Crazy idea.
Imagine letting in all immigrants as long as they sign a contract. The contract says that they have to leave when they turn 50.
That way you have them while they're young and contribute to the economy and once they get old and start needing healthcare and would get a pension you kick them out.
What do you think?
>>67752350
>Crazy idea
Every Western Country already does this.
It's one of the things people hoped Trump would do away with, and it's one of the thing the Silicon Valley billionaires shit brix over, because they rely on it for wider profit margins.
>>67752350
Completely and utterly retarded.
>>67752350
We did this with the Bracero program. It doesn't work. They never leave.
This is what Germany had been trying to do with the Turks in the 50s and 60s. Guess what happened.
What happens when they refuse to leave?
>non-White immigrants
>contributing to the economy
lol
How about mandatory military service for 8 years? After 8 years of military indoctrination, they become citizens.
You view ppl as workforce meanwhile it is actually social structure. Imagine they have kids & etc. This is nowhere realistic. A lot of professors and skilled technicians are over 50. They provide valuable guidance to the young generations.
>>67752350
That's stupid. They'll have kids born in the country who will be legit citizens and then because of human rights laws you won't be able to kick them out because kids have a right to family.
>>67752686
I think there's already something in place like that. When I was in the military I met multiple people who were about to get citizenship
>>67752350
What if we just drown them
>>67752350
no. you wont be able to handle the swarm that would show up. the west needs to shut its borders now
>>67752705
First two sentences are the reason OP's idea wont work.
>>67752350
just make them sign a paper that says they will adhered to the country culture they are welcomed in and they wont force you to stop doing your culture becuase they get offended.
>>67752350
muh muh if they le sign a document they totally won't turn around and refuse to follow it and do criminal things like other immigrants have done b/c gov's is like god or somethin right ain it?
If some one breaks into your house and puts a gun or a sledge hammer on your head, you think some wispy little paper document gonna keep you safe right at that moment?
Laws only go so far.
>>67752686
A step closer to the fall of Rome.
>>67752350
>That way you have them while they're young and contribute to the rape, homicide and general crime statistics
ftfy
>>67752686
the Romans would be proud
>>67752350
>The contract says that they have to leave when they turn 50.
M8 there's literally an entire section of the government that solely exists to round up people who have broken their immigration periods.
Raj from India or Abdul from Pakistan doesn't have an interest to go back home and work a week for $10. Most don't leave.
>>67752350
Better idea.
Don't let the sandniggers in our country in the first place.
Much better plan.
>>67752350
>contribute to the economy
kek
>>67752350
>That way you have them while they're young and contribute to the economy and once they get old and start needing healthcare and would get a pension you kick them out.
except they never fucking contribute, one out of ten contributes while the rest leech off.
>>67753294
>Implying anyone cares about beaners refusing to speak English.
The problem with illegals is the amount of welfare they use.
>>67752350
So they get te budge for longer. Their younger years are the years in which they will be commuting the most crime, dumb ass.
Here is a radical idea, how about you FUCKING FOLLOW THE LAW and deport them?
>>67752350
Because they are illegal.
If they didn't go the paper signing, test taking route to get here, what makes you think they will sign a contract stating they have an expiration date?
>What do you think?
Terrible, sorry man.
Germany had similar to this with Turkish "guest workers".....they didn't fuck off.
>>67752350
They dont care about economy.
They just like you-> want a free house food and safe 4 walls around them(the only difference is they want to fuck).
Top kek cuckroach
>To this day, Turks in Germany, even after 50 years and three generations, remain poorly educated, some 30 percent don't have a school leaving certificate, and only 14 percent do a degree from Germany's top-level high schools, half the average of the German population. Only 20 percent of Turks have a regular job; the other 80% live on state social benefits. The Bertelsmann Foundation calculated that immigrants in Germany generally, before the massive migrant invasion of 2014 and 2015, were costing the government up to $20 billion per year.
http://www.eurocanadian.ca/2016/03/no-capitalist-or-socialist-economic-rationale-exists-for-mass-immigration.html
The second someone has asylum they, and their families, basically have citizenship and a meal ticket for the rest of their lives.
