Why does Maxson exist?
- Home
- Board: /v/ - Video Games
- Reading: Why does Maxson exist?
Seeing how this is the same brotherhood of steel members from the Capital Wasteland.
How in the hell did this fuckhead become the Elder of this group and completely reimagined everything?
What happened to the mindset that was established on to the members by Elder Lyons and his daughter?
He's such a god damn child.
>THE SYNTHS ARE ALL EVIL
>THEY'RE NOT HUMAN, THEY'RE MACHIIIIIIIINES.
>THERE ALL EVIL AND MUST BE DESTROYED!!!
>Nevermind that my most trusted Paladin in the whole group is a synth and has nothing but loyalty while never having the intentions of betraying the brotherhood, ALL SYNTHS ARE EVIL!
>A MAN PLAYING AS GAAAAWD!!!
I mean, it's fine he doesn't like synths, but destroying every single one as if they're ALL evil is dumb as fuck.
The thing that he can't seem to come to an understanding is that he barely knows jack all about synths and his only problem is that they didn't come across this idea first. Why destroy something when you can really use it to your advantage?
Not the mention the stick up his ass attitude he always shoves on you as if you've actually loyal too his punk ass.
Every time I have a conversation with this jackass, I kill him. Just for sure laughs.
>why did the Brotherhood go back to their core values after being fucked over by a shithead trying to play white knight of the wasteland and decimating their numbers
Gee I wonder
>>318345067
The brotherhood are just mad thay didn't make them first
>Why does Maxson fear sentient robots that will end up enslaving or wiping out humanity?
>Why is the Brotherhood going back to their roots?
>Why am I fucking retarded?
About sums up your thread, op.
The BOS from 3 were an abberation. The brotherhood's job was to retrieve all pre war technology by any means necessary. If you didn't give them what they wanted, they would just kill you and take it because you're too stupid to be handling it. It's not difficult to see why they would want to destroy synths. Technology belongs to the brotherhood. No one else.
Capital Wasteland BoS were breaking all the directives by being the wasteland police. The BoS directive is to seize every toaster and lightswitch in sight, by force if necessary. Lyons decided that survival/safety of the wasteland people was more important than hoarding tech and was effectively given his walking papers by west coast BoS. Some shit happens after F3 and both Lyons die so the BoS gets Maxson as their new elder. He stops them from being the police and returns them to their dickish roots.
>>318345067
>THEY'RE NOT HUMAN, THEY'RE MACHIIIIIIIINES.
As said by the Father himself.
>>318346782
>supporting Hitler reborn.
Says a lot about you too.
>>318345067
Last I checked the BoS weren't the ones trying to wipe out the Commonwealth and then replace everyone with Synths which have no emotions (according to Shaun).
Last I checked it was the Institute who's so disconnected from humanity that they feel they need to control it, what makes them so sure the Synths won't rebel and then wipe them all out? ..... SKYNET.
BoS realized this and made the decision to destroy them because people abuse technology time after time.
>>318347446
>species=races
>ghouls are people too!
>>318347102
>>318347109
It just begs the question of why can't they literally do both?
As in still seek to have the people stay save, protect the lands for the greater good, while still trying to preserve lost technology?
Why do they HAVE to be dicks about it and kill everybody in the process. What they do is no different from what a raider does.
>>318347446
>supporting the destruction of humanity
I think the Lone Wanderer should've lead the brotherhood.
>nearly immortal
>10 special across the board
>captain of a star ship
>has a house in megaton filled with several thousand pounds of weapons and armor
>has plans to harness the power of swamp hicks as shock troops
>would've been the father/big brother Maxson needed to keep from growing into an edgy cunt
>would've kept Sarah alive
>would've done everything right
what the fuck todd?
>>318347743
Name 1 time where the BoS has fucked your shit over.
>>318347743
Because moderation is an abomination in their eyes. No advanced tech whatsoever. BoS only looks out for BoS. Lyons saw reason. Would there have been infighting after the torch was passed from Lyons to Maxson? Absofuckinglutely. But you listen to the elder or you leave the brotherhood.
They have liberty prime and power armor.You guys act like they're a hard faction to justify.
>>318347743
That's exactly what Maxson believes he's doing
>>318347639
>Ghouls are people too!
>Ghouls are people who survived the Nukes but elongated life! That must mean they all should die.
It's just as OP said about synths, not ALL Ghouls are total brain craving zombies. Some still have their sense for the living.
>>318347893
>don't join up with them
>they constantly send vertibird death squads after you
>>318348015
It's hard to get on board with killing all synths when you have 4 synth companions
>>318348042
>make it clear you are an enormous threat to them
>be surprised they decide to fuck your shit up
I want a Fallout game where the antagonists are literal communists.
>>318347743
>Why do they HAVE to be dicks about it and kill everybody in the process. What they do is no different from what a raider does.
This is truer to the original brotherhood, but now all the newfags are learning they've always been assholes.
Maxson probably went fundementalist after Lyons and Sarah died for people he never personally valued.
>we gotta destroy all the synths, that kind of technology is what destroyed the world!!
>hey, we need some nukes can you go clear out that fort so we can have like 1000 nukes at our disposal?
>hey so our giant deathmachine is almost finished, all we need is more nukes, can you go get some even bigger nukes for us?
>>318347893
rivet city
>>318348161
>ask to join them
>send you to a radioactive crater for a bottle of armor wax
Only Railroad want synths to control the world
Institute just made them for labor
its funny how the Railroad decide to kill their creator in their ending and effectively cut off the chance of any more new synth of being born
>>318348206
Maxson's brotherhood is a combination of original brotherhood and Lyons. He's gone back to the original goal of protecting technology, but has dropped the tribal shit and is highly aggressive.
>>318347893
In Fallout 1 they send you to the Glow to get rid of you and are surprised if you return with the tech they asked for.
In NV they put an explosive collar on you and make you potentially murder an innocent man just because you were both sniffing around their bunker.
Classic BoS are grade A dicks.
>>318348027
If one day humanity meets another species with the same values and a similar way of living, are you planning to accept them as a part of your kind?
>>318348027
All Ghouls /will/ go feral at some point though, it's just a question of when. You could argue the same for the Synths- you blend them in to look and act as human as possible, but some day there's going to be a malfunction or the like that makes another Diamond City happen.
>>318348284
That is standard brotherhood behavior yes. They don't accept any random wasteland retard into their ranks so they send you off on what is clearly a suicide mission. If you do somehow manage to do it then you clearly are a cut above the rest and deserve proper consideration.
>>318348341
>tribal shit
what tribal shit?
They're even more insular now then before. They'll steal food and kill farmers without concern and only care about their own members. They're even more tribal?
>combination
What elements of Lyon's philosophy have been reserved?
>>318348016
Nah, that's bullshit.
Maxson's case (along with BoS standards) compared to Lyons resolve is that he actual believes he can save the wastelands by killing everyone and perserving old technology so they can rule over people.
The difference is that they can do that, but not have a need to think EVERYTHING that's not with their cause is solely evil.
Take the railroads for example, why have the need to kill railroad members when they have REALLY, done nothing to you and they're only mindset is to help synths who are good. (Key phrase here, Synths that are GOOD). They even kill synths, but the difference is that they're all controlled by the Institute.
It just sounds like from a perspective, that they're mad they didn't come from it first, and automatically assume...With no attempt to establish contact or agreement, that everything that's not them are evil.
>tfw Midwestern BOS never gets any recognition
>tfw Bethesda stole their blimps
>>318347743
>why can't they literally do both?
But they don't go around killing everybody. They're only interested in establishing their own order by putting tech into the hands of people who respect it and use it responsibly. The people who don't are the same people who caused the world to fall into nuclear devastation.
The brotherhood literally did nothing wrong.
>>318348042
BoS have saved my life numerous times while on their patrols. There are times where i'm literally getting facefucked by mutants and raiders and ghouls all smashed together at an intersection, and out comes the BoS swooping down with their birds gunning them down.
>>318348612
Yea thay wanted me to go and tell people to give up there food and shit
>>318348534
That's good, it really is, but in Maxson I'm dissapointed that he didn't end up with Lyon's Benevolence and the west's pragmatism.
The brotherhood expanding into a government military that doesn't govern but hold major sway in the politics and protection of settlements would have show some development in the region.
Now, it's like nothing has changed. Less yellow mutants because they cant find FEV and no more enclave, but all the good you attempted to do in 3 meant nothing when in 1 and 2 you actually had a clear positive effect on the region.
>>318348478
>If one day humanity meets another species with the same values and a similar way of living, are you planning to accept them as a part of your kind?
What that sounds like to me is:
>If humanity meets another species that does the same exact thing as what humanity does. They should die just because of this. Don't you agree?
>>318348612
>They'll steal food and kill farmers without concern and only care about their own members.
No, that's what YOU did. They never said you had to wipe out the farmers, even if they said "by any means necessary". He didn't force you to do that.
>>318348962
That's not strictly true, you gave the capitol wasteland clean water and an opportunity to actually rebuild and defeated the Enclave. Both things can only have had a net gain on the region even if you get no direct proof (and probably never will)
>>318348642
tactics is basically retconned at this point
>>318349060
And what would happen if a farmer got uppity and wouldn't be sweet talked or accept payment from the assholes in the sky?
>>318345067
To be fair, there's still a chance that Danse could've been a double agent. While it was a low chance, Maxson couldn't take that chance
>>318349129
Deacon has some random dialogue about wishing he was in the capitol wasteland because you can drink the water there.
>>318349207
Then you WALK AWAY. These are side missions by a BoS merchant, these orders aren't coming directly from Maxson last I checked, it's not their top priority.
>>318348640
>With no attempt to establish contact or agreement, that everything that's not them are evil.
From my perspective, rivet city is evil
>>318349059
No, the issue here is that you are trying to accept Ghouls as people. If they have a chance to hurt your kind, that's enough reason to eradicate them.
>>318345067
axing the synths was fine, what was dumb was wanting to nuke the institute instead of securing the technology and figuring out which scientists could be safely integrated into the brotherhood. What a waste.
>>318345067
Synths aren't sentient.
How is this such a hard concept to grasp. They're no more sentient than your computer. Do you think your computer have feelings? That the ATM machine feels abused you only use it for money? Consciousness isn't just something that pops up when you simulate it. It's as retarded as to think that your computer is going to fry because it may be wet when running a simulation to predict the weather for the next two days.
>>318349309
But he just rolls over on his "all synths must die" mentality. Hell that uppity bitch in Covenant had more resolve than the leader of [probably] the strongest military faction that side of the continent.
>>318348478
I plan to fuck the everloving shit out of their pussy analogues, or whatever passes for a meathole.
>all these blubbering vaginas ITT
>>318349060
>They never said you had to wipe out the farmers
ok, come on. That's like when you're on campaign in Mount and Blade and the king sends you to go get some food. Sure, you could buy all their stock, but seeing the infamy score and actions of every other lord, it's obvious you're the odd one out and they wouldn't bat an eye if another lord let their peasants rape, pillage, and return with a few butter, bread, and olives.
>>318349129
In the end all that Mattered was getting the water going.
Chosen One and Dweller start cities that grow prosperous, the lone wanderers legacy can be replicated with a water purifier.
>>318349696
>freedom
If liberty prime had advanced AI, it'd probably shoot down maxsons blimp without the institute's help.
>>318349696
Are you implying bullying the weak defenseless masses with laser weapons and power armor to get what you want is manly?
>>318348839
>Finally get tired with fucking around and head to concord to clear up the starter quest out of my log.
>roaming into town with power armor and a plasma gun, blasting faggot raiders.
>vertibird swoops in and drops off a couple of knights.
>raiders and deathclaw get manglefucked while I take a smoke break on the roof.
>>318345067
>Nevermind that my most trusted Paladin in the whole group is a synth and has nothing but loyalty while never having the intentions of betraying the brotherhood, ALL SYNTHS ARE EVIL!
There no organized government in the commonwealth only because institute use synths to fuck up everyone who wants to create it(Fallout 4 was shit, but at least institute politics was less retarded than House one)
Why would he trust a synth?
>>318349696
>Posting Lyons' BoS
>>318349948
If you're not gonna serve the brotherhood then get the fuck out of our way.
>>318350052
>less retarded than House one
House? You mean the guy that explains his thought process and doesn't lie to you?
