[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Alexander the Great. Was he Greek? or a southern slav.
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /pol/ - Politically Incorrect

Thread replies: 84
Thread images: 22
File: atg.jpg (16 KB, 225x225) Image search: [Google]
atg.jpg
16 KB, 225x225
Alexander the Great.

Was he Greek? or a southern slav.
>>
he was Great
>>
>>55213675
He was a nigger, any way you look at it
>>
He was Black, Whites white washed him though.
>>
>>55213743
they wuz kingz and shit
>>
File: ancientgreek.png (467 KB, 451x587) Image search: [Google]
ancientgreek.png
467 KB, 451x587
>>55213743
This.
>>
>>55213675
He was Macedonian, therefore Greek. There were no Slavs at the area at the time. They migrated in the Balkans several centuries later.
>>
>>55213837
>brazil calling someone a nigger
>>
>>55213675
motherfucker looks afghan, i look just like him holy shit i'm hideous.
>>
Modern Macedonia (as in, the sovereign nation) is actually just a bunch of slavs who migrated to that area almost a millennium after Alexander's time, and now pretend to be the descendants of the same people, and living on the same land, that Alexander belonged to, even though, geographically, they're miles North above the historic kingdom of Ancient Macedonia (whose historic boundaries are mostly located in modern-day Northern-Greece).

Ancient Macedonia during Classical Greece (6th century BC - Alexander's time) was considered to be 'Hellenic', but there were a some people in the Southern Greek city-states who didn't respected them as such, and considered them to be less civilized and culturally different. Alexander I of Macedonia in 460 BC was denied from participating in the Olympic Games (which only Hellenic states could participate in) because Macedonia was considered barbarian / non-Hellenic, but he managed to persuade them in letting them in by claiming the country's lineage from Argos. And there were a bunch of other similar accounts during the 5th and 4th century that were likely just done out of propaganda purposes in-between the city-states.

But genealogically, Macedonians were very likely the same as their Southern Greek neighbors.
>>
Macedonia (the real one, not the modern slavic imposter) was one of many hellenic states in the mediterranean. He was a greek from the kingdom of macedonia.
>>
>>55213675
Where did this meme Ancient macedon=Helenic greece even come from?

For greeks, every nongreek was barbarian. Macedonians were barbarian tribe, and they were helenising onver time.
But even at the time Philip II defeated greek city states, Macedonians were still considered half barbaric.
He was not greek, neither slav, but helenised Macedonian.
>>
>>55213675
we came there like 1000 years after he died , he was greek fucking obviously , trying to make him slavic is some albanian level history bending goddamn it this meme needs to die
>>
Aleksander's mother was Albanian.
Albanians are the closest race that currently exists to ancient Greeks, modern Greeks are closer to Turks.
>>
>>55213675
He loved COCK
>>
>>55216281
>trying to make him slavic is some albanian level history bending goddamn it this meme needs to die
>albanian level history bending

I can't stop laughing
>>
>>55216488
Case in point
>>55216397
>>
File: protoRomanWarrior.jpg (109 KB, 609x811) Image search: [Google]
protoRomanWarrior.jpg
109 KB, 609x811
>>55213675
>or a southern slav.
Slavs didn't arrived until the Byzantine period. Alexander was 4th century BC

