[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y / ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo

Ace Attorney


Thread replies: 364
Thread images: 91

File: 1466038137638.png (192KB, 400x240px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1466038137638.png
192KB, 400x240px
>Worst girl as the main attorney
>Weeaboo as your assistant
>Clown as one of the characters
>Too Japanese

Are you ready for another round?
>>
Apollo is the worst attorney though.
>>
Eat your burgers.
>>
>>342098753
Athena is the worst attorney though.
>>
Tell me what happens to Maya at the end? Does she go back to training again?
>>
>>342099049
Nice opinion, Apollo's ability sucks gameplay wise, all you do is spot the difference. Athena's ability is at least okay and doesn't feel like a chore.
Also, Athena is a cute girl and Apollo is a total bore. Hell, DD is better than AJ. Apollo's character going edgelord is a headscratcher too.
>>
>>342099260
>Athena's ability is at least okay
It's a lot more bullshit than Apollo's tick detector.
>>
>>342098753
Who is worse: Gohanfags or Apollofags?
>>
File: 1465560631733.jpg (82KB, 400x240px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1465560631733.jpg
82KB, 400x240px
>>342099260
You're going to hate Spirit of Justice then.

>>342099238
She's like this in Spirit of Justice
>>
The final boss of AA6 is a female version of Manfred von Karma and Quercus "extraterritorial rights" Alba.

I am not kidding about this.
>>
>>342099260
Spirit of Justice is all about Apollo, thankfully.
We're back on track, no more Phoenix fanwanking.
>>
>>342099570
Who's the prosecutor for the final case ?
Is it mister DESIGNATED or is it this Mangrill you're mentioning ?
>>
File: karma2.jpg (487KB, 1366x768px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
karma2.jpg
487KB, 1366x768px
>mfw the last episode

How do you fuck up a finale that bad
>>
File: Final Boss.jpg (202KB, 400x240px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
Final Boss.jpg
202KB, 400x240px
>>342099634
Nayuta, then Mangrill.

This is her BTW.
>>
>>342099634
My mistake.

It's Phoenix, Nayuta, and Mangrill.
>>
>>342098529
>That feel when best girl is back with based Blackquill as his assistant
>Maya is still a useless maiden in distress used for fanservice
>Apollo stays in Kurain
>Because of that, we will have more Athena in the following games

Feels so fucking good, man.
>>
>>342099378
>>342099582
Really? You're joking right?
Shit.

>>342099313
Not really, at least for Athena's ability, it's more of implementation that was the problem.

For Apollo's ability, you already know the contradiction but you still have to spot the difference, and in some cases they're really vague. It's just a bad mechanic that doesn't suit Ace Attorney in my opinion.
>>
>>342099975
>Because of that, we will have more Athena in the following games

You do know they're going to throw her under the bus because she didn't do jack shit in AA6 so they made a filler case.
>>
File: 1465490867711.png (162KB, 400x240px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1465490867711.png
162KB, 400x240px
Apollo's past is fucked up.

How did [spoiler[ he went back to Japanifornia for Clay?
>>
>>342100305
Whaaaaaaaaaaat
>>
>>342100064
As long as we can play as her more, I couldn't care less. I prefer that to the complete clusterfuck that is Apollo's backstory.
>>
I'm currently playing the series for the first time
What the fuck happened to Phoenix in AJ?
>>
>>342099975
I agree, Athena is so fucking cute, she's smart, she's close to perfect, she's so fragile too that I need to protect her.
>>
>All those negative reviews from Amazon JP
What the fuck happened?
>>
>>342098529
I admit I am hyped for this case because I want more cute moments between Athena and Blackquill. Also I like her, I didn't find her to be a bad attorney. Much more plausible than Apollo "my-bracelet-tightens-when-someone-is-lying" Justice, at least.

Will this available in the rest of the world then? Not just Japan?
>>
>Athena
>Good
Can we stop this meme already
She's literally just
>haha lets just use my bullshit matrix to uncover the feefees of the witness
>HEY WITNESS READY FOR SOME THERAPY
>pls no
>TOO BAD HAVE SOME THERAPY
>>342100674
He became a turbo-bum and raised a daughter
>>
>>342098529
You misspelled "best girl".
>>
>>342100849
Stop the Athena bullying this instant. She's lived a hard life and you should be ashamed of yourself for shaming her.

Apollo didn't suffer that much so you can bully him though, fuck that guy.
>>
>>342100849
>Disliking a character because of her gimmick instead of the characterization
>Posting Maya, one of the worst female characters in the series.

Shit taste senpai.
>>
>>342100849
That's rich coming from a literally just le spirit medium girl fan.
>>
>>342099339
Vegetofags.
>>
Holy shit, the culprit breakdowns in this game are something else.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UmQAvn5q2PY
>>
>>342101332
This.
>>
File: maya and phoenix.png (410KB, 718x818px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
maya and phoenix.png
410KB, 718x818px
>>342101332
What characterization was there for Athena?
She didn't even do anything for the majority of AA5 besides for use the ebin matrix and flip back and forth between wondering if she murdered her mother
>>
They did a redo of the circus case twice now, and both were very good cases.

Fuck your shit.
>>
>>342100758
amazon jp reviews anything negatively
>>
File: miles edgeworth.jpg (149KB, 1278x717px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
miles edgeworth.jpg
149KB, 1278x717px
Hello, it's me, Miles Edgeworth.
>>
>>342101332
I like both of them.
>>
File: THE CHESS DIMENSION.png (27KB, 256x192px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
THE CHESS DIMENSION.png
27KB, 256x192px
>>342101783
Something seems off here.
>>
>>342098529
My least favourite GS/AA by far.
So boring and way too rooted in japanese mythos.
Last case is meh at best.

I feel like this series lost the plot why it was so liked.
>>
>>342099378
Guess I won't be buying the game then. Hope the series dies. Fucking Capcom.
>>
>>342101906
>So boring and way too rooted in japanese mythos.
2jap4u
>>
File: Bg_01.png (272KB, 400x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
Bg_01.png
272KB, 400x600px
>>342101563
>What characterization was there for Athena?
Little girl born with an uncontrollable special ability to read people's emotions and was used in experiments by her mother to try to reduce their effects.

Because of this difficulty, she was a shut in who didn't have many friends and, since he was in close company with robots, had a hard time seeing them different from humans, which is why she had that whole terrible misunderstading with taking her mother apart in DD and why she couldn't speak out loud well in public when trying to talk in the courtroom in Simon's case.

After that, since she felt guilty about it, she decided to study law so that she could find a way to free Simon or to not allow that mistake that happened to him to other people and also tried her best to be more outgoing. However, she was still traumatized about it when under heavy preasure (since it reminded her of when she was young and couldn't do anything) and needed people to keep her from freaking out, until she finally faced the "phantom" that keep eluding her for long.

She is a well developed character with faults and an interesting gimmick. If you don't like her, fine, but saying she is badly characterized is laughlable.
>>
Athena a shit

SHIT
>>
>>342102371
Reads like a tumblr "About me" section tbqh famajam
More best girl for the rest of us, then.
>>
>>342102371
She is still a Mary Sue though.
>>
>>342102371
You're arguing with a shitposting waifufag (like most mayaposters are). You can't reason with these people, it's just a waste of time.
>>
>>342101872
No, nothing wrong here.
>>
File: ramen maya.png (547KB, 700x800px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
ramen maya.png
547KB, 700x800px
>>342102610
>not being a funposting mayabro
>he doesn't even have any pics of his waifu to use
rolf'd hard fampai
>>
File: athenacomesup.png (85KB, 661x716px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
athenacomesup.png
85KB, 661x716px
>>342102371
please don't start this shit, it triggers people
>>
File: edgeworths ass game.png (1MB, 1027x4168px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
edgeworths ass game.png
1MB, 1027x4168px
>>342102721
If you'd insist.
>>
>>342102560
>Can't handle being under heavy preasure to the point she loses her shit and has to be encouraged
>Mary Sue

I see, you're shitposting.

