Lets finally settle this
Which was better?
>>69742752
deadpool
>>69742752
Kino vs flick
well geez idk :^)
Both were shit
>>69742834
Literally high five for having good taste
>>69742752
>>69742752
There was nothing good about Batman vs Superman, there is no competition because there's nothing for Civil War to go up against with BvS.
BvS was a compilation of unedited unnecessary scenes with shit dialouge just scrunched together. Casting was shit minus Affleck and Cavill.
This is from someone whose always preferred the darker DC side in all media. Captain America Civil War, I was excited all the way through, and I was thinking about the flick after I saw it.
BvS was so fucking forgettable and shit, it's saddening. And I really liked Man of Steel.
TAKE THIS CAPESHIT OFF OF /tv/
TAKE THIS CAPESHIT OFF OF /tv/
TAKE THIS CAPESHIT OFF OF /tv/
This is why you guys will constantly battle this issue out: because you inherently think one was better.
They were both garbage, and the garbage won't end till you realize it. They're the cinematic equivalent of shitdick.
i enjoyed BvS a lot more, i don't get why it's gotten so many bad reviews.
civil war was just another marvel MCU flick with all the usual shit, while BvS was new and fresh.
civil war, no contest
I usually enjoy these bloated capeshit movies, but I don't think I will ever have the need to rewatch bvs
>>69743089
That's your loss
>>69742834
>Kino
>relies on JUST tweets to say it's good
>Mistah_J
>>69742752
Civil War easily.
Even funnier is it succeeded in doing the exact thing Batman v Superman couldn't. It was the cinematic equivalent of kicking an unfinished sand castle that was almost done.
>>69743214
>empire
>forbes
>variety
>usa today
>hollywood reporter
well done Shlomo
Both were shit and predictable.
One was trying too hard to be intelectual but fall flat on it's face, which is something i can expect from Snyder.
The other just had an stupid plot and bad cinematography, another bland product from Marvel.
>>69742752
Personally I enjoyed bvs more. Civil war was a better made flick but it lacked soul
>>69743296
>@SunflowerJD
>@DaniielaBernal
>@TylerGFetterman
>@vanesapaez
Bravo Zack
>>69743214
>110% Perfect
>@vanesapaez
Both were really crap
Shockingly enough BvS ended up making more sense than civil war as bizarre as that sounds .
Civil was just a cluster fuck of guest appearances and nonsensical plots left over from the original script
I hated lex...until I saw Zemo and then suddenly he didn't seem so bad.
Why not just mail Iron Man the information about his parents being killed ??
Marvel has shit villains and Zemo was the worst of them all
Ant man was cool though
>>69742752
>Civil War
I expected to see good action scenes. I expected to heard quips. I was hoping that the airport scene would be decent. I was hoping that Spiderman wouldn't suck.
Overall I was happy with the movie.
>BvsS
I hated their choice for Wonder Woman, and I was hoping that I would be wrong. I hated their choice for Luthor and I was hoping that I would be wrong. I enjoyed the animated movie The Dark Knight Returns and I was expecting something similar in the movie (until the trailer spoiled the Doomsday appearance). I enjoyed MoS so I knew what to expect from Cavil. I was expecting Batfleck to be pretty good.
Overall, the movie was ok. It didn't flow well in my opinion. As much as I hated the casting of Gadot, Eisenburg was *horrible*. I also didn't like the Flash scene: He looked ridiculous, and why did they make it appear to be a dream? Also, did they explain in the movie why Wayne had the dream about Darkseid's army?
Civil War was better by a wide margin.
>>69742752
BVS was superior. Civil War was underwhelming and the whole conflict between Cap and IM got resolved over a letter. The focus wasn't even the superhero registration act, and Zemo's plan was weak as shit.
>>69743419
>why not just mail Iron Man the information about his parents being killed ??
then he'd get to chance to think it over and not try and kill cap and bucky
>Marvel has shit villains and Zemo was the worst of them all
not even close, at least Zemo had a relatable motivation unlike the villian from any DC film except maybe ras al gul from batman begins
also how the fuck can you say BvS is more coherent? Fucking hell during the entire thing superman never even says one word to Diana during the entire film. And at the end it made literally zero sense why superman decided to fight batman.
