Customize your cookie preferences

He's objectively wrong on Pet Sounds.
Otherwise yeah he's right.

>>65373531
Donuts and MPP need to be lower, but otherwise yeah

Wow that's the lowest score I've seen for MPP or Kid A to date
Yeah not right

Make the Swans and Kanye a 0

Switch MPP with Strawberry Jam and give both that and Spirit 9s

Make Radioheads 5s

Make Death Grips a 0

Make Pet Sounds a 9

you're golden

>>65373575
And Death Grips

>>65373589
Has Scaruffi ever given a score lower than 2? I haven't seen one yet, and the only 2 I've seen is for a Sufjan christmas album or something.

>>65373588
t. newfag

>>65373588
>it's not the norm so it's wrong
>>65373571
I agree, too high.

>>65373646

He gave like 20 2's to Tangerine Dream.

>>65373728
Why does Pet Sounds deserve a lower rating?

>>65373752
Has he ever given a 1?

>>65373834

I'm assuming a 1 would be the worst album ever, and similarly to a 10, he hasn't given that out yet.

>>65373894
if scaruffi gives a 10 i'd worry if he's going through a mid life crisis or something

Make Spiderland 9.5

Make Kanye 5

Make Spirit 9

Make Kid A 9

Make Sufjan 7

>>65373531
He's right, like always.

>>65373894
High hopes for the new avalanches album though

>Still pushing the Jason Aldean meme
Hahahahahahaha

>>65373531
Switch MPP and Spiderland
Then switch Pet Sounds and TMR

not even kidding

>>65375562
fishmemes detected
go suck off your /daily/ pals and watch anime

>>65373531
King Crimson, Kanye, AC, Swans, MBV, Avalanches, and Newsom should all be a couple points lower.

>>65373531
everyone's ratings are right

>>65373531
Does explain his ratings?

>>65373531
Don't even care, he gave stftb a 8. I value his reviews

TMS - 8/9
Kid A - 7
STGSTV - 8
Pet Sounds - 8

Everything else is alright

Remain in Light, Spiderland and Pink Moon are perfect 10s