[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Will there ever be another good LOTR game? Also, LOTR Thread
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /v/ - Video Games

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 93
File: 13769311467488.jpg (81 KB, 1000x672) Image search: [Google]
13769311467488.jpg
81 KB, 1000x672
Will there ever be another good LOTR game?

Also,
LOTR Thread
>>
Probably, eventually. Still no real Lotr RPG has been made for some reason. Might be cool.
>>
Shadow of mordor was... mediocre. But it wasnt a lotr game
>>
>>332294916
>Probably, eventually. Still no real Lotr RPG has been made for some reason. Might be cool.

What about LOTR: The Third Age?

It had problems because it ended up getting rushed, but it had some seriously cool shit in it.
>>
>>332295093

I liked the nemesis system. Kept me entertained a while.
>>
>>332295161

I'm talking real RPG, not shitty Final Fantasy remake. I am talking full party of adventurers, lots of dialogue, lots of traveling etc. Like Baldur's Gate kind of. The setting is pretty much made for a deep RPG but nothing has been made yet.
>>
>>332294916
War in the North, while not a proper RPG, still gave me tons of fun. Felt like I was playing Dark Alliance again.
>>
>>332295258

It was amusing I guess but still too simple.
>>
Nothing fun about playing a game when you know what will happen afterwards anyways. How people can find a universe already predetermined what will happen in the future, fun, I'll never understand.
>>
>>332295163
yeah that was what made the game special in some way.
>>
File: 1459175834207.gif (2 MB, 200x293) Image search: [Google]
1459175834207.gif
2 MB, 200x293
>>332295428
>poopyface
is this a serious insult adults use now?
>>
>>332295359
Lol? The game could simply be about something within the universe that doesn't completely pertain towards the original story?
>>
>>332295510

SHUT UP POOPYFACE SHUTUP SHUTUP SHUUUTUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUP
>>
>>332295359
What
>>
File: Gondolin.jpg (247 KB, 1280x902) Image search: [Google]
Gondolin.jpg
247 KB, 1280x902
>tfw Silmarillion RPG set during the War of Wrath.
>>
>A game in which you're just a dwarf looking for the silmarils in your dwarf submarine.
>>
File: feels women will never have.jpg (225 KB, 1179x742) Image search: [Google]
feels women will never have.jpg
225 KB, 1179x742
>>
File: 1371764209485.png (20 KB, 157x150) Image search: [Google]
1371764209485.png
20 KB, 157x150
>you will never see the trilogy for the first time again
>>
>>332298517
Fuck id at least want to read the books for the first time again

What a world
>>
List of great LOTR games

>Fellowship of the Ring (yes I'm serious, try it out)
>Two Towers
>Return of the King
>The Third Age
>Battle For Middle-Earth 1/2
>War In the North (yes, it's also awesome.)

Am I missing any?
>>
>>332298769
The Fellowship of the Ring was absolutely god-tier and I cried in a few places. Both the Two Towers and Return of the King felt a little too fast paced for me, and I actually liked the movie versions more.


At the hill's foot Frodo found Aragorn, standing still and silent as a tree; but in his hand was a small golden bloom of elanor, and a light was in his eyes. He was wrapped in some fair memory: and as Frodo looked at him he knew that he beheld things as they once had been in this same place. For the grim years were removed from the face of Aragorn, and he seemed clothed in white, a young lord tall and fair; and he spoke words in the Elvish tongue to one whom Frodo could not see. "Arwen vanimelda, namári!" he said, and then he drew a breath, and returning out of his thought he looked at Frodo and smiled.

"Here is the heart of Elvendom on earth," he said, "and here my heart dwells ever, unless there be a light beyond the dark roads that we still must tread, you and I. Come with me!" And taking Frodo's hand in his, he left the hill of Cerin Amroth and came there never again as living man.
>>
i liked lotro before the f2p bullshit
>>
>>332299008
eat shit you tasteless faggot
>>
>>332299624
I'm sorry I enjoy video games.
>>
>>332299509
>and I cried in a few places
kekking beyond control
>>
>>332299970
>not tearing up when Frodo begins crossing the river at the end and Sam runs after him, almost drowning
>not tearing up at the broest of bro scenes

Feelingless faggot.
>>
Lego LOTR was pretty good from what I remember
>>
>>332294846
Hey thanks for reminding me OP, I need to marathon the LOTR Extended Edition boxset again.
>>
>>332294846
there will never be another battle for middle earth
>>
>>332300104

That was very good. It was pretty cool being able to walk from The Shire to Mordor
>>
>>332300104
i really wanted to like it but i couldn't. i guess im not much on puzzle/platforming.
>>
File: LOTR War In The North.jpg (116 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
LOTR War In The North.jpg
116 KB, 1280x720
Am I the only one who enjoyed playing this?
>>
>>332300856
No, I loved it and have beaten it three times.
>>
>>332300856
how is the single player? a lot of people say it's shit and is only worth playing with friends.
>>
File: image.jpg (50 KB, 256x333) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
50 KB, 256x333
This shit was too fun
>>
I liked Shadow of Mordor.

