>First team to score wins the whole game
>In the playoffs
You ameritards have some fucking stupid rules
>>64974302
>What is the golden goal
>>64974302
Give up 75 yards on a play to their most dangerous receiver because nobody is within 15 yards of him when he catches the ball, a case could be made that you deserved to lose.
>>64974302
Well you can just GIT OUT if you don't like this country.
>>64974302
>First team to score wins the whole game
>Not knowing the rules
>>64974302
>Team that makes the most penalty kicks wins
>In a World Cup
>>64974302
all you have to do is win the game before OT.... then you dont have this problem
>>64974375
That doesn't exits any more idiot
>Penalty shootouts decide games in soccer
What's there to complain about here?
>>64974302
Nope, just score a touchdown, your team should be good enough to hold the other to a field goal and be good enough to drive back down the field and tie it or better. If you give up a TD on the first drive, you don't deserve to be there anyway
>>64974302
Not knowing the rules
If it's a touchdown or defense score it's over. A field goal allows the other team to try again.
College has it that both teams get the ball and it ends up in 6 OTs
>>64974302
At least it wasn't on a shitty FG like what happened to the Vikings against the Saints some years back...
Sorry, we'll try to make more of those exciting 0-0 ties you love so much.
>>64974484
>>64974523
please be b8
>>64974579
and college games are guess what
more entertaining than pro football
>>64974302
you know i could have sworn that the NFL moved to college rules where the opposing team gets one drive to tie the game instead of it being sudden death
or was that only due to field goal?
>>64974302
>who cares if your team is imbalanced, who cares about having a good defense
>>64974302
Play defense
>>64974302
بو هوو هوو، وأنا مستعرة تؤخر الأوروبي، بلز اغتصابي محمد
>>64974657
the official rule is if the first offense gets a TD its over if they get a field goal the other team gets a shot then if its 2 field goals its the first to score wins.
>>64974302
>penalty shootouts
>away goals rule
>>64974657
only on gay FGs
>last two world cups
>takes more than 110 minutes for a goal
>only 1(one) goal decides the game
>basically first to score wins
>defending this shit rule
The defending team should get a chance to match the score to continue the game.
>>64974647
Yeah this game was boring
>>64974646
PKs just about equivalent to a coin flip anyway
we just skip the extra time and get straight to it with a coin flip
>Murrifats get called out on their shitty overtime system
>Immediately shit on real football
lmfao
>>64974302
>that flag
>that post
>happens all the time
>now that it happens to Packers, people bitch
stay classy fudgepackers
>>64974950
>real boreball
fify
also
>>64974302
>you ameritards
>posts with american flag
>>64974375
We got rid of that shit like 15 years ago.
>>64974986
People have bitched about the rule for years you fag
>>64974950
Do we really need to start posting all webms of the flopping and faggy shit that goes on in soccer? I don't think you'll like the results.
>>64974916
You're correct, they should clearly play the full 15 minute OT.
letting both teams try for the td is difficult because the 2nd team would have 4 downs to work with the whole drive, which is also a huge advantage
there's no ideal solution
>>64975149
>>64975149
It's worse in the NBA where all your players are complete divas
I'm absolutely HATE the Packers, but I would be fine if the rule was that no matter when a score happened, the other team gets one chance to match it in OT. Unless it's as OT expires.
college football has the best football OT tbqh senpai
>>64975218
true, nba does suck
>>64974302
The overtime rules are better than they used to be but I still would like to see some more change. Specifically have the teams play a full 10 minute quarter(shorter than a regular quarter on purpose) and whoever has the most points at the end of that quarter wins. If it's still tied start another 10 minute quarter, possession doesn't change and it becomes sudden death.
>>64975197
the team that wins the coin toss still has a pretty significant advantage
>>64975199
How about letting them play the full OT time to determine winner no matter what type of scores are being made during it the highest score at the end wins.
Maybe 1 full 15min OT, followed by 5min OT's is still tied until there's a winner. Makes perfect sense to me.
college OT is literally perfect
>>64975435
much less of an advantage than with the current rules.
