>97 metacritic
Is the first Mario Galaxy one of the most overrated games ever? I found it completely mediocre and forgettable from start to finish. My main complaints are the absolutelinearity, lack of exploration, and lack of challenge. Most levels are a series of micro puzzles on floating balls, you move from floating ball to floating ball until you reach the star. Galaxy 2 was a bit better in level design and not as dumb and repetitive, but still was hurt by the lack of exploration and linearity. The first galaxy also annoyed me a bit with the cutscenes it had, the story was complete nonsense anyway, so I'm glad they removed the story altogether from Galaxy 2.
In the end, neither game was as good or as fun as 64 or Sunshine, or even Banjo Kazooie.
What's your opinion on Mario Galaxy?
I liked it.
>>338492105
I also didn't flat out dislike it but it seriously wasn't "3 points short of perfect". It was an ok game, 7/10 being generous.
>linearity and lack of exploration
It's a fucking platformer, it's supposed to be that way.
>>338491960
No, because it's actually good.
Gtav and bioshock infinite are better contenders for most overrated
>i don't like it so its overrated
Thats not how it fucking works.
>I found it completely mediocre
Allright
>and forgettable
Nah m8
Hello hi yes i'm the most overrated game from last gen.
>>338492252
But a 7/10 is also 3 points short of perfect
>>338491960
yes, it's overrated.
sunshine was better
>>338491960
The big levels of N64 platformers are a misstep, they exist only because creating a large amount of unique levels was hard due to technical limitations and unrefined mechanics
>>338492725
>It's a fucking platformer, it's supposed to be that way.
No you dumbfuck, most 3D platformers have exploration.
>>338491960
>In the end, neither game was as good or as fun as 64 or Sunshine, or even Banjo Kazooie.
HOW THE FUCK DOES ANYONE FIND SUNSHINE FUN?
Seriously has anybody actually played it? Too much of it is a chore to play, and its central theme and gimmick aren't particularly great to begin with.
>>338492252
>7/10 being generous.
Jesus christ you are power tripping hard on your own opinion there.
I can't get far into Sunshine without getting bored of the level design.
>>338492970
Hardly anybody talks about this game anymore. If you wanna go overrated last gen, you gotta talk about a Halo or CoD, maybe something like TLoU.
>>338493260
That's adventure/collectathon games you're thinking of retard. Platformers are almost always use linear level design.
>>338491960
collect-a-thons are not platformers
>>338493348
>Popular/most discussed = overrated
>>338492252
>wasn't "3 points short of perfect"
>gives it 3 points short of being perfect (7/10)
How dense are you?
>>338491960
Fucking amazing, just talking about it make me want to play it again.
>>338493290
>too much of a chore
What? FLUDD is one of the most fun things ever.
>shoot a ton of water in front of you with a soft trigger press
>slide into it
>slip 'n' slide wherever you go
>horizontal movement with hover nozzle
>>338493448
>>338493394
>>338491960
Easily the best game of that generation.
SM64 set a standard which was not topped until SMG, which was then topped by SMG2.
Thus it is hard to discuss SMG as some kind of pinnacle of gameplay when it was almost immediately usurped by its successor.
>>338492725
for a platformer it sure lacked platforms
just floating balls and gravity gimmicks out the ass
combined with wiimote shake controls it's easily the weakest 3D mario game
>>338493485
>being this retarded
>>338491960
Lack of exploration is not a problem. The game is designed around the linearity. Sounds more like a personal problem you have with the game.
>>338493458
>lots of discussion = popularity
>popularity = people must think it's good or worthwhile
>people think it's good + a large amount of people + game isn't really that good = overrated
It's okay though, man. Wouldn't expect anybody who uses nigger twitter memes to understand simple concepts.
>>338493630
That's what made it brilliant. Idiot. It redefined platforming.
>>338493348
> Hardly anybody talks about RDR anymore.
Bait
If you prefer your 3D platformers open with exploration that's fine, but the game was designed to be linear, sounds like it comes down to preference for you.
I agree on Galaxy being overrated, but that comes more from a lack of challenge than anything else, which Galaxy 2 stepped up a bit.
>>338493749
except it didn't
>>338493872
You do realize how small of a percentage /v/ is? Even including other video game boards, it's still a small amount of people. Go talk to people who exclusively play AAA stuff and they will most likely not remember it.
>waaah but AAA gamers aren't REAL gamers
They're certainly the majority these days.
>>338493519
It's mainly the vertical platforming uses of it, just felt so slow to use.
