[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
5>4>3>6>1>2 search your feelings, you know it
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /tv/ - Television & Film

Thread replies: 119
Thread images: 17
File: 103012-star-wars111.jpg (86 KB, 620x375) Image search: [Google]
103012-star-wars111.jpg
86 KB, 620x375
5>4>3>6>1>2
search your feelings, you know it to be true.
>>
>>63247232
3>6
what?
>>
2 is the only Starwars film i ever bought on tape or disc because of the sound design.

Suck on dem lemons
>>
>>63247232
5 was the best a a sequel, as a standalone 4 was GOAT
>>
>>63247247
do you have a problem with the correct order?
>>
>>63247232
I know it's played out to say so, but "I am your father" was seriously the fucking coolest thing ever. Nothing will ever beat that.
>there are autists who will show their kids the prequels first and cheat them out of that
>>
>>63247232
Fuck you and all your prequel shit I bet you are excited for the Abrams movie.
>>
>>63247232
I love how retards have convinced each other RotS was actually a good movie. It's like a chain reaction of delusion; one of them says it and they all latch on. Every positive review of RotS I've seen is just a list of things that weren't completely ruined in it, as opposed to the the other two. That doesn't make it a good movie you shits, it's just as bad as TPM, just for different reasons.
>>
>>63247313
>not showing them the best order of 4>5>1>3>6 in order to give the greatest impact when you get to episode 6
>>
>>63247247
ewoks ruined the movie
>>
>>63247294
There will never be an end to the argument between prequel and OT fans. Can't we agree that they should be judged by their own tier?
3>2>1
5>4>6
7>?>?
>>
File: 1446766642673.jpg (103 KB, 355x642) Image search: [Google]
1446766642673.jpg
103 KB, 355x642
5>4>6>POWER GAP>2>3>POWER GAP>1
>>
>>63247322
TPM was bad because it was slow and because they explained the force.

AotC was bad because hilariously bad dialogue and a terribly done, hamfisted romance

RotS was meh because of hilariously bad dialogue, but saved by hammy acting and powerful scenes

star wars was good as a standalone, but riddled with plot holes and mediocre writing as a franchise

empire was...uh....
yeah, empire was good.

jedi was a terrible attempt to tie everything into a bow, including character 180s and a contrived ending.


gungans=ewoks=C-3P0
>>
>>63247332
>1-3-6
>not superior 2-3-6
>>
>>63247412
>voluntarily watching 2
>>
>>63247232

So close

5>4>6>>3>1>=2
>>
5>6=4>Tartakovsky's Clone Wars>>>Clone Wars tv show>3=1>Rebels>Clone Wars movie>>>2
>>
>>63247313
>there are autists who will show their kids the prequels first and cheat them out of that

I am that kid
Not only did I get cheated out of that, but I found the prequels so boring as a kid that I stopped paying attention by the time we got to the original movies that I never actually watched the good star wars movies properly as a kid

Last week was the first time I watched star wars
>>
The correct order is 4>5>6>3>1>2, you stuck-up, half-witted, scruffy-looking nerf-herder.
>>
>>63247362
>2 better than 3
>>
File: 1443225414675.jpg (17 KB, 220x246) Image search: [Google]
1443225414675.jpg
17 KB, 220x246
>watching anything other than the despecialized versions of the original trilogy
>>
>>63247426
>jumping from 1 to 3
>Anakin goes from little kid to being married to Padme with no explanation
>>
>>63247465
who you calling scruffy looking?
>>
>>63247456
What did you think?
>>
>>63247486
>go into episode 2
>no idea why obi-wan would ever train a little shit like anakin
>>
>>63247489
>who you calling scruffy looking?
>not "Who's scruffy-looking?"
You can fuck off and all.
>>
>>63247232
> 3>6>1>2
holy shit, u r faget anon
>>
i dont understand people that say 3 > 6

like did they even see the movie? that mustafar scene is literally The Room tier
>>
>ewoks are bad

when will this meme end
>>
TPP was the worst
At least AOTC had Obi-Wan in the lead role
>>
>>63247514
>skip from 1 to 3
>Count Dooku is literally nobody, comes out of literally nowhere, took Anakin's hand offscreen, and dies in the same scene he is introduced
Why do you hate your kids?
>>
>>63247232
>3>6
Are you threatening me, Master Jedi?
>>
>>63247340
>>63247362
>attack of the clones
>better than anything
fucking niggers, man. I swear.
>>
File: Mace_Windu.jpg (40 KB, 400x550) Image search: [Google]
Mace_Windu.jpg
40 KB, 400x550
>>63247570
you mean like obi-wan or yoda?

