Rate Artist Discography
- Home
- Board: /mu/ - Music
- Reading: Rate Artist Discography
One of these threads
Template
The college dropout: 7
Late registration: 9
Graduation: 8
MBDTF: 7
Watch the thrones: 2
Yeezus: 4
FLOP: 1
>>66312913
>Graduation better than CD and LR
How?
>>66314501
College dropout sucks. I hope people start realizing that soon. Half that album is disposable and the other half ain't shit compared to his future works. In conclusion, fuck college dropout.
>>66314544
Nothing on CD is even close to Drunk and Hot Girls level shit
>>66314529
death magnetic is not THAT bad
>>66314612
Songwriting and performance wise you're right, but the production IS that bad.
>>66314579
Except for the skits, new workout plan, last call... The list goes on. And nothing on CD is as good as Flashing Lights
>>66312913
when will the 808s and heartbreaks is good meme end
>>66314814
Close but no cigar
>>66314767
>New Workout Plan and Last Call bad
>Flashing Lights best song on an album with Can't Tell Me Nothing and Everything I Am
>>66314492
switch those around
>>66314544
this.
>>66314536
no find candace?
Fresh OC inbound
Here's to a not shitty LP4
>>66314942
really didn't think Horse and Goat was anything special,i'll give it another try
>>66314956
I can't help comparing find candace to doll doll doll and it just doesn't flow as well
>>66314915
No way! ITAOTS is the worst album ever made.
>>66315188
Dat edge son! That pic isn't even your OC so you're in no position to be trollin with it.
>>66315088
I much prefer Aaron's EPs and singles to his LPs generally. They tend to exhibit much greater relative variety, and overall I think his style works much better in the shorter format. Most of the full length albums feel drawn out and repetitive halfway through. Also in those EP releases he just in general seems to like to break boundaries much more especially in regards to sampling.
>>66315227
Absolutely not.
>>66315227
lol
>>66314978
tru
>>66315310
Is this some sort of new meme or something
>>66315227
Official Mastodon Rankings
1. Blood Mountain (the best starting point and the culmination of their sludge/psychedelic sound)
2. Leviathan
3. Crack the Skye (a fantastic album, but overrated in the Mastodon discog)
4.The Hunter
5. Once More...
>>66315340
woops forgot Remission. Put it after Leviathan and move it down one. I'd say it's about on par w/ Call of the Mastodon if you're being a stickler
>>66315310
Didn't even know he had that much material. thought he was just an industry plant
>>66313159
This is the most accurate one
I've changed this one a little, I figured out I was actually wrong and Graduation is the worst album so that would be below 808's obviously.
>>66315352
childish gambino hasnt made anything higher than a 3
>>66315624
I actually completely forgot about yeezus because of how bad it is.. it's actually below grad, my mistake.
>>66315612
I agree. I love their post hiatus stuff, Asunder is easily a 10/10
>>66315227
i'll never understand why people don't like remission as much as their other stuff
it's better than leviathan IMHO
College Dropout: 8
Late Registration: 8
Graduation: 7
808: God Tier
Dark Twisted Fantasy: God Tier
Yeezus: 10
Pablo: 8
>>66315310
His best album deserves a 3/10.
Black boys thinking they're hot shit kek.
>>66315751
>Rodeo not at least an 8/10
Nice b8
Someone rate Drake Bell's discography.
newfag here
how are 10 and god tier justifiably different?
>>66315783
He has a discography?
>>66315696
definitely, i much prefer the huge, sludgy stonery vibe of remission. leviathan felt too much like a straight-up metal record for me, but without the huge hooks that they developed later on.
>>66315300
>over a 6 for any national album
>it's a band ends their career on their worst album episode
Hopefully nobody will have heard of these guys so I don't need to argue over it
>>66315635
for me its, in order
2
3
5
10
6
7
10
8
8
>>66316070
oh fuck Mortification, my girlfriend goes to the same church as the bassist's wife, small world
>>66315793
god tier is just better
Need to change this, put 21CB down 1
>>66316179
forgot image
>>66315703
>NOTM as godtier
Fuck yeah. I think JD is worse than an 8 but I like how your ratings show that their discog is super consistent, save for Fashion Week.
>>66316189
>>66316179
Spot on I'd say. I wouldnt change 21st century though. The score you have there is bretty gord
>>66315703
pretty close to my feelings, just switch the scores of Jenny death and exmil
>>66316256
Yeah, I might knock Warning down a peg instead.
>>66316285
>using the cringey new faces
adjust that to the official faces
>>66316292
Why? Although I agree with the score from an outsider perspective, Warning is one of my personal faves from GD.