Being an immortal spirit of vengeance was cash. But it was kind of too easy to slaughter normal orcs and certain combinations of the warlords/ranked orcs was bullshit. Looking at you Mr immune to ranged, immune to melee, immune to stealth niggers, with a big ass tower shield that can't be broken.
>>
>>332300856
i would like to play it but for some fucking reason it runs at 5 frames, just like the darkness 2, some day these 2 games just stop working
>>
>>332295093
If they wanted crazy magic stuff they could just place the game in the 1st age. But nooo,this faggots need to have Sauron and the Rings of Power
>>
File: 1359837490453.jpg (201 KB, 1500x625) Image search: [Google]
1359837490453.jpg
201 KB, 1500x625
>>332296435
One day someone will make this in a game similar to Dark Souls + Baldur's Gate + TES.

Or not.

>tfw no first age game
>will never find Gondolin just before its fall after getting lost in the mountains
>will never ride into battle with a massive army at your back ending in a terrifying pyrrhic victory against the armies of Morgoth
>>
>>332301001
It's not exactly the greatest game ever made and it's a bit repetitive and confusing at times but if you enjoy the setting it's definitely worth a play. The city hubs like Lothlorien are comfy and good to explore and have conversations with the characters as they will tell you stories.

Online coop play is always better than playing it alone.
>>
>>332302297
so much this, the universo of lotr is huge, but developers always want to make the same shit over and over again.
>>
>>332302395
You're now realizing you would have to stoop like Gandalf just to fit in this tiny fucking 4 foot high room.

Unless you're a midget or something.
>>
>>332302985
It's because casuals know nothing about the Middle Earth setting and only know about the Third Age/War of the Ring so devs and their execs want to play it safe.

>tfw friend of mine actually prefers the Hobbit trilogy over LOTR movies
>>
File: 1456829296992.png (202 KB, 360x690) Image search: [Google]
1456829296992.png
202 KB, 360x690
>>332294846
>Battle of middel earth had good working units that could merge and good building workarounds
>Battle of middel earth 2 had custom heros, alot of new units, races and diffrent ways you could play the races. they also upgraded the power tree

i love both of them for diffrent resons
>>
>>332298517
Hope for Alzheimer's, bud.
>>
File: 1438483378165.jpg (265 KB, 540x874) Image search: [Google]
1438483378165.jpg
265 KB, 540x874
>>
>>332295161
I remember playing that on the ps2, I know what you mean about rushed but it was really good. they experimented with a few things and it was interesting, but ultimately a bit too much like final fantasy
>>
The Lego Hobbit game was pretty good for what it was

Though for some weird reason it doesn't cover the third movie and they canned the DLC that was going to.
>>
>>332301238
It was.
I wanted to play it again not too long ago only to see that EA shut down the servers. Fucking faggots, the game isn't even that old.

The multiplayer was hilariously unbalanced, archers could literally oneshot everything.
>>
>>332304147
It's a goddamn tragedy. So much potential.
>tfw no children of hurin rpg
>tfw no fall of numenor game where you have to stealth your way out of the island as elendil
>>
>>332305624
i yawn at that image

i cant appreciate it like other can

nice to know someone was happy because of it
>>
bfme 2 was the best lotr game
>>
>>332295161
>final boss is literally SAURON'S EYE

it was so bad but I still love that game
>>
>>332305624
Woah.
That's pretty amazing.
>>
>>332305624
I don't believe this much detail went into movie. Legolas' smile is just a coincidence.
>>
>>332307093
i dont belive it too, but still it fits nicely
>>
>>332307093
>I don't believe this much detail went into movie. Legolas' smile is just a coincidence.

What's neat is that this awesome little detail is never stated in the LOTR books nor in anything Tolkien published in his lifetime. The significance of this seemingly minor detail only came up years after Tolkien's death when his son published The Silmarillion.
>>
File: gr.jpg (9 KB, 200x199) Image search: [Google]
gr.jpg
9 KB, 200x199
>>332295359
>>
>>332296435
Damn I love me a good well done fantasy landscape, why is this kind of shit not in more vidya games?
>>
>>332298201
But there was a woman in that scene charging and yelling just like all the men.
>>
>>332307683
I doubt this is what woman would think about in the shower though.
>>
>>332307093
I dunno. Christopher Lee and Magneto were both huge dicks about details like that while on the set.
>>
File: Scared Little Gravewalker.jpg (198 KB, 1768x992) Image search: [Google]
Scared Little Gravewalker.jpg
198 KB, 1768x992
>>332295163

For a first attempt, I thought the nemesis system was pretty clever for what it tried to do. Enemies learning from previous engagements, finding new ways to fight and defeat you.