Nevermind then, I will just post more Athena,
>>
>>342102560
For who?
>>
File: maya.png (279KB, 400x551px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
maya.png
279KB, 400x551px
>>342102858
>encouragement is apparently huge in the tiny head of an athenigger
Easily the weakest asspulls in the game.
>>
File: laughing cry.jpg (28KB, 390x310px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
laughing cry.jpg
28KB, 390x310px
>Apollo FAGGOTS gloat and laugh and chuckle about how Athena is now Assistant tier
>she gets a case
>the BETA BITCH BOYS literally SHIT THEMSELVES
>>
File: GS6_screenshot_1.png (1MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
GS6_screenshot_1.png
1MB, 1280x720px
Cute.
>>
>>342100674
He became Punished Phoenix, a fallen legend
>>
Athena's despair faces do funny things to me
>>
>>342103036
It looks like he is disappointed Phoenix isn't the one sleeping on his shoulder.
>>
>>342102970
Don't mind Apollo personally

Though I am finding it humorous that he essentially got his back for Phoenix stealing the spotlight in 4-4.
>>
File: hamburger phoenix.jpg (56KB, 400x240px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
hamburger phoenix.jpg
56KB, 400x240px
>>342103097
>>
>>342102970
This is the only logical development the series could've gotten.
Wright & Co. is a proper lawyering agency now, they have three professional defense attorneys. There's literally no reason why wouldn't each one of them get a case to work with in the sequels.
I actually really like this model too. People have been bitching endlessly, how they don't like that Phoenix has to start the game like some rookie attorney, even though he's a veteran by now. Well, now you can save him for the final case, while the other two work on different cases (seemingly unrelated, but in truth deeply tied to the mystery of the final case). This game writes itself.
>>
File: athenafulbright.jpg (209KB, 400x240px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
athenafulbright.jpg
209KB, 400x240px
>>342102970
I'm a bit surprised people would be glad about that, Athena is way, way better as a playable character than as an assistant. Giving her Blackquill as assistant is great, too.
>>
>>342103176
Despite the general consensus of AJ, Kristoph always did have one of my favorite breakdowns.

https://youtu.be/hkg1dPFOUEA
>>
File: 4-1 opening.webm (3MB, 256x192px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
4-1 opening.webm
3MB, 256x192px
>>342103306
Kristoph is a great villain, it's just that the rest of the game is a mess

4-1 is legit good though
>>
File: classy maya.png (573KB, 765x1020px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
classy maya.png
573KB, 765x1020px
>>342103262
>Shithena fags would rather play as girls
It all makes sense now
:^)___________________________
>>
>>342102560
>Mary Sue
Anon, she's one of the most fragile and flawed characters in AA.
>>
>>342103262
I like both her role as an assistant and as a defense attorney. Her wide range of sprites and emotions she displays on them is great. The other assistants seem dull in comparison.
>>
>>342103512
Her best face is when she's full of despair and looks mindbroken.
>>
File: miadahlia.png (47KB, 256x384px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
miadahlia.png
47KB, 256x384px
>>342103410
every time you played as a girl it has been good

so yes
>>
File: Pollu.png (220KB, 398x236px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
Pollu.png
220KB, 398x236px
>>
File: Durk.jpg (180KB, 400x240px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
Durk.jpg
180KB, 400x240px
>>342104017
>>
>>342104017
I'm not a fan of edgy Polly but the wanting to believe in Athena speech was pretty hype. Then entire fifth case (or rather, 4.5) was pretty good. The only good thing to come from DD.
>>
why do they have to keep fucking Apollo up with shit tier writing? He has 3 different mysterious pasts now. Fuck off with that shit.
>>
>>342104017
>>342104110
>he inherited his foster dad's eyebrows
>>
>>342104178
Let's see

AJ: Apollo is the son of Thalassa and the brother of Trucy. He has magical powers
DD: He has a bestfriend named Clay who gets murdered in the final case
SoJ: He has a foster brother and father. His real father was a musician who died in a fire. He actually lived in Khurain Land.
>>
File: 6-4.png (187KB, 500x302px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
6-4.png
187KB, 500x302px
That's a nice stack of pizza boxes.
>>
File: thats opressive.jpg (46KB, 816x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
thats opressive.jpg
46KB, 816x600px
>>342104325
>He has magical powers
Wasn't it just the bracelet reacting?
>>
>>342104325
>Apollo's father played guitar
>Apollo's rival ended up being a guitarist


POTTERY.
>>
>>342104486
Do you remember how Trucy also has small lie seeing powers? Apollos is just as strong as hers, it's just the braclet helps a ton.
>>
>>342104325
How does this work? Is he still siblings with Trucy?
>>
>>342104552
Also

Thalassa wrote the song despite having amnesia. She was trying to remember her husband.
>>
>>342104552
>>342104325
Don't forget

POTTERY
>>
>>342104685
>Burning
>Fire
>Take my life away
>Guitar
>Up together to the sky
>>
>>342104658
>>342104685
>Burn my love away.
>Apollo's father was killed in an arson


Kudos to Yamazaki.
>>
File: AA6 Cases.jpg (327KB, 400x1200px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
AA6 Cases.jpg
327KB, 400x1200px
Here you go.
>>
>>342098529
>Athena
>Worst girl
I thought she was fucking annoying in case 1 since I just wanted to play as phoenix but I started warming up to her around case 3, and by the end I liked her in her own right especially after 5-5
>Weaboo
Don't act like blackquill isn't both hilarious and based. Definitely approaches edgeworth levels. Sucks that we don't get to see his "chains breaking" animations in this game. Poo in Loo has a lot to live up to.
>Clown
Fuck clowns though.
>Too Japanese
It'll make the Japanifornication all the better, though. One of the best parts of ace attorney is seeing the mental gymnastics the localization team goes through to make everything set in the US

>>342104685
just reading those lyrics gives me PTSD flashbacks to "LETS WATCH DA BIDEO ONE MORE TIME"
>>
Now that I think about it.

Does Apollo's hobbies include singing and other musical shit?
>>
>>342105060
>Apollo's backstory based on the worst case in the series

nice, not to mention the weird Oedipal shit that had with it in DD
>>
I miss hobo naroowhoredoor
>>
File: FinalCase2.png (215KB, 500x297px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
FinalCase2.png
215KB, 500x297px
What a happy foster family.
>>
>>342105390
I just wonder what the reasoning was for bringing him back to Japanifornia just before his teen years. Hope someone translates that part soon.
>>
File: 1424932642996.jpg (101KB, 500x346px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1424932642996.jpg
101KB, 500x346px
>>342104860
I'm glad that they came back to making these collages for every chapter. They were dope in PW:AA
>>
>>342104178
Apollo is literally JUST: the character.

I really liked him in AJ despite being one upped by the hobo, but he was awful in DD with that unnatural shoehorned foreshadowing about muh bestie and then edgelord mode. And while I don't know the full story of his past revealed in Spirit of Justice, it sounds absolutely garbage.
>>
File: FinalCase4.jpg (132KB, 1200x675px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
FinalCase4.jpg
132KB, 1200x675px
JUST HOLD ME

FATHER OF THE YEAR
>>
>>342105858
>>342105390
>>342104110
>>342100305
This foster dad seems like a cool guy.
>>
File: Case2.png (244KB, 540x324px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
Case2.png
244KB, 540x324px
Apollo is getting a little bit too excited for Trucy.
>>
>>342105278
>hobo outfit is not an unlockable Phoenix costume
W H Y
>>
>>342106351
It's okay, she's only his half-sister.
>>
>>342098753

Shut up nigger, Apollo is fine.
>>
>>342105278
That was easily one of the worst things to happen to the series.
>>
>>342106670
>calm and collected phoenix
>worse than a bumbling retard

pls
>>
So, will I have fun with AAI2 if I've been spoiled who the mastermind is already?
>>
>>342106745
Yes, each case is fun in its own right (I was in the same boat as you are)
>>
>>342106745
He's not even Debeste part of the game anyway.
>>
>>342105278
This.

Master manipulator that does illegal shit to get culprits behind bars was the best.
>>
HOW THE FUCK IS GUMSHOE NOT IN THIS GAME BUT THAT SHIT CHARACTER EMA SKYE IS

I AM SO MAD
>>
>>342106745

AA has always been more about proving the villain did it than finding out who they are. Most of the villains in the game are pretty obvious and reveling in their viliainy to be actually enjoyable instead of being obligatory "WHAT A TWEEST" subversions.

Also, it's the best game in the series and much superior to AAI1.
>>
>>342106745
it's the best game in the series

the mastermind's one of 4-5 great villains anyway
>>
>>342106863
>make a bumbling retard a master ruseman in AA4
>excellent breath of fresh air to his character; highlights the fact that phoenix's seen some real shit
>suddenly retardify him again when AA5 happens and he gets his badge back

why
hobo phoenix was da bes
>>
SHIT CHARACTERS
>Klavier
>Ema Skye
>Trucy

Why do they always bring them back every game
>>
>>342107075
Gumshoe is most likely dead by now, pal.
>>
>>342107075
Ema is awesome.
>>
>>342107292
He was in one case of AJ as a cameo, if he died the other characters should at least address it, not fucking write him out, FUCK YOU CAPCOM
>>
>>342107075
Ema is a better character than Dick "I'm a fucking retard with a heart of gold character that has been done a gazillion times already" Gumshoe.
>>
Apollo's backstory

>Born with the two "horns" on his head
>Father died in a fire
>Mother had her memory erased in a rehearsal
>Foster dad adopted him and met his foster brother Nayuta
>For whatever reason, went back to Japanifornia for his teen years
>Met Clay, his best friend
>Few years later, won his first case by forgery
>Few months later, Clay got murdered and Apollo went full edgelord
>Few months later, met his foster father again
>Foster father told him that everything about his father was destroyed by the fire and didn't know about what happened to Thalassa
>Phoenix stayed silent about the issue
>Foster father died
>Apollo stays in Kurain until the justice system is fixed.
>Apollo and Trucy has yet to find out they're related by their mother.

