ITT: Albums where literally every song is perfect
>>64600041
>Punk rock will never be this good again
Hold me /mu/
>>64600041
Holy fuck what is with the sudden resurgence of spamming this garbage album?
Please stop
Not a single bad song on this album.
>this wasn't the shape of punk to come
>>64600041
nope
>>64600041
>Wake Me Up When September Ends
So close. Pic related is better.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HmV4UrklBjk
>>64600165
Reminder that it's literally reddìt to hate American Idiot. Jesus of Suburbia is still a masterpiece.
>>64600263
>it's literally reddįt to hate an album which is literally reddît
So it's also nigger to hate hip hop?
>>tfw i first listened to this while smoking weed for the first time
>>64600219
>still viral marketing this piece of trash tweeny brit pop
>>64600235
objectively true
>>64600041
This album is unironically better than half of /mu/core shite
>My Name is Jonas
10/10
>No One Else
10/10
>The World Has Turned and Left Me Here
10/10
>Buddy Holly
10/10
>Undone
10/10
>Surf Wax America
10/10
>Say It Ain't So
10/10
>In the Garage
10/10
>Holiday
10/10
>Only in Dreams
12/10
>>64600235
Nah, that's one of the good songs.
She's A Rebel and the title track are the only not god-tier songs
>>64600219
I like it as well...but perfect?
>>64600522
Only in dreams way underrated here bro, 14/10 at least
>>64600522
all are 10/10 except for only in dreams which is a 3/10 imo
>>64600547
She's a Rebel is great. Extraordinary Girl is the only song on that album I find unmemorable
>>64600565
you can't actually have this opinion. i could understand if you didn't like the other songs on the album, but thinking every song but this is a 10, and giving it such a low score, that's actually not possible, so please stop posting bait this obvious
>>64600298
On the Run kind of sucks and I think the album would be better without it.
>>64600662
not bait, i think the bass sounds really annoying and the song is way too long and boring
>>64600671
I can agree with this, but it's not exactly a shit piece.
IMO would have been better if they kept the travel sequence instead of OTR
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXsYp9Ye2xg
>>64600683
you should probably stop listening to music desu
>>64600759
>don't like one song from an otherwise perfect
>you should probably stop listening to music desu
lol
Idk if everyone likes this style of music but id say for its genre its a very well rounded album.
Jesus of Suburbia > Letterbomb > Homecoming > Give Me Novacaine > Holiday > Boulevard of Broken Dreams > St. Jimmy > American Idiot > She's a Rebel > Whatsername > Wake Me Up When September Ends > Are We The Waiting > Extraordinary Girl
Based album tho
>>64601013
exactly right anon, u got that 100% spot on
>>64601013
>Whatsername that low
>>64601013
Letterbomb is my shit, man.
>>64600263
Jesus of Suburbia is just a low fat version of The Decline
>>64601013
Homecoming > Letterbomb > Jesus Of Suburbia > Give Me Novacaine > Whatsername > Wake Me Up When September Ends > Boulevard of Broken Dreams > St. Jimmy > Holiday > Are We The Waiting > Extraordinary Girl > American Idiot > She's A Rebel
Waiting is their best overall song though.
>>64600041
>Extraordinary Girl
I unironically love that album but I can't agree. Sorry.
>>64600298
> ITT: Albums where literally every song is perfect
> Posts greatest album of all time
Floydposting is cheating m8
Shocked that no-one posted this yet.
How does a band make an album that is literally one of the greatest indie records of all time and then go on to make a load of shit? I'm fucking baffled by that alone.
>>64601839
I love albums with overarching storylines. Gonna give this a listen.
>>64601911
Be warned, before you go into it. It is utterly emotionally devastating.
First album I ever cried at the end of. Seriously. I cannot listen to it more than once every six months. Its just...too much.
But an absolute masterpiece none the less.
Speaking of concept albums, any recommendations?
>>64601926
>>64602018
Added to my to listen list. Thanks!
>>64600219
There are literally two good songs on this 80s wannabe MBV ripoff glammy brit pop rock album. Please Be Naked which is actually a decently produced song and is similar to a Helios track, an actual good ambient artist. Lost My Head is the only other good song because it's a MBV rip-off so obviously it's only likable for that reason. Rest of the album is boring tumblrcore trash. The intro song is alright to I guess but at a lower level because I'm not a faggot.
