ITT: The album they should've stopped at.
- Home
- Board: /mu/ - Music
- Reading: ITT: The album they should've stopped at.
ITT: The album they should've stopped at.
>>64720187
>I have been rocking
>When I should've been rolling
What did he mean by this?
Actually, this is my favorite Zep album along with Zep II.
Where they should have stopped and where they did stop, despite evidence to the contrary.
Could've saved themselves a lot of embarrassment
>>64720280
That's not Some Girls
>>64720371
Monster is the correct answer
>>64720187
But Presence is ace.
>>64720526
Confirmed for never having heard a Beach Boys album after Smiley Smile.
Dude I can't WAIT until some EDGY MEMÉ KING decides HE'S SO FUCKING FUNNY and posts In Rainbows. That would be THE SHIT.
>>64720753
they should have stopped at pablo honey desu
>>64720799
Highway to Hell is theyr best one, but Back in Black was still AC/DC. The newer ones are good, but they're...
>end my sentence
>>64720835
Nah they should have stopped after revolver
>>64720835
see this is actually goddamned hilarious because there's considerable debate over whether this or let it be should be considered the final beatles album
>>64720187
In Through the Out Door has some good tracks. Everything afterward sucks though.
>>64720620
I knew someone had to post that
>>64720932
You mean Coda?
I'm not a fan of most of their albums between Wake of Poseidon and Red (I like both of those two, though) but they're really fucking important albums, I'm just not a big fan.
After Discipline there's not one redeeming thing about anything they put out, bar none.
>>64721026
Even Absent Lovers?
>>64720955
Trigger warning
>>64720777
Yeah
>>64721043
Live stuff is fine. I'm mostly talking about new studio material.
>>64720928
Abbey Road is the last Beatles record. You go by recording dates.
>>64720685
Man. What about Painkiller?
>>64721155
And parts of Let It be were recorded after Abbey Road
>>64721170
There's like ton of stuff they did after it, yeah.
>>64721155
They were finishing recording on I Me Mine in January of 1970 after Abbey Road had already come out.
Granted, I still think Abbey Road is the last because John wasn't at that 1970 recording session, so it wasn't "The Beatles", it was just three guys that used to be in a band together.
Wow, this thread still has a lot of untapped trolling potential.
>>64721200
doesn't change the fact that they should've stopped
>>64721237
I got you pham
>>64720484
>>64720498
>>64720533
>>64720551
>>64720573
This is objectively the best answer in this thread.
>>64720187
>He doesn't like Presence
Achilles Last Stand is pretty jammin'.
>>64721479
>Achilles Last Stand
Literally the only reason for listening to that album.
>>64720531
If they stopped after Sabotage, they'd be revered as the greatest band of the 70s.
>>64720835
>>64720928
They recorded Abbey Road last.
>>64721515
Candy Store Rock?
>>64721535
Except
>>64721222
>>64721026
Bruh "Dinosaur" off of Thrak is one of Crimson's best
>>64721551
OK, I'll give you that.
>>64721619
This is the answer you give to seem cool but accurate.
>>64721696
Should have stopped at around half the tracks from this album desu senpai
>>64721515
>not Tea For One
>>64720490
I wish we could stop pretending their other albums were any good
>>64721615
SOMEONES BEEN DIGGIN MY BONES
Dissappointed no TKOL memepost
>>64720531
>>64721516
Sabbath don't have any truly wtf albums except TE and Never Say Die (maybe Seventh Star?).
>>64721923
Seventh Star isn't really a Sabbath album anyway, it was just Iommi recording a solo record with a bunch of studio guys after all his bandmates departed following the 83-84 tour. The record label insisted on putting the Black Sabbath name on it for marketing purposes.
>>64721967
Maybe move the cutoff to Yield or Binaural.
>>64721790
She still had a few good singles up to All Hung Up, but as far as albums, that was the end.
Anyone else glad Chuck Berry stopped recording new stuff after Rockit?
>>64720753
pablo honey is where they should've stopped
>>64720777
van halen II desu
>>64721619
>>64721729
sung tongs is where they shouldve stopped
>>64721967
>>64721894
>>64720622
>>64720539
correct
>>64721262
Shouldn't have broken up [spoiler];_;[/spoiler]
>>64720622
was about to post this
>>64722142
>sung tongs is where they shouldve stopped
That's like saying Talk Talk should have stopped with Spirit of Eden.