I hope that one day, the system will be built into other games, where what you do and how you interact with the wold and those in it will have lasting, appreciable affects on the world and your role/choices in it.
>>
Hoping for a good Battle for Middle Earth 3

Provided EA doesn't dumb down the mechanics
>>
>>332308275

It'll be like C&C4.
>>
>>332308153
>That quote
That's pretty gay, orc.
>>
>>332305624
>>332307093
Some nerd who read the books told Jackson to tell Orlando Bloom to smile in that scene. Nothing more to it.
>>
File: Am I Kawaii Uggu.png (382 KB, 819x599) Image search: [Google]
Am I Kawaii Uggu.png
382 KB, 819x599
>>332308513
>>
>>332308513
It's supposed to be.
>>
A bit slow, but I just started reading the Silmarillion. Feanor seems to be a huge retard, but I must say that I like this guy.
Goddamned you Telerei, just make some new boats for them.
>>
>>332295093
I literally just closed that game
Only worthwhile thing about this turd is the nemesis system, sole reason I have 9 hours in it so far
The lorerape is just embarassing
>>
File: FroDo's Bizzare Questioning.png (255 KB, 400x400) Image search: [Google]
FroDo's Bizzare Questioning.png
255 KB, 400x400
>>332304147
>>332302297
Wasn`t it that Tolkien`s nephew or something has the rights over the silmarillion and he keeps it from everyone? I thought that was why we don`t have anything from first age
I mean armies of balrogs, dragons, gods and all that would sell a lot, no one is that retarded to let that pass
>>
File: som.png (148 KB, 1236x433) Image search: [Google]
som.png
148 KB, 1236x433
Will you faggots stop talking about Fuck Tolkien: The Game?

This is a LotR thread.
>>
>>332308920
Best part of the game is taking over the army. Ratbag is the tutorial on that. Follow his quest, get to the second map, and do main quests until you can convert orcs. Then it's fun.
>>
>>332308995
Tolkien's son Christopher, who himself teaches at Oxford, holds the rights and he'll be damned if he lets one more piece of the legendarium ever become licensed.
>>
>>332308864

I think the Silmarillion is one of the better books, especially if you've read his other works. And it does start off slow, but you need to get a good grasp on lineage, as it becomes more important later. Enjoy the ride, there is nothing like reading it the first time.

If only Feanor wasn't such a fuckboi, things wouldn't have turned out so bad. He is the catalyst for everything.
>>
>>332308995
No studio is going to pay 300 million to make a movie in which none of the lotr characters has a role.
>>
File: Tom Bombadil.jpg (43 KB, 500x492) Image search: [Google]
Tom Bombadil.jpg
43 KB, 500x492
>>332309072
>>
the only LOTR game/mod you need
http://www.moddb.com/mods/third-age-total-war
>>
>>332294846
tfw they couldnt just make shadow of mordor co-op like the PS2 games
>>
>it's been 15 years since Fellowship of The Ring
I'm feeling old and i don't like it.
>>
>>332307093
>>332307225
>>332308535

You guys are thinking of Hobbit Jackson.

Jackon, Walsh and the others who wrote up the script for LotR and worked on the worldbuilding actually really cared about what they were making and knew their shit. It was a real passion project that Jackson couldn't believe he was funded to make.

He never wanted to direct The Hobbit but Del Toro dropped out and I guess the studio offered him a gorrilion dollars to half-arse it.
>>
>>332309712
>best mod
>not The Last Days for M&B
>>
File: image.jpg (43 KB, 250x319) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
43 KB, 250x319
Did anyone else play it?

I thought it was really fun
>>
Fuck, this thread shows me how much I miss the Lord of the Rings games, I got almost all of them, even the Gameboy/Gameboy Advance games and Playstation 2 games, also that amazing The Hobbit game for PC and consoles. That were great times I'm telling you, really great times. My favorites are still BFME 1 and 2.
>>
>>332310361
Man the Hobbit movies were fucking awful
I expected bad but not that bad
>>
>>332310605
Was also a good time for comfy Harry Potter games.
>>
>>332310669

I know, man. I know. Sometimes I catch myself staring at a wall and thinking about how bad they were, have to pull myself back to reality. It's a wound that doesn't heal.

Still haven't watched the third one. Fuck that noise.
>>
>>332310574
Hell yes I fucking did.

