[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Were shield maidens real who fought along side the men?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tv/ - Television & Film

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 56
Were shield maidens real who fought along side the men?
>>
you actually think a woman would stand a chance against any male soldier?
>>
Who gives a shit?
>>
>>70921457
Kek. This is the first phase of their brainwashing. Eventually they will revise history completely
>>
>>70921430
no, but they're rewriting history to fit their narrative.
so shut your whore mouth, shitlord
>>
Lagertha is the most agonizingly frustrating blue-balls-inducing character of all time. seeing her clothed triggers my anxiety. JUST FUCKING SHOW YOUR TITS ALREADY
>>
>>70921430
anon do you really think any woman can match a man in combat ? you should be well aware of the physical limits of women
>>
>>70921430
>There are few historic attestations that Viking Age women took part in warfare,[6] but the Byzantine historian John Skylitzes records that women fought in battle when Sviatoslav I of Kiev attacked the Byzantines in Bulgaria in 971.[6] When the Varangians (not to be confused with the Byzantine Varangian Guard) had suffered a devastating defeat in the Siege of Dorostolon, the victors were stunned at discovering armed women among the fallen warriors.[6]

it happened, but most of the stories are for the same reason as now: the idea of women fighting is sexy.
>>
File: hqdefault.jpg (25 KB, 480x360) Image search: [Google]
hqdefault.jpg
25 KB, 480x360
>>70921430
i can imagine they would be real but they would look like pic related and certainly not like lagetha pinup waifu mode
>>
why do we tolerate these bigots from /v/ and /r9k/ on our board, bros? we are better than this
>>
>>70921430
Doubtful. It hardly ever happened in any society, especially before firearms.
>>
There are historical chronicles of shieldmaidens (Lagertha was a name) but they were quite scarce in numbers to point them as soldiers, chronicles suggest that they fought in their homeland and not going to war.
>>
File: rektmaiden.webm (1 MB, 558x416) Image search: [Google]
rektmaiden.webm
1 MB, 558x416
>>70921430

Maybe a few did, but if so it was rare enough to be regarded as more legendary, and probably ended like it does in the show (for everyone other than Lagertha).
>>
The answer is "we're not sure":

https://blog.britishmuseum.org/2014/04/19/viking-women-warriors-and-valkyries/
>>
File: 1465733341097.webm (2 MB, 1120x806) Image search: [Google]
1465733341097.webm
2 MB, 1120x806
>>70921554
haeving porblem
>>
>>70921430
I'd doubt they went raiding even if there were but it's hardly impossible that women would pick up arms to defend their homes.

But Ragnar Lothbrok is sort of maybe not real anyway and all this shit is based of salad that were only written down in the 1200s or something and had been getting Chinese whispered for a few hundred years. The Ragnar saga or whatever it's called does definitely mention one of his wives being a shieldmaiden though I'm pretty sure it was Aslaug.

I've only started season 1 and was pleasantly surprised by it.

I expected it to be shit based on the fact that most of the characters look more like gluten free organic free range double hopped beer drinkers with some sort of weird leather fetish.

My only major gripe other than appearance and the fact that the Saxons seem to have forgotten what the fuck a shieldwall is, is why the fuck did Lagertha care if Knut raped a saxon woman.
>>
>>70921786
please tell me theres more
>>
>>70921635
Yea reality needs to be banned
>>
>>70921656
It would make sense to train women to defend themselves when the men went off raiding.
>>
>>70921786

mother of gawd. sauce?
>>
File: brigida-large.jpg (187 KB, 960x1248) Image search: [Google]
brigida-large.jpg
187 KB, 960x1248
>>70921627
> implying
>>
>>70922694
> painted nails
why did they have to ruin this
>>
>>70921786
I had no idea her hip and pelvis game was so amazing. I am new levels of diamonds.
>>
>tfw Katheryn will never pour water on you

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xp_9u-NtV4c
>>
It happened but for the most part its stuff based on the Valkyries who in Norse Myth didn't do much fighting in the first place
>>
>>70921666
Satan trips of truth. Shield maidens were a myth.
>>
>>70923242
I fucking laughed at that scene
>muh warrior women
>>
>>70921430
There was probably one or two here and there. There are female warriors present all over history. Very rarely as part of any female organization or according to any tradition, mostly just rare individuals going against the grain.
>>
>>70921430
Yes, but not like that. They were a backup plan, and would defend the homes and farms(hence the 'Shield' in the name) Lots of places did stuff like that, Sparta for example.
>>
Maybe but females on the front lines has always been such a stupid idea that even in the modern feminist world it isn't done. Females who serve are in rear echelon units for very obvious reasons.
>>
>>70921457
>>70921606
Idk lads, try fighting ronda or some othere female mma meme. They would probably fuck you up in the end.
Trained fighter vs trained fighter, not a chance.
>>
>>70923828
but if you took up boxing and wrestling for 2 months you'd take them easily
>>
>>70923977
>2 months
Now you are being silly. You won't even get to spar in that time.
>>
File: 1447587132522.jpg (78 KB, 608x720) Image search: [Google]
1447587132522.jpg
78 KB, 608x720
>>70923828

m8 Ronda couldn't even take a punch from a female boxer without her jaw crumbling.

Yeah she'd probably beat up most pencil neck nu males but any decent inshape male with some boxing or mma training could drop her.
>>
>>70923991
6months?
>>
>>70923991
>>70923977
Just going to point out, you can be physically superior all you want but if you get hit by a propelled rock your still going to get quite badly hurt.

Slings are neither difficult to make nor use. And there are plenty of other weapons available. Humans are no where near as physically dangerous as our other animal competitors, but we win using tools we make.
>>
>>70923828

Eh, maybe a modern lifelong sedentary guy but not a dude that's been working a farm or doing some other hard manual labor job his entire life like you would get in any army where people still fought wars with spears and bows, to say nothing of the professionals among them. Ronda wouldn't be totally helpless but if she actually needed to pick up a sword and defend herself, chances are pretty good something has gone horribly wrong.
>>
Then again, you should remember that Vikings only ever drew victories from fighting monks, or women and children, in spite of how much Nordics of today exaggerate their deeds.

