>samples other people's work
>music "artist"
It really depends how you do it.
>makes shitty threads
>a "person"
>>65665852
>stealing is fine if it's done creatively
But Replica is really good
>Only plays guitar, maybe sings
>"Musician"
>>65665865
this
>>65665866
Classical guitarists aren't musicians?
>>65665837
is this were the sad toad meme came from?
>>65665854
Disagree? Use your words kid
>>65665884
Don't get smart with me, kiddo
>>65665892
>make shitty meme thread with a waifu picture
>expects serious replies
>>65665866
when did you change your trip, Montie?
>Had songwriters write their songs/lyrics
>Artist
>>65665862
>people like Pete Rock aren't artists
Ayy lmao
>>65665910
So you don't. Next
>>65665928
I wasn't the guy you were replying to Mr. Baitmaster
>production team
>ghostwriters
>choreographers
>plays no instruments
>"musician"
>"artist"
>>65665862
>Making something creatively
>not art
>>65665953
Ah the whole "I wasn't that guy" cop out, epic
>>65665862
So are 4chan posts and all of your's are egregious. Have some imagination with your shitposting
>>65665918
Was about to mention Pete rock too.
Whether you like it or not, all songs are stolen from other songs. There's only 12 different notes on a piano. Every song has been replicated thousands of times. Good use of sampling is difficult and requires more creativity than you'd think.
>>65665981
this
>>65665981
>charisma
>talent (vocal ability)
>stage presence
>can dance and sing
>>65666025
It's true but ok. Add some spice to your bait, I'm not really feeling it
>>65666070
What's he point of coming here and calling things bait? If you don't wanna discuss nothing then fuck off
>>65665837
She looks like a perfect MILF
Help
>>65666091
Ok I'll discuss. Explain to me why sampling is bad
btw if you want discussion, don't start your thread with memes
>>65665865
Eccojams is better desu
>>65665862
>stealing is fine if it's done creatively
fucking absolutely
>>65666126
it's legal plagiarism
>>65666197
And why does that make it bad? I'm sure you've pirated music before.
Explain to me why it takes away credibility as an artist to sample something?
>>65666108
if joanna gets pregnant, it'll be too much for my dick to handle
>>65666250
it's cheap and lazy. you're using someone else's hook.
>>65665862
exactly.
>>65666327
What sort of sampling are we talking about? Like the way Kanye did it with King Crimson, something more or less than that?
>>65666069
you described a performer, not an artist.
>>65666411
Those two terms aren't mutually exclusive. As a matter of fact, they're synonyms.
>>65666477
>As a matter of fact, they're synonyms
No they're not, and I can't even see why you'd think that
>>65666250
They didn't invent it, they heard it and thought " that sounds good, I'll use that."
>>65666530
Same question as this>>65666376
>>65666477
>As a matter of fact, they're synonyms.
uh...no they're not.
>>65666524
>>65666585
Synonyms does not have to have the exact same definition.
>>65666477
>they're synonyms
maybe in the most basic semantic sense. nominally in that instance.
i mean sure, you could call a person that performs other people's creations an artist, but i would call them a performer.
>>65666644
Well I suppose they could be synonyms in the sense that performing is an art. But the thing about Beyonce and other such performers is that they don't conceive of the performance or the music. It's all written, choreographed and everything by someone else. She's just told what to do and she does it
>>65666644
Would you call a cheer squad artists?
>>65666069
>great ass
>can shake that ass
>bearable voice
ftfy
>>65666644
So I guess Milo Yianopulous, cheerleaders, Kpop fuckdolls, strippers and professional athletes are as a much artists as Mozart, Swans, John Cage, Jandek and Bach, right?
Your argument's a joke. Then again, it's probably bait.
>>65667165
>are as a much artists
There no spectrum of how much of an artist a person is. If you're involved in making art, you're an artist.
>>65667165
Yes
The question is how good their art is
>>65667165
Well Milo has more relevance and importance than those other things but either way music isn't art and is largely pointless.
>>65667220
>Milo
>relevant and important
>>65665866
>Makes music
>""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""musician""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
>>65667220
When someone says that music isn't art I automatically assume it's your fault for listening to shit music. Music is art and no matter how hard you try to defend your own definition of it, it's still is.
>>65667217
No, what you're saying implies that the creation of the first 5 is art to begin with. I don't consider it true art and I suspect neither do any people with basic understanding of culture and expression. If you believe those 5 are artists, I'd like to read what do you define as "art".
>>65667203
Agree. That's why Bach is as much as an artist as, say, My Bloody Valentine, even tough the latter has far, far less artistic value in its craft. If you don't make art (as the 5 first cases don't) you're not an artist. Milo Yianopulous, cheerleaders, Kpop fuckdolls, strippers and professional athletes have other virtues and products which are not art. Very simple really.
>>65667220
Who?
>>65667806
>even tough the latter has far, far less artistic value in its craft.
>an overrated Meme composer has less "artistic value" than one of the greatest and most innovate rock bands of all time
Holy shit, I'm fucking dying.
>>65665862
Are we just stating facts in greentext now?
>>65667980
jej Im not a classical fag. You need better bait my friend.
>>65665862
>bad artists borrow good artists steal blah blah
it's true though
also every piece of art is influenced/stolen from somewhere
>>65665866
this is some dumb shit lol
>>65665837
Everything we know is someone's idea revised and improved.
Only recently have people claimed to own ideas...
It actually halts progress .
Join or die
https://m.soundcloud.com/ronniescholarship/suntrust-1
>>65665837
>tfw sampled Joanna Newsom like half a dozen times
