problem.
Then it's a good thing that those are all optional if you hate them so much. Main quests are still over 80 hours of gameplay.
>>339937592
>clicking buttons
>great gameplay
>>339947837
To me it was like playing a Tolkeinesque adventure that made you feel the massive stretch of a journey that consists any great epic. I was exhausted by the end and couldn't touch anything for a few days from fatigue, but that was good. There's not many stories told that really pull off the task of having you feel how the main character must have felt.
>>339946763
>combat is completely subjective
>there is no exploration
>Gwent criticism is vague as hell
>Witcher Senses are the only legitamite complaint and even ?>then its not that bad
And yet /v/ circlejerks over you being a messiah and gives you Reddit gold
Yeah, /v/ really hates video games doesn't it?
>>339948315
How do you think the game comes together to offer more than the sum of it's parts? How do you see the strength of one element influencing another? I'll take any example of this.
>>339948315
>>Witcher 3's defense is that a videogame can be much better than the sum total of its parts
In theory, sure that could be true.
But I cannot say that TW3 rises above it's bland writing, uninteresting characters, Deus Ex Machina storyline, horrible RPG mechanics, and brainless combat.
If you put those together, the whole product of TW3 is like a really average fantasy movie with a ton of drama that pads out the really not very interesting action scenes and all tries to be way higher concept that it actually should. The end product of TW3 is decidedly average, not really excelling at anything.
>>339948383
>The main quest isn't mediocre
>>339935158
>graphics
who else believed in slav magic until the release trailers for this game
>>339948356
>Skyrim is played more to this day
And it was explained to you that this is because of people using it as a modding platform.
Which still leaves this for you to address.
>In months of doing this you've never managed to explain why lots of people changing a game to make it something else, is somehow meant to show that that game is superior to one where people don't feel the need to change it.
Go on, explain why having lots of furries adding sexual shit and people reskinning everything is somehow proof that the game is better than a game that doesn't actually need that
>>339948443
>start up a game
>click on "New Game"
>a new game starts
WOOOOOOW What the fuck is this shit?
>>339948356
Who really thinks they'll be as successful as Skyrim, let's be real, but TW3 is definitely one of the most successful games ever.
Go make a Skyrim thread if you love it so much.
>>339948383
>Main quests are still over 80 hours of gameplay.
...and it's just as bland and boring with it's forced romance choices, female macguffin plot device that you never actually care about, and a conclusion that answers precisely zero questions about what the fuck is supposed to be happening and why.
I'm picking my nose right now and it's the best thing ever, I probably got hundreds of hours stacked into just picking my nose, and there's so much content and the graphics are off the hook.
Is picking your nose GOAT?
>>339948315
But here's the problem, the sum total of its part is mediocrity, it excels nowhere nor does it try to.
>dialogue
1-2 dialogue options on average each being some form of neutral
>combat
Repetitive restricted nonsense with under 10 total moves, one weapon type and some gimmicks attached.
>Story
Generic plot that is literally (and i'm not exaggerating when I say this) identical to Marios overarching plot. "Quick Mario (Geralt), go save Peach (Ciri) from Bowser (Wild Hunt) who keeps kidnapping her!"
>open world
It's open world has nothing to see or do and is filled with the same repetitive bloat that Ubisoft games get shat on for having
>quests
Quests are well written but are so sickeningly formulaic that any originaltiy that may be found in the plot is lost in translation with the games "single note" gameplay
When you look at games like Skyrim, its sandbox is where it excels. The ability to do virtually whatever you feel like (within reason. Without reason with mods). Souls games are known for their tight nit level design/combat (modern day Castlevania games). GTA are known for their brainless fun and impressive tech.
Witcher 3 really excels nowhere and unless you are attracted to it exclusively for the Witcher world/characters then you're likely to be disappointed with its ultimately generic (visually) setting and shallow gameplay mechanics.
>>339948569
Yeah it isn't. The expansions have even better main quests and bosses.
>>339948656
Sorry for your shit taste.
>>339948356
which was a weak-ass excuse because they only released redkit a long time after W2 was out, and then it was supposed to be 'proof' they were going to have the redkit available on day-1 for witcher 3
that was one thing where CDred dropped the ball--and i'd be willing to bet it was intentionally dropped, since M$ was giving them money to optimize for XBONE and obviously the xbot management would've insisted that PC not get mod tools because it would make buying it on shitbox less appealing. Gotta have that console parity!