>>64600263
Homecoming is also a fucking masterful song, a classic. Letterbomb and Whatsername are the only other worthy songs to be mentioned. And Wake Me Up When September Ends.
>>64600263
This is actually true.
>le Green Day sold out
>it's not le real punk
>i grew up with Dookie so it's better
Cancer.
>>64601839
>How does a band make an album that is literally one of the greatest indie records of all time and then go on to make a load of shit?
It happens all the time. Be it a drive to make one more than they are or capturing a moment that cannot repeated. I'd go so far as to say that, at least in music, being constantly good is a harder get than being great once.
>>64602130
I guess you're right there, but the sheer discrepancy in quality between Hospice and something like The Attic is stunning.
>>64600041
No one on /mu/ listens to grunge but IMO Badmotorfinger by Soundgarden is a 10 because every single song is good/great. Not a single low point, but still manages to have high points. Really doesn't get talked about enough in the grand scheme of the 90s pantheon
Angel Dust would be on there too because its high points are much higher, but I feel like Jizzlobber is lacking a bit and Malpractice is just too intense for most people at first listen
How long til /mu/ goes through a grunge resurgence phase? I feel like it's unpopular enough now that it'd be hip to start talking about it again
>>64602139
True.
>>64602115
I was on r/music and some guy got a hundred or so upvotes for unironically saying that Boulevard of Broken Dreams is the worst Green Day song. That's how much of a meme it is to hate American Idiot there.
>>64602221
Are you serious? Wow. I'm so grateful I unsubbed from r/music and r/listentothis
DAE LE GEM????????
Been listening to this album for at least 100 times in it's entirety, if not more, and here is my priority of goodness:
Jesus of Suburbia > She's a Rebel > Letterbomb > Homecoming > American Idiot > Give Me Novacaine > St. Jimmy > Boulevard of Broken Dreams > Holiday > Whatsername > Wake Me Up When September Ends > Extraordinary Girl > Are We The Waiting
1 "American Idiot"
>very relevant in times when Trump is winning and shit, good energetic upbeat pop-punk melody
2. "Jesus of Suburbia"
>teenage zeitgeist, really diverse and varied tempos
3. "Holiday"
>again, really relevant in times when Trump is winning and shit
4. "Boulevard of Broken Dreams"
>hugely and insanely overrated. Not a bad song, but quite average when compared to all of Green Day's discography
5. "Are We the Waiting"
>I'm a sucker for that slow drum beat, good to listen to when drunk
6. "St. Jimmy"
>Used to like it more when I was younger, I like the second part after the release
7. "Give Me Novacaine"
>quirky sound effects, used to like that song so much that I can't listen to it anymore, too overplayed
8. "She's a Rebel"
>Top favourite now that I am 22 and grown out of Green Day, mainly because it's short and sweet and I never listened to it before that much
9. "Extraordinary Girl"
>Not a good standalone song, but when you listen the entire album at once, it fits in there nicely
10. "Letterbomb"
>I love the stretched out vocals part, it makes me jizz my pants every time
11. "Wake Me Up When September Ends"
>Overrated song, can't listen to it, too overplayed
12. "Homecoming"
>lovely energetic beat, what's not to love
13. "Whatsername"
>used to love this song so much it became a part of who I am today, now I can't listen to it, too overplayed
It's nice to see /mu/ unironically finding American Idiot album, it's a good find for real.
>>64602233
>>64601724
>>64601013
Any list without Wake Me Up When September Ends at the bottom SURELY has to be wrong, right? That song is legitimately terrible, easily the biggest stain on a very good/otherwise listenable pop punk album
I don't know if Fleetwood Mac is ever talked about here, but Rumours is one of my favorite albums.
>>64602314
I wouldn't call it bad per se, but it is just so poppy and overdone. Then again, it was such a integral part of my formative years that I've fucking worn grooves into the disc. Perhaps that's why I find it unlistenable these days.
Every song is perfect
So how many great albums will the Trump presidency produce?
>>64602337
QOTS is legitimately one of the most influential rock bands of all time. Absolutely. Could not agree more.
Era Vulgaris as well.
>>64602314
I don't think it's terrible, but it's nowhere near as good as the best the album has to offer, and it honestly just seems out of place. Sounds like it belongs on 21st Century Breakdown.
This album got me through a terrible break up, so I may be biased, but it's literally perfect.