>>63247575
the senate will decide your fate.
>>
>>63247510

I watched the original trilogy first. Started with some random online stream of A New Hope but it was the blu ray version with all of the random CG scenes added in that clearly did not belong. Made sure to watch the despecialized versions of Empire and Jedi because of that
The movies are really good, super engaging and fun. I like how they focus most on the characters instead of the fact that it's scifi.

Then I watched the prequels and they were boring as fuck. plinkett does a good job of explaining on a technical level what about the movies made them so disinteresting to watch

I didn't care much about Force Awakens before besides respecting what a big deal it was, now I'm super hyped
>>
>>63247247
He's right. 6 was a terrible sequel to 5, and the movie is very bad. The only saving grace is the fucking great final showdown where Luke beats Vader, and then spares his life. That's also the best duel in the entire saga, since it had 3 movies leading up to it.
>>
>>63247514

Obi wan gave qui-gon booze his word
>>
>>63247530
Those people fell for "darker movie" meme, some of them listened reviews, including Plinkett's that actually said some good things about it. Some of them seem to enjoy those emotions from highgrounded Anakin, Order 66 scene and overall increase of quality from ep. II nd I agree with them, but they seem to forget rest of the movie was mostly the same boring shit with some even more hilarious moments than sandhating in AotC.

Ep. VI's main fault were Ewoks, but it's still not that bad, since that battle is at least fun unlike Wookie CGIfest. Also everything else was great, especially everything about Hutts and final confrontation that were GOAT moments. Fuck, that one fight between Luke and Vader has more emotion into it than all prequels combined with animated series.

If not for Ewoks, I'd say it would be even better than ep. V.
>>
This '6 is a bad movie' meme is getting old
>>
>>63247652
It was. Bad compared to 4, 5 and even 3.

5>4>3>6>1>2
>>
5>4>6>1>3>2

At least TPM kinda pretty at times.
Also rotj is nowhere near prequel levels you fucks.
>>
Have you forgotten how bad Revenge of the Sith was?
>>
>>63247668
It was better than 4 and 3 tho
>>
>>63247640
>If not for Ewoks, I'd say it would be even better than ep. V
It would've been fine, but Empire is one of the best mainstream films of all time. Besides the bit with luke, vader, and sheev in the death star, it's just alright.

>>63247669
>5>4>6>1>3>2
>1>3
Is this some new form of meme? Revenge is literally the only passable prequel. Barely passable, but passable.
>>
>>63247668
You just have shit taste
>>
>>63247710
The only picture I get in my head when I think of 2 and 3 are those red hallway scenes in the senate, and the CGI jedi temple. There was tons of bad scenes and cgi in TPM, but I just can't bear those dialogue scenes in 2 and 3. TPM looks kinda neat as the only prequel shot on film.
>>
>>63247833
I'd rewatch the movies if that's all you're basing them on. Phantom is one of the most dead and emotionless movies I've ever seen. Better than Clones, but still awful. At least Revenge actually tried to care.

I actually kind of like the order 66 scene. Kuadi's face when he realizes what's happening still gives me chills.
>>
5>6>4>1>3>2
>>
>>63247703
It had a bunch of awful dialog and CGI, but the best scenes from the prequels came from it.

The final 40 minutes of the movie are actually pretty decent.

Ep 6 starts off with a dance number, has ewoks, Luke being a retard and the whole Leia sister crap.

I still think 6 is better than 3 though, because the duel between Vader and Luke is fucking incredible.
>>
>>63247894
>the best scenes from the prequels came from it.
As true as this is, it's not the high complement you make it out to be
>>
>>63247232
They're all great films.