I don't think the left really understands how asylum works. It's not like letting a mate sleep on your couch for a few nights.
>>67753352
being similar to rome in one respect does not signify that a nation is doomed to fall like rome.
>>67752350
>young and contribute to the economy
A bunch of ignorant, violent, lazy idiots contribute to the economy ? These people can't even speak the local language and you expect them to become regullary employed and pay taxes ?
>>67752686
How about mandatory get the fuck out forever?
There will be no illegals. And after Trump ascends to Emperor, there will be no non-White immigrants whatsoever.
Piss off, mudskin.
>>67752350
Considering most of the troublemakers are people in their teens to early 30s and that all the productive ones would end up accruing sizable amount of wealth over the years which would just walk out the door once they hit 50, your idea is heavily floored.
>>67754413
All nations are doomed to fall.
>>67754928
>like rome
>>67755079
All nations did fall like Rome though. It's either because of a new group conquering them, or a civil war, Rome had both at the same time.
>>67752686
yea muslims in the military , no thanks
>>67755153
so would it be fair to say there is no point comparing anything to rome in the first place?
>>67755295
I think the paralell between Rome and US came because of the size of both empries and their very similar military doctrine and exceptionalism.
The fall of Rome was unique because similarly they never thought Rome could fall, similarly to many modern Americans.
>>67752350
>What do you think?
Great idea, its not like they ever brake the law or anything.
>>67752971
You get citizenship faster through the military service in the US, so I could see why some one would go that route.
>>67752350
>A contract
My fucking sides. Here refugees have to sign a contract that they will respect our "western values" (whatever the fuck those might be in todays interpretation, but they probably mean gaysex and trannyrights) and they recieve a class where they are thought how to have sex and how to treat women.
Yes, western politicians is this nuts.
>>67755447
>Letting another man about your age sit between you and your wife/girlfriend in a photograph
How dickless can you be.
>>67752350
Germany has already spent billion lol
>>67752350
You just described rich arab countries. Unlike europe they can into labor immigration.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMh-vlQwrmU
>>67752735
Kids are not allowed m8. Beheading for adultery.
>>67752668
Beheading.
>non-White immigrants
>contributing to the economy
>we can't into economy
>>67755364
The US is also separated by two oceans from any meaningful military threats, unlike Rome. Water is one of the greatest obstacles over which to project military power.
The US also has the benefit of having protected its returns to power by making its currency the world reserve currency and by establishing the UN, and being a prominent member of it. Nations seeking to attack or destroy the US would first need to rid themselves of the various ways the US has entrenched itself on a global scale.
but you're right, people's attitudes kind-of sort-of sound like rome, so the US must be doomed to fall just like rome.
>>67755834
Yet the US is being overrun by immigrants, just like Rome. Also a civil war is very likely considering the cultural war going on which doesn't seem to end or soften.
Good luck, you're gonna need it.
>>67755364
Ancient and modern times are quite different in relation between civilisation and military power. For armies who fight with sword been civilized could hurt your military power. Soft pussy population who can't be drafted into sword fodder. But modern wars are fought by industries and money.
>>67752686
People who come to Australia for working holiday have to do atleast 6 months picking fruit
>>67752705
>china more rational than everyone else
i have a feeling your country is actually better than most countries in the world for whatever reason. but i cant get enough unbiased info to see if thats true or not
Crazy idea.
Islam.
>>67752350
>implying ISIS would honor a contract
criminals and terrorists don't follow the law
fuck off
>>67752350
>signing a document
how about we inject them with a micro chip, straight into their brain stem or some shit
this chip will have gps, the ability to emmit electric shocks varying from a police tazer effect to 100% excrushiating tormenting pain, if immigrant is found to be playing up or chimping out
and it would also have a small explosive charge that would be cabable of terminating the immigrant if required or desired.
that would surly keep the fuckers in line and at least pretend to act civilized