What a fucking mess. Apollo seems like a normal boy. Why give him this kind of backstory?
>>
>>342107075

He's happily settled down with Maggie and retired.

Hopefully.
>>
>>342107169
>suddenly retardify him again when AA5 happens and he gets his badge back
reminder that when you are playing as APollo or Athena he still has the same cool personality from AJ. The only reason he seems like a retard in his cases is because you aren't watching him through rose colored glasses.
>>
Didn't like Dual Destinies that much.
Apollo didn't get much character growth.
Athena's gimmick wasn't much fun.
Parts between court sessions felt really dumbed down.
No real development of Blackquill's character, even though he was a lot more interesting prosecutor than Klavier.
And worst of all where was best character?
Gumshoe
>>
>>342106792
>>342107145
>>342107159

Alright, good to know, downloading it.
>>
>>342107462
Why does everyone related to Apollo dies?
>>
>>342107286

A thousand fucking times this

People calling Athena and Kay mary sues haven't seen fucking Klavier
>>
>>342107376
>awesome

>annoying snackoo meme
>not likeable
>passive aggressive towards strangers
>doesn't get a dressing down like Gumshoe despite being far more incompetent
>makes Apollo do her detective work with stupid minigames

>>342107453

and this faggot just described Phoenix, Apollo, Larry Butz, at times Edgeworth, well done. Ema Skye is yet another bland soulless waifu for you people to fap over and Gumshoe stood out far more than her, we already have Trucy, Maya, Athena, etc etc etc to serve this purpose. Your shit taste comes down to wanting a green pants flavour of waifu.

>>342107558
I wouldn't mind this if you know, it were ever addressed. He was a pretty important character to just write out in place of random characters like Ema.
>>
File: 46785581_p7.jpg (379KB, 538x678px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
46785581_p7.jpg
379KB, 538x678px
>>342107286
Nigga, I'll fight you. Trucy is best daughteru.
>>
>>342107462
What?
>>
File: FinalCase.png (135KB, 396x238px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
FinalCase.png
135KB, 396x238px
>>342107838
This is the so called "horns"
>>
>>342107774
And she was bitter about not getting her dream job.
Now that she has it she's considerable more chill
>>
>>342107664
>character inconsistency is A-OK
>>
>>342107774
Phoenix is not retarded.
Apollo is still very inexperienced, not a retard.
Edgeworth is just tsundere.
Larry I agree, he's a terrible character.
>>
>>342108050
There's no way she could be worse than she already was, but I don't see the point of bringing her back over and over. She's just not an interesting character. AAI2 introduced a lot of better characters but they refuse to bring them back or make AAI3. At this point being in AAI is just an excuse to write the character out of the franchise if you aren't Edgeworth.
>>
>>342108095
>inconsistency
>>
File: 1466078284489.gif (1MB, 408x244px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1466078284489.gif
1MB, 408x244px
ENGLISH RELEASE FUCKING WHEN?
>>
File: 1-4 art.png (82KB, 256x384px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1-4 art.png
82KB, 256x384px
>>342105523
Yeah, the standard character art for everything was really boring, no idea why they ever went back to that, this shit's dope
>>
Playing as Athena is the best thing about her. As an assistant she's just a genki girl, but as a player character we can see her actually competent side. Apollo as a player character is too close to Phoenix, personality-wise.
>>
>>342108153
Larry came back in this game and Gumshoe didn't. Now I'm not asking for much, just mention why Gumshoe is not taking part in any of the cases when he's been around now for 20 years in the police force, did he just die? Did he retire? What the fuck. I care more about him than all these shitty characters like Klavier or Larry who we've seen 10,000 times already and gotten all this development for some reason.
>>
>>342106745
No, but you will keep seeing more duplicitous shit behind everything Ray says, they foreshadow it pretty well
>>
>>342104618
Yes.
>>
>>342107764
>everyone
What?
>>
Do they have a reason why they removed Gumshoe? Is it because he won't appeal to the young audience or something?
>>
>>342108543
Because every detective we've seen in the second triliogy is crooked.
>>
>>342108543
They changed detectives at AJ's new cast and are just following up from that, there doesn't seem to be much of an ulterior motive here
>>
>>342108502
Not exactly everyone but you get what I mean

>Thalassa lost her memory
>Musician dad died in a fire
>Trucy gets arrested
>Clay got murdered
>Foster father died

Nayuta is safe for now.
>>
>>342108543
because they had such amazing replacements such as Ema "sticks snackoos and dicks in my eye" Skye and Fulbright. In fairness Fulbright was a great idea, although you'd think Gumshoe would come back for what is apparently the "final" most importantest AA game.

Not having him in here is shitting on the character and all the fans who liked him in the past games, but bring back fucking Klavier and Ema a million times. There are sooooo many returning characters but they specifically hate Gumshoe.
>>
>>342108736
Oh, come off it. He's a great character but he's also been in six fucking games, it's not like he's "been shat on". They just wanted a new dynamic.
>>
>>342108590
>>342108630
It wouldn't hurt a little to have a little cameo or a single mention of him? Gumshoe has yet to have some sort of hint to what he's doing in the second trilogy.
>>
>>342108736
>you'd think Gumshoe would come back for what is apparently the "final" most importantest AA game.
It isn't, there is a clear sequel hook after the credits.
>>
>>342108736
Guy already had six games, five where he had a main role.

You can fuck off right now.
>>
File: 1453642034746.jpg (852KB, 1386x932px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1453642034746.jpg
852KB, 1386x932px
>>342103251
Many people nowadays tend to talk about how Phoenix should fade into obscurity, because his arc was finished in T&T when he finally became as competent as Mia. However him becoming a boss and a mentor for Apollo and Athena could really work out as next chapter, if it's done correctly.

I would really like to see Phoenix struggle with his new position as a boss. DD was kinda doing something with it, but it was pretty scarce.
And it's really nice to see how far has he gone from his first trial.
>>
>>342108830
Well Edgeworth is the chief prosecutor so he's either retired from detective work and became a secretary or he's working with other prosecutors.

It doesn't make much sense to have gumshoe work with either Gavin or Simon.
>>
>>342108816
We already had the "new dynamic" in AJ and it sucked and everyone hated it. Then they bring it back again, not even a new detective, must insert Ema the Mary Sue into all games.

After being in the Gant case, besides DD, Ema has been in every. Single. Fucking. Game. AAI1, AAI2 and now AA6.

>>342108872
Sure he could be in future games, but how long will that be from now? 2 years for the game, 3-4 years for the localisation, or 5-6 for the fan translation? It's fucking bullshit.

>>342108953
He's a better character than Klavier, Ema and Larry and they all got into this game. He should be in 10 games before those three characters, and it's not like Athena or Phoenix are anything special either.

your argument may have any ground with DD or AJ where he has a cameo, but no, we've had 3 games now without him but bringing back every single other character. He doesn't need a "main role" just make him a 3D model finally and give any indication of what he's doing, IDFC about Ema, Maya, Trucy, Pearl and Klavier but we MUST know what they're fucking doing every year.
>>
>>342109006
DD was also his first real case in court since the whole falsified evidence thing, so he naturally was a little bit rusty.
Can't tell about the new game, but logically he should be more of a proper boss figure now.
>>
File: 1451813891760.jpg (23KB, 247x167px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1451813891760.jpg
23KB, 247x167px
>>342109173
>Every game
>What is JFA and T&T
>>
>>342109018
It still seems a bit weird that Phoenix never bothers to mention about him in DD and SoJ.
>>
>>342109306
Gant's case was made after JFA and T&T as an extra for the DS remake. Prepare for many (you)s informing you you're a retard.
>>
>>342109173
>We already had the "new dynamic" in AJ and it sucked and everyone hated it.

no we didn't, people hated the cases and the writing, not the new characters

grump ema is far from a sue either
>>
Why does the second trilogy feel inconsistent?

AJ was more on Phoenix's disbarment
DD was more on Athena and the DARK AGE OF LAW
SoJ was more on Apollo's backstory
>>
>>342109849
either you are too underage to remember the hate or a liar. Everyone hated Ema and Klavier was only like by fan girls and fags, which one are you?