If you want to put him outside of the Greeks, see pic related, it is Celtic, found in Romania and dated to the 4th century BC.
>>
File: Alexander_Sarcophagus.jpg (96 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
Alexander_Sarcophagus.jpg
96 KB, 640x480
>>55213743
might as well post Greek art.
>>
>>55213675
Greek
>>
File: bg.jpg (50 KB, 342x400) Image search: [Google]
bg.jpg
50 KB, 342x400
>>55216668
>>
File: 1416611035613.png (490 KB, 449x401) Image search: [Google]
1416611035613.png
490 KB, 449x401
He was a manlet.
>>
>>55213675
>implying greeks aren't southern slavs
>>
File: Peplos_kore_as_Athena-Artemis.jpg (97 KB, 800x1067) Image search: [Google]
Peplos_kore_as_Athena-Artemis.jpg
97 KB, 800x1067
>>55216686
>>
File: realColors.jpg (73 KB, 490x245) Image search: [Google]
realColors.jpg
73 KB, 490x245
>>55216754
>>
>>55216754
God. These look so fucking ugly painted. Completely ruins them. Finding out that Greek and Roman statues were painted is the biggest letdown since finding out that dinosaurs had feathers.
>>
>>55216930
>Finding out that Greek and Roman statues were painted is the biggest letdown since finding out that dinosaurs had feathers.
Ikr. At least we don't have to make their mistakes.
>>
>>55216930
At least we can BTFO out of all these crazy Afrocentrists trying to creep into history that is not theirs.
>>
File: 1444141694740.jpg (45 KB, 552x817) Image search: [Google]
1444141694740.jpg
45 KB, 552x817
>>55213920
>>55216281
Thats what German school states.
Dont trust Germans when it comes to history, ever. Its mostly bullshit.
There are records of Slavs living in these parts in 30 AD.

Macedonians at that time were akin to Greeks, but not quite Greeks.
They were probably a mixture of Greeks and some local tribes.
All in all Alexander was more Greek than anything, how ever the Greek elite didnt consider him Greek until he conquered Greece.
He basically came from the shitty part of Greece that even the Greeks renounced.
>>
>>55217212
>There are records of Slavs living in these parts in 30 AD.
Some links pls inb4 deretic meme
>>
>>55216930

The Greeks just had really gaudy taste in color.
>>
>>55217212

I've heard that Slavs were so successful because they allowed their slaves to become one of the tribe or to go back to their home, the slaves of the Slavs loved the equality of the Slav society that allowed them to appropriate the native Illyrians and other tribes.

So I wouldn't have an identity crisis just yet, most of the Balkan people are natives to the region, just assimilated into Slavic identity.
>>
>>55217382
This. Colours were expensive. Most people didn't even have anything coloured. It's like how churches in Rome and such are covered in gold and silver; it shows you are wealthy, you can afford gaudy colours or gold and silver.
>>
>>55213837
That can't be real, holy shit. I'm gonna need some sauce.
>>
File: 1444062159404.jpg (78 KB, 936x824) Image search: [Google]
1444062159404.jpg
78 KB, 936x824
>>55217337
It would take me really long to find it right now.
It basically goes:
St Paul was spreading the word of Christ in the Balkans.
Some Slavs became monks continuing to spread the word.

In essence Slavs lived all across Europe as well as Balkans. There just weren't as many Slavs living there, as there were a couple of centuries later.
>>
>>55217457
>allowed their slaves to become one of the tribe or to go back to their home
how the fuck does that constitute a slave?it's some guy that can hang out with you or not , that's a slave? I never heard about us having slaves , i mean it's entirely possible but still I've never heard of this
>>
File: black_athena.jpg (33 KB, 330x475) Image search: [Google]
black_athena.jpg
33 KB, 330x475
>>55213675
ALEXANDER THE GREAT WAS BLACK

>>55217174 (You)
>>55217202 (You)
>>55217234 (You)
>>55217257 (You)
>>55217285 (You)

Who is Raziocinante / Enrique Cardova / Zarahan?

He is a radical Afrocentrist.

SEE LINKS RELATED
>>
>>55217382
>>55217623

It does make you wonder how European art aesthetics might have evolved differently if those colors hadn't faded away over the centuries.
>>
>>55217948
I heard the guy on the History of Byzantium podcast talk about Slavic peoples, he's pretty well sourced, but that is my source.

He said Slavic people assimilated most people in the Balkans into their cultural identity.
>>
>>55218040
indeed
>>
>>55217836
That picture, lmao.

When is your slava, brat?
>>
>>55218040
Renaissance artists might have preferred gaudy colours a bit more, and wouldn't have recreated marble statues fully in white. Reimagining iconic renaissance marble statues fully in gaudy colours makes for fun thoughts though.

I don't think it would have changed much, other than renaissance statues we have, but I think that we still would've disapproved of gaudy colours nowadays, since they're so much more prevalent.