>>64722142
>sung tongs is where they shouldve stopped
That's like saying Pink Floyd should've stopped with Division Bell
>>64722283
Not really, senpai. Some of the later albums are fine, I'm quite partial to Kiss of Death myself.
>>64722142
>sung tongs is where they shouldve stopped
That's like saying Radiohead should have stopped with Kid A.
>>64721923
But anon, TE and NSD are good
>>64722501
Maybe although about 90% of their setlists in the later years were 1978-86 material.
>>64720187
Maybe even before this tbqh
>>64720187
i hate to say it, but this band still hasn't recovered from the loss of Steve Clark even though they've made 6 albums since and still tour.
>>64720539
MOP is more like it.
>>64720685
SFV and DOTF are badass albums though
>>64721894
nigga they should have stopped after RIP
their last two albums were pretty good though.
>>64722283
>Built For Speed
I get the amphetamine reference, Lem.
I mean Reflektor is great and all but they would've left a great legacy if they just stopped here. Or like if one of them died tragically or something.
>>64722752
This.
>>64723124
nah
>>64722777
This
But I wouldn't say it really was The Clash after Mick and Topper left.
>>64720280
We can debate forever where the Stones jumped the shark. Depending on who you ask, it was anywhere from GHS to Dirty Work and some people like my mom only liked their 60s stuff and think they already lost it at Exile.
>>64720344
But it's been such a wild ride though. Had we not seen the depths we would have never seen the comeback kid rise again.
I might get shit for this because pop punk, but I kind of wish they stopped here and just focused on dan's side project because now they've gone away from the more emo side and have become 100% warped pop punk.
>>64720711
>Implying Fear Of The Dark, Brave New World, and Book Of Souls wern't good albums
bruh
>>64723436
This. The only worthwhile songs on the new album are Cardinals, I Don't Like Who I Was Then, and Cigarettes & Saints. Other than that the album was pretty boring. You In January made me cringe.
>>64723043
>>64722752
I think David Gilmour felt too guilty leaving TDB as the last album considering the last song is High Hopes, which was a very negative song to retire a band with. Lost For Words may suck, but at least it has a positive message.
>>64724090
>Lost For Words
I meant Louder than Words
>>64720520
Lonerism was the shit dude. Currents was ok.
>>64722777
They should've broken up after Give 'em Enough Rope. (Nice trips)
>>64720685
The only advantage that would have is sparing us from the horror that is Turbo. The other albums are all meh at worst.
Sometimes you just need to let sleeping pop punk bands lie.
>>64724448
His second album is better. More ambient and less memes.
>>64724466
more like let them die
>>64722777
I actually don't hate Cut the Crap.
>>64724466
>>64724487
>you will never live in the alternate universe where Travis died in the plane crash and Blink are treated as legends
>you will never live in the alternate universe where Neighborhoods never happened
While i really really want them to have made more stuff, it's the only good thing they've brought out.
>RELASHAAAAANS
>>64722998
I preorderd the suburbs yet have yet to listen to reflektor
in my mind they did stop at the suburbs
>>64724573
There is literally no reason to dislike their full-length if you like FYEB
>>64724604
I'm gonna listen to it again right now and get back to you.
>>64724466
man I havent listened to blink 182 in for fucking ever
time for a nostalgia trip
Don't get me wrong, I liked The White Album, but this would have been such a great final chapter to their story, and I can't shake the feeling that they're going to blow it sometime.
>>64721923
TE and NSD are based, just nowhere near as based as the stuff they were actually committed to
seventh stars not an actual black sabbath album, it's iommi's solo album but the label slapped sabbath's name on it for the cash
also it's a pretty good listen anyways
>>64724604
Way less energy, guv, doesnt immerse me nearly as much.
>>64724774
>Implying Rivers won't retroactively remove Green-Hurley from their discography release the Black album and kill himself
>>64720510
Kek
>>64721165
sucks balls. Bleach rather.
>>64722035
i fucking hate you
>>64722852
i also fucking hate you
>>64725580
lol
(unless we count live albums, then it's the Unplugged one)
>>64720344
>Implying Pinkerton isn't an embarrassing listen
>>64720187
But then we'd never get Achilles Last Stand.
>>64720582
If anything it's worth it for just Achilles Last Stand
>>64720280
I thought this album was really boring and that Sticky Fingers was their first shitpile. Their 60s stuff is alright for the most part, though.