So it isn't that far fetched that woman would fight alongside them. Vikings men themselves were pretty feminine, and were never once victorious against Franks or Saxons (until they adopted frankish tactics, but that's a story for another day).

But truth of the matter is that spear-women remains feminist wishful thinking. Some viking women were found buried with weapons, though to modern historians it will be left dubious whether this was officiated as part of burial rites for women of note, or if it really was the weapons those women had carried to battle.

So err we don't know. Could be. Could not be.

t. /his/
>>
>>70921627
damn ronda got fat after she got beat up
>>
File: THICC.png (814 KB, 1113x691) Image search: [Google]
THICC.png
814 KB, 1113x691
>>70921786
>>
>>70924353
t. lying anglo
>>
File: 1437429462596.jpg (63 KB, 800x533) Image search: [Google]
1437429462596.jpg
63 KB, 800x533
>>70921430
Lets see, battles in those days were decided by strength and hardiness, with large engagements being a shoving match between shield walls.

Yeah, no they were never a thing.
>>
>>70924353
Somebody post it
>>
>>70924428
Frenchie but eh, close enough.

Vikings are grossly overrated in today's culture, when their entire accomplishments can be summated to "good travellers, but niggers of Europe for pillaging and raping, and always avoiding true conflict".
>>
>>70924474
That chart that enumerates all their failures? I should have it somewhere, so I'll be looking.
>>
I want lagertha to beat me up!
>>
File: image.jpg (320 KB, 1532x763) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
320 KB, 1532x763
>>70924521
So here it is.
>>
>>70921430
Yeah, my teacher told me nordics had progressive views towards their women so it is liikely they fought alonside/agaiinst male warriors
>>
>>70924562
The Vikings were really scared shitless when they heard about Charles the Fat's army. They packed their shit and left in a matter of days.
>>
>>70924656
>heard about Charles the Fat's army.
To be fair, you don't fuck with the French in Medieval Europe. Nor in Renaissance Europe. Nor in Napoleonic Europe.
>>
>>70924353
>Vikings only ever drew victories from fighting monks
>What is Paris
>What is Northumbria
>What is Mercia
>What is Normandy
>What is the rest of England
>What is Luni (or not!Rome, kek)
>What is southern Italy
ect
>>
I think the only genuine female military force of worth was the Royal Guard of Dahomey. But that was only because the King wanted >muh harem over an actually effective guard. The thing is despite an inherent inferiority, they were still trained and worked like dogs so they were hardened enough to be create the imposing image of the 'Dahomey Amazons'
>>
>>70924643
4chan is for people aged 18 or older. Come back when your older and you don't have a overexcited 'i' key
>>
>>70924562
>>70924688
>savages ever winning real battles
people expected this
>>
>>70924688
>Normandy
Solely because Frankish monarchs understood that Paris could only be raided through the Seine, and that by bestowing Normandy (which is the mouth of the Seine) to the vikings, all raids would end because vikings wouldn't raid their own lands nor would allow other vikings to pass through the Seine. There never was really was any threat looming on France from the vikings, other than the small raids they would berate the Frankish armies with, and which only angered the French because the vikings would plague undefended villages rather than face off a true army. Hence, they operated as Medieval-times niggers.

Genius move in the end.

>Paris
The Vikings weren't even able, in all their might to raid a city whose only inhabitants were inept peasants and merchants, and had to besiege the city until Charles the Fat would have his patience fade and just pay for them to depart.

>the rest of England
They'd adopted Frankish customs and tactics by then, and it would be unfair to ever acquaint those norman """""vikings"""" with the vikings from beforehand.

>southern Italy

Winning against moors is a victory these days heh? Easiest thing on Earth.

I don't know for the others because they don't much concern my country.
>>
>>70924562
history was written by butthurt british monks.
The genetic materials they left behind tells another story
>>
>>70924861
>The genetic materials they left behind tells another story
Raping defenseless villagers = victory ?

Thank God that other european nations knew to fight under more virile and civilized ways, by which I mean that they'd formally engage each other, rather than prey on the undefended civilians of your enemy.
>>
>>70924836

>They'd adopted Frankish customs and tactics by then, and it would be unfair to ever acquaint those norman """""vikings"""" with the vikings from beforehand.

I think he means the Danelaw, not the Norman conquest
>>
>>70924943
Gahh sorry! Again, I wouldn't know that extensively about English history.

Though that bear the name "Danelaw" is a good sign. Danish vikings were those that actually accumulated some victories, while Norwegian and Swedish vikings were more navigators and rapists than anything.
>>
>>70924991

Well true the Danes were most successful in England, but Norwegians did take over parts of Ireland and the Isle of Mann, but I guess the locals weren't too well civilised either.
>>
>>70923828
>>Idk lads, try fighting ronda or some othere female mma meme.
As soon as they give me the same dose of steroids, sure.
>>
>>70925040
So it's the Swedes that end with nothing to pride themselves with, yet are the most vehement internet-wise on how we "we wuz vikangz annd sheit"?
>>
File: swncy.webm (3 MB, 640x359) Image search: [Google]
swncy.webm
3 MB, 640x359
>>
>>70925095
>she will never castrate you with a rusty knife
jdimsa ;_;
>>
File: 1458672135551.jpg (55 KB, 500x500) Image search: [Google]
1458672135551.jpg
55 KB, 500x500
>>70925200
>>
Soon they'll be making movies about WW2 with tons of women pulling some Mulan shut.
>>
>>70923828
Did you see the male MMA fighters?

There is no comparing them, she would be killed if she went against them
>>
>>70924836
>The vikings weren't able to raid paris
What, they sacked and occupied it. They also caught the fucking plague and the franks still couldn't drive them out. Charles had to buy them out.
Pretty sure that's a victory mate.

>muh Normans don't count
They were no true scotsmen aye.

