ITT: Graph an artist's discography
>>64474436
wrong
OKC > Kid A > HTTT > TKOL > amnesiac > the bends > IR > Pablo
Fag
IR > Kid A > OKC > Amnesiac > Bends > HTT > TKOL > Pablo
bluebird handwriting
>>64475377
Close
IR > Kid A > TKOL > OKC > Bends > HTT > Amensiac > Pablo
>>64475477
>the king of memes
>above OK Computer and Amnesiac
>>64475477
>>64475377
>IR # 1
fucking plebs get out
>>64475377
>>64475477
yeah but those are your opinions, and they don't mean anything to me if you can't justify them in words. besides, I don't really care much for radiohead in the first place
nice twin dubs btw
>>64475543
>Not realizing that the King of Limbs is a masterpiece
>>64475563
>He doesn't like dream pop radiohead
>>64475635
TKOL is the gift that keeps on giving, Bloom is fucking top-tier and the details in each track are amazing
IR and TKOL are my favourites too so i'm pretty fucking psyched for LP9
>>64475635
>not realizing the king of memes is overhyped by fanboys
To be honest.
>>64474829
good taste
>>64475929
who
>>64475970
do you have a moment to talk about Alison Elizabeth Margaret and The Goldfrapps?
blink
>>64476051
perfect although i would switch pants with enema
>>64474866
>IDLSIDGO is lower than Doris
>doesn't know that kitchen cutlery is a fan made compilation
Fuck off dummy
taking back sunday
>>64474436
yeah that's p accurate well done
>>64476111
nice
>>64476071
yeah both are pretty much interchangeable to me, but while enema has their best song - adam's song - i feel like take off has more longevity. but can't go wrong with either
>>64475982
yeah but those albums are already so far above everything else that they are maxed out
>>64476111
bruh you fucking serious? Ummagumma is better than literally anything else they did, especially fucking dark side of the meme
>>64476111
thanks this saved me time but i disagree with you
>>64476200
nah, though the live half is great
>>64475937
I think you did it wrong. They should all be in a straight line at the very bottom
>>64476303
there we go, much better
>>64476306
edgy meme kid
>>64476200
Too much wankery and attempting to be psychedelic to me. It's like they were trying to go back to when Syd was the head, but couldn't quite get it. David And Roger's parts were really great, but Nick and Rick's just do not appeal to me at all.
>>64476303
I agree, the live half is pretty good
>>64476306
Hating Gilmour doesn't automatically make you cool. AMLOR and Division Bell had some quality stuff, just not as good as their previous works. Of course a fourth of the group leaving will reduce the quality a bit, but they managed quite well without him.
>>64476672
>GP C-
>but it's still above TMS at B-
explain
also JD is NOT better than TMS and GP
>>64474866
First isn't an album. Thep gap between Earl and Doris should be much bigger.
how can hot soup even compete
>>64474802
>Graph an artist's discography
You can't follow simple directions?
>>64476873
/cold soup/ here
>>64476303
yes
>>64475937
I've come to realize that most of /mu/ praises American Idiot.
Looks like it's /mu/core now
>>64475563
but thats wrong senpai
>>64477071
Do they? All I see is hate on Green Day here.
>>64477447
wow they have a lot more that I need to check out
thanks jamie
wooo
here's Shearwater
>>64478104
Do people actually like this band? I listened to their cover of I Luv the Valley and thought it was fucking awful
>>64476051
This is literally so fucking wrong
>>64478276
that's from the Fellow Traveller's album, which was full of covers (the second from the right), and it really isn't a favorite of mine. The band's sound is more ambient folk, but I can't really classify an accurate genre, but listen to their albums Palo Santo, Rook, and The Golden Archipelago to get an idea of what they became well known.
Their last two original albums, Animal Joy and Jet Plane & Oxbow are more straight out rock, and though it bummed me out, the albums grew on me after a few listens, but they are far removed from their folkish sound.
>>64476051
I agree with >>64476071, but I just wanted to say thanks for giving the s/t the respect it deserves
>>64478340
post yours
>>64478445
yeah like i said above, i think take off is slightly better but i love both. and yeah their s/t is their best by far imo
>>64475970
Spotted the Grimes fan
>>64478476
Why in the fucking world would you put s/t so high? Dude Ranch and Buddah are their best albums by a million miles
>>64478104
continuing with Genesis
>>64478646
Because it's their best. And their first two "albums" are trash; why wouldn't you listen to some actually good garage punk like Libertines or something instead?