>>338491960
ok then
point to a 97 worthy platformer that is not a mario game
>>338491960
Controls were shit especially walking around a planet with holes. The game was pretty much one long tutorial. Galaxy fans are so retarded that they had to release tutorial dvds
Fluid system was a shit gimmick that didn't belong in a mario game
Perfection, in every area, from beginning to end.
>>338493561
>platformer doesn't have any subgenres
It is a platformer but more specifically it's an adventure-based platformer (with a hubworld), as well as a collectathon.
>my main complaints were the absolute linearity
there have been 2 nonlinear games in the entire 30+ year history of mario, you fucking doofus
mario galaxy has great level design. interesting areas, interesting mechanics that slowly layer on top of one another and increase in complexity as the game goes on. almost every stage, something new is introduced, there is barely a dull moment. you say they're not challenging but the later parts of galaxy 2 are far harder than anything 64 or sunshine throw at you - and besides, when has mario been about challenge?
you sound like you want a different game series, OP, and it's not mario's fault that you have shit taste
>>338493687
Explain how 7/10 is not 3 points short of being perfect. I'll wait.
>>338494085
Donkey Kong Country 2 in my book
>>338491960
100% yes
the camera is awful and disorienting on the "planets" and makes me feel disconnected from the character i'm supposed to be controlling.
>>338491960
>foreverially delitized
>>338493749
It redefined "platforming" as "not platforming"
Ingenious
![[Metacritic score] Super Mario Galaxy 2's 97!.jpg](https://i.imgur.com/71Y0EN8.jpg "[Metacritic score] Super Mario Galaxy 2's 97!.jpg")
Super Mario Galaxy 2 was so good that DESPITE being Nintendo, DESPITE being punishing and DESPITE being popular, reviewers STILL had to concede that it was a perfect game and award it 100 points.
>>338494085
psychonauts
>>338491960
This is a game for children, which is why it's held to a lower standard. Grown adults don't still play Mario, do they?
>>338494307
>7/10 being generous
Learn to read
>>338494437
and loving it
oh man
>>338491960
It is way better than Mario 64, m8.
>>338494624
Super Mario Bros 3 is my favorite game
I also think it's not that good
But SMG2 is a masterpiece and the most perfect game I know
>>338494307
If a point is 1/100 then 7/10 + 3 points is 7.3/10 you fucking retard.
>>338494637
So why didn't you say 6/10 instead?
Both Galaxy games are the most overrated games of all time. They are by far the worst 3D Mario games, providing the least movement options. That combined with the floaty nature of the game makes them drags to play.
>>338494624
I think at this point grown adults are the only ones playing Mario games. Kids like violent games.
>>338494814
The scale you provided was out of 10, not out of 100. If you meant to rate it where a point is out of 100 then you should have said 70/100.
Mario Galaxy was pretty fun. I enjoyed it, it was also insanely colorful and had an excellent soundtrack to boot. That's all that really matters. I didn't finish Galaxy 2 though because I got bored...
>>338493917
Galaxy 2 was even easier. I'm not sure what you're getting at here.
>>338494637
You should learn that 7 + 3 = 10
>>338492252
>>338493485
>>338493687
>>338494307
>>338494637
Alright, retards.
The first guy said "3 points short" in reference to 97/100. That is 3 points short on a 100-scale. Now for those of us who passed 3rd grade math, we know that his rating of 7/10 is equivalent to 70/100, which is 30 points short. His math is spot on and it makes sense when you think about the statement.
That being said, the OG "3 points anon" can't write his way out of a cardboard box and yeah, it was a poorly made sentence, but his actual point still stands.
Learn to do math and learn to write better. This is why the Western world is crumbling.
>>338494859
I feel sorry for you if you really think this
>>338493561
>I love super 64 mario!
>>338495018
>Claims "the Western world" is crumbling because people can't make proper sentences.
>Doesn't understand a joke
>>338495018
>The first guy said "3 points short" in reference to 97/100
He didn't though, at no point did he mention he was judging on a 100-point scale. Wait why am I saying "he" when it's pretty clear now that you're him, and you're also the fickle OP.
The greatest misstep of all time. Overrated, completely mediocre and forgettable from start to finish.
Guys, it's obvious he meant 3 points in a 100 point scale, let's not be autistic about it because it's honestly pretty pathetic.
>>338495018
This has got to be bait. Do you think the posts are genuinely serious?
>>338494551
2 wasn't hard at all. Maybe he post game was a bit challenging, but "hard'?