>Winning against moors is a victory these days.
Yes. Moors weren't Christian Monks
>>
File: dany laugh face.jpg (25 KB, 536x536) Image search: [Google]
dany laugh face.jpg
25 KB, 536x536
>>70925250
>>
File: 14346489053.png (230 KB, 549x308) Image search: [Google]
14346489053.png
230 KB, 549x308
redpill me on bi curious yuri viking girls
>>
>history will be rewritten in your lifetime
>>
You have to understand that every show is the same show now, the same stupid soap that pushes the same stupid diversity shit, it just has a different skin.
>>
File: 1458659742756.jpg (28 KB, 300x300) Image search: [Google]
1458659742756.jpg
28 KB, 300x300
>>70925299
well.. you see.. they like to """explore"""
>>
>>70924904
>European nations
>Formally engage with one another
>Rather than prey on the undefended civilians of your enemy
Top Kek
>>
>>70925250
I'm ok with it as long as the woman is a Jewish teenager living in Holland.
>>
>>70924991
>Danish Vikings were those that actually accumulated some victories.
How to defeat your own argument 101.
>>
>>70925398
"some" = "Vikings were the fucking shit and they defeated all those pussy armies of the germans, french, british, byzantines like my movies tell me"

My beginning argument was that vikings mostly preyed on the weakest of any kingdom, though even I have to concede that that can be nuanced, especially with Danes that weren't that pitiful at the end of the day.

The chart someone made me post is very cherrpypicked and I can acknowledge that.
>>
>>70925250
Soviet Russia had female snipers in WW2, though it might have just been the one, I can't remember.
>>
File: Lady of the Mercians.jpg (75 KB, 700x539) Image search: [Google]
Lady of the Mercians.jpg
75 KB, 700x539
I'm not so sure about the Norse but among their English opponents, Ethelfleda, Alfred the Great's daughter, fought and led men in battle.
>>
>>70925461
Well to be fair, slavs are basically orks
>>
>>70925461
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyudmila_Pavlichenko

>strong womyn killing 309 right-wing straight white men
/pol/'s nightmare
>>
File: 1466032448621.jpg (312 KB, 943x943) Image search: [Google]
1466032448621.jpg
312 KB, 943x943
>>70923828
bullshit. women are weak as fuck.
>>
>>70925270
>Moors
Were still a very weakened people when the Vikings swooped in to oust them from Sardania.

>What, they sacked and occupied it. They also caught the fucking plague and the franks still couldn't drive them out. Charles had to buy them out.

They never occupied it nor sacked it. In every depiction of that episode there's to be found, Vikings were confined to besieging the Paris walls, but they certainly never breached. And upon arriving, Charles the Fat simply negotiated that they'd be allowed to move down the Seine so long as they would leave French villages unharmed, and would only raid the villages only they delved into Burgundian territory (french enemy from the time, now they're our vassals heh, so it all worked out).

>They were no true scotsmen aye.
I don't get british idioms.
>>
>>70924353
Yeah, whatever you say, cuckboi
>>
File: 1462273392735.png (768 KB, 1280x1172) Image search: [Google]
1462273392735.png
768 KB, 1280x1172
>>70925512
>not russian propaganda.
>like the Stahanov case, who later claimed that he got ''some'' help in that night.
>>
File: 2sweete.jpg (35 KB, 400x330) Image search: [Google]
2sweete.jpg
35 KB, 400x330
>>70923828
>They would probably fuck you up in the end.
I would never be this lucky
>>
>>70924228
>Humans are no where near as physically dangerous as our other animal competitors, but we win using tools we make.

Also through our endurance. True, we're not as fast as, say, cheetahs, but humans can walk long distances for hours on end and little rest. The same cannot be said for, say, horses (in fact, following a horse until it tired itself out and couldn't move any more was actually a good tactic to capture one alive).

Of course, tool use also greatly helped our endurance (for example, the fact that we could carry water with us in jars and bottles lengthened the distance we could go and shortened the time we needed to rest).
>>
>>70923828
Can a /sp/ fag post that webm of Ronda throwing punches

I wanna laugh
>>
>>70925542
Loving the argumention.
>>
>>70925452
>le strawman argument
>Moving goalposts

>>70924353
>You should remember that Vikings only ever drew victories from fighting monks, or women and children.
>Only ever
Come on anon, you had no chance of winning this argument anyway.
>>
File: 1440596457939.jpg (47 KB, 604x369) Image search: [Google]
1440596457939.jpg
47 KB, 604x369
>>70925549
>in fact, following a horse until it tired itself out and couldn't move any more was actually a good tactic to capture one alive
>good tactic
>>
File: i1vzjrg.gif (1005 KB, 351x263) Image search: [Google]
i1vzjrg.gif
1005 KB, 351x263
>>70925571
/his/fags think they know a little about history because they frequent a chinese shitposting forum. I've read more books than you will in a lifetime, faggot. It's called the Viking age for a reason. I don't even understand how you cucks can be this butthurt about it.
>>
>>70921430
Real but extremely rare.
>>
>>70925487
The same Alfred that got slapped by a fishwife?
>>
>>70925262
Did you read the WHOLE post, or just the beginning?

>>70925523
So are untrained males
>>
>>70925596
It's done even today , you retard. Some niggers in Africa follow an antelope, in shifts , until it fucking collapses from being too tired.
>>
>>70925595
Kinda admit that I do overstate the failures the Vikings earned in their time to rebalance how much unwarranted praise they'll be granted by reddit pr 9gag fags. Or even the screenwriters of this shows.

I can't always be right can I ":p" ?
>>
>>70925641
He did other stuff too, anon.
>>
>>70924353
>>70924562
love the butthurt /pol/tards who cant deal with the fact that their beloved nordics are in fact, pussies
>>
>>70925654
>mfw everyone of 90% of adult , healthy males can overpower anyone of the 95% of healthy adult women.
>>
>>70921430
>Were shield maidens real who fought along side the men?

No.

They were a meme based on the legends and myths of the time.

I don't understand why people are so desperate to make womyn warriors out of this, considering that there are historical societies that had women fighting side by side with men; steppes people, Scythians in particular.