But please inform me how Ema is such an amazing character and not an annoying unlikeable cunt in AJ.
>>
>>342109849
>new characters
>Zak Gramayre, Kristoph, Klavier, Wocky, Thalassa, Ema Skye
not him but AJ had the most hated characters in the series, easily, including Ema. I would guess this is an accident where fans assumed Gumshoe would be back but actively wanted Ema so we got this. It's a huge shame because Ema is a shit character.
>>
>>342110143
Kristoph is good though.
>>
>>342109424
Oh, you meant the period after RFtA was released. My bad.
>>
>>342110350
Kristoph is involved in the mess of Zak Gramayre, Thalassa and Hobo Phoenix's awful plot, plus he's so calm that there's no atmosphere or drama when dealing with him, and his ultimate takedown (oh there's a jury so you lose lol) was lame. Compared to the other main villains like Karma, Engarde or Godot, he's so ineffectual and barely appears in the game anyway.

Personally also fucking hate his gay ass design. Klavier is a faggy enough but makes any sense, Kristoph is meant to be a serious prosecutor but dresses like a douche hippie. Compare to von Karma, Gant, Blaise, he looks so out of place.
>>
>>342109849

What AJ characters?

>Apollo was a non character while Phoenix was the backseat driver protagonist of the story. His backstory was irrelevant to his character and he only got any actual development in DD.
>Klavier is the actual most "perfect" flawless mary sue in the series. The fact he manages to get off the hook blameless while Daryan and Kristoph are thrown under the bus only emphasizes it more.
>Trucy is just the panties gimmick and is still obsessed with her father and following in his footsteps after him being a horrible unlikable person. The character arc to give her some actual development practically writes itself.
>Kristoph was an incompetent villain who barely even got a chance to revel in his villainy, most of his screen time is in the fucking first case to make him the biggest anti climax in the series. Also, his motivation is because a clearly insane man turned him down as his defense attorney.
>>
>>342110787
You realize you can have a personality without being the main focus of the story, right? Apollo has a distinct personality that contrasts to Trucy pretty well. I swear the people going "lol panties" for Trucy are the same going "lol burgers" for Maya, too.
>>
File: hamburger apollo.jpg (54KB, 400x240px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
hamburger apollo.jpg
54KB, 400x240px
>>
>yfw chinese bootleg Steel Samurai

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=328Zqvnapl4
>>
>>342109953
nigger I was moderating the mess that is court records when it came out and frequented /v/'s threads here

they weren't hated bar klavier
>>
File: a41.png (100KB, 557x605px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
a41.png
100KB, 557x605px
>>342113317
>Most of SoJ OST
>>
>>342113918
Forgot link
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TRoGMtsBcsk
>>
>>342109173
>must insert Ema the Mary Sue

god, kill yourself
>>
File: stare patchoulli.png (62KB, 233x258px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
stare patchoulli.png
62KB, 233x258px
>>342104860
>Phoenix Wright game
>2 out of 5 cases mains Phoenix Wright
>>
>>342114335
6-1, 6-3 and DLC are Phoenix
>>
>>342098529
Why does every Attorney need a sidekick?

Are they all so incompetent they can't solve a case without any help?
>>
>>342113624
The fact Klavier was hated is kind of important, when he was the prosecutor and one of the most relevant characters to the plot. You may not have seen Ema hate but I saw it everywhere too.

>>342114321
>likes Mary Sues
>doesn't kill himself
>>
>>342114335
it's not a phoenix wright game
>>
>>342110787
>following in his footsteps after him being a horrible unlikable person.
Are you fucking retarded? Trucy didn't know the double life Zak was running. She never saw him during all those years since he left her
>lol panties
That was in DD.
>lol burgers
>lol stealing
>lol science
>>
>>342114607
Ema has mostly been fine, she's actually the character that works best with the charisma vacuum that is Klavier

You really can't call Ema a Mary Sue, what exactly makes her that? The fact that they gave her an actual personality in AJ to differ from Trucy says enough
>>
File: maxresdefault.jpg (596KB, 4000x2500px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
maxresdefault.jpg
596KB, 4000x2500px
>>342114624
lel'd mildly
>>
After how shitty DD was, I don't have high hopes for SoJ.

They clearly don't know what to do with the mainline anymore, and they don't even try to have some sort of continuity across games.

Athena is also a terrible character, trying too hard to be the next Maya, and she falls too much in the typical deviantart special snowflake self-insert.
>>
File: trucy mad.png (31KB, 150x150px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
trucy mad.png
31KB, 150x150px
>>342114825
just because Capcom USA is retarded enough to think the games can't sell without Phoenix on the cover doesn't mean it is

they're always called the much more neutral Gyakuten Saiban in Japan, so it doesn't actually matter who you play as
>>
>>342114896
self-insert as who?
>>
>>342114672

Please direct me to her other character traits within AJ then?

She has to at least know the basics of the trial, and she obviously knows he abandoned her for whatever reason. She grew up without him for the majority of her life, but apparently those first 8 years were just that damn impressionable.

And of course, she still faps to magic after all of it's shown in any games after AJ.
>>
>>342114896
t.Mayashitter
>>
>>342114991
The Phoenix shadow is still on the jap logo, dumbass
>>
>>342115080
>>342110787
I don't think that in-game people ever saw Zak as a particularly bad person? Like, randomly leaving and moving around seems to be part and parcel with AA parents, and Zak talking to Phoenix or whatever never comes across as Phoenix having some sort of grudge. It's not like it's just Zak she's following either - her granddad and mom were magicians, too.
>>
>>342115072
The prodigy with special powers who becomes super best pals with the main cast and saves the day in multiple occasions with a dark and tragic past.

>>342115083
Epic argument, Athenafaggot
>>
>>342114714
Lets go through all of Ema's appearance to highlight how pointless and bad she is as a character

>1-5: Phoenix's sidekick, personality is a slightly more annoying version of Maya, redundant and largely exists for explaining DS minigames like blowing into the mic
>AJ: No interaction with Klavier or other characters so has no development, aggrieves Apollo constantly as the millionth character to do this as a NPC in this series, again exist to explain DS minigames and has less plot relevance than in AJ
>AAI: A cameo that serves as fan service.
>AAI2: Ditto.
>AA6: Now gets to fully replace Gumshoe as the detective in the mainline games because waifu I guess.

As far as being a Mary Sue, how about her being a genius scientist who casually brings out every forensic device known to man. She gets no comeuppance, no development as she rapes Apollo with snackoos and is an annoying bitch to everyone. Klavier is much much worse I'll give you that, but Ema is in far more games and somehow presented as likeable. She should be one of the characters whipped by Franziska and bullied by everyone for it to even begin to be likeable if you aren't a pussy.
>>
>>342115128
They can't put three lawyers in the logo, so they go with the oldest
>>
>>342115080
>I mashed A without reading

Not my fault you don't remember how Trucy acts
>>
>>342099570

>Female final boss

About time desu

Even Dhalia got upstaged by that overrated shithead.
>>
>>342115318
Weren't we talking about AJ? Her appearances in AAI1/2 are fucking awful, and 1-5's is kind of whatever, for sure. Don't change the subject.

She gets comeuppance through not being a scientific investigator, which is kind of a major point. She already failed her dream. Mary Sues aren't known for not succeeding and being grumpy assholes.
>>
File: CalistoYew.jpg (78KB, 634x799px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
CalistoYew.jpg
78KB, 634x799px
>>342115519
I'd argue Dahlia still very much feels like the final boss of T&T

the real female final boss that gets upstaged horribly is this
>>
>>342115318
>Gumshoe

>LOL PAL I'M SO DUMB PAL LOL I FORGOT PAL XDD CONTRADICTION IN MY TESTIMONY PAL LOL MY SALARY PAL

God I fucking hate you Gumshoefags. Literally in every game except AA5 and AA6 and now NOOOOOOOOOO WHERE MUH GUUUMSHOOOOEEE?!?!? :(((((

Fuck off.
>>
>>342115628
I don't agree with that guy but this kind of flanderizing, all caps posts are bordering on shitposting. Fucking don't.
>>
>>342115278

The fact Zak isn't treated as the villain as he is in-universe is one of the biggest problems of AJ for me. Kristoph is the only character allowed to have any blame for anything from a narrative perspective - hell, the writer treats Valant with more disdain.

All I'm saying is this would've been an obvious route to develop the character of Trucy and that I find it very one dimensional and strange as is. AAI2 over there has some actual villainous parents presented in the proper light.
>>
>>342115548
I have always been talking about Ema as an overall character, she sucks in every appearance she's in, and your argument is "oh maybe she won't suck in this new game!"

No, I don't want that stupid character in the game, let alone replacing a fan favorite who is surreptitiously written out without explanation.

>>342115628
>in every game except the two most recent games that made the transition to 3D
oh jeez I wonder why Gumshoe fans want him in these games, it's almost as if literally every fucking terrible character has made it into AA5/6 except him.

Please defend Klavier, Larry, Athena being in over Gumshoe. I'll be waiting, faggot.
>>
>>342115820
You don't see Franziskafags sperging about her not being in 3D games.

Gumshoe simply doesn't have a purpose in the new games.
>>
Is Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney worth playing through? I haven't really played much Layton games.
>>
>>342115943
Franziska was shit in AA2, lets be honest. Gumshoe is a better character than her period.

