The Seeds of Death edition
Previously: >>67256335
What does /who/ think of The Seeds of Death?
>>67279578
Nah pretty sure people know who Moffat is. He just won an OBE.
>>67279637
Phucking shite.
>>67279615
Now that I think of it you're probably right.
>reminder that some persons consider series 9 to be metaphorical pig droppings
>>67279694
>implying it's better than Vincent And The Doctor or Pandorica Opens
>>67279637
Oh wow one I've actually watched.
It's alright. The fucking around in the huge foam pit is the best part.
>>67279727
it is
>>67279752
Nah.
>>67279529
How do you vote in an AI? How do they get people? I've never known a single person who votes in it. What if its a big government conspiracy?
>>67279637
what's with the Ice Warrior, I thought Seeds of Death featured a giant plant monster.
>>67279727
I certainly appreciate both examples, but I'll remind that I stated "run for their money". Not necessarily a concrete statement of supremecy.
>>67279791
You're thinking of The Seeds of Doom.
>>67279791
Seeds of DOOM. Can't you READ????
>>67279637
what's with the Ice Warrior, I thought Seeds of Death featured the Eminence.
>>67279657
Never read that but it wouldn't surprise me at all.
>>67279863
You're thinking of The Seeds of War.
Remember when "Jenny" was in the cast list for Good Man Goes to War and some people were convinced that Jenny from Doctor's Daughter was returning? That was a great Mofftroll.
>>67279835
>>67279891
So what's The Seeds of Fear?
>>67279668
No, the general public don't.
>>67279910
Nah you're thinking about Seeds of the Doctor
>>67279914
Yeah they do.
>>67279914
they do anon!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
>>67279637
Very good, though not as weird as the best of season six, but it has that striking look of being shot on black-and-white 625-line video.
>>67279914
I know Moffat.
>>67279929
>>67279953
If you think the million and a bit viewers Doctor Who lost will come back because the executive producer is moving on at the end of the season, you are on the autistic spectrum.
>>67279925
I am now.
>>67280025
Perhaps you underestimate the sophistication of the viewing public anon.
>>67279978
Wait, when I say 'very good', I should clarify that I mean in terms of suspense and design. Story-wise it's nothing unusual, but the production lifts it.
doctor who more like doctor poo
>>67279610
not that guy but I wouldn't call it a drop either
it stays roughly in the same range
Deep Breath AI 82
Into the Dalek AI 84
Robot of Sherwood AI 82
Listen AI 82
Time Heist AI 84
The Caretaker AI 83
Kill the Moon AI 82
Mummy o/t Orient Express AI 85
Flatline AI 85
In the Forest of the Night AI 83
Dark Water AI 85
Death in Heaven AI 83
Last Christmas AI 82
The Magician’s Apprentice AI 84
The Witch’s Familiar AI 83
Under the Lake AI 84
Before the Flood AI 83
The Girl Who Died AI 82
The Woman Who Lived AI 81
The Zygon Invasion AI 82
The Zygon Inversion AI 84
Sleep No More AI 78
Face the Raven AI 84
Heaven Sent AI 80
Hell Bent AI 82
The Husbands of River Song AI 82
>>67280089
Knowing the name of the executive producer of a TV show isn't sophistication.
Zoe's least eye-catching outfit, though.
>>67280025
It depends entirely on the marketing
If they promote S11 as 'featuring a new showrunner who worked on broadchurch' they will likely attract more people because they will be curious to see what's different
If all they say is 'moffat's fucked off' less people would care
>>67279637
Looks like lego
>>67280201
No, they genuinely would not. Normal people, the kind Doctor Who relies upon to remain profitable, could not be less interested in the names that go up at the end, most of them turn over.
>>67280232
Wrong m8.
>>67280156
>Knowing the names of city council members isn't sophistication.
Reminder Capaldi should stay to make Chibnall watchable.
>>67280232
Everyone knew Vince Gilligan when Breaking Bad was on, I'd say Moffat is the Brit equivalent
>>67280141
Its the two experimental episodes SNM and Heaven Sent that bring it down. I thought SNM was mediocre but I hope this doesn't scare them off from trying different things.The Woman Who Lived was a bit low too. Was it because of the lack of companion?