>>338495282
OP, stop being so buttmad about it that you had to backpedal on your dumbass statement :^)
>>338495184
Nope, I am neither 3 point man or the OP. It's even funnier though that once again, there are anons in this thread who jump to conclusions through ridiculous hoops requiring no logical thought, then have the gall to call out other people with zero proof.
>>338495282
>didn't get the jokes and banter
>thinks everyone else is autistic
LMAO
>>338491960
Foreverial delitized Bologna tongue and loving it
>>338495443
>Nope, I am neither 3 point man or the OP.
Prove it ;^)
>>338495309
Yes, I do. 6 years on a board and you kind of get accustomed to the fact that the majority of this board is composed of windowlickers.
And now here's the part where all of the incorrect autists start saying ironic shit like "oh hahaha I was joking" or "you really fell for that?" and if they really aren't trying, you'll see a greentext ">hurr durr I was only pretending to be retarded"
>>338495686
Watch out anons, OP is going full autismo over this one
>>338492725
>What is Super Mario 64?
>>338491960
>I DON'T LIKE STORY THEREFORE IT'S BAD
No, you're just a goddamned tasteless sperg.
>>338495213
>the first sidescrolling platformer as we would come to know them
>the first example of good screen scrolling on console hardware
Stop pretending you know anything about vidya anytime.
>>338495470
>Hey everybody let's pretend to be retarded.
>gets called retarded
>Jokes on you we were just pretending to be retarded
God you're pathetic
>>338495805
Not OP, just tired of seeing faggots shit up this board. I already tried discussing Sunshine up there but it got shit out by arguing over numbers.
>>338495686
How have you been here for 6 years while at the same time being unable to pick up on one of the most "chan-culture" type jokes in quite some time.
>>338491960
t. Sunshinecuck
>>338495029
I wouldn't say most over rated of all time but he's right that the floaty gravity and lack of real momentum to the game makes it a weird and shitty Mario experience.
>>338496084
No it doesn't. Why would it? Do you have mental issues?
>>338495828
>What is Super Mario 64?
An adventure-platformer/collectathon
>>338495906
So are you pretending to be autistic?
You didn't state in your original post that you were talking about the 97/100 metacritic score, nor were you replying to someone talking about it. So it's not that big a stretch for some to question that, jokingly or not. Instead of hikdingr up your hands at the mistake and explaining from the get-go, you made it worse and fed right into them with stupid rant-posts exposing your autism.
>>338495930
>waah why don't people have the same views as me
I'm not even joking, this is one of the common traits of autism.
>>338495906
My wifes' son who's 8 years old could've picked up on the fact that it was a joke
>>338491960
Nintendo games are (or should I say 'used to be') vastly overrated.
>>338496367
Is pretending to be retarded a joke?
You got some low tier bants there.
>>338496347
Anon if you can't correlate numbers, something a child can do, you are literally retarded.
>>338496603
nobody was being retarded, nor pretending to be so
>>338496717
You can't when there's no context in his post
>>338495686
>I-I've been here since 2010 guys
Come on man, people made a joke and you spurged out and wrong five paragraphs and talked about "this is why the western world is crumbling". Sad part is I can't even tell if this is bait.
I don't think the challenge of the game, or lack thereof, factors into critical reviews as much as you think.
And even if it did lean on the easier side, so what? I still think it was worth the money/time put into it.
I love threads where 1 autists fucks up, exposes his density, and then argues with the entire rest of the thread on their own.
>overrated equals bad
I seriously hate Egoraptor for starting this meme
>>338496942
It has to be genuine, nobody would go this far to make anons laugh at them
>>338496156
Were you literally 7 years old when Galaxy game out? Do you know anything about how Mario levels are (usually) designed? For the most part, you are encouraged to run full speed ahead and use your acrobatic moves to beat the level. Mario is known for his running speed as well as his jumping prowess. For a really long time it was hotly debated on whether Mario or Sonic ran faster, which is why they appear in those Olympic games together.
Galaxy having the levels separated by planetoids with floaty gravity goes completely against this principle. You run fast then jump, great! But now you orbit around the little ball you're on. And you have to stay there until you solve the puzzle or kill the enemies. Where the fuck is the fast?
>>338495686
>100 - 3 = 97
>10 - 3 = 7
Who's the real retard here?
>>338494041
>they will most likely not remember it
>most requested backwards compatible game on xbone
Alright
>>338497015
I just don't see how you can be so angry about a pleasant, fun game like SMG.
>AAAAHHH FUCK SHIT LONGJUMPING OVER THIS GAP IS MAKING ME SO FUCKING MAD
>>338496907
Alright I'm starting to think you might actually be retarded
He lists 97/100 in the OP then gives it a 7/10.
