band claims to be post-punkis only punk

File: no.jpg (18KB, 360x274px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

18KB, 360x274px

>band claims to be prog
>is actually emo

>>65858849
> The Mars Volta

>>65858849
muse

File: George Reaction.png (17KB, 222x252px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

17KB, 222x252px

>band claims to be "just a rock n roll band"
>is some other subgenre of the wider rock music genre

>>65857355
>band claims to be good
>is only radiohead

aren't we all post punk roflmao :L

File: AmericEno.png (202KB, 306x251px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

202KB, 306x251px

>singer claims to be post punk
>is jon the postman

>>65857355
why are proto and post punk so good, while actual punk is boring af

I mean The Velvet Underground vs Ramones vs Talking Heads

>>65859036
>who cares what we are? we just wanna RAWK!!!
I fucking hate this shit.

>>65859088
>proto
Actually bold and experimental for its time.
>post
Changing up the very slim punk sound by introducing outside ideas.

>>65859088
I'd say Wipers are good but they kinda straddle the line between post-punk and punk
post-hardcore and hardcore punk are pretty good imo

>>65859088
I totally agree that proto and post punk and more interesting but how do you not like any punk if you are a fan of those genres? I get that it's less varied but there is still some great stuff out there. Ever try wire's pink flag, that's a great album that toes the line of punk and post punk.

File: 1444150236214.jpg (21KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

21KB, 300x300px

>>65859534
>wire's pink flag, that's a great album that toes the line of punk and post punk.
Pink Flag isn't even remotely post-punk. Compare it to 154 or Dome discography, Document and Eyewitness even mocks this by only playing ten seconds of 12XU and then playing nothing but post-punk pleb filters.
Chairs Missing is the one that blurs the line between punk and post-punk.