what haooened
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
what haooened
Everything on that image is shit, pop "music" is not music
>>66104752
Stop being 14
>>66104784
If I were 14, I'd listen to pop music. Adults should only listen to art music and traditional music.
>>66104730
>implying /mu/ ever gave a shit about Christgau
>>66104835
Why
Fantano and Scaruffi where the same era faggot
Scaruffi > Anthony > Christgau > Markel
>>66104857
Because pop music is only made for monetary gain, traiditional music is the music of the common people, art music (with the exception of modernist Atheist art "music", which is not music) is a form of worship of the one true God
>>66104897
>>66104897
tips
>>66104924
>>66104934
Found the Atheist degenerates. Go tip your fedora over at r/atheism, music is a Christian art.
>>66104934
You mean these Sweet Trips?
>>66104974
>he still believes in god
you physical realmers crack me up
call me when you've transcended into the spiritual realm and have connected with our divine creator ra'am al sha|mus
>>66105000
WITNESSED
>>66104974
what the fuck that chin
>>66104752
>>66104835
>>66104897
You don't actually like music
Why are you here
What is wrong with To Be Kind and The Powers that B.
>>66105009
Enjoy burning in hell.
>>66105058
God punished him for becoming an Atheist.
>>66105085
hell is on the physical realm, child :^)
if ive already transcended, how can i revert? dont bother posting on this board until you understand the basics of planar travel
>>66104974
music existed long before christianity you fuckwit
>>66104897
lots of popular music is made with an artistic statement in mind, and lots of popular music is given away for free without monetary gain involved. you're a young teenager.
>>66105065
That's funny, coming from someone who only listens to degenerate pop "music". The "music" you listen to is the most simplistic garbage imaginable and is only made to be sold and to promote hedonism.
>>66105109
You're laughing now, but that is going to change when you will have to face the consequences of your actions.
>>66104752
>>66104835
>>66105142
>>66105142
>implying emotions that simple exist on the spiritual realm
kek
literally a fetus in the eyes of any spiritual realmer
>>66105129
Too bad it's not worth listening to.
>>66105139
>lots of popular music is made with an artistic statement in mind
No, it's only made to sell records and to promote hedonistic values.
>lots of popular music is given away for free without monetary gain involved
Only to sell it later on, when the "artist" has gained attention for giving his early works away for free. All popular music has a target audience.
>>66105169
I don't wear a fedora because I'm not an Atheist.
>>66105142
Popular/rock music can be much more than "simplistic garbage".
Listen to these:
Yes - Close to the Edge
The Velvet Underground - Sister Ray
>>66105204
le trole : D
>>66105000
hoho
>>66105237
>Popular/rock music can be much more than "simplistic garbage".
>Sister Ray
pls
>>66105253
good old /mu/ calling historic and artful rock songs bad
>>66104835
if you were 14, why wouldn't you listen to art music and traditional music, instead of pop? don't give me any of that "le less developed brain" stuff because a lot of people i knew as a kid listened to your "art music" as well.
>>66105283
>it must be good because it is old
>the meme
:)
>>66105237
Everything you listed is garbage. The latter example even proves my point, degeneracy is all Lou Reed ever wrote about.
>>66105349
Obviously no one should listen to pop music, but it's understandable if children like it because it's extremely simplistic music.
>>66104894
wait what's so bad about marcel? he posts some really good obscure stuff i wouldn't have found out about otherwise and offers a wildly different take than most contemporary critics.
>>66105457
marcel pls go
>>66105477
that doesn't answer my question retard
>>66105484
whatever you say marce now go to bed
>>66105512
that still doesn't answer my question
>>66105527
alright marcel
>>66105563
XDDDDDDD
>>66105434
You realize that probably more babies listen to classical than adults, right?
>>66105594
Listening to music and understanding it are not the same thing. That's why pop music is popular among children and manchildren, most songs are only two or three chords over a simply rhythm, a monkey could understand them.
>>66105434
So what if the lyrics are "degenerate"? I'm talking about the music, not the lyrics. Musically, Sister Ray is possibly on par with many classical compositions.
>>66105457
I didn't say Marcel is bad you fucking retard. I'm just ranking him the lowest among the four, that's it.
>>66105643
>So what if the lyrics are "degenerate"?
Lyrics are the only aspect of music most people understand, it is therefore the one that influences people the most.
>Musically, Sister Ray is possibly on par with many classical compositions.
It's three chords over 18 minutes. People only praise it because it's edgy and because of the terrible recording quality ("muh noise rawk").
>>66105643
Sister Ray is 3 chords for 17 minutes.
>>66105000
holy shit
>>66105745
look at this fucking child
>>66104730
spiderland, crimson king, filosofem and notm are the only good albums there
fight me
>>66105793
Ahhhhhh... I missed that game.
>>66105000
czeched
>>66105932
You have still not rebutted my claims and only post a reaction image. It seems to me that you're the one who is a child.
![1417580104502[1].png](https://i.imgur.com/uDqv2ui.png "1417580104502[1].png")
>>66105932
>pop listeners consider this on par with many classical compositions
>>66106090
wew lad, you know this board is 18+ right? shouldn't you be in bed or something?