>>318350212
Yes, the guy who allowed NCR and Legion in his zone of interest
>>318350052
House at least explains his motives to you instead of being a cloak and dagger faggot.
>>318349935
lyons' battalion only survived because they didn't piss off the rest of the BoS enough to be dealt with then instead of later. Liberty Prime wouldn't stand a chance.
>>318349519
This guy gets it
If I can pork it and it doesn't eat my organs afterwords, we're good.
>>318350147
Brotherhood? I'm SYNTH.
>>318350327
Fighting a two front war with non upgraded security bots against a well armed standing army and a fanatical bunch of assholes in football pads. Ok.
>>318345067
>Seeing how this is the same brotherhood of steel members from the Capital Wasteland.
I recall talking to the elder there back in fallout 3 and he says there was a falling out where half the members left. The elder back in Fallout 3 wanted to help and save the wastelanders while the ones who left didn't give a fuck about em. Also the same situation with the other brotherhood leaders away from the capital wasteland. In fact... most of the brotherhood soldiers left that help protect the people from supermutants are really recruits from the capital wasteland.
Well I guess within the Bortherhood... there are good people and then power hungry retards like Maxson.
>>318350147
I'm getting flashbacks to when Fallout 3 came out and all the edgy teenagers thought the Enclave were reasonable patriots looking out for the best interests of American citizens.
>>318350378
The way of Picard. If first contact isn't with your dick, you're doing it wrong.
>>318347872
I'm guessing they axed the Lone Wanderer because they didn't want to piss anyone off by giving him a canon ending. Although the existence of the Brotherhood and the lack of any mention of the L.W at all makes me think that Bethesda just made the original ending of the game canon, the one where you die of radiation even if you had a way to avoid it.
>>318350327
Ah yes, the guy who is milking one dry while playing one against the other with his own forces on in the wings ready to strike.
I bet you think when it's STR>DEX when it's really WIS>INT>STR=DEX
>>318345067
>Why destroy something when you can really use it to your advantage?
That was the Brotherhoods attitude right up till 4
You know who had a all that does not come from us must be destroyed mind set?
The Enclave
>>318350432
He could stop them before they came here
For legion it would be enough to assassinate Caesar, NCR is corrupt shithole so it wouldn't be a problem either
And explain me please, why the fact that House explained his motives makes his politics less retarded?
>>318350147
The BoS gets fucked up by farmers. FARMERS.
>>318350383
You are a big robot.
>>318349390
>Let's kill a species that intentionally has no value or reason to harm regular beings who are just like them because they are differents
See, you say this, but we'll talking about GHOULS....Not Ferals. Even if they may end up being feral, the difference is that some Ghouls don't even like ferals. Why should that be the only reason Ghouls should be wiped out?
They survived, so they're punishment is that they should be eradicated?
Honestly mate, it's no different from the mentality of Hitler and his army.
>>318350697
At least you understood why you were driving a golf club into his skull. The institute is all "do this for MUH SCIENCE!" "No time to explain, MUH SCIENCE!"
>>318350508
>Also the same situation with the other brotherhood leaders away from the capital wasteland
No, it was only the east coast chapter that was divided. The rest of the BoS cut Lyons off. It was only half of HIS soldiers that defected and formed the outcasts.
>>318345573
That was never there core values anon
There core values were to hide underground and horde tech
Like the institute
That's what's fuck up: a more military type Institute was the end goal dream of the Brotherhood By this brotherhood wants it all burn to the ground because "man was never ment to play gawd!" bullshit even though that's exactly what they are doing to the commonwealth.
>>318350660
>They're a terrorist group, basically. Militant, quasi-religious fanatics obsessed with hoarding Pre-War technology. Not all technology, mind you. You don't see them raiding hospitals to cart away Auto-Docs or armfuls of prosthetic organs. No, they greatly prefer the sort of technology that puts people in hospitals. Or graves, rather, since hospitals went the way of the Dodo.
Yup. That's how House described the Brotherhood. The BoS in 4 has even less in common with the brotherhood in fallout 3. They would've taken over the institute not blow it up.
>>318345067
>Why did the Heir of the Maxson name whose bloodline founded the brotherhood, come lead a branch of the brotherhood who went rogue
well he probably got it naturally, brought back in the outcasts, put them in command positions, let the balance of power fix itself while still keeping the useful traditions of testing and taking in dirty wasters
>>318348478
If they're friendly and willing to cooperate with us, why the fuck wouldn't I make some form of attempt to accept them? Because they're not me? I don't get your reasoning.
What would have been really funny is if you found out Maxson was a synth. What would have happened then? Offed himself or decided that synths aren't so bad?
>tech that BoS doesn't understand and can be manipulated against them as soldiers and spies
yeah m8, wonder why
>>318350938
The Brotherhood do go out and find things, that's why there are on the east coast in the first place. They also roamed the Mojave and set up camp at helios one until the NCR kicked their asses and forced them underground
>>318350697
>For legion it would be enough to assassinate Caesar
If he had an employee of the courier's quality and it was most prudent to do so, he might have. With his current supplies, he had to be a bit more shrewd.
>NCR is corrupt shithole so it wouldn't be a problem either
You don't slay a cow for shitting in the river. House took it over to a field and started planting flowers with it, feeding it, the milking it.
>>318345067
We lost countless lives saving the wasteland from poor-quality water full of radiation. It might have cost us the functionality of a giant war robot that could have pretty much ended the Legion and let us conscript pretty much everyone into the BoS, or punch the Pitt in the Dick. It might have apparently cost us Elder Lyons and depending on when I'm saying this, my first waifu nanny Sarah, but it seems our carebear "let's actually help people instead of being army jews" philosophy is finally paying off.
>Hey BoS did you know you can purify water using a little concrete, a few screws, a bit of copper and a power generator?
>Moments later.
I also like to think of Maxson's negotiation to bring the Outcasts back into the fold went like this:
>Are you going to stop being sad sacks of shit?
>Yeah
>Alright we're back in.
>>318351143
In Fallout 4's glorious quest styles you have:
two speech options that have him kill himself and put the Captain of the Pywed in charge. The captain would still have the kill them all MO and nothing would change short of who gave orders
two speech options that keep him in charge but he is still all "fuck the Railroad, Fuck the Institute" and the game goes on like you never discovered that plot twist.
>>318351143
He probably would have killed himself like danse. He truly believed his own bullshit. There was no debate in his mind.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=87US9AXNMME
This one conversation has more substance than anything Shaun tells you.
BoS Plan to save humanity in the Post-Apocalypse
>Acquire Technology
>Prevent anyone else having technology.
>????
>The world is saved.
>>318351168
Pretty much this
Synths are just too dangerous to let them live
>>318351312
A gorrillion water purifiers over one mega one that is already in the works. Hmm tough choice.
>>318351221
When I said Hide I meant more like the Institute where they just don't give a fuck topside short of owning the best tech in the land.
>>318345067
Is this the kid in the citadel from 3?
>>318351495
But as easy as he rolled on Danse? That torture lady in Covenant had more strength than him.
>>318347743
Brotherhood of Steel do not perceive synths as human, or self conscious beings. They solely consider them as technology gone rampant and used for a bad cause.
Your argument doesn't make any sense from their perspective when they do not consider them on the same level of humans. To them synths aren't any different from other technology, despite being very advanced as such. There is also the added belief that no other group in the waste should have access to more, or otherwise better technology than the Brotherhood.
>>318351495
Oh samefag, man Obsidian was good at writing a lot of the time.
>>318351480
Sarcastically wave a pistol in front of his face for him to take
Shoot him on the spot
Talk it out
Hate Newspapers
>>318351168
By that logic they shouldn't use half the tech they have acquired over the years
>>318351312
>army jews
>went from helping others to only helping themselves
Jews indeed.
>ended the Legion
irrelevant to any of the goals or near future plans of the brotherhood.
>let us conscript pretty much everyone into the BoS
They didn't need liberty prime for that. They didn't try.
>or punch the Pitt in the Dick
A smart person might attempt to take over an operational steel mill, cut the raider/slaver power, and some ammo production. The brotherhood isn't a smart person.
It's to much to even joke they had good ideas in mind.
>>318351504
I don't think a toaster will bring about nuclear armageddon anon. Well, except for one, but he's in some science crater.
>>318351554
10,000 easily built water purifiers that even the smallest community can set up themselves with LITERALLY no help from anyone and hardly anyone dying.
1 Purifier project that meant that most BoS members in Fallout 4 weren't members of the BoS in 3, because most of the ones in 3 are fucking deaaaaaaaaaaaaaad.
Also this isn't a discussion about the purifiers as much as demonstrating why the BoS might be very willing to make a 180 reactionary return from their previously more helpful and not-being-fucking-jews philosophy. If you want a different one there's the fact that Maxson's young and brash, the Institute is a genuinely capable threat that they need serious resources to counter, and the fact that Synth fakers are everywhere so better not let any of them have any of that dangerous tech that's actually inferior to their own existence.
>>318351504
This. Saving technology for themselves is not saving the world as they so preach.
What would have doing that is essentially what they were doing in Fallout 3, ONLY TO also grab technology that may seem harmful.
>>318351682
Life is easy when you let a book do your think for you.
>>318351956
Danse's commander literally died storming that stupid airforce base thingy, and Dance was apparently a trader in rivet city and a scav for a while, so he is a knight by 3
so would a new elder scrolls be a possibility next year or would it be a bit longer
>>318351943
Yeah I appreciate that it was a far fetched joke to say the least, but a VERY smart BoS elder might have considered the Legion plan (assuming of course they even knew about the Legion, having any facility to re-establish contact with the west or not) Simply because of the same reasons the Pitt would have been a great place to take over: Resources and bodies.
I assume at some point the BoS will have to actually start trying to occupy territory rather than spray-paining "NO MUTANTS ALLOWED" on old concrete forts that seem to be specifically built for them and only them.
But this is fallout, so of course fucking not. It's going to be 3056 and everyone is still living in corrugated cardboard houses and curiously well built ruins.
>>318352187
2 years probably
>>318348027
>not ALL Ghouls are total brain craving zombies
Exactly. Some could even be classified as modern day saints because they not only want to completely make amends with regular humans and live side by side peacfully, they even want to find cures for their feral brethren, or at LEAST take them somewhere where they cant hurt anyone.
Wonder if Joshua or whatever his name was was able to make a home for them in the stars....
>>318352119
Eh 10 years is decent time, kind of a cock slap since most paladins are grown ass men before they become knights. What's even more of a cock slap is becoming a knight in less than a day because you're useful.
>>318345067
Fallout 4 factions
Brotherhood: Enclave 2.0
Institute: "we are evil because we are successful and work privately rather than in public, it's a commentary you see"
Railroad: Peta the Robot edition
Minutemen: the biggest bitches that will put up with anything
>>318352308
They came back and helped people after NV, primm or novac I think. But, how would they land the space ship?
>>318352345
He was a Knight by the seige of the final enclave base because he had his own squad moving for the common wealth by the time his commander died in broken steel, just one of those random fucking knights you see eat total shit, good job danse, real leader you had
>>318352405
Correction! MinuteMAN as in you, just you and only you. You are the errand bitch, ahem I mean General.
>>318352345
yeah that was fuck up.
Hell you could be a Paladin in as little as a week if you just push though the BoS quest line hard enough.
But again they have an ELDER that's exactly 20 years old so they are already fuck up in so many ways.
>>318348478
Well, we did it with niggers and sand people, and look where we are now....
This is what house says with the cut content restored.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WdEPn5FZAo8
I know, the uploader fucked up bad.
NEVER 5GET TENPENNY TOWER!
WORSE THAN 911!
>>318351661
Yes.
McCready and Madison Li are also in it
ITT: Fallout3fags who only ever saw the cuddlyfluffbunnies that were the exiled BOS of the Capital Wasteland.
They were exiled for being shit at being BOS.
Now an actual BOS leader comes around, and all these little pussies are shaking in their boots, that their qt3.14waifufaction isnt actually a bunch of pussies anymore.
Get fucked, losers. This is the real BOS.
>>318352308
The thing for me is that I literally don't see Ghouls as any different from humans, except its slightly easier to tell which ones you should immediately shoot on sight.
Hell, humans are worse, raiders don't have the excuse of rotting brains.
>>318351661
Yes.He's in his early 20s in Fallout 4
>>318351753
>They solely consider them as technology gone rampant and used for a bad cause.
