Scaruffi rates /mu/core
- Home
- Board: /mu/ - Music
- Reading: Scaruffi rates /mu/core
Do you agree with these scores?
>>65289593
I thought he gave lift a 7
Missing 21 pilots
10/10
>>65289593
Yeah, Scaruffi's the only on-point music critic left.
He actually gave these surprisingly high ratings
also this is hilariously outdated
>>65289647
kill yourself, i mean it
I'll never understand how Kanye fans meme'd their way onto every essentials chart on /mu/
>>65289593
From a technical standpoint yes. Spiderland, Loveless and ITCOTCK were definitely more influential and innovative than the rest.
>>65289593
>remain in light only 7/10
nu-male spotted
>MBDTF better than RiL and Kid A and on par with ITAOTS and STGSTV
And don't even get me started with ExM.
where is the banana album and the fish
Correct:
>STGSTV, Loveless, Untrue, Talking Heads, ITCOtCK, Exmilitary
Too high:
>Spiderland, MBDTF
Too low:
>Kid A, LYSF, ITAOTS
>>65289593
Kanye is overrated, as is Slint and Loveless here. Kid A here is underrated, as is Lift Your Skinny Fists and In the Aeroplane, but everything else I agree with to the extent of what I've listened to.
>>65289642
He did. OP's messing with the score to please himself.
>>65289710
what about remain in light?
>>65289952
Nah man.
>Correct
Spiderland, Loveless
>Too High
Burial, ITCOTCK, LYSF, MBDTF, ExM
>Too Low
ITAOTS, STGSTV, Kid A, RiL
>>65289593
All I want to know is what the fuck happened to /mu/core.
>>65289647
implying any sort of critic can be "correct"
>>65289593
>RiL worse than any Kanye
no he's a senile old man desu
>>65289647
listening to that shriveled pedo prune
>>65289977
Actually I remember the score being a 7.5 so I just put that score because I was lazy to look it up. I'm guessing it must have dropped.
>>65289593
>giving mbdtf and examilitary bigger score than kid A
>being this edgy
>correct
Spiderland, Loveless
>incorrect
The rest
>too low
Kid A
stop using this shitty outdated chart
use this instead
>>65291757
>another fucking Radiohead album
>>65289643
You joke, but he gave Vessel a higher rating than Revolver and the White Album.
>>65291757
>no deathconsciousness
>>65291790
>>65291824
-in rainbows
+ the glow pt 2
It's not that hard kids.
>>65291824
I haven't seen people talk about it much lately
>>65291757
>three (3) Radiohead albums
>It's In Rainbows
