Well, I guess you could make a case with the Mudkip Line being Water-Ground and Brock having a rock fetish but that's grasping at straws. Giving May Torchic was the right decision though.

>>25853299
Why?

File: [PM]Pocket_Monsters_-_Diamond&Pearl_Special_-_The_Greatest_Crisis_in_Nibi_Gym's_History![SUB_720P_H264][6EAFA946].mkv_snapshot_13.53_[2016.02.23_14.46.36].jpg (110 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]

110 KB, 1280x720

>>25853299

His mom is a water type trainer and his dad is a rock type trainer. I think it is a great fit

Well the starters are always on the main cast so Mudkip would have gone to somebody.

If not Brock, Ash? I know in Sinnoh both of Ash's starters evolved but all the other times he got starters only one evolved (not counting Cyndaquil almost a decade later)... I don't want to give the possibility of not evolving to poor Mudkip.

>>25853324
Maybe May should have gotten both Torchic and Mudkip like the ORAS short. Torchic would have been her starter but then she caught Mudkip in the wild instead of Brock.

I was always really disappointed that it never became a Swampert. Mudkip was cute and Swampert is cool, but Marshtomp is one ugly motherfucker.

>>25853583
This. They repeated the same mistake next gen by evolving Tepig only once.

>>25853592
My bad, actually two gens later.

File: [PM]Pocket_Monsters_Best_Wishes_074_The_Fierce_Donamite!_Kirikizan_VS_Enbuoh!![H264_720P][260AE4B7].mkv_snapshot_17.59_[2016.01.06_13.12.12].jpg (79 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]

79 KB, 1280x720

>>25853592

Bianca made it cute

File: Pokémon SE3 EP128 - Chikorita Rescue.avi_snapshot_01.41_[2016.03.02_22.10.53].jpg (46 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]

46 KB, 640x480

Will Brock ever catch'em all?

>>25853324
And giving Ash Treecko was also the right decision.

>>25854047
All the STDs? Yes. Even the legendary ones.