They could fight with men, because their armies were mounted on horseback and shot arrows using a hit and run tactic. Any idiot can understand that this nullifies most of the advantages men have in combat and that this is the sole reason it worked out this way.
>>
Yes. Women fought alongside men.

No, it wasn't common practice.

No, they didn't participate in raiding groups and shit.

The truth of the matter is, it's not some sort of established norm or treaty or whatever. Basically, when someone invaded your land and it was a case of either fight or die, women would often join in. Sometimes an ugly, testosterone-ridden woman might join her fellow men in an invasion or whatever. Slavs often brought women along.

In general, women were used as a last resort or just an added thing. A woman would usually get absolutely destroyed in the battlefield and she was a liability - ranks and organization mattered a lot and one woman in a formation could lead to the deaths of hundreds of men just by being a woman, no matter how strong or capable she was.

But in terms of the show, no, they didn't exist like that, not at all.
>>
File: 1465637241437.jpg (31 KB, 639x424) Image search: [Google]
1465637241437.jpg
31 KB, 639x424
>>70925654
>So are untrained males
Who fucking cares. A man can shoulder press 50 kg easy. That's the average weight of a woman. A woman can barely do anything even with steroids. Women are naturally weak. The argument that women could ever fight and win is nonsense. Check this video out. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wby1vUy8aYI That guy looks weak as fuck. If a man actually fights back then the woman hits the ground. Women as warriors is just fiction.
>>
>>70925654
>So are untrained males

Not true, if someone can post that webm of ronda throwing punches you will understand why

Any hillbilly that works the field or basically any man that doesn't spend his entire day wanking and watching anime would fucking crush a trained female MMA fighter, its not a matter of training even, its just a matter of fucking punching her as hard as you can once, she cant stop you, SHE CANT, neither can she knock you out unless you're a fucking retard that just stands there or a /tv/ wimp
>>
>>70925654
>Did you read the WHOLE post, or just the beginning?

You mean the part that says "Trained fighter vs trained fighter"?

I'm assuming you meant "vs untrained fighter"?

Even in that case a farmer could probably beat a woman fighter, people in the past were hard as shit cause they had to be.
>>
>>70925605
Err do we share the same website? This is a Laotian calligraphy forum, from what my time here has taught me.

>I've read more books than you will in a lifetime, faggot
I've never had any friends in my life, so I'd
highly doubt that.

>Viking age for a reason
That's only because they're what's particular from the era. Those decades revolve far more around the Papacy acquiring lands, the Byzantine empire facing off against the Sassanids, France building up a decent royal domain, the last spanish kingdoms succumbing to Al-Andalus, etc...

Am I really expected to believe that some raiding changed the face of Europe more than those?
>>
>>70925681
>/pol/
>beloved nordics

nope
>>
>>70925765
its not even people in the past, average oil worker is hardened enough that he'd knock out any woman '''''''''''fighter''''''''''''

its just fucking basic biology, females carry children, males defend them
>>70925775
average american poltard claims norwegian ancestry
>>
>>70925797
>average american poltard claims norwegian ancestry

c'mon bro, I only go there to shitpost and even I know thats not true
>>
>>70925769
>I've never had any friends in my life
So you're a friendless retard, what a surprise.
>>
>>70925797
>average american poltard

Is hispanic.

I'm not even joking. Go look at the flag diversity too, most people on /pol/ aren't white.
>>
>>70925730
>>70925654
>>70925698
>>70925549
>>70925523
>>70923828
>>70921606
>>70921457
>strength and prowess

You do realize that does not matter one bit? Combat before firearms was a matter of ranks, formations and other things. Strength never came into play. As long as you could hold your shield against a hit, which requires basic fitness, you could fight. The point is, a forlorn hope dude with a huge claymore would punch through a weak guy in a formation, but that was no reason to remove the weak guy as it's a single case, not the case of the whole situation.

Hell, romans were one of the most effective fighting forces in all of history and they were largely 5'0 - 5'2. They were trained mostly in cardio and stuff like gymnastics, with little to no strength training and they didn't need much, because stabbing a dude with your gladius didn't require that much strength.

Spartans weren't the biggest and strongest either, they were starved and forced to endure insomnia, they were just the most organized, brutal and had no morale issues (no one gave a fuck if they died so they rarely broke formation).

Strength has almost never mattered in the history of military warfare.
>>
>>70925818
well I dont, my interactions are those of /int/ and other boards, maybe I'm wrong but they seem enamored with nordics because muh aryan

even go as far as to claim that painfully average norwegian bitch everyone posts is a 10/10 because muh blue eyes and blonde hair
>>70925858
that's hilarious if true
>>
>>70925862
Nice bait, cuck
>>
>>70921430
There is one record of the ERE encountering women guarding wounded Varangians, at best they functioned as auxiliaries
>>
File: 1463187015930.jpg (86 KB, 749x751) Image search: [Google]
1463187015930.jpg
86 KB, 749x751
>>70925862
RETARD ALERT
>>
>>70925862
>march fucking miles carrying equipment
>hurr strength didn't matter
>>
>>70923828
>ronda rousey
>155lbs

This is why I wish they would just put up or shut the fuck up, put her against a scrub male in the same weight class and she gets destroyed. But you'll never see it because people instinctively know it would be fucked up to do. Especially the promoters and doctors involved in match making.
>>
>>70925842
Well you are too.
>>
>>70925528
>B-but Moors were very weakened
Doesn't matter, don't care. Weren't Monks, women and children
>They never sacked and occupied it.
Yes they did, in 845. And Charles the Bald had to buy them out.

>I don't get British idioms
A no true Scotsmen is when you disregard something that matches all the necessary criteria because of an arbitrary reason.

Like a Scotsman, a man who is from Scotland, doesn't count because he doesn't like haggis, or doesn't wear a kilt.
When in reality all you need to be a Scotsman is to be a man from Scotland.