>>64602337
Personally, the title track seemed superfluous to me considering Vampyre is on the album. Not that great a song. This has to be one of the (if not THE) best "rock" releases in the last 5 years though
>>64602453
Eh, I can somewhat agree. The beginning feels kind overdone.
Just great. Listen with headphones. I've listened to this album over 100 times and I find something new every listen.
Shoot me, but I legitimately think that The Suburbs is the best album of the decade.
>>64602139
Are you stupid? The Attic is fucking amazing. Actually, I don't know what you're even talking about, Antlers remained more or less consistent through the years. Burst Apart, Under the Sea, Familiars, these are all great.
>>64602616
Not gonna shoot you. Instead I'm gonna agree with you. Seriously fucking amazing.
Add The Lonesome Crowded West by Modest Mouse and Transatlanticism by DCFC on there and we good.
>>64602620
I disagree with you there. The Attic was underwhelming. Not bad, but underwhelming.
Then again, the first record of theirs that I've ever heard was Hospice, so I could be really fucking biased on this.
>>64602591
>Metalcore
>Nintendocore
>Mathcore
>Experimental Metal
These are the worst genre tags I've ever seen
literally best album of the decade
>>64602743
Bait
Worst album Animal Collective have ever made.
>>64602644
https://youtu.be/A0fcwYaABw8
>genre tags
You've spent too long on /mu/ anon
>>64601906
Agreed, except for Only The Good Die Young,
The Evil That Men Do is a fucking classic, as well as the title track.
>>64602743
This. Fuck the haters this album was brilliant. Nothing even comes close to it melodically and sonicly.
is this whole thread ironic?
>>64602642
>The Lonesome Crowded West by Modest Mouse
yes
only problem is Long Distance Drunk but it's not too bad
>>64603170
Long Distance Drunk has its place on the album as a whole. I don't mind it much, but it is definitely a weak spot.
its just facts
>>64600128
Do you even know what the fuck punk rock is?
>>64603424
Go back to reddït.
>>64600165
The generation that grew up with it are at the age where they discover /mu/
>>64603458
>gets called out on being an ignorant tool
>R-reddit! Fuck off!
>>64603490
This album came out 12 years ago. The people who grew up with it are well into their 20s.
just listened to this album. so perfect.
>>64600215
This album gets worse every year that goes by. I think Freedom is better
>>64603678
forgot pic
![RHCP-BSSM[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/8DjLm4u.jpg "RHCP-BSSM[1].jpg")
>>64603698
i need more albums like this. like, rock with the cool electronic noises
This album will always be Green Day's ultimate masterpiece.
Panic Song is the best song on the album mademecum/10
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sPy0Vc_RDrQ
>>64603729
Only album I listen to that came out the year of my birth
Great, but not as good as Warning or Nimrod
>>64604082
wrong
>>64602644
generally bad genres but the instrumentation is very interesting on this
>>64600475
THIS
>>64600475
literally this desu
>>64600475
let's not forget this
>>64604795
Way is a master at his craft.
Danger Days gets a lot of flak for the pop, but the lyrics and themes are spot on. He's a really great writer, even his comics.
I'll never stop the Gerard Way wank.
>>64605368
Danger Days was fucking fantastic.
Na Na Na is one of the greatest songs they've ever made. S/C/A/R/E/C/R/O/W and Summertime are also great.
Perfect IMO
>>64605400
Agree wholeheartedly, their whole discography is damn near perfect.
Also, adding this masterpiece to the pile.
>>64602337
YES.
Who /passingshipsinthenight/ here?
Favorite album from my favorite band.
Fucking perfect
This album too is incredible
>>64602337
Agreed. Although Fairweather Friends does not stick out to me as much. Most definitely an artistic peak for QOTSA for sure.
I personally think Lullabies to Paralyze is another relatively flawless album.
>>64600041
why is this allowed?
>>64603729
Straight up nigga.
>>64602233
>Wake Me Up When September Ends
Only Americans could write a song so terrible.
>>64602743
I don't think anything will beat this album ever.
>>64601839
Burst Apart was great, fuck off.
>>64602337
Kalopsia is a goddamn masterpiece.
>>64600041
OP can't even follow his own rules baka
GOAT
I had the Blues but I shook them loose?
>>64600475
yep
>>64602616
Suburbs is pretty damn good... However first half of the album outshines the later half really hard... so it kinda makes it sound like a filler.