Clearly that's not the case for the synths that you have as companions, while also the many Synths the Railroads have helped out.
It's just like a ghouls argument. There's a MAJOR difference between a Ghoul, and a Feral Ghoul. There's a difference between a Synth, and Synth that is given orders.
Again, Not all Synths seek the destruction of humanity and just want to establish what free will is.
Curie for instance is a Mr. Handy, given life to into a synth. But as you see, her sole intention is NOTHING harmful but living her life as a "human" and studying science. Wow, that's so evil right?
Danse, Been the Brotherhood serving them for however long he was made into a synth, stayed loyal and helpful. He helped them get to the position that they are while even using The Sole Survivar help. Essentially, Danse isn't anymore different than a regular BoS soldier...Yet the only difference is that he's a synth...Oh no, that must instantly means he wants to kill us.
It also really begs the question of how the use of robots in this series is also questionable. Clearly the BoS use them as well...but they are ALSO a threat towards humanity. They're kept alive because they can be used as tools don't have free will? That's bullshit.
>>318352631
>McCready
I just talked to him for the first time today and I had no idea it was that little shit from Little Lamplight.Now I can finally axe the fucker
>>318352229
>But this is fallout, so of course fucking not. It's going to be 3056 and everyone is still living in corrugated cardboard houses and curiously well built ruins.
Betheda will never ever learn fallout is about the passage of time and politics since the fall of the bombs, not being mired in a 10 years after the bombs story.
>>318352696
The difference between a ghoul and a feral ghoul is time, that's it.
Even if someone isn't feral, there is absolutely no way to know how long it is until they go feral.
Quarantine is the only option, if you want them alive.
>>318350938
You're wrong, though.
The Brotherhood hoards tech because they fancy themselves the protectors of mankind from the dangers of technology. They always have, in every game except 3.
Which is exactly why they hate the Institute.
Don't say shit without knowing better.
>>318345067
Maxson is son of Maxson
Who is the son of Maxson. Etc. This has been the same since Mariposa.
The question to ask is why the high elder is on the east coast
>>318352469
Personally I think they landed somewhere in the middle of the Old Nuclear Test site and then just walked back. If they hit the right place they might have found the remains of one of the fake towns the US built to test the blast effects, so it could be a pretty sweet deal.
>>318352787
>not paying him 200 cap pittance to make him toil at your farm in sanctuary
shit, the kids over at the raider camps got it better than that
>>318352787
>Who's the Mungo now, fucker?
>>318352875
He was sent off by the west coast council IIRC to accompany Lyons and man up and get first hand experience of the BoS and how they operate.
>>318352696
They do consider your companions the same case though, they just don't act on it because it would be a conflicting design choice. The brotherhood makes comments about you having Nick and Hancock with you, and they also spew hate against Hancock if you bring him with you to Diamond City.
This is a compromise or a design flaw of the game at best, it in no way shapes their already defined presumptions as evidenced by them calling you out if you actually do bring one of those companions with you.
>Silver shroud quest
>Suddenly in a comic book game
pretty good
>>318351312
It's not about being able to purify the water. It's about not needing to. It pretty well scrubbed a large portion of DC or radiation. Reminder that radiation is much different in fallout than in the real world as well. So basically in Fallout it will linger despite as stated in new vegas that a cave can purify it well enough to drink.
>>318351526
Once the Institute is dead I don't see any reason not to let synths who don't pretend to be human left alive. As well as special cases like Curie. Gen 1/2 synths must die no matter what. Gen 3, however are at least 95% human with some cybernetic brain attachments. Without the Institute influencing their actions they should be afforded the same social status as non-feral ghouls. Fuck coursers though. Kill em all.
>>318351953
The other appliances killed that toaster.
So what did the vault dwellers/courier get up to after the games anyway? They could easily have led any faction. Did they just keep heading into more dangerous parts of the wasteland? Or maybe someone started collecting them?
>>318352646
Retard who isn't reading the thread. We know the east is different from the west, we're discussing their radical ideological flip and the reason behind refusing to getting a bit more settled and adapting while finding a bit of western pragmatism.
The South West BOS had their separation lead to a faction that developed into something else while the east simply becomes the west.
>>318352945
"Hey MacReady, you got a pair of gloves on you?" No, why? "Too bad, that razorgrain isn't going to harvest itself."
>>318352696
Miss Nancy, not Mister Handy.
>>318352696
There is an undercurrent threat to humanity that a slightly less braindead writer would have made use out of. I was shocked when they didn't at least try to make this argument against Synths but then again writing is hard and who wants to pay for good writers?
Okay, so Synths aren't bad, inherently Ghouls aren't bad inherently, why hate them? Because there's a good chance that in the latter case we could all end up like them and in the former: There's a pretty good chance they could replace and wipe out humanity.
The BoS, for right or wrong are definitely invested in keeping humanity going in this crazy, mixed up world. Humanity. not Humans. Not sentient beings, the actual concept that makes people people. Ghouls escape this humanity through immortality and looking like shitcakes. Synths escape it by looking like a human but inherently not being human.
Imagine you're raised all your life being told that you exist as the weapon of Humanity to keep its existence going against a million trillion threats. You're introduced to a mechanical facisimilie that is immune to most of the threats against humanity, looks human (but isn't) and would have a pretty good chance of getting rid of us if it got big enough and decided it felt like reenacting the Matrix.
You'd probably go full retard crusade too. However, nobody in Bethesda bothered to explain the BoS standpoint beyond "HATE ROBOT".
>>318353097
F3 Vault dweller is MIA after both Lyons died. As for NV, I'm pretty sure F4 pretends it doesnt exist except for one random obscure terminal entry.
>>318352631
Also Dr. Zimmer is not in the game for some reason although he's referenced in Institute terminals as the head of SRB.
I guess it's because he can be dead although you'd think the institute would know that by now.
>>318353182
>not modding in potatoes and a british flag
>not throwing cait in the field with him too
>not watching from the caste battlements with Codsworth pouring you a fresh cup of tea
>>318353438
HATE MACREADY
>>318350938
BoS one and only goal is to protect the world from dangerous tech so the world doesn't destroy its self again.
4 fucked a lot up but BoS was written closer to 1/2's BoS
>>318353387
Zimmer is still on a mission outside the commonwealth to capture priority synths
>>318352875
The West Coast Brotherhood is fucked, the Eastern BoS is probably much stronger now.
>>318352863
That's only fine, Quarantine them. Give them there own little place, let them live.
They don't HAVE to die because they're not the same as smooth skins.
>>318353438
>What's on TV today, Codsworth?
>Zulu Dawn, mum.
>Zulu Dawn Marathon, 24/7/365
>>318353438
Having Whitechapel Charlie there throwing rocks at them
>>318353337
It's for the best that Bethesda completely ignores the proper fallout games honestly. Easier for obsidian to do proper plots when they don't have to write around how bethesda might handle the NCR or legion.
>>318350697
>For legion it would be enough to assassinate Caesar
If you kill Caesar, he outright tells you you probably did more harm than good, and that the Legion will be out for vengeance in the name of their dead god. If anything, killing Caesar would just magnify Legion efforts towards completely undermining and destroying House. Vulpes and Lanius together would level New Vegas.
>>318352863
>Don't say shit without knowing better.
says someone that has clearly never played Fallout 1 and 2
They send you to your death in Fallout one and see anyone not in the brotherhood as both a threat and something to be avoided
protectors of mankind bullshit you are trying to sell was somewhat in Tactics and everywhere in 3
>>318353556
inb4 Zimmer is Courser.
At least Toddthesda is going in the right direction.
I look forward to the not shit depiction of the BoS in 2-3 more games!
>>318353727
Worse for New Vegas in the short term, but everyone and their dog says the Legion will collapse in short order after Caesar dies.
>>318353727
>Lanius
>working with vulpes
The only reason Lanius hasn't killed Vulpes himself is because of Caesar. Wouldn't be surprised if Vulpes and most of the Frumentari just decided to fuck off in the event Lanius takes over.
>>318353827
>WTB Canadian Brotherhood Chapter that very politely shoots you in the back of the head for your tech, then apologizes.
>>318353694
Yeah, kinda sad, but heres to Fallout 5 by Obsidian.
>>318353872
it will rip itself apart which if you know history, is worse for everyone nearby, the assasination of Julius fucked with the world
>>318353541
>BoS was written closer to 1/2's BoS
How?
They would never be so open about that shit nor would they burn everything to the ground.
They would totally take over and keep making synths
Ya see, the problem with synths is all it takes is a bit of a tinker and all their free will comes to naught because as machines, they can be reprogrammed to do anything.
You think you can trust something that can do that? Even a psychopath works within the boundaries of their free will, a synth can be the best friend you could ever have, then have programming activate and pull your spleen our your shithole with a coathanger while singing BINGO BANGO BONGO!
At least you'd half expect a Raider hyped up on more drugs than a frathouse to do that.
>>318353729
>They send you to your death in Fallout one and see anyone not in the brotherhood as both a threat and something to be avoided
And in their ending they improved situation a lot
It's like you never played first 2 fallouts and just spout bullshit about evil brotherhood you saw in the NV threads
They are dicks, but not villains
>>318353872
Most of obsidian kids can only understand short term goals. This is why every villain in their game so talkative. They literally needs to be spoonfeeded
>>318350521
If you look at the brotherhood in a "preserving the human race" light of view then it doesnt matter if its right or wrong. Getting rid of ghouls, supermutants, and the possiblity of self replicating machines is in the best interest of man. Anyone that joins with the brotherhood without the pragmatism that goes with it is Edge Enclave
>>318353965
>how
go play 1-2
>they would just keep making synths
just like how they used FEV to keep making super mutants?
fucking retard.
>>318353965
Because of Maxsons 20 year old "gotta prove myself shit" He went from Lyons' police patrols to full on storm nigger. Hell if he had asked the MC about the institute and some dialogue along the lines of "Oh, I'm the director of it now" then there wouldnt have been a problem.
>>318353541
In F1 they send several people to there death and killed whole settlements taking their tech and making it look like raiders did it.
The elders made it clear that they saw the outside world as this nightmare scary place that can't be help
>>318353337
>references the Mysterious Stranger in Shady Sands, the NCR, the Commonwealth, and the Capital Wasteland
>completely neglects to mention that he was in the Mojave
what the fuck
>>318345067
>AI are friends
No, AIs are potentially autistic psychopathic world destroying machines. They'll bulldoze you, your family, and everything you ever loved or cared about if it means maximizing paper clip production for which they were programmed.
In fact the only reason you'd have any sympathy for them is precisely because of the result driven psychopathy of their prime directive, APPEAR as human as possible.
>>318353961
>the assasination of Julius fucked with the world
>implying the senators weren't pigs fattened on the blood of Rome
>implying Caeser didn't do more while he was alive for the common man than half the senate in their entire lives
>implying based augustus didn't do the write thing when he made the senate impotent through kindness and appeasement then have them name him first citizen
im shaking my head at you to be honest laddie
>>318348120
One of those companions is legit evil though
>>318354226
"Oh, I'm the director of it now"
>5 Minutes later
>>318345067
He's butthurt the LW c ucked him with Sarah. That why the LW go struck from the codex and no one talks about him.
>>318354315
Bethesda don't like no one stepping on their zany wasteland adventures turf.
>>318352945
>>318352973
What are the fucking chances of this happening?
>within 20 seconds of each other
Is this some kind of inside joke that I'm not getting? I'm shaking.
>>318353872
And House can't deal with a direct Legion onslaught. That's why he props up the NCR in the first place, he needs someone to keep the Legion at bay. Killing Caesar and telling the NCR to fuck off would damn the region, since the Legion would march in, raze the city, then disintegrate.
>>318354315
I couldn't give two shits about mysterious stranger.
I give multiple shits about Imaginary Motorcycle Grenade Man.
>>318354195
>go play 1-2
I have, have you?
>just like how they used FEV to keep making super mutants?
They had FEV strains anon
They were trying to find bio weapon ways to kill them.
>>318348120
theres literally an entire town of people who hate all synths except for the one they like
>>318353965
>They would never be so open about that shit nor would they burn everything to the ground.
As a group I could imagine them blowing up tech they didn't think needed to exist for anyone
A good elder would take the technology and cut synth production.
>>318354461
I was shocked too, hivemind I guess.