>>64974579
College games rarely make it past 3 because both teams have to attempt 2 point conversions
>>64975486
>wasting everybody's time.
why not 5 min from the get go. why waste everyone's time with another full quarter?
>>64975439
>>64975486
It's just a meme version of football
>>64975624
If more of a thrilling game is a waste of time then it's your fault you hate the sport.
In the playoffs the OT should be a full quarter.
>>64975199
what if they just moved one whole team to the locker room, so they didn't know what the other team did? that way you don't know if they scored a FG or TD or at all so you can't play call based on it
Only fans of teams with shitty defenses hate the OT rule.
>>64975624
Like you have anything better to do
>>64975760
Everyone hates the OT rule because it's unfair to whoever loses the flip
>>64974579
>College has it that both teams get the ball and it ends up in 6 OTs
I honestly wouldn't mind this in the NFL.
I haven't seen an OT game in High School or College in forever. But doesn't the starting position of the ball also change?
OTs are rare in the NFL. But it feels a little cheap to have one team score a TD and the other not even get a chance to play. Not as cheap as penalty kicks in soccer...but still pretty cheap.
>>64975649
That's an inordinate amount of time
It usually takes team 5 minutes to score
Or at least more than 3
Still gives the team who won the toss a big advantage
>>64974646
Imagine basketball games being decided by who shoots the most free throws.
A truly superior system.
>>64975812
There is no way to make it completely fair. Do the majority of drives in the nfl end in touchdowns or did the cardinals beat the odds?
>>64975812
>Everyone
Everyone whose team has a shitty defense.
Should add a field goal kickoff.
Start at the 20 and move another 10 yards every successful kick.
Its been established that NCAA OT rules > NFL OT rules
>>64974647
Oh look, someone from the South.
>>64975956
>implying
I just know where the bullshit lies, and that is in the professional sports.
>>64975902
Should have a leap frog race
Entire roster and coaching staff must participate
>>64975956
>tfw actually from Massachusetts
when will the memes end, cfb is a global languange
>>64975828
After the 2nd overtime you have to go for 2
Out of the thousands of college games played since 1995, you can probably count the times it's gone past four on your hands
To even get to 3 is rare
>>64975980
Would watch 2bh.
>>64975978
Learn what implying means you fucking hillbilly.
How is it that such a corrupt system as College Football has their rules more together than the NFL?
>>64975895
If the first team gets a touchdown, the other team get to try and match it. If they do we go again.
It's so simple. The current OT rules are hot shit and I hate the Packers.
>>64976004
He is probably from Montana or some shit state where the only thing that keeps him from killing himself is bandwagoning nfl teams.
>>64975956
he's not wrong though
college fb still hasthe best OT
>>64975980
Fuck that have them all play dodgeball using footballs. Team with the last man standing wins the game.
>>64974396
>palmer throws like shit all game
>he deserved to win
yeah no fuck the cardinals
Just add another quarter without the golden goal rule. How hard is that?
Not a pucks fan in the least and I wanted Arizona to win, but I do agree the ot rules are shit. If two teams with strong offenses and relatively weak defenses go to overtime, the coin flip is essentially determining the game, or at least unfairly exerting an influence on it. The game is determined by both sides of the ball, both offenses and both defenses should be guaranteed to have a chance to play in overtime. Back and forth until one team fails to match or exceed the points scored by the opponent. The logic they used to changed the ot rules over field goals needs to be carried to its actual conclusion.
college rule is better, no one denies that
if packers won coin flip cardinals fans would be boohoo because "we get no chance to touch ball"
Would just continuing the game after the clock goes to zero until someone scores be effective, or is that easily exploitable/turned into a shit game?
>People actually defending Jewdell's rules
Yeah god forbid we got maybe another half hour of football.
>>64976167
If a coach thinks the OT rules are bullshit, he can always go for two instead of tying the game, especially if the other defense is weak.
>>64975956
Oh look, someone hates dat SEC speed.
>>64976078
That's not fair to the team that loses the coin toss. Team that wins the toss would kick because if they give up a td they know they have to score one so they are in 4 down territory the entire way.