The game was buggy out the ass though, or at least on my grandparents PC it was. Had to constantly restart a few levels because shit literally wouldn't spawn, or the boss would get stuck behind a wall.

But fuck it was fun and made me love the hobbit as a kid.
>>
>>332310361
Del Toro didn't dropped. Apparently he wanted to make changes regarding styles to fit his personal vision, which would depart from the estabilished Jackson style. The studio then pushed him out and brought Jackson back. And yeah, Jackson had no interest in directing this.
>>
>>332310605

>BFME
>Rohan
>Train a shit ton of Rohirrim
>Theoden hero
>Charge power that makes all of your Rohirrim super strong and quick for a short time

All day erry day. So much fun.
>>
Just play LOTR mods for Total War
>>
>>332310574
Was this the game with 3 minute load times to get into a simple house on the original Xbox?

I think I "played" it for a bit.
>>
>>332310837
Oh yeah, the Harry Potter games totally, got the PC and Gameboy Color version of Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone and also played the Gameboy Advance version of Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, such amazing games.
>>
File: 1452372186967.png (662 KB, 628x617) Image search: [Google]
1452372186967.png
662 KB, 628x617
>>332310605
>Beating Two Towers and Return of the King on Gamecube with my bro

What the fuck happened to EA?
>>
>>332310986
And then after you won the game: https://youtu.be/ESnMzQZubKg?t=59s this theme plays. I've to play these games again
>>
File: 1458218325077.jpg (409 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
1458218325077.jpg
409 KB, 1920x1080
>>332308620
>>332308153
>>
>>332311451
Nothing, they drain companies to death. They are the ones that published most of the LotR games actually, and then promptly kill whoever made them.
>>
It was all the Noldor's fault.
>>
>>332299970
Robot detected
>>
>>332312378
Yes, Melkor dindu nuffin.
>>
>>332312689
For the good part, yeah he didn't.
>>
So what happened to all The Hobbit merchandise? Every Hobbit game, boardgame, card game, etc dropping it after desolation of smug.
The Lego Hobbit game was never finished.
>>
>>332311202
I had it on PC and it always ran fine
>>
>>332313146
Movies sold like shit.
>>
>>332312930
Like engulfing the world in darkness like never before? Are you serious?
>>
>orcs taller than men
Why they do this?
>>
>>332313213
Did he actively shit on his own plans while his enemies where sitting around plotting?
>>
>>332313196
They all made more than 900 million worldwide
>>
File: d9300201-1.jpg (84 KB, 312x320) Image search: [Google]
d9300201-1.jpg
84 KB, 312x320
>>332294846
> Not posting the most based character
>>
>>332313327
Nobody is afraid of a manlet orc
>>
>>332313447
What does this have to do with teaming up with Ungoliant, destroying the trees of Valinor and stealing the Silmarillions?
>>
>>332294846

There is Sil and Angband.
>>
>>332313878
Kinslaying
>>
>>332305624

I love stuff like this
>>
>>332310397
>even worse grind than vanilla
>cringe worthy eastern factions
>can't even start sieges
>horrible resource system
>equipment is either worthless or OP
>bugs everywhere
>Orc factions gimped so devs could masturbate to 360 no scope elves
>players can't recruit trolls
>>
>>332313591
Underrated (only for the french speaking).
>>
>>332314095
Happened after Melkor was a huge dick. Do you actually have an argument or am I wasting my time?
>>
The Rise of the Witch-King's campaign was so fucking good, even if itsn't canon.
I love playing as an evil overlord.
>>
>>332314381
C'est pas faux.
>>
>>332314413
Melkor is an evil asshole who caused terrible wars but the son of a bitch didn't breed infighting and distrust among his forces so they couldn't hold the line against an enemy.
>>
>>332314381
It's a shame the series will never be known outside of french-speaking countries.
>>
>>332307617
Copyrights, anon.

Everything is an "intellectual property" now
>>
>there will never be a coop game about the blue wizards doing fuck knows what fuck knows where
>>
>>332314751
But it's okay because he did the same thing earlier among the Noldor. That's absolutely fine, it's not like this caused all the later mischief. He was just a bad guy, how could I forget!
>>
File: DwarfFortressMatrix.jpg (22 KB, 400x285) Image search: [Google]
DwarfFortressMatrix.jpg
22 KB, 400x285
>>332314056
Don't forget about Dwarf Fortress if you want a more generalized fantasy story generator.
>>
>>332301238
It got such meh reviews but I loved it.
>>
>>332314935
They went east, which is basically mordor controlled land. Probably got buttfucked, them light blue sissies
>>
Mordor was ok you faggots, the nemesis system is cool as fuck, yeah it kinda shits on the lore, but every game does that, so I consider it it's own thing like an alternate timeline

the world looks authentic and the visuals are top notch, the orks and uruks are amazing and the real star of the show
>>
>>332315338
That final "boss" nothing more than qte bullshit. They hyped up that final battle so much. Was cool as hell to fight bunch of nemeses/chieftans with your ragtag uruks at same time tho.
>>
>>332315857

yeah, but they did deliver on the Sauron boss fight, in the bloody DLC
>>
>>332315295
>they failed and became like Sauron in the end
>no wait, actually they didn't and they cut him off from great reserves of allies
Maybe it was a mix of both?
>>
>>332299970
>am i fitting in guys?
>>
>>332299509