>>66316209
>The Glowing Man
>Shit Tier
Dude what
I spent way too long making this
I hope I get some (you)s
>>66316491
absolute garbage opinions mate
>>66316497
>first album is snakeskin
>second album is a snake
>third album is dried snakeskin
POETRY
O
E
T
R
Y
>>66316523
so what are your opinions?
>>66315793
A 10 is an album which you think has very few imperfections; a god tier album maybe moved you, or changed you emotionally. Or was just mechanically superior.
>>66316684
>>66316684
better than yours
>>66316714
i know mate, everybody knows it here, i just want so see them, please teach me
>>66314767
Last Call and The New Workout Plan are great, the beat to the second part of The New Workout Plan is one of Kanye's best beats. Last Call is great so long as you don't listen to the autobiographical portion every time you listen to the song, and I don't know why the hell you would do that when it's the last song on the album and you can just end it when the autobiographical section starts. I just don't know what to say if you don't like
>Now I could let these dream killers kill my self esteem
>Or use my arrogance as a steam to power my dreams
>>66316344
Billie is a decent songwriter, but the album doesn't have any real standouts like the others. Just a lot of decent songs with a stinker or two (blood, sex, and booze). I like that they went out of their comfort zone, though. Might keep it at 7.
>>66312913
absolute garbage opinion mate
>>66314529
absolute garbage opinion mate
>>66316501
absolute garbage opinion mate
>>66316209
absolute garbage opinion mate
>>66315703
Bump exmilitary to an 8 and switch fashion week with interview and this is good senpai
>>66316914
absolute garbage opinions mate
>>66316497
why would you listen to music like this
with album covers that look like that
>>66312913
>>66313159
>>66314492
>>66314529
>>66314536
>>66314621
>>66314814
>>66314885
>>66314942
>>66314978
>>66315065
>>66315227
>>66315258
>>66315300
>>66315310
>>66315352
>>66315612
>>66315624
>>66315635
>>66315644
>>66315703
>>66315749
>>66315941
>>66316070
>>66316189
>>66316209
>>66316285
>>66316491
>>66316497
>>66316501
>>66316914
absolute garbage opinions mate
>>66317086
absolute garbage post mate
>>66314767
Last Call is one of the best songs on the album you fucking pleb
>>66317055
It's power metal, I like it cause it's catchy
>>66317136
absolute garbage genre mate
>>66316491
>the incident
>4
>in absentia
>not a 8+
>>66317086
If this becomes a new meme I'd just like to say that this was me and I started it
>>66316523
Keep on being garbage mate
>>66317176
absolute garbage albums mate
>>66317202
absolute garbage taste
>>66317252
absolute garbage pleb mate
>>66317160
power metal is fine but i personally grew out of it like 7 years ago
good for anon though who still likes it
>>66317086
So I told anon to make a new meme.. he actually did it the absolute garbage hahahahahahaha!
>>66317301
I went back and forth on it. I liked it when I was younger, really intensely disliked it and made all kinds of edgy comments about it being for babbies when I was a teenager, ignored it for a while, and am back to liking it again at 34
>>66317353
absolute garbage meme mate
>>66316209
>The Burning World 9
>The Great Anhilator 5
>My Father 9
>To Be Kind 4
>The Glowing Man Shit-tier
FUCK YOU
So I like Elliott Smith.
>>66317378
absolute garbage band mate
>>66317394
absolute garbage b8 mate
>>66317371
absolute garbage opinion of a meme mate
>>66314544
Wtf college dropout was when Kanye was most open of his insecurities it had not one bad song
>>66317455
absolute garbage opinion of an opinion of garbage meme mate
>>66317502
mate...garbage...you...opinion...have
>>66315703
Since when did NOTM become everyone's favorite?
>>66317541
absolute garbage grammar of a meme mate mate
>>66317617
absolute garbage album mate
>>66317667
absolute garbage garbage mate
>>66318044
absolute incoherent garbage of a garbage meme mate
>>66318145
absolute garbage opinions mate
>>66318171
absolute garbage opinions mate
>>66318212
absolute garbage reaction, meme and artist ever mate
>>66312913
The college dropout: 8
Late registration: 9
Graduation: 8
808s: 10
MBDTF: 10
Watch the throne: 6
Yeezus: 8
TLOP: 6
>>66314492
OAI is actually good though
>>66314814
this is more accurate than this>>66314885 imo
>>66315612
I actually liked Yanqui more then Asunder
>>66316209
Heres mine
>>66315612
am I the only contrarian that thinks Allelujah is their best
>>66318375
is not more accurate, is closer to an absolute garbage opinion mate
>>66315612
>>66315651
>Asunder
>10
You guys know what's up
>>66318919
we know, you are an absolute fucking garbage pleb mate
>>66315703
>GP above a five
OPINION AUTOMATICALLY DISCARDED
>>66319402
absolute garbage opinion discard mate
Fresh OC, m8s
pleb coming through
I'm aware you guys think blink sucks
>>66312913
>Late Registration = 6
>Yeezus = 9
Whew, lad...