Or Normans don't count as Nordic people because they adapted some tactics from their neighboring Franks.
>>
>>70925858
Really?
I would have bet it was mostly Asian Americans because all the insecurity about black dicks.
>>
>>70925913
>especially the doctors involved

I mean no shit, you have to have a decent grasp of biology to be a fucking doctor
>>
Not really

the shieldmaiden meme comes from some graves they found of women buried with shields and weapons

theres 0 proof they ever actually fought or went on raids with the men
>>
File: 1454950044882.png (651 KB, 697x713) Image search: [Google]
1454950044882.png
651 KB, 697x713
>>70925918
Assburgers. Get a life. Get some friends. Spend less time online. Really.
>>
>>70925797
You're a moron. The only Norwegians in America are in rural Minnesota and North Dakota.
Jesus Christ.
>>
>>70925912
That's more about stamina.
Where women are actually a good deal closer to men (still not on the same level but good enough to be useful)
>>
>>70925912
>being able to march long distances is a matter of having large muscles
Do you know how I know you've never marched long distances?
>>
>>70925943
Saxo Grammaticus said they fought at Brávellirm but he's generally full of shit and writing 500 years after the fact
>>
>>70925882
>>70925910
Average roman soldier height was 5'5 I think.

The marian reforms made that the minimum.

>>70925912
That doesn't mean they have that much upper body strength senpai. Certainly not as much as if you trained upper body strength instead of that.

Certainly not a level of fitness women can't achieve.
>>
>>70925965
Thanks I guess. I didn't have any friends where the internet didn't exist yet, but I'll duly do as you say.
>>
>>70925987
>>70925991
you still need strenght, which no woman has 1:1 as a man

and no, big muscles =/= strenght you fucking retard, average hillbilly is stronger than your groomed body building idiots
>>
>>70925666
Its fine anon.
Nice Satan trips btw
>>
>>70925991
>carrying equipment

seems you missed that part you intellectually dishonest cunt
>>
>>70925971
do you know what the word claim means or are you just not aware of the muh heritage meme?
>>
>>70926019
No, i mean it. I imagine most people here are losers and all but if you've never had any friends ever then, you know, having friends is nice.
>>
>>70925991
>being able to march long distances burdened with 25 kgs of armour, weapons and equipment, and being able to fight properly after the march and also erecting a wooden palisade camp in the night.
>>
>>70925730
>A man can shoulder press 50 kg easy

Not true. Go to /fit/. People consider pressing 1pl8 (which is 60kg) a 6-12 months of lifting achievement.
>>
File: dfbbd.jpg (291 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
dfbbd.jpg
291 KB, 1920x1080
>this fucking retard gave up a qt shieldmaiden lagertha to fuck that ugly hag aslaug

legitimately the maddest I've ever been at a show, why the fuck did this happen
>>
>>70925991
This. I regularly rucked 30km with a pack half my weight but I was still pretty scrawny.
5'8'' 140lbs
>>
>>70926033
body builders are weak meme
>>
>>70925991
>>70926043
No, he got it right. Carrying equipment while marching does not require serious upper body strength in the conventional sense in which we're discussing it, i.e. what women can't have.
>>
File: vikings-katheryn-winnick-2.jpg (1 MB, 2030x3000) Image search: [Google]
vikings-katheryn-winnick-2.jpg
1 MB, 2030x3000
Why is she so perfect?
I want to be her eunuch foot slave.
>>
>>70926043
I felt as if that was sufficient implied, but I guess I was wrong.
>>
>>70925765
No, I meant exactly what I wrote. That a trained female has 0 chance against a trained male.
>>
>>70926109
same
>>
>>70926102
they are in a way, they train for those specific movements and to have big muscles but they cant apply their strength in other regards

when I went to gym I could bench 130kg but I still had trouble skanderb beating your average hillbilly because those fucks are strong, ACTUALLY STRONG from working the field
>>
>>70926033
What exactly do you mean by strength if not muscle?
>>
>>70926060
Literally Noone says it except Minnesotans and North Dakotans

I don't even know why you're so butthurt about it you retard
>>
File: 1457981754703.jpg (140 KB, 1080x1080) Image search: [Google]
1457981754703.jpg
140 KB, 1080x1080
>>70922058
>>
>>70926139
Moral strength, shitlord.
>>
>>70926139
I honsttly dont know how it works, maybe density has a thing to say but honestly having big muscles doesn't make you strong by default, it just fucking doesn't
>>
>>70926084
Endurance, discipline, and avoiding that kind of scenario at any cost because a tired soldier is a weak soldier. Read any military manual and it'll tell you to not fucking march long distances before a fight.
>>
>>70926151
I'm not you triggered amerilard with totally norwegian heritage and not one drop of mexican blood
>>
>>70926136
>when I went to gym I could bench 130kg
No you couldn't

>ACTUALLY STRONG from working the field
Nice meme. Working in field requires a lot of endurance and very little actual strength.
>>
File: AshaYara.jpg (166 KB, 800x800) Image search: [Google]
AshaYara.jpg
166 KB, 800x800
I literally can't tell who's angry over what at this point.
>>
>>70926043
>What are Mules
>What are wagons.
And another thing.The kinds of thing an infantry soldier would have to carry on a march, things like swords, axes and mail armor aren't actually as heavy as you think they are.
>>
>>70926197
i dont care if you believe me or not but bodybuilders are weak at applying their ''''''''''''strength'''''''''''''''' in the real world

now frig off to /fit/
>>
>>70926199
Same, this thread should really be about waifus.
>>
File: 1463764469070.jpg (99 KB, 950x609) Image search: [Google]
1463764469070.jpg
99 KB, 950x609
>>70926090
yeah /fit/ is filled with betas, man. everyone is always talking about dicks, insecurity and their fucking height. i did 60kg after a week.
>>
>>70926199
I didn't know Eve Lawrence was in Game of Thrones.
>>
>>70926188
You're just being a fucking retard now

Probably some Britcuck
>>
>>70926226
honestly not even /pol/ is as insecure as that board
>>
>>70921430
No, women buried with swords were basically socially important (see nobility) and were buried with a military symbol to project that.
That or they were peasant wives that fought to defend themselves, but not as actual soldiers.
>>
>Lagertha is a furry

https://www.instagram.com/p/BGC1dsVGKAB/?taken-by=katherynwinnick
>>
>>70926244
this is exactly what I mean, some small pockets of retards claiming norwegian ancestry even though their line is mixed AF and now North Dakota is strictly aryan norwegian

you're just a dumb fuck and you'll never ever be norwegian, or german, or whatever fuck else you stupid fucks claim
>>
>>70926226
I guarantee you can't even bench 1 plate.
>>
>>70926222
Yeah, bbers are pretty shit FOR THEIR SIZE. But they are still much stronger than your average cuck. And that working in field makes you stronk meme needs to die.

