What is your opinion on RYM's top 10 albums of all time, according to user ratings?
(Please say your opinion nicely, when we are nice to each other the discussion becomes more enjoyable for everyone)
could be better without all the dadrock
>muh music peaked in the late 60s/early 70s meme
its a reasonable list for the most part, but Kid A at #6 is head-scratching
idk, i feel like Ok Computer was simply memed to number one. Other than that it's pretty good.
Less dadrock tho
why are they ranking numbers too?
fuck number 4 btw
sup crazyaga. missed you
only albums i dont absolutely hate are 7 8 and 9
>>60686381
i get why most of them are there like Pink Floyd, King Crimson, Velvet Underground, the Beatles and Radiohead (although i don't really like them much), but i disagree completely
and i don't get how MBV and Led Zeppelin is there, one is a fucking pop reocrd and the other is groove based shit, might as well have a slam album there (ignoring it's influence of course)
>>60686398
But anon, the fact it was rock that was made earlier is not an indicator if it's quality.
could be better without all the radiohead
OK Computer should be lower and Kid A should be higher. I don't object to the inclusion of two Beatles albums, though I'm not sure those would be the two I'd pick. There's obviously a bias toward music from the late 6ps and 70s on RYM.
>>60686381
shit, but better than anywhere else
>>60686381
only the prime number albums are any good
>>60686381
I am disgust that some peoples might start their journey by straight, thoughlessly consuming this list. Its so stupid - limiting music to few lyrical american rock albums. I pity those peoples, they will miss so much good music out there, thats instrumental so rym teens dont care about it
when will the "le Beatles are le best band of all time!!!" meme end?
>Radiohead
>Not only once but twice
>>60686473
agree tbqh
i think music is kind of a path to self realization, by listening to album in several genres until one finds what truly appeals to them, and then explore those genres more deeply
>>60686473
i agree with you completely
>>60686381
none of them should be in the top 10. the only one that should be in the top 100 is loveless
/thread
>>60686473
>american rock bands
>only one band from the US on the list
sure thing bud
>>60686520
loveless and velvet
>>60686520
>/threading your own post
not even surprised you picked loveless as the best one
>>60686546
>tripfag
JUST
My opinion about this albums:
Ok Computer - 9/10
Dark Side Of The Moon - 9/10
The Velvet Underground - hmm. 5/10 probably.
Wish You Were Here - 10/10 or 9.5/10
In the Court Of The Crimson King - 7~8/10, i'm not too sure.
Kid A - 10/10
Abbey Road - 7.5/10. it might grow in me to 8 though, i dunno
Revolver - 5/10, maybe even 4/10. completely mediocre. maybe i will change my opinion though since i haven't heard it a really long time
Loveless - 8/10, maybe it will grow in me someday
Led Zeppelin IV - 8/10 probably, but Stairway To Heaven is being played way way way too much in a very unproportional way.
>>60686524
so, the cancer of music is actually british
>2 fucking Radiohead albums
Yeah, get this heap of bullshit out of my face.
Otherwise, it's not too bad.
Ok Computer - 1/10
Dark Side Of The Moon - 1/10
The Velvet Underground - 7/10
Wish You Were Here - 2/10
In the Court Of The Crimson King - 2/10
Kid A - 2/10
Abbey Road - 4/10
Revolver - 3/10
Loveless - 6/10
Led Zeppelin IV - 0/10
>>60686559
Please don't call music other people love in that way i find it offensive thank you ~
>>60686473
I disagree. there is nothing wrong with starting your musical journey by listening to albums that are actually famous and popular classics
>>60686584
The fact you swear says nothing about me, it only says things about you. by swearing, instead of making the other person look bad like you try to, you only make yourself look bad.
Please be kind and friendly anon <3
What with these anti TVU posters
>>60686645
I'm just not a fan of TVU. but i respect fully people who do love them ~
>>60686398
>implying dadrock is not the best
fuggot
>>60686381
I think its shitty.
And have the reason, the reason is that many users there dont vote on stuff they hate, this leave stuff that shouldnt be on chart because the guys that know the albums and hated them, never bothered to rate it.
This nullfy the style of voting rym uses, that is called range voting.
By voting only on stuff you like you turn the system into some variant of approval voting system ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Approval_voting)
and approval voting system is worse than rating system
>>60686612
This board isn't a good fit for you m8.
>>60686686
is that so.
I would say, friendly and nice people like me is actually exactly what this board needs ~
legit, there is not a single good person in this thread.
wtf?
Reddit/10
I hate that every website's rankings are decided by the entry level plebs
They just shouldn't show rankings at all. The masses are fucking ignorant
welcome to /mu/
Loveless, ITCOTCK and TVU&N are the only albums that deserve to be there.
>>60686769
>why won't they put my le patrician avant garde whale calls played backwards on the list!!!