>>318348172
the anchorage dlc of f3
>>318347872
>maxson likes sarah
>grew up listening to the lw plough her every night
it's probably half his fault to begin with
>>318354402
True. The institute is all cloak and dagger for no goddamn reason. Just set up a link to the outside world and operate that way. But since no one knows anything about them Maxson wants to purge them all. Shit, why couldn't Dr. Li have told them about what they do there?
>>318353234
There is a comment from maxxon that literally says this in the BoS line that you had to dig in conversation for. He mentions that machines with the ability to self replicate wouldnt be far fetched from the synths we see today and are unacceptable for the survival of man. I agree with your point that this should have been more in the forefront.
Everyone focuses on the confiscation of toasters and lightswitches so much and not the endgame of the BoS, which is the survival of the human race regardless of the cost. The BoS isnt right or wrong, they believe their actions will be justified by the result.
>>318352945
>>318352973
>Jacksonmind
>>318354053
>Synths can be reprogrammed to do anything
>They can be good, but some how in some way, they can be used for evil
Anon, that's literally no different than what humans are in this series. All it takes is a hit of Jet, or some manipulative way of meaning to convert somebody into doing something.
>>318345067
Maxson and Kellog both feel like they are player characters in all honesty.
Maxson is the good karma PC and Kellog is the bad karma PC
>>318354778
>literally no different
It's vastly different.
>>318354664
That doesn't excuse his complete and total destruction of the Institute. I can understand them destroying Robotics and the SRB, but not Advanced Systems or the Biomech campus.
>>318354634
>Dr.Li
>Gets all butthurt because BOS wants her to rebuild Liberty Prime.
>Goes to work for Institute who are literal bodysnatchers out to destroy human race.
>MFW you cant have her thrown in the gorilla tank.
>>318354461
>>318354582
great minds think alike
>>318354824
Maxson no, Kellogg yes. That's the whole point of the Kellogg memory thing
>>318354824
>Maxson is the good karma PC
>literally kill everything that's not even a threat to us high powered tech heads.
kek
>>318354849
no it isn't. If it was, you wouldn't ever bother arguing with people.
>>318354315
>>completely neglects to mention that he was in the Mojave
F4 takes place like a year after NV. how would he know?
>>318354342
thats what im saying, the world would have been better if Julius stayed in power, he was the first major world leader in history that seems to have cared for the lessers more then the highers, he also never became an anime girl, not that i wouldnt stick my dick so far in nero she would need her twin king arthur to take it out
>>318354971
It takes place six years after NV.
>>318354883
Yeah, even in 3 she was a total bitch, but she was a resource to the BoS, but nah lets not get schematics of the place or an inside scoop. Just build our robot. Still, Prime crushing the head of that behemoth was pretty sick.
>>318354634
Because the entire plot was thrown together in such a ham fisted way.
none of it makes sense and none of it adds up because they all just deiced "hey you gotta choose"
what's truly funny is that these kinds of issues should have aroused in Skyrim and Oblivion but never did while in Fallout 4 the fact you are told you are becoming the Director should open doors to end all hostilities with all the groups but nope, they want you to kill everyone that's not them. Except the Minutemen who really should be the most against all three groups.
>>318349153
One of the captains talks about them and half ass confirms their destruction.
>>318345067
Synths are abominations though. Machines should never be allowed to believe they are human.
>>318353965
the brotherhood on the east coast doesn't have to deal with the ncr or any powerful faction aside from the institute
>>318354961
>no it isn't. If it was, you wouldn't ever bother arguing with people.
>you replied to me therefore you're wrong
That's completely absurd.
>>318350558
You mean Kirk,, you uncultured PLEB.
>defending Liberty Prime
>Maxson shows up in full power armor
>one hit him with Super Sledge
>his body disappears forever
>>318354409
what happened to her anyway?
>>318354596
>canon LW took the cyborg perk
>maxson has hated cyborgs, naturally hates synths, and only barely tolerates robots now
He also loses his shit when he hears this song. Reminds him too much of LW.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Arq-340mIUQ
>>318355186
This game ugh, I'm having so much fun playing it, but the writing. Goddamnit why did I ever come here? I could have been blissfully ignorant of all this shit, ah well, heres to the next Fallout being Obsidian.
>>318354869
I rationalized it as that level of technology was dangerous for anyone to have. He wanted to wipe self replicating robots and the technology to do so off of the map. Most of the institute tech was modeled in the direction of synth creation.
>not equipping the populace with Enclave parts and blowing the prydwen the fuck up
MUTIES GET OUT REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>318345067
>he's a filthy synth sympathizer
>>318350743
Swords to plowshares, and vice versa.
>>318354973
I caught autism, skimmed your post, and thought you were suggesting the assassination of Gaius Big Dick Caeser (Julius) was good.
>>318355408
MIA after both Lyons died.
>>318355408
Became head of the EC BoS and then died in battle.
>>318355537
what quest lets you destroy the brotherhood and the railroad?
>>318355301
>the brotherhood on the east coast doesn't have to deal with the ncr
there was no NCR in fallout 1
They were secretive as fuck in fallout 1
>>318345067
they ruined him with the haircut and his young age.
>>318354596
>>318355413
>Maxson grew up looking up to Sarah
>Probably had a crush on her while he was a kid and she was a woman
>LW giving her deep dickings every night is probably in his mind somewhere
>>318355537
>That fucking ship.
>Feel awesome sense of accomplishment as it lifts off ground.
>"Uh, hey guys, might want to turn..."
>"Sooner rather than later will help..."
>"FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF"
>>318355218
My Synth Waifu would do more for me than most of the people I come across in the game.
Junkies, psychopaths, morally bankrupt mercenaries...
Humans aren't so special.
>>318355694
there were organized super mutants that followed the master in the first game
Here's my idea for a fallout New York.
>But New York got hit by so many nukes it's completely gone!
Here's how I'd do it.
>New York was only MOSTLY destroyed.
>The enclave was turning Ellis Island into a secret base
>They got Vault-Tec and General Atomics as contractors for the general parts of the base and self defense capabilities with the goal of being completely self sufficient for OVER it's max occupancy limit.
>Have materials/technology transported from Area 51 to turn the Island into a short range mobile station like some sort of super Prydwen, but not nearly as able to travel at the same speed as the dirigible.
>Lady Liberty turned into an anti-missile platform/beacon but incomplete and waiting on more materials/software from the French who were taking it by ship to the US.
Now for the area itself and the people.
>Ellis Island is of course Enclave
>Lady Liberty could only take down a small number of missiles and the upper parts of New York got nuked. Several landed just off shore and made a small tidal wave where the irradiated water flooded the metro system.
>The French Fleet arrived after decades suffering through several battles. The commanding ship of the fleet suffered a core breach and the entire ship of that crew were turned into ghouls. Most of the other ships were safe. After arrival, the enclave attempted to kill them for being ghouls. They said fuck you, broke into the metro system, then broke into the sewer systems to drain the flooded areas and fortified them with what they could take from their ships.
>There was a guy in New York who bank rolled a lot of Vault-Tec stuff. His price was his own personal vault with ALL the best stuff beneath his business tower. On the day the nukes dropped he took in as many people as he could. Once some of the radiation cleared he opened his vault and attempted to retake the city.
>Combination of several other groups who survived formed a sort of government and try to make do.
>>318345067
you're a little shit you know that?
>>318355832
Only if Lady Liberty is transformed into a literal rocketship, and fired into space.
>>318355784
A sex machine is not the same thing as a human.
>>318355949
nah dude she's gotta be like, liberty prime 2.0 with a sexy lady voice and a massive flamethrower that comes from the torch
>>318355080
Still, That's a really short time
>>318355784
I love how they made Eve ugly on purpose to reflect the fact that she's one of the first synth which is supposed to look like humans
>>318355832
oh and one last thing.
>those last 3 groups are all "gangs". All are actual factions distinct from raiders.
>>318355949
She's much larger than Liberty Prime so I couldn't justify making her too functional other than anti missile defense and maybe a laser from her torch.
>>318355784
https://vimeo.com/12915013
>>318355746
Scratch what I said earlier. The Lone Wanderer had an enormous effect on this game's story.
To this day, Maxson wakes up in a cold sweat after a dream where a Winterized t-51b armored man scoops Sarah off her feet, plants a kiss on her lips, turns back, and winks at young maxson.
It's probably canon the the LW stole his Grognak the Barbarian comic book in his room too.
>mfw someone puts 10 in any special from the start
Holy shit nigga, haven't you heard of bobbleheads and equipment with bonus stats?
>>318355812
I am so sick at you retards that just spew bullshit without even playing the games
Or hell you don't even try to fact check anything
>It was from the Vault-Dweller that the Brotherhood subsequently learned of the Master's mutant army and its plans to forcibly convert the surviving human population into Super Mutants.
They knew jack shit about the Supers short of losing a patrol to a mysterious force before the MC came along
and hell they argued if they should really even get involved, they were debating about just letting the mutants do their shit while they did theirs
fuck man why does it seem the Fallout threads bring out the dumbest people here.
>>318345067
>I mean, it's fine he doesn't like synths, but destroying every single one as if they're ALL evil is dumb as fuck.
That's exactly what a filthy synth would say. Why don't you go liberate some vacuum cleaners instead of shitposting on /v/?
>>318346782
Underrated post.
>>318356216
>look at me I'm a min-maxing faggot
>be in Sanctuary
>Synths suddenly attacking my settlers
>I just came back from the institute
>I'm all good with them so the Synths aren't hostile to me
What the fuck Shaun
>>318356216
Legendary leather leg of charisma. Maximum DT of 3. That +1 Charisma sure is worth sacrificing like 20 dt.
>>318356186
>Implying that LW isn't Mean Joe Green, and Maxson isn't the kid.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xffOCZYX6F8
>Coke is Nuka Cola
>Towel is used condom, just used to fuck Sarah Lyons
>>318356216
Im lost why you want max in any of them
Seems the best perks stop at 6 in any talent and the level ten ones are not good.
Some can be fun but they are not good talents to invest in.
>>318356186
>Maxson finally is old enough to wear Power Armor like a real man of the Brotherhood
>He can finally impress Sarah who he's looked up to for so long
>A 10 in everything Vault Dweller comes in the most pristeen T-51B power armor in comparison to his inferior T-45d and snatch his love away
MAXSON CONFIRMED KEK
>>318356359
Happened to me at The Castle. Also, apparently some settlers are synths and that will stop you from getting 100% happiness. Seriously Shaun? Fuck off trying to overthrow my shit. Keep your sleeper agents away.
>>318356461
>Nuclear Physicist says hello.
>>318355976
>sex machine
I said waifu, not sex machine.
>>318356137
My responsibilities are for the minutemen and other synths to take care of now. By the end of the game I did enough things for enough people for a life time.
>>318345067
Completely unrelated, but what ethnicity do you guys think Maxson and Danse are? They both look immensely middle eastern to me.
>>318354520
Did you even play the game? He gets a pass because he is obviously not a human. It's the same reason they don't get mad at the robots.
>>318356430
Sarah's room is next to Maxsons. Every night he has to force himself to sleep while he hears the pounding in the next room as bits of sheetrock fall from the ceiling on his face.
>>318356510
>brotherhood exclusively uses t-60 now
this lore is so deep
>>318356216
It doesn't matter in FO4, you can go way beyong 10
here's the BoS in a nutshell:
initially, on the west coast:
>incredibly insular, no recruiting from wasteland
>arrogant hoarding of technology
post FO1:
>Master's defeat creates power vacuum for the BoS
>as the NCR expands, a faction within the brotherhood argues that the only way to properly rebuild the Old World and stop NCR supremacy is through recruiting wastelanders and sharing technology
>West Coast elders send this dissident faction eastward to crush super mutant remnants
>Midwest BoS forms when they crash land in Midwest US and form their own power base (current status unknown)
post FO2:
>West Coast BoS refuse to admit their founding principles are absolutely shit
>eventually wage war with peaceful, Vault Dweller approved NCR
>despite superior tech, they get their shit kicked in for the most part and begin losing power and holdings
>Second detachment BoS chapter desperately sent eastwards to find Midwest BoS, accidentally reach Pittsburgh instead
>once again, this isolated chapter similarly deviates from shitty West Coast values
post Tactics:
>Under the Warrior's guidance, the Midwest BoS dominate midwestern US with benevolent/traditional rule (good or bad canon in dispute)
post FO3:
>Lone Wanderer transforms East Coast BoS into a successful and good natured force (just like the Warrior does with the Midwest BoS)
>However this turns out to be all for nothing when the Lyon dynasty dies out
>East Cost BoS once more becomes the underling of the decrepit West Coast, resuming their old shitty values pretty much out of nostalgia when another Maxson takes power
post New Vegas:
>McNamara's Mojave BoS is already sick of the failed Lost Hills elder's shit especially after Elijah turns out to be a massive asshole
>Under the Courier's guidance the Mojave chapter reaches a joint truce with the NCR and Independent New Vegas (hopefully canon)
>this effectively severs them from the absolute shit West Coast/Lost Hills BoS
>>318354195
>just like how they used FEV to keep making super mutants?
anon they had Super mutant cadavers at their base and were testing the FEV on vermin such as mole rats.