Wendy Padbury's arse is so exquisite that I'm tempted to believe her shit tastes like Nutella. It would be worth getting proved wrong just to get my tongue up her anus.
>>67280232
Have you forgotten the interest that was generated when S5 started? They highlight the fact that something's new, and it attracts curious people who wouldn't regularly watch the show
>>67280313
I live in Britain, no he isn't.
>>67280316
Woman who lived had the Catman who had no relation of Survival and Dick Jokes. Companion lack was a footnote.
>>67280347
No, I haven't forgotten the interest that was generated by two new stars, no. Nothing to do with the production staff.
Chronological anon, just finished Prison in Space, it wasfun.
listening to Rosemariners now, based David Warner
>>67280316
Well Heaven Sent got great reviews. I don't think we'll see the end of experimental episodes.
>>67280398
Other episodes have had dick jokes and silly aliens and scored better.
>>67280316
Dude, Heaven Sent was the one highlight.
Smoke some more cush, brah.
>>67280440
Liked it when it seemed like the solution would be ingenious. Meh'd when it turned out to be dumb.
>>67280473
>dick jokes
Crimson Horror sonic erection (and who could blame)
anyone got more?
>>67280469
I think he's attempting to say that the Cat man alien in Woman Who Lived should have been related to the cat people from the Cheetah planet in Survival. Not sure how that would have helped it get a higher AI.
>>67280492
Yeah, it was a highlight for me. I was replying to the post showing it had the second lowest AI score of the series though.
>>67280504
The breaking the wall scene was the best part mate.
>>67280521
Slab fellatio in Love & Monsters.
>>67280521
Day of the Doctor, Doctors comparing sonic erection
Deep Breath, the sonic hits the Doctor in the dick
>>67280577
But it looked like a fucking Swiss watch mate, proper sophisticated, and then he's like 'ull fuckin smash it mate'.
>>67280590
Tennent and Smith comparing Sonics:
"Compensating are we?"
>>67280627
The ironic part is matt has a bigger willy than tennant
>>67280627
>tfw that joke is ruined after the fappening leaks
When the first lady Doctor happens, I hope we see the regen from the POV of the Doc's trousers, as his junk agonisingly concaves.
>>67280616
>GOAT music
>GOAT Capaldi
>the poem
>constantly dying and doing it again
Nah m8 it was intense as fuck and the best part.
>>67280705
Compensating for the face
>>67280705
How many of the Doctors have dick pics floating around the internet?
>Tom
>Ecclescake
>Teninch
>Matt
>Capaldi if you count pic related
>>67280728
Doctor Who was hit by the fappening?
Why?
>>67280763
I still remember the day the legend of Tom's gaint wang died
>>67280763
Tom Baker, eh?
I am not asking for a link.
Not doing that. Nope.
>>67280750
It was intense...ly disappointing.
>>67280780
Just Matt Smith. He was a bystander in his gf at the time's leaks.
>>67280798
And I am not, in any way, suggesting that you google"Tom Baker Canterbury Tales".
>>67280791
Although his physical wang may be aevrage.
His emotional wang it gaint.
It's like his heart and his heart as well all know is mighty.
In a way his wang is part of who we are, and we it.
We all have a little bit of Tom Bakers Gaint Wang inside of us.
>tfw wang became a teacher got a GF and no longer has time for /who/
He was the best poster. Him and Faceless made night /who/ so comfy. Now neither of them post. What the fuck happened to Faceless anyways? He started to become really shitposty and agressive and then I never saw him again,.
>>67280827
Naw, you're looking at it all wrong.
in 50+ years of a TV show, the most impressive feat is this:
Do something new.
Hell Bent succeeded swimmingly at this.
>>67280798
He claimed in his autobiography it was really a screwdriver handle wrapped with gaffer tape. Didn't look it to me, but they can do wonders with camera tricks.
>>67280861
Huh?