>>70926226
Wow, you must be pretty gifted. I wonder why you've never been scouted to be an athlete.
>>
>>70921430
Yes, but they were exceptionally rare.

Usually they'd be women who were sterile, or all of their children had become adults. They'd also have to be the wife of one of the raiders.

Most shieldmaidens just guarded the villages against bandits when the men were raiding, though.
>>
>>70926174
>Read any military manual and it'll tell you to not fucking march long distances before a fight.

Being this kind of an retard.You fucking nigger, sometimes you had to fight while tired after a long march, because the other army could leave, pillage , siege a castle while you lazy faggot would rest.
>>
>>70926257
I think this goes past furry and into straight up beasting
>>
>>70926276
>I'm not American but let me fight this dude that even has a fucking map of ancestry.

Dude you should kill yourself. Pathetic faggot.
>>
>>70926276
>getting this triggered about the dna of some anonymous stranger on the other side of the planet

Tell me what you've done in life so I can do the opposite and not end up like you.
>>
>>70926302
Yeah shit for their size is a good way to put it. I mean there's a reason why there is training for pure body mass and training for strength, because being big wont necessarily make you strong
>>
>>70926165
Well, there is the question of what muscles have been trained and for what. Different training produces different muscle fibers, suited for different things, for example there are explosive muscles and enduring muscles. Body builders focus on large and visual muscles, for aesthetics. They're strong, sure, but they haven't trained to be good at working on a farm, for instance. They'll still be good at it, because they've trained so fucking much, but the same amount of muscle growth with more suitable muscles and fibers is going to be much stronger for that kind of work.
>>
>>70926316
>>70926332
>amerilards this triggered because no one believes they are german

TOP FUCKING BURKEK
>>
>>70925933
Apologies for the late reply.

>Doesn't matter, don't care. Weren't Monks, women and children
Ugghh suppose I must concede that you're right there, but my attitude on exacting those insults on vikings mostly stems from this : >>70925666

>Yes they did, in 845. And Charles the Bald had to buy them out
Fug! I've been debating about this one for the entire time (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Paris_(885%E2%80%9386))

>Or Normans don't count as Nordic people because they adapted some tactics from their neighboring Franks.
They can be heralded as Nordics, although by that time, they'd merged with the French peasanry, and even William has been asserted as 80% french, but whatever. I mostly mean that they can't be vikings: it's vikings the historically-unaware look to, and that they praise for being small rugged bands of warriors taking on the whole of England "hell yah xD!". This is why there must be an obvious distinction between normans and vikings. Normans had buried those vikings ways, and facing the Saxons at Hastings portrayed that, since fighting in the open-field against other armies is a quintenssially unviking strategy.

This is like saying that the Plantagenets kins are kings. By adopting english ways, they amputated from themselves their french roots, and became effectively english.

It's the culture you have that defines you. And normans certainly didn't have viking culture.
>>
File: 1465047953717.gif (3 MB, 800x352) Image search: [Google]
1465047953717.gif
3 MB, 800x352
>>70926244

>All those nigger patches on the east coast
>>
>>70926362
Alrighr later bro, if you want reply to me again and get the last word in you tard
>>
>>70926106
women are almost incapable of carrying heavy equipment bud, go watch any rucksack run from the U.S military involving women, the men usually have to help them and they lag behind the men by huge margins.

Aka, it wouldn't be smart to include a bunch of weak cunts that can't fucking march and carry gear into battle with your war party.
>>
>>70926307
>Being this kind of an retard.You fucking nigger, sometimes you had to fight while tired after a long march, because the other army could leave, pillage , siege a castle while you lazy faggot would rest.
Sure, sometimes it was unavoidable. Doesn't mean it didn't lead to defeat in more cases than not, or that it often wasn't just the result of dumb commanders. I said avoid, not never do it ever.
>>
>>70926174
>Read any military manual and it'll tell you to not fucking march long distances before a fight.


UNLESS UR LIGHT INFANTRY BABY FUCK YES

RUCK ALL DAY
RUCK ALL NIGHT
RUCK RIGHT IN TO A FIREFIGHT

WHO GIVES A SHIT IF YOUR KNEES AND LOWER BACK WONT WORK WHEN YOU'RE 30, PUT ON THAT 100KG RUCK AND LETS ROUTE STEP ON UNTIL SOMEONES BOOTS ARE FULL OF BLOOD
>>
>>70926395
>I'll be the b-bigger guy in here and c-concede

top kek , just top kek
>>
>>70926395

Not him but that's literally what you're doing.
>>
>>70926420
>he actually did it

Petty and butthurt
>>
>>70921430
Why didn't that fucking cunt her fake tits and hairy muff out yet? God she's a cunt.
>>
File: 1451090935410.jpg (103 KB, 721x481) Image search: [Google]
1451090935410.jpg
103 KB, 721x481
>>70926297
I basically grew up on a farm so it's not that hard to believe. My dad was tall, strong and had broad shoulders. >>70926302
>Wow, you must be pretty gifted. I wonder why you've never been scouted to be an athlete.
There's no scouts for that sort of thing where I live.
>>
File: all is confusion.jpg (4 KB, 122x118) Image search: [Google]
all is confusion.jpg
4 KB, 122x118
did all the autists on 4chan converge on this thread?
>>
>>70926362
>>amerilards
Nope, and I'm not even the guy you're arguing with. Your posts just stand out as massively butthurt.
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJ_GCPaKywg
>>
>>70926440
And he is free to keep replying to me with his butthurt
>>
File: Physical.png (973 KB, 1846x1620) Image search: [Google]
Physical.png
973 KB, 1846x1620
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VCCBn5yvZMQ

World champion female kickboxer versus completely untrained, unfit male.