Now tell me how to make OT fair
>>64976167
then don't have a weak defense. defense is the most important part of the game--if you can't stop your opponent from scoring a touchdown just once you don't really deserve to win
>>64976240
cardinals would of held them to a fieldgoal
>>64976382
You can't guarantee that. Aaron Rodgers was running on meme magic. Anything was possible.
>>64976376
So you're ok going back to first field goal wins the game then, right?
>>64974647
They are boring with inflated maymay scores
>>64976291
Essentially just OT without the coin flip
>>64974772
kek
>>64976362
The fuck are talking about?
>the game isn't fair because what if my team has a shit defense
If your team has a shit field goal kicker, you're fucked too. Fuck you. Make a well-rounded team, you cuck.
College rules vastly favor the second team to have the ball. NFL rules are more balanced now that FGs don't automatically win.
>>64976487
You would ALWAYS defer if you get a possession no matter what because then you would know whether to go for TD or when it's safe to kick the FG. That's what happens in college.
>>64974927
No, but it was incredibly anti climactic that Aaron Rodgers didn't get to step onto the field after it was all said and done
>>64976104
he had an injured finger tho
>>64974986
No, any time a major game ends without both offenses touching the field during OT people bitch. It's retarded
>>64976602
thats why the advantage is up to a coin toss 50/50 chance of getting it but not necessarily winning because you get the advantage. Plus if you tie the first series the second series is reversed.
>>64976532
You do realize that even the best defense in the league isn't expected to prevent every drive from even a sub par offense from ending a touch down? The game is inherently designed to favor scoring, lest scoreless games be common as fuck.
Well I'm sorry that we don't have 90 minutes of no one scoring.
Didn't the OT rules change after that playoff game where Farve didn't even have a chance to take the field? It was after a field goal I think.
I wonder if the NFL will take another look at it now that (some) fans are raging online.
>>64975869
>Kek
I honestly didn't have an opinion but that comparison made it seem retarded
>>64976602
Yea but both teams get possession at least once so even if it's still unfair it's still lightyears ahead of the current rules.
>>64976532
The big issue is that only one team gets their defense tested.
10 minutes
2 timeouts
if still tied, most yards during OT wins, add a second OT if you're really a madman.
>>64976624
>anti-climatic
Only if you're a packers fan. Otherwise that shit was crazy entertaining.
>>64976532
the OT rules are disgusting and ableist, as it prevents armless people from contributing properly by prioritizing touchdowns over field goals
>>64976727
The other team got their coin "flip" calling ability tested
>>64976532
>r#Kt
>>64975416
that gives the recieving team way too big of an advantage
>>64976769
an armless guy can still block and he'll never get called for holding. Fuck of back to tumblr anyway faggot.
>>64976726
Disagree. Most possessions don't end in a TD.
Under the equal possession rule, the advantage is greater to the kicking team than the advantage of the receiving team in the TD but not FG wins rule.
Under equal possession rule, the kicking team has PERFECT information on going for 4th downs vs kicking FGs. That's a HUGE advantage.
>>64976742
>Alex smith 10 minute drive for game winning fg
>muh OT rules aren't fair
>>64975149
yeah retard watching a bunch of gorillas chimp out for 4 hours is way better.
>>64976831
>a game of luck gives the winner an advantage
>>64976727
in most games both teams get their defense tested
however if your defense decides to lay an egg and give up an 80 yard TD drive with the game on the line, you blow your chance to test the other defense
seems okay to me
>>64976858
Yes. Yes it is.
>>64976858
>implying what we're watching isn't commercials
>>64976602
How is it unfair? The first team to have possession has to decide to go for a touchdown and force the other team to have to match it, or settle for a field goal allowing the other team to settle similarly. No matter what, the first team is entitled to go for a touchdown. And it's match or exceed, so if they settle for a fg and the other team gets a td, they now get the ball back but have to match the td. They don't need to have to predict what the other team will do in order to overcome some disadvantage.
What I don't understand is how is this luck?
Like the Packers didn't even have a chance to stop the Cardinals from scoring a touchdown
>>64976935
sometimes funny comercials are better than zoning out to soccer because nothing happens though.
