Should Toby just stick to composing music?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pcamjcoRmrQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YHL_Bk60F_4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ijrzwMLd218
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B2jVbSI9H4o
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lGaneyDfyls
>>322262726
it's derivative but ok i guess. Didnt toby pirate fruityloops to write all these tracks?
>>322263320
Wouldn't surprise me DESU
>>322262726
Is just generic chiptune. Not bad, but easy shit to compose.
>>322262726
You just have shit taste.
This is what a good soundtrack sounds like;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3W32h-3EHCg
>>322263320
Pretty sure that was the LISA guy.
>>322264087
Well Undertale was made by one guy, I don't think he can produce SE quality music
>>322264245
didn't pirate, did it all on the demo version
>>322264282
BD OST was composed by one guy only and then performed by his band.
>>322262726
Undertale's music is so good because of how it fits in the game. It's not really meant to just be listened to on it's own.
>>322264282
Hotline Miami 2 music shits all over Undertale.
>>322264282
Bravely Default soundtrack was composed by one guy (Revo) from the band Sound Horizon.
>>322262726
Megalovania is so fucking overrated. There I said it.
>>322264454
lol it's just a 19 year old's soundcloud mix
>>322264696
Almost everyone who's actually played the game agrees. Undertale just has a orbiter fanbase that doesn't care about the actual game like Bloodborne, Persona, Majora's Mask, etc
>>322263320
>it's derivative but ok i guess.
He just has a giant hard-on for leitmotifs. it was really obvious in his tracks for homestuck.
http://undertale.wikia.com/wiki/Undertale_Soundtrack
Look at the far right of the table. Just about every track shares a leitmotif with another.
>that track on the way to asgore's throne
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bPCMJC1Ig6s
Why you not post this one, OP.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qF-BGHhEpk8
I personally like Finale, though, in its context. It's hard to listen to it on its own.
>>322264696
It is, just like it was overrated when it was Vriska's Theme. Not enough people knew about it during the earthbound hack for it to be overrated though.
>>322264747
Undertale? Yeah. Music is bland as fuck and all over the place.
>>322264884
He's used Megalovania like 3 times.
>In his Earthbound hack
>In Homestuck
>In Undertale, when it finally got attention, and memes
Also gave it to some guy for an RPG Maker game similar to Earthbound
Yes, Undertale was lightning in a bottle and should be his only game.
I'd like to see him do an actual album.
>>322262726
No, the soundtrack was pretty good but not extremely so, and the rest of the game was also good.
>>322265038
>go through the elevator on the way to the throne to see where it takes me
>it just leads to the other side of the long corridor I just walked down and cuts off the music
>moment completely ruined
Fucking Red Dead Redemption does the exact same thing if you stop to save on Marston's way home for the first ime.
How old are you people because everyone in youtubecomments is 15 or younger and always mentions how they "cried" during the game or got "emotional". What is this bullshit, on my first playthrough I got the darn near impossible Flowey ending and now I'm mad as fuck cause it's such a shit ending. Shitstain ending literally ruined a passable game.
>>322264884
>Hardon for Leitmotifs
You say that like it's a bad thing. The world needs more leitmotifs.
On a side note, Toby did some Homestuck stuff, but I notice a lot of his better stuff is, ironically, the songs that are remixing older stuff.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jyDdV8eIHGE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5NACWZBDtN8
Malcom brown is the better composer, Homestuck wise, at least.
>>322265434
They could be 15 or younger, or just be gigantic pussies
>>322265434
They're people who never played Pokemon Mystery Dungeon 2 and thus are still sensitive
Speaking of - lots of Toby's music reminds me of PMD stuff.
>>322265434
Old enough to know that judging a game based on youtube comments is a trait exclusive to retards
>>322265436
I didn't mean for it to be a bad thing, leitmotifs are wonderful and I agree they're underused.All this homestuck is making me want to reread it, but I know it wouldn't be worth it.
hell no
>>322265615
Well because my experience doesn't include crying or getting emotional. So I'm asking if I'm just not sensitive to this or is this somethow age related as teens can get quite emotional compared to other ages.
The only thing that made an impact on me was the encounter with Undyne but that was a real manly tears moment, so that's expected of a male.
>>322265930
You got the ending you deserved
>>322266340
Good thing this game explains that you're taking the bullshit route throughtout the course of it. Oh wait. It doesn't. It pretends to slap you on your wrist at the very end ruining any sense of meaningful playability or even a story.
Maybe game designers should read some Bible to understand what redemption is and maybe try to incorporate that?
>>322266952
You get the ending you work for.