>and I cried in a few places

there are a few scenes in the trilogy that get me too, the last one obviously

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=URmQXIeVpN8

>My Friends, You Bow To No One.

10/10 scene
>>
>>332310574
>Did anyone else play it?
>I thought it was really fun

I played it on Gamecube. I really enjoyed it, and I'm not one for platformer games. It had good puzzles, the platforming was multidimensional, and the combat could be approached in many different ways.

Overall a great game, with a fantastic soundtrack.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XWN9cGE1EY&list=PLD9621DDE87CF13F7&index=10
>>
File: sad pepe.png (7 KB, 230x219) Image search: [Google]
sad pepe.png
7 KB, 230x219
>>332316606
I feel sad that im unable to cry during any sort of media, i didnt cry when my mom died. What the fuck is wrong with me /v/?
>>
>>332316606
>that one scene during RotK final battle when Sauron finally looks at Aragorn
>he starts walking towards him, losing his fighting stance while everyone else watches him worried
>he stops and turns around
>there is a little despair in his face, but there is something else too
>"For Frodo"
Shit was so fucking beautiful.
>>
>>332310574

Beaten it many times.

Top notch soundtrack, decent level design, pretty faithful, gameplay was solid. Would always play again.

I even owned the GBA version and beat it a lot.
>>
File: An Evening in Rivendell.jpg (91 KB, 741x734) Image search: [Google]
An Evening in Rivendell.jpg
91 KB, 741x734
This is my favourite thing to come out of the books, even more than the movies and the video games.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7bIUx_rjYw

>>332300057
>the broest of bro scenes
The aftermath of the Tower rescue, right? It was definitely the most emotional scene in the story for me.
>>
>>332317000
>that moment when frodo leaves his friend when he leaves to the undying lands
>>
>>332317050
The GBA version of it was 10/10 for a GBA game.
>>
File: QONVIyz.gif (2 MB, 331x197) Image search: [Google]
QONVIyz.gif
2 MB, 331x197
>>332294846
>Total War: Middle-Earth

>historic battles such as Isengard at Helms Deep, night + rain included
>and the OST https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WnbOcNmbpj4
>>
>>332317000
>Merry and Pippin are the first ones to run into battle

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sMCXrlxkhx0
>>
>tfw still enjoying LOTRO

COMFY
O
M
F
Y
>>
Honestly they should go the GTAV route for Shadow of Mordor 2, give us Hobbit, Human ranger and Elf gameplay and the ability to switch between all three
>>
>>332317704

>play LOTRO on and off since 2008
>still haven't got past moria because of the desire to level 40 alts
>>
Is lotro still fun? I stopped at mines of moria
>>
File: Born to feel.jpg (41 KB, 638x638) Image search: [Google]
Born to feel.jpg
41 KB, 638x638
>Cate Blanchet will never be Galadriel again
A shame, at least she got some more screentime on those horrible Hobbit movies.
She is smoking hot despite being almos 50
>>
>>332317792
Wasn't there a game a couple of years back that had something like that? I remember elf and dwarf and being able to change between them.
>>
>>332317872
>tfw never got gud enough as a Warden
>tfw only ever created dwarves
>but bought a house in Bree in the best possible placement
>>
>>332318127
>She is smoking hot despite being almos 50
Perfect elf.
>>
File: 1333452043241.jpg (52 KB, 300x230) Image search: [Google]
1333452043241.jpg
52 KB, 300x230
>>332314576
My nigga.