If you think 3 points is equal on those scales...
>>338497189
[autism intensifies]
Everything will be okay, OP, just take your meds.
>>338491960
Sunshine > 64 >>>>>>>>>> Everything else
>>338497260
Ya know how autism is a common go-to insult?
Well I wasn't using it as one, I actually do think OP has autism
>>338497189
People who were 7 when Galaxy came out will be legal to post here in 2 years.
>>338497097
>overrated equals bad
Link 10 posts in this threads that say that.
>>338497269
>He lists 97/100 in the OP then gives it a 7/10.
>He
You mean (You)
Also, the 7/10 post was not a reply to the OP, and had no context of its own beyond the thread itself. Which, as I said earlier, is why anons (mostly jokingly) replied as they did. You see unusually riled up about that. Take a break from /v/
>>338497189
>For a really long time it was hotly debated on whether Mario or Sonic ran faster, which is why they appear in those Olympic games together
What the fuck is this?
>>338493593
SMG is better than SMG2 in literally every way except the reward for getting all the stars though.
>>338497630
Either a hilarious master ruseman at play, or one of the biggest autists of /v/
>>338497189
>Mario
>Fast
Anon...
>>338497653
Except gameplay and level design
>>338491960
I thought it was really boring
>>338491960
Sounds like you have absolutely no understanding of what makes a good game.
Discarded. Next.
>>338497653
The action is too far spread apart. Lots of standing on moving platforms or just crossing empty areas without meaningful obstacles.
SMG2 is pure action from the moment you set foot on a planetoid.
>>338491960
better than any mario game that came after it that's for sure.
>>338495184
then why did i immediately realize upon reading his post that he was referring to the 100-point scale.
am i a genius or are you retarded?
>>338497576
>He doesn't know how to check for
samefag.
Arguing with retards is a futile endeavor. Here's your final (You)
>>338498230
>am i a genius or are you retarded?
Neither, you are the same anon as 7/10 anon
I completely agree with you. The game wasn't challenging and exploration did not exist as it does in 64 and Sunshine.
Also Mario feels significantly slower/floaty in the Galaxy games than 64 and Sunshine, which fits the setting but doesn't make for great gameplay.
>>338498296
I know a samefag when I see one
The first galaxy also had serious camera problems due to the poorly designed levels.
>>338498308
why claim this if you have no way to prove it and no evidence to support it
>>338498478
Why deny it if you have no proof to support it
>>338496347
>platformer
Throw in all the sub-shit you want to help you sleep at night, it's still a platformer, and to this day still one of the best ones BECAUSE it went sandbox format instead of railroading you.
Neither SMG1 nor SMG2 had to railroad the player to do what it wanted, Nintendo just chose to make it that way because they thought the players were too stupid, I guess. Even though SM64 already proved that wrong.
>>338498547
>and to this day still one of the best ones BECAUSE it went sandbox format instead of railroading you.
I don't fully agree with this, but I respect your opinion. To me, platformers at their core are about jumping from A to B in a generally linear environment, but if you prefer open-environment platformers that's fine - it doesn't mean everyone has to agree with you and that what you didn't like so much is overrated.
>>338498537
there's no reasonable way for anyone to prove they're not samefagging, though there's no reasonable way for you to prove someone is samefagging.
but nevermind i can see you're epic trolling me.
>>338498813
but linearity would only be better if the platforming itself was better and it's hard to argue that for the galaxy games because mario floats and moves like shit.
>>338491960
Well it looks like you got yourself shit taste. There's really not much you can do but keep on having shit taste until it might develop into something better.
>>338497259
>most requested backwards compatible game on xbone
it isnt, cod and skyrim are
RDR is still a masterpiece tho
>>338498841
A screencap can help a lot. It's not exact proof but most regard it as close-enough, especially if the cap is provided quickly.
Nonetheless, the opinions and speech/typing of posts makes it fairly easy to tell it's likely the same anon speaking.
>>338498950
In your opinion, most would disagree with you and there's nothing wrong about that.
>>338498547
This is actually the opposite of a good opinion. In fact, the only levels in SM64 and Sunshine that are still fun to replay are the Bowser levels and Fluddless levels that focus entirely on linear platforming, while the rest of the game is a slog to play through again after you already know the layout and the novelty of the "sandbox exploration" is gone because you aren't a kid playing it for the first time anymore.
>>338491960
You're absolutely correct, but the nintenyearolds on this board will try to beat you sown with the same old arguments of "It's ok when Nintendo does it. " and "Having no difficulty doesn't make it a walking simulator."