>>64976844
>game managers actually have a place to be clutch
im okay with this
NFL OT just needs to give the team that loses the toss, or defers, a possession. I don't get why the outcome of a game can be left up to the coin flip. And no, don't give me that "Well the other team should've stopped them xD" bullshit. With the way rules have been changed and the pass-happy state of the NFL, actually stopping a team is hard. Pick plays are still rarely fucking called as it is.
>>64976126
>game lasts six hours
>>64974375
Golden Goal was an experiment they used for like 1-2 World Cups. It was stupid and unpopular (outside of America), so they ditched it.
IMO, though, penalty kicks aren't much better. They should just play extra periods until someone comes out ahead. The main reason they don't is that it's not very TV-friendly. If you've ever watched a 5OT game in the NHL playoffs (and even that's sudden death), you know what I mean.
>>64976766
I'd say for a cards fan it was amazing. As a general fan not caring about either team, I wanted to see Aaron walk out there one more time
>>64976961
Wtf? Your proposed rules would make it so that if the first team scored a fg and the second team scored a td, the first team would get the ball again?
>>64976961
What, so if the second team exceeds the first team then the first team gets ANOTHER chance? That makes less sense than anything proposed. Then the first team has a possession advantage AND an information advantage.
>>64976742
>most yards
Do any of you fuckers actually watch the sport or did you get lost looking for /s4s/?
>>64976973
>le 90 minutes jogging meme
everytime an American says this I imagine some evangelist YOC zionist who thinks some random cammel on the other side of the planet is a real treat to his country
but seriously
>score
>commercial
>kickoff
>commercial
is fucking ridiculous
>>64974302
Only casual faggots who don't believe defense is an equal and important part of the game think this.
If it bothers you so much, go invent a sport where everybody just keeps scoring and the game never ends.
Never mind, the NBA already has that, and nobody enjoys it anymore either.
>>64977215
yeah that is pretty dumb. I could see it working where if the first team scores a TD, the 2nd team gets the ball, then if they score, you just keep playing until a team doesn't score a TD
>>64977173
Not a cards fan. Don't care about either team. That ending was great. Didn't need to see Aaron one more time because I don't give a shit about him.
>>64977103
In that case introduce a penalty type system if we're still tied like college rules. The point is both teams getting possession of the ball at least.
Why even have a winner or a loser? How about everyone gets a superbowl trophy just for playing?
>>64977272
Except there's some truth in that meme. Soccer is 89 min of boring for maybe a possible minute of action.
>>64977215
Yes! And now they *have* to score a td. Otherwise you'd be 100% right (assuming you're the anon I was replying to).
The only downside to this and the reason it will never happen is that it's somewhat anti-climactic by casual nfl fan standards, because every sudden death ot will end with an offense failing to score, rather than the potential hail Mary Dragon into the end zone to end it. But it's the only way to actually make it fair and eliminate the influence of winning a coin flip.
>>64977272
>They both suck
>everybody gets to watch mindnumbing bullshit outside of a few fantastic plays in their own special way
>>64977075
Yes, the "unless the offense scores a TD" part is too gimmicky for my liking, but they did it to encourage teams to go for the TD, rather than being content to go back-and-forth trading FGs, as they were afraid would happen otherwise. Still, I don't see they problem there, because even then someone is going to fail to make a FG eventually.
The only thing that the NFL OT rules have in their favor, IMO, is that they are slightly less gimmicky and inane than the college OT rules.
>>64976742
>most yards during OT wins
Is this a joke or are you some fag who wandered in here who isn't into sports at all?
>>64974523
Penalties are great television though, several people have died of heart attacks while watching them, well maybe they aren't great for your health but pretty exiting nonetheless.
Stay mad Cuckerfag
This discussion has just convinced me that the current NFL rules are the fairest, most reasonable rules possible for overtime.
The only way you can fairly give each team a possession is if you kill the information advantage.
So no FGs or Punting. Each team gets 5 mins to score a TD only going from their own 20. Keep playing until both teams have had a chance and the score isn't tied.
>>64977382
>>64977408
Confirmed for not watching Cruz Azul vs Guadalajara today. Literally 90 minutes of action.
>>64977272
It's kind of true though. And stop pretending you watch every second of a soccer game intently and don't zone out/do something else at times.