>>339948759
>Sorry for your shit taste.
You're not very good at this whole "discussion" thing, are you?
>>339948574
>downgrade the game
>still looks better than bloodborne
>>339945180
That, and you will NEVER be Anthony Burch.
Life is fucking excellent.
>>339948585
>is somehow meant to show that that game is superior to one where people don't feel the need to change it.
Because it means the game has more replayability and mechanical depth.
>>339948356
Not him, but Skyrim has had more sales because it fucking famous for modding support and you can practically make different games out of it
Hell, why are you even circlejerking about Skyrim anyway? I want Bethesdrones to leave
>>339948356
How do yo fail to see just how retarded you are?
How can you use sales as an argument when one game has bee out for five years and been ob sale for $3 many times against a game that has been out for obe year and has yet ti drop in price?
How can you use a difference in score of 2-4 points as a fucking argument? If there was a 10+ difference ib score fair enough but bot 2-4.
Again,how can you be so retarded to expect a single player game that everyone finished a year ago to have a high playerbase?
I am not joking when I say you are one of the dumbest people to have ever posted on this board. I truly mean it with all my sincerity.
Please seek help for your mental condition and get some education.
>>339948536
I thought my Gwent criticism was pretty straightforward. It's a worthy successor to Triple Triad, except Triple Triad can be played online to it's full potential and Gwent cannot.
You know what makes me feel better when /v/ is getting on my nerves? Write out what you're thinking. Yeah, opinions are subective, that's the 1,000,000,000 someone with no opinion has posted that.
Do you have opinions? Post em. If all you do is shit on other people for unrelated reasons, that's sort of the definition of shitposting.
If you have no criticism, positive or negative, to the topic(s) presented, then you're just joining the circle.
>>339945172
/v/ in a nut shell, CDPR gave 3 games,
they were literal nobody,
with first game they made some money,
everyone shat on how combat was bad and how it should be more Dark Souly(game was objectively great in most other parts),
so they made The Witcher 2, totally revamped the combat(even if that is not important thing for that game to original fans but to console crowd and latecomer's) , it was not their strong-suit and combat is not why Witcher 1 became highly popular game, so no one gave a shit about combat ,(but they did it because the fans insisted), so in The Witcher 2 ver 1.00 combat was really hard(and actually great, first with the feel of weight) and people died like flies and couldn't past first guy with shield, so they released the patch a week later where they eased the game play.
From their point, its, how much they try to please the crowd, there will always be some fucking faggot who doesn't like this or that, but point is, The Witcher 3 is objectively best game in last decade, you really have to either not love the format of the game, be blind, troll or just an total moron to not see that.
You can literally thank CDPR that whole gaming industry has got up from their lazy assess, stop duplicating CODs anually and finally start to work on their games, trying to actually do a good game.
Also, I really hate to compare games(because personal preferences) but I bet you FO4 & every Souls and Borne game would be much less polished and big if there was no TW3.
Those guys pushed the envelope with every sequel, only people who are pissed are actually those lazy dev fucks (mostly in USA) who finally figured out that they have to actually work on their games(and not use copy/paste from last sequel with higher texture res)
>>339948656
>>339948569
There are a lot of great stories in TW3 and its far from mediocre. You hinge the entire story on the plotline which primarily exists to drag you from place to place and experience the stories on the way. That's really what makes the entire story, what happens on the journey; I think this is how it should be.
The ending was satisfying, though perhaps not as strong as so many of the moments that preceded it, but that's alright. All in all its some of the best writing in games.
If you played the whole of it and couldn't stop thinking it should have been a linear mono-story experience then I don't really think there's much else to discuss, I disagree.
You know a game is good when even the dlc is rated higher than bloodborne
Final Fantasy XV will never live up to the standards set by The Witcher 3. The Witcher 3 is pretty much the pinnacle of RPG quality, whether it's the icredible OST (goat imo), the vast beautiful world, the attention to detail, the amount of content, the fantastic characters, the deep story, the lore and mythology, the sidequests etc. I feel like The Witcher 3 truly excelled in everything that makes an RPG great and then some (except maybe combat but it more than makes up for that). When Cyberpunk comes out, it will shit on everything japan has made in the last few generations.
>>339948939
see
>>339942843
>Now go on, give me another paragraph that's 99% insults and 1% "d-doesn't count".