I also didn't know Franziska even had fans outside of fappers/shippers. She's not likeable, and not even that good of a prosecutor, decidedly below average like much of JFA.
>>
>>342115739
I think most of what came to light about Zak is mostly in 4-4, which means there isn't much character development possible there. And then there was the pre-DD gap in the games until Capcom thought it was needed to force Phoenix into the new one, leaving little space for development like that. It's more on DD's head than AJ's.

That's not saying AJ isn't massively flawed writing wise, it is and it's definitely the weakest game, but I don't think in AJ itself there could've been more to that particular route. I kind of hate how they left open the Lamiroir bullshit at the end of AJ rather than solving that, though. It would've been the place for that.

>>342115820
You were literally talking about "when the game was released" and AJ, see >>342109953
. Fix your short-term memory, dingus.
>>
File: franziska.gif (2MB, 392x284px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
franziska.gif
2MB, 392x284px
>>342116079
Franziska really came into her own in the AAI games and T&T, though honestly she gets shafted in JFA because she only gets two cases to prosecute, one of which is the worst in the series.

She's actually pretty good in 2-2.
>>
File: 1386034865296.gif (1MB, 296x172px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1386034865296.gif
1MB, 296x172px
I hope the villain isn't a last minute asspull again like Phantom

Literally the worst villain.

>tfw will never have GOAT villains like Engarde or Mastermind
>>
>>342116095
Yes she sucks a lot in AJ and that's her biggest appearance, everything else is but a cameo, that is the offensive part here. She now gets another main role off the back of being such a shit character in what, 4 fucking games? Fucking ridiculous.

>>342116193
Franziska was very poorly executed and definitely suffered from being introduced in JFA. Besides the final case that game is utter shit. Still not like that's much of a defence, I have never seen anyone who cares much about her, she's just there.
>>
>>342100674
Some idiot thought it would be a funny idea to just throw away 7 years of the characters life for no reason.
>>
>>342116402
She's pretty good in AJ, she's meant to have good chemistry with the prosecutor and act off him, which she does. It makes sense to bring her back for SoJ too, if DD's plot didn't require her to not appear she would've likely been in there too.

Everything that wasn't 1-5 or AJ has been dumb cameos, you can't judge a character by that. It's like judging Gumshoe by his AJ appearance.
>>
>>342116526
And then some idiot thought it would be a funny idea to just soft-reset everything and throw away all those 7 years of development out the window for no reason, back to "le nervous bluff attorney" persona.
>>
>>342116298
>Engarde
>GOAT

It was great to take him down, but he was a terrible villain
>>
>>342114896
I didn't like DD, thought its text was trying too hard to be funny and ended up being cringy many times. it annoyed me a lot.
But SoJ is definitely one of my favorites. they improved it in every way.
Not like the AAI to GK2 evolution though, I enjoyed Divination Séance more than Mood Matrix. The ending was also more satisfying than DD.
>>
>>342099727
It wasn't the finale.
>>
>>342116601
Wait, she has interaction with Klavier at some point? I don't remember anything like that.

As for comparing her in the several cameos, lets be honest, Ema's cameos are a lot bigger overall than Gumshoe's in the mainline series after T&T. Seeing as I don't remember her having any interactions with Klavier or serving any purpose I don't see why she would be brought back, and it's not as if she has been on a huge break from the series. Definitive example of overexposure of a lame background character, may as well be Ox King.
>>
File: adrianshoe.png (257KB, 480x640px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
adrianshoe.png
257KB, 480x640px
>>342116758
He's an incredible simple villain, it's great. He has no grand scheme or anything, he's just an asshole who wants to murder someone and hires an assassin.

One of the reasons I think 2-4 works so well is because its basic plot is incredibly simple, but it gets complicated and interesting because of character interaction. There aren't many one-off characters that get as much depth (or purposeful non-depth) as the trio of de Killer, Engarde, and Andrews.
>>
>>342116762
How did you consume SoJ? Compare it to AAI2 directly in terms of villains, that is the high bar for the series imo.
>>
>>342099049
at least she's fuggable, unlike apollo
>>
>>342116884
>Wait, she has interaction with Klavier at some point? I don't remember anything like that.

Maybe... try replaying the game sometime? You're barely remembering. Yes, she does. That's kind of who she interacts with a lot, and they constantly shittalk each other.
>>
>>342115434

I mean, I guess you can call fapping to Klavier like a standard issue fangirl characterization. I'm more concerned why you find this likable in any way and not annoying. I'll just say we have very different taste and leave it at that.
>>
When is this out?
>>
>>342117072
I replayed the game a month ago and there's nothing there. Maybe a few lines exchanged back and forth at most?

It's about 1% as substantive as Gumshoe and Edgeworth's friendship, and 0% as interesting or fun.
>>
File: end.jpg (3MB, 563x7720px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
end.jpg
3MB, 563x7720px
>>342116762
To me, DD's biggest flaw is that it tried way too hard to be all GRAND and EPIC, but it was just bland.

The whole game played it too safe and there was a bunch of cringe moments like most of 5-3 and that "speech" they give to the phantom before he breaks
>>
>>342116962
I disagree. I think he was way too one-dimensional for me to take seriously and was way too fucking stupid to take seriously with trying to blackmail a top tier assassin that could kill you anytime.

The whole case was a disappointment to me though. Way too overhyped just because of "WOW blackmail" and "your client is the culprit bit". Didn't like a single character either.
>>
>>342117223
It's actually pretty significant, especially in court where Klavier constantly talks down on her, and during investigation where she constantly talks down on Klavier. When they meet, which does happen a bunch, they have this passive-aggressive relationship that's pretty funny.

I can't really argue this with you if you don't actually remember the game, sorry.
>>
File: 1452998123842.png (11KB, 253x173px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1452998123842.png
11KB, 253x173px
>playing T&T second case
>manage to finish the crime in one trial day, we truly are the ace attornies
>back in lobby
>ron is now convicted for murder because you proved he wasn't able to steal the urn
>>
File: hugh double.jpg (81KB, 943x653px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
hugh double.jpg
81KB, 943x653px
>>342117253
>most of 5-3

most of 5-3 was fucking awesome
>>
>>342117357
I think you are fan fictioning this up a lot because I don't remember anything about this, probably like how this guy makes up Trucy having a personality >>342115434

I may have played this game more recently than you and what you said just sounds made up at worst, very exaggerated at best.
>>
>>342098529
>Worst girl as the main attorney
Read: I'm a Mayafag! Yay for having to save my damsel waifu again!

>Weeaboo as your assistant
Blackquill was pretty great though.

>Clown as one of the characters
This could be either very bad (Moe) or very good (Simon).

>Too Japanese
Eat your hamburgers, Apollo
>>
>>342117460
This.

I don't understand why people are so autistic and just can't enjoy a good case that doesn't take itself seriously all the time.
>>
File: shrug trucy.png (237KB, 394x236px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
shrug trucy.png
237KB, 394x236px
>>342117518
You didn't, I'm marathoning this series right now before SoJ comes out. You're skipping text, or something, I don't fucking know. The entirety of 4-3 day one is Klavier pulling a fast one on Ema.
>>
>Want to like this series
>it's enjoyable and the characters are fun
>Can't finish a trial beyond the first one because nothing ever makes sense to me
I'm too dumb for this series, managed to finish the first one moreo rl ess without a guide, the second one was just impossible and it burned me out. Seeing the solutions brings me no joy, but trial error is fucking tedious. Had no issues with danganronpa though, liked the small dig that they did with the swimsuit.
>>
>>342117638
oh, but they aren't even on screen at the same time? sure there's some back and forth but it's nothing special and I mean, maybe it was under developed or rushed, but certainly a lot shittier than Gumshoe's interactions in the original trilogy. I don't know why you'd want more of it other than it being "different."
>>
Do you need to know moonrunes to "play" AA6? Any translations out already? Any impressions of the game?

>>342117759
>liking Danganronpa
>>
>>342117773
What? They're in the same court room talking to each other, and they're in investigation scenes together as well.

Look, you can like Edgeworth and Gumshoe's relationship more (I do too, but it's also partially because they have five games together as opposed to one), but you can't say that she doesn't interact with Klavier or that she's a Mary Sue in AJ (or beyond, most likely). Tastes differ, but that's just bullshit.
>>
>>342117884
It's more or less the same shit but easier and with logic that I can follow. What can I say.
>>
>>342117884
>Not liking Danganronpa
HOPEman makes the entire series worth it.
>>
>>342117884
It's out in the West in September
>>
>>342117460
Not him, but to be honest 5-3 had its small dose of cringe, the main contender is probably Hugh screaming in the anime cutscene. Reenactment of the mock trial was kinda stupid too, I feel that it was made just to somehow shoehorn Klavier into the game.
Despite that, it's still my favorite non-DLC chapter from Dual Destinies.
>>
File: reddwhite.jpg (64KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
reddwhite.jpg
64KB, 1280x720px
>>342117759

The Frank Sahwit case is basically a demo, I'd say the case after that is a tutorial, and the third case is your first full case. Not going to lie, getting stuck on this guy is kind of pathetic.