I think attack of the clones is the weakest. ESB would be great but it's last act ruins it.
>>
File: 1418797970475.png (428 KB, 1008x891) Image search: [Google]
1418797970475.png
428 KB, 1008x891
>>63247232
3>2>1>5>6>4

The old movies are kinda of trash in general, people only like it because of nostalgia.

>shit boring lightsaber duels
>luke is LITERALLY the WORST protagonist ever
>slow paced as fuck

Well, you can say that the movies were original and with good special effects for it's time, but that's about it.

Almost forget, but only Han solo, vader and Yoda are good characters, every other one is shit. Specially Luke.
>>
>>63247232

Only OT is good. Liking PT is like admitting you are under 21/have poor taste.
>>
File: 3f2.jpg (11 KB, 680x680) Image search: [Google]
3f2.jpg
11 KB, 680x680
>>63248105
I must say, I'm impressed.
10/10 I know it's bait and I'm still PLATINUM MAD
>>
>>63248105
shit boring lightsaber duels that are storytelling devices instead of choreo-wanks
Luke is not a protagonist, he's a blank slate only there to be relateable.
>>
File: 6fa.jpg (34 KB, 600x602) Image search: [Google]
6fa.jpg
34 KB, 600x602
>>63248180
>>
>>63247232
5>4>6>2>3>1

IT'S NOT AN OPINION, IT'S A FACT
>>
>>63248223
>Implying I didn't know
I won't let something-being-bait stop me from makeing use of my right of free speech anon, thank you.
>>
>>63247314
OT is all you need. PT is utter trash and should be ignored by anyone with taste.
>>
File: 1401061447814.jpg (238 KB, 2100x1722) Image search: [Google]
1401061447814.jpg
238 KB, 2100x1722
Who /objectivetruth/ here?
4 > 5 >> 6 > 3 > 1 = 2
>>
>>63248529
haha kill yourself
5>4>6>=3>1>incomprehensible powergap>2
>>
>>63248609
>1 has Jar Jar and young Anakin
>2 has romance bullshit
It evens out.
>>
4 > 5 > 3 > 6 > 1 > 2
>>
>>63247232
1>2>3>6>4>5
>>
File: SST-2171-2.jpg (81 KB, 432x395) Image search: [Google]
SST-2171-2.jpg
81 KB, 432x395
>>63248635
>1 has jarjar
I fail to see why that makes it spectacularly worse.
>>
I think it's pretty much accepted that the "correct" order is 5>4>6>3>2>1, but I'd personally go 4>5>6>3>1>2.
>>
File: absolutelydisgusting3.jpg (63 KB, 400x300) Image search: [Google]
absolutelydisgusting3.jpg
63 KB, 400x300
>The "3 is better than 6" meme
Literally kill yourselves, you contrarian faggots.
>>
>>63249228
I kinda get it.
6 looks bad after 5, and 3 looks good after 2.
>>
File: 1421358498275.jpg (72 KB, 512x512) Image search: [Google]
1421358498275.jpg
72 KB, 512x512
>>63247232
>>63247294
>>63247336
>>63247412
>>63247625
>>63247668
>>63248657

>3>6

I will admit that 6 is the worst of the original trilogy, but to say that fucking Revenge of the Sith is better than Return of the Jedi is full fucking retard.
>>
5 > 4 > 3 > 1 > 6 > 2

Episode 5 was literally perfect. 4 was also really great, but 5 remains supreme. Episode 3 was really interesting, General Grievous was neat and Anakin's betrayal was a good watch.

Episode 1, if it wasn't for JarJar binks, the horrible beginning and that awful master jump from Obi-Wan against Darth Maul, it would be good. Episode 6 was a massive letdown, those meme ewoks winning against stormtroopers, the way the Emperor dies, how anticlimatic the final showdown between Vader and Luke was, jesus fuck what a letdown. And episode 2 was hands down the worst addition to the series, simply a filler movie.
>>
>>63247232
I am with you.
>>
6 > 5 > 4 > 3 > 1 >>>>>>>>>>> 2

From my point of view this is the best order and anyone who disagrees has horrible taste.
>>
File: 1421543886548.jpg (117 KB, 860x1280) Image search: [Google]
1421543886548.jpg
117 KB, 860x1280
>>63249332
Kill yourself.