Those tracks are also pretty good, but they just aren't as consistent as everything from "The Suburbs" to "Half light" which is a fucking strong 10.
Tl;dr:
>First half of album 10/10
>Second half of the album 7/10
>>64603638
2007 is 40 years ago
is this some shitty meme? when did /mu/ develop such dumpster taste?
Pornorgraphy
>>64609541
Nostalgiafags. I think half are memeing though.
I'd like to think that the only reason this wasn't posted already is because it's already implied that this is the best album ever made
>inb4 touched
>>64601802
haha oh wow
>>64601839
Burst Apart is alright, it has a more crisp sound. It even continues the theme
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KE68udXLHgI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tbA66jyyyTU
>>64603707
I use to love that album
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4L1sxibr8IA&list=PLebly2Oi1iIPeVodehLIKT3apzgqSgb0s
>>64609772
Just listened to it for the first time. I can't believe I missed out on so many great bands in the 90s. I mostly just listened to meat loaf. Speaking of which, greatest album of all time right here.
This fucking masterpiece
>>64609692
This fucking masterpiece
This fucking masterpiece
>>64600522
I've always thought Holiday and In the Garage were garbage but I realize I'm in the minority there so I'll agree.
>>64600565
Heh
>>64600683
>the bass sounds annoying
Ok now you need to stop.
>>64602616
The Suburbs has to be the magnum opus of Arcade Fire thus far. It'll be hard to imagine a better album then this one. Even Reflektor paled in comparison to this one.
>>64602616
>>64602642
>>64603170
You guys must be pretty young huh
>>64614113
Hands down, every song was enjoyable and great to listen to.
And the album's epilogue "Venice Queen" made it all the sweeter with that frenetic and uplifting end.
>>64614101
kek
>>64614243
What's a better album then that? Their self-titled was great but not nearly as great and profound as The Suburbs.
>>64614421
Hipsters think Funeral is better. It's not.
>>64600522
>>My Name is Jonas
>10/10
>>No One Else
>10/10
>>The World Has Turned and Left Me Here
>10/10
>>Buddy Holly
>10/10
>>Undone
>10/10
>>Surf Wax America
>5/10
>>Say It Ain't So
>10/10
>>In the Garage
>10/10
>>Holiday
>10/10
>>Only in Dreams
>10/10
FTFY
>>64604704
>>64604721
Both correct
>green day
>punk
>good
go back and listen to any good punk band from the 70's to 80's and maybe you'll understand its nowhere near punk. american idiot is garbage, dookie is mediocre, kerplunk is meh, insomniac is meh at best. don't let your nostalga get in the way of realizing how crap green day always was.
>>64600041
garbage
>>64600189
don't care for him, but that's just me.
>>64600219
lol
>>64600235
90's kids still think this is good. it isn't.
>>64600270
eh.
>>64600298
not even the best floyd album.
>>64600522
decent
>>64601839
many bands do, sadly.
>>64603707
overrated
>>64603729
decent
>>64604704
no
>>64606666
>fav band
u tickle me pink
>>64606743
lol
>>64607829
pretty good
>>64607925
far from perfect
>>64613701
late registration is much better
>>64613917
classic
>>64613937
100% correct.
>>64614247
anything not homework is mediocre.
>>64602329
this is one that always gets swept underneath the rug. superb album.
>>64614986
>>>Surf Wax America
>>5/10
:{
>>64601906
Oh come on, Can I Play With Madness is pretty bad
>>64615212
this kid
>>64600041
Ok, I'm convinced to explore this release for the first time in maybe a decade since this was a definitive release in my early teenage years. I expect /mu/ to be vastly interested in my expression of how it sounds to me now.
>>64615212
>listen to le real punk
Why? Real punk is garbage.
>>64615491
Come back and tell us how it holds up.
>>64616054
Excuse pls?????
>>64615212
>see, im a true punk man myself. Black flag, minor threat, husker du, minutemen....the list goes on. Pretty underground stuff really
>>64602425
I love that album. 10/10.
>>64600522
>>64602337
>>64607873
>>64615245
>>64615462
Kinda agree
>>64601791
>any grimes album
>perfect
>>64600475
>>64601839
>>64602425
>>64604721
>>64604795
>>64605925
>>64606666
>>64609096
>>64609692
>>64609772
>>64613701
>>64615015
good but not perfect
Hopefully not overlooked due to recent times
>>64604721
Agreed, surprisingly better than their debut
>>64603424
>>64603537
summer is here
>>64607895
under my voodoo is underrated as hell
>>64615245
This is my all time favorite album but I will admit it'd be flawless if they had left off Hare Krsna. I know it's part of the story but still it just seems so out of place.