>>69742752
A more appropiate comparison would be X-men Apocalypse vs BvS.
And even in that comparison Apocalypse wins by far
>>69743160
Not really
>>69742752
X men apocalypse.
/thread
>>69743214
>it's real
Oh my good Lord.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RvrQEKwmxqk
![oa5PStF[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/VmXfQdN.jpg "oa5PStF[1].jpg")
>>69743649
>and the whole conflict between Cap and IM got resolved over a letter
are you seriously arguing that pic related is better?
besides it wasn't resolved, they're aren't even on speaking terms.
>The focus wasn't even the superhero registration act
and thank fuck for that, who the fuck wants to watch superheroes debate law inside a courtroom
>>69742752
Civil War >>> Apocalypse >>>>>>>> BvS
Objective fact.
>>69742752
we've settled it a shitton of times imbecile
BvS>X-Men A>>>CW
![latest[2].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/oEMyaSy.jpg "latest[2].jpg")
>>69743900
>>69743883
At least Spider-Man liked it.
>>69743883
>>69743214
Jesus Christ.
Dcucks will literally defend this.
>>69743900
Switch civil quips with apoca lips and you're good.
>>69743920
Only if you rank them by shittiness
>>69742752
>Implying it debatable
MCU wins.
>>69743214
wow lol wtf are warnerbros doing
>>69743958
>>69743186
DELETE THIS
>>69743419
DAMAGE CONTROL
atleast try harder cuck>>69743958
>Newly christened as Superman, Clark Kent sets out to serve the world in his own way despite being disheartened by the planet's reception of him. Embittered by the loss of his loved ones and the futility of his crusade, Bruce Wayne vows to destroy the potential threat to humanity known as Superman. Meanwhile the enigmatic Lex Luthor manipulates the the two heroes to conflict along with creating his own weapon against the Man of Steel.
>New tragedies motivate the creation of the Sokovia Accords which split the allegiances of the Avengers down the middle. Coincidentally, the shadowy Helmut Zemo manipulates Captain America's devotion to his friend Bucky to create a rift that splits the allegiances of the Avengers down the middle.
Yeah i pick the one with actual character arcs
>>69743968
I like Apocalypse but it honestly wasn't as good as Civil War. Heck it wasn't even as good as the two preceeding X-men movies. It was an alright movie, but also nothing that blew my mind
I DON'T KNOW CAUSE I DON'T WASTE MY MONEY ON JEWISH MEDIA
YOU ARE ALL BRAINWASHED
>>69743992
I'm almost positive that Pulitzer recipient @DFinley22 was referring to Gal murdering Wonder Woman and everything her character was supposed to be.
>>69743214
I still can't believe respectable film reviewers gave this trash five stars
Just because this board is swarmed by brainwashed Marvelets it doesn't make CW better.
>>69743942
>DCucks damage control is getting worse
>>69744111
Haven't paid a dime for either Batman v Superman or Civil War.
Civil War was still better. At least it knew what it was and didn't pathetically try and fail to be deep.
>>69743883
How JUST is Warner even at this point?
>>69743081
What was new and fresh about BvS?
Boring dialog, editing mess, plot that makes little sense, usual build up to a big CGI mess fight. Fake death scene.
Fresh and new kek
>>69744111
>>69743883
Look at this dude...
>>69744202
I swear Hancock did everything BvS tried to do but ten times better.
And that's saying something because Hancock was a piece of shit
>>69744202
Dcucks are pulling the "what's the matter, too deep for you?" card because they're too young to know that we used to mock that shit on sight.
BvS' plot is silly, but CW's is stupid
I'll never rewatch either
>>69743883
JUST
>>69744269
I'll agree with that. What's sad is I feel getting a better actress to play Hancock's wife would've helped. Ever since Monster Charlize just shut the fuck down and phones every performance in.