Most of the later games all greatly reference the first one, but if you want an easier game I'd suggest Dual Destinies - people complained that was too easy if anything, but if you can't get fucking past Redd White, it should be fine for you.
>>
File: meanssolve2.png (56KB, 262x198px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
meanssolve2.png
56KB, 262x198px
>>342118123
5-3 had bad moments for sure, but /v/ has this tendency to blow up bad moments and forget literally everything else

The entirety of day 2 is fucking hilarious, with both Hugh and Means amping it up. Scuttlebutt is great fun, too.
>>
>>342117946
>5 games as opposed to 1
Therein lies the problem, why would I want to replace Gumshoe and Edgeworth with Ema and Klavier? They're just outright shittier in every way and have worse chemistry and are worse characters. I mean, if you like that, okay, but there's no objective way to argue it's better than what we had, even just surrogating Gumshoe to a new character would be better. Granted it's not going to have the depth we had but it's less half assed.

Also who else is there to even look to for a bro friendship anymore? Apollo and Phoenix is some weird mentor/father relationship, and all the main characters are female or autists like Blackquill and Edgeworth (not to say they're bad, but they're not normal people).

>>342117947
>>342117964
DR1 is mostly abstract and subversive crap, though I didn't mind some of the middle cases, Junko is an awful villain and her twist ruined the second game. Nagito's case and the preceding DR2 are cool, but the last case is a worse abomination than anything in AA. The happy ending ruins the franchise.
>>
>>342117964

This guy is pretty much the entirety of what made the second game worth it. The whole game went to shit after he's gone in the last chapter.
>>
>>342118294
Because at a certain point stories are just over and done with? They really can't do much else with Gumshoe except either killing him or marrying to Maggey and living a retired life in Allebahst. Gumshoe is great, but they got pretty much out of him what they wanted, and it's time for new characters to come in.

Which is also why I was slightly miffed with DD pulling the reset button on people like Phoenix, who actually changed a bit, to go back to being trilogy Phoenix. You see the writers talk in interviews about being forced to come up with more and more wacky scenarios where Phoenix can be at a disadvantage somehow because he's such an overwhelming character at this point. Edgeworth is a little more okay because he's more of a cameo.
>>
>>342118172
No man, I finished the first game. Without many issues too, I lost here and there but the logic made sense. That stupid fucking vase though.

The second was just gibberish for me. Nothing really made any sense to me so I just tried stuff at random or read a guide until I finshed the game. Got burned out of the whole series afte this. I heard that the third game is the best, but it follows the logic threads of justice for all and I don't want to go throught that again.
>>
>>342118294
Looking at the amount of Ema/Klavier rapefics I'd say people like them because they can ship them.
>>
>>342118294
>Doesn't understand the meaning of having other characters in the story once their role is over
>"why can't I brofist my bro ;_;"

Oh shit, is memester.
>>
>>342118696
To be fair, the second game is probably the most bullshit, difficulty wise. There's a lot of shit that is just plain unintuitive.

I wouldn't say later games are easier, per se, but they make SENSE.
>>
>>342118575
The appeal of Gumshoe is having a normal guy who could be an actual detective in real life as a likeable sidekick at times and one who always makes you laugh and now has some nostalgic value. Why does he have to be written out just because this has been done before? Ema's role is no less redundant. We've had plenty of generic females in every role now who have a similar personality. She's nothing special. On the other hand, name me heterosexual males who aren't autistic or obviously appealing to fan girls in this series who have a main role.

Gumshoe's role was important for having any sense of reality in this series, may as well have defendants be aliens and ghosts at this point.

>>342118905
Yeah because Ema's such a great character and not there for reasons like >>342118905
>>
File: Maya_and_Phoenix.png (218KB, 960x640px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
Maya_and_Phoenix.png
218KB, 960x640px
Will Phoenix finally marry Maya?
>>
>>342119074
meant to quote>>342118751
>>
>>342118696

My mistake. I can definitely see getting stuck on some of the sillier logic in the first 3 cases of the second game and the filler cases of the third game.

The second game is pretty skippable. The only plot relevance going forward is the second case which is shit, and the last case is pretty irrelevant even if it is one of the best.

If you've played the first game you probably have enough knowledge of the series to try the AAI titles which have a pretty different style for figuring things out. If you're just looking for the cream of the crop and being this picky with the games, try AAI2.
>>
>>342119074
>We've had plenty of generic females in every role now who have a similar personality.

Who?
>>
>>342119134
No. They only Fey Phoenix was interested in was Mia.
>>
>>342119243
well she's unique in AJ but she's shit and barely used, in every other game she's a naive sidekick cameo so that'd be
>maya, athena, pearl, trucy, franziska in AAI, mia in 5-1/4

As a detective we've had 3 and one was Fulbright so it's really 2, but if you're going to promote Ema to that role, why not promote IDK, Larry? It's totally random and unwanted just for the sake of it being more "diverse & different."
>>
>>342119074
He's not written out because he has been done before, but because he was created to interact with Edgeworth, in the same way Maya was created to interact with Phoenix. Characters don't exist in a vacuum.

I'm not really sure what would make Ema unrealistic or redundant, either, as a detective? She seems pretty normal.
>>
>>342119469
none of those characters are remotely similar, especially
>mia
>franziska
>pearl

are you fucking kidding me
>>
>>342119545
>been done before
so they wrote out Phoenix, Edgeworth, Trucy, Apollo, Klavier, Larry? Wait no, they keep bringing them back. Gumshoe's friendship with Edgeworth was developed over many games, he could have some development in another direction, how about not making him a literal hobo in the street? That'd be a nice way to give him any kind of conclusion.

also don't kid about Ema being remotely realistic. There's no detective IRL who resembles that donut.

>>342119618
>ignores the fact I said Franziska in AAI and Mia as a protagonist in T&T

Well if you mash up what I said I can see why it'd confuse you
>>
>>342119816
franziska in AAI and mia in T&T aren't remotely similar to any of those others either, what the hell are you on about
>>
>>342119469
>franziska and mia
>naive
Are you fucking retarded? No, seriously, are you retarded?
>>
>>342119816
There's no lawyer IRL who resembles Phoenix or Edgeworth. What the hell is your point? Ema's personality isn't wacky or out-there, she's pretty down to earth.

>so they wrote out Phoenix, Edgeworth, Trucy, Apollo, Klavier, Larry? Wait no, they keep bringing them back.

Yes, which is also stupid. I completely expect Gumshoe to have a cameo in AA7 too, to appease people who only ever want the old characters to come back again and again.
>>
>>342098529
That case is actually alright.

Case 1 is kinda standard first case tier stuff with some interesting plot details revealed during and after it,
Cases 2, 3 (yes even 3) and 4 (granted it's an extended courtroom sequence instead of a full investigation + courtroom deal for some reason) are fun
Case 5 is your typical big dumb melodramatic finale with obligatory "shocking" plot revelations that'll probably be moot by the next game anyway

AA6 is solid. Personally I can't help but feel sorta tired of the series though. I'm not really getting attached to any of the recurring new characters and I'm sorta indifferent towards the direction taken with the older ones. I think this is more a personal thing than an objective flaw with the games themselves though.
>>
>>342119967
>>342120024

Franziska as a child in that game is a naive sidekick to Edgeworth, Mia is a naive sidekick to hemorrhoids man and Godot. Did you faggots even play the games? Oh let me guess, it's not 100% perfect as an analogy therefore it is wrong and Ema is a super original character and I should not steal her away from AA6.
>>
>>342120116
Edgeworth and Phoenix were realistic in the original trilogy though, and Ema's personality is just boring but absolutely not fitting for a detective, it's more like a college liberal. Makes no sense for her to go from a scientific career into forensics when they aren't even in the same field, but all science is the same I guess.

How is it stupid to bring back all those characters but not stupid to replace Gumshoe with a character who is also being brought back, actually more times than Klavier or Trucy? We've seen her a million times even if they were only cameos.

I also like the AAI2 new characters as an example, it's just that certain characters like Ema and Klavier are shit.
>>
File: miaphoenix.png (46KB, 256x384px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
miaphoenix.png
46KB, 256x384px
>>342120156
Mia is the main character in both those cases, she's not a "sidekick'. And she's pretty fucking snide, see also >>342103610 She's literally never been "naive".

Franziska in AAI acts a lot like Franziska in later games, super aggressive and competitive.