>that mission where you corrupt the barrow-downs
>that mission where you have to pick up shards of palantir before the enemy does
>all those sieges
>dark rangers all day every day
>>
>>332318127
>Hobbit movies
I still don't know how they managed to get everything wrong in the last one.
>>
>>332318127
>Cate Blanchet was Galadriel
I, what, fuck, I never made that connection, what the flying fuck, never once have I seen Cate Blanchet and thought "oh right she was in LotR, she was Galadriel".
>>
>>332318536
Let's not forget the absolutely fucking best scene of Legolas running up falling bridge and then doing head scissors on that one orc
>>
>>332299509

Beautiful.
>>
>>332318467
>dark rangers all day every day
I remember making a bunch of this, giving them the ice arrows power and pretty much soloing the whole map with them alone.
Fuckers were so broken.
>>
File: mattock.jpg (149 KB, 2000x2000) Image search: [Google]
mattock.jpg
149 KB, 2000x2000
>>332318720
>implying the best scene wasn't the elves hopping over the dwarf phalanx or how the orcs were huge, armored, and disciplined and with nary a wolf in sight
>>
>>332319220
Third movie was a fucking disaster

What the fuck was even going through Jacksons mind, fuck.
>all those CGI same-looking troops everywhere
>>
>>332295359
Nothing tasty about food you already know the taste of. How people can find a taste which is already predetermined tasty, I'll never understand.
>>
>>332318834
Yeah, they shit on everything, elves included.
Though, they were evil numenorians so it's kinda justified.
Took forever to build/upgrade them too.
>>
File: 1445368728544.jpg (34 KB, 427x300) Image search: [Google]
1445368728544.jpg
34 KB, 427x300
>2003
>LOTR craze is in full effect
>The Two Towers had just premiered a few months ago
>playing WC3/SC:BW custom maps with complete strangers
>we all spam quotes from the movies and have a great time
>Helm's Deep maps had lobbies filling up faster than you could blink
>sneaking orcs in to blow up the sewage drain and everyone ragequitting
>holding out for an hour to witness Gandalf's charge
>War of the Ring map
>sniping Sauron within the first few minutes of the game
>alternatively, sniping Frodo and possibly the entire fellowship within the first few minutes of the game
>get a lobby with experienced players and it would last for hours

It was truly a fantastic time to be a kid.
>>
>>332318536
There was no way that dedicating an entire movie to like 30 pages could ever turn out good.

You have to wonder how badly moviefags took it. Imagine waiting a year to see the conclusion of Smaug's menace only for him to die in the first five minutes.
>>
File: 1449342808528.jpg (65 KB, 401x720) Image search: [Google]
1449342808528.jpg
65 KB, 401x720
Why are the lotr movies so damn good? I could rewatch them every week.

It just feels like a damn adventure. I want more of that. Maybe a nice D&D movie exactly like lotr.
>>
File: feels ba.jpg (13 KB, 225x215) Image search: [Google]
feels ba.jpg
13 KB, 225x215
>>332316606

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AlyYBtASteQ

Ultimate sadness
>>
>>332320124
They were made with love.
>>
>>332320164
>That whole scene

When was the last time a vidya made you feel like a hero?
>>
>Just started reading the LOTR Books
>Fellowship of the ring starts off so different compared to the movies
>Frodo ends up going on a trip from hobbiton to Buckland with Pippin and Sam and meets a bunch of elves

I can kind of see why the book fans were a bit miffed over the movies, Anybody here even read the books?
>>
>tfw no Tom Bombadil
>>
>>332320592
Of course I've read the books bruh.

Fatty Bolger's my homeboy
>>
>>332320592
I got the books for christmas, after watching the movie with my senpais. Good times. The ending in the books may suprise you as well.
>>
I can't believe how perfect the casting was for LOTR. LITERALLY PERFECT!
>>
>>332320592
The books are great, lots of more world building.

You should give the Silmarillion a chance too, it's basicly old testament with elves, gods and giant shadow weaving spiders
>>
>>332320592
Why wouldn't I read them?
Since I watched the movies first I was surprised it took Frodo 20 damn years to get off to his quest.
Though that higlights differences between hobbits and humans when 50 is only middle aged.
>>
>>332320826
>you're now older than Elijah Wood was when he was Frodo
>>
>>332320826
But Orlando Bloom... he did an alright job, but it could have been better.
>>
>>332320973

I was already older than him.
>>
>>332321071
I can't imagine anyone else as Legolas.
>>
>shield skateboarding
>>
>>332321209
Damn
>>
>>332321071
He was good in lotr.
>>
>>332321071
He was the elfiest elf.
>>
>>332321274
What a classic moment in The Lord of the Rings™: The Fellowship of the Ring©
>>
>>332317140

Nice, thanks for that. Have one I like.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pISzxdEgDCU
>>
I wish there were more grand fantasy movies as good as the LOTR trilogy. It seems like every other fantasy movie that's come out since has been massively inferior/total shit.
>>
>there are people that lotr is medieval fantasy
>>
>>332322173
>I have dyslexia
>>
>>332311874
Bane?
>>
>>332303082
Gandalf only had to stoop in the doorways
>>
>>332322061
I think the main diffrence between LotR and other fantasy fiction is that LotR is very much written like a historical epic whilst other shit is not only derivative (of another work of fiction rather than real mythology) but it's written like regular fictional novels.

