>Some people genuinely don't want a successor to pic related
Are people really that afraid of AAA games nowadays ?
It doesn't need one; it's already complete.
It'd be like giving Cowboy Bebop a sequel.
I don't like regenerating health.
It wasn't a very good game to begin with.
So what timeframe can they set the next Red Dead game without feeling like they're taking a step back? Because 1914 is about as late in the "Wild West" period as you can get. They can't make it any later than that and any earlier and you have to make due with less weapons.
it would take AGES for Rockstar to churn out another RDR
>>333028017
It's just, where the fuck would the story even go? It was completely wrapped up at the end. There is no reason to continue it whatsoever.
Sometimes you just need to leave things alone.
>>333028485
SPACE WESTERN
>>333028017
they want it. its the PC faggots who are afraid of the NEVER EVER happening again. I'm hoping it happens just so they can stop fucking shitposting.
>>333028594
There's always room for another story. The setting covers a pretty broad period of time and place. Red Dead Revolver has no relation to the events in Redemption other than fan speculation. What would stop another game being in a completely different region of the US?
>>333028523
The next one will most likely come out next year Anon
Its rockstars next big thing
They should go in the opposite direction of the timescale of the mythical oldwest this time.
>People dying on the oregon trail
>Goldrush miners getting the shit scammed out of them
>Chinese immigrants building railroads
>Trail of Tears
>Mormons
>Abolition vs. Slaver tension playing out in Bleeding Kansas
I'd play the shit out of Red Dead Frontier
>>333028464
NEVER EVER
Isn't Red Dead set at the start of the 20th century? So what would the next game be exactly?
There isn't much they can do with the setting besides maybe something that happened at the same time or before, a game set after it wouldn't really be Western anymore, it would just be Mafia.
>>333028354
Uhh... there are rumors about that, and FLCL is already confirmed getting a sequel.
>>333028464
Delete this.
>>333028848
I enjoyed the game on 360 but i'd just rather have a game that didn't drop to 10fps every time it rains. It's a good game but my god does it run like ass at times.
>Game set as Landon Rickets bastard son.
Trying to track down your old man. Retracing his steps as a gun slinger. Run into a few characters from RDR. Game ends with you getting into a duel with Landon himself.
>i.....I'm proud of you,...b-boy...
>>333029140
>mission where you help Joseph Smith and unknowingly help found Mormonism
Holy shit, someone needs to make this
>>333029314
hello darkness my old friend
Landon Ricketts is dead anon, he dies in his sleep some time before the last mission
>>333029278
Just go back to the time of Red Dead Revolver. Or, make it about the time John was running with Dutch's Gang.
Or you know, just make another set in another time .. doesn't have to be a direct sequel, and doesn't have to take place after 1914.
>>333029968
Meant for >>333029812
>>333029968
>while healing from a gun wound.
Newspapers weren't reliable back then.
>>333028017
Rockstar is ded anon they only care about cashing in on shitty GTA online
>>333030109
>passed away quitely in his sleep
Yeah, you don't go quitely from a gunshot wound, especially in the early 1910s.
>>333028017
We want a prequel set in about 1875. You are a ranch hand that runs with a gang to get revenge on those that murdered your boss.
I speak for everybody when I say we need this.
THEN WHO WAS STRANGER?
>>333030325
What part of "newspapers weren't reliable" didn't you understand?
>>333030325
>quitely
quietly, knew i spelled it wrong and clicked Post anyway.
In truth i want Rockstar to make GTA VI first so that we get RDR 2 with fully fleshed out current-gen tech, akin to the difference between Gears of War 1 and The Last of Us. It would be a shame to waste a RDR now, when devs haven't even nearly scratched at the possibilities with the new hardware
>>333030441
Do you actually believe Rockstar have that much foresight? It's not happening.
>>333030353
So you want >Red Dead Revenge
>>333030581
subtle
>>333030581
Rockstar games are never the best looking of their gen, hell look at San Andreas. Look at GTA:V, it was obviously going to be an 8th gen game but they downgraded significantly so that they could get on that massive 7th gen install base.
>>333030581
This sounds stupid
RDR is a game set in wild west therefore doesnt need much new hardware to look great
Hell i think the next RDR game will look better than most games now
GTAVI on the other hand needs all the knowledge of this gen to be better looking than V
>>333029314
>>333028464
This to be honest. It has great ideas and they really did wonder with the setting but it was buggy as hell, gameplay/controls were shit, sidequests were awful... 6.5/10 at best.