>>64474436
http://output.jsbin.com/fehoranula
>>64478758
Shoot, just realized it erroneously rounds...
>>64478715
lol
>>64478758
>any album better than CTTE
>>64478843
'CttE' is dazzling, but after a time you just begin to ask yourself if the spiritual factor is enough to carry the album into the 9s 10s. I've read comparisons of the title track to no less than a verse/chorus/verse song. It has lot of great playing, but 'Relayer' just objectively has even more, and 'Soon' is just as moving.
>>64478926
eat shit retard you have NO CLUE what your talking about
>>64479083
shove your shitty website UP your ass faggot. if i EVER catch you dissing CTTE again ill personally sail a rocketship up your rancid ass. dont reply to me again
>>64479000
You're the rudest Yes listener I've seen.
>>64478758
http://output.jsbin.com/deredafata should handle fractions.
>>64479113
(Sorry, deleted and reposted this post in which I said you're rude so to link to the new version of the script to >>64478758.)
>>64479152
last warning buddy. BACK OFF
>>64478648
CTTE is a good album but only true patricians know that Tales is the GOAT Yes album.
>>64479195
Internet tough guy.
>>64476141
s/t wasnt THAT bad. and where you want to be is better than new again
>>64479152
good script thanks
>>64479263
youll think internet toughguy when i neil armstrong that ass your gonna need landing gear to even find your own asswhole
>>64479293
Cheers, and I'm happy its first use was for a band and album as great as TMV/FtM.
>>64476111
Pretty good, but Atom Heart isn't their best.
>>64479305
I'm not the original guy you were talking to. You sound like you're gay for arseholes.
>>64474436
Fixed
Something like this. Didn't think it through TOO much.
>>64479365
u will be
>>64476303
Meddle should be higher
>>64479319
works well
>>64479387
Amnesiac is better than Kid A though
>>64479441
Maybe
>>64476111
>obscured by clouds
>bad
filthy plebeian
>>64474447
is this jay electronica?
>>64475477
Swap IR and Kid A and this is perfect
>>64479265
I really really really really really really really really really really really really REALLY fucking hated it. It's seriously one of the most disappointing albums I've ever heard.
I have both New Again and WYWTB rated the same, I just got a shitty picture.
>>64479510
you're wrong
>>64474436
I rarely hear the Bee Gees mentioned here. I thought they were pretty good, and their musical style varies throughout the years but their three-part harmonies remain a constant. Their only true disco album, Children of the World, is awful and only saved by You Should Be Dancing. I didn't include Saturday Night Fever since it is a soundtrack and not a studio album.
>>64479387
correct
>>64480016
which album is holiday on? and do they have any concept albums or experimental stuff?
>>64479387
good taste
>>64480094
Holiday is on Bee Gees' 1st, their debut. It is a typical 60's psychedelic album, and it is a nice listen. As for concept albums, check out Odessa, and it is very comfy and melancholic (which is a typical sound throughout their career, especially in the early 70s).
Two albums that should be checked out are Mr. Natural (1974), which was released right before they exploded into the mainstream in the mid-70s, and Living Eyes (1981), which was released after the post-disco era, and is a very soft-rock/pop album but with great melodies.
>>64476303
>Meddle that low
>>64474436
how does a remix album have anything to do with their discogrpahy
the real list
>>64478952
Nice to see OHM that high up there. Might not be their best in my book but it's top 3
>>64479964
I applaud you.
>>64480193
does marina just have fans here because she's attractive, or is her music worth listening to?
>>64480228
meddle is TRASH other than echoes
>>64478952
FS and Cali should be higher but pretty good, also 2nd half is still really good
inb4 shit opinion
>>64478952
do you like jane's addiction? whats so great about OHM? Have only heard californication, BSSM, BTW and SA personally
>>64480313
I'm the guy who posted that and I enjoy her music genuinely. I mean, sure, she's hot, but I didn't even know what she really looked like when I heard the bulk of her stuff.
I'd recommend giving at least The Family Jewels a listen, as I think it's her most "artistic" album, with Froot being second and Electra Heart being the closest to modern pop.
Here are my favorites
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1VTcJfL7RE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S_oMD6-6q5Y
The difference in hearing what Asunder sweet live and studio is cause for the two versions.