>>67280744
>implying the Doctor's time tentacles change with sex
>>67280859
>What the fuck happened to Faceless anyways? He started to become really shitposty and agressive and then I never saw him again,.
Dying while your mother being fucked by a milkman all the time would make you sour too, I'd imagine.
I havent seen him since before the holidays.
You can still find wang on tumblr.
>>67280897
Who?
>>67280835
Oh right, well as long as nobody actively wanted to see Matt Smith's mutton dagger. That would be odd.
>>67280842it's average and he had a nice ass
>>67280924
>implying you don't get curious
>>67280861
Not really when the vast majority of the show was two or three highly padded plots done again and again.
I was talking about Heaven Sent. Hell Bent was just the usual bollocks.
>>67280763
>that image
>>67280902
He has a cock and balls, it's canon. Capaldi is I think quite well endowed in that department, but I don't know where I heard that.
>>67280912
Surely Wang could spare a few mintues or two just to say Hello? I want muh comfy /who/ back.
>>67280939
Not about Doctor actors, no. Baker T put me off, I
>>67280521
Would Missy tickling a Dalek's ball whilst implying it's a testicle count?
>>67281022
... guess.
>>67280763
Photos of Mccoy are online from his old stage act before he was acting. It looked small.
Bearing in mind he was on stage and flaccid.
>>67280744
>the Master's face when it happened to him
>>67280959
Christ I've gotten confused. Hell Bent Was bollocks, as you say.
I meant to defend the one where he dies over and over in the confession dial.
Damn.
>>67280895
How is Davison ever going to top "Who in the World"?
>tfw John Simm could have been the best Master if it wasn't for the useless drums and having to play the role really OTT and pantoish
>>67280959
Hell Bent was GOAT.
>>67280990
I wish he would too from time to time. I think i even asked him to on his ama thingy on his tumblr. I suspect he's occasionally here as anon, just a feeling i get, but /who/ nose? Probably just ghosts.
I should mention he's married now, I'd guess to the same girl...And I just checked his tumblr has been deleted. Sorry.
>>67281090
>Christ
>not Christel
>>67281090
That's Heaven Sent. I think most of it was different, I think the [SURGING MUSIC] MUH FEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEELS ending was what we've come to expect, unfortunately.
>>67281225
back once again
it's the renegade time lord
killing all the people
>>67281201
> gets married
> disappears
It's like the last Quantum Leap.
>>67281277
Back once again
It's the renegade Pie Lord
Eating all the people
>>67281166
Nah. It really wasn't.
>>67281322
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hfgjC2LJ3UI
>>67281267
>Muh Feels ending
Wut? You thinking of a different episode m8? What would you have preferred then?
You're a Rose now
The new companion is reluctant to get inside the TARDIS because she's claustrophobic and thinks it's a really small box at first.
>>67281507
That would make for an interesting first companion story.
>>67281507
no she isn't
>>67281358
On the one hand, this is 6 minutes more original Doctor Who related media that I have ever created, and as such I'm not in the greatest position to criticize.
On the other hand, this is fucking shyte.
>tfw leak /who/ will never return
I want scripts and episodes leaks for S10 like S8.
>>67281622
it'd never happen, moff erased marcelo carmago from doctor who
>>67281622
>tfw scripts leak tomorrow before filming starts and Moffat just decides to quit early followed by Capaldi and we're getting Chibnall Who next year
Are you sure anon?
>>67281376
No, the montage is meant to be an erhmergerd, Doc is so based moment. I would have preferred something I hadn't already thought of and dismissed as too basic.
>>67281666
>implying Moffat can resign during his contract
We'll still be getting a Moff s10.
>>67281694
>erhmergerd
>>67281696
>implying the Moffat isn't leaving whenever the fuck he wants
>>67281619
It was a /who/ project, more intended as a meme than to be actually good. See
http://doctorwhogeneral.wikia.com/wiki/Small_beginnings
>>67281666
tfw is just mfw without having to post a fw
>>67281818
The Missing Tupperware is GOAT though
>>67281818
Say, anything ever come of Foreman?
>>67281201
I suspect wang's smart enough to know that in the long run taking a trip is more trouble than it's worth and ends up lowering the quality of threads.