>>64602329
100% agree
Each song compliments one another in a unique way, it's brilliant.
>>64617653
All Grimes albums are perfect<
>>64600549
Yes, The 1975 are a great, fun upcoming band, you should definetly check them out!
>>64615212
>anything not homework is mediocre
>>64600041
I thought you said every song is perfect, not every song is garbage. This is a right proper album here.
>>64601839
B-but my dead wife, get fucked. Trash album.
>>64602069
Love Me is solid af fool.
>>64604704
>an inconvenient truth, the post
>>64605442
>FUCK LIKE A KENNEDY
>>64607895
Seriously?
>>64600128
You forgot the pop with the punk, there is nothing "punk" about green day
>>64600475
This is an amazingly good workout album
>>64617653
back to r/music with you
>>64617654
True, honetly i prefer Origin of Symmetry but Absolution is a solid album
10/10 all the way through
>>64602616
>arcade fire
>not funeral
get outta here m8s
whole lotta b8 in this thread. but i dig the shitty emo i cant even lie.
>>64614986
surf wax is literally the best song on the album go fall in an everlasting hole
Fight me.
>>64614239
bretty good album. Cabron and Can't Stop are two of my favorite chili songs.
>>64603707
Great album, but Under the Bridge is one of the most overrated songs of all time.
>>64620408
I agree with you anon
Pic related is fantastic, but has shitty cover art.
>>64620141
>>64620141
Banshee beat is kinda subpar for me.
>>64620646
You haven't had a crush have you?
>>64620661
Of course. I just find it, instrumentally, very... meh.
>>64615212
>le it's not REAL PUNK
back to reddít
>>64620921
i still cant get the awful taste out of my mouth from thank god for girls. other than that its fine
>>64600041
why do you hate your parents so much?
>>64600298
lol the first shit i heard high was fashion monster by kyary pamyu pamyu
>>64606006
fuckin love this album for long drives through the midwest
>>64615212
reddit-man
>>64620265
hahaha the skit in me + geniene where they call the police cause they smoked weed makes me laugh every time
i dig this album but its not 10/10 desu
>>64605354
best resp in this thread
>>64620646
are you okay? like......what?
>>64614697
it's actually such a shame that Funeral has become the "hipster" album because now people have an excuse to think it's bad when it's fucking incredible start to finish
>>64600263
Jesus of Suburbia could literally be a classic GBV tune but people hate on this album because it was a huge hit
>>64621965
i personally really love this album. im not saying its 10/10 but i tend to post albums in these that people might not know so they listen to something different ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
find a flaw
>>64622475
It's basically a better American Football
>>64618009
Bob's vocals on Chartered Trips is super annoying
>>64600041
Put down the fake "punk" and meet the real deal.
>>64622740
>no true Scotsman
>>>/r/eddit
>>64622674
Are you high?
>>64622819
Reality is a motherfucker.
>>64622868
prove it's "fake"
>>64603129
... Y'know, except LITERALLY ANY OTHER ANCO RECORD
>>64622880
Eyes and ears, use them.
honestly, this album is fantastic.
>>64622989
im not convinced.
+ in rainbows - radiohead
+ vespertine - bjork
>>64623076
Made with no artificial sweetners.
Yeah uh, I'll just leave this here
I loved Green day and I just realized that they say She is holding on my heart like hand grenade and one of there pics is a heart hand grenade... I feel so dumb xD
>>64600165
/mu/tants will even call hybrid theory 10/10 anything to make them contrarians i suppose
>>64602170
You're completely right about Badmotorfinger and Angel Dust.
>>64600522
>>64602337
>>64607829
>>64609772
>>64611360
>>64613937
>>64615245
>>64620532
>>64622308
>>64622475
>>64623254
these too
>>64620675
This is BTBAM's weakest with the core lineup and it's still spectacular.
for me at least
>>64600165
fucking faggot
why even come into the thread
>STOP LIKING WHAT I DONT LIKE
>>64623159
artificial? Maybe you misunderstand, Green Day isn't Punk, it's Pop-Punk.
>>64623314
Oh Fuck Yeah!