You couldn't be more mad if you tried
>>339948756
>nothing to see or do
>restrictive nonsense
>quests are formulaic
>proceeds to ciclejerk Skyrim as doing AAAAAAANNNNYTTTHING
Bethesdrones are delusional as fuck
>>339948985
>the journey is what counts
Witchercucks are LITERALLY Biowarefags
>>339948818
I'm not actually even trying to get into an argument with you m8, sorry. I've come to accept that /v/ has a handful of autistic retards with retarded arguments and nitpicks hating on W3, and refuting one's points gets me nothing when they'll come back the next thread anyway
>>339949091
Seriously, how do people become as stupid as you!?
>>339949108
Don't know why I said Skyrim, meant to say the series as a whole (Primarily Morrowind/Oblivion)
>>339949174
Why would an RPG not be like a journey?
All of them strive for that.
Besides arent you the one bragging about how critics rated Mass Effect 3 higher?
>>339949174
>plot = story
Witcher haters are literal retards
>there are people in this world like legitimately think skyrim had better combat than w3
be still my sides
>>339948551
>How do you see the strength of one element influencing another
I would say the overall gameworld lifts the quality of the combat in terms of the way the two things interact.
There's a focus on preparing for fights with monsters out in the main world. Researching their weaknesses, making sure you have the right oils, potions and weapons prepared etc.
Is the combat worse than a game where it's based purely on your mechanical skill rather than what you brought with you to the fight? Sure. But I find that layer adds something quite interesting and rewarding.
>literally 90% of all the anti-Witcher posts mention Skyrim in some way, shape or form
No wonder, nobody on /v/ wants to discuss shitty Bethesda games so they have to shitpost in threads instead!
>>339946907
Are you blind?
Or do you belive it is not a fuck up and reasonable hitboxes?
It's a good game. An 8/10.
The only people who call it a "10/10 masterpiece", "greatest game of the generation", etc. are people who don't value gameplay above all else. Because the game excels in every area, except for the actual gameplay. The Witcher Sense parts and the actual combat just feel like a shittier Arkham game.
>>339949274
>Besides arent you the one bragging about how critics rated Mass Effect 3 higher?
First post in this thread
>>339949323
Literally what are you talking about. The person I quoted never made that distinction.
Story, graphics, gameplay, everything is in there.
The content of the DLC is fucking amazing, and it's only worth 20 dollars.
Is Bloodborne the best game this generation offered us?
>>339949443
see
>>339924112
bethesdabros unlike Witchercucks don't need to put bait in the OP to keep their game relevant on /v/
>>339949189
>If you like the game you're educated, intelligent, and eloquent and capable of refuting all comers, but you don't need to because they're just autists!
>If you dislike the game, you obviously have shit taste and autistic nit-picks because the game is clearly perfect and cannot be legitimately criticized.
Yep, you're the average TW3 fan alright.
>>339949174
>Ass Effect is better than Witcher
>Skyrimjob is better than Witcher
Holy fuck, if this is the same guy from earlier you are LITERALLY worse than Barneyfag
>>339949379vanillaSkyrim's bow combat is still one of the funner experiences I've had, but TW3 had that intense, 1v1 duel feeling that For Honor is attempting. Both had some good moments/peaks, both failed miserably overall.
>>339949530
Your blatant falseflag aside. Pic related, it absolutely is.
>>339949539
>bethesdabros
yeah fuck off back to /vg/
You assholes are known for D&C and trying to shit up /v/
>>339949426
Looking back many of the fights are very memorable with pretty distinct areas, too.
There's a lot of ambushing random guys in the woods but every large monster that you fight is in a place that will stick in your memory. I think that's what they were going for and I feel it.
>>339949456
>Literally what are you talking about. The person I quoted never made that distinction.
You were saying the story is bad because you think the plot is bad, yet the other guy was talking about the story being good, which it undeniably is
>>339949189
Can you do me a favor?
Can you name a single thing that anyone could criticize about TW3 that you would not call a "nitpick"?
Anything at all?
>>339949530
It is, actually. Too bad it's stuck on a system with no other games.
>>339949264
>Morrowind
Most RPGs today and even back then don't compare to Morrowind, thats a loaded comparison
Here's the real test:
Name 3 memorable sidequest from Skyrim
or
Name 3 memorable sidequest from W3
>>339949658
>You were saying the story is bad because you think the plot is bad, yet the other guy was talking about the story being good, which it undeniably is
I never said anything of the sort. I used his "journey is what matters, not the destination" comment to draw a comparison with ME3 apologists
>>339948841
>a bunch of 'see that mountain?' features
>no explanation of actual quality
top kek
>>339949451
You are entitled to your opinion, as are they.