>>64476672
no.
>>64480549
MMT isn't my favorite, but I really like it and it's nice to know someone else likes it too.
That being said, you put Rubber Soul above White Album. Fuck you for that.
>>64480739
3 good songs and 27 filler desu
>>64480823
what 3 songs?
>>64480861
while my guitar gently weeps
blackbird
helter skelter
>>64480739
Revolver used to be my favourite, but I'm tempted to put Rubber Soul over it because it's so consistently good. I've never liked the White Album. Even its best songs are just "okay".
>>64480919
i disagree with you vehemently but respect your opinion
>>64475591
Leaves>Challange>Fake Train> NPI > Repetition > Future > S/T
>>64475705
>In Rainbows
>dream pop
wot are you on
>>64475937
Like this
Nimrod
Insomniac
Dookie
American Idiot
Slappy Hours/Kerplunk!
Warning
21st Century Shitshow
Those last 3 just need to go
>>64479510
literally perfect aside from bottomless pit being that low
>>64481362
>nude
>all i need
>faust arp
>reckoner
>house of cards
>jigsaw
>videotape
>not dreampop
>>64480362
I dont really like Janes Addiction. no. and OHM is their weirdest and darkest release. Flea and Chad are at their technical best. Kiedis' lyrics are at their most cryptic (sometimes) and personal - his singing is also much best than usual. Navarro isnt a song writing genius like Frusciante but he has some great lines, catchy solos and interesting textures. Songwise the album includes some of their least poppy material - featuring extended instrumental solo, progressive structure, frequently breaking the verse-chorus-verse format, sampling.
Im pretty tired right now - so sorry im not too eloquent but yeah its a good album
listen to Walkabout, Coffee Shop and My friends
>>64481556
Enjoyed those, will give it a full listen soon. Thanks but I hope you didn't spoil the best songs already
>>64481950
theyre some of my favourites but theyres a bunch more good songs. make sure you also listen to the version with Bob as a bonus track
>>64475937
>21st Century Breakdown and Warning are better than Dookie
Fucking WHAT
>>64476051
Neighborhoods isn't better than Enema but otherwise accurate. They really did improve with age. I'm gonna be optimistic about Skiba182.
>>64479513
Maladroit should be higher than Red and Hurley
White should be lower than Maladroit too
Make Believe should be slightly better than Raditude.
Otherwise accurate.
>>64481444
maybe it's a 7
Ring A Bell is my favorite Death Grips track ever. like that the punk influence remained from JD
>>64482091
I can see why people shit on 21CB but Warning is mad underrated.
Also Dookie is like a 7.5, the scale is pretty high because Green Day is (or at least used to be) my favourite band.
>>64482149
It's not. I put them on par.
SOMEONE DO ANCO IM TOO LAZY
>>64480587
where do i find a proper live recording of Assunder?
i actually love that album as it already is
>>64479513
ewbate slightly below white and this is perfect senpai
Plus 2 albums for comparison.
This isn't bait.
>>64485544
For anyone who's wondering, every pre-yeezus Kanye album is better than Wolf, Yeezus is just below Cherry Bomb and TLOP is below Goblin.
I'd put BTI as equal to Wolf as a whole, but if I was judging each song as a unit it'd average out as OF Tape tier.
>>64483603
I wouldn't know, sorry friend. I've seen them live, that's my source.
>>64476672
pleb taste m8
>>64485544
Disagree, cherry bomb was his best. People only listened to the title track and called it garbage. Going through it on one sitting, it's his only record aside from wolf where over 80% of the tracks are listenable.
>>64483603
there are dozens of recordings:
https://archive.org/details/GodspeedYouBlackEmperor
>>64475937
>Uno and Tré on par with Kerplunk and Insomniac
>Nimrod, Warning and 21st Century Breakdown better than Dookie
Sure
>>64476051
BLINK 182 IS SHIT
>>64474436
>Graph an artist's discography
You are aware that you could just say 'discograph an artist', right?
>>64487658
what are opinions?
>>64474436
black sabbath
>>64479743
>this afraid of posting xach's dick
someone's insecure about their sexuality..
faggot!!
>>64479513
Green and Maladroit need to be definitely higher, about on the same level of the last two.