>General Grievous was neat
>He's like a cyborg with lots of lightsabers and he's Russian and he coughs a lot and he doesn't do anything and dies like a bitch

>Anakin's betrayal was a good watch.
>"Save me and you can save your wife"
>Anakin kills Mace Dindu and then says "WHAT HAVE I DONE?"
>Sheev tells him that he can't even save his wife
>Anakin still turns evil for some reason and then immediately slaughters innocent Jedi

>Episode 1, if it wasn't for JarJar binks, the horrible beginning and that awful master jump from Obi-Wan against Darth Maul, it would be good.
This is just retarded

>Episode 6 was a massive letdown, those meme ewoks winning against stormtroopers, the way the Emperor dies, how anticlimatic the final showdown between Vader and Luke was, jesus fuck what a letdown.
>Not liking Vader/Luke showdown
>Caring about the exact way the Emperor dies when the whole point is simply that Vader does it to save Luke
I'll give you the Ewoks
>>
The only people mad about Ewoks beating the Empire are angry Brits who get flashbacks seeing a ragtag army beating their perfect and invincible military machine. God bless America.
>>
File: 1444972915905.png (458 KB, 803x688) Image search: [Google]
1444972915905.png
458 KB, 803x688
>people think 5 isn't the best
>people think 3 is better than 6
>people think 3 is bad on the same level as 1 & 2
>people think 1 is better than anything except 2
>people think 2 has any redeemable qualities at all
Did I get shadowlinked to reddit?
>>
>>63249424
Oh yes, because simply lifting the emperor like a bag of potatoes and throwing him into a pit was a perfect way to finish the Emperor. I'd be happy with a simplistic approach, even if it was Vader just unsheating his saber and backsabering him. But he just picks him up like a newborn baby and throws him into a pit.

Episode 6 was a mess. Boba Fett dying like a bitch, Han Solo not cracking a single good joke but spamming several retard faces, nobody from the good guys gets injured, let alone killed, those meme ewoks killing stormtroopers with stone arrows, Darth Sidious being a mastermind who purposedly led them into the planet but didn't thought about leading them into a fake planet with no shield generator, etc.

And Episode 1 was entertaining, if you removed jj binks, the awful beginning and those meme super powered jumps the Jedi started doing.
>>
4>6>5>The Clone Wars>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>...
>>
Force Awakens will probably be worse than Revenge of the Sith
>>
>>63249332
>Episode 1, if it wasn't for the bad shit, it would be good
Also, you forgot the awful characters, dialogue, and story that's way too hard to follow for a Star Wars film.
>meme ewoks winning against stormtroopers
Yeah, that was stupid.
>the way the Emperor dies
It's fine.
>how anticlimatic the final showdown between Vader and Luke was
Literally the best thing in the entire franchise.
>>
>>63247232
They are all shit and you should kill yourself for having such a disgusting subhuman manchild taste.
>>
>>63249675
>Someone's going to fall for this
>>
>>63249675
Alec Guinness get out
>>
>>63249610
>Episode 1, if it wasn't for the bad shit, it would be good
Come to think of it, my argument was pretty retarded. Episode 1 was indeed, real bad.

>the way the Emperor dies, it's fine
No it wasn't. The shittiest of the jedi/sith can feel the force from others, and he couldn't feel Vader shifting to the good side? Being so easily grabbed and thrown like that? Again, i'd be content with a simplistic approach towards his demise, like in episode 4, a single saber strike against him would be miles better. That throw was just too comical.