>>67281894
Nope. Probably dead at this point.
Remember when someone on here infiltrated into Foreman pretending to want to write a story for them and got access to their "series bible" and it was just a cesspool of autism?
>>67281996
do we still have the link to it?
>>67281201
>tfw I will never be remembered this fondly
s-should I adopt a trip?
>>67282022
Yes, did you think it might have evaporated or something?
http://pastebin.com/ZpfdYVWF
>>67282072
No.
>>67281940
Everyone loved Wang though. We did strawpolls and he was always considered to be the best trip. I remember when I jokingly said everyone should drop their trips for a few days just to see what would happen and Wang said he'd do it for a week and all the other trips gave in like a day later and acted like little bitches while Wang lasted the whole week before ever turning it back on.
>yfw there are people in this thread RIGHT NOW who have no idea who Wang is
>>67281619
Yeah, I couldn't listen to more than a minute of it. People trying to imitate characters' voices is always cringey to me unless they do it really, really well.
We should still do a short story anthology. Get all the wiki writers on board
>>67282207
Yeah I liked that idea. I was going to make a cover.
>>67282207
collaborative writing
tools / websites?
>>67282072
Depends whether you are actually a cool dude like Wang or a faggot like FNA.
>>67282207
the literal virgin new adventures?
i still have an unfinished jazz hands regen story for that, i havent worked on it in ages, but ill have some free time very soon so ill work on it
>>67282243
'Collaborative writing' just turns into autism with everyone spamming it. Not saying we couldn't do a story that way but letting people do their own (with zero quality control) would be more productive.
>>67279637
>What does /who/ think of The Seeds of Death?
Don't know. I've never seen it. TBQH I don't watch much Dr Who anymore. I'm just here for the dank memes.
>>67282500
oh lovely, lovely cunt
>>67282583
Well thanks for commenting.
>>67282583
What's your favourite dank /who/ meme?
>>67282633
You are most welcome.
>>67282658
To be replaced by Katy Manning, who could fit your entire tackle in her mouth.
What will you guys give me for this?
>>67282765
10p
>>67282367
FNA is a qt faggot
>>67282658
I like the one where we all pretend series 9 is good.
>>67282765
Grill it with cheese.
>>67282765
blowjob
>>67282792
lmao is this actually fna?
>>67282946
But it was good. The return of the Daleks, the Doctor on an alien planet once more, the return of the Silurians with the Master, and ahahahahaha do you see i did it again
>Reminder that Perspective
reminder if you weren't around for the wang days you don't belong here
get out.
>>67283088
>muh supar sekrit klub
>no grils
>no newfags
>>67282946
You mean the one where we pretend Doctor Who is good?
>>67279637
>a pessimistic portrayal of a 21st century where humans have lost interest in traveling beyond the moon thanks to their convenient teleports
>reality is the same minus the teleports
>>67282081
Should we put the bible on the wiki?
>>67283129
GET OUT REEEEEEEEEEEE
>>67283065
Don't you remember how he thought it was a brilliant idea to make a /who/ subreddit, which he made with his own reddit account with 2 years worth of porn requests?
He used that same username for youtube, that pic is from 2011 but it's him
>>67283138
On rare occasions it sometimes is good.
>>67283139
It's because military technology has gone beyond the idea of bombardment from space, the only reason nations ever went there.
>>67283179
Like series 9
>>67283179
Nah it's always been shit and will forever be shit. That's why its fun.
>>67283170
This would only be worth doing if we went through and added a shitload of our own commentary and annotations.
>>67283186
Rods of God will still happen at some point.
>>67283139
Despite romantic portrayal in fiction, distant worlds are barren rocks that are pointless to explore on foot.
>>67283190
I couldn't say. I didn't watch it.
>>67283206
But there's good shit and awful shit. The good shit only really comes along once in a blue moon.
>>67283190
spit_take.jpg
>>67283139
>"And that's nothing, 'cause the human race will spread out among the stars, oh, you just watch them fly. Billions and billions of them for billions and billions of years - and each and every one of them, at some point in their lives, will look back at this man making that very first step. And they will never, ever forget it."