>the masses are ignorant!!! >:^(
>>60686769
It's true most people aren't as knowledgeable about music as true music fans like the ones in /mu/, but, ignoring the votes of people in a public site like rym just because "they are not familiar with enough music" is not the right thing to do. everyone should have the same rights when accessing a site like this
RYM was made so that EVERYONE can rate and share their opinion, remember that.
>>60686381
>2 Beatles, 2 Radiohead, 2 Pink Floyd.
Wow its just like fucking Rolling stone magazines but instead of Beatles and Bob Dylan its the Beatles and Radiohead
Seriously DOTM is such a mediocre album, I really don't get the hype
>>60686813
But its stupid though. When everyone has their opinion, popularity goes over quality every time. Easy listening dadrock beats (initially) hard to stomach experimental sounds
That's just wrong, democracy is a failure
>>60686810
okkid.jpg
>>60686813
>music fans
>/mu/
/mu/ is just a pissing contest to see who can find the shittiest, most obscure wankery to pretend that you're better than everyone else. I don't even know why you made this thread and expected anything more than ">list has two radioheads xPP" or other retarded comments.
>>60686827
Well, the whole atmosphere of the album is absolutely beautiful and i think anything on this album, from the songwriting to the performance is absolutely phenomenal. just my opinion
>>60686849
>they don't share my opinions so they're wrong
haha fucking plebs right
>>60686863
/mu/ is for real music fans anon you get /mu/ wrong ~
people here post alot of memes just because they like to do silly fun things way too much, but they are still genuine music fans :3
>>60686849
But anon, quality is entirely subjective. unless you are making the list by your own, it's almost certain there will be something you won't like in it if other people vote on it. the albums that got to the top 10 of rym are the albums that are perceived as "top quality" albums by the largest amount of people, and that is how the system should be.
>OK Computer in the 1st place
>two Radiohead albums
>two Beatles albums
>two Pink Floyd albums
>no electronic music
The only decent albums in that list are le banana album, king crimson and pic related
>7/10
>7/10
>7/10
>8/10
>9/10
>4/10
>6/10
>7/10
>9/10
>4/10
im glad i dont go on rym
>>60686924
According to this ratings you like most of the albums there though
>>60686453
>OK Computer should be lower and Kid A should be higher
lol
why aren't you active on rym, crazyaga?
>>60686919
>people here post alot of memes just because they like to do silly fun things way too much,
You missed my point, people here post memes because the actual music threads are just a bunch of faggots yelling at each other because STOP LIKING WHAT I DON'T LIKE!!1!1!!1!1!
never forget: http://rbt.asia/mu/thread/S41089822
i'll never underatand RYM's radiohead worship
abbey road is the best album in the top 10 btw
>>60686381
>[Post a Reply]
>11/28/15 New trial text board added: /news/ - Current News
>11/12/15 Name changed. WWE topics on /asp/ - Alternative Sports & Wrestling
>11/09/15 New trial board added: /trash/ - Off-Topic
>[Hide] [Show All]
>Please support 4chan by disabling your ad blocker on *.4chan.org/*, purchasing a self-serve ad, or buying a 4chan Pass.
>You anon might like it more. "Anonymous Documentary - How Anonymous Hackers Changed the World Full Documentary"
>[] [Return] [Catalog] [Bottom]54 / 4 / 33 / 1 [Update] [Auto]
>File: opinions.png (167 KB, 441x801)
> crazyaga !!gDYZXg02vsZ 11/29/15(Sun)09:58:13 No.60686381▶>>60686441 >>60686460 >>60686461 >>60686473 >>60686520 >>60686683 >>60686817
>What is your opinion on RYM's top 10 albums of all time, according to user ratings?
>(Please say your opinion nicely, when we are nice to each other the discussion becomes more enjoyable for everyone)
>>>
> Anonymous 11/29/15(Sun)09:59:06 No.60686398▶>>60686447 >>60686679
>could be better without all the dadrock
>>>
> Anonymous 11/29/15(Sun)10:00:29 No.60686414
Nico and the bananas is so overrated
>>60686922
>"electronic"
>albums
>only likes /mu/core trash
That's a tripfag alright
>>60686381
how do they decide what order they go in?
you would think average rating would decide it, but tvu&n has a higher rating than okc, and abbey road has a higher rating than tvu&n, but their positions in the chart are the reverse of that
what does it mean
>>60686919
>quality is subjective
No it isn't. You can objectively rate production quality, ideas, lyrics, you can compare it to other artists in their genres
Popular and quality sometimes happens, but more often it does not. Something like Bowie is an example of quality that was mainstream successful. He would not have gotten anywhere in any other time period though. Had he been born today he'd enjoy some success but not become a huge star. Most mainstream/entry level artists are just bad when you start exploring genres properly. They are all just weaker, less well made versions of the better albums out there
>>60686961
They get angry sometimes because of how passionate they are towards music, they see it as a part of their self definition, so whenever someone says he dislikes something they love, some people here find it hard to deal with ~
People here should just relax, and learn to respect each other, and understand that having a large variety of opinion is a positive thing.