>>322265818there's an audio visual version of Homestuck on youtube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLQ7JOidKp_xzsrVMGT1QFpjEavSkQMbV0But your enjoyment of it directly correlates with how much you like the voices.
>>322265930
The game is overrated. Story is nothing special. Is baby's first Earthbound.
>>322262726
Toby can't even stump the trump.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=dkwXKL0F9Fg
www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXJwllEL7Sg
www.youtube.com/watch?v=IFh5Duj4PJ8
www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZuI3ZkCHfs
www.youtube.com/watch?v=bg6SCZjI48U
>>322267038
Oh shit they're still doing that? I stopped watching it years ago.There were a couple that rubbed me the wrong way, but a lot of them were pretty good if I remember correctly. I may do that, thanks anon.
>>322267053
Some people claim it's better than the entire Earthbound series
>>322267483
I certainly like it more than Earthbound
>>322267483
That's a blatant overstatement. And logically flawed, because Toby Fox copied shit from the Mother games. Most PC players are experiencing that kind of ride for the first time. It's really popular with kids for some reason.
>>322267483
It's made it hard for me to suspend my disbelief when playing normal video games where your characters are fighting and massacring dozens of monsters per day but I still have fond memories of Mother 3.
>>322267825
The majority of people who like Earthbound played an emulated version on a PC
>>322268089
>let me tell you how it was for me and my small circle of friends
>>322268089
Agreed, but Undertale still was the first Earthbound-like experience for a lot of people. You don't see games like that on PC.
>>322268172
Yeah dude I'm sure the Mother fanbase is mostly people who play on a SNES with a $200+ cart and also learned Japanese to play the Japanese releases and not a translated ROM
>>322267440
>mfw realized He's my dad is a slowed down version of Goodbye baby
>>322267440
I just can't get into Lisa's soundtrack. Good game, but the music is too fucking weird.
>>322268845
It's more abstract and environmentalistic whereas UT's is a little more generic
I don't like Nyeh Heh Heh/Bonetrousle.Papyrus is my favourite character, though
>>322269129
I like it within the game, I'm glad Toby didn't reuse it a lot like the music gags with Undyne which were pretty funny
>>322267825
I'm playing through Undertale with my nephews and Neice as its the only way I'll give this game any time despite my legit desire to play it.
They enjoy the characters but perhaps its because I've gotten myself stuck reading the dialogue to them(which I've grown tired of and occasionally drop the theatrics or forget whose voice was whose.).
Sans is top favorite among them for shitty jokes and them saying hes lazy like me(those fucks.) and surprisingly Undyne after her cooking scene.
fuck i left for like 5 minutes and now I've lost my train of though....fuck it, long story short my nephews and neice like this game.
>>322269416
Sans is everybody's favorite
>>322269727
Sans is my least favorite
His fanbase doesn't help with that either
>>322269727
Yeah forgot to mention hes my favorite too. Hes like the only normal person in Undertale besides Papyrus who is just overly happy and the dumb friendly guy.
>>322262726
>fruity loops
> composing
Pic one
The music that plays during the final scene before ASGORE always makes me tear up. The story is dumb as fuck, but the music really makes it for me.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EBhFHJMVfiI
>>322269416
I really don't know why kids love the characters so much. I find the game pretty bland overall, but a lot of people think otherwise.
Protect those kids from the cancerous fanbase tho.
>>322267483
It is, Earthbound will forever be the most overrated game of all time
Of course, a game in the spirit of Mother will be overrated as well
>>322270327
>Protect those kids from the cancerous fanbase tho.
Too late, I already sent them my fanfiction
>>322262726
Hopes and dreams is the only one that sounds like there was legitimate effort put into
>>322270004
People who like something should never affect how you feel or think about that thing.
I can still understand you not liking Sans though. Mind explaining why you dont like Sans? Just curious. I feel like hes not around often enough to actually give too much feel for his character to dislike. Only reason I like him is the shitty jokes basically.
All the "character development" he gets to make up for that is through all these fucking fan comics and shit that make him out to be some depressed dude but i just ignore those and focus on whats in the game.
Lately I've been drawn into the world of shitty fandubs of shitty fan comics on youtube since I dont feel like playing games lately and man....none of them are any good. One dude's voice acting seems alright though, Timber puppers. Too bad he seems like a furry but eh, im not here to criticize his dumb lifestyle.
>>322270327
Games not amazing 10/10, I'd say its a solid 7.5 for me so far, might be why I need to have the excuse of "me and kids are playing it" in order for me to muster the will to play through it.