>>67283175
Fna is on the bottom tier of trip lists
cats is near the top. he has moments of brilliance desu.
>>67283308
I know that's you catsyou're right though
>>67283333
I'm not cats.
>>67283333
nice quads - its not me tho
i do occasionally take off my trip to make my opinions seem more popular tho :)
>>67283175
i remember that, but he deleted all his videos :(
>>67283280
Sorry m8 he's right. You're just gonna have to deal with the fact that it was objectively the best of NuWho and if you disagree if you have shit taste in Doctor Who.
>>67283458
I snuck a screenshot in before he removed them
I was about to download it to make a webm when he hid them all
>>67283473
>Love and monsters above evolution of the daleks
kek
>>67283175
> with 2 years worth of porn requests?
oh yeah lol, pic related
>>67283531
I'd say it was a little better. They're both pretty bad though.
>>67283473
It's only ranked the most popular because it's the most recent.
People thought Series 4 was the bees knees before Planet of the Dead.
>>67283531
Of all the things to disagree with anon
Question:
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dI5BUSpfzPw
This time vortex that was used for basically all of the S5 promos...
...why was it never used?
>>67283550
Yeah, at least L&M was only a one parter.
>>67283473
>mfw colin is still ranked near the bottom
>>67283578
Yeah I don't know how Tennant got so high.
>>67283578
That's fair. Not everybody listens to the audio stories.
>>67283563
I wondered it at the time too
It's either a mid-production concept that was changed before S5 aired, or it was never actually meant to be the time vortex
>>67283556
I see people praise S4 all the time.
>>67283473
>S9 only has one GOAT but has the highest average quality of all
I always told you this
nobody ever believed me
then you all proved me right
>>67283619
It was GOAT though. Way better than wibbly wobbly stormy wormy.
>>67283637
I see people with stains on their trousers.
>>67283578
>mfw both of my favourite Drs are ranked bottom
>>67283556
why is series 8 still so high?
>>67283652
It looked too much like water
>>67283637
Cause of the Ten/Donna combo. It only had 3 good episodes
>>67283664
Hurt is in your top 2?
>>67283675
Because it was the golden series
>>67283556
Nah everyone hated S4.
>>67283675
Because it was reasonably well made.
>>67283714
Yes.
>>67283714
War is GOAT.
http://poal.me/ht7mdb
>>67283793
G
R
8
B
8
M
8
Also, War is NOT canon as his own Doctor. He is an AGED 8th Doctor.
>>67283793
First objectively correct statement of the thread.
>>67283833
bad b8 m8
>>67283749
Cool. I love him too. I never hear anyone call him a favourite though.
>>67283829
BUT I'M CLEVAH!!!
>>67283829
How is this a question? The Sontaran two-parter doesn't even have a 'good bit' at the end
>>67283859
It'll be while, he's in the position 8 was circa 1999. Wait 'till he gets his own Chimes-tier story
>>67283859
Yeah, I'm gutted we're only getting two more box sets.
>>67283905
>implying Briggs Finish will ever make something that GOAT again
>>67283897
This. Those episodes were fuck awful. The return of the sontarans and they gave it to the writer of Daleks In Manhattan....There's a reason why pretty much no one remembers it anymore.
>>67283897
They're not all that similar but they reminded me of each other and that invited some comparison. Invasion theme and evil doppelganger of companion, UNIT involvement.
Remember the cliffhanger where Wilf was trapped in the car and couldn't breathe? That was so bad its good.
>>67283913
Only two more after Infernal Devices? Is this final?
>>67283897
The Valiant showed up for a little bit
remember the valiant?
>>67284095
I don't know if it's final but it's what's planned.
>>67284070
it wasn't bad, it was foreshadowing the end of time
>>67284131
Maybe Hurt will be up for more in the future.
>>67284148
>bee.webm
>is a wasp
>>67284126
Man the Valiant Effects look so bad now.
Shame they didn't do a real model like the scene in Trial Of A Time Lord.
>>67284144
I don't want to associate one of the few good scenes from EoT with that awful cliffhanger anon.