>>339949752
It's on a system with no other games and nobody who owns it will buy the game.
Enough said really.
>>339949550
The claim about autists and nitpicks isn't an over-exaggeration though. Just look at the guy who keeps posting metacritic scores in every single thread, or the guy who posts the "good combat" webms of glitches and whatnot in every single thread.
Same goes for pretty much all the people who cry about the combat. There's much more to gameplay, and the combat is fairly good on average RPG combat standards, yet these people make it seem like the game has the worst gameplay of any game ever, clearly false
>>339943790
nintendrone are delusional as ever i see
>>339949550
>the game is clearly perfect and cannot be legitimately criticized.
I would like to see you just provide a single game that you believe is better than Witcher 3 by itself in all areas. Then have a thread where we just discuss the two games in comparison
The fact that you have to jackknife between Skyrim, Bioware games, Bloodborne and everything else depending on what suits your argument, suggests that you can't actually do this and you know that you are full of shit.
maybe if bethesdafags and fromcucks unite you guys will have a chance..
>>339949956
>Same goes for pretty much all the people who cry about the combat. There's much more to gameplay
Yeah, and it's all pretty bad.
Witcher Sense? Bad.
Inventory? Bad.
Movement controls? Bad.
Crafting? Bad.
RPG mechanics? bad.
>>339949780
Errr
errrr
Jackie Chan
>>339949956
>There's much more to gameplay, and the combat is fairly good on average RPG combat standards, yet these people make it seem like the game has the worst gameplay of any game ever, clearly false
It really doesn't deserve it, either. Even for somebody who can offer honest critiques it's undeniable the passion and desire to please that went into this game.
In an industry where this is so rare and a developer is so rarely willing to listen its a shame; because if I were CDPR I'd have been pretty disheartened up until about the point its reception skyrocketed through the ceiling and it came out.
But the people dedicated to shitposting it before never stopped even over a year later. Pretty sad, but they're definitely a fraction of a minority.
>tes games
>having more than 1 class
ahaha, holy shit, no they don't. Fallout3/4/TES characters all become the exact same homogenized fucking tankmage that plays the exact same way. A guy who shoots fireballs out his ass while swinging his sword at 9000 mph and who can leap over tall buildings while in full daedric heavy armor and when he gets tired of that he can relax by playing some shitty Simon Says diplomacy bullshit.
also your pet horse can kill dragons because your horse is the strongest creature in all of skyrim, excluding the player character
>>339949698
I don't claim it's a flawless game, but none of the flaws make the sum of the parts a bad game.
Combat could be better, was pretty disappointed when it hadn't improved much from TW2
There's a few places with too much hand-holding, like the famous witcher senses part you like to tackle onto
Enemy leveling was a big negative for me but they fixed it with the new patch
>>339949789
You implied it, stop being retarded.
>>339950172
Only bad thing in that group is Witcher Sense
Everything else is just fine, how is it bad?
>>339950172
why are they bad
movement controls is the only thing that could be more fluid, especially on horseback and swimming. dont see how the others are bad
>>339949426
For me, even on deathmarch the only thing I had to bring to a fight was whatever sword my stats allowed me to use. There wasn't really a need for bombs or spells
>>339950370
he's a fromcuck, he doesn't understand logic.
>>339936307
Hi Todd
>>339950185
Yeah exactly. The amount of effort that went into it should count for something even for the shitposters. This whole phenomenon is limited to /v/ though
>>339949530
Yes. One day hopefully ps4 will be cheap enough to justify a purchase
>>339950225
>You implied it, stop being retarded
see >>339948985
> You hinge the entire story on the plotline which primarily exists to drag you from place to place and experience the stories on the wa
That's literally what Mass Effect 3 faggots use as a defense. You're retarded
>>339948598
>start new game
>it says it'll overwrite my old saves
>all my old saves are gone
>fromdrones
http://webm.land/media/pM54.webm
>>339935158
Not really. I couldn't get past the shit loot system, floaty combat , and awful leveling system. The story and dialogue were good but I felt like the Witcher 2 had a much better story. I also preferred the graphics style in the Witcher 2 over the Witcher 3. I also preferred large levels with lots of exploration and meaningful loot and quest to big open world sandboxes. I'd rate the games Witcher 2>Witcher 1> Witcher 3.
