Let's get another one of these threads going.
Scoring them is optional as well.
I didn't save the original template as well so if someone has it please feel free to post it.
...1...................3..................5..
............2...............................
............................................
..................................4.........
>>333517292
>SH1 better than 2
>>333517728
Sonic Adventure 1&2 should be higher and Shadow should be on Par with 2006, other than that I agree wholeheartedly
>>333517728
Adventures should be around Colours level and Shadow should be alongside Heroes. Good to see Generations get some recognition though.
>>333517653
mgs?
>>333517292
>SH4 better than SH3
>>333517728
>Sonic Boom higher than 06
They're both awful broken games but at least 06 had a good soundtrack.
>>333517653
Resident Evil 4 needs to be higher and RE5 needs to be lower. Everything else is fine.
>>333518673
lucky guess
>>333517728
You're missing the Ngage game from that list, its really good for a sonic game.
>>333518862
i stand by my statement
>>333517728
>Still perpetuating this meme that SA2 is bad
I bet you thought Batman v. Superman was a good movie too.
Got some shit for this, but I still hold that Underground has better level design than 4 and Underground 2 which is why it's higher.
Can someone post template
>>333519095
Is 5 fixed yet
>>333519095
>THPS3 At second best
>below THUGGood choice
>>333519246
THPS5 can't be fixed.
Even if they sorted out the bugs - which they presumably haven't - it's still a terribly designed game which ruins several standard features of the series.
It's best to forget 5 exists.
>>333519207
>the next Uncharted
every time
>>333519095
I agree with this completely, shit you can put American Wasteland down a few more notches and I'll still be happy. Underground and 3 are the best THPS games ever.
>>333519245
>>333519245
Sorry it took so long, had to edit out all this shit
>>333518826
Biggest gripe I had with SH3 was that it was way to short, and the amount of endings it had.
2 real endings and 1 UFO ending, and even then one of the real endings I guarantee no one got there first time, you had to be DSP levels of awful to get the Possessed ending.
It's a great game don't get me wrong, it did the SH formula perfect, I was just disappointed with it's replay value.
>>333517728
SA2>>>>>>>SA1 you faggot
>>333517292
SH - 7.5/10
SH2 - 9.5/10
SH3 - 9/10
SH4 - 7/10
Origins - 6.5/10
Homecoming - 6.5/10
Shattered Memories - 8.5/10
Downpour - 6/10
Book of Memories - 4/10
Played them all on release.
>>333522806
Adventure 2 was a good game but 1 was better. Much better designed action stages with actual platforming. Adventure 2 started the "must go fast all the time" mentality that plagues Sonic gameplay nowadays.
>>333522037
1 should be the highest but otherwise I agree.
>>333523912
>I started with MGS2: the post
MGS1 > MGS3 > MGSV > MGS2 > MG2 > MGS4 > MG1 > PW
>>333521324
I love how BC2 kids are delusional
>>333517292
posting the one i made last time
>>333524150
This guy gets it right
Being a resident evil fan was a mistake
>>333525241
This looks about right. I wouldn't have 6 quite that low and Survivor and Dead Aim are way too high but otherwise it's perfect. No Revelations 2 though.
>>333525472
Eh. for a kid who also grew up loving lightgun games and also resident evil, I got a real kick out of the novelty of it.
And I haven't played revelations 2. I've kinda lost all love for the series after 5.
Man you guys have some shitty opinions.
Silent Hill Homecoming is not that bad.
>>333525650
Yeah I'm not a big fan of light gun games so that's why I didn't like them. To each his own I I guess. Revelations 2 is solid but continues the mostly action in favor of actual scares.
>>333525787
I gave it a 6.5 though. I'm using 5 as average, not the IGN "7 = it's shit" scale.
>>333526030
Guy in the OP gave it a 1.
>>333519095
You're missing American Sk8land for the DS. I'd wholeheartedly recommend it as it's up there with the classics.
>>333526297
You're right, it's easily a solid 2.
>>333519207
Fucking kek
>>333526297
Guy in the OP is a retard that likes the least scary game in a horror series the most.
fuck you, I liked homecoming.
Bosses were great, true SH atmosphere.
>>333523912
MGS2>MGS1>PW>MGS4>MGSV>MGS3
Fatal Frame - 8/10
Fatal Frame 2 - 8.5/10
Fatal Frame 3 - 8.5/10
Fatal Frame 4 - 6.5/10
Fatal Frame V - 8/10
Spirit Camera - 5/10
>>333526759
Wew I'm not a fan of anything after 4 but those are some opinions.
>>333526903
>Likes 2 the most
>Dislikes the game that's basically just sucking 2's dick the entire time the most
I'm confused.
>>333524150
muh nigga
MGS1 will always be number 1 in my heart
>>333527270
How is sucking another games dick good? 9 was obnoxious. It was a huge step back in the series.
The worst level design, meme difficulty, ear grating music.
Its okay for 2 to be somewhat primitive and simplistic since its the second in the series, but 9 honestly feels like a fan game.
>>333521324
>bad company is worse than 4
???
