>/a/ wants KanColle moved to /jp/
>/jp/ wants KanColle moved to /a/
It's like /vg/ doesn't exist.
>>470150
The game thread should be moved to /vg/ and the non-game thread should be moved to /jp/.
Discussion of the manga and anime can remain in /a/ (which is as good as throwing it out, since other than the 4koma nobody really cares.)
>>470150
It should be moved to /trash/ where it belongs
>>470151
>the non-game thread should be moved to /jp/
Why not merge with the game thread at /vg/ instead?
>>470155
/vg/ is nominally about video games. I guess in reality people use it for whatever the fuck they want.
Kancolle is also a multimedia franchise, the game itself is untranslated (qualifying as a "niche Japanese thing" in Western terms even it's plastered everywhere in Japan), and the franchise has an incredible amount of secondary Japanese creative content backing it.
>>470158
>Kancolle
>small c
`>>470164
FUCK YOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU
>>470158
There's game discussion in the /a/ threads so many posters in /a/ play the game too and a good number of them don't like /jp/. I'd think that merging with the game thread wouldn't be too bad a solution.
>>470168
They are unlikely to like /vg/ much more than /jp/.
Though I guess I have no idea what the relative valuation of the two boards is in /a/ these days, they've been through a lot.
>>470170
Maybe not much more, but definitely still more.
>>470164
艦これ、you fucking pleb.
>>470150
No, because when you suggest that they go
>you clearly dont even know what you are talking about
Like as if it isn't a fucking game.
>>470158
Most of the Kancolle discussion IS game discussion. The generals should go on /vg/. Any disagreement is just /a/ssholes being too stubborn to leave their home board.
>the franchise has an incredible amount of secondary Japanese creative content backing it.
Not even true, Kadokawa shuts down most of it so all you get is art. Guess what? /c/ already has a thread for that.
>>470150
This happens in slightly different ways more often than you think.
>/tv/ wants capeshit movie threads moved to /co/
>/co/ wants capeshit movie threads moved to /tv/
>/pol/ wants tinfoil illuminati threads moved to /x/
>/x/ wants tinfoil illuminati threads moved to /pol/
>>470228
>Not even true, Kadokawa shuts down most of it so all you get is art.
And writing, and comics, and animations. Kancolle has only shut down fangames, which is incredibly jewish behavior, but fangames aren't "most of "any franchise.
>>470228
There are a few 24/7 threads on /a/ which have no purpose being there:
`drawfag general - we already have a board for drawing
`buyfag general - we already have a board for toys
`Japanese general - right in bloody title, why on earth isn't this on /jp/?
`Seiyuu general - once again, /jp/
`sales threads - /biz/, in a nutshell
`sad panda literal circlejerk - how many porn boards do we have now?
`madoka general - this is nothing but a /soc/ grade tripfag ciclejerk
`one page manga thread - /wsf/ was created specifically for rec threads.
There is probably at least half a dozen more that should be moved. Mods are moving threads, though. Just not the fucking obvious ones that without a shadow of a doubt do not belong on /a/.
It is so bloody bizarre.
>>470235
And in their cases, are there better alternative boards for them?
>>470240
Edit: really only the Japanese and sometimes buyfag threads are 24/7.
>>470241
Nope. Further, mods ignore requests to take action even if it derails threads.
>>470228
>>470236
>Kancolle
>small c
>>470240
I think seiyuu threads can stay. Madoka threads may be /soc/ tier, but I can't see a way to get them out unless you specifically change the rules to ban Madoka from /a/ (so never). I don't know enough about one page threads or sadpanda threads to comment on them.
The rest should go though.
>>470240
>`Japanese general - right in bloody title, why on earth isn't this on /jp/?
Because /jp/ hasn't been "Japan / General" for six years.
>`Seiyuu general - once again, /jp/
/a/ for the same reason that discussing directors is /a/. Unless you think it isn't.
>>470247
>I think seiyuu threads can stay.
Why? They are firmly in /jp/ territory.
>>470251
>Because /jp/ hasn't been "Japan / General" for six years.
It is still vastly more relevant to /jp/ that it is to /a/.
>/a/ for the same reason that discussing directors is /a/.
Voice actors are nothing like directors, anon. They are discussed for entirely different reasons. Have you ever been into those threads? They are no different to the half dozen 3DPD worship threads on /jp/.
>>470247
I will continue using that small c because I think the big C looks stupid. I don't give a fuck about the official spelling, just like Kadokawa doesn't give a fuck about America.
>>470240
Because we don't have any /a/ mods left, only crossboarding ones. And mod-kun won't do anything with any of the generals because that means he has to get rid of them all, including his favourite one.
>>470275
And people try to claim /a/ has the best moderation. What the fuck?
>>470251
>Because /jp/ hasn't been "Japan / General" for six years.
Well then Hiro should change it like he changed /asp/.
>>470278
We DID have the best. That's long in the past now.
>>470279
Yeah, it should be "/th/ - Touhou". VN and Idolmaster threads can go on /v/ and /vg/, and that about covers all there is on /jp/.
>>470280
How long?
>>470283
Probably around 2013 was when everything started truly going downhill.