This is pretty much best-case for a "female vs male" match, and the male isn't IMMEDIATELY ended.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WspeoRo9KTQ

This is one of the best female soccer teams in the world going up against a bunch of average guys who play together on the weekend
Spoiler: The guys win 7:1

Shieldmaidens did exist though, but they were usually with their husbands and it was still quite rare
>>
>>70926453
>grew up on a farm
have some more dank memes about farmwork making you super stronk?
>>
>>70926461
>I swear I'm not an american getting triggered because people ridicule my heritage claims

holy shit this is getting funnier, can we go 3 for 3 or have I only triggered 2 of you enough to reply to me?
>>
>>70926456
Last word.
>>
>>70926401
We're talking about Roman legionaries being smaller and weaker than many of those they fought against, and prevailing despite lesser strength, due to organization and discipline. I mean, I'm not disputing the fact that militaries have been like >99% male on average since forever, or that men are physically more suited for soldiering, just saying that it's not like a woman would automatically be useless in any military scenario just because she's weaker, because there are others things to war and combat than body strength.
>>70926442
It doesn't sound like you have any issues at all.
>>
>>70926489
>being this paranoid

ok dude lol, you're just proving my point but w/e
>>
>>70926481
the top 5 womens football teams regularly practice (and lose) against UNDER 16 BOYS teams.

that should give an understanding of the limit of the female body, its just biology, people need to not get so butthurt about obvious facts like this.
>>
>>70926511
>t. Reddit
>>
File: 1451417802133.gif (492 KB, 480x270) Image search: [Google]
1451417802133.gif
492 KB, 480x270
>>70926482
>lifting stuff makes you stronger
>meme
Do you even know what people do on farms or are you're just retarded?
>>
>>70926481
They had to find fucking White Trash Meriadoc Brandybuck, did they?
>>
>>70926510
>>70926515
>tfw when you get to trigger americans on an anonymous chinese basket weaving tip forum this easily

never ever will you be what you claim lard asses
>>
>>70923828
lmao, I'm barely trained and I'm 100% certain I could pin that Ronda cunt down and rail her as much I wanted
>>
>>70926511
Even a small man has like 70% more upper body strength than the average woman. You're making a false equivalency here.
>>
>>70926569
Last word
>>
>>70926569
t. nigger
>>
>>70926481
having some jackass retard flail about and pretend it hurts him SO much isn't a good point to make, m8
>>
>>70926569
>americans
Are you replying to the wrong posts?
>>
>>70926561
>Do you even know what people do on farms
I'm not him but all we did was drive tractors and forklifts around to lift all the heavy shit, I guess maintaining the machinery was a slight workout though
>>
File: 12412412421121.jpg (38 KB, 620x349) Image search: [Google]
12412412421121.jpg
38 KB, 620x349
>>70926594
>>70926595
>>70926611
>the triggering continues

its time for the reaction image phase
>>
>>70926481
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WspeoRo9KTQ

You know, I'm starting to get the opinion that women are shit mostly because they are completely incapable of being goalkeepers.

Look at that match, the women had dozens of great shots, but the guy goalkeeper was a fucking rock.

Then every shot by the guys went in or the woman fucked up.

Watch women football highlights, so many retarded goalkeepers.
>>
>>70926639
It's been a minute since I've seen this one throw a tantrum this hard. You ok man? Want to talk about it or something
>>
>>70926639
Last word. Getting last word in.
>>
File: 1450035499024.png (53 KB, 227x223) Image search: [Google]
1450035499024.png
53 KB, 227x223
>>70926667
>>70926674
>>
>>70926550
>>70926585
He's right you know, women aren't taken in military because they don't have the mentality, discipline, logic anda bility to perfectly follow logic.

Not strength.

Yes, they are weaker, yes that is a disadvantage, but no, that's not the reason they are not taken in the millitary.

Similar to how strength barely matters in actually fighting in an army.
>>
>>70926307
>siege a castle while you lazy faggot would rest.

But that's exactly what you'd want the enemy to do... Waste time, men and resources on sieging a castle while you're having a kip around the corner so you can slaughter them with a good night's rest and food in your belly, instead of marching in tired and hungry to break a fucking siege.
>>
>>70926481
>posts a jackass video as proof
lol
>>
>>70926699
Last word
>>
>>70925452
Vikings quite simply were just traders by default.Through all their extensive trading they knew very well which kingdom or area was weak or unprotected allowing for easy raiding.

Add to that the fact that they did have a kick-ass version of a ship, outclassing every other people for a couple of hundred years allowing for two-way movement ( no need to turn). It leads to the age bveing called the Age of Vikings.

Comparing a viking raid party to a fielded european army is simply ridiculous.
>>
DUDE LAST WORDS LMAO
srsly tho kill yourselves
>>
>>70926774
Last word
>>
>people seriously think women can fight
Feminists or movies have you guys brainwashed it's almost unbelievable
>>
>>70926453
>basically grew up on a farm

This is something someone who didn't actually grow up on a farm says.