>>318356531
It's because you didn't Press (E) to comfort him, before you got in the cryotube.
>people actually find nothing wrong with kidnapping people, murdering them and replacing them with robots
And "Father" is just an overrated vault overseer who has no moral foundation, no family values and showed that he fundamentally lacks empathy for humanity. He called the death of his own mother "collateral damage" and continued to employ a ruthless mercenary who killed god knows how many people in the wasteland including his own fucking mother.
The brotherhood of steel is completely justified in wiping out the institute (and railroad), neither group has the capability to keep their robots in check (there are plenty of in-game cases of robots going off the reservation and murdering people).
>>318356708
continued (ignore inaccuracies in attached pic)
post FO4:
>now the power and ideology dynamic is geographically reversed - the West Coast BoS has faltered under the NCR's and New Vegas' popular power grabs, creating a new traditional narrative conflict of good vs bad
>now there is a powerful, shitty traditionalist Maxson leadership on the East Coast
>and a weakened but "correct"/Old World BoS faction on the west coast (mojave chapter)
>NOTE: this is only true if writers decide to let the BoS survive in Fallout 4, and let the old Lost Hills chapter get crushed by NCR and replaced with reformed and allied Mojave faction, or simply stay canonically weak and useless
Now what does this mean? Right in the middle of the geographic/ideological Divide, we have the Midwest Brotherhood, fate unknown. Will they ally with the "good" yet weak West Coast, the powerful yet arrogant East Coast, the Enclave remnants in the North, or will they carve something new, an independent, "Old World" Mid West?
We might even see the NCR, Legion or Minutemen influence the Midwest.
>>318352624
>If one day humanity meets another species with the same values and a similar way of living
>same values and a similar way of living
Nick is the main reason why I don't want to kill ALL synths
>>318356708
>keeping Mcnamara in the hidden valley
>not kicking him the fuck out
It's like you WANT Veronica to be the snowflake to get them supplies
>>318356942
That's a bad reason because he's literally one of a kind so there are no other synths like him.
>>318356902
Midwestern BOS could probably take on the rest of the US combined. Their power level at the end of Tactics is insane.
>>318356942
Sturges is pretty alright for a very minor character too.
>>318356552
Nuclear Physicist is so/so anon
The best guns in the game don't use Radiation and you get swimming in cores to the point that extra 25%/50% is worthless
and tossing them like grenades is even more fuck all stupid
Again, I can see fun in that last rank but it's worthless
>>318356942
As soon as I saw that he was a synth I tried to blow that abominations head clean off.
BoS may be borderline fascist, but in terms of the lore and history of the games, they are 100% correct. From the Great War, to the Master, to President Eden and Richardson, to the Institute synths, technological capacity being abused by small minorities of nefarious or misguided individuals is constantly threatening to destroy humanity or rip apart the small societies they have cobbled together. Even Ulysses in NV shows what one determined and delusional fool can do with access to some sophisticated technology. The only problem with the Brotherhood in Fallout 4 is that Maxson goes on this rant about souls and loving mothers and all that garbage, when in reality that is not what should be important.
Danse should be executed because he's a synth, and he is presumably under the control of the institute. Does he have a kill switch? Does he have a direct data feed to the institute? He is an enormous security risk. The Brotherhood has been INFILTRATED, and Maxson should probably say something along the lines of "the lines between Danse's personal characteristics and his programming are blurry, but in the end the Institute likely controls his actions, has access to his memories, and the fact that he may be a genuinely good person and genuinely ignorant of his identity doesn't matter. he needs to be terminated."
I like that the BoS returned to their roots, although I don't remember them devoting resources to just murdering super mutants in fo2. The only real problem is the way Maxson is characterized. His decisions have a fiery spiritual passion underpinning them it seems. They should be cold, and calculating. He should be reluctant to executre Danse, instead he seems like he's fucking wet with the thought.
>>318356704
Yeah I hate it too
>T-51b is the pinnacle of armored infantry technology
>NUH UH NOT MY T-60 THAT WAS MADE DAYS BEFORE THE GREAT WAR
>all these synth apologist
Holy shit this place really has been taken over by reddit and tumblr. I really hate neo /v/
>>318357069
>Implying I'm not jetpacking over people, dropping cores like tiny nukes.
>>318356510
>A 10 in everything Vault Dweller comes in the most pristeen T-51B power armor in comparison to his inferior T-45d and snatch his love away
Ah! That's too perfect. He finally steps into his t-45d after years of training tougher than every other recruit because he needs to be better than every other recruit.
He runs off to show Sarah in her quarters and her face is flushed red. The lone wanderer is just putting his helmet back on, pristine, white, perfect, rare T FIVE ONE B, and tussles walks out saying "nice armor, kid".
I'm not even mad he's such a shit leader anymore. I feel bad for him.
If I were a drawfag, you'd have this in vivid MS paint illustrations.
>>318357010
I hated Veronica, but McNamara was a better choice than the other guy. That fucker would have led a charge DOWN the damn if he felt like it. The potential "Lyons esque" chapter would be wiped out under him.
>>318357047
even in the endings where the calculator is destroyed, they'd be one of the strongest factions in the continental us
>>318357164
Why do you have that saved?
>>318355214
>and half ass confirms their destruction.
how?
discounting lib prime the midwestern brotherhood was better than the east and west combined
>>318356842
If you'd payed attention to the debate. The OPs deal is that BoS under Maxson order is outright tyrant and stupid because not all Synths have a will to destroy humanity, using Danse as an example of how all Synth are not just machines with the will of murdering. He's not even defending the fucking Institute, the ones that are doing the kidnapping. He's defending the ones that break loose of the Institute's control and use to have free will, not the dumb brain dead drones that are given orders.
>>318357047
They are/have been at war with legion.
Caesar says the have captured bos scripes maybe mid bos havent acted yet.
Imo legion going down if midwester bos goes at it.
>>318357146
I only like Nick and Danse. Pls no bully
>>318357237
Are you implying that McNamara was Lyons-esque?
Your verbiage is confusing me.
Why the fuck is the Railroad so short sighted ? Even if synths are people , it's a very small number compared to the people suffering in the Commonwealth.
>>318348027
#NotAllGhouls
>>318357136
I can't wait for the t-70 PA that was concepted, produced, and deployed while the ICMBs were being exchanged.
>>318357146
>he doesn't want a robot waifu
>>>youtube.com/femfrequency
>>318357158
again fun
Not needed or useful
because if you are to the point in the game where you can build jetpacks you should have already taken the luck and agility perks that make everything a one hit kill in vats and you just keep getting your vats and crits back to kill more
I get it you like it but in terms of making a powerful character early on or ever you never need any special skill above 7, most don't even need to be above 6.
>>318357403
He was willing to negotiate peace and help better the wasteland instead of attempting to finish what they started with the NCR and inevitably get slaughtered again.
>>318357136
t-60 would've been ok if it was like an uparmored retrofit kit for t-45, to bring it up to t-51 standards and avoid obsoleting the remaining inventory. but making it it's own model AND top of the line was fucking stupid
>>318357326
>Danse as an example.
>First action after coming to grips with his Synthness is to murder himself.
First choice again proves to be the right choice.
>>318357326
You cannot guarantee that a 'synth' programmed with 'free will' will not go haywire. The Danse we know is simply a robot who replaced the real Danse at some point.
>>318357547
So, you're confirming that he is a shit-tier BOS leader, and deserves to be purged.
>>318357185
I'm in legitimate tears.
Imagine Maxson with the Just Fuck My Shit Up hair, I think it fits
>>318357269
IIRC, BoS people say "Remember the Citadel!" in combat, so that's one way
>>318357363
Yeah, he also says that scribe didn't even know who the first Maxson was, so that confirms they're still recruiting tribals
>>318357667
We'd better get a DLC where the real Danse shows up, with plenty of anti-synth purging.
>>318357569
"You have served your country well, you have led men to glory and some have died under your command. You are the pinnacle of the BoS. But we're blacklisting you now and you will not be remembered for any of that" Gee, I'd like to see anyone take that well.
>>318356842
minutemen letsargego haywire. Might as well kill them too.
>>318357737
"Remember the Citadel!"
Is this confirming that the LW nuked the Citadel in Broken Steel?
>>318357668
Sure, he didn't follow the directive, but if he had, Nevada BoS would have ceased to exist.
>>318357668
You are pretty good at jumping at conclusion, mongo.
If you actually played the game, you'd know what happen. THey are ''allied'' with NCR, they do exactly what they want to do. THey confiscate too dangerous technologie for safekeeping. Sometimes they take basic laser and the stuff on the side for themselves, but they are basically harmless.
>>318357771
He was a good soldier, to the end.
He died in the act of destroying an enemy of the BOS.
Anyone who spared him is a Synth Sympathizer, and must be purged.
Synth Sympathizer...
Synthesizer?
>>318345067
there are people on /v/ RIGHT NOW that think synths are humans just built instead of being born and okay despite being able to be programmed on the fly and given what ever ideas,memories,personality some cunt wants.
hail maxson
REMOVE SYNTHyou will never have your own gen 3 synth modelled into what ever vidya waifu you want
>>318356902
>>318356708
You deserve a medal doktor.
>>318357761
I think I should just reiterate this so people get it, the Danse we meet in-game is a filthy fucking robot created by the institute who was implanted the memories of the actual human-Danse who in all likelihood was killed by the institute. The institute does not simply come up with these memories themselves, they take living human beings and harvest their memories for their robot spies.
>>318356902
minesotafag here, wouldn't mind the next game taking place in MN and in a twist ending the enclave are the good guys.
>>318357875
>Implying this is a bad thing.
>>318357906
They do fucking nothing but sit in their hole, while the savages ruin the surface above, they failed as a BOS chapter, and deserve no mercy.
>>318357761there is no real BoS DanseHe was a railroad synth that got a mind wipe and was living in the Capital Wastes prior to 4
>>318354356
Just because he's black?
>>318358004
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h14HvgWTSoA
Sad Synthesia song for synthesizers
>>318357068
is he a synth? IS THAT WHY HE CAN FIX ANYTHING!?
>>318358154
Anon, you seem so deluded as to think BoS was formed to rule the surface or be some kind of superpower. Almost like that Lyon retard wanted to be.
>>318358004
You only make him realize that his thoughts and feelings are his own. Remember the gen 3s are basically just cloned humans.
>>318357667
>You cannot guarantee that a 'synth' programmed with 'free will' will not go haywire
>You cannot guarantee that a 'human' in a 'deterministic universe'/endowed by his creator with 'free will' will not grow up to hang corpses from meat hooks and execute farmers for fun
>>318358026
Agreed. Hail King Lorefag, giver of good information!
>>318356461
Pain Train is 10/10 fun
>2015
>Not charging deathclaws
>>318358126
They could have dumped Danse in the same trashheap that Nick came from.
>>318358135
>MN
>Implying that a New Orleans, Southern Fried Fallout isn't the best choice from here.
>Implying you don't want a Wilted Flower Southern Gentleman follower in a nice suit, smoking, and carrying a Derringer.
Go back to your snow-pile, you're basically Canadian.
Am I the only who can't give a single fuck about any of the faction or the synths? They went so stupidly far with their -muh grey morale- factions that I end up not giving a fuck.
They added so many stupid concept to each faction just to even things out that they all end up being stupid.
BoS wants to protect humanity and hoard technology for no reason whatsoever they also want to burn books that contain no useful knownledge (which is hilarious considering you learn stuff from comic books) and straight racket farmers even though they're rich as fuck.