You have no fucking clue what you're talking about.
>>
>>342103306
Best case (and best breakdown) is 1-5

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O3_05OZdFAE
>>
>>342120116

Not that anon but on the whole Gumshoe thing, it's not so much I'm dying for him to come back at this game is flooded with returning characters. Gumshoe is the character who arguably has the most in-universe reason to appear of the old characters, and there's a lot more mixed feelings about some of these other characters if this thread is any indication.

Just glancing at nothing but a character list for this game, there barely seems to be anything but fanservice for people who like all the protagonists. I don't know how much room there is for actual plot with a billion recurring characters who can't be killed and/or be murder suspects.
>>
>>342120501
>Mia is the main character in both those cases, she's not a "sidekick'.
That's like saying Apollo is not a sidekick to Phoenix in AJ-1 when he obviously is, and even in the final case of the game it's kind of true. Especially is obvious with Godot and when these are her first cases, she's clearly being led by her "assistant" like Phoenix guides Apollo, just not as forced.

As for Franziska, she follows around Edgeworth and is very peppy, but still more naive than normal, it's pushing it the most yes, congrats one of the many analogies was slightly wrong. Ema confirmed to not be exclusively made for hentai.
>>
>>342120519

Gant's a great villain but the time it takes to get to him can get fucking painful. How most people feel about the last case of AAI1 is how I feel about 1-5, though at least it's not the villain's fault.
>>
>>342120741
He's not a sidekick to Phoenix in the final case. He's a sidekick to Klavier in the final case, and the two cases before it.
>>
>>342121415
This is true.
>>
File: dqNEME5.png (283KB, 256x1344px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
dqNEME5.png
283KB, 256x1344px
>>342120741
Your analogy isn't just imperfect, it's absolute horseshit. You can't seem to think beyond a very general "oh it's a girl" characterization for any of these characters, not recognizing what makes them unique, somehow amalgamating them all in your mind. You barely remember games you apparently only just played. It's bizarre - and on top of that, a strange dislike of Ema even though she's one of the characters that actually got some sort of arc.

But hey, keep hating Ema. I'm sure they'll bring her back for AA7, too, and you'll fail to recognize her as anything beyond an amorphous female blob too.
>>
>>342122438
Okay so you have no problem with
>maya, athena, pearl, trucy
at all then? just going to throw a tantrum over the fact I said Franziska? The fact is that unless you think Ema is your waifu and fap to her there is no reason I can see why you'd like her.

When I said that those other characters fit the naive sidekick archetype I didn't mean they were bad, and clearly you have a hang-up about loving female characters for being female with your rant in this post. All the characters mentioned are better than Ema imo except for Trucy, who I'd say is about on par.

More than saying how shit Ema is, what's more terrible is she's brought back and promoted so heavily when there's so many better characters they could do this with. Just look at AAI2 for good new female characters who aren't "generic character with tits." The male version of Ema is Victor Kudo with the snackoo eating and throwing. Compare that to Courtney or Kay or PatRol in AAI2, they're obviously shittier and just waifu bait.

Sorry about your shit taste and anger issues tho
>>
>>342122898
>they're obviously shittier and just waifu bait
meant to say Ema is
>>
File: hemorrhoid wizard.png (43KB, 520x378px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
hemorrhoid wizard.png
43KB, 520x378px
Yes, yes, well done Phoenix, well done...
HOWEVER!
>>
File: cinmcnon.gif (814KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
cinmcnon.gif
814KB, 500x500px
3DS emulation when?
>>
>>342098753
Athena has overtaken him in uselessness.
>>
>>342113624
>the mess that is court records
aka "lesbian fan fiction central"

the joke Hotel Dusk page was the best part of the site.
>>
File: 1430342887236.jpg (28KB, 284x215px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1430342887236.jpg
28KB, 284x215px
>>342123098
>>
>>342120501
one thing this case captured perfectly is how much women are bitches to one another.
>>
>>342118283
>>342117460
5-3 case was annoying as fuck, especially the trap.

2-3 tier or irredeemable assholes.
>>
>>342124701
cast*
of*
>>
>>342098529
I just wanted more Playable Athena + aloof mentor Phoenix in the 'assistant' role like near the beginning of 5-3 to be honest, they had a nice dynamic together in that position specifically. Assistant Blackquill sounds like it could be fun though.

I do think that balancing 3 playable characters (or 4 assistant characters if we include Trucy) could work, I just think that they're doing a fucking terrible job at it so far. The player characters don't need big dumb tragic backstories, it's their fucking job to help others with the tragedies they've gotten mixed up in even.
>>
>>342124845
>or 4 assistant characters if we include Trucy
lel she's irrelevant as fuck in this game too.
>>
>>342098529
I'll be honest, Simon smiling as his promotional art is rather heartwarming.
>>
>>342125064
On top of being prominent in the 2nd case she's apparantly with Phoenix during the Apollo vs Phoenix nonsense, so that's something.
>>
>>342103172
He's thinking he got a daughter by association way too fast.
>>
>>342115956
Yes, just be prepared for bullshit ending
>>
>>342103036
Uncle Edgeworth is best
>>
>>342099049
Shit assistant
Decent attorney
prove me wrong
>>
File: cute.jpg (246KB, 897x607px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
cute.jpg
246KB, 897x607px
>>342098529
>>342099049
I liked Athena a lot honestly. She's cute, her backstory was nice, and I legitimately enjoyed the gimmick she brought to the table. I just wish it was more fleshed out.
>>
>>342117460
>Simon says fuck it and takes a walk
Fucking great case.
>>
>>342125905
this doujin is trash. The face doesn't look like Athena at all, more like someone cosplaying her
>>
who is that cute clown girl
>>
>>342118283
What the fuck, is this equation even solvable.
>>
>>342126129
That's even hotter imo.
>>
>>342117357
Having replayed AJ a while back
>When they meet, which does happen a bunch, they have this passive-aggressive relationship that's pretty funny.
She blames Klavier for what happened to Phoenix and finds his demeanour annoying on top of this (like how several other characters in the game do). Klavier acts the same way towards her as he does towards everyone else. That's pretty much all that's there as far as their "relationship" goes.
>>
>>342123270
Nigga just buy a used 2DS, they're cheaper than new games
>>
>>342123270
Nigga just buy a used 2DS, they're cheaper than new games
>>
File: 1466119560822.gif (32KB, 205x39px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1466119560822.gif
32KB, 205x39px
>>342127034
>>342127036
>>
File: CksWTdEUkAITcuc.jpg (52KB, 432x528px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
CksWTdEUkAITcuc.jpg
52KB, 432x528px
>>342123270
>not having a hacked 3DS in 2016+6 months
>>
>>342127408
Fucking hell why do you not put all that shit in folders.
>>
File: latest[1].png (340KB, 306x1001px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
latest[1].png
340KB, 306x1001px
>Could've had a comfy AA thread
>instead we get butthurt anons shitposting about detectives
Instead of talking about Ema Skye, why don't we talk about Ema's thighs?
>>
>>342128743
lewd posting is pleb tier shit for underageb&

Just take it to /aco/
>>
>>342099378
>Expect Maya fanservice
>Instead we get Maya being "away" most of the time and ugly sprites of her bodyframe.
>The crapcom staff thought this would please the Mayafags

I fucking hope they go bankrupt.

>>342101332
>Dissing Maya
Kill yourself senpai
>>
>>342101724
3.3 out of 5 for a hyped game is not really impressive.
Most of the reviews give it 4 stars meaning there is something they didn't like about at all.
>>
>>342129531
Mayafags deserve to suffer for being such obnoxious shits.
>>
>>342129531
Seeing annoying Phoenix/Maya shippers get BTFO is worth it.
>>
>>342100758
>amazon reviews

Monster Hunter has like 2 1/2 stars or something.
>>
>>342117559
>Read: I'm a Mayafag! Yay for having to save my damsel waifu again!
>implying being a Mayafag is wrong
Maya a best. A BEST.
>>
>>342119134
Yes. It is inevitable. If the fujo fanbase were not this big, they would have already got married by the end of 4.
>>342119319
Iris and Dahlia are Feys as well. Not like they are any more relevant to anything though.
>>
>>342131851
I forgot about Iris. Just like Capcom.
>>
>>342104860
6-5's collage reminds me a lot of 5-5's

Can every final case in the series be described by a picture of the prosecutor in the middle with a sad-looking girl to the side?
>>
>>342129723
>>342130243
Kill yourselves, Shithena faggots. Maya deserves better.
>>
>>342132319
This means Edgeworth is the best girl
>>342108224
>>
>>342132549
And this is why Mayafags are obnoxious. Notice you are the only one that mentioned Athena.
>>
File: 1460047724384.jpg (59KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1460047724384.jpg
59KB, 500x500px
>Shittalking about Ema
More proof that she's best detective
I'm glad they chose her over dickshoe lads.
>>
am i the only one that feels they went too over-the-top with apollo's tragic past? he has 3 dead dads.
>>
>>342131192
I think I read somewhere that the reason for this was actually acceptable because they reheated pretty much the same game for a second release in a different title and only released one of those games in the west or something similar.
>>
>>342132769
I actually find it hilarious in a meta sort of way how life shits on him at every instance.
>>
>>342132706
Gumshoe just isn't funny anymore. His character has been squeezed as much as it could and he's honestly not interesting anymore. He was in all 4 main games + the investigations. He had enough screentime already.
Ema is now unjaded in AA6 so it will be interesting to see how she'll act
>>
>>342132675
It is not really hard to deduce to you being Athenafags if you were to read the thread from the beginning.