Though obviously we can't know for sure as it is all conjecture.
>>
>>55218040
If you seek medieval statues, you'll find them painted.
>>
>>55213675
He was blonde, that image is roman, Greek images of him were blonde.
>>
File: Pompeii.jpg (182 KB, 768x1024) Image search: [Google]
Pompeii.jpg
182 KB, 768x1024
>>55218529
Fair like this guy from Pompeii?
>>
File: Blonder_Kopf_von_der_Akropolis2.jpg (123 KB, 800x1200) Image search: [Google]
Blonder_Kopf_von_der_Akropolis2.jpg
123 KB, 800x1200
480BC


Greeks confirmed Blondefags
>>
>>55218683
Many Greek and Roman noblemen and gods were blonde, not because they were Germanic, but just because they liked fucking blonde woman
>>
File: 1402951554806.jpg (25 KB, 569x428) Image search: [Google]
1402951554806.jpg
25 KB, 569x428
he was greek long story short commies manipulated slavs into thinking they were macedonians just to fight for them but sadly some of them survived and since they had to pick their country for scratch they kept the joke that they are descendants of macedonians hoping one day the might claim greek also they are brainwashed af
>>
File: greek singer.jpg (10 KB, 480x360) Image search: [Google]
greek singer.jpg
10 KB, 480x360
>>55218877
>DURRR
>>
File: samefags.jpg (223 KB, 1323x585) Image search: [Google]
samefags.jpg
223 KB, 1323x585
>>55218917
Etruscan wall paintings suggest that there is a continuity in the art of the Mediterranean where hair color can range from Black to Blond and all shades in between.
>>
>>55218215
St John the Baptist.
Are you diaspora?

>>55218200
I dont know why they were so successful but they did indeed assimilate most of the population. Also its the first time I've heard of Slavs having slaves, they usually just pillaged.
>>
>>55219010

>implying that's a natural blonde and not just bleached

diasporafag pls
>>
>>55219105
>I dont know why they were so successful but they did indeed assimilate most of the population. Also its the first time I've heard of Slavs having slaves, they usually just pillaged.
It was a podcast, and I didn't check his sources for it, you know the way, trust someone and you'll forget to rigorously test their facts.
>>
>>55216055
Fellow leaf has it right. Modern "Macedonians" are an invention of rising Balkan nationalism throughout 1830s - present day
>>
File: 1406850526740.jpg (146 KB, 686x900) Image search: [Google]
1406850526740.jpg
146 KB, 686x900
>>55219266
That's the point of my post.

This >>55218877 is a nordicist who is unaware of the fact that they didn't look like their highly idealized statues.

They weren't actually ''blondefags'' like many of their gods/heroes and their noses didn't actually start from their foreheads.
>>
File: 1433398291361.jpg (273 KB, 960x895) Image search: [Google]
1433398291361.jpg
273 KB, 960x895
>>55219298
I think I know what he was talking about then.
When Slavs conquered cities they offered people to assimilate or leave to their country.
This often led to Greeks recapturing their cities quite easily.
>>
>>55219861
I'm not a Nordicist you stupid faggot. That was the paint they used on the statue, you can view it on google.

Also see Etruscan artwork.
>>55219021
>>
File: godsOfColour.jpg (28 KB, 299x520) Image search: [Google]
godsOfColour.jpg
28 KB, 299x520
>>55219885
Interesting, I must research this now, piqued my interested.
>>
>>55220000
>That was the paint they used on the statue
and the color is the same as this bleached greek woman's >>55219010

>see Etruscan artwork.
Yeah and?
>>
File: colorsTheyUsed.jpg (44 KB, 514x416) Image search: [Google]
colorsTheyUsed.jpg
44 KB, 514x416
>>55220201
Razio? Only a faggot like you could pretend to not answer the fucking question.
>>
>>55219861
>They weren't actually ''blondefags'' like many of their gods/heroes and their noses didn't actually start from their foreheads.