>>66315624
ayy
>>66318305
>>66313159
>>66312913
respect to 808s- ye's best
>>66315703
>NLDW not god-teir
>>66317394
candy?
>>66317394
Sounds about right I agree man. this guy knows whats up.
>>66320803
absolute garbage kanye album mate
>>66321119
the only bad kanye albums are graduation and wtt
>>66321246
>TLOP
>god tier
People like you are why /mu/ is so shit
>>66315635
Bruhh, your ratings for the bends and ok computer are absolutely insane.
>>66321384
>my shitposting only gets a 3/10
Harsh
>>66312913
Kanye said the same thing in every album except graduation.
>>66321384
Thank you.
>>66321246
>808s
>2
>TLOP
>God tier
Literal garbage opinion mate
>>66312913
>>66313159
yeezus is trash
>>66321824
this is completely untrue. literally the only thing setting kanye apart is the fact that each album is thematically different based on his life when he made it.
>>66315612
pretty much
>>66321998
Absolute garbage post mate
>>66322069
So no other Hip Hop artists has done that? (Assuming that what you said was even true about kanye.)
>>66320806
tru
>>66322069
If there were to be anything that separated Ye from the others ( besides his uncontrollable desire to be labeled an artistic genius) is the fact that his music was, for the most part, not very violent in comparison to the other shit at the time. Besides good sounds there isnt anything special about his music.
Alot of people prefer GKMC over TPAB, but man, if there's funk/jazz implemented into Hip-Hop, it always gets me.
>>66322321
is overly dedicated really that bad?
>>66314824
it's actually really amazing
>>66322450
(You)
>>66322438
No, it's great. this dude's an idiot.
>>66318488
>My Father a 9
I agree with pretty much everything here but this. It's not bad, but it's easily the weakest of their reunion material.
>>66320213
>Buddha 2/5
>Chesire Cat 1.5/5
>Dudee Ranch 1.5/5
>Enema 2/5
>Take Off Your Shirt 1/5
>s/t .5/10
>California 1/5
>>66322884
why do you do /5 for some but out of /10 for others
anyway, blink-182 isn't even that bad although California was shit
>>66322666
trips of truth
>>66315635
>the bends
>3
>Okc
>5
what the fuck????
>>66314885
Patrish
>>66321103
Patrish
David Bowie - 7.8/10
Space Oddity - 8.3/10
The Man Who Sold the World - 8.7
Hunky Dory - 10/10
The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars - 10/10
Aladdin Sane - 9.6/10
Pin Ups - 6.3/10
Diamond Dogs - 9.3/10
Young Americans - 9.1/10
Station to Station - 10/10
Low - 10/10
"Heroes" - 10/10
Lodger - 9.5/10
Scary Monsters (And Super Creeps) - 9.4/10
Let's Dance - 8.9/10
Tonight - 7.2/10
Never Let Me Down - 5.0
Black Tie White Noise - 6.7
The Buddha of Suburbia - 5.5/10
Outside - 7.0/10
Earthling - 8.2/10
Hours - 7.3/10
Heathen - 8.8/10
Reality - 7.7/10
The Next Day - 9.0/10
Blackstar - 9.7/10
>>66323083
do you still enjoy Pin Ups?
>>66323042
v good rate
>>66323120
It's not terrible but also not great. I don't really consider it to be in his discography that much.
>>66323083
Whoa, you really love Bowie.
>>66323083
how did you feel when bowie died
>>66323212
He is a huge influence for me an so many others. A true loss to the music world.
>>66321103
>Ranking Centipede Hz above Campfire Songs, Here Comes the Indian, and Feels.
I thought we could be friends, but guess not.
>>66312913
not as good as
>>66313159
>>66314492
stale, moldy meme
>>66315352
you're getting hate but if BTI was a bit lower it would be on point.
>>66315635
Jesus man, I know their earlier stuff is pretty simple but The Bends and OKC are pretty good.
>>66315644
I didn't know her discography was something that people listened to.
>>66316285
That accurately sums up the disappointment that was Coloring Book
>>66320213
You can like Blink and not make half of their albums 8+
