[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Would socialism work on an island of only high iq ppl?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /pol/ - Politically Incorrect

Thread replies: 58
Thread images: 13
File: image.jpg (659 KB, 1125x1068) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
659 KB, 1125x1068
say u turned singapore into a "high iq only" country where u needed a 150 iq to live there. To be fair, i only have a 140, so i couldnt join. Would socialism work their? Would the genii there be able to simply run a functional society just by letting the ppl do what they wanted?
>>
>Would the genii there be able to simply run a functional society just by letting the ppl do what they wanted?

Explain how this is socialism?
>>
>Would socialism work if not bound by reality?
>>
File: 1461522337284.png (311 KB, 480x480) Image search: [Google]
1461522337284.png
311 KB, 480x480
>>75833980
No because high IQ people are just as lazy as low IQ people.
>>
>>75833980
>Would socialism work

No.
>>
>>75833980
Who cares? That girl is beautiful.

And no I'm not talking about the jungle creature sitting further back in the photo.
>>
>>75834081
socialists btfo
>>
>>75833980

High IQ people are just as evil if not more by low IQ people and the population would have aspergers or something. That is impossible, OP. Post more feet
>>
File: SNN1114KK_532_1468448a.jpg (38 KB, 532x355) Image search: [Google]
SNN1114KK_532_1468448a.jpg
38 KB, 532x355
>>75833980
>he fell for the IQ meme
Pic related has an IQ of 139
>>
>>75833980

>He didnt read "Brave New World"
>>
>>75833980
Are people with 150 IQ immune to human nature? No, it wouldn't work for an extended period of time. Socialism is inhuman.
>>
have a 140, so i couldnt join. Would socialism work their?
>their

You've left the decimal point out before the zero again, Tyrone.
>>
No. Too many people who think they are better than everyone else in one place only leads to people thinking they are above certain responsibilities. No one will want to do the shit labor because they are too smart for it. Conflict is inevitable. They will probably work out some new way of determining a ranking of who is better/worse among themselves to rectify this.
>>
in an ideal world socialism would work, but in an ideal world you wouldn't need socialism... really makes you think
>>
>>75834240
When will this "IQ meme" meme die?

My IQ is 140, just because I stay at home all day fatting my ass up and wasting my life away it doesn't mean I'm not a superior human being.
>>
>>75834090
In my experience they're lazier.
>>
If you have an iq of 140 and asking this, the answer is no.

Also proofs that iq does not mean nothing and you are retard.
>>
>>75833980
>To be fair, i only have a 140, so i couldnt join. Would socialism work their?
>140
>their

High IQ people wouldn't want socialism. We'd prefer anarchism.
>>
>>75833980
>Would socialism work their?

Look, I live in a socialist wonderland. And socialism isn't a system that you want leading your life. It works fine as an addition to capitalism, but no more.

And honestly, the parts of socialism that work best by far here in Quebec are the ones that are the most capitalistic. Our crown corporations like Hydro Quebec, Loto Quebec, the SAQ. All of them have clear mandates that they fill while also being profitable to extremely profitable.

So I would say that the best way to have "socialism" is to have crown corporations that take care of the necessities and vices of humans. Things like power, transport infrastructure, healthcare, water, land, education, gambling, alcohol. All of these would work under the simple mandate of providing these services to the population at an acceptable rate, accessible price, while trying to turn as much of a profit as possible if not from the residents themselves, then from outside (as Hydro Quebec does by selling power to the USA at a much higher rate than residents of Quebec, but still competitive compared to prices in the USA).

Combined with this, you can have a very minimal government, and an otherwise completely free market.
>>
>>75834166
The girl in op is actually a microceph with a really low iq. Ur kids with her would be stupid, and ud only think they were attractive until, like girl in op, you realized how repulsively small the head was
>>
>>75834571

What does small head have to do with how smart you are?


You are making me quite insecure, anon.
>>
>>75834341
It happens.
Let me know how giving a fuck works out for ya ;)
>>
>>75833980

high IQ people would get rid of socialism

why would they ever need it?

wtf is this thread

kys OP you 85 OP reddit nigger
>>
>>75833980
No. High IQ people wants mentally challenging jobs. A society still need people who doesn't mind doing the lower jobs. "A brave new world" would be a good exemple.
>>
>>75833980
No. Kill yourself.
>>
>>75833980
>people

You've already fucked up OP.
>>
>>75834090
and if those who aren't are more capable at milking the system
>>
>>75833980
No because soon enough they will bring in people with low IQ
>>
jesus fuck who is this semen demon
>>
>>75833980
Of course it could.

Fundamentally, all kinds of politics and governments are the exact same, and everyone wants the same thing, it's only a convoluted way to define who you want to share it with. When you're having a party at your place, everyone can get a drink and shit in your toilet, you just don't let random people in and carefully pick them. And it works.