>>64724503
That isn't Random Album Title
>>64720771
Nah m8. OMRS is pretty good
>>64721900
tru
>>64720280
personally I listen up to Tattoo You, but I consider Some Girls to be the essential cut-off.
>>64720371
>>64720436
Green, and even that's a bit whiny in places.
>>64720539
strongly agree
>>64721696
would've said BSSM, personally
/thread
>>64727106
nigga you cant do this
>>64727260
dumb pleb
HAA was a masterpiece and RAM was 10 years ahead of its time
>>64727356
more like 40 years in the past
>>64722035
>>64725759
You have to admit that they never made a good album after Since I Left You
>>64724551
Am I the only one who likes neighborhoods? It's no s/t or enema of the state that's for sure, but I think I might like it better than take off your pants. It's a pretty consistent album and natives and after midnight are pretty good. It can feel pretty lame and cringey at times but so can everything they make.
The new single is a nightmare which is a shame because I like skiba a lot
>>64720533
>ignores that their best two albums come right after this.
This one is fucking obvious. Greetings from L.A. is sub-par funk and Sefronia/Look at the Fool are embarrassing.
>>64720777
Exactly what I was thinking
Check'em
soa re these the artist's last good album? or the album where you could see them going downhill/rehashing their work?
but if they stopped there we wouldn't have Achilles last stand!!
you didn't think this through, did you?
>>64720526
what about surfs up?
>>64722128
absolutely not
seasons in the abyss is a fucking masterpiece how could you not know that
>>64720928
I think that may have been the joke, you trip cunt.
>>64728421
the correct choices are:
>surf's up
>holland
or
>love you
>>64723792
Exactly. It's like they're caught in between what they personally want to do(emo shit) and what the label/tumblr kids want(generic pop punk). The way I see it, they should have just taken the songs you mentioned in your post and made them into an EP, and then release the rest as an album. If they had done it that way, it would have been a much more coherent album.
>>64726113
>>64726139
Behave
>>64728494
more like silent alarm
>>64726972
I think you mean this. SP died when Billy cut his hair.
>>64720371
Fuck you Automatic For The People is their second best album
>>64720473
Fuck you Bottomless Pit is better than Jenny
>>64720510
Fuck you Viva La Vida is their best album
>>64720520
Fuck you Lonerism is better
>>64720563
FUCK you. Their only mediocre album is the s/t, don't be a drone
>>64721170
Fuck you m b v was amazing
>>64722614
Thats their best album anon
>>64724628
No
>>64726972
>>64728769
Fuck you Adore was great. Machina would be good if it wasn't so obnoxiously loud produced
>>64728769
nah. too long, and ditching Vig for Flood to produce was the wrong move IMO.
>>64728908
>Tells someone how to think
>"Don't be a drone"
k
>>64728908
>Machina would be good if it wasn't so obnoxiously loud produced
Have you ever listened to the unmastered version of Machina? It's so much better.
>>64722142
>sung tongs is where they shouldve stopped
That's like saying Animal Collective should've stopped with Sung Tongs
>>64728999
Im not telling you how to think, but when you disregard 3 albums that are technically similar to the acclaimed one with just a few differences Ill assume you're hopping the hate bandwaggon surrounding that band.
>>64720665
Tru
>>64729090
true, they would've had a perfect discography
>>64728908
while BP is pretty good, it's obvious they don't plan to do anything new. Hot Head is the only track that stands out as something new for them
>>64729090
More accurately
>>64730413
Idk they're pretty unpredictable. I just think with BP they perfected the style JD went for while being more consistent.
>>64724899
The Resistance is okay at times, but I agree
>>64720280
We wouldn't have gotten Some Girls though, Miss You and Beast of Burden are some of their best songs
>>64730538
It's no doubt better overall, it's just kind of retreading old material, which isn't what I think of when I think of Death Grips
>>64729090
Should've stopped before that you mean. Going out on Moon and Antarctica wold have been great.
>>64730518
Eh, I liked 'Good News' and can still stomach it, but I've listened to 'We Were Dead' maybe 1.5 times total, and barely remember anything from the one time I listened to the latest one. The first three albums + the EPs would have been a great discography by itself.
>>64728389
The correct answer.