I'd seriously argue that LotR and the books related to the setting deserve their very own sub-genre; epic fantasy.
>>
Why was Gandalf so useless a lot of times

I know he's supposed to be some envoy sent by the gods or some shit but come on.
>>
>>332322610

I think the main diffrence between LotR and other fantasy fiction is that LotR is superior to literally everything
>>
File: 1442436995315.jpg (58 KB, 722x349) Image search: [Google]
1442436995315.jpg
58 KB, 722x349
Why did they fuck up the Hobbit so badly?
It's like they forgot everything that made the LOTR movies good.
>>
>>332322610
It's mythical folk tales. That was Tolkien's life pursuit, studying and writing those things. He did a lecture on Beowulf and single handedly changed the academic perspective on it from "just a story of a hero killing some monsters" to it's own place in fictional history.
>>
>>332323012

they cashed in, it was about the money, also jackson went full lucas with green screen and CGI
>>
>>332322954
>he's supposed to be some envoy sent by the gods
Yeah, to offer advice mostly.
>>
>>332323152
Jackson might deserve some of the blame, but he was literally incapable of doing anything about that part. The Hobbit had virtually 0 pre-production whilst the LotR films had years.

There's a video from one of the Hobbit dvds (I think) that shows how fucked the whole production was. Conan Stevens jumped ship on GoT (he was the original Mountain) to play the son of Azog in the Hobbit, but they eventually turned to CGI simply because it was easier and quicker.
>>
File: gandalfproblemsolving1.png (66 KB, 600x699) Image search: [Google]
gandalfproblemsolving1.png
66 KB, 600x699
>>332322954
>>
File: pic906495[1].jpg (385 KB, 900x900) Image search: [Google]
pic906495[1].jpg
385 KB, 900x900
This is still the best LotR game I have ever played. And they are still making expansions for it regularly.
>>
>>332322954
Because he was forbidden to match power with power since last time they did that a subcontinent sank.
Also he was scared of orcs.
>>
>>332322954
>>332323297

Gandalf didn't really have the right to go fuck shit up. If I'm not entirely mistaken (and correct me if I am) he wasn't allowed to directly confront any other maiar. Durin's Bane (the balrog in Moria) completely overstepped his boundaries when he went to fuck with Gandalf and was summarily fucked up. Likewise, Saruman failed in his duty as a maiar by being a powerhungry twat and subsequently had his staff broken by Gandalf who was the new boss of the istari.
>>
The Hobbit
The Lord of the Rings trilogy
The Silmarillion
The Children of Húrin

Is that everything, as far as Middle-Earth narrative novels go?
>>
>>332322061
Game of Thrones fits the bill. Not gonna debate which is better but its not total shit.
>>
File: TN-At_Tarn_Aeluim.jpg (291 KB, 1344x864) Image search: [Google]
TN-At_Tarn_Aeluim.jpg
291 KB, 1344x864
>tfw you'll never get an epic RPG with the same epic feel as Ted Nasmith's artwork.
>>
>>332324013
>no lost tales
>>
>>332324128
Why is Ted so fucking godlike?
>>
>>332324049
I like GoT a lot, actually. Show and books.
>>
File: tirdawn.jpg (427 KB, 1300x933) Image search: [Google]
tirdawn.jpg
427 KB, 1300x933
>>332324175
He's probably a maiar himself, desu.
>>
>>332324130
That's why I'm asking. I'm a Tolkien casual.
>>
File: 1459183799033.png (145 KB, 214x384) Image search: [Google]
1459183799033.png
145 KB, 214x384
>>332324128
>there will never be a single player/coop LOTR game set in the first or second age
>with open world
>and all the locations and factions being there
>with a coherent storyline that doesn't interfere with the lore itself
>>
>>332324420
>that sense of scale
>that coloring
>that comfyness
>YOU CAN FUCKING MAKE OUT THE TILES ON THE WALLS

So good.
>>
File: Ted Nasmith - At The Falls.jpg (180 KB, 1024x768) Image search: [Google]
Ted Nasmith - At The Falls.jpg
180 KB, 1024x768
>>332324459
>>332324695
Prepare for Tedposting.
>>
Fuck, is there any fantasy world more comfy than Middle-Earth?
>>
>>332324128
>>332324420
>>332296435
Doesn't look that far off from what you could see in Skyrim, with some reservations of course.
>>
>>332324425
Then you might want to add these and that book where Tolkien replied to letters.
>>
>>332318536
Short answer is that it was rushed. They were shooting some of the battle scenes even before the script was finished.
>>
>>332324830
pic related
>>332324920
Problem with Skyrim was that is lacked the sense of scale >>332324695 mentioned. It didn't really help that the colours were way too muted.
>>
>>332324128
>that subtle flame lighting up the nearby rocks