I'll do what I can to keep them from the fanbase but my duties as an Uncle are to keep them entertained, not make them better human beings.
>>322269727
I like Alphys and Papyrus the most. Napstablock too but he's less fleshed out.
>>322271705
I just didn't get the appeal of him.
I know his chill pun shtick and how he's secretly depressed because of the fear of resets but he didn't really get to me as a character I would really enjoy. Same for Alphys.
To be completely honest family, all of the characters are like that, very shallow with a lack of depth. Although that isn't a bad thing in itself, just makes for easy waifu/husbando targets.
>>322272395
Alphys is the fucking worst, Killed all my will to replay the game.
>>322272721
She's called the trash lizard for a reason
>>322272721i think she's cute and i'd watch anime with her
>>322272395
Is it actually in the game that hes actually secretly depressed about the reset thing or is that like a community thing?
I'm basically just sticking to believing things the game just flat out states....which sounds counter intuitive to him being secretly depressed now that I think about it.
Alphys is eh from what I've experienced., I may be playing through with my neice and nephews but I already watched an LP or 2 of the game since I felt I was never actually going to get around to playing it.
>>322272721
theres no 2 replays of the game isnt there? I know the "True" ending starts you off right before the Asgore fight then you go do the true lab shit and you're done right?
So you really only need to put up with Alphys once since I dont think shes in the genocide run right?
>>322273071
>theres no 2 replays of the game isnt there? I know the "True" ending starts you off right before the Asgore fight then you go do the true lab shit and you're done right?
If you did a full pacifist run and hung out with Undyne yes.
>>322273071
>you go do the true lab shit and you're done right?
She's in the epilogue too
>>322273216
Ok, so people complaining about 3 runs of the game are just being stupid right? 2 runs of mostly different stories is acceptable, at least in my eyes.
>>322273219
What happens in the Epilogue? Thats after the Asriel fight and shit?
Some of the remixes are insanely good though. Just listen to this shit:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L4IxBW_LLWI
>>322265818
I reread Problem Sleuth recently, it's still pretty good
Just read that; unlike Homestuck it's not a fucking disaster AND it's actually finished.
>>322273652
>Thats after the Asriel fight and shit?
You can talk to your friends or backtrack to explore more or leave the underground and watch Papyrus drive a car
>>322262726
>>322263320
Why do people fucking forget that the music dude behind Tower of Heaven (WHO IS KNOWN AS FLASHYGOODNESS) Is the one who helped Toby with the music in game?
Shit he has much rights to be praised then Toby. Esp with his Piano skills.
Also UNDERTALE DETERMINATION REMIX RIP (METAL/EDM)
https://mega.nz/#F!ytMiGb4D!KrFTvpGSN6XhYSFlX3nXKA
https://mega.nz/#F!ytMiGb4D!KrFTvpGSN6XhYSFlX3nXKA
>>322273652
the different runs don't add enough for it to be worth it
>>322274891
By different runs do you mean:
Pacifist, dont kill anything run that gets you story A.
and
Genocide, kill everything run that gets you Story B.
That seems worth it to me, any more runs than that isnt worth it, we agree on that part
>>322267440
>no go home johnny
>>322270068
>Sans
>Normal and happyDude is stone cold, if Toriel hadn't made him promise not to hurt you he would've turned you into a smear on the ground the second you stepped out of the caves
>>322275502
should have actually swapped boy oh boy with goodbye baby now that I think about it but eh
Darren Korb is my favorite vidya game music producer.
>>322262726
What kind of manchild listens to vidya OST's aside when they play in the games themselves?
>>322275939
I used to have a lot of respect for Danny B. before he completely shit the bed with Isaac's OST and went on to fuck everyone over for the SMB re-release.
It's hard to say who my current favorite is, probably Marty.
>>322275990
>>322275729
Oh no, I agree with you. You misread what I wrong, Hes not a happy guy, I was describing Papyrus as happy guy.
>>322276169
Crypt of the Necrodancer was well done though.
>>322263785
>generic chiptune
https://youtu.be/2OqigCz2S1w
Toby needs to learn how to make ost
this was made for NES/SNES and it sounds better than averything on undertale
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=peuTnilEv9g
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4_gObHt1uZA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BGNSHNf-nlU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SJwh3erQlyE
his musics are Ok but nothing 10/10.
Megalovania, Asgore and the Ambient track on the Core are the only ones that are top tier in my opinion
>>322276612
>tim follin
That's just unfair.
