ITT: Albums whose quality nobody can agree on

it's shit

>>66098496
I think you meant to say It's THE shit as in it's the best radiohead ever.

All music because each person's experience is unique and disgusting in its own way.

>>66098496
>>66098521
Proof of >>66098476

>>66098476
Literally every album

>>66098529
>>66098521
>>66098496
Samefriend

>>66098476
>The Butcher
>Staircase
>Supercollider
>Daily Mail
>These are my Twisted Words
If any 4 of these were on the album, TKOL would be a legit 9-9.5/10

SAINT ANGER
PROTECTOR, PROTECTOR, REJECTOR, INFECTOR, PROJECTOR, INFRECTOR INJECTOR DEFECTOR REJECTOR!!!

Trout Mask

>>66099163

Identikit should have been on TKoL instead of AMSP

I think the band was playing with it at the time

>>66098528
>>66098549
I'm pretty sure OP meant albums that are polarizing.

>>66099416
Then we wouldnt have the choir part
>you will never live in a world where identikit was a 10/10 from tkol era

KoL is great

I've never seen so radically different opinions than for mbdtf

>>66098476
Teens of Denial

Thanks to all the "Hi Will" memes I still have no idea if /mu/ likes it or not

THE ARK WORK

>>66099601
>Identikit stretches the album out to In Rainbows' length
>no one complains about length
>all they can complain about is the music now
>but they can't because Identikit is a 10/10 that makes them see the genius behind the album's sound

>>66102248
Has anyone ever complained about the length of in rainbows? Only ever heard that for httt, even though it's not even that long

File: Whatever_People_Say_I_Am,_That's_What_I'm_Not.jpg (16KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

16KB, 300x300px

>>66098476

life of pablo

>>66102295
HTTT needs cutting because of the filler songs, not because of the length

>>66102350
You mean I Will? The rest isn't filler