>>69744290
>Lol they're both shit
>haven't watched either xd
Are you literally 13 years old?
>>69743893
Yes, that was better. Considering they didn't know each other and Bruce's trauma with his parents this served a much better purpose as a stop sign for the battle.
The conflict in Civil War was handled in the last 15 minutes and it was over something that could've happened even if Zemo didn't interfere. It was superficial and the fact Tony reads the letter and doesn't crush it or show any signs of being infuriated by it is more indicative that it did make amends rather than antagonizing them more.
The registration act was something that tested the very fiber of their being, with IM becoming more authoritative and shit. It was going to create a deeper conflict than MyParentsGotBucky'd.avi.
A movie about the registration act wouldn't have to be in a courtroom. It would be more akin to an Empire vs Resistance kind of thing, and much more suitable for something called Civil War, man.
>>69744345
He said never rewatch. Which means he's seen them once already.
Over
http://www.nationalreview.com/article/433246/batman-v-superman-culture-war-gets-mythic
http://www.nationalreview.com/article/435036/captain-america-superheroes-dumbed-down
>>69744361
Yeah, the end of Civil War felt like Joss Whedons directing and script.
They're best friends again at the end of the movie. IM should have done something like you said. Even if he threw that box in the air and a glove few on his hand and he blew it up or some shit.
Instead it's "everyone is friends again hehe". No doubt Marvel interfered with Russos. Especially since this was essentially an Avengers movie.
>>69744361
>It was superficial and the fact Tony reads the letter and doesn't crush it or show any signs of being infuriated
I feel the same. Movie was a solid 7 until that ending.
But i hope it just meant that Tony was only tired, that would be the reason of why he didn't go to the Raft to fight all of them.
Anyway, i'm happy i didn't pay to see it.
>>69744428
Yep. Obvious Civil War pretty much took the cake this round. Our contrarian king has spoken. Civil War is far better than BvS.
BvS was messy, poorly edited and rushed. There is the kernel of a great film within it, but it was let down by trying to cram too many plot elements into it, even if some of the scenes and dialogue were superb. If it had been done in two parts or maybe if some bits had been introduced in prequels, then it might have worked better. I get the impression that Snyder has a huge, epic, director's cut version coming which could be a genuine masterpiece.
Civil War was actually a disappointment. MCU usually deliver very solid, if uninspired, pieces. But CW was dull. The plot was never really tackled in a meaningful way because they were too busy trying to work all of the characters in. The whole Bucky storyline (continued from WS) was hamfisted. For me, it really struggled. Something was missing. Maybe the (supposed) seriousness of the plot cast a pall over it that destroyed any chemistry between the cast. Even the quips were irksome.
Of the two, I think I enjoyed BvS more. I felt that, thematically, it had more meat. There was more to think about. CW was just a big disappointment - it frustrated me the entire way through.
>>69744428
Lel contrarian republican gay nigger that thought they kicked him of RT because of racial issues.
>>69744485
>They're best friends again at the end of the movie.
Iron Man just looked even more hurt when he read the letter from where I was sitting. It's also been confirmed that their feud isn't over.
>>69743698
>then he'd get to chance to think it over and not try and kill cap and bucky
Zemo had no way of knowing they'd be the ones showing up to stop him - those specific three. You can backtrack from there to a vast array of circumstances he had no control over that all influence his "big reveal" having any effect whatsoever, not the least of which is whether Rogers had already shared with Stark what he already knew about Hydra's involvement with the Starks' deaths.
For his plot to work as presented, Zemo has to be an omniscient, precognitive chessmaster moving all the pieces through the means of vast resources it's never even hinted he has. If you want to make that case, be my guest. Just don't expect any of it to ever be revisited in the MCU.
>>69744428
>can't even review on Rotten fucking Tomatoes anymore because he's such a fucking intentionally bad critic
kek
>Superma dies
>"Wow yeah right we all know theyll just bring back Superman in the next one. Wheres the stakes?"
>Captain America writes a cute letter pretty much saying 'See you in the next movie bro!'