I will fight people who think Monster is shit, and I don't even see how you could like their post IRS years stuff and not see this one as a strong effort.
what's with all the pleb tier and dadrock bands here
>>64720665
>>64720551
>>64720533
>>64720498
>>64720484
Even if you're samefagging I agree wholeheartedly.
>>64721515
Candy Store Rock, Royal Orleans, and Nobody's Fault But Mine are good
>>64723098
that's not a picture of Auschwitz
>>64730934
I posted the second one not knowing that someone else had posted it, and it took off from there.
>>64730886
new adventures is just such a logical conclusion
electrolyte would be perfect to go out on
plus they went to shit anyways after this album
>>64721026
Oh come on, Beat was a great album. So was Three of a Perfect Pair.
>>64723124
>implying This Is What You Want...This Is What You Get and Album are bad
Come on mate, you know you like Rise.
>>64724318
London Calling is their objectively best album, but come on, everybody loves that record.
>>64725951
Best one I've seen so far.
>>64728308
Eh...debatable. Empire Strikes First was dope tho.
>>64730562
Pretty much.
>>64730591
Nice bait
>>64730776
PRECISELY.
>>64722142
>sung tongs is where they shouldve stopped
That's like saying Yes should have stopped with Fragile.
>>64730413
I would say there's as much new content on BP vs their older music as, say, The Money Store vs Exmilitary. It's still Death Grips, but they definitely created a distinct sound for the album and address new topics in their lyrics.
Appetite for Destruction
>>64721619
even if it is their best album, that clearly isn't where they should've stopped.
Probably MPP if anything
>itt: only the album I like the most should exist
>>64725112
I'd go with Holy Wood.
>>64732306
I feel ya, but Lies was pretty good, too.
>>64732847
Meh. Lies sucked, but if they would have taken all the filler out of UYI I&II and made one good album instead of two really uneven ones.
Wild PLanet was their peak
shame it was only their second album
Nothing exists after this in my mind
>>64728615
What did New Order do post-80s that was of any value?
>>64732502
Merriweather Post Pavilion is the objective answer, most people just don't feel comfortable with admitting it, or feel the need to be unique.
>>64733293
But then we wouldn't get Fall Be Kind
>>64726972
Californication>bssm
Its literally the only bearable rhcp full length
>>64733228
this
>>64733392
I meant the whole Merriweather era, including ODDSAC, which is the last thing of worth they did.
>>64733559
CHz era was great though too.
>>64733559
I can get behind this.
>>64724551
They are regarded as legends by nostalgic 90's kids and hip throwback highschoolers who will love the wonder years and front bottoms in a few years
>>64732734
Naw, Deadwing is great.
>>64720344
Weezer went from a band that should have quit while they were ahead to the band that proves you can come back from anything.
>>64733596
It was terrible. The songwriting sounds forced and uninspired, and the sonic attack is repulsive and nonsensical. They were clearly not in the right state of mind when making that album. The album never should have been made. Even the 'good' songs sound forced and unnatural. Amanita, for example, which everyone seems to praise, sounds like they're really straining for a "great closing track," but it has none of the effortlessness that Brother Sport possesses, and isn't even a very good song. The whole album sounds like throwaways. Everything on it sounds corny as fuck. Still, though, it's not their worst, because at least they sounded slightly engaged, if just barely. On Painting With, they sound completely defeated, like they just threw their hands up and stopped giving a fuck. On Centipede Hz, it sounds like they wanted to believe that they were capable of something great.
>>64733469
>Its literally the only bearable rhcp full length
So you'd rather listen to whiny middle schooler/soccer mom music than a badass and creative Funk Rock album?
Good taste you have m8 :^)
>>64733791
THIS. EWBAITE and White were fantastic. Apparently they're getting more experimental with their next release and I can't fucking wait.
>>64733596
Not to mention, the Centipede Hz era resulted in Monkey Been to Burntown, which is the worst release with Animal Collective's name attached to it.
>>64733890
>creative funk rock
Where the fuck am I
Also both albums suck but atleast one is tolerable, Anthony Kiedis has to be the worst, most obnoxious frontmen ive ever heard
>>64734019
Even if you think it's shit you can't deny it's a creative Funk Rock album. Also if you're implying Californication is tolerable then you should leave.
>>64734019
>Where the fuck am I
>proceeds to make a case for Californication
You're on the wrong fucking board m8
>>64722142
Soon over babalula you pleb scum
>>64734402
Babaluma
>>64727356
Well if it isn't the very same tripfag who tried to defend RAM
>>64733228
BP was pretty good desu
Amnesiac
That is all.