Unless they fix EVERY problem the original has, they shouldn't even bother.
>>333032937
>gameplay/controls were shit
End yourself
>>333033060
If you don't think they were then YOU should end yourself and all of your retarded siblings.
>some people didn't die of boredom when watching RDR
Next game needs to be named 'The Red, The Dead and The Revolting'
>>333033060
The controls were pretty bad and the horse was fucking retarded. You'd call it and it'd start running towrads you, then when you were just about to jump on it it would change direction and start running away from you.
>>333033512
>watching rdr
w0t
>>333028017
I am against all sequels,
let them rather do something else
>>333033838
Uhh Red Dead Redemption WAS a sequel...
I'd rather just get a PC remaster or something that makes the game look like this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZUUVV2rjoc
The game was already perfect and I don't think it really needs a sequel because it will probably go out of it's way to ruin parts of the original.
>>333033887
Redemption was more of a spiritual successor than a sequel.
I do, but not by Rock star. They're incompetent. Their games feel like crap. Bad riding and awful gunplay. A lot of it was nice and done well. I think they mean well, just have no idea how to make a game that plays nicely. It's a lot better than modern GTA though. Even if gameplay is the same.
>>333033828
I think he's making a joke about the game being very cutscene heavy.
>>333033989
It was more of a reboot than a spiritual successor
>>333033989
>>333034426
It's set in the same universe during a later time period and characters from Revolver are mentioned a couple of times. It's a sequel with an entirely new cast and location.
>>333033698
>see criminals ahead
>stop horse and continue on foot to avoid horse getting killed
>gunfight
>suddenly out of nowhere horse running toward the criminals for a bullet shower
>kills an animal while on horse
>get off horse to get loot
>cougar sound
>ohfuckohfuckohfuck
>press triangle to ride horse like crazy
>doesn't work
>look behind you
>horse is nowhere to be found
>whistle
>horse spawns so far away it only appears on the edge of the mini map
>dealing with a bunch of criminal
>the leader is trying to get away with horse
>whistle while chasing the criminal on foot
>horse passes next to you just a tad to far away to jump on it
>stops about 30 meters ahead
>finally reach retarded horse
>criminal flew away
Fucking kill the guy responsible for this seriously.
>>333034571
>It's a sequel with an entirely new cast and location
so not a sequel?
>>333034627
Marsten is not very good at training his horses.
"GODDAMN STUPID HORSE GET BACK HERE!"
>>333034793
Previous story is canon so it's a sequel.
>>333034571
Isn't the entire point of a sequel to continue the story of the previous title? Sounds more like a spinoff with some nods and camoes than a sequel.
Carcer City from Manhunt is regularly mentioned in the GTA games but you wouldn't call San Andreas a sequel to Manhunt.
>>333034875
I guess he's not good a moving/shooting either which would explain the shitty controls.
>>333034875
Nigga he broke the 4 horses of the apocolypse and a god damn unicorn.
>>333035026
No, different universes with a cameo appearance is not a sequel. Skyrim is clearly a sequel to Oblivion despite being in a different time period with a different cast and a different location and a different story. The previous game happened within the canon of said story.
Red Dead Redemption is a sequel to Red Dead Revolver.
>>333035354
Manhunt and GTA are in the same universe anon. Even Red Dead is in the same universe as GTA.
>>333035107
Given that he runs like an old man trying to reach the outhouse in time I'd say yeah he's not so good at it.
>Are people really that afraid of AAA games nowadays ?
Name one released relatively recently that is very good. Okay doesn't count. Above average doesn't count. Just one new AAA game that you can say with complete honesty is very good.
>>333035408
No, there are cameo's and references but no direct links between any of the different games. Hell even the different Grand Theft Auto generations aren't in the same universe.
>>333028485
It's easy, you make it a Korean Western. They had a similar Wild West situation in Asia but with many more groups and factions at play.
>>333035582
>there are cameo's and references but no direct links between any of the different games
You do realise that the exact same can be said for RDR, right?
>>333035636
Not marketable.
>>333028485
It doesn't have to be 1914.
It doesn't have to be California.
Don't come to me with problems, come up with solutions.
>>333028017
A sequel to RDR would be great. Rockstar is one of the only decent devs left.