Unfortunately for these posters the only shred of dignity that they have left is clinging to the well being of a childrens toy company.
>>338491960
Galaxy is way way more fun than Banjo Kazooie. It doesn't follow the Golden Standard of Non-Linearity, but the levels are a lot more involved and interesting.
>>338491960
>2007 was 9 years ago
>its been almost a decade since nintendo has made a high quality, original game
Fuck my ass, I remember playing this game on a CRT
>>338499329
Nice shitpost attempt, OP! ;^)
>>338499201
>A screencap can help a lot.
he could claim i'm forging it.
>>338499539
>its been almost a decade since nintendo has made a high quality, original game
So I guess Splatoon, 3D World, and DKTF don't count?
>>338491960
>I found it completely mediocre and forgettable from start to finish.
Nice shit taste you have there. Develop some critical thinking, and work on your retarded hyperbolic words and maybe next time we can talk about why your prefer for open world games doesn't make the amazing game that is Galaxy "completely mediocre and forgettable"
>>338499201
>most would disagree with you
most people are normies who can't even remember the difference in movement between 64 mario and galaxy mario.
>>338499671
no.
>>338491960
I remember being crazy hyped for it and then after being so disappointed that I replayed sunshine, which before galaxy I didn't really think it was that good, but I ended up enjoying it way more.
I was dumbfounded when later I saw Galaxy getting game of the year awards left and right and it was around then that I just started to ignore review scores.
>>338499597
It really doesn't help your case when it's already edited just to crop/stitch images that didn't need to be cropped in the first place.
>>338491960
I agree with everything you said. You rock OP
>>338499889 (OP)
>>338499859
it doesn't help when i edit an image that HAS to be edited in order to fit the OP and the alleged samefag posts?
dumbass.
>>338500003
Ya could just have replied to each of those posts then capped it
>>338500239
but those could be edited too? what are you getting at here?
>metacritic
>>338499317
Says you - that is all completely your opinion. The fun, the things you like and don't like.
All I know is, SM64 has relatively quick-to-get Stars instead of SMG's railroaded slogging, and that combined with finding new ways to the destination are why SM64 still gets love.
>>338497848
ITT: underage and B& get their feelings hurt ppl dont share the same childhood game as them
>>338492784
>>338492784
This. SMG might be overrated but how could you possibly say its the most overrated game when Infinite exists?
>>338492725
That's not what you fucks say when it comes to 3D World.
>>338500313
They could be but it'd be harder to make a convincing edit if they're all in one place like that in an image that has not been modified via crops.
>>338495890
>What is Pac-land
Super Mario Bros was fucking shit get over it.
>>338500772
What the fuck yes it is. 3D World is the absolute best for linear levels, easily trumps SMG2's similar level design style.
>>338500865
they wouldn't all be in one place though if i retroactively decide to respond to the OP?
>>338500969
What are you talking about
>>338497429
People who were 9 when the original Modern Warfare came out will be old enough to post this year.
>>338501059
there is the OP. then 100 posts down, there are my posts. then another 50 posts down i could respond to the OP.
where can anything be in one place?
>>338500948
Pac-Land wasn't on a console and wasn't a platformer in the sense of SMB, it was an auto scroller.
>>338501212
I said already you dolt just reply to them all and cap it
>>338491960
Yes. The only thing it did better than SM64 and SMS was the soundtrack.
The gameplay was shallow and simple compared to both predecessors, and especially compared to SM64.
The environments were linear and forgettable after the god-tier world design in SMS.
The visuals were alright but they weren't fully realized due to the Wii's graphical restrictions.
>>338499741
Great argument you got there
>>338501307
which can easily be forged using a webpage editor/developer tools.
that would be even more flimsy evidence than the cropped image i posted.
are you being serious man
I found Galaxy 2 better in every way. The game was a fucking fun experiencie and the best 3d Plataformer in the past and actual gen.
>>338501370
nailed it
>>338501478
Do I have to spell it out?
>reply to each of those posts
>post it
>cap it
>post cap IMMEDIATELY after
That is the definitive classic way to prove you're not samefagging in any situation. Is it foolproof? No, quick anons may be able to edit out the (You)s, but you'd have to be really fucking quick to pull that off.
>>338501370
>god-tier world design in SMS.
LMAO
>>338491960
>97 metacritic
Should have been 100.
Also, I don't understand people calling this game easy. It has a fair challenge, like all other Mario games.
>>338501765
>Is it foolproof? No
exactly.