>>339950123
>I would like to see you just provide a single game that you believe is better than Witcher 3 by itself in all areas.
Why, what does that matter? Why do I have to compare TW3 to another game that has all of the same features? Why can't I evaluate the game on it's own merits? Are you saying "TW3 is the best game because, even if it's not particularly good, it's the best by default?" A game doesn't get a 10/10 just because no other game does it better, that doesn't make it perfect by default. It's still a mediocre game.
>The fact that you have to jackknife between Skyrim, Bioware games, Bloodborne and everything else depending on what suits your argument,
I haven't mentioned any other games, nor have I needed to. I criticize the game on it's own, I don't need to compare it to anything else.
>>339950123
Personally I found Bloodborne way better in all areas, exploration included
>>339950546
>That's literally what Mass Effect 3 faggots use as a defense. You're retarded
Okay let's say you're right. So what then?
>>339950546
I wouldn't know I didn't play ME3 but I'm still pretty sure you're the one whos been bragging about it having higher critic ratings than TW3 and insisting that critic ratings are the only ones that matter.
>>339950597
this is the kind of voice i imagine the w3 haters in this thread having while spurting out things like >>339950172
>>339935158
I concur. Also what do you think about the new Manticore Sword and Armor Witches set?
>>339950664
>fromcucks this deluded
>>339950225
>Combat could be better, was pretty disappointed when it hadn't improved much from TW2
>There's a few places with too much hand-holding, like the famous witcher senses part you like to tackle onto
>Enemy leveling was a big negative for me but they fixed it with the new patch
Now suppose I call you a nitpicking faggot who is clearly going into the game looking for things to hate on just to not have to admit it's perfect.
You see why you're fucking stupid when you call someone else's criticism "nitpicking"? Nigga if I play the game and I notice "Wow, this crafting and inventory system is horrible", that's not nitpicking. That's me making an observation about the game as I play it. You only diminish and deflect criticism, you don't want to accept that maybe these things stand out and actively ruin other people's experiences.
Maybe that's not nitpicking, maybe that's you being anti-observant or anti-critical.
>>339950903
Dunno about the sword but the armor is fucking ballin'
Been waiting for this armor since TW1 actually, it's perfect
>>339950261
>>339950370
Well from these two posts, it seems that we a agree that both the Witcher Sense and the movement controls were legit complaints.
Give me two more posts and people will agree with the rest, and we can all come to the conclusion that those are all valid complaints.
>>339949451
It's a game that says: your mother sucks an dwarven cock! to your face.
It is literally 10/10 game out of all times and spaces and you cant do shit about it.
>>339944110
top kek, BTFO
This is some tumblrtale and sonygger level of faggotry.And I like the Witcher.
>>339951061
>make my arguments for me because i havent played the game i am criticising
this is /v/, it checks out
>>339951063
So what we can deduce from this post is if you are the kind of person that thinks the phrase 'your mother sucks dwarven cock!' is funny and/or entertaining and/or worthy of mention, you will love Witcher 3.
>>339951154
I already posted my playtime screenshot of the game ITT.
Also, I made 5 very simple points; The Witcher sense, the inventory, the RPG mechanics, the crafting, and the movement controls were bad.
I then had two separate TW3 defenders agree with two different points, and claim that the rest were nonsense. Now this means that they cannot all be nonsense, and at least those two are legitimate, unless the argument is that both me and the two responses are all wrong and the game has NO flawed areas (which we know isn't true).
So I say, give me a few more replies, and you'll see people agreeing with the other 3 points, and thus proving my post correct.
>>339950980
>combat in an RPG is not on level with top-tier action games
>>SHIT COMBAT, SHIT GAME
>there's a witcher senses feature
>>SHIT GAME
Yes, these are nitpicks. Actually, the first one is a valid complaint, and might break the game for you if you don't appreciate the other elements of an RPG, but otherwise it's a nitpick as well.
>Wow, this crafting and inventory system is horrible
That doesn't break the game, faggot. It even isn't horrible (an exaggeration again, congrats), but if it was, it's still a minor part of the game
>>339935158
The biggest problem with this game in my opinion is the gameplay. If a game doesn't have good gameplay, it's just not worth playing. I uninstalled it sometime after getting to Skellige
>>339951432
Witcher senses is by far and away the most egregious failure of the game imo
>>339950805
This is what they look like, too.
