Which Gen V mons did you think were good? Which did you think were passable?
>>25853556
Template
Everything crossed out is shit.
Everything untouched is lackluster at worst.
Everything that wasn't X'd is good.
Whoops forgot my image
i did it
good, neutral, and shit
Gold = great
Green = good
Red = bad
Overall a really good batch of Pokemon.
>>25853556
This is purely design wise. I like some of the yellow pokemon enough to use them on a team, but there's something about their design that keeps them out of green.
All things considered, not bad.
Now that I look back on it, there were very few Pokemon I disliked in Gen V. Probably why it's my favorite gen.
Note: I like all of the Genies' Therian Formes, just not the Incarnate Formes
>>25853606
>crossing out my boys heatmor and bouffalant
Guess I shouldn't be surprised
I really don't understand the hate for Keldeo.
I forgot to put durant on the good list.
>>25853822
What's wrong with Pignite?
The ones that aren't marked are ones I'm neutral towards.
>>25853556
Gen 5 had the best designs overall imo.
Green is good
Red can go burn
>>25853948
>disliking the Seismitoad line
butthurt tcgfag detected
>>25853898
Rudolph the red nose raindeer's retarded cousin can go eat shit.
>>25853898
It's a pony and ponies are bad because bronies obviously
I'm happy to see everyone here can realize the greatness of pic related
>>25853963
>butthurt tcgfag detected
why, what happened with Seismitoad cards?
>>25853963
I actual don't play the tcg, just don't the seismitoad line
Dark Green: Great
Light Green: Alright
Yellow: Meh
Pink: Cute is just a four letter word
Grey: I expected better from Game Freak
Anything not squared is acceptable
>Snivy has literally the only starter evolution line that I like
>Lilipup too fucking cute
>based fucking Blitzle, I'm an electric trainer all the way
>Archeon, both cute and my favorite kind of dinosaur
>MOTHER FUCKING ZORUA
>Reuniculus is adorable and it got me through some tough times
>Deerling because I love deer
>based Emolga, once again electric types are my favorite
>goddamn Chandelure, that elegant mother fucker
>Victini dropping the A-bomb with its cuteness
There are a few others from this generation that I think are cute or otherwise nice but these are my favorites. It also might be worth mentioning that Raichu is my all time favorite with Zorua as a close second so good job gen 5. You did good.
>>25853988
Oops wrong one
>>25853913
it shit
I'm surprised there hasn't been a blind Gen V hater to come in the thread and make one big red circle around the entire pic yet.
>>25854035
Do you hate Samurotts existence that much?
>>25854045
It sounds like you're the only faggot whose faggot enough to handle the job. Get to it.
>>25854056
Nah, I would never do that to my favorite gen.
>>25854035
>>25854035
>crossing out Mienshao but not Stunfisk
>>25853935
How dare you cross out my bro klinklang
if there is a ton of blue its cause i like gen 5
never realized how many gen 5 mons i actually genuinely like
>>25854140
It's pretty uninspired desu senpai
>>25854147
fuck i forgot to post the file
>>25854165
A Pokemon doesn't have to be massively inspired to be good.
>>25853781
>>25854035
>>25854166
Fuck you. You guys hate the best mon.
>inb4 the person who can know who's my favorite pokemon wins
Red cross doesn't mean I outright dislike it, but I'd be perfectly fine with it not existing.
Yellow cross means I'm fine with it on the whole, but there's something small about the design that annoys me.
>>25854190
Garbodor or panpour?
Green = Good
Yellow = Okay
>>25854223
Nope! Both I love Garbodor. It's cute.
>>25853556
Amonamoblah was gen 5? This whole time I thought it was an evo of the heart fish thing.
>>25853556
Go ahead and tell me I have bad taste, but I'll fight you over Purrloin, Leavanny, and that's about it.
How come people seem to be so mixed about Sawk and Throh?
Why does everyone hate Emboar/Pignite? I legitimately don't understand. Hating it's movepool or typing, whatever, but the design? The designs are top tier. Did pigs rape a lot of families?
>>25854317
Tepig could have evolved into something interesting. Instead, we got a fat blob with limbs. It doesn't help that it was the third Fire/Fighting starter in a row either.
Blue-Love
Green-Like
Brown-Dislike
Others-Neutral
>>25853556
>Which Gen V mons did you think were good?
All of them because I understand how to appreciate Pokemon designs.