>"10/10 theres real emotional stakes here and fun and heart and love for the characters and hardhitting drama. Its a real psychological thriller you see, thats how most thrillers end: apology letters"
>>69744698
This guy right here is implying no one shat on CW for not killing off Cap. He think everyone is agains him, look at this poor soul.
>>69744740
XD made me laugh
>>69744740
Yes, the quote clarifies nothing. Who even clicks those post numbers anymore?
>>69743698
Zemo's plan was absolutely idiotic . Just give it up.
>zemo motivation
>revenge
Very original
I didn't understand what was going on in bvs i mean what the fuck was with that desert scene with the flying monkeys also i didnt have any fun and it was to dark and depressing where were the quips
I feel sorry for you, I really do.
Disney has you by the balls, and because of that you won't be able to appreciate the depth and complexity of BvS yet. But your time will come.
>>69744698
Looked like the apology letter backfired. Calling it.
>>69744565
>The whole Bucky storyline (continued from WS) was hamfisted.
Well, yeah. Their plan was to do a WS centered movie but RDJ came and public opinion turned it into Civil War.
I'm seeing a lot of parallels here:
>Goyer writes Man of Steel 2.
>Markus and Mcfeely write Winter Soldier part 2.
>Retarded executives scrap those plans and turn them into clusterfucks.
>>69744990
At the very least Civil War was a more entertaining clusterfuck.
Marvelettes on suicide watch.
>>69745225
The most ironic picture I've seen since she clearly fucked Will Smith.
>>69745225
Why would they be on suicide watch?
Marvel fanboys have to be the most content, confidently smug, fanboys on the planet right now.
>>69745372
>Marvel fanboys have to be the most content, confidently smug, fanboys on the planet right now.
Indeed
>>69745372
>>69745446
It's hard to say Marvel didn't win or won't win in the future. DC was dead before it even left the ground.
>>69745372
>>69745446
Kek, I can feel your anger through your screen
>>69745664
Do you cry yourself to sleep too?
>Marvel nu-males hate Snyder
I'm not surprised. After all, their idols are Peyton Reed and Joss Whedon.
Seeing an alpha male like Zack Snyder causes them to remember how they were bullied by an alpha male and uncomfortable and lash out the only way they know how -impotently typing out hateful words on a Japanese jpeg board. Some, like Ant-Man director Peyton Reed when shown a statement from a capeflick rumor monger saying "DC directors can physically beat up Marvel directors," choose to withdraw into safe spaces instead. It's little wonder why /tv/ connects with Marvel more.
>mfw X-Men was also better than BvS
>>69745799
Snyder directs in sweatpants and Under Armour wristbands.
If that's not badass I don't know what is. Nerds can't stand that an alpha auteur is in control of their products, and he's elevating them to heights their puny brains can't comprehend. They can't stand that someone who appears on the outside as a manchild with a comic book fetish, is pushing the medium further than they thought possible.
Snyder, Affleck, and Cavill get the bitches and gays all juicy. They are just ripe with raw sexual energy. This offends the virginal fanboi. MoS and BvS deal with emotional issues and belief systems in a mature way. This doubly offends the fanboi, who is stuck in perpetual adolescence. They can't process or register mature emotions. And people hate what they don't understand.
>>69745724
It just wasn't funny, anon. It's a joke I've seen hundreds of times.
>>69745892
>it's bad to be a manchild unless you're Zack Snyder
Go to bed, Zack.
We "finally" settled this twice now.
Pic related was the first poll.
We had another poll made by an obvious DC fanboy where Civil War was winning until the OP unlocked IPs, meaning someone could vote as many times as they wanted, when BvS *suddenly* surged in votes by the hundreds...when the thread had 16 IPs.
>>69745791
No, I have tranquile dreams that reflect my current state of mind, unlike you who are slowly coming to the realization that you've invested unsurmountable time, money, and emotion in a Disney mass heist.
>>69745892
>>69745799
Joss Whedon: 5'10"
Zack Snyder: 5'7"
>>69746391
>Zack Snyder: 5'7"
when will they learn ?