>>64977402
So you are giving the team that won the coin toss two chances to win
>it's unfair to expect us to play defense and prevent the other team from scoring!
What the actual fuck am I reading?
>>64977505
see >>64977501
btw the result was a tie
>this trigger the Americans
>>64977501
>google score
>1-1
Yeah I miss out
>>64977525
Visitors get to call because Home team has 'home field advantage'. Lower ranking playoff teams get to act as visitors because they didn't play as well during the regular season.
I have to say they stack the advantages to the team who is less likely to win.
>>64977265
The fact that the first teams gets the ball back is exactly the reason they do not have an information advantage. You don't need to know what the second team is going to do. The first team is entitled to gamble the fg in favor of a td and gains them the same yield as the second team.
>>64977437
IMO, it's just dumb to decide the outcome of a match by radically changing the rules.
Soccer is an 11-on-11 game. It shouldn't be decided by 1-on-1 penalties.
In a sport where only your offense or defense is on the field at one time there is no truly fair way to create OT
>>64977501
>2 total goals
>90 minutes of action
Pick one
Bonus it was a tie which is super gay.
>>64977505
>And stop pretending you watch every second of a soccer game intently and don't zone out/do something else at times
Yes most of use do pay complete attention during a match. You realize there's more to the game than just goals right?
>>64977594
There is if you allow both teams a drive.
>>64977570
>first team scores a fg
>second team scores td
>first team knows they need to score a td
>you're not a smart man
>>64977634
>You realize there's more to the game than just goals right?
People who don't watch soccer don't realize that 2bh
>>64977673
This was meant for
>>64977572
>>64977562
>>64977618
kek I knew this would happen
since we are not jews and we actually care about athletes, not making them die on the field even if there's not a winner is an option in regular season
>muh high scoring
>muh I need to be rewarded to feel like I've accomplished something
white suburban ameribaby syndrome
>>64977666
No because if both teams get a drive no matter what, the second team gets an advantage
>>64977525
They're getting a second chance to win, sure, but the other team would also necessarily get a second chance to win. They are exchanging drives until one team fails to match the previous score.
>football night
>americans celebrating their papa john's coin toss special
>europeans still ass ached that we only give a shit when the US is in their corrupted as fuck FIFA
>rest of the world worried fifa and shit will shut down because everyone is arrested
>pissed the US doesn't care
>tries to bring it divegrass
>nobody will watch divegrass tomorrow
>eurostan will try again next week
Every fucking year. Get it through your skull, we won't watch your shit unless it's some neckbeard, beaner, or we win in your kicking game. 90 minutes of playing pass with feet isn't exciting.
>>64977673
>first team knows they have to score a touchdown
So??
>people saying "if you dont like it have a good defense"
are you not considering that the defense is tired as fuck after four quarters. its a shit way to end a game.
>>64977697
I was gonna say.
>>64977705
If you can't accomplish the goal of the sport your team sucks at the sport. Also
>Not fighting until there is a winner
Yuropoors just enjoy shit entertainment and are confirmed pansies.
>>64977705
>you were born just in time to subjugate mexican subhumans because they are unable to run their own country
glorious times
>>64977766
>implying both defenses won't be tired if the game isn't lopsided
>implying offense will still be spry
>60% of teams that win the coin toss win the game
Great """sport""" you have there. Glad I switched over to real football (or as you call it, "soccer") years ago.
>>64977763
Unfair advantage determined by the coin toss
>>64977556
Only some. I personally prefer ties to gimmicky OT rules. I'd much prefer for the NHL, for instance, to bring back regular season ties and get rid of the 3-on-3 OT bullshit and shootouts.
But ties aren't an option in tournament play. There you need a winner and a loser.
For games like ice hockey and soccer, where they are frequent possession changes and scoring is relatively infrequent, sudden death is still better than a shootout, IMO. But I don't like it much in the NFL, where possession means more.
I don't really see why all sports can't do it like basketball does, and just keep playing extra periods until someone comes out ahead.
>>64977763
So they NEVER punt, they NEVER kick a FG and ALWAYS go for it on 4th down. That strategy yields a higher TD likelihood than the first team who had to make a hard choice of punting or kicking a FG because they don't know how many points the second team will score.