>>60686956
idk. i rate albums and save my ratings on a notepad. want me to copy paste my lastest notepad album ratings?
I mean, it's a list created by mass opinion, of course popular releases are going to be at the top
Honestly, the fact that loveless is even there and radiohead is there twice proves what a massive influence /mu/ kiddies and their ilk have. Not that those are bad albums, but if this was more wide-reaching they wouldn't get a look in
It's pretty embarrassing how desperately /mu/ tries to distance itself from RYM. Go into the yearly charts for anything from the past ~15 years and it's literally just a war between prog/metalheads and mu/fantano/p4k drones
it's pretty bad. two radiohead albums in the top 10 sums up my feelings about it exactly. disgusting.
>>60686810
false dichotomy
>>60686994
>You can objectively rate production quality, ideas, lyrics
No you cant, because the selection of criteria for what makes any of those good or better is a subjective choice
>>60686994
Quality of music is entirely subjective because different people perceive "beautiful" differently.
For example, some lo-fi album can be absolute masterpiece in the ears of one person, and for the other person he won't like it because of how lo-fi it is
Ok Computer has a few weak tracks
Kid A is basically the peak of western civilisation though, should be #1
>>60687056
LMAO
>>60686381
ok computer: 9.5/10
dark side of the moon: 9/10
velvet underground + nico: 5/10
wish you were here: 8/10
in the court of the crimson king: haven't listened lol
kid a: 10/10
abbey road: 10/10
revolver: 10/10
loveless: 10/10
led zeppelin iv: 9.5/10
These are almost all fantastic albums.
>>60687000
you should copy / paste your ratings onto rym instead
They're all either good or ok, nothing totally mind blowing, but reasonable for a top 10
>>60687027
You just proved your point fagtron. lo-fi is objectively shit, the first person is just wrong
>>60687091
and what exactly is inherently wrong with lo-fi music?
>>60687090
pretty much. I can see why it would be considered to be top 10 of all time because it doesn't delve into more in-depth personal preferences of the listeners.
>>60687013
Are you actually defending someone who probably uses the word sheeple irl?
>>60687137
i'm not defending anybody, no.
>>60687026
It's not subjective though, only ignorance influences musical opinions. Someone who can handle an instrument and can produce music has better 'opinions' than some kid who has no musical bone in their body and downloaded Radiohead for
>the feels brah
Also, nobody exists who has listened to tons of albums and still remains at the entry level. They might hold some fondness for the stuff they used to listen to, but you never find people exploring genres returning to Iron Maiden and Linkin Park
>>60687112
It's shit.
>>60687012
Why you thinks so?? Loveless is extremely acclaimed 90s album, it even had 10 from pitchfork, hell i loved this album a lot of time before i found /mu/
>>60686935
I have to assume you disagree with me. I'm aware that most people think OK Computer is better, but Kid A is one of my favorite albums of all time.
>>60687176
elaborate?
>>60686769
>I hate that every website's rankings are decided by the entry level plebs
This is solved with the style of voting called range voting (some other may solve this but I cant remember them at this exact moment), a thing rym use.
With range voting, you can show that you hate the pleb stuff on the chart and so reduce the chance of it being on the chart.
Actually with populatiry come not only the guys that love it but the guys that will discover the band and hate it.
The problem with rym, is that the guys that hate those pleb albums, dont rate them and so you have bullshit on charts because this extreme amount of guys not liking some band will means almost nothing at the end.
1 guy like to drink snake poinson
the rest of the world dont.
This means poison has some quality as a drink. I mean the amount of people that hate something doenst matter right?
>>60687091
Sometimes, a lo-fi texture can be very beautiful anon. it depends on how the album is done
Kindly listen to pic related, it is an incredible work of art in my opinion
>>60687165
Different people have different minds. different minds find different things as beautiful and enjoyable = quality of music is entirely subjective.
1/10
7/10
9/10
5/10
8/10
2/10
6.5/10
7/10
9/10
5/10
i will never understand the praise that Radiohead gets. their albums sound so bad, empty to me, idk why
>>60687222
>b-but different people
Are you just going to repeat this dumb fucking shit when you can't even disprove anything I've brought up to the contrary?
Fucking tripfags, we're clearly done here if you can't actually retort with something of value
>>60687165
Write down an objective list of the criteria for quality in music then. You'd be the only person in history ever to do so.
>Someone who can handle an instrument and can produce music has better 'opinions' than some kid who has no musical bone in their body
Not necessarily. Look at the fanbases of artists like Steve Vai and Yngwie Malmsteen for example. Theyre entirely composed of guitarists who are impressed by/jelly of the technical ability. But the music is shite. Musicians are very often influenced by technical skill in their own instrument to the extent that they end up listening to horrible music.
>>60686381
rockist, boring, dated, unimaginative.
>>60687254
I did'nt read your comment all the way through because you started swearing and it made me feel comfortable so i just used to hide function. can you please repeat your claims in a post that does not include swears so i can read it without feeling uncomfortable? thanks.