Whenever I see Ted art I instantly think of LOTR.
>>
File: 497.jpg (9 KB, 177x278) Image search: [Google]
497.jpg
9 KB, 177x278
>>332324936
Fuck me.
>>
>>332324420
>>332324830
>>332325148
You know what's a surprising combo? Looking at Nasmith and listening to Hirasawa music. It's a weird blend of Berserk and LOTR.
>>
>>332306225
Evil Mode was one of the best things in any game ever
>>
>>332310847
They are pretty bad, but I think they are better than the star wars prequels.
>>
>>332325415
They're worse than the prequels because at least those gave us podracer.
>>
I liked The Hobbit movies, although they're not a patch on the LOTR trilogy and they're very bloated.

Saying that, I have not seen the extended versions.
>>
>>332325415
The Star Wars prequels are watchable. The Hobbit movies are not.
>>
>>332325415
Well the prequels are trainwrecks in every way so yes I guess^, but that's no high praise
>>
File: 1458750514475.png (373 KB, 525x717) Image search: [Google]
1458750514475.png
373 KB, 525x717
>>332325763
>The Star Wars prequels are watchable
>>
>>332310847
>Still haven't watched the third one

me either m8
>>
>>332294846
warhammer: LOTR would have been cooler than warhammer:war:hammer:warhammer
>>
I remember wasting hours playing BFME when i was younger. But the hard AI got easy after a short while.
>muh isengard

Wasn't crazy about BFME 2, I enjoyed the castle layout from the original it felt more immersed.
>>
>>332294916
Except there has been. There were lotr GBA games that were RPGS.
>>
Yeah sure the star wars prequels suck but they are still better than star trek, battlestar galatica, firefly, Andromeda, Farscape, etc.
>>
>>332298201
>SHIELDS SHALL BE SPLINTERED
>>
>>332325913
Are you implying The Phantom Menace is not at least a decent SW movie?

TWA is much worse imho.
>>
File: 1347143346210.jpg (46 KB, 480x480) Image search: [Google]
1347143346210.jpg
46 KB, 480x480
>>332326106
>warhammer: LOTR

kek
>>
>>332326289
Stop drinking.
>>
Tedposting galore.
>>
>>332326419
Can you be any more of a hipster Zelda cycle shithead?
>>
>>332326106
Didn't Games Workshop have their own LotR miniatures set going on?
>>
>>332300057
ofcourse you are mister frodo

And im coming with you.

drowns

suddenly hands clasping together.


i cried during the end of return of the king

>my friends, you bow to no one
and aragorn kneels
>>
>ctrl+f
>conquest
>0 results

I can't be the only one. This game was the shit on 360
>>
File: 4 stickers.png (198 KB, 480x411) Image search: [Google]
4 stickers.png
198 KB, 480x411
>>332326419
>The Phantom Menace
> decent SW movie
>>
File: 14354534543534535.jpg (38 KB, 362x346) Image search: [Google]
14354534543534535.jpg
38 KB, 362x346
>>332294846
>LOTR game
>Posts a picture of Ned Stark & Jamie Lannister

Uhh, OP?
>>
>>332299970
I only cried in was the Frodo & Sam boat scene.
>>
>>332326635
it was fun but short lived
>>
How is Lord Of The Rings The Third Age game for Gamecube?
I never actually played fully through it, and am thinking of playing it again. Is it worth plugging in my gamecube for it?
>>
>>332326689
>Jame Lannister
>Faramir AKA David Wenham

You better be memeing shithead.
>>
File: 1436383477022.jpg (697 KB, 1718x1264) Image search: [Google]
1436383477022.jpg
697 KB, 1718x1264
the ultimate dungeon crawl
>>
>>332326419
I agree with this guy.
I could always watch prequels.
I can't even bring myself to watch TWA a second time.
You can shit on Lucas all you want, but that man had a vision.
He didn't execute it properly in the prequels, but at least he didn't play it safe like Jew Jew. The movie ripped it's own original trilogy so much it hurts.
>>
>>332320124
>I want more of that.

You got The Hobbit and you will like it
>>
>>332326689
>>332294846

Wait, was there actually a scene of them together like that? Boromir dies in the first one and Faramir gets introduced in the second one, right?
>>
>>332326354
>A SWORD DAY...
>>
>>332327019
its a flashback to show you have much of a cunt their father is
>>
>>332326949
Jesus Christ.
>>
>>332327019
flashback from the extended edition of the two towers
>>
>>332326778
>when you get to be gandalf and fuck shit up for the rest of the match
>when you get to be sauron and get wrecked by a mage in 20 seconds
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 93

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.