>>338501868
What a compelling argument! I am now completely convinced that my statement was in poor judgement!
>>338501887
It's usually because they played SM64/Sunshine as a kid, so when they play SMG as an adult they feel it's too easy - failing to realise SM64 and to a slightly lesser extent Sunshine are also easy.
>>338501954
Oh so I guess you really were samefagging then. I got to admit you almost had me in doubt.
>>338502121
i replayed sm64 and galaxy 1 recently and galaxy is WAY easier than sm64.
>>338502068
>I'M A CHUCKSTER
>>338502068
I had as much substance as your "arguments" did. Saying something is bad, no matter how you word it, tells nothing about the game. Better criticisms would reference some specific levels or mechanics. I can't be bothered going into that detail over Sunshine since I don't really care for posting hit opinions, but since you care enough when it comes to SMG I'd be happy to see what specifically you didn't like in SMG? Or is it really just the fact it's a mostly linear format?
>>338502235
In your opinion, I don't see much a difference between SM64 and SMG persoballyy, both are incredibly easy. Sunshine has a fee tricky areas, but not necessarily in the good way.
>>338502360
I don't get how one silly aspect of the game that's only used in like 2 stages completely invalidates the fact that the world design (not the level design, necessarily) is extremely creative and coherent.
>>338502445
>In your opinion
it would be in most people's opinions. galaxy pretty much holds your hand. there are way fewer hazards.
>>338502462
>PACHINKO LEVEL
>>338502540
>it would be in most people's opinions
Really? As most if not all in this thread that don't like SMG seem to be you.
>>338502593
That's not even as bad as the toxic lilypad area, and both of them are optional challenge stages not required to beat the game.
>>338502642
what does liking SMG have to do with my point you illiterate moron?
2d mario >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 3d mario
>>338502681
>MANEUVERING YOUR BOAT IN CORONA MOUNTAIN
>>338502753
Because the ease of the game (despite SM64 being arguably just as easy) makes it unlikeable for you, when most wouldn't give a shit.
>>338502863
>makes it unlikeable for you
i didn't say that you illiterate moron? difficulty is one factor among many that contribute to my overall dislike of galaxy. difficulty alone wouldn't make or break the game.
>>338492784
GTAV gets more hate here than it deserves, it's a very impressive game in scale and detail. If were talking overrated games it's undertale and borderlands.
>>338495309
Is this loss?
>>338503002
>difficulty alone wouldn't make or break the game.
I didn't say that either you illiterate moron, I only said that others wouldn't regard it as a negative given it's a trait of almost all of 3D Mario games. Seriously why are you so desprate to shitpost, OP?
>>338503142
>Because the ease of the game makes it unlikeable for you
you JUST said that the ease of the game makes me not like it.
c'mon man, try to keep up.
>why are you so desprate to shitpost, OP?
what's up with the samefag accusations in this thread? if i were OP how would that change anything?
>its a psuedo intellectual wannabe game reviewer thread
>>338503106
>it's a very impressive game in scale and detail
so, impressive in ways that have nothing to do with games
>it's an "assburgers pretend sm64 was hard or fast because they saw some webms of speedruns on vee" thread
>>338503265
>you JUST said that the ease of the game makes me not like it.
Yes, which is not the same as me saying that's the sole reason you dislike it. I never said that since you've already repeated multiple times in this thread the vague reasons on why you apparently don't like the game.
>if i were OP how would that change anything?
You are the OP, it's blatantly obvious to everyone in the thread. What's bad about this though is you keep posting inane opinions whilst expecting people to agree with each and every hot opinion you throw in the thread. I know /v/ has a reputation for hating vidya but this really isn't what people generally do even in the worst threads. Spend some time lurking then come back after a month or two.
>>338493561
By this logic Super Paper Mario is an RPG because that's what genre it falls under.
>>338493348
The Last of Us is underrated though.
It's even better than most people think.
>>338503591
>You are the OP
i'm not, but if i were how would that change anything? what is the point of this narrative?
>which is not the same as me saying that's the sole reason you dislike it
saying someone dislikes something because of X means that X is why they dislike it. just what the fuck are you talking about.
>What's bad about this though is you keep posting inane opinions whilst expecting people to agree with each and every hot opinion you throw in the thread
what makes you think i expect everyone to agree? this is /v/ and the galaxy games are well-liked here. i'm posting my opinions knowing most are going to disagree.
i don't get it. again what's the point of this narrative?
>>338493139
underrated
>>338491960
>Mario Galaxy
>forgettable
I can believe that you didn't like it, but you don't know what forgettable means
>>338503883
>saying someone dislikes something because of X means that X is why they dislike it. just what the fuck are you talking about.