And my claim is absolutely correct.
consider this: quality is an entirely human made thing. there is no such thing as quality without having a human that perceives it as something that has quality. and since the perception of everyone varries and is not the same, quality is a subjective thing.
some people think vegetable soup is absolutely delicious, some think it's not. so what is the quality of vegetable soup? the answer is, that it's determined by the one who ate it, subjectively, and it doesn't have any objective quality
>>60687298
>I did'nt read your comment all the way through because you started swearing and it made me feel [un]comfortable
lol. classic crazyaga.
>>60686381
too white
>>60687294
Well, i think Dark Side Of The Moon, Kid A and In The Court Of The Crimson King are very creative and imaginative albums
>>60687315
typos happen....
>>60687336
That is a pretty racist thing to say anon.
>>60687275
And yet the modifier is that Steve Vai fans haven't listened to any fucking music so the rule is still pretty good
I'd say the major factor is ignorance, less bands listened to = shit taste. Then on average, people who have listened to more music will also have more musical experience aka they will know how things are made even if they don't personally make them
There are always going to be outliers, but not experiencing anything means you are going to have bad taste.
>>60687298
>quality is a human made thing so there's no such thing
How fucking stupid are you. Seriously your arguments are horrible. People who don't like vegetables in general are often children, aka people who have no experienced many flavours and prefer to return to comfortable, easy eating foods which are bad for them
>>60686381
OKC - 8/10
DSOTM - 7/10
Le Banana :^) - 9/10
Wish You Were Here - 7/10
ITCOTCK - 8/10
Kid A - 7/10
Abbey Road - 5/10
Revolver - 5/10
Loveless - 8/10
Led Zep 4 - 4/10
it's a good list
>>60686827
I'm in the exact opposite boat. I think it's beaitiful and has this amazing atmosphere no other album has managed to gripe for me.
>>60687350
crazyaga missing the point, what else is new.
The taste is unimaginative, not necessarily the composition of the albums themselves.
>>60687294
>Musical prejudice that doesn't really exist, I have no attention span, God forbid something sound its age, imagination is what I look for in my best of all time lists.
Good for you anon.
>>60687336
But I think we can all agree that this is the real problem plaguing our society.
>>60687350
With regard to the list being "too white," it is interesting that all the albums are by white (and almost all British) bands. One would expect more black and American artists in the list (Miles Davis springs to mind).
>>60687353
>How fucking stupid are you
https://archive.rebeccablacktech.com/mu/thread/S43890693
>>60687406
I don't even care about the skin color of the artists i listen to to be honest. it's like, completely irrelevant
And Kind Of Blue by Miles David is the 11th album in RYM, just barely missing this list
>>60687429
It actually used to be in the top ten too. It goes back and forth.
>>60687350
>That is a pretty racist thing to say anon.
you gotta admit is somewhat troubling that barely-innovative white bands get all the credit while the black and brown musicians who were actually breaking boundaries get relegated to the bottom of the list
>>60687400
The only reason you'd make such arrogant assertions like that is if you felt threatened by what I said, meaning you're probably a dad-rocker yourself.
>>60686849
lol
>>60687457
:^)
>>60686934
yeah but i would never put them in the top ten
i'd maybe put itcotck in the top 10 but thats it
the fact that a 7/10 qualifies as a top ten album is gross
>>60687427
I'm diagnosed as gifted, with an IQ higher than 99% of the population. i went through 3 different professional IQ tests (not internet ones, actual real life ones) and all of them indicated that i'm gifted. i used to study in a class for gifted students in a boarding school too.
I'm not trying to show off or anything, but i don't like it when people underestimate my intelligence
>>60687427
4chan would actually be good if the mods even attempted to do their jobs. Proxies aren't infinite, and taking people's names away from them has worked often to stop attention whore trolls
You can't have a good community when you just let faggots post because they can't be fucked to do anything that isn't blatantly rule breaking
>>60687472
>you're right and I have nothing else to say but I am a very passive-aggressive person so here is an insulting meme
>>60687491
and yet you still post on an image board for retards.
>>60687511
:^)
[spoiler]Nice dubs by the way[/spoiler]
>>60687491
I was with you until now, nobody cares about your IQ faggot.
Someone post the crazyaga pictures pls
>>60687496
I'm pretty sure the only way to get banned on /mu/ is to call someone a nigger desu
>>60687491
>>60687538
>>60687517
Oh come on, you know that is not true.
Also, I'm lonely, and i want to discuss music with other people, and this is one of the best places for music discussion i know about.
>>60687539
You are now "not with me" because i told my IQ as a response to someone who underestimated my intelligence? there is nothing wrong with posting that.
