ITT: Take out a song to make an album a 10/10
- Home
- Board: /mu/ - Music
- Reading: ITT: Take out a song to make an album a 10/10
>Hell of a Life
>I'm a Man
>>65582809
Have you lost your mind?
>The Gift
replace it with one of the unreleased tracks.
Ballad of Jerry Curlan
>>65582909
No, keep The Gift and Sister Ray and make a 10/10 EP
>>65583000
Or not have the gift at all.
>The Decline
>>65582809
Hell Of A Life is a top 3 track on the album you pleb
What You Want
>>65582809
You would need to remove both Monster and So Appalled for it to be anywhere near 10/10
>>65582909
This album can't be improved by subtraction.
>Same Old Man
>>65583131
Yeah.
>>65582809
you're crazy dude
try taking out blame game or who will survive in america
>needs no progress
>>65583108
>This album can't be improved by subtraction.
Can you read you f***king ****tard
>>65583108
Monster is fine but I agree with So Appalled.
>>65583240
Not sure if you're baiting with the self censorship, but either way, taking out The Gift or any of the other songs won't make it 10/10, even if you replace them with something else.
>>65583296
Then what's your point of being in this thread? let alone contributing?
Are you this F***ing dumb?
>>65583346
Have a nice day.
>>65583346
He's implying the whole thing is shit.
>>65582809
>Monster
Nicki Minaj's verse always puts a damper on the rest of the album. Like does anyone who isn't 13 and female actually like her?
>>65582809
You mean Runaway
>>65583364
but he contributed to the thread?
Big hypocrite
>>65583108
what you want is the best song on the album m8
>>65582809
Also take out Blame Game
>>65582809
>>65583108
>>65583376
>>65583379
>>65583413
You're all correct with your opinions on MBDTF. That album is fucking whack, only keep Dark Fantasy, Power, All of the Lights and Lost in the World and then it's aight.
>>65583429
desu people who think that album is a masterpiece or even more than an 8/10 are either fooling themselves or just plain retarded
>>65583364
That's not what I was implying at all.
>>65583411
Well that's definitely not true. I'm not sure it's actually the worst, but by the time it comes around on the album, it doesn't really add anything new.
>>65582909
>Doesn't like the gift
>>65583108
Pleb detected.
>>65583108
There's no way you can't adore that song's melody, listen to it more closely
why does Female Lover have to be such a lame closer?
>>65583635
I don't think I was clear enough. I like the song. I'm not going to remove it or not listen to it, and I don't think anyone else should. I wish that it was never on there.
>Money
it should be moved between Have A Cigar and Wish You Were Here desu
>>65583720
The reason it was there was because they wanted it to be the first song you hear as you turn over to side B on the record. As you walk back to your seat you hear that riff
>>65582809
This album doesn't need any tracks removed it's already a 10/10
If any of you think Monster or Runaway are bad you should honestly off yourselves.
>>65583757
I know but it's still a bit jarring compared to the rest of the record. The semi-funky riff fits in better with the bass of Have A Cigar and HAC's theme of capitalism in the music industry and could serve as a great cross-over/contrast to the melancholy of Wish You Were Here with a few tweaks. Still a great song, and it's good on DSotM but it could've been better with a different sound that stands out a bit less imo
>>65583201
>blame game
>bad
>Rundtgåing av den transcendentale egenhetens stotte
>>65582809
Album: Meddle
Song: Seamus
>>65583868
That song is so hypnotic, I can't see myself liking the album as much without it
Album: Hail to the Thief
Artist: Radiohead
Song: Sit Down. Stand Up.
>Drunk and Hot Girls
>Electioneering
>>65583379
I can't believe you just said that anon.
>Dopesmoker
>>65582809
Firstly you dont take out any of the tracks on that masterpiece. But if you did, itd be Who will survive in America obviously.
Hell of a life is GOAT
>>65584254
>screenshot of your phone
Fuck off.
>>65582809
yup
>>65582809
Would just take swizz beats out of so appaled
>>65584212
This or Barry Bonds desu
>>65583108
Nah just remove Jay-Z and Nicki's verse and replace them with better rappers because otherwise Monster is a great track.
>>65585881
While Barry Bonds is bad, it aint Drunk and Hot girls bad.
That song is literally Ye's worst besides Pinocchio Story.
>>65583015
But...but no
>>65584254
That and subterranean homesick alien are the best songs on the album though.
Chocolate Girl
>>65586019
Get outta town
>Infinity
>>65586019
nice b8 m8
Hot Head
Volcano
>inb4 yum yab
>Recury
>>65586264
Delete your account.
>>65582909
wtf
>Big Man With a Gun
>>65586019
get out
Empty Churches
>>65583868
Fuck off. That song is incredible and necessary for the album, which is perfect the way it is.
>>65585404
True
>>65584212
I really don't understand the hate for Drunk and Hot Girls, is it just bandwagon shit? It's a legitimately fun song.
>>65584254
i completely agree. it doesnt belong
>>65585404
This joke sucks balls since none of the Dopesmoker-realeases consists solely of that track