But yea most recent sequels have been shit. Like Battlefront (which was literally butchered, cut into little pieces and then fed to the pigs) and Bioshock Infinite.
>>333035636
>Korean Western
Fuck off weebshit
>>333035695
Huh. I went full circle and totally destroyed my own argument there didn't I? Fair play to you anon, I admit my defeat graciously.
>>333035783
>Not marketable
ok, you come up with a better idea that hasn't beaten a dead horse
>>333035910
>weebshit
This I take offense to, it's not even the right insult here. The proper insult would be gookshit or chinkshit.
>>333036046
Close enough.
>>333034960
So by your logic, iron man 3 is a sequel to Captain america 2, cause they're both canon?
>>333035408
Manhunt's in the 2D universe (3 to San Andreas), Red Dead's in the HD universe (IV and V so far).
Carcer City exists within the HD universe and it's still a desolate shithole but the events of Manhunt may or may not have happened. In GTA V's online you can choose John Marston as a Great Grandfather when making your character.
>>333036046
kek. Fuck off, you're as bad as those fags who suggest an European Fallout.
>>333036148
It's a sequel within the wider Marvel Cinematic Universe but not a direct sequel to Cap 2
>>333036302
not even close being that there is historical evidence to back up my claims. ill say it again, suggest something better
>>333036379
whatever you say dude
>implying this wouldn't be perfect
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Tk80iXCspM
>>333036547
Irrelevant. It's along the same line in that it goes against the series' conventions.
If you want an unique snowflake setting, choose something cool, like the Klondike gold rush. Not fucking gook cowboys.
>>333036616
Kinda like the Legend of Zelda series where the games are all sequels/prequels within an established universe but are rarely a direct sequel to a previous game.
>>333036823
>there were no americans anywhere else in the world during this era
whew
>>333036823
>goes against the series' conventions
How? How is a different setting going against the series conventions? A location is not a convention.
>>333036864
>shoehorning an american protagonist in a shoehorned asian setting
wew lad
>>333036927
>History
>Shoehorned
>>333036927
>there were no americans in Asia during this period of time
even whewer
>>333029278
Make it about trappers in the Midwest during the early 19th century :)))
>>333036969
>>333036980
>it'll be just like my last samurai
wewo
>>333037032
>implying the last samurai wasn't based off of historical events
whewie-wowoiee whowhewhi
Does anyone want a more snowy environment? I loved Tall Trees in RDR, and recent films (The Revenant, The Cuckful Eight...) have made me really want a game set in a harsh place like that.
But I guess one of the most iconic Westerns' features is the wild desert.
>>333037032
>Japan
>relevant to the discusion
wew?
>>333028464
/thread
>>333037084
>with a shoehorned in American protagonist
Look, I get what you're saying. It's historical. But it doesn't make sense. Klondike is already a better suggestion.
>>333037130
It really was. Context son, context.
>>333037084
Based off of historical events =/= historically accurate
>>333037130
>korea
>relevant to RDR
heh
>>333037265
>zombies, unicorns, and intelligent mexicans
>relevant to RDR
oh wait
:^)))))
>>333037261
We're discussing the viability of a video game setting here, accuracy is irrelevant.
Just make the controls feel better instead of floaty as fuck
. . . and stop the fucking "press a button repeatedly to not walk at a snails pace"
We have analog sticks for fucks sake
>>333037315
>a spin off with mostly re-used/re-textured assets that didn't sell very well
So, not marketable. Thanks.
>>333037352
Literally anything can be a viable video game setting.
>>333037425
>canon DLC
>oh no dont pay attention to that, we are serious game for mature gamers
wowie
>>333037479
>canon DLC
Undead Nightmare isn't canon.
>>333037461
EXACTLY! Yes! Thank you.
As long as they don't write another ''le snarky social commentary man xD'' protagonist.
>>333037479
> You play Undead Nightmare as John, and it is an entirely stand alone game that runs separately from Red Dead Redemption’s main story.
http://www.rockstargames.com/newswire/article/10061/asked-answered-undead-nightmare-edition.html
>canon
kek
>>333037529
Doesn't mean it's a good choice ;)
>>333029314
Sauce?
>>333037923
https://www.turner.com/pressroom/turner%E2%80%99s-adult-swim-announces-new-seasons-anime-hit-series-flcl
Idk anything about a new cowboy bebop. Probably true through.