>>60687580
There is absolutely nothing wrong with the statement i was making.
wish it wasn't so heavily biased towards rock, I don't understand why "esoteric" is considered a different scale than the all time best music chart. classical, hip hop, jazz, "worldly" music (ie non American or European) is also almost completely absent. its a good chart if you want to get started on good wasp music but that's it
>>60687601
You don't have to reply to people who call you retarded, nor do you have to tip your fedora so hard you create new copy pasta
>>60687601
people have questions for your genius
>>60687551
>>60687568
>>60687452
>>60687452
not really
>>60687601
IQ without information is like poop without an asshole
>>60687635
I have all the rights to reply to it if i want to.
And please, your attempt to associate my statement and intelligence with a certain hat and type of people is not working. my post was completely fine, and it has no association with the image you were posting it with.
(and btw, there is nothing wrong with fedoras or people who wear them. it's just a hat. and also, people who were that hat might be from a large variety of personalities and ideologies. in fact, the stigma people here give to people who were fedora as people who see themselves as "enlightened", is not even a negative stigma. there is nothing wrong with seeing yourself as enlightened - "The Enlightenment, known in French as the Siècle des Lumières (Century of Enlightenment), and in German as the Aufklärung, was a philosophical movement which dominated the world of ideas in Europe in the 18th century. The principal goals of Enlightenment thinkers were liberty, progress, reason, tolerance and ending the abuses of the church and state.". being enlightened is a good thing. without people being enlightened, the church would still treat people who present ideas that counter their own religious ideology as criminals. so say thanks enlightened people exist so you can have freedom to speak your own mind today.)
>>60687791
*who wear that hat
>>60687791
what is wrong with you
>>60687791
Is this satire, irony, post-irony or new sincerity? And if so, what is new sincerity?
>>60687791
i am grateful for the freedom i have to tell you that your taste in music is fucking awful :)
>>60687600
computer
>>60687791
>I have all the rights to reply to it if i want to.
>And please, your attempt to associate my statement and intelligence with a certain hat and type of people is not working. my post was completely fine, and it has no association with the image you were posting it with.
>(and btw, there is nothing wrong with fedoras or people who wear them. it's just a hat. and also, people who were that hat might be from a large variety of personalities and ideologies. in fact, the stigma people here give to people who were fedora as people who see themselves as "enlightened", is not even a negative stigma. there is nothing wrong with seeing yourself as enlightened - "The Enlightenment, known in French as the Siècle des Lumières (Century of Enlightenment), and in German as the Aufklärung, was a philosophical movement which dominated the world of ideas in Europe in the 18th century. The principal goals of Enlightenment thinkers were liberty, progress, reason, tolerance and ending the abuses of the church and state.". being enlightened is a good thing. without people being enlightened, the church would still treat people who present ideas that counter their own religious ideology as criminals. so say thanks enlightened people exist so you can have freedom to speak your own mind today.)
What did he mean by this?
>>60687491
When you use IQ and academic history as a replacement for actual intellect and arguments, you're definitely not going to gain any credibility in the eyes of your peers.
Any fool can go through the school system and be called gifted. It's not particularly difficult, and the culture of entitlement that stems from that inevitably turns the children who emerge from that system into self-centered and pretentious nitwits, as they have been appreciated and praised for the most minute and trivial tasks their entire lives.
Wake up kid, the real world is shit and no one cares. Eat or be eaten, that's the rule, and no IQ or report card can stop that
good thread so far
>>60687791
I don't think you realize what context is
"Enlightened" hardly makes a reference to the historical movement of Enlightenment anymore. These days, it's a token belief associated with a blind hatred of the church and of conventional culture with no actual reason or agenda, nothing more.
>>60687874
I was diagnosed as gifted not just by my school, i went to a special institution that is dedicated to diagnosing gifted people - it was needed to get accepted to a gifted class in a boarding school i went to.
And by the way, i fully disagree with your statement about the world. the very fact we exist and can experience beauty and joy at all is utterly amazing.
>>60687791
amazing
I honestly think Muse's Origin of Symmetry is better than OK Computer.
>>60686381
Ok Computer - 8/10
Dark Side Of The Moon - 7/10
The Velvet Underground - 6/10
Wish You Were Here - ?
In the Court Of The Crimson King - 7/10
Kid A - 5/10
Abbey Road - 5/10
Revolver - 6/10
Loveless - 5/10
Led Zeppelin IV - 8/10
pretty boring list t b h
>>60687921
and that's why you ended up on 4chan :D
My honest opinion knowing that all top 10 lists are auctions is that the top 100 drum and bass albums by RYM is a really good list but has alot of artists that should never even be on that list like third eye foundation and cmon fuckin radiohead are u kidding there's so much shit on all those albums, what are music reviewers even doing to evaluate their balance, besides depending harshly on success by when marketing was around before the internet? fuckin waste
>>60686381
The only 9/10 on that list is TVU&N, everything else is just kinda meh or just pretty decent
>>60687956
I discovered /mu/ in 2012 because i told a guy in omegle i really love godspeed and boards of canada, and he asked me if im from /mu/, and i told him i'm not, so he introduced me to this site, saying that i will find here alot of people who share similar tastes with me.