Spending your summer holidays down at the lake by grandpa's farm doesn't mean shit, kid.
>>
>>70926651
There's like a hundred times as hard a selection process going on in male-dominated sports. Many more men try to become professional soccer players, so the bar is higher. Same way larger nations have more potential players to choose from, or nations where a sport is more prestigious have a much larger portion of the population attempts it. Just not enough internal competition (or money) in women's sports to produce similar results/strength.
>>
>>70926702
>can't carry 100kg packs
>can't carry their 100kg fellow soldiers that get wounded
>shorter and less strong

yeah dude, they don't have the mental capacities either but pretending war has nothing to with strength is a joke
>>
>>70921617
Anecdotes abound in the thread while this shit goes ignored.
>>
>>70926702
>to perfectly follow logic
You mean orders?
>>
>>70926794
Most men can't fighter either, they just windmill like a retard at each other, hardly surprising if a woman could beat that pathetic shit
>>
>>70926795
I'm also in a rural area and actually small farms are more difficult than 1000+ acre farms

You might trick people living in large cities but anyone in a town of 1000 people or less knows how low risk modern day farming is
>>
>>70926825
you forgot

>cant march carrying their gear
>will give up sooner than men hence hurting unit cohesion

Also having a girl near horny warfighters I dont think is a good idea but I'm not in a charge so whatever, feminists be damned some of them should join the frontlines if they want so much equality
>>
>>70926844
a 5'5 manlet could beat the shit out of like 90% of women, its not even a contest
>>
File: 1452197858664.jpg (65 KB, 1529x742) Image search: [Google]
1452197858664.jpg
65 KB, 1529x742
>>70926795
Keep projecting, it's great. I don't see how being forced to help people is something worth bragging about.
>>
>>70926710
>or you miss the right timing and arrive a day after the castle has fallen , only to see all of it's inhabitants butchered, all the gold, the jewelery and provisions taken and the enemy army gone, only for you to hear that they have retreated and burned everything in their way.
>>
>>70926813
Fucking bullshit.
Hormonal differences make all the difference in terms of strength, specially at the top tier competitions.
>>
>>70926813
>sports

Who the actual fuck is talking about sports?

>>70926825
>100kg packs and 100kg people

We're talking pre-firearm warfare here retard
>>
>>70926877
>this lol
>ronda rousey starts flailing her arms
>hits manlet in the head
>breaks her hand
>manlet hits her once in the belly
>she down

its not a contest
>>
>>70921430
You just know she has a hairy snizz......
>>
>>70926380

Well technically viking was an act. The Danes would go viking. And if we're using it that way and not as a nickname for the medieval Danes and other assorted nordics, then its a bit unfair holding them on the standard of beating armies.
>>
>>70926855
>I'm also in a rural area and actually small farms are more difficult than 1000+ acre farms
Word. I spend some months on a large farm a few years back, it had modern machinery doing all the hard work. A few friends bought a small farm last year, with like a 70-year old tractor as the sole mechanical equipment. So much back-breaking lifting and carrying to be done. You need a larger farm to make enough money to buy the machinery to make farming easy.
>>
>>70926877
That's why they just kick windmillcucks in the balls and everyone laughs
>>
>>70926719
Seriously? You think this makes you clever or funny but really it just makes you 16 and autistic.
>>
>>70926920
A goat's beard between her legs?
>>
>>70926651
>>70926813
There's also some (potentially pseudo)-science about men having better hand-to-eye coordination because of the division between genders in sustenance-gathering. Males hunted prey and needed the aim/dexterity to throw rocks at shit or catch a wild animal, while females gathered food and needed a good eye for detail.

The biggest difference in sports is definitely because the female teams will have any bitch who's up for it, they're so starved for participants.
>>
>>70926899
Of course it makes a ton of difference, I'm just saying that the gap in ability is widened by the fact that there's less internal competition in women's sports.
>>
>>70926937
24 and autistic and getting the last word in. Last word
>>
>>70926900
>Who the actual fuck is talking about sports?
The dude posting about goalkeeping?
>>
>>70926900
>heavy ass swords, axes, shields, and armor made out of fucking metal
>not heavy

>warriors of the past were all 120 pounds

top lel kid
>>
>>70926937
I actually feel bad for triggering him this hard
>>
>>70926961
Well that could very well be true, we don't have data but a smaller populational sample and less investment would logically breed lesser results.
>>
>>70926898
>missing the right timing
>in an event that takes years

Sieges did not end within a day like in your movies, mate.
>>
>>70926988
I seriously am getting last word in.
>>
>>70926813
Another event dubbed a "Battle of the Sexes" took place during the 1998 Australian Open[33] between Karsten Braasch and the Williams sisters. Venus and Serena Williams, aged 17 and 16 respectively, had claimed that they could beat any male player ranked outside the world's top 200, so Braasch, then ranked 203rd, challenged them both. Braasch was described by one journalist as "a man whose training regime centered around a pack of cigarettes and more than a couple bottles of ice cold lager."[34][35] The matches took place on court number 12 in Melbourne Park,[36] after Braasch had finished a round of golf and two beers. He first took on Serena and after leading 5–0, beat her 6–1. Venus then walked on court and again Braasch was victorious, this time winning 6–2.[37] Braasch said afterwards, "500 and above, no chance." He added that he had played like someone ranked 600th in order to keep the game "fun."[38] Braasch said the big difference was that men can chase down shots much easier, and that men put spin on the ball that the women can't handle. The Williams sisters adjusted their claim to beating men outside the top 350.

An 18 year old 4th ranked Serena Williams claimed she could compete with men in professional sport; the US Open champion believing she could take on and beat the best players in the men's game. Nothing ever came to be from this claim.[39]
l m f a o
>>
>>70926981
Imagine a 5'5 roman weighing 100 kg please.

Now imagine a gladius, which is about as long as your forearm or a spear made of wood and an edge the size of your hand.

How does that weigh more than 100 kg?

Shields were heavy, but not of a weight that would not allow a woman to carry it.

Armor was heavy, but also not heavy enough to not allow women to carry it.

Finally, platemail and some types of armor were too heavy for women, but lighter roles have always existed.

Plus, archers.
>>
>>70926561
Tie the horse to the plough?
Harvest your small strip you'd been allotted to do for three hours and then go to the pub with your peasant pals?
>>
>>70925270
>No true scotsman

No, he's right. The Normans were mostly French: they were Catholic, spoke French, and married into French nobility. Their military doctrine was mostly French as well, with an emphasis on cavalry. They may have been descended from Norse but they were primarily French.
>>
File: 1458280305405.jpg (56 KB, 600x450) Image search: [Google]
1458280305405.jpg
56 KB, 600x450
>>70927045
No.
>>
>>70925862
>roman army of manlets
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 56

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.