>>322267440
>no Brokentooth March
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qTKOah18x0g
>>322276612
>>322276947
>no C64 Follin
pleb taste desu
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BHg14wwgtbY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BEUJd8iQiOE
He's made some bretty good music for homestuck tbqh
https://homestuck.bandcamp.com/track/the-la2t-frontiier
What does THIS sound like, Undertale kids?
https://youtu.be/BTmQDAUSvac
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y4VNZdsjveE
>the best music is hidden away
>>322277991
Shit?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oJAfX2fSod8
>>322277803
>It's been over two and a half years since cherubim released
Christ, where does the time go
>>322264087
>MFW Revo said he wasn't doing the music for Bravely Second
>>322278179
>tfw there will never be another good homestuck album
>>322276612
>>322277489
>>322277991
we posting OST now?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CbvfsWBpL5M
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUWOxOgPhMI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jQYsJA_2usk
You dandy FUCK.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yjFr_vW8kwc
>>322262726
yes
>>322278407
>tfw there will never be another homestuck album
ftfy famicom.
>>322264087
>weeaboo garbage
literally kill yourself my man
>>322274767
Huh? Flashygoodness helped him with programming the audio systems into the game. All the music was written solely by Toby and is consistent with his past body of work.
>>322277991
>yfw Toby just remixed this for Dating Start!
>>322278826
And like half of the OST
>>322277991
Garbage?
>>322278826
He probably took inspiration from it, but the melodies are completely different. That mix lining the two up was cringeworthy with how dissonant it got.
>>322278954 (You)
>>322278106 (You)
Post your favourite remix's.
1) http://youtu.be/0ywWyLUSD2g
2) http://youtu.be/UaDAeI_eIkg
3) http://youtu.be/uI0CxTgpA6Q
4) http://youtu.be/Gc_eI9It_NA
5) http://youtu.be/baV-6-oHnA8
>>322279137
sorry pal
>>322262726
No, I'd like to see what video game he would create next as Undertale was a very enjoyable game.
>>322264884
Leitmotifs are great
Instead having a bunch of catchy songs, you just make a small handfull of catchy phrases and then vary the instrumentation, rhythm, and harmony.
That's right /v/, leitmotifs areARTIFICIAL CATCHYNESSSUCK IT WAGNER
>>322279202
>there are people who wasted their time on this shit
>>322262726
Writing and music, yes. Maybe have some input on design. Hopefully on his next project he teams up with some other devs that let him work to his strengths.
>>322262726
His music making is clearly the strongest of his skills. By a big fucking mile.
>>322262726
>throwing together bad loops in magic music maker
>composing
>>322279718
his story writing and character creation are also top notchi wanna fuck that goat
>>322279587
Frank Zappa was big on leitmotifs.
Toby's miles better than Frank, though.
>>322279797
composing music in a digital audio workstation is the standard operating procedure for nearly every composer working today, from toby to jake kaufman to koji kondo to even big film composers like hans zimmer
>>322279797
>shitposting on 4chan for attention
>>322280031
>>322280134
>digital audio workstation
Most real composers write their songs then they hire an orchestra to perform them. Except if it's electronic music, which isn't real music anyway.
The austist that made Undertale only threw together some guitar and electro samples he found for free in magic music maker and you people are sucking his dick.
>>322277991
holly shit mind blown
>>322280359
>Except if it's electronic music, which isn't real music anyway.
so the vast majority of video game music isn't real? simply epic t b h
>>322262726
>le undertale meme again
>>322280359
>Except if it's electronic music, which isn't real music anyway.
>Have "Undertale" filtered
>It's the only word on my filter list
>Four threads filtered
How many threads do you guys need?
>>322280463
>>322280558
Well yes, most of it is pretty shit. Just like video game stories are garbage.
>>322279616
Making good music isn't a waste of time
>>322280359
Hiring an entire professional orchestra ensemble is a bit over blown for a 16-bit indie game.
>The autist that made Undertale
>Threw in some sample in Magic Music Maker
>People are sucking his dick
>>322280359
>this whole post
>>322281515
Better than you've ever done or ever will do, faggot
>>322280359
>electronic music isn't real anyway
>>322281851
Did you think my post was against the OST?
Nigger Undertale has my favourite OST.
Use to do mashups with that OST in pirated Fruity Loops when the game first came out.
>>322282245
Oops sorry. Didn't realize you were quoting somebody, I'm retarded. sorry.
>>322273071
>Is it actually in the game that hes actually secretly depressed about the reset thing or is that like a community thing?
It's in the genocide path
>>322267440
>666 Chop Kill Deluxe
sickest beats of 2015
>>322278554
>there is weeb and non weeb music
what?
Aside from that, Bravely Default is not a weeb game at all.
