Comparing Games Thread
let's keep this calm and nobody get too butthurt
>battle revolution that high up
I understand the other two Stadium games being up there but come on, man.
>>24893921
partially blinded by nostalgia much like some genwunners, because we used to BR that to throw down in times of heartgold/soulsilver in my dorm
>RS in F and Emerald in D
>BW in A and BW2 in S
>HGSS in S
My nigga
>Platinum in D
Come on, it deserves higher than that, at least B or A
>>24893912
>Colosseum, platinum that low
>>24893940
I'll agree with you on Platinum but Colosseum is very overrated. XD outshines it in pretty much every way except story.
>>24893912
>Mystery Dungeon all grouped together AND that low
>>24893936
I'm nearly shocked to see even this similar of a view. Hell yeah bro.
>>24893956
Care to post your opposing view point, or do you wish to just spew filth like the knuckle-dragging mongoloid you are?
>>24893912
Why are all the Mystery Dungeons lumped together? Have you even played them?
>>24893976
haha
>>24893912
>Sinnoh games on the bottom
>Jhoto games on top.
Acceptable taste. Your opinion on Spinoff games is shit though, however. PMD Sky has the best story of anything with Pokemon in the title.
>Colosseum
>Trading Card Game
>Conquest
>Platinum not S rank
>PMD all grouped into one and that low
>Shit
>G/S
>ORAS
>Good
>Snap that high
>G/S being above crystal
Gen II was mediocre.
>>24893976
Almost every spin off is better than the main games.
>>24893912
How do you objectively place 3rd gen so subjectively low? I don't think you do, just because you just don't.
>>24893912
>ORAS and gen 2 trash at the top
epic shit taste
>>24893985
Yeah, they're not great, explorers of the sky was easily the best, but it still wasn't good, on par with yellow and emerald and platinum, still better than original red/blue ruby/sapphire and others.
>>24893988
No pokemon games have "good story", the only truly passable ones are games with implied time jump.
>>24894033
Because I just do? Fucking water trumpets digimon creature concepts HM spam which continued on to gen 4.
Anybody else gonna post some rankings? Just me? Okay, whatever.
>ORAS
>S
>>24894124
I cackled.
>>24893992
This is the truth. I've only ever seen this being contested here.
>>24893912
Smh at TCG being F.
>>24894146
The coinflips are mostly pre-determined. It was a failure of a game.
>>24893992
>>24894143
If you're like under 18, maybe.
>>24894163
Nah, I just don't like eating shit.
>nobody get too butthurt
You've broken your own rule OP.
>>24894157
>one aspect is not pseudo-random as it should be
>concludes that complete game was failure
I think you missed a step there.
>>24894177
Not even butthurt, where are the other game-rank images?
>>24894190
>>When card games back then were more luck based then they are now because you couldn't bend it to your will like you can nowadays.
>>Luck based.
>>But then, the luck aspect is actually pre-set.
>>No luck in that.
Welp.
bump because mspaint is too hard to tackle
OP I actually agree with your shit. I would personally swap Art Academy with Emerald but otherwise no complaints
>Platinum and Colosseum that low
>GS, Snap, Shuffle that high
>Crystal actually worse than GS and HGSS
It's shit, though everything else I can live with, differing priorities and tastes and such.
>>24893912
>GS On top of Crystal
>Battle Revolution over PMD
>Grouping all of the PMD games together
>ORAS at the top
That's some shit taste right there