Pic related is some guy who made multiple metacritic accounts to vote straight 0's on TW3 and 10's on everything From.
>>339951432
>>Wow, this crafting and inventory system is horrible
>That doesn't break the game, faggot. It even isn't horrible (an exaggeration again, congrats), but if it was, it's still a minor part of the game
But there are no good minor parts of the game. That is not the only crap part, it's one of many.
>>339949530
But does it says:"What, do you have water on the brain?"
>Many NPCs will state "What, do you have water on the brain?" as an insult to Geralt.
>Water on the brain , or hydrocephalus, is a condition that afflicts about 1/200 live births in the United States. It's more common than many conditions that get substantial more attention and money.
You literally have to be smart to be insulted by this game...
or
Geralt:"Want to hear a limerick?"
Labert: "Sure"
Geralt: "Lambert Lambert, what a prick."
or
"may your mother drawn in dwarven cocks"
or
Margarita Laux-Antille: "I just realized that off all woman on this ship only you, Ciri and me didn't have sex with Geralt."
Phillipa Eilhart: "Don't worry, I'm sure it's only a matter of time in your case."
or
Geralt: You smell wonderful.
Yen: Geralt! We're at a funeral!
Geralt: You smell wonderful at this funeral.
sorry, the Witcher is 11/10 game of all times, its just logical
>>339951432
Can you define "break the game", please?
Because as you describe it, clearly you think there is some hard limit at which a feature becomes suitably bad or unusable to merit not being called a "nitpick", and to do this it is required to "break the game" somehow. I'd like to know what that means.
Because for me, every time a quest says "Use your Witcher Sense to find/solve/see <thing>", and I get to just hold down my mouse button and follow the red dots, that's pretty much ruining my enjoyment of the game. It's boring, it's tedious, it's not enjoyable, it adds nothing to the experience, and most of all it's fucking brainless. You're just doing it to get it over with, no one is ever actively enjoying holding down the Witcher Sense button and following the red trail that lights up while Geralt comments on what he knows but you, the player, never have to figure out on your own.
>>339951703
They should just make things able to be activated without it because you could play the entire game without using it if it didn't force you to in order to interact with some things.
>>339951848
It's also the only way to know where certain things are, it's so lazy
>>339951830
Most of it you can still find the way without doing that, the problem is ultimately interacting with the object when you reach it like I said, >>339951848
>>339937952
>>too long to finish
>>339951928
Not really, there are visual cues for everything except scent.
>>339951848
This is what I went into the game hoping.
Nigga, you have a WHOLE BESTIARY that tells you monster habits, weaknesses, behaviors, locations, etc. All of it. You could SO FUCKING EASILY have made the game fun by having the player have to refer back to the knowledge in there to actually hunt down monsters or find clues and shit and actually feel like you're accomplishing something.
But instead, you just make everything glow red and follow it because you can't do anything else. Even if you see the tracks or markings or item, you can't do shit until you make it glow.
>>339951810
All of that dialogue is FUCKING ATROCIOUS. It's literally Danielle Steele-tier innuendo, aimless swearing or tired flirty dialogue. You HAVE to be false flagging or trolling or whatever right?
'Do you have water on the brain?' is a common insult in the western world btw
>>339952061
But are you really going to wander the entire map until you find an upturned cart in the hope it's the right upturned cart?
>>339939042
This is the most blatantly obvious biased shitpost I've ever seen.
>>339952201
No, because there are tracks along where the upturned cart was riding before it crashed imprinted into the dirt. They don't just put random carts laying around, they actually have visual cues for it. I know because I played the entire game for the most part avoiding senses.
>>339951810
>You literally have to be smart to be insulted by this game...
>Geralt:"Want to hear a limerick?"
>Labert: "Sure"
>Geralt: "Lambert Lambert, what a prick."
>You literally have to be smart to be insulted by this game...
>Margarita Laux-Antille: "I just realized that off all woman on this ship only you, Ciri and me didn't have sex with Geralt."
>Phillipa Eilhart: "Don't worry, I'm sure it's only a matter of time in your case."
>You literally have to be smart to be insulted by this game...
>Geralt: You smell wonderful.
>Yen: Geralt! We're at a funeral!
>Geralt: You smell wonderful at this funeral.
>You literally have to be smart to be insulted by this game...
>"may your mother drawn in dwarven cocks"
Im fucking dying
![[glass him].webm](https://i.imgur.com/vimb1gw.jpg "[glass him]")