Anyways Capcom made a big deal of Maya being coming back even though she had such a limited apperance. It was annoying and disappointing. FUCK.
>>
>>342132549
Kek.

I love Maya, I just find the shippers annoying (and there have been tons of them in every thread both on here and in the anime ones on /a/) since Phoenix and Maya's relationship has always been platonic and it's clear the writers will never have the main characters in romantic relationships outside of backstory.
>>
>>342103306
I don't know of its just me.
But during his massive breakdown and rant I keep getting this feeling that the perfect voice for this would be Toshihiko Seki (Rai of Gundam Seed)
>>
>>342101332
>Maya
>Worst
Where do you live
I will fight you
>>
>>342133171
>it's clear the writers will never have the main characters in romantic relationships outside of backstory.
This is really disappointing especially when Maya is 28 and Nick is 35 now.
What is so wrong with wanting to see them get together?
Fans might be annoying but this is not really limited to the Mayafags right? Every fanbase is similar to each other in this aspect.
>>
>>342133728
Of course there are many annoying factions, right in this thread you can also see Gumshoe fans shitting on Ema for instance, or the ever-present Athena haters. There's nothing wrong with wanting to see Phoenix and Maya together, I'd love it myself, but at some point you just have to accept they're not going to do it. I suppose this game was seen as a new chance of sorts since it's Maya's first appearence in a long time (both in-universe and in real life), but since it still didn't happen, I hope more people come to accept it. The real issue is that they decided to keep having Phoenix as a main playable protagonist. Had they phased him out after AA4 like they probably should've done (leaving him in a mentor role to Apollo and Athena like Mia), they could've done more with his character.
>>
File: 1428511604392.jpg (303KB, 1400x988px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1428511604392.jpg
303KB, 1400x988px
>>342133171
DELETE THIS

It's true though
>>
>>342133728
Mayafags are just the most vocal, and as such as the ones who push for shipping the most (outside of fujos/husbandofags of course), as well as the ones who shit on the other girls the most.
>>
>>342132706
>>342133064
Gumshoe isn't the best character, but he's better than the shit tier character of Ema Skye any day.
>>
>>342132319
a 2-4 collage would have phoenix in the middle, that story was about him imo
>>
>this crazy I-hate-Ema-fag is still going

calm your autism, jesus fuck
>>
If it helps you sleep at night Emafag
>>
File: courtrecords.jpg (374KB, 977x1715px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
courtrecords.jpg
374KB, 977x1715px
>>342123783
It used to be pretty good, and this is going to sound hipster, way back when the series wasn't very popular when only the first three games were just out on DS. Close-knit, friendly kind of community mostly discussing the games.

/v/ is now legit the best place to discuss this series, not necessarily because /v/ is always so good (see: the constant hammering on standpoints like in this thread), but because everywhere else is so bad.
>>
>>342135452
I don't give a shit about Ema, it's just that this kind of retarded hate shits up threads. We had some dipshit a while back in here who constantly had to bring up how much he hated Athena, making every thread a dumb shitstorm. Point is made. Give it a rest.
>>
>>342134396
I guess you are right.
Capcom is really so unwilling to do anything regarding Maya/Nick...
I don't know what they will think for the story and characters in AA7 but as long as they keep Phoenix as a playable character, he will remain single, yeah.
Maya will remain single as well even when she is 40 and needs heirs asap because Capcom is scared to take the risk of pissing faction(s) in the fanbase. If they ever decide to a Maya/Nick pairing I guess it would be when they are over 60 and and the current fanbase at the time doesn't give a damn about them anymore thus they have low popularity.
>>
>>342135723
Um, I was at least on topic, you are the one who derailed into whining about the "hate."
>>
>>342135612
Didn't CR do the AAI2 translation though?
>>
>>342134564
>who shit on the other girls the most.
Why would they want to shit on other girls when Maya is the only competitor in the race? The race doesn't seem to holding any meaning for this whole time though.
Who are they shitting on?
>>
>>342136005
They did, with some recruitment on GBATemp and the like.

Look, there's definitely a good few people in there, including some of the admins (the site itself is a good resource too, always has been). But for the most part it's teenagers and shipfags, which makes it kind of like voluntarily going to GameFAQs and trying to have a conversation there.
>>
>>342136292
I was more interested in further stories about how bad it is honestly. I know some guys who did some of the VAing for AAI2, such as Gregory's awful "(h)Old it" that sounds like Hank Hill crossed with an old british codger. Though Blaise's objection is one of the best in the series.
>>
>>342135612
I remember being on court-records when the hilarious Edgeworth "alone time" meme was birthed along with its related greentexts (well, greentext equivalents). How long ago was that?
>>
File: Young_Phoenix_Sad_1.gif (32KB, 256x192px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
Young_Phoenix_Sad_1.gif
32KB, 256x192px
>>342136292
>tfw we'll probably just get a straight translation for DGS instead of an unofficial localization with heart put into it
>>
>>342136541
jesus, forever ago, like actually something like 8+ years ago
>>
>>342103206
What?
>>
File: dgs jury.webm (283KB, 422x252px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
dgs jury.webm
283KB, 422x252px
>>342136684
AAI2's translation is the kind of Mother 3-like exception to normal translations, which is just making stuff understandable.

If anything, though, DGS is probably the best game to have it on. It's more reliant of there being a division between Japan and England, so not localizing the names and such doesn't matter quite as much.
>>
>>342137048
Agreed, you can't go around changing the names of Japanese characters since it's so multi-cultural. As for the text itself, it could definitely benefit from some spicing-up rather than being a straight translation, but beggars can't be choosers (if the fan translation is made at all).
>>
>>342136684
better than nothing
Capcom can eat shit. I'm pirating AA6
>>
Is the anime any good?
>>
>>342138260
Nope.
>>
So do we know why Pheonix is playing prosecutor all of a sudden?
>>
>>342138365
Great
>>
>>342138260
6/10 it's okay.
>>
File: 1400214987080.jpg (176KB, 950x1000px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
1400214987080.jpg
176KB, 950x1000px
So, I want to play AAI 2 but I never finished the first one, is it worth going back and playing or can I fill in the Blanks?

Also I've only played AA 1 and 3
>>
>>342138260
It's acceptable.
>>
>>342138694
If you're too bored of playing every game the series ain't for you.
>>
>>342137469
You absolutely can change the names (except that one of that real life writer) with names that sound Japanese but are puns in English, you just can't make them.. not Japanese

A lot of the English names especially are super awkward and sound bad to native English speakers, so they do deserve a localization
>>
>>
>>342116797
It was. Next episode is filler.
>>
>>342137048
I want to fuck that meido.
>>
File: iris hawthorne.jpg (7KB, 94x158px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
iris hawthorne.jpg
7KB, 94x158px
Just finished the third case in DD.
Blackquill is the most unfunny and boring prosecutor in the series so far.
>>
>>342139527
Okay, I guess you can (aside from Natsume Souseki as you mentoned), but since they'd still have to sound Japanese would there really be a point?

And yeah, I agree that stuff like Jezail and Megundal should be changed, I was only talking about Japanese characters.
>>
>>342140313
Jezail is actually one that shouldn't

Jezail is a reference to the gun (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jezail) Watson got shot by in the Afghan War in the Doyle books
>>
>>342140498
Oh gee, I guess I should've expected stuff like that. Still sounds bad as a person's name.
>>
File: blackquilldesparate.gif (1MB, 334x201px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
blackquilldesparate.gif
1MB, 334x201px
>>342140165
you have bad taste, namefag
>>
>>342140831
Chuckling Taka a cute.
>>
File: theheroweneed.png (872KB, 972x823px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]
theheroweneed.png
872KB, 972x823px
AAI2 > T&T > AAI1 > DD > AA > DGS > JFA > dog shit > AJ
>>
>>342140165
>blackquill
>most unfunny and boring
>implying anyone can be worse than klavier
shit taste confirmed, blackquill is based
>>
>>342101783
Hey it's me ur brother
>>
>>342140165
>Iris has the same hairstyle as Predator
Was this intentional?
Thread replies: 364
Thread images: 91
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y / ] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
If a post contains illegal content, please click on its [Report] button and follow the instructions.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need information for a Poster - you need to contact them.
This website shows only archived content and is not affiliated with 4chan in any way.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoin at 1XVgDnu36zCj97gLdeSwHMdiJaBkqhtMK