Railroad recognizes the self awerness and consciousness of synths as worthy of being preserved but also want to save vending machines and gen 1&2 synths
Institute just wants to develop science and technology to help rebuild but kidnap and kill people to do some useless experiments ala Vault-tec , and again, for no fucking reason whatsoeverMinutemen are irrelevant and therefore the best choice
It's like bethesda tried its best to make them all look stupid so that you have a hard time choosing
Fuck this kid, elder maxon is probably the most true member of the brotherhood. He wants to rid the Commonwealth of any dangers to man be it tech, synths, or any sub humans, he's doing what's right, like the brotherhood always should. He also wants to do it so humanity can rebuild itself and allow freedom to live. Ad victorium
>>318358126
He's a Railroad runaway
The scribe says as much because those Synth codes/data you got them was comparing runaways.
>>318358239
ANYTHING
>>318358457
Cascadia. Give it to obsidian. Bam, a better game than fallout 4 already
>>318345067
>How in the hell did this fuckhead become the Elder of this group and completely reimagined everything?
This statement tells me that the only prior game you've played is Fallout 3 and even then you skipped all the dialogue and just followed the map marker.
>>318356842
I sided with the Railroad.
Synths are essentially the new nukes - they are far too diverse and powerful to be removed from Fallout history by 2287. Any attempt to genocide their kind will only entrench humans and synths as mortal enemies, and potentially spell the end of mankind.
Therefore a policy of "disarmament" pursued by the BoS is tantamount to a complete betrayal of their core principles. They will only fail, and the wasteland will be crushed, just like the US was in 2077 after trying to destroy China, the "synths" of the Great War.
By befriending and creating an incredibly powerful political bridge with the synths, the Railroad posits the objectively safest and good natured outcome of the Synth invention - why throw away such valuable technology and establish indemnity with immortal death machines? Instead there will be good and bad synths, balancing each other out through deterrence and preventing the second apocalypse.
>>318358558
where did the synth get its memories from, they were not created out of thinair.
>>318358227
Look are preston's soulless beady eyes. He's just planning something. I know it.
>>318358457
Ahem. Radgators.
DLC trip to Florida. Not just Florida. Fucking Didney Worl.
>>318358535
Railroad would probably try to "Rescue" Drinkin' Buddy, and reprogram him as a Nuka Cola dispensor.
Bunch of useless cunts.
>>318357667
>You cannot guarantee that a 'synth' programmed with 'free will' will not go haywire.
That's like saying you can predict when a human becomes a meth head and starting into murderous rapist asshole.
>The Danse we know is simply a robot who replaced the real Danse at some point.
And did you really have a problem with Danse without even knowing he was a synth?
He didn't even know he was a synth. Did he want to kill you when you actually first met?
Was he loyal to the BoS even though he was a synth?
Did he still have a clear and uncorrupted state of mind he Maxson found out and exiled him from the BoS.
Just because it's a robot, doesn't mean it's automatically evil, just has Maxson's mentality states.
>>318357475
#GhoulLifesMatter
>>318358239
yes. turn off his essential tag and kill him the moment you meet him, he has synth parts on him
Also the Singer at the Third rail, she's a Synth too
And that general dealer in Diamond that is paranoid about synths
and the Mayor
and many of the guards have synth parts
>>318357761
That would be awesome. I couldn't let him live, as cool a synth as he was.
Why can't i kill Nick Valentine after becoming loyal to the Brotherhood? Or at least tell him to go away.
>>318358697
>Not Gatorland
It's like you've never even been to Orlando...
>>318358848
>Not dumping him in an undefended settlement with no beds/crops/defenses/fucking anything.
>>318358736
>>318358339
>well humans are capable of being bad to!
>therefore we should continue to allow these potentially-homicidal robots exist and continue to be made because.... muh feelings!
what is wrong with you people.
>>318357761
>Danse DLC
>>318356842
She's only his biological mother. He never knew her and was raised by someone else. On top of that he's freaking 60 years old. She completely abstract.
>>318358886
Ughh that would be amazing! Imagine radgators like the ones cut from Tactics. Your first encounter is seeing a deathclaw being ripped apart by a group of the fuckers.
>>318358736
Synths can be overridden and reprogrammed though, that right there just makes it really dangerous.
Danse could always not know, but it's possible that Danse could be commanded by some sort of master command.
>>318358820
>the general dealer
Heh.
>>318358736
He DID run away after finding out he was a synth. This was possibly a pre-coded response to give a courser time to get to him.
>>318347593
Way to show you didn't even play that part of the game. The institute doesn't care about the Commonwealth enough to kill every one, they were plenty satisfied with cooperation but some one fucked up and sent a prototype to diamond city that ended up malfunctioning and killing people. The Institute just wants to keep doing their experiments and ensure the security of mankind's future.
>>318359021
http://www.iflscience.com/plants-and-animals/carolina-butcher-croc-stalked-north-america-dinosaurs-arrived
Yeah baby.
>>318356216
You can go BEYOND 10, and become a fucking superhuman.
>>318358683
Talk to Desmona, and Glory at the railroad and the Memory Den people after you join the Railroad.
Many Synths that run away to the Railroad want their minds wipe and get an uploaded new identity.
That's the major purpose of the Memory Den in Good Neighbor, they copy memories from real people and edit them for the synths and upload them in and pretty much dump them somewhere or program them with an urge to just travel away from the commonwealth.
>>318345067
>Brotherhood of Steel are mad and deluded
This was to be expected
>>318359065
I just can't Imagine why they wouldnt have triggered him before when they could have stopped the BoS from ever getting to Boston. [aside from the plot] they could have taken out that airship like nothing!
>>318356902
some extra thoughts:
It's interesting that the idea of an "Old World" reconstruction (e.g Arroyo, best ending for Vault 0, the Divide and independent New Vegas), so coveted by Interplay/Black Isle/Obsidian's writers (and rightly so) sounds very similar to Metal Gear Solid's the Boss' Will - a philosophy of libertarian/anarchistic civilization (often policed by an absolute power, think Yes Man/Outer Heaven) that a variety of powers/characters usually interpret incorrectly, leading to a conflict that the Player Character resolves.
It seems that FNV's Ulysses was "rescued" and converted to Old World ideals when he witnessed the Divide, and the series' protagonists (especially the Courier and Vault Dweller) seem to canonically hold the "true" vision of the reformed United States of America. Groups like the Followers of the Apocalypse, Lyon's BoS and post FNV Mojave BoS also reflect this.
What I'm really excited for is an inXile/Obsidian produced Fallout, centred on the player character (canonically) bringing a Midwest BoS and greater Illinois wasteland towards the Old World philosophy that Lyons and McNamara were heading towards (though McNamara's BoS is of unknown status).
>>318358820
>Everyone is a synth
>Everyone you hate is a synth, every raider you've killed were synths
>Everyone you love is a synth
>You are the Sole Survivor not because you alone lived in Vault 111, but because you are the only surviving man in the Commonwealth
P O E T R Y I T R H Y M E S
>>318359208
so you believe that Danse would willingly upload his memories for a robot to takeover his identity, okay.
>>318359178
Oh anon, I, FUCKING HELL YEAH!
>>318359251
Well in Danse's case he was a runaway, though if they knew of him it'd only be a matter of time to find out which synth he was, I doubt the railroad had the ability to remove their full programming.
>>318356842
Does no one pay attention? I feel like they would since all they do is bitch about it.
He tells you that he only discovered his past a few years after gaining the title of Father
He never knew you or mom existed till he was in his 50s
You know what the worst thing is. Even though the BoS are massive dicks and are completely out of character in F4, it is canon that they succeed. Since in EVERY fucking Fallout game, it's always the case.
>>318359219
But house only had experience with Elijah Brotherhood. Hell, he never knew about the Lyons dynasty.
>>318359065
Execute order 66
>>318359460
>Out of character.
FO3fag detected.
>>318359343
It's improbable. How does Danse feel about ghouls?
>>318359530
BoS is suppose to be tech raiders, I don't see F4's BoS raiding any tech, although they don't seem to have any problems NUKING it.
>>318358683
I think like the memory den, they are fabricated. I double the Memory Den abducts people and pulls their brains out in order to give synths new memories. Actually does anyone know more about this and how the Memory Den works?
>>318358703
Everyone in that game are retarded useless cunts.
>>318348612
>taking jet
only drug i use.. and psychobuff
>>318359607
Oh, so you didn't even play the fucking game then.
>>318359343
Danse was a capital waste land trader that was recruited into the BoS during the events of Fallout 3
He tells you this.
During Blind Betrayal he admits he had dreams in the capital wastes that was the institute.
There was no Danse
just uploaded memories of someone else and he was drop off at the Capital Wastes
>>318345067
>He's such a god damn child
That's the point. Maxon desperately wants to prove that he's better than Lyons and that his ideals were right. Lyons has the destruction of the Enclave under his belt while Maxon has yet to pull off a big win. By destroying the Institute, Maxon has something that he can compare to Lyons to validate himself
>>318359607
I don't see BoS using enclave power armor/weapons either, what's your point?
>>318358978
>These escaped robots that mean no harm and just actually want to know what the world is like is HERESY! IT'S NOT UNDER THE GOOD BOOK OF GAWD! They should die because they're them!
Bethesda wanted to appeal to all the people who thought the white knights of D.C. were garbage, so they tried going back to the F1/2/NV roots
Problem is, Bethesda doesn't get the lore, and Bethesda's writers suck balls
Now, make no mistake, if the western Brotherhood was capable of it, they'd be trampling all over everyone with their superior firepower instead of hiding in bunkers - but they wouldn't be blowing up a bastion of scientific development, from agriculture to energy production, just because they disagreed with its leaders.
>>318358978
If a synth starts fucking shit up you can turn it off. You've got to kill a human, imprison him, or torture them if they do the same.
I'd trust a synth I made and taught before any of you motherfuckers.
Do I think they should still be produced? I'd create, teach, and allow them to fulfill a role in my operation I don't trust humans for with the option to switch roles or pursue whatever learning they want an-
Oh well, I suppose this could be said easier by saying I wouldn't be evil and would help the surface with technology that I respect.
>>318345067
>Why does Maxson exist?
because he's a strawman for conservatism
>>318357547
>and help better the wasteland
Mcnamara didn't cared about the fate of wastelanders or Vegas, he just felt that staying undercover and trying to get a better view of the politics (and also of the NCR communications if you decide to join the brotherhood) was better for the long term.
The fact they don't threaten people into giving their technology in the NCR ending is only because they know the NCR army will go back for them if they fuck shit up, not because they care about the vegas population or anything.
>>318359168
Yea, cooperation, that's what the institute calls sending a synth to represent the institute in the commonwealth's new government meeting and then shooting literally every leader of every faction in the commonwealth that was present, fucking up any chance the commonwealth had of uniting under a single flag.
Sure is cooperation!
>>318345067
When did the Brotherhood turned into an order of tech savvy knights who take technological advancement to almost religiosity like the Hammerites, to a bunch of fascist pricks harassing innocents settlers scrounging off a meager living "If they are not with us, they are against us, intimidate that poor settler village" murdering everything not known to them like ignorant cavemen or peasants during the Black Death, and forcibly acquisitioning technology from everyone.
reminder that by wrecking the railroad you make the robot waifus you whined so much to get unattainable forever
>X6-88 himself says he had no idea Danse was a synth
>Literally a fucking BoS Paladin
>If you spare Danse and keep him around the BoS literally put you on a hit list and fucking scout you like buzzards in the wastes
Danse isn't even a synth is he. Kells set up the ruse just to get rid of him soon as he saw the opportunity.
>>318359709
Because that's tech they already fucking have. The Institute was clearly FULL of other tech besides Synth. Hell they even cleaned out the place, they could've easily assumed control of it, but nope, have to nuke it.
And what did that accomplish? Absolutely fucking nothing, other than making another "Reminiscent of Master's Army"
>>318359837
Since Mariposa.
The real issue with this game is that 90% of the hats in this game make your character fucking bald.
>>318359837
Day 1.
Go back to FO3, kid.
>>318359919
>Because that's tech they already fucking have
>BoS already has Enclave tech
Nah fuck off, no way in hell do you geinunely think Advanced power armor is the same thing as their old pre-war bullshit.