The second team basically gets 4 downs where the first team only has 3.
>>64977875
>Unfair advantage
>Unfair
inigomontoya.png
It's an advantage, yes. But the coin toss (which is 50-50) makes it fair.
>>64977875
They're not at an unfair advantage though. They do not have to predict what the other team will do in the next drive nor does it have any impact on their decision making.
>>64977882
You do realize that in the regular season if they are still tied after OT the game is called a tie and each team gets half a win, right?
>>64977933
But if they succesfully stop the team and force the other team to kick or go for a field goal then they don't get to go for it on every 4th and the advantage is lost.
>>64977718
If the first team scores within their drive, the other team is then forced to score otherwise they lose the game.
If the first team does not score, then the other gets the ball. If that team scores, either make it so they win or the other team that didn't score first now has to score in order to stay alive. This would be fair because both teams had a chance to both attack and defend.
The only thing that I want to see implemented is that both teams get a chance to score.
>>64977786
not getting scored on is a part of the game as well
>Not fighting until there is a winner
only when it matters, not need to do it in the regular season
>>64977882
>I don't really see why all sports can't do it like basketball does, and just keep playing extra periods until someone comes out ahead.
LeCramp.jpg
>>64978007
>I want pk
NFL should just use college rules
>>64977980
In the NFL, yes (I'd prefer they did away with regular season OT completely, though). Not in ht NHL anymore.
>>64978024
Again, if apehoop can do it with its tiny rosters, then the NFL with its massive rosters certainly could.
>>64978068
Or you could just go watch college ball.
>change for me
Fuck off.
>>64977979
They don't have to make any choices. They have 4 downs to score a td no matter what to win the game. In this OT iteration, the other team will never get this advantage. Only the team that wins the coin toss can ever have this advantage.
>>64978024
Soccer is just shit. If you want it to be entertaining make the field smaller, reduce the number of guys, make the goal smaller, put up walls on the edges so there's no out of bounds unless the ball goes over the wall, then stop the damn clock until play resumes.
>>64978068
The college rules are worse than the NFL's.
>>64978092
I like OT. As to your statement about extra OT's, those boys get the shit beat out of them enough.
>>64978115
>Both teams play defense and offense
Literally best OT possible
>>64978113
I say they can keep the clock running. Let the game end faster.
>>64978171
This only works if you don't add imaginary time to the game like they do
>>64977933
The first team had four downs you fucking goon jesus. The first team is fully entitled to not punt and go for it on every fourth down too. They lose by failing to match the previous score, pure and simple. Neither team will at any point be at an 'information disadvantage' because they will always be playing to *respond* to the previous score, never the possible future one.
>>64978037
At least in penalties both teams have a chance to score and it doesn't matter who goes first.
>>64978115
We get, we get it. You hate the Packers.
But please come to your senses. College OT is GOAT.
>>64978092
yeah but nobody wants to watch third stringers vs third stringers
>>64978113
literally futsal
>>64978207
Futsal > soccer
>>64978222
Futsal - soccer's special needs cousin
>>64978131
The thing is, given how NFL scoring works, in practice it probably wouldn't result in extra OT periods very often (especially with the new PAT rules).
>>64978149
That's not the problem. The problem is the bullshit part where there's no kickoffs and teams start from the opponents' 25. At least make them go the length of the field.
>>64978198
Both teams have a chance to score if the defense is worth a shit.
You're missing the forest from the trees.
>>64978186
If the first team scores a td then the second team can never win on offense
>>64978222
Trips confirm
>>64978247
I can agree with that have a kickoff and whatever team 1 does team 2 has to at least match it. Force 2 pt conversions and boom
>>64978247
Superbowl has never gone into OT but it has the infinite OT rule. They keep playing until someone wins.
OT isn't all that common (ties almost unheard of) but the point of OT is basically sudden death. They implemented first scoring drive exception to balance OP offense vs. defense.
>>64978260
Yes they can. They have to score a td, then on the following drive, prevent the other team from scoring a td, then they win.