>>60687921
Being called gifted doesn't matter. You have to prove it to people, with intelligent arguments and logical points. If you simply whip out your accolades when you appear to be losing an argument, it makes you look desperate and hopelessly arrogant. In addition, we can argue about existence and its implications all you want, but I'm frankly not willing to imprint my inherent pessimism on you for the fear it might shatter your rather endearing and innocent naivete
>>60688015
do you love beautiful things?
>people giving beatles albums less than a 5/10
>>60688072
You new to /mu/? It's the cool thing to do to hate The Beatles here.
>>60688029
I love them with all of my heart ~
>>60688102
do you touch yourself when you get horny?
>>60688102
i see youve been diagnosed as being gifted-- were you also diagnosed with severe autism?
>>60688097
ofc but is it said to be edgy and controversial or is it legitimately believed
>>60688132
kek
>>60687353
sorry, I had to take a phone call
Id still like to see your list of (objective) criteria for quality in music. If you cant come up with an exhaustive or complete list, maybe just half a dozen of (objectively) the most important?
>>60688138
By some, sure. There are few bands discussed on this board that prove as divisive as a conversation about The Beatles. Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin. But really few others.
>>60688138
i would go for the latter. they're a pretty boring and lame band, i'd rather listen to the beach boys or any of phil spector's work in the 60s if i want to listen to old pop/rock.
>>60688119
:3
>>60688132
I'm mentally healthy. i used to suffer from depression, but not anymore - i gained alot of strength
>>60686381
>Kid A as a number 6
not even a top 200 material
kek
>>60686810
>2015
>not liking whalebient
There's no excuse
>>60688311
http://ivanflutskaar.bandcamp.com
I only think Velvet and loveless deserve to be in the top ten
I'm also surprised to see all the Radiohead and Beatles albums but no pet sounds
>>60687353
You are the one with no argument my friend.
>>60686441
>might as well have a slam album there
I pray for the day that Molesting the Decapitated is in the top ten on RYM.
>>60686611
Very accurate except for Revolver.
>>60688475
what would u give revolver?
>>60688475
>Taking the bait
So awful. Typical pseudo-intellectual pretentious crap to believe rock is the superior genre of music. Much less "art rock" a meaningless term if there ever was one.
Does /mu/ copy RYM or the other way round?
>>60686827
The Wall was a way better album, but a couple of songs from DSotM were alright. It was just too bloated and repetitive
>>60686520
>>60686535
>>60686556
>>60686611
>>60686803
>>60687080
>>60687355
>>60688336
>Loveless is good
plebs actually believe this
>>60688629
its ridiculous how theres only 4 Beatles albums on there
>queen is dead at #22 and meat is murder at #570
>>60688770
Yeah, there should be six.
>>60688805
Yeah, you're right, both should be in the top 500.
[spoiler]Meat Is Murder is their weakest album too[/spoiler]
>>60688834
i disagree i think meat is murder is the most consistent album musically and lyrically
>>60686381
3/5
1.5/5
3/5
2/5
2.5/5
2.5/5
0.5/5
1.5/5
3.5/5
2/5
>>60686701
turn off the trip and you'll be golden, faggot
>>60688982
>>60686556
radiohead fucking sucks stop rimming thom yorke u fucking homo
>>60688629
The same people use both.
>>60688676
>thinking the Wall is better than TDSOTM
>>60688929
I'll just have to give it another listen. I wasn't trying to be a dick or anything by the way. I just think all they're albums are great and wouldn't mind seeing all of them in the top 500. Or the top thousand at the very least.
>>60686381
radiohead is so shit
>>60689141
igy nw i agree but i think that strangeways has a few good tracks but the rest is crap, just shows them running out of ideas
>>60686381
One too many Beatles records, and too much 60s/70s stuff. Also, too much Rock.
>>60687012
People say the same kinda thing about ITAOTS. Do you people not realize that those albums were really popular and influential before /mu/ even existed? We didn't "make" them.
>>60686381
I remember when loveless wasn't even in the top 20
>>60687791
You've gotten so much better at trolling over the years. I'm almost proud...
>>60686426
that album is a good meme though
daily reminder : thom yorke wrote all the lyrics to ok computer when he was seven
>>60686990
the number of ratings factors into it
rym also has a weighted rating system
>>60687080
listen to it binch
>>60686381
>tfw people take influence into account in their ratings
just rate it based on how much you enjoyed it, y'all
>>60686381
Ratings:
Ok Comp - 5
Dark Side - 4
TVUN - 7
WYWH - 6
ITCOCK - 8
Kid A - 4
Abbey - 7
Revolver - 8
Lovless - 5
Zep 4 - 5
So RYM users like old british rock bands. Its not really my thing, but the lasting popularity of this stuff says something. Also most rym users are probably english speaking if this is what came out.
>>60692471
people can enjoy things by virtue of this though. hearing how one piece influenced another can be an enjoyable experience
personally i dont like to see multiple entries by the same band in most any rankings, and never put more than one when I make my own lists. that being said this list makes sense when it comes to memeshit
How does this make you feel?