>>318359343
No Glory took X1-45 to the memory Den and they created the identity of Danse from piled memories of other people edited to make Danse.
He was then smuggled to the Capital Waste, switch on, and became a trader in Rivet city.
The Danse you meet is the only Danse like him in any shape or form.
>>318359903
That would actually be a pretty damn good twist. Far above any bethesda writers pay grade, but I can see Kells being butthurt not getting enough attention because of posterboy Danse.
>>318359501
He would've calculated the chance of and predicted a fundamentalist reform after Lyon's death.
>>318359882
Good
robo waifus are still 3dpd. VR waifus and hologram waifus are the only true 2D goddesses.
House realized this.
>>318359882
what?
wouldn't that make it happen for sure?
Also anyone else find it weird as hell that Curie is a ok with killing the Railroad?
>>318359065
>Literally no different from when a Human that can suddenly turn against their own because of a money deal, drug addiction, or some different philosophy he/she agree with.
Question, how would someone actually know that one is a synth if it has perfect image of a regular human?
Second, how exactly would they be able to "reprogram" them when it's not just solely a "machine".
Keep trying though. Because you're doing a horrible job as to why Synth's that don't work for the institute should still be killed.
>>318360089
Kells is just mad that Senpai Danse never noticed him.
>>318359903
No, he's a synth, if you kill him he drops a component.
>>318359837
Wow, this is seeing use already. >>318358026
>>318360217
>how exactly would they be able to "reprogram" them when it's not just solely a "machine".
Do you know what the railroad does?
>>318359954
dude in Fallout 1 they were the Institute they only gave a shit about top side if they had tech they wanted then they just go run and get it and then hide back at base.
Anyone play Wolfenstein the New Order on Fergus' timeline? Remember that Telke chick who used math to predict probability and odds? Guess who I found in the Railroad HQ? Motherfucking P.A.M. gg Bethesda.
>>318345067
If you actually fucked around the Citadel in Fallout 3, you would find out that his mother sent him east to be raised under the tutelage of the respected Elder Lyons, after his father died died during the BoS / NCR war. Elder Lyon died, Sarah Lyon took over, but she died in battle. After that, the east coast BoS changed Elders a lot of time, until the Western BoS appointed Arthur Maxson as the Eastern leader, after he defeated the leader of the Capital Wasteland supermutants and made peace with the Brotherhood Outcasts, at the young age of 16.
>>318349476
Prove a synth isnt concious. Prove your mom has conciousness.
what's his name again?
>>318359668
>Overdrive, Psychobuff, mysterious serum & maybe Med-x for good measure
Literally unkillable death machine
>>318360369
Pops
I love how they fucked up FO3 BoS completely just to appease to people who bitched that it was lore breaking, considering FO tactics did that years before bethesda ever got interested in FO IP
>>318360369
Post
>>318359981
I'm not, I'm just saying they probably have it in their arsenal already.
>>318360369
Rice Krispies
>Brotherhood wants to horde technology and use it for their own ends despite whatever chaos it brings to the lives of people in the wasteland
>Wants to destroy a guy who managed to create robots that are indistinguishable from humans in a world where the transistor never existed.
>>318359837
The Brotherhood's attitude depends on the belief of the person in charge. Jeremy Maxson turned the Brotherhood from a peaceful research and development house back into it's original "Seize Everything Technological" state.
>>318358535
Bethesda's idea of morally grey choice is making all the factions really stupid. Institute is the most halfheartedly evil faction just for the sake of having an 'antagonist' for the first part of the game. If Gen 3 synths are such a problem, then stop making them. If you want to replace people on the surface, do so by not killing innocents for your FEV projects. Capture the teeming masses of dumb shit raiders roaming around.
>>318358650
You blow up the Institute in the RR ending so not sure where you got the idea of that they save technology. To be honest, I have no idea what the railroad is really about outside of m-muh synths. They have the least backbone out of any of the factions and less surface presence than even the Institute. With the amount of bad blood between synths and humans already, no one's going to flock to RR to join up. It's an entirely self-serving organization for muh morals and its going to die as soon as the Institute dies.
>>318360425
A massive armed organization capable of bringing order to the wasteland suddenly gets a glimpse of reasonable thinking? Strange.
>>318360283
>Do you know what the railroad does?
Key words here: "Railroad"
If someone was not a Railroad member, how would one know that someone is a synth and that they can be reprogrammed?
The best evidence is of course, Danse, because literally NO ONE knew he was a synth until one of the scribes snitched by the code.
>>318360594
>"Seize Everything Technological" state.
bout time they grew their balls back.
I don't get, why Institute wasn't able to destroy Railroad before?
Isn't it simple to infiltrate just by imitating "runaway" synth and then destroy them from the inside?
>>318360425
They are still fuck up in terms of original lore
They are pretty much the Enclave now.
>>318358457
>Not wanting a nuclear winter
>Not wanting essentially the only location in the US where you can have two large cities right fucking next to each other in a game, with some kind of warring faction dispute between them
Not him, but twin cities would be perfect for a Fallout game. Especially given how Minneapolis was essentially san jose for the tech and medical tech industries in the 50s, so would logically be an extension of that in Fallout deviated timeline.
>>318354315
i think the ncr ending is canon
>>318360712
Plot anon, plot. If the railroad was destroyed the game wouldnt have its one of three forced fuckfuck choices. And it would be down 3 achievements.
>Go to Greenetech to catch the Courser
>Deactivate him with some codethat I have no idea how or where I acquired
>try to open the elevator/maglocked door
>get stuck in first person after exiting the terminal, can look around and aim but can't use my pip boy or move at all
>happens consistently
>>318360789
>Implying people want Skyrim 2: Nuclear Boogaloo
>>318360635
>>318360716
>>318360425
Btw, I meant FO4 BoS, which is the fucked up version of the FO3 one.
>tfw, in Fallout 5, the institute sends a synth back to pre-war times to destroy the brotherhood before they even start
Before you post, ask yourself if Bethesda wouldn't stoop so low as to introduce time travel into the series.
>>318360637
Deacon tells you that there are rumors of ways to track synths
Some are true some are not but he brings up that leads to a lot of fear and why they are so obsessed with getting to places where people have never heard about synths.
>Being surprised Maxson is fucking crazy
>>318355685
You destroy the Railroad for the BOS, then you piss off the BOS by killing someone and destroy the BOS with the minute men.
>>318360712
runaway synths were getting out through a single contact inside the institute. if patriot was made the institute could've put its own agents in the pipeline sure
>>318360920
And blatantly rip off the Terminator series? They don't have the balls for it, but the retardation? Yes.
>>318360906
Apparently you've literally never been to the twin cities if you think it's empty or there's fucking any mountains.
There are lakes though. And lakes are maximum comfy.
>>318360712
They were a 'nuisance.' Aka. we have no good reason as to why a known organization capable of trafficking almost all escaped synths is allowed to exist especially with a secret base with the password RAILROAD. But why don't you kill all of them when we ask you to. Yeah they could probably have sneaked a Courser or two in. Even if it failed at slaughtering the leadership, it would give the Railroad something think about when they're smuggling every single fucking synth because they're idiotic douchebags.
>>318360712
The doctor there tells you that has been attempted.
Also it's how they lost one of their safe houses
Christ how can you guys not catch this shit?
It's a bad game but fuck man stop giving the other side ammo to laugh at you.
>>318350374
what the fuck are the rest of the BoS going to do? Get ran over by the NCR or retconned?
>>318360929
>Listening to anything from Deacon
Motherfucker I'd take wisdom from a bhramin turd before I ever listened to his ass again. Motherfucker probably lied about his origin story too.
>>318350383
turbo tastic
>Implying Bethesda won't do this with DLC.
>>318347446
>synth din do nuffin
try saying that when the institute replaced you with synth dumb leftist.
>>318352875
His mother sent him east under the tutelage of the respected Elder Lyons after her husband died in battle against the NCR.
>>318361091
Midwest BoS is fucking MIA as far as Bethesda is concerned. West Coast is still being west coast and dealing with NCR.
>>318361089
Then how do they deal with that possibility? Do they have new procedures with dealing with new synths or what?
>>318360712
Father talks about them as if they were gnats on an oxens ballsack. Not worth anything but token efforts.
>>318360425
If they made a choice, stick with it or provide a satisfactory reason for a 180 on ideology.
A terminal in maxsons rule detailing his life as a squire, his interpretation of lyon's ideology and the codex, his wrestling between the two, and finally what made him perform a 180 instead of melding the two ideologies together.
I'll admit, I didn't even speak with maxson in my playthrough, but the best it seems we have to go on is he was keked by the lone wanderer who was a cyborg and now hes
SUPPORT FUNDAMENTALISM
HATE SYNTHS
LYON'S IDEOLOGY?
PEACE (SARCASTIC)
>>318360712
The Institute destroyed several Railroad HQ. Are you even playing the game?
>>318345067
did you know that he had hes scar by fighting a deathclaw as a kid ????????????
So what did the Russkies get up to? I can't imagine them not having power armor and junk.
>>318361304
Some of the posts about him getting keked out of Sara Lyons in this thread are pretty fucking hilarious.
>>318345067
>expecting more coming from a fairly young elder of BoS
then again BoS are technophobic, it's expected.
>>318361215
If you were following the conversation, any of them, you'd see people that disagree with the institute but recognize Synths potential for humanity.
>>318361304
He literally grown up and was raised into a completely altruistic BoS, taught and educated by the elder who made the change himself, and only heard stories/studied the traditional BoS, and yet he choose the latter. That's just lazy story telling.
>The institute is super advanced
>They do not put a remote destruct code in case that their synths become sentient or escape
>>318348457
I like to think the first one is also because the amount of chuckle fucks coming up to them has to be high.
>>318361414
Eh, the US was allied to them before the war. Can imagine that they went the way of the Metro series.
>>318361460
evidence and explaination please
>>318356461
Blitz (Agility 8) makes melee builds way more fun.
>>318361414
Too close to China, probably nuked to fuck.
>>318361463
>Not being able to collect pink flamingos
Why Todd
>>318360929
Anon
How would someone know, someone else is a synth if they look exactly like a real human with no different personality?
You say Deacon tells you, but here's the thing. Who out there in this post-apocalyptic world would be searching for a android besides the Institute (who's only stationed in Boston) and the Brotherhood (who was completely oblivious to knowing a synth was in their ranks the entire time)?
Better yet, Who would think the android is automatically evil when it's intentions are only neutral? (besides the Brotherhood)
>People whining that bethesda has shit writing
>after each fallout game, there are years of arguins on /v/ about factions and shit and who take which side
guess they are doing pretty good after all
>>318360712
If you played the game you'd know that they almost did destroy it right before you join them.
The first mission for the railroad is an assault on their old HQ that's occupied by Synths and littered with dead railroad agents.
>>318361524
>Metro
>with power armor
>russkies have their own liberty prime
>and a better space program
>>318361507
>the institute is super advance
>they don't have any power armor
>they only use one type of weapon: institute energy rifle
>>318361302
Multiple channels and they never go to the core base. It's always a safe home that one person mans and others meet at other locations to confirm it's legit.
Also they use EMP generators to mess with signals and shit.
Seriously do none of you actually listen or read anything in the game?
>>318360892
You would have had to have given Mama Murphy some drugs while you had the quest and she told you the deactivation code. THE SIGHT, KID.
>>318361662
Fallout Russia when?
>>318361451
>technophobic
They really aren't, are they.
They are scared of people having technology, not of technology itself. In fact they embrace any technology they find and can control.
You wouldnt say a person is Arachnophobic because they are scared a person has spiders and not scared of spiders themselves.
>>318361665
A rusty switchblade does more damage than their rifles fully modded. WHY?
>>318361702
>wanting mama murphy dying from drug overdose
>>318361702
SPOILER: Turns out Mama Murphy is channeling the lovecraftian Dunwich Oldgobs, and is behind everything.
>>318361505
If anything that makes it more plausible. He saw firsthand the flaws and dangers of Lyon's system, the overextension and the seemingly meaningless loss of life in service of a people he probably couldn't relate to considering his upbringing was totally isolated from them. But his image of the traditional BoS would be completely idealized, since he's never experienced it first or studied any of its on the ground effects.
>>318361721
Удap в cпинy
>>318361721
Never, unless Todd wants to really fuck the setting and lore.