I can't remember the writers but descriptions of the Makedonians from Hellas report them to be largely blond.
>>
>>55217212
>how ever the Greek elite didnt consider him Greek
macedonians participated in the olympic games and are therefore unarguably,demonstrably greek
>>
>>55213675
He was a manlet who only won because he conquered all the nignogs who fought with sticks, and had no armour. At the battle of Hydaspes he actually challenged the Indian king Porus (who was supposedly around 7 foot tall) and when Porus defeated him, (because he was a weak manlet) he broke the deal and had his men attack the Indians. Not as great as they say, the years preceding him were greater, he just took advantage of what he had.
>>
>>55213675

He was Greek.

Don't let pseudo-intellectuals on /pol/ tell you otherwise.

Source : educated individual
>>
>>55213675
Macedonian royalty was descended from the Argeads, and so, in turn, they were Greek.
>>
>>5522096
Quebeckers participate in Canadian national sports teams and shit but a lot of Canadians don't really consider them Canadian
>>
File: nig.png (270 KB, 353x394) Image search: [Google]
nig.png
270 KB, 353x394
>>55218022
Que carajo estas aciendo aqui? Largate, cabron!
>>
>>55216796
I want to know how they came up how they came with the idea that Greeks were that pale if in the original statue the skin is darker than the helmet in contrast.
>>
File: mediterranean.jpg (81 KB, 595x446) Image search: [Google]
mediterranean.jpg
81 KB, 595x446
lol southern Slav? what the fuck.

Greeks were Mediterranean people. Pic related.
>>
>>55216281
>Serbia never fails to be my bro

Greece and Serbros should invade albania and divide it. We only want North Epirus
>>
>>55216110
macedons participated in Olympic games, so they were considered greeks.
>>
As someone who has done a literal degree on this I think the most embarrassing thing to come out of Europes North Korea (Republic of "Macdonia") is not the statues of ancient Macedonians (whom even Borza BTFO) but the statues if things like the Titan Prometheus (pic related edit: Corrupt, just google it senpai) from greek myth, the state broadcast of Macedonian prayer or the 'time travelling historian' pasko Kuzman.

Its turned Macedonian Slavs into soviet era republic of clowns. When they have a real history as illiterate peasents-cum-resistence fighters who have managed to build a people ex nihilio, they do have a real (albeit short) history: An Ethnic conciousness as a south slav people going back to the late 19th century (ad) a lingustic and literary tradition going back to 1940s and a church going back to the 60s.

Ok so its not ancient but so what?

And they have pissed it all away for literal shit tier "we wuz kings" and have become the laughing stock of the world in certain circles, do they not think it odd everyone else on the planet has a different history?

As for Ancient Macedon as this was my dissertation I can tell you all current written and material record shows they were ancient hellenic, in thier own Macedonian way, like the Spartans were hellenes, but very spartan.

>b b but le Demosthenes

Sadly we dont base all history on one political rhetoric.

>le Athens = Ancient Greece meme is long dead.

Slavs on suicide watch.
>>
>>55221827
Alexander was ethnically Macedonian, hence a "southern slav"
>>
>>55222527
>le diaspora

Sorry mate but you cannot establish a link with antiquity any more than albanians are le illyrians.
>>
>>55221827
>were
>>
>>55222527
Ἀλέξανδρος ὁ Μέγας was a Hellene, hence a ''greek''.
>>
>>55213675
He was black.
>>
>>55222666
Where do the Albanians come from anyway?
>>
>>55223064

they were mix of the pre slavic tribes that lived around the area before slavs decided to shitty up the place i.e. thracians/illyrians

they've mixed with slavs too since

now
>>
>>55215887
Confirmed greek fag.
>>
>>55216110
>>55216110
It's not a meme, it's history.
>>
>>55223751
If only I was. But sadly, I'm a German-Polish burger-mongrel. Even if the memes of modern Greeks being Turkish rape-babies is true, I still rather be born Native there, with the history and culture, than here. But there's no need to describe this feeling to you anymore, as I'm sure you're probably familiar with it as-well.
>>
>>55216796
shit so vaporwave.
>>
>>55218022
que bajo has caido, mas bajo que andar de zeton maton es creerte un puto negro...
Thread replies: 84
Thread images: 22

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.