>>67284201
They always did.
>>67284162
I do hope so. I had given up on hearing David Warner's Dr again but they've gone and got him for the new Bernice Summerfield series. So it could happen.
Someone help me recover this magnificent Peter Capaldi video pls ;_;
https://youtu.be/DaMb-5w-V0Y
>>67284241
Yeah you're probably right.
>tfw RTD Who looks worse than Classic Who
>>67283473
I always think it's a bit odd to put Hurt into these Doctor-polls. He only had a single episode, and he was not even the lead actor there. It's like treating David Warner's character from Cold War as a companion.Technically it matches the definition but they're treated very differently in the actual stories.
I think in these situations people care way too much about continuity and canon so that the obvious things get out of sight.
>>67284328
He has a book and Hurt is doing Audios now.
He's the doctor that fought in the Time War, he as canon as all the others.
.
>>67283473
It's a shame that I share the thread with imbeciles who think season 9 is good.
>>67284355
In the audios, 8 fought the Time War.
>>67284292
Computer graphics rendered at <480
>>67284387
No?
>>67284373
But it is, you've got the first Dalek story in five years, the first Ice Warriors in four, the return of AHAHAHAHA I DID IT AGAIN
>>67284373
Can you faggots shut up about series 9 for once?
>>67284257
HELP ME
>>67284373
>>67284387
Only in one box set and that isn't out yet
>>67284387
>In the audios
Only in the beginning of the war.
>>67284435
It's the most recent Series, so of course we can't shut up about it.
Come back in two years.
>>67284405
Yes.
>>67284328
>Haha, TV Doctor Who only for me thanks!
>>67284456
Because they stole his fucking territory after RTD gave it them.
>>67284466
No you fucking dipshit. 8 only fought in the beginning of the war that's what the audios are based on
>>67284487
> haha I'll listen to shit-tier fan fiction read out by long term dole queue resident has-beens as long as it's licenced
>>67284457
But you're just repeating the same moronic butthurt over and over.
>Series 9 was pigshit!
>Series 9 was GOAT!
>Series 9 was bad ratings prove it!
>Series 9 was good critical acclaim proves it!
Shut the fuck up about it if you don't have anything to say.
>>67284355
>He's the doctor that fought in the Time War, he as canon as all the others.
yes, I know, but as I said, canon in this case doesn't help us. Hurt is really hard to rate as a Doctor because he didn't have a story where he actually was THE doctor, in Day he was merely ONE OF the doctors. It's like rating Troughton purely based on his perfomance in The Three Doctors where he was a comedic foil to Pertwee, and not the three seasons of Doctor Who where he was in charge, know what I mean? It's a bit unfair and in my opinion kind of pointless.
>>67284508
Because Moff took back what RTD gave them.
>>67284591
Wut? They couldn't use NuWho stuff until recently.
>>67284560
Well that's like.. your opinion, man.
>>67284591
Didn't RTD tell the comics they could regenerate 8 into 9 in his last strip?
>>67284611
RTD specifically said in 2005 that the Time War was for other media to flesh out and wouldn't be shown on screen.
>>67284644
So? I don't get what you're saying.
>>67284621
Yeah, why are you telling me stuff that proves my point? RTD understood what to do with the EU, Moff doesn't.
>>67284681
What I'm saying is: making Hurt canon involves shitting on existing work that had a better rationale.
>>67284535
Dank meme dude, so sick
>>67284535
>because watching shit tier fan fiction is so much better.
>>67284711
I dunno, I haven't been following the conversation that close but I thought your point was that RTD intended 8 to fight in the Time War. Which wouldn't have been true if they'd regenerated him in his last comic story like RTD suggested.
>>67284781
Doctor Who is a television programme. That's it. The rest of it is skid marks from a tramp's actual and literal undercrackers.
>>67284644
And that was a legally binding contract, was it? As opposed to a general (and generally accurate) statement about how much the new series would end up depicting the Time War?
FUCKING KEK.
The Chinballs image from the wiki is one of the first images in the search results if you type in Christ Chibnall into google images.