>>64720539
The Black Album was still good.
Even Load was ok, tbqh.
>>64721696
Californication
>>64721967
No Code is their best album.
>>64724628
Fuck no. Even his final albums were amazing.
>>64720519
>>64720711
>>64720901
>>64725112
>>64728347
>>64728389
>>64732631
>>64733186
>>64734345
Correct
>>64735069
>Californication
>not By the Way
Wrong.
>>64720187
Bonzo shouldn't have died and they shouldn't have ever stopped
>>64720280
Tattoo You
>>64720371
Monster
>>64720510
Viva La Vida
>>64720531
Heaven and Hell
>>64720539
They shouldn't ever stop
>>64720620
Kill yourself
>>64720771
Once More Round The Sun is objectively better than Crack the Skye
>>64721053
what the fuck Panopticon is one of the best albums of all time
>>64721262
what the fuck is wrong with you. literally the worst post in this thread
>>64721894
Endgame is fucking god tier
>>64722128
>what is Seasons In The Abyss
>what is Disciple
>>64722752
they should have stopped at the wall
>>64725580
awful post
>>64726972
mellon collie has some good songs
>>64720484
>>64720777
>>64720799
>>64721026
>>64721170
>>64721696
>>64721967
>>64722742
>>64723273
>>64728769
correct
>>64722752
Waters leaving should have been the end
>>64727214
B-but he has yet to release his 2nd LP. We want more
>>64727260
>He hasn't listened to Alive 2007
Wait next year, Alive 2017 will be dope
>>64722752
They should of stopped after the wall not one decent album after that
>>64722035
More like the only one they should have made
>>64722752
They should have stopped at Animals. Everything after was a musical atrocity
>>64725983
Can The Fall really be considered it's own album? It's basically just a B-side to Plastic Beach.
>>64720539
Yes
>>64720685
No. We would have never had painkiller. But I will agree that Judas Priest was a hell of a lot better before this album than they were after.
>>64720711
They should have stopped after Somewhere in Time imo
>>64721894
Correct
>>64722128
Seasons is great though
>>64722752
Should have stopped after The Wall
>>64725580
dumbass. Should have stopped after Sabotage.
>>64720344
>>64720510
>>64720539
>>64724899
>>64734345
correct
>>64721894
Rust in Peace
>>64722128
Seasons in the Abyss
>>64722852
(you)
>>64725112
Holy Wood
>>64721170
MBV is just as good
>>64738596
Jeff looked just him ;_;
>>64720344
the green album is okay
>>64721026
If you sit on the Power to Believe for a while, you'll realize it's actually the Penultimate
>>64726972
Adore is their best album tho
Not implying that this one is bad, just that they've never put out anything as good since
>>64720775
kill yourself
>>64724573
how can you deny so i shotgunned a beer?
>>64720490
agreed
>>64721619
Close, but you were off by one
>>64730934
Idk, if they did stop we wouldn't have Relayer and Going for the One, which were still very solid albums.
>>64724503
I agree with>>64726184, Rat is the only good album he made
>>64730776
I prefer Avery Island more, as well, but you can't deny that we just think it's better because we've heard ITAOTS so many times. The latter is clearly Jeff's masterpiece.
>>64725445
this might be true
It's not his best release
But would be a good end
He didn't necessarily have to stop, but the whole digital noise clusterfuck was cool for a bit but really got old fast. I don't know how he can still be doing the same shit for so many years without getting tired of it. I want '80s Masami back.
>>64738546
I think you picked the wrong picture, anon.
>>64731290
I disagree. I hate that album
>>64724541
Highly under rated. Great songs, especially all of side one.
>>64720711
I disagree
>>64730776
Ferris Wheel On Fire is pretty tight
>>64740162
I disagree, Machina II is one of my favorite albums of all time. Also unpopular opinion, but I think TbK is pretty nice too despite all the hate it gets.
>>64740262
RoF is pretty good but ITI is the better album
>>64732731
sad but true
>>64740282
I just listened to this and it's surprising how good this is. i'm not really a fan of nevermind.
sorry rome
>>64740282
i get it
The last album where they attempted to even be bluesy.
![talon[1].png](https://i.imgur.com/lwVw3JZ.png "talon[1]")
![album-covers[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/6o8LZhk.jpg "album-covers[1]")