>>66105759
there is so much more going on during that song than 3 chords. it is not just 3 chords
>>66106182
>"pop listener"
>"art music"
> "modernist Atheist art "music""
see >>66105065
or rather:
You don't actually listen to music
why are you here
>>66106188
Not an argument
>>66106202
Well, the audible part consists of only three chords, everything after that is hardly recognisable due to the extremely poor recording quality.
>>66106233
Stop projecting.
>>66106262
>"wow le edgy comeback xDDDDD"
>someone memes at him
>"THIS IS NOT AN ARGUMENT IM HAVE A SERIOUS CONVERSATION ABOUT GOD"
>he memes at someone
>????
I have better things to do with my time
>>66106331
This is a music discussion board, maybe you should try [s4s].
>>66104730
both are revolting tbqhdesu
>>66104752
>>66104835
>>66104897
>>66104974
>>66105142
you realize that "Christian rock" does the same thing as "pop music" and its marketed to your fucking Christian audience to make a quick buck. it's one of the worst genres and youre implying that
a: only Christians write good music
b: Everything on OP's pic is pop music. its not.
with you're logic, pic related is better than Loveless.
define your fucking terms before you trash pop music.
>>66104752
I think to fear pop music is just as pleb as not being able to listen to anything other than pop.
>>66106720
this
if you can't groove out to some nice rock, jazz, or hip-hop, and listen to music only for intellectual purposes, you are either
a: pretentious
b: don't actually like music
c: literally autistic
d: all of the above
>>66107160
>a: pretentious
Not listening to anti-intellectual music is not pretentious, it's the right thing to do.
>b: don't actually like music
>people who don't share my taste in music don't like music
>c: literally autistic
See a)
>>66106566
"Christian" rock music is not Christian.
>a: only Christians write good music
That's the truth.
>b: Everything on OP's pic is pop music. its not.
It is. Everything on the OP picture was just recorded to be sold.
>with you're logic, pic related is better than Loveless.
They're both equally terrible.
I can't believe you managed to rope this many people in. Good job anon.
>>66105000
whaatttttt
>>66105000
Sweet trips, you're my favorite anon/meme
>>66107330
Not an argument.
>>66105637
then you dont seem to understand that pop means popular and everything, I mean EVERYTHING, can be pop.
Just see, classical music was the thing centuries ago so it makes it pop because everyone listen to it.
do you enjoy music?
>I understand music you dont
Im pretty sure you dont have friends
>>66107376
I'm not arguing with you though.
>>66107453
No, popular music is music recorded to be sold.
Art music is music preserved through notation.
>Im pretty sure you dont have friends
Projection.
>>66107277
wow ur so much better than me i wanna be ur friend :^)
>>66107721
>art music
>"art music"
how do you even define art music? isn't music an art form? is it music made for the sake of being art? if so, there's pop songs with more noteworthy reasons for existing
>>66107726
Not an argument.
>>66107756
>Art music is music preserved through notation.
I answered that question in the post you replied to.
>isn't music an art form?
Only art music is art.
>is it music made for the sake of being art?
Good art music is made as a form of worship.
> if so, there's pop songs with more noteworthy reasons for existing
Wrong.
>>66107795
art1
ärt/Submit
noun
1.
the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power.
"the art of the Renaissance"
synonyms: fine art, artwork
"he studied art"
2.
the various branches of creative activity, such as painting, music, literature, and dance.
"the visual arts"
>>66107823
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Art_music
>tfw art music-kun has returned
>tfw plebs too lazy to google art music and getting mad at the term
>>66107949
I just thought it was some edgelord, not an actual thing
>>66107948
Art music is art music, but all music is art, if that makes any sense.
>>66108078
No, only art music is art. Pop music is a product.
>>66108106
And products can be art.
Example: books are art, and they are sold.
>>66104730
people on /mu/ don't really talk about Barter 6 tbqh famalam
>>66104894
Musicreviewingthony Godtano is better than all of them
>>66105000
Nice.
>>66105000
absolutely based
>>66107795
>Only art music is art
>Good art music is made as a form of worship
>>66105000
epin
>>66107325
no, look dude i think i get what youre saying. you're saying that only music that's made for the pure good of it is the only meritable music. not true, ALL ART is designed to generate an income in a campitalistic environment. real art takes dedication, time, and a love for the craft, and that's it. it has nothing to do with whether the artists are selling their stuff or not. everyone fucking does that. In this culture, it can't be a side project that's free for the public, nor is everyone entitled to free art.
However, where you're wrong is telling other people that the passion they have for their "pop" music isn't authentic. fuck you. the one thing in common people have on this board is a genuine love/appreciation for music, which a lot of people don't have.
enjoy you're avant garde bullshit, and the pretentiousness that comes with the genre
>>66105000
>>66105000
no
>>66105000
GOD IS REAL
>>66105000
good jab
Why can't anyone on /mu/ just enjoy the music they enjoy and not care about what music other people like?