I honestly can't explain it any clearer than I already did so I don't know what else to say now.
>i don't get it. again what's the point of this narrative?
What's the point of your posting your hot opinions if you're aware most may not agree? You also don't seem to be actually discussing anyhing at all - you're only posting hot opinions and occasional defenses for your hot opinions whenever they're questioned/criticized. I don't get it.
I wish Nintendo would quit the home console market and instead release its IP on multiple platforms.
Imagine a Super Mario Galaxy HD 60fps remake for the PS4 minus the gimmick waggle controls.
I'd pay full price for that. I love Nintendo games, but cannot justify buying another dead Nintendo console just to play the 3 great Nintendo games on the system.
How much custom do you think Nintendo are losing out on by not going multiplatform?
Just think about it.
Wii U has sold ~12 million
Xbone has sold ~20 million
PS4 has sold ~40 million
That's 60 million potential customers than Nintendo are missing out on. When will they see the light, /v/?
Mario Galaxy is an extremely limited 3D Mario game, and one of the most overrated games ever. 6/10 for good graphics.
>>338503846
It was game of the generation man. I only place Ocarina of Time above it on my all time list.
>>338491960
It's the only Mario game I fell asleep while playing, so take that as you will.
>>338504220
>Imagine a Super Mario Galaxy HD 60fps remake for the PS4 minus the gimmick waggle controls.
What the fuck why would anyone want literal rehash remasters. I know that's the PS4 specialty but fuck off.
>>338491960
My favorite part of the 3d marios has always been the overworld
that dumbass spaceship and even dumber spaceship in 2 are really a far cry from the GOOD OL DAYS
Super Mario Galaxy was the first Mario platformer that I just quit out of sheer boredom. Linear, gimmick based platforming is just so dull compared to the exploration element of SM64 and Sunshine.
>>338504213
>I honestly can't explain it any clearer than I already did so I don't know what else to say now.
kinda how i felt in response to whatever it is you tried to say.
>What's the point of your posting your hot opinions if you're aware most may not agree?
isn't that the point of a forum? sharing ideas? i mean if i say "galaxy is easier" and someone disagrees with me, not much can be said there (although i don't think that person has played both games recently and/or is being honest). however if someone were to argue that the galaxy games are easy but still have other strengths then i'd be open to that.
>>338504220
nintendo doesnt care about that
they're moving on to mobile games, toys and amusement parks
>>338504379
Weak b8
I r8 it 7/10...3 points away from that perfection anon.
>>338504493
>isn't that the point of a forum? sharing ideas?
I'd argue they're more for discussion not for just sharing your opinions on something just because you want to see others challenge it. As let's face it, if most agreed this thread would've died quickly. You know you made the thread with the sole purpose of being controversial so that others would reply to it to challenge your views. There's a word for that...hmm...oh yeah, shitposting.
>>338503363
It's a good game in every way, don't be retarded. Although you're most likely a pcfag so calling out undermeme is a no no, right? Literally the most overrated game in the last decade and you pick gtav which is a great game, kill yourself you have garbage taste.
>>338504421
They'd make new games too.
>What the fuck why would anyone want literal rehash remasters
Protip: Not everyone owned a Wii and played SMG
>>338504841
>Protip: Not everyone owned a Wii and played SMG
Nigga they're cheap as fuck, plus almost any PC can emulate SMG easily, there is no reason to want a remaster unless you're a salty Sonygger so desparate for games you'd play remastered fucking mario rehashes.
>It's a stealth anti-Nintendo thread episode
>>338504754
>You know you made the thread with the sole purpose of being controversial
i didn't make the thread but there's nothing wrong with fostering discussion by challenging people.
>>338505095
>stealth
It was obvious from the start
I'm only staying to see how that 1 anon keeps shitposting all on his own about SMG
>>338505095
>SU image
Have a (You)
>>338505095
Why don't you try reading the thread you dumb phoneposter.
>>338504482
>Super Mario Galaxy
>Linear
I don't get this criticism. All Mario games are somewhat linear, while still giving you the option to tackle levels within a galaxy randomly.
Only the galaxies could be described as linear, as they required a certain number of stars before opening up.
>>338504482
I forced myself to get all the stars (extremely easy) but I didn't bothing playing Galaxy 2 as I'd had enough.
>>338505136
>i didn't make the thread
Sure thing bucko, either way what I said still stands - you're literally posting just to stur shit. Shitposting.