>the final showdown between Vader and Luke
The concept was great, the execution was so poor. Not to mention there you were, engaged in watching that confrontation, only for the camer to cut again to those meme ewoks using stones and slings winning against armored soldiers with laser weapons and siege machines.
>>
5>4>6>1>3>2
>>
File: 1447714156666.png (165 KB, 777x656) Image search: [Google]
1447714156666.png
165 KB, 777x656
>>63249984
>1>3
>>
5>4>3=6>1>2 is how I'd put it

5 is just the best. 4 is nice too. Sith and Jedi have there fair share of ups and downs (I personally think the opening scene for sith is the strongest of all the series opening scenes). 1 is a shitshow if you include Jar Jar and kid Ani. The only redeeming qualities from 2 are the clones and Jango, but even then they can't save the movie.
>>
>>63250378
>clones
>cgi discount stormtroopers with no personality

>django
>managed to have more dialogue and backstory than Boba and still be half as interesting

yeah, stellar redeeming qualities
>>
6>5>4>3>2>1
Fucking faggots
use pedmas
>>
>>63247232
Fuck off dude, 3 better than 6, what have you been drinking and eating lately, I bet you've been getting a lot of vaccinations to get this level of autism, it surpasses my brother's level, and he is a fucking assburger deluxe I tell you. Fuck off dude you don't know what the fuck
>>
5>4>6>3>2>NIGGERS>1.
>>
you should all kill yourselves
>>
I'd go with 4>5>6>3>2>1

Don't agree with the meme opinion that Phantom Menace is good
>>
>>63250378
you actually liked that cgi shitfest at the beginning of episode 3?
>>
5>4>6>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>3>>>>1>>>>>>>>2

I'd pick watching Darth Binks any day over watching hamfisted romance written by a neckbearded kek.
>>
File: 1446119693407.jpg (130 KB, 880x880) Image search: [Google]
1446119693407.jpg
130 KB, 880x880
>>63247232
Finally someone who gets it. This ranking is objective fact. Plebs need not apply.
>>
File: 1444505371803.jpg (30 KB, 500x590) Image search: [Google]
1444505371803.jpg
30 KB, 500x590
Correct order:
5>4>3>1>2>6
>>
>>63247521
Here's betting Boyega does a call back to that line but says it like that. "Ayy bitch who u callin scruffy lookin?"
>>
http://www.idigitaltimes.com/star-wars-force-awakens-release-date-marathon-real-best-order-watch-star-wars-movies-494809

Thoughts?
>>
5>4>6>1>3>2

3 is objectively shit and only "muh edgy" "muh darkness" "muh black clothes" kids think it's actually a good film.
>>
Personal preference is

6 > 5 > 3 > 4 > 2 > 1
>>
5 > 6 > 4 > 3 > 1 > 2
OBJECTIVE OPINION COMING THROUGH MAKE WAY PEOPLE HONK HONK MOTHERFUCKER
>>
>>63247232
5>4>6>1>3>2

At least we can agree Attack of the Clones was a failed abortion
>>
Coming from a guy who just marathoned the entire series.

3>5>6>2>1>4

Come at me.
>>
>>63251666
>3 over 5
Bait
>>
>>63251751
What was good about 5?
It's horribly boring.
>>
>>63251835

kill yourself
>>
>>63251893
So you have no way to refute my ranking?
Cool.
>>
Ewoks were just filler, not so bad when you compare them with gungans
>>
6 > 5 > 4 > 3 > 2 > 1
>>
>>63251666
>4 is the worst
Nice try, satan
>>
>>63247232
>le revenge of the sith is better than retrun of the jedi meme
High quality bait
>>
>underagefags hated 1 because they found the politics boring
>>
>>63252235
>contrarians liked 1 because it was slow
>>
>>63247485

This to be honest senpai.
>>
6>5>4>1>2=3

i honestly think jedi is best and cant decide between clones and sith
>>
File: searchyourfeelings.jpg (34 KB, 700x289) Image search: [Google]
searchyourfeelings.jpg
34 KB, 700x289
>>63247465
5>4>6>3>1>2
>>
>>63247247
6 isn't that good except for the last scenes in the Death Star. The rest of the movie has serious flaws and yeah, the Ewoks kinda ruined it. Special Edition made it even worse in the Jabba's Palace scenes.
>>
Slightly different topic: correct watching order?

for my money it's 4->5->explain what happens in 1->2 with liberal fastforwards->3->6
>>
5
4
6
POWER GAP
3
1
2
Thread replies: 119
Thread images: 17

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.