>>25853898
Because it looks silly. Especially Resolute's dildo horn
>>25854284
It's certainly a more forgettable one.
>>25854316
Sawk was my nig back in my first Black playthrough. I wouldn't have beaten that last Hydreigon without his Sturdy ability, Low Sweep, and Reversal setup.
>>25853898
Cobalion looks magestic, Terrakion looks rugged and Virizion looks sleek. Keldeo just looks cartoony. Also gen 5 has too many legendaries in general, it shares this trait with gen 4.
>>25853948
PALPITOAD IS MY BRO FUCK YOU
>>25854317
Tepig started off really cute and then Pignite was just meh and for Emboar they went full ugly. Most starters do this which is why I usually don't like their evolution lines. Fennekin was my biggest disappointment though. Its bar none the cutest starter, then it becomes a cute fox witch and I was like oh fuck yes, this is MY fucking line! Then the real final form was revealed and I felt nothing but repulsion. Why do they have to make the final evolutions of all the starters so damn ugly?
Why do people hate Durant? It's design isn't that bad at all.
Green: like it
Nothing: it's OK
Orange: something about it bothers me
Red: DELETE THIS
>>25854484
I imagined it would have a staff and a witch hat. Not only did they pass that opportunity, but the overall design looked terrible.
>>25854317
I like Emboar because it does feel like huge grappling pig, but Pignite is just awkward with neither cute nor strong.
>>25854555
Someone gets it.
>>25854351
>>25854484
>Ugly
>Ugly
He's a boar. A luchador. A luchaboar. His entire evolution line is based on wrestling. What the fuck is wrong with you?
>>25853983
Damn shame about its evolution level. Are moths supposed to be really old or something?
>Multi-circled Blue: Absolute favs (even across other gens)
>Blue: Great.
>Green: Good. These add a lot of value to the dex.
>Yellow: Uninterested. Most of these I can see the appeal to
>Red: Totally dislike
>*: I think the Incarnate form is good, but I love the Therian form
Overall, damn good. Most of the stuff I dislike is at the beginning of the dex, usually just the first route shitters that you can ignore. Gen 5 had a really interesting eco system, I love imagining how the food chain works between the pokemon in this gen the most.
>>25853556
Do you have the templates for the other generations?
>Most people in this thread like Hydreigon and Bisharp
Good taste all around.
Behold opinions. Overall, a pretty decent Generation with a fair number of standouts that floundered a bit towards the end of the Dex.
>>25854529
I couldn't agree with you more. I completely believed that the wand would logically go on to something bigger but Delphox doesn't have anything. Why even give it a wand if it isn't going to be incorporated into the final form? Like, okay, I get it. Its supposed to be a gender neutral figure but come on! Boys wear witch hats just as much as girls and it could have been neutral without wasting all of its potential. Biggest disappointment in Pokemon history for me.
>>25854035
Dewottfags are literally cancer. Enjoy your shitty low-class samurai.
>>25853556
The Genie trio were just flat out retarded and I hated the design, and even more when they got land formes. I don't see what the big deal about the ice cream cones are though.
pignite is ugly
>>25853983
from what I've gathered from shitposting in the TCG threads, it was part of Mill your opponent to death: the deck, AKA Not Playing The Game: The Game
Red X = Dislike
No Mark = no opinion/ it's okay
Green Circle = Like/love
>>25855618
Pignite is friend.
>>25856368I forgot to green circle Haxorus
> Pink = Actually are in top ten favorites of all
> Blue = Liked, Good in a lot of ways and few have many fair flaws.
> Green = Clearly good in some way. Could do with a little improvement, but not bad for what they are
> Yellow = Meh. They're not awful but I wouldn't train it.
> Red = Bad in some way or all ways if you're Sawk.
> Black = Please stop existing.
>Purple = Wut
Yes I like Keldeo.
Ducklett is in it's own plane of existence.
>>25853556
Liligant, Whimsicott, Deerling, Zoruark, Leavanny, Jellicent, Chandelure and Beartic lines were good.
Emolga, Cincinno/Mincinno, Hydreigon, Audino, Vanillite ,Munna, Gothitelle line and starters and the three musketeers and Victini and Volcarona were passable.
Everything else was SHIT!
green underline = like
red strike = dislike
nothing = indifferent
>>25856483
wew lad.
>>25853556
Every Unovamon is perfect except Maractus and Alamamola because they should have been evolutions of Cacnea and Luvdisc
>>25854190
Heatmor or Sigilyph