>>338504519
>has a different opinion
>must be b8
>>338505328
literally posting just to get people to discuss things. shitposting.
>>338505428
>posting intentionally controversial hot opinions and shitting on anyone that disagrees is a "discussion"
/v/ logic, I guess.
>>338505037
I own a Wii and both Super Mario Galaxies.
I'd buy them a second time in a remastered HD collection on PS4.
I'd argue a lot of other people would also buy Nintendo games if they were released on other platforms.
I'm not sure why you're getting so mad. Have you taken your medication today?
>>338504220
5x the customer base at half the profits and with a shit load of restrictions.
>>338505535
>>338505545
"shitting on". what?
>>338505328
>bucko
>>338505551
I'm not mad, I just think you have shitty taste. Something like Splatoon would make far more sense as a multiplat recommendation, not SMG which would barely benefit from a remaster not multiplat release. Git gud tastes lad.
>>338491960
It was ok, but the reliance on the Wiimote was annoying. I don't want to use the Wiimote, gamepad, or any gimmick device in any which way you try to shoehorn it in.
>>338495018
Why would 7/10 translate to 70/100 just because the OP used the 100 point scale? Why wouldn't he just say 70/100 instead of 7/10 if he is referring to the same scale instead of being stupid? No professor would ever give anyone a 7 on an exam and expect people to think it's a 70. It's fucking retarded and so are you.
>>338491960
Either a bait or a shitty taste for gaming.
Go back to your manly FPS
>>338505689
>I just think you have shitty taste.
Am I supposed to care about your opinion or something?
My argument is simple:
I believe Nintendo would benefit financially from exiting the console market (not handheld) and releasing their IP on other platfroms.
My taste in games is irrelevant to my original post.
>>338505281
Ehhh it's not about linearity in the traditional sense, just very lazy level design. Galaxy has 0 atmosphere, just giant floating platforms with a single gimmick each.
>>338505631
Anyone that likes SMG tbqh, like in many earlier posts in the thread such as >>338498547
Don't even act like that post wasn't yours.
>>338505670
Neat I found someone's trigger word
>>338505698
>7/10 does not equal 70/100
Holy shit we've gone beyond shitposting
>>338505694
This. I think that SMG was fantastic, but it would have played much better on a standard controller withoug the wavy wavy waggle faggotry.
>>338491960
All Nintendo games that aren't Metroid are overrated as fuck.
>>338505932
ok i won't
>>338505908
>just very lazy level design.
>Super Mario Galaxy
Ah come on, m8. That's one of the areas where SMG excels and SMG2 is even better again in its level design. You can't be serious.
>>338506146
Going from a to b isn't good level design
>>338505980
It doesn't if we're talking about "three points away from perfect", dumbfuck.
>>338506146
Instead of even finding ways to tie their gimmicks together they just go with warping from gimmick to gimmick. It's the laziest level design I've ever seen in a high budget game, and it applies to both galaxy games.
>>338505908
What is "atmosphere" in a mario game?
>>338505980
In this context it actually doesn't, I don't even need to explain why as anons have already discussed it earlier in the thread. TL;DR the 7/10 anon was retarded to not have instead put 70/100 in the first place, but they've been shitposting all along so who cares?
>>338505887
>I believe Nintendo would benefit financially from exiting the console market
I doubt this given they'd have to compete with games on multiple systes as opposed to selling games on their own systems. Which, despite poor system sales, has still been working well (with Wii U titles selling very well). But I wouldn't care much either way honestly, you just could've picked a better example than a fucking redundant SMG remaster as your example.
>>338506064
Good. You've learnt since last time.
>>338505980
When we are talking about people rating games and using those scales, it really doesn't. Why would there be a 10 point scale and a 100 point scale? People use both in different ways to translate different meanings of a game's quality. This isn't strict math we are talking about here you fucking retard, we are talking about arbitrary point systems to equate a game's quality. They aren't the same.
>>338506318
>Going from a to b isn't good level design
I do believe you are just shitposting at this point.
It's how you get from a (start of level) to b (star end of level) which determines the quality of the level design.
>>338506518
>I do believe you are just shitposting at this point.
Lol I've been shitposting all this time. So many (You)s like holy shit /v/ is stupid
>>338506515
i think it's funny that people here pretend they're good at recognizing samefags. nobody can take the claim of samefagging seriously any more.
>>338495310
You ever complete the perfect run in that game? That is HARD. And rewarding, and challenging, and fair. Great game.
>>338494916
Obviously points would be relative to the denominator, just stop
>>338506703
also the screenshots i posted could easily be forged. they're not good evidence.