>>318361860
I'm sorry, this is Todd we're talking about. Fallout Russia Fall of 2016.
Fallout Uganda:
There is 1 suit of Power Armor, and the entire village takes turns hitting it with sticks.
>>318358535
Yeah they all suck. At least in FO3 and NV I had clear choice depending on what character I was playing.
He's in power because he's the descendant of the founder of the BoS, and because he has a single will that doesn't get caught up in emotions.
Synths need to be wiped out because they're unpredictable. They can malfunction at any time, and they aren't beholden to the rules that humans have to play by. They are a threat, no matter how you cut it.
>>318345067
I don't know maybe it's because it's been almost 20 years since the Lyons have both died? At this point it's almost 100% a different group of people.
>>318348527
Considering that some have been fine for two hundred years, like goddamn Raul, or Vault-Tec Rep, you might as well argue that we should wage war on the sun because it's going to engage in a rapid, hostile expansion across Earth's territories. Eventually.
If there are ghouls who have gone since the war without going feral then the person arguing to kill all the ghouls is the more dangerous person in this scenario.
If it's a matter of not knowing when they might turn violent and kill you, humans can turn violent at the drop of a hat, and one time when they did, they slaughtered billions in nuclear fire.
>>318361607
Not that anon but Good neighbor was able to detect them and it was stared that if you get them around enough radiation or electrical waves they tend to "glitch out"
Also the fact that it's stated they can withstand heat of jet engine or larger could lead to telltale signs if they withstand shit a normal person couldn't.
>>318361960
Fallout Nigeria:
There's 1 Albino Deathclaw and the entire country want a piece of it to make viagra powder
>>318362006
10 years from the end of F3 to beginning of F4
So what are the chances Shaun had a synth made as 1 to 1 replica of himself, and transported to an off-site location as a backup?
What made the Tactics BoS decide to go nation building?
>>318362136
>1 to 1 replica of himself
So it still has cancer?
>>318362136
The only "replica" of Shaun that exists is that child.
>>318361960
>Village of Tribals worships full set of X-01 Power armor.
>Minigun held in vice-like grip of deactivated armor.
>Village occasionally raided by other tribes, who rape/pillage every time.
>Village 1 never actually figures out how to access the working armor.
>Village 1 wiped out by tribals with sticks.
>Power armor remains untouched.
>>318361960
honestly more tribal stuff would be neat, like the scavenged and decorated t-51 in fo2 art
>>318362057
Yeah that first mission with Danse where he gets hit with the rocket blast made more sense.
>>318362176
Only Synth-Shaun has cancer.
Real Shaun eaten by mirelurks.
>>318360615
I mean they preserve the synths, who a pieces of revolutionary tech themselves.
And I hope they cease to exist once the institute is dealt with, that's the point. At most they would merge into the Minutemen and form some kind of Commonwealth government much like the NCR.
>>318362176
The cancer is a foreign body in his system. His synth would probably have a predilection towards getting cancer for genetic reasons, possibly but it wouldn't have it right away.
>>318362136
None, he wanted to give his father the chance to raise Shaun so he only made the child synth.
>>318362342
Speaking of mirelurks, Thicket Excavations. Now that was a twist!
>>318362424
He was a mirelurk the whole time.
>>318362392
Do synths age?
What happens if I wipe out everything and everyone in the institute the very moment I get inside? Does the game stops?
>>318362483
Well considering gen3s are all biological, I'd assume so.
>>318362392
>No More Baby Parts
>>318354961
So you really think that convincing someone with some hot opinions is the same as controlling them with a code?
Are you autistic? Do you think that human interaction is nothing more than skilled hackers uploading CHECK MY DUBS.EXE to the human database or some shit?
>>318361570
Pay attention the next time people are speaking or ask while the conversation is going on. I'm not going to troll through 400 posts for you, but since you're asking for evidence of what people think, it's what I think and others I've discussed the game with think.
>>318361791
We've speculated that their technology especially weapons developed along the path of advanced plastics research and getting effective and easy to make weapons into the hands of replaceable users. If I led the Institute, I'd give our top side synths easy to make, but not god tier weapons and save that stuff for human researchers and coursers.
>>318361505
what>>318361821
said except I've been suggesting he should been taught the folly of the west and made some compromise between the two ideologies.
If there were a terminal entry saying he returned to fundamentalism after seeing what altruism lost them (lives and his love), we wouldn't even be discussing this.
>>318354510
I wish we could have met him.
>he pretended to have trouble starting his imaginary motorcycle
>>318362497
You get a quest to go back and sabotage the reactor. The place is filled with generic no-names either way.
>>318362628
I thought there were some implications they didn't. Like the Coursers being superhuman and even the regs being able to do more than a human could.
>>318362773
>DLC
Start Suckin, anon.
>>318354510
Who?
Is it wrong to want to fuck a Deathclaw Matriarch/Broodmother
>>318362424
The first quarry?
There's a terminal right outside showing that he's a raider. I would've killed him there, but I recognized the location from the trailer and made a not to myself to return for XP and loot.
>>318362827
Yeah I'm not too clear on it either, but they are biological "clones" essentially. But other than that I don't know any more about their processes.
>>318362681
Not him, but it's effectively the same thing as being human if only the institute has the codes and the synth escaped successfully.
>>318362917
>He doesn't know.
>>318354315
Mojave IS NCR you rome cosplaying faggot, there is no way they would make any other ending cannon
>>318350626
It's really LUK>all
>>318362938
Oh shit, I don't remember reading that, well, I was pleasantly surprised in any case.
>>318349948
According to Americans trying to pick fights with vastly weaker forces is the manliest thing ever.
Except when the other side wins because then it's all "WE DIDN'T LOSE TO VIETNAM WE JUST GOT BORED AND LEFT!"
>>318363036
He sounds hilarious. I would like to know who he is.
>>318362721
He's also only 20 (despite looking like a grizzled 30+ vet, thanks bethesda) so it's not implausible he'd be making somewhat impulsive and reactionary decisions instead of digesting and the two philosophies and understanding their respective pitfalls.
the writing isn't great (or even good most of the time) but it's hardly as shoddy as people imply
>>318363215
Wouldn't we all.
He's out there somewhere, that magnificent bastard.
>>318363215
Listen to the raiders conversations.
"Who the fuck carries just a desk fan"
What if the institute was staffed by a man who turned himself into a cyborg and has been creating synths for over a century and conducting research on synths all alone.
When you get down there he's legitimately trying to do well, but he's going senile at this point. He thinks he's sending synths up to guard people, but the teleportation wipes their minds. He keeps notes of this and tries to fix it, but he loses his memory and has to start over before making any progress.
It might be a rehash of OWB, but senile evil is better than ideologically selfish and occasionally retarded evil.
>>318363303
>>318363320
Well whoever this glorious fucker is I hope we get a dlc dedicated to him.
>>318352646
>Get fucked, losers. This is the real BOS.
It sure is. Real BOS served medium rare with a pint of tears.
>>318360892
That is a glitch that happens when you run the game at a high fps.
I had to limit my 144hz monitor to 60 fps because it was happening to me on every terminal and sometimes while entering power armor.
>>318363245
>somewhat impulsive and reactionary decisions instead of digesting and the two philosophies and understanding their respective pitfalls.
Ah, Bethesda's explanation for FO3's writing.
You're 19 years old.
>>318363149
Yup, they won in the end didn't they.
>>318363470
I didn't know they released FO4 on the Commodore 64.
>>318363547
FO1 in FO4 when?
>>318360892
>>318363496
The game has a capped framerate of 60 by default for a reason.
>>318360356
I thought I explained why synths aren't conscious. They're emulating emotions, they're based on computers, and no matter of computations will make a simulated version a real one.
Why don't you go create a shelter home for abandoned cellphones.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I07xDdFMdgw
>>318363245
the real reason he hates synths is because cyborg-perk having lone wanderer boned sarah and maxson just listened and hated
>Implying I didn't save Lorenzo, and drink his magic immortality cum until the end of time, watching as all the pathetic factions crumble to dust.
>>318363909
Yeah, that joke happened already.
>>318363815
Mine went well above 60 fps without changing any of the default settings, I had to cap my video card at 60 fps.
>>318363894
>Why don't you go create a shelter home for abandoned cellphones.
the classic false equivalency to top off the argument
It's effectively the same thing and you'll never know unless it's head get bashed open.
>>318363894
That argument doesn't work for gen 3s. They literally have an organic brain, modeled from Shaun's own dna. It is augmented with cybernetics. So more or less they have inhibitors which over time fail.
>>318356043
And have her say patriotic shit like the patriots from infinite.
I know it's off topic, but can anyone tell me if you need to complete your companion quest to reach max relationship level?
It doesn't seem like I'm gaining any more affinity with countless likes, and I'd rather wait to finish it.
>>318364191
>like the patriots from infinite.
>Not like Liberty Prime
Get the fuck out of here.
>>318364006
Not him, but we'll have to find another thread to make the definitive greentext so that a drawfag will take it from there.
>>318364226
You need to complete the quest to get the perk.
>>318364284
Maxson kek thread? Sounds good to me.
>>318364226
Yes. you'll know youre done when you get the perk.
>>318364284
See>>318356430
There you go.
Bonus points if LW walks away with Sarah Lyons, and condom hits maxson in the face.
>>318363245
>20 (despite looking like a grizzled 30+ vet, thanks bethesda)
How was that strange? Stress makes you age like crazy and the shit he's been in is one helluva ride.
>>318364312
thanks m8
do you know if you need it to get past admiration?
>>318364427
still, looking a decade older when you're that young is usually only for addicts and severe alcoholics
>>318363538
Turns out we lost the Mexican-American war since they have restaurants here, huh? Take your deluded jingoist ass back to your circlejerk on /k/ where it belongs.
>>318364427
Fuck me he has been president since 08 It's weird to see it in writing. Maybe because its 130 in the morning, but damn. He's been in office for a while.
>>318364404
I want something more crafted than splicing maxon into a commercial. We can fit the citadel in and his life there.
>>318364516
Vietnam was fighting to keep foreign influence out. They failed and missed out on the chance to become SK 2.0.
Not the same.
>>318364514
*and leaders in tremendous positions of power and responsibility
So about Lady Liberty being turned into a secret weapon. Libery Prime is 40' tall. Lady Liberty is 111' 6" from head to toe.Prime barely functioned. How the fuck would they get the Lady to move?
>>318364179
This is a fair point and I'll admit that Bethesda's shitty (and lack of) writing doesn't allow one to know for certain. They have organic brains, yes, but we don't know how they're structured. For all we know they could be just biological Turing machines and if that's the case then they aren't conscious. If it's literary a human brain with just mechanical inhibitors, fucking with the biochemistry to place the right chemicals at the right place to in a sense "program them", then I'd have to agree with you.
The reasoning for why I don't think they're conscious is that I find it utterly retarded that the people making the synths would be so utterly retarded as to think that just because they're synthetic while having a human brain that actual work as a human brain and can do everything a human brain can do, wouldn't be consciousness.
Can we talk about the shit varying types of ammo? Cause this shit is cool, but a 10mm Walther? Come on.
>>318365089
Forgot pic
>>318364926
Have you seen the way the're constructed? They're mostly organic.
>>318364926
if the memory den's machines can interface with a human and synth brain with little to no difference, that points towards them being almost the same
>>318365152
IT JUST WERKS
>>318364925
Where did they try this?
>>318364926
Fair enough. Sadly we'll have to wait for dlc or possibly Obsidian to clear the matter up. That said Is it possible for it to be a Turing Machine? they are completely flesh and blood up until a certain percentage of grey matter. And as >>318365212 pointed out here, both synths and humans can use the memory den. The only one who couldn't was Nick who was a 2.5 gen and even he got some reaction out of it being partly organic.
>>318365242
They haven't. It was just wishful thinking on my part.
>>318365212
Curie cannot into human brain.
Curie can into Synth brain.
They are not the same.
>>318365163
It isn't a matter if they're organic or not, it's a matter of how it's structured.
>>318365212
Oh fuck you're right. I don't know how I oversaw this. Yea, synths are conscious.
![[Insert Racist Joke].png](https://i.imgur.com/labxCri.jpg "[Insert Racist Joke]")
![obama-hair-aging-hrzgal[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/DqX2yx2.jpg "obama-hair-aging-hrzgal[1]")