But we share this planet with nignogs so obviously we need something more elaborate.
>>
File: post-16-1190103595.gif (16 KB, 150x307) Image search: [Google]
post-16-1190103595.gif
16 KB, 150x307
>>75834196
dont worry its not a 1-1 correlation, but there is a strong correlation.. im pretty pos i know the girl in the op, she posts her pics on here from time to time bc she thinks shes cool and down with the internet culture... but shes just another serbian stripper who failed out of community college
>>
>>75833980
post the full set faggot
>>
File: 1464055243032.jpg (16 KB, 390x352) Image search: [Google]
1464055243032.jpg
16 KB, 390x352
>>75835635
>full set
>>
File: 1464240165235.jpg (57 KB, 827x960) Image search: [Google]
1464240165235.jpg
57 KB, 827x960
socialism only works in very small groups, like for instance - the family unit. a family with one earner and one care giver and dependent children is "socialism". the wealth is redistributed, but the other members of the family are giving social currency in return, cooking,cleaning, returning love and kindness, etc.

this can be extrapolated into a small village of 10-20 families max i'd say. men share the work work in fields/livestock... share hunting responsibilities, women communinally care for children while they perform domestic responsibilities, as well as tasks like weaving, reaping, basket/potter... you know there is always something to be done in a village. food is shared communally and as long as food stores are kept positive this socialism would work. they would even be able to absorb the non-production of elders, sick, wounded, or disabled.

it breaks down when you start throwing luxury items or any limited quantity high value goods into the mix. who gets to have? who will have not? primates brains are wired to know when you arent getting your share. the strongest males will take the limited quantity items, the betas will resent it and group together, division occurs and the system falls apart.

if you made currency only available for the "towns" use to trade for unavailable things witho other towns... and only traded for quantities of things that everyone could have without feeling left out... it might work. but then you'd have richer towns and poorer towns, the trade values of goods would fluxuate, eventually it'd break down too.

tldr: humans are jealous fucks who dont know how to share.
>>
>>75833980 (OP)
>I only have a 140
>Would socialism work their?

top kek
>>
>>75833980
Socialism only works in a highly-religious and goal-oriented society.
>>
>>75833980

misty?
>>
>>75833980
We have limited land, so we must be picky with our immigrants and foreign workers. Citizenship and welfare are privileges to be earned with sweat of your brow from your efforts
>>
As homogeneity increases, so does their will to differentiate from one another.
>>
Btw the reason u ppl saying "their ong" and not believing a 140 iq person would make such simple mistakes=the sane reason u couldnt concieve the way a 140 iq brain works= the same reason ur iq<<< 140.
Iq=1/(fucks given)
>>
>>75833980
>say u turned singapore into a "high iq only" country

Nation state with strong borders - check
Nation with performance mentality - check

Congratulation, you describe NATIONAL socialism
>>
File: kewl.jpg (16 KB, 326x326) Image search: [Google]
kewl.jpg
16 KB, 326x326
>>75833980
got any more?
>>
>>75833980
There wouldnt be a need for socialism if everyone was intelligent and productive.
>>
OP describes anarchy, not socialism.

Anyway, a high IQ society faces the same issues as any other.
>>
File: 7dc54aea21.jpg (2 MB, 1197x1228) Image search: [Google]
7dc54aea21.jpg
2 MB, 1197x1228
>>75837748
It's unsourceable apparently, I'll dump what I have.

1/6
>>
>>75833980
People who have an IQ > 130 tend to have other deficits like psychological and behavioral problems. You want a society full of asperg batshit crazies. So to answer your question: no, it wouldn't work. No political system would actually work with the exception of totalitarism.
>>
File: 1457555261874.jpg (789 KB, 969x1920) Image search: [Google]
1457555261874.jpg
789 KB, 969x1920
>>75837938
2/6
>>
>>75833980
It wouldn't work because smart people would get on a boat and go to a different country where they can capitalize on their success.
>>
File: 1457556725104.jpg (1 MB, 1090x1126) Image search: [Google]
1457556725104.jpg
1 MB, 1090x1126
>>75837990
3/6
>>
>>75833980
yes
>>
File: 1457561489061.jpg (1 MB, 1097x1086) Image search: [Google]
1457561489061.jpg
1 MB, 1097x1086
>>75838108
5/6
>>
>>75833980
If it had a small population, yes.
>>
>>75838146
Population 1, always works

>Wilson!
>>
File: 1457561520201.jpg (1 MB, 1125x1068) Image search: [Google]
1457561520201.jpg
1 MB, 1125x1068
6/6, that's all I ever found. Good luck to anyone who feels like searching for more.
>>
>>75834636
Don't worry anon, small head just means your brain has more wrinkles than that of large-headed people. For those of you who don't know and actually give a shit, more wrinkles means more conectivity between parts of the brain.
>>
I disagree.
Socialism works perfectly fine when its crony capitalism where the government feeds the corporations and supports them with legislation. The problem is when the government itself runs a shitty business and the business turns into a public sector thing, which at least in the history in the U.S is a huge cancer in which the politicians basically promise the public sector tons of money and then act surprised they don't have money for other things or that they need to raise taxes. If anything, if the government is actively promoting the growth of businesses that are allowed to operate on free market principles then thats a great thing, because the governments policies are often very limiting to businesses.
Socialism that we are familiar with is basically turning the private sector to another public sector.
Public sectors are rife with corruption all over the world. Public sectors get guaranteed money and have little oversight if any. Public sectors are what makes socialism suck, not the number of people or the business involved.

This is why Socialism will not work, because big government invevitably means a small private sector and that means the large public sector is not allowed to fail. Constant failure is what drives the economy and is the source of American prosperity, that and buying things you could never afford and spending the rest of your life paying more for them than normal.
>>
>>75834428
You obviously don't have an IQ of 140 since a) you're Brazilian and b) don't even understand the concept and meaning of IQ. You're lazy AND stupid.
Thread replies: 58
Thread images: 13

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.