>>64479390
didn't really want to graph it so here it goes
Long Drive>TLCW>BNOOS>TM&A>SSS>The Fruit>We Were Dead>Everywhere(?)>Good News>>>Strangers
>>64487936
meh, I just didn't have a censored version on my PC. Regardless I happen to have a boyfriend
>>64479743
make it a porabola with no love deep web as the minimum for the left side and its perf
>>64479246
Nope, CTTE is literally perfect, there isn't a single album in history thats better than it, maybe just as good but never better.
And any true patrician knows that Tormato is Yes's 5th best album
>>64479568
Didn't say it was bad, just average. It's a good soundtrack, better than More, but while making a soundtrack, you need to play it safe or the director will either make you change it, or will just hire somebody else. It's good, but there's nothing significant about it at all. They had done much better before and after.
>>64487830
Dookie is their best album and the meme trilogy is utter shit.
I'd say:
Dookie > Imsomniac > Kerplunk > American Idiot > Nimrod > 39/Smooth > 21st Century Breakdown > Warning >>> Uno > Dos > Tre
>>64474436
How can someone be so wrong
>>64488440
Dos is trash I'll give you that but Uno and Tre had some pretty solid, if unremarkable, pop punk tunes on them.
Also,
>warning last
Stop the memeing
animal collective here.
reminder I enjoy most animal collective albums, regardless of the placing on the list. there's really no one else like em imo
death grips
>Exmilitary:
high
>Money, the Store:
high high...
>NLDW:
veryhigh
>Govermment Places:
high? but that much
>Fashion Week:
not low
>The Powers that B:
a side) very high
b side) super high hhhh
>Bottomless Pit:
very high
>>64476672
make GP an A and switch ExM and TMS and u got it
>>64479510
embarrassing taste
>>64474866
I like earl better than doris, more precocious and carefree.
>>64485544
>camp is bad
Trash opinion
>>64488865
danse should be higher.
>>64478952
>UMPP overrated
>>64479510
>Amnesiac is better than Kid A though
>Amnesiac
>Better than Kid A
>>64490019
you prob right. I need to fix it.
Is nobody a bad enough dude to chart Dylan's 54 years' worth of albums?
>>64476672
accurate
>>64480016
>>64480216
I appreciate you talking (and knowing) about the BeeGees in such detail.
>>64488865
Prospect Hummer should be higher, but apart from that it's pretty agreeable
>>64487151
no I listened to the whole thing and called it garbage. As did every single reviewer who could be bothered to look at the incompetent piece of shit
>>64490486
>GodWeenSatan not being the best
>>64487924
Those poor guys.
>>64475591
why do people put the s/t after future of what? it was their first recorded album.
also i'd put their discography at always high with fake train and new plastic ideas at the maximum top instead of leaves but that's just me and i get why people like leaves so much
>>64475937
holy shit this couldn't be more wrong
actually it could, all it needed was for dos to be higher
>>64476303
perfect
>>64476672
i think they go a little bit more downhill than this 2bh
>>64478952
ohm is definitely underrated but i wouldn't put it this high
>>64474436
>Including a remix album
>In Rainbows that low
>>64479387
inflated af
>>64479390
pretty accurate
>>64479510
i'm okay with this
>>64479743
'no'
>>64480549
>magical mystery tour that high
>white album that low
abbey road is their best btw
i like this thread btw
>>64478952
awful. just awful.
BTW-9.7
Californication-9.4
BSSM-9.3
SA- 9.0
MM- 7.6
OHM-7.2
UMPP-7.1
IWY-6.7
FS-6.5
RHCP-2.4
IWY- 6.5
>>64493941
>decimal scores
>californication and btw top
holy shit could you be any more pleb
>>64495435
you've made me lose all will to listen to the rest of m83's discography. i disliked hurry up, we're dreaming, and the rest is only shittier
>>64495487
if that's the only one you've listened to, give one of the first 4 a try, since they're very different. The last 3 have just been 80's nostalgia pop, but the first is just nice lo-fi electronic, the 2nd is icy electronic ambient noise, the 3rd is shoegaze/dreampop, and the 4th is sleeping music/ambient
>>64483603
search on youtube for Behemoth - it was the name of the song before they changed it and called it Asunder
>>64480337
This is probably the most accurate one I've seen so far. The only thing I disagree with is TKoL should be almost as low as pablo honey. I really don't like TKoL.
>>64489776
thanks, sorry i don't jