ITT: Ratings
- Home
- Board: /mu/ - Music
- Reading: ITT: Ratings
one of these
>>65058343
Template?
>>65058343
pretty much spot-on damn
sgt pepper's a 7 though
>>65058343
>>65058479
Agreed. Seems pretty close to the norm.
>>65058379
>TKOL
>2
>Lower than PH
I just don't like them.
>>65058856
Accurate
>>65058379 pretty pleb 2bh
>>65059547
this is dumb because even if you didn't like them they wouldn't be 0's
>>65059914
You catch on quick.
>>65059979
>Speakerboxx/The Love Below their best
JUST
>>65059935
did you listen to Live in pompeii?
>>65059935
Never got the appeal of Animals. I agree with Meddle, though. That's their true masterpiece.
>>65058343
>rating any beatles album above a 3
The fact that so many books still name the Beatles as “the greatest or most significant or most influential” rock band ever only tells you how far rock music still is from becoming a serious art. Jazz critics have long recognized that the greatest jazz musicians of all times are Duke Ellington and John Coltrane, who were not the most famous or richest or best sellers of their times, let alone of all times. Classical critics rank the highly controversial Beethoven over classical musicians who were highly popular in courts around Europe. Rock critics are still blinded by commercial success. The Beatles sold more than anyone else (not true, by the way), therefore they must have been the greatest. Jazz critics grow up listening to a lot of jazz music of the past, classical critics grow up listening to a lot of classical music of the past. Rock critics are often totally ignorant of the rock music of the past, they barely know the best sellers. No wonder they will think that the Beatles did anything worthy of being saved.
someone tell chris martin to stop this fucking shit
>>65058343
>revolver
> 10
>>65061512
accurate.
Interpol tbqh
>>65058343
coming through with the accurate ratings.
>>65059935
Probably the most accurate floyd chart yet. It's triggering my autism that it's not chronologically ordered though.
>>65062006
If by accurate you mean Scaruffi's thoughts on The Beatles, then maybe.
>>65061047
>Graduation
>4
Seriously? "Flashing Lights" alone was better than Late Registration...
>>65061512
I can get behind this. I'd lower Parachutes and raise A Rush of Blood though.
>>65058379
>>65061025
bad rankings, yeezus, graduation and the bends need to be much higher
>>65059979
Someone really listens to that other than that Hey ya! song for laffs and nostalgia?
>>65062395
The Love Below is one of the best r&b records of the decade
Speakerboxxx is a decent hip hop album
it's not a 10 tho
>>65062006
kystbqhwyf
>>65058343
>>65058597
>>65059547
>>65062006
I Beatles appartengono certamente alla storia del costume degli anni '60, ma i loro meriti musicali sono quantomeno dubbi.
I Beatles vennero alla luce all'apice della reazione nei confronti del rock and roll, quando innocui "teen idols" (rigorosamente bianchi) prendevano il posto dei selvaggi rocker neri che avevano scosso le radio e le coscienze di mezza America. L'arrivo dei Beatles rappresento` il salvagente per la middle-class bianca, terrorizzata all'idea che il rock and roll rappresentasse una vera rivoluzione di costume. I Beatles tranquillizzarono quella vasta fascia di pubblico e conquistarono i cuori di tutti coloro (soprattutto al femminile) che volevano essere ribelli ma senza violare i codici imperanti. Ai volti contorti e lascivi dei neri del rock and roll si sostituiro i sorrisi innocenti dei Beatles; ai ritmi scatenati dei primi si sostituirono le cadenze orecchiabili dei secondi. Il rock and roll poteva finalmente essere accettato nelle classifiche del "pop". I Beatles rappresentarono la quintessenza della reazione a una rivoluzione musicale che non era finita, e per qualche anno riuscirono ad arenarne l'impeto.
>>65062975
Swap I&W and Awake and bump BC&SL up to an 8 and that's pretty much my opinion
Best fucking band of the 2000's.
>>65063718
overall accurate
>>65062006
THE FACT THAT
>>65058856
Feels is 10, and STGSTV is God-tier
>>65063718
STGSTV needs to be god-tier, but accurate otherwise
>>65062975
this >>65063288
Awake is easily their best album and Black Clouds is solid
>>65061047
>>65061860
what's the starfish cover one?
>>65066465
xylem tube ep