>>470235
Eh, I'm alright with tinfoil in /pol/ except when it delves into reptilians, ghosts or aliums.
>dat infowars feel
lmao
>>470284
I saw some people who were claiming that /a/ has the best moderation as recently as this year. How do you feel about them?
>>470294
In comparison to almost every other board? It is still fucking better, but it isn't as great as it used to be. The only board that I can think that has any moderation as good or better than /a/ is probably /vg/, sadly.
>>470299
/vg/ is nice in that you don't have to worry about people making random shit threads that go on for too long, all the shit is neatly contained inside boxes.
>>470300
And that is exactly why /vg/ and generals are so bad. If I wanted neat tidy boxes that are all separated from each other, hate each other and think the other one is in a worse state than them, I wouldn't be using an anon image board.
4chan is more fun when the board is all mashed together instead of being separated into their own circlejerks.
>>470325
I'm forced to use the cancer board for a few things. But, in my experience rule breaking content will generally be deleted within seconds to a few minutes. Shitposting will generally take around 30 minutes. I also recall KoG saying the same himself and that any time he GETS his posts are deleted within about 5 minutes making it a shallow GET and it is why he doesn't do /vg/.
It isn't perfect, but it definitely has people who actually pay attention to it.
>>470331
It probably depends entirely on which thread it is and whether that kind of posting is "accepted" by the thread's culture. In which case nobody will report the post, especially since generals don't have "outsiders" that would see this stuff passing by and report it themselves.
>>470325
>There is basically no moderation most of the time.
I don't know which threads you went but every /vg/ thread I lurked even remotely I saw shitposts get deleted pretty quickly. At the very least it's a lot better than /a/ is now.
>>470352
>thread's culture.
there's no thread culture, that's why generals are cancer. It's called a circlejerk, where a small group who never lurked other threads or boards stays there every day like mongoloids. That's why most generals are SJW shitholes, they never left it so they weren't purged by other threads.
and /vg/ ones are beareble, /a/ ones are bringing the real cancer around.
>>470391
>where a small group who never lurked other threads or boards stays there every day like mongoloids
that's literally thread culture
if a small group of people posts in a board for long enough it becomes "board culture"
>>470307
>4chan is more fun when the board is all mashed together instead of being separated into their own circlejerks.
/thread.
this shit is killing the main boards too.
>>470392
>that's literally thread culture
No, it's a Circlejerk
>if a small group of people posts in a board for long enough it becomes "board culture"
No, because they won't leave their small hole of general only 5-10 people lurk on. Board culture only happens if multiple people share something through a board, newfag.
>>470397
>Board culture only happens if multiple people share something through a board, newfag.
thread culture happens if multiple share something through a thread
this isn't a very hard
>>470400
there's no "multiple" here, most threads are too empty and the same people, it's a circlejerk
>if a small group of people posts in a board for long enough it becomes "board culture"
kek,no. Have you been spamming threads thinking you are a trend-setter?
>>470402
just as an addendum
>small group
I hope the kid meant "big group" because a minority never works. /co/mblr only became sjw after tons of those started to come over there, if they stayed on a general, it wouldn't be board culture. And thread culture was never even said by anyone.
>>470402
>most threads are too empty and the same people, it's a circlejerk
i took a look at a couple random generals in /a/ and they all had about 100 IPs in them, which is hardly low for an average thread
>Have you been spamming threads thinking you are a trend-setter?
if you've never seen someone force something until it became "board culture" you're blind or dumb or both
>>470262
Because /a/ considers seiyuu 2.5D, not 3D.
So... how good is it an idea to move both /a/ and /jp/ threads to a single /vg/ thread?
>>473320
/vg/ wouldn't even notice the difference since they have worse threads.
>>473338
I was referring to the reluctance of the KanColle posters to move anywhere else.
>>474029
Than yes. Why wouldn't it be a fucking good idea? Kancolla IS a game, just like the mobage shit like Granblue. There isn't anything wrong with the threads on /a/ when they aren't a fucking general and are about anime/manga. Dozens of threads just for the fan made content shouldn't be allowed in this regards because those are just cancer used as an excuse to have a general and talk about the game on /a/.
They should be banned from both /jp/ and /a/ for a while and be pushed off into /vg/ where they belong. They'd fit right in.
>>470151
>which is as good as throwing it out, since other than the 4koma nobody really cares.)
Wait it got a 4koma and the 4koma is shit? How do you fuck up the glorious format of 4komas? Those are always gold wtf.
>>470240
Since you named virtually everything, I'm surprised you didn't go after DJT
>>470240
Because nearly everyone on /a/ that considers themselves primary /a/ refuses to go to other boards because those boards are "cancer" and /a/ gets what /a/ wants. The only thing they do most of the time on other boards is anime reaction images but on occasion when they don't get what they want (read: Naruto must be on /a/) they throw incredible shit fits all over the site that last for literal weeks. The only board that rivals /a/ in their whiny tantrums is /v/
>>470408
Posting from a phone through dynamic IP increases the IP count.
I do wonder what's the purpose of having an IP count if it's so easily fooled anyway.
>>474257
A true 4channer browses 5 or more boards.