The autism is so strong ITT
>>64978356
this
>>64978202
Actually, no. I didn't have a team in tonight's game (my team already won earlier today).
>>64978207
In the NFL, people are coming in and out all of the time anyway.
And in soccer, they could fix it perhaps by awarding extra substitutions for OT and allowing previously subbed-out players to return.
>>64978310
>Force 2 pt conversions
Fuck no. I hate the 2 point conversion, too. That's another stupid idea the NFL got from college.
>>64978314
All NFL playoff games have the same OT rules. The SB is no different from other playoff games. And while it hasn't happened in the SB, it did happen once in the NFL championship in the pre-SB era (in '58, when the Colts beat the Giants in the first-ever OT game in NFL history).
>>64978356
So once a team scores a td there is no strategy anymore. It's just 4 downs to gain 10 yds until you score a td every time.
>>64978356
Actually, I just realized I have to modify this a bit. In fact, in can be as simple as this: first offense to end a drive with less total points on the board than the opponent past each teams first ot possession, loses the game.
>>64978433
Well, yes, the sudden death rules in the Super Bowl are the same as the playoffs. But they keep doing a fresh OT until someone wins.
In the regular season if no team has won by the OT rules it's a tie.
Also, yes a championship game has gone into OT. But the SuperBowl is not a Championship game. That's next week.
>>64978433
>And in soccer, they could fix it perhaps by awarding extra substitutions for OT
Yeah this sounds good, it would increase the quality and quantity of play in OT (no more faggots faking cramps every 5 minutes, you get one you gtfo of the field)
>>64978451
Or rather, starting on the second teams first possession not past it.
>>64978542
>But they keep doing a fresh OT until someone wins.
>In the regular season if no team has won by the OT rules it's a tie.
Yes, I know this. This is not my issue. My issue is both cases is with sudden death. I also think OT is pointless in the regular season where there's no problem with having ties.
>But the SuperBowl is not a Championship game. That's next week.
It is and isn't. There were no conferences in in the pre-SB era. In 1958, the AFL didn't even exist yet. So the NFL championship was considered the world championship of that era, and was thus arguably equivalent to the SB of today, not the NFC championship of today.
>>64978618
Exactly.
>>64975956
You're literally retarded if you think the NFL is more entertaining and is not fixed
>>64977575
The fact that you can win with field goals is a travesty.
>>64974579
When is the last time you saw 6 OTs? For real, they almost never go above 2 OTs. 3 OTs is rare. It makes the game more interesting.
>>64974302
Didn't the Vikings score like 3 times before Seattle put points on the board.
It shouldn't have OTs in regular season matches. If ended in draw, so the draw shall be keeped.
In playoffs, OT with 15 minutes and no sudden death rules. If ended in draw, decision by FGs.
>>64975320
Horse shit.
>>64977575
Got something better?
>>64974375
One of Fifa's tools to fuck with Italy
>>64982691
thats stupid because teams only have one FG specialist
How about teams learn how to play fucking defense?
>n-not fair if the other team scores a TD first!
Holy shit stop them then
>>64982691
>Ties are totally A-O-K
GTFO CARNIVALFAG.
>>64987939
or how about not letting it get to overtime in the first place? The original sudden death rules were fine because if you couldn't win in regulation then you have no right to complain.
I looked this up and apparently 60% of teams that win the coin toss win the game. Which isn't that bad of a system, it's a 50-50 chance for a 10% advantage.
>>64984172
the other tool is the yellow card for diving ?
Alright what about this, instead of a coin toss.
Each team kicks the ball in turn, with a receiver trying to gain as many yards as possible.
The team that wins the most yards gets to pick what to do.
>>64980696
You're smoking crack if you think college football isn't rigged.
>Get to decide your own fucking schedule
>Good teams go out of their way to avoid playing other good teams, and get judged subjectively on how badly they performed against No One GIves a Fuck State.
>Position in polls is decided by popular vote before a single game is played
>Only allows 4 teams into playoffs for championship, those 4 teams are chosen by committee.
Most games are lop-sided, one-sided affairs between a major program and a shit one, or are played between two shit programs and are little better than high-school football.
Oh yeah, college football soooooo much better.