>>60692702
Warm and fuzzy inside like I'm doing something worthwhile with my time when in reality I'm just shitposting on an anonymous Parisian anti-terrorism, pro-refugee forum.
>>60692702
i kinda threw up in my mouth a little honestly
>>60692951
tbqh senpai you're kinda edgy
>>60686611
here's your reply
>>60686381
They're pretty much the biggest meme albums of all time tbqh.
It's funny that a thread on /mu/ at almost two hundred bumps in which the word 'meme' occurs eleven times (now twelve) is actually an instance of people exercising restraint. Amazing discussion guys. Keep it up.
>>60686381
OKC is good.
Kid A is good
MBV is good
The rest is dadrock-not that that's a bad term. ITCOTCK is a great prog album.
The only one I would argue does not deserve a spot is Wish you were Here and TVU&N.
>>60692702
disgusting 2bh
>>60686381
I could live without WYWH, Revolver and IV.
>>60693726
Yes, you could. :^)
>>60692702
Is this for the past 6 years?
T.b.h it's not very good.
>>60686381
I know the term is meant to be a meme criticism, but rockist describes it pretty well. It's not that the majority of those albums aren't good enough to potentially deserve a top ten spot (they are,) it's that there are so many equally great albums out there that are ignored because people spend too much time obsessing over rock and ignoring jazz, funk, electronic genres, and pretty much any non-rock genre that's album-oriented outside of a few trendy albums that mostly adhere to rock-y ideas of songwriting.
>>60693776
For the decade thus far tbqh senpai. And why do you say that?
>>60693780
Examples of alternatives then?
Pink Floyd, King Crimson, Velvet Underground, and all that other dadrock shit needs to fuck off and be forgotten by the industry for good.
>>60693859
E D G E
D
G
E
>>60693803
Have one on me is not very good
The Suburbs is good, but not that good.
TPAB isint even Kekdricks best album
Carrie and Lowell is not that great (and I am a Sufjan fan, I just don't think it compares to other albums across the board that well).
And kanye fucking sucks.
>>60686381
>1
9/10
>2
9/10
>3
6/10
>4
6/10
>5
7/10 or 6/10
>6
8/10
>7
4/10
>8
4/10
>9
5/10
>10
6/10
imo
>>60688693
>le loveless is bad meme
>>60693824
Go find a genre on rym that isn't related to rock and listen to the top rated albums, those will generally be at least alright.
>>60693859
>I listen to REAL music like Kanye West and Death Grips. Upvote if you were born in the right generation.
>>60693897
Look at this pleb and laugh!
>>60693884
But your words were
>it's not very good
Not
>I don't like it.
Which in addition to being more accurate would actually also be easier.
>>60693951
Cool. Most of us here are more versed in music than just rock music. But are those albums worthy of the top ten? Probably not.
>>60693897
>okc
9/10
>dsotm
8/10
>vu&n
8/10
>wywh
7/10
>itcotck
7/10
>kid a
9/10
>abbey road
8/10
>revolver
7/10
>loveless
8/10
>IV
7/10
just my opinion
>>60693977
Look at this dubs and check!
>>60693999
Nice trips.
too boring shitrendy music
thanks for read
>>60686922
would u put geogaddi in the top ten?
It's all shit. If you're not listening to minimal synth and no wave you have horrible taste.
Just being honest.
>>60686414
>OK Computer
>late 60s/early 70s
lol
>>60686381
it's fucking terrible, the only album that deserves to be on there is TVU & Nico. ITCOTCK and Loveless are good albums, but they don't deserve to be in the top 10.
>>60694064
No problem bb, I read it real good it was nice.
>>60694114
This. A million times this. The only worthwhile music is music other people aren't listening to at the moment. Everybody knows this. And that's why no music is worthwhile.
>>60694163
>I HAVE OPINIONS THAT DIFFER FROM THOSE OF OTHERS AND THEY'RE ALL TERRIBLE BECAUSE I SAID SO I AM THE ARBITER OF WHAT DOES AND DOES NOT BELONG IN RYM'S TOP TEN LIST THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT TO ME AND LITERALLY NOBODY ELSE
>>60694190
thanks for agreeing with us. now that we all agree the top 10 is shit can rym finally restart the charts so albums that deserve to be at the top go to the top.
1.) Led Zeppelin II
the rest of the albums can be whatever you people with bad taste listen to
>>60694263
>This fucking post
You're twisting my melon man.
Why do people like the banana album and rosburg I don't get it
Superior album coming though
>>60694295
>You're twisting my melon man.
>not "squeezing my lemon man"
you fucked up desu desu
>>60694263
This. A million times this. The only worthwhile music is Led Zeppelin. Everybody knows this. And that's why no music will ever be as good as them.
>>60694307
Spoon-feeding general is this way >>60691646 senpai.
>>60694341
Good album, shit opinion.
>>60694344
Nice dubs but you're dead wrong about my citrus fruit.
>>60694365
This. A million times. This. And that's why I'm a colossal faggot who only listens to The Beatles. You can't always get what you want is their best saddest song. Kek.
>>60694406
>Nice dubs but you're dead wrong about my citrus fruit.
that was a reference to Lemon Song from Led Zeppelin II but whatever...
>>60694437
Bitch, you think I don't know this shit. No one gives a shit lad. You'll look back on this once you've grown up and be embarrassed for yourself. Personally I feel sorry for you. At least you've made this mistake anonymously online so it won't have any consequences for you. I just hope realise how dumb this is some day and take it back.
>>60694437
>>60694467
PS, my twisted melon was a Happy Mondays reference senpai faggot. :^)
>>60694406
>>60694467
Fuck off. A million times fuck off. The only worthwhile music is Led Zeppelin. Everybody knows this.The Beatles are shit pop for losers who haven't discovered the greatness that is Led Zeppelin.
* puts on headphones and plays Thank You to drown out your annoying ass posts *
>>60694505
No one gives a shit lad. You'll look back on this once you've grown up and be embarrassed for yourself. Personally I feel sorry for you. At least you've made this mistake anonymously online so it won't have any consequences for you. I just hope realise how dumb this is some day and take it back.
>>60693719
>not liking hip hop makes you edgy
>>60686441
>one is a fucking pop reocrd
what's the problem if it's good, tho?
>>60694525
Stands true with unusually high frequency come to think of it. But why don't you like hip hop anon?
>>60686398
this t b h
yes
no
yes
no
no
yes
no
no
yes
no
>>60694558
senpai done fucked up desu
>>60694494
>>60694467
>PS, my twisted melon was a Happy Mondays reference senpai faggot. :^)
Cool, even though it had nothing to do with a more applicable LZ reference 先輩ですね。。。
>>60694608
Well I understand if you're English Happy Mondays are pretty much considered the greatest band ever outside of Arctic Monkeys and Oasis. :^) Also, I don't like them. And LZ a steaming pile of dadrockist shite.
>>60694554
the funny thing is that i like hip hop, at least some early gangsta rap /before it went to absolute irredeemably garbage) and modern industrial/experimental hip hop, as well as some other rappers i happen to be fond of, but i just find most hip-hop to be dull, and having the musical equivalent to muh production and a hip hop album that is essentially a ''hot'' topic album (although i'd say it's pretty damn decent, although it's doomed by it's lack of timelessness and that alone shouldn't put it that close to the top albums of the decade)
just my opinion though
>>60694529
nothing wrong with it m8, but in the top 9? With that much other better music out there? fucking no
>>60694653
>just my opinion though
Fair enough. Agree to disagree then. Have a nice day anon senpai.
>>60694639
>Well I understand if you're English Happy Mondays are pretty much considered the greatest band ever outside of Arctic Monkeys and Oasis. :^)
haven't listened to Happy Mondays, probably should check them out if they generate so much passion from you
>And LZ a steaming pile of dadrockist shite
I disagree but whatever floats your boat
>>60686381
ugh finally bands i like. i'm wearing my dark side of the moon shirt right now what a freaking coincidence. i wish we had more music like pink floyd here. a band with actually talent instead of that dumb hip hop with loud random fast speaking. blehh i just feel like this forum is missing out on great underrated albums like The Wall and such albums from pink floyd. i tried to listen to that my bloody valentine album but i ended up watching the movie which was kind of worth it but i still haven't heard the album. i think this forum could be great if we all took the time to listen to pink floyd. i'm listening to wish you were here for the first time right now and i can't even control my emotions i'm actually in tears. music has never moved me like this before.
OKC - 8/10
DSOTM - 8/10
TVU&N - 10/10
WYWH - 7.5/10
ITCOTCK - 8/10
AR - 8/10
Revolver - 8/10
Loveless - 8/10
LZIV - 7.5/10
>>60694730
Les rite generator. :)^
>>60694778
what are you trying to say? i only speak english
>>60694842
I only speak meme. :&^(
>>60686381
All pretty top notch if you ask me
>>60694929
Nobody asked you.
>>60694730
loooooooooooool
>people unironically don't like Pink Floyd
>>60694949
>if you ask me
>OK Computer
Deserves the spot
>Dark Side
Eh, it's grossly overrated, but I still like it
>VU&N
Get this 2edgy4u garbage out of my face
>Wish You Were Here
I'll allow it
>ITCOTCK
Deserves its spot
>Kid A
I think Amnesiac is better, but I can dig it
>Abbey Road
Overrated
>Revolver
Overrated
>Loveless
It's good, dunno if it's top 10 good
>Led Zeppelin IV
holy dadrock batman
>>60695290
If I pull that off, will you die?
>>60695346
Uh huh
OK COMPUTER IS THE GREATEST ALBUM OF ALL TIME YOU FOKIN PLEBS
>>60686381
I like and get the appeal of all of these albums