>>64988493
It's better than the regulated to the point it loses all authenticity that is the NFL
>>64988526
>regulated to the point it loses all authenticity
that makes no sense
dumbass
>>64988641
>draft
>cap
>retarded scheduling mechanism
>franchises can move
They should copy the new NHL rules.
Make the overtime 4-on-4 or something.
I'd definitely like to see that.
>>64988526
Oh yeah, let me tell you, Watching Bama play Middle Tennessee, or ULM sure is compelling. It's just sooooooooo authentic.
>>64988734
the draft and cap are both there to avoid the problems outlined here >>64988493
the schedule is determined by a clever formula so no one can complain about bias.
franchises move because they're businesses and not "educational institutions" like colleges.
>>64988885
Having a draft AND a cap causes a league to lose all authenticity
I don't care what it's designed to "prevent"
It ruins every game
Every team is just some corporate scam to make money
The draft force players to only sign with one team unless they have some leverage
How the fuck can you say that?
>>64988878
Every college gameday there are 64 games
Not all of them are Bama-ULM
>>64988734
>draft
Yeah it would be way more interesting if the top 10 teams made wild promises to players that the others couldn't possibly hope to match and stockpiled all the talent
>cap
See above
>retarded scheduling mechanic
Being allowed to make your own schedule to avoid as much competition as possible is much better.
>franchises can move
So what? What the fuck does that have to do with anything?
>>64989010
if there was no cap the Cowboys would win the super bowl every year. If there was no draft then teams like the cowboys, packers, steelers and 49ers would get all the top recruits out of college
>>64976104
Yeah they didn't deserve the win. Ref's were terrible. I'm excited to see the cardinals get fucked next week.
>>64976104
Aside from some fluke last minute heroics on Rodgers' part, he looked like shit too.
>>64989010
>Not all of them are Bama-ULM
But most of the games are. Or they are two sub-par teams without professional caliber talent. Out of 64 games, how many are actually worth watching? 1? Maybe 2?
>>64988855
That would just turn into grabass.
HOW TO FIX SHITTY NFL RULES
1. Ties are perfectly acceptable because competitive integrity should always prevail over ADHD armchair fans
2. In the post season Overtime there is no coin toss, the visiting team gets choice of receive, kick or defer
3. If there is a score in the opening drive, the other team gets a chance to match it
4. If a field goal is scored and then a touchdown, the game is over.
5. If a touchdown is scored and then is answered with another touchdown, the game continues until a winner is decided.
>>64974302
>Yuropoos cant handle sudden death
>prefer gradual expiration
>>64989076
You force players to teams they may not want to sign with
John Elway and Eli Manning should be heroes
A cap would be okay by itself if it wasn't for the draft
College teams have to play at least 9 high level games a year
They can't avoid big teams to go to the playoff
You're rooting for a corporate creation that exists solely for making money
At least college teams started for.less nefarious reasons
>>64989103
>If there was no draft then teams like the cowboys, packers, steelers and 49ers would get all the top recruits out of college
No
That's not true at all
Most players would to a team where they'd have the most chance to play or the closest to home
The Yankees don't win the World Series every year
>>64989296
Better than the 0 with all of the boring ass offenses in the NFL
>>64989664
Or just go with college rules
Even if you don't like college football their overtime rules are so much better
The NFL OT rules are a variation of rules invented spur of the moment in 1958
>>64990108
>You force players to teams they may not want to sign with
You don't HAVE to sign with the team that drafts you. Look at Bo Jackson
>drafted by the bucs
>lol no
>does whatever he wants until next draft
>drafted by Raiders
>sounds good
>>64990281
He had leverage with the ability to play baseball
But how many others have that ability?
>>64990323
Or you could always do what Eli did, just throw a tantrum until the team that drafts you has to trade you or risk losing the pick.
>>64990424
Which works great for high draft picks
But after that you don't
>>64974717
Canada knows
>Draft ensures bad teams get a chance at being good
>Cap stops mega franchises from stockpiling all the talent
>The most well run franchises will still enjoy sustained success
Why are people so against socialism?
>>64990098
>Yuropoors can't stand sudden death
>Americans spend hours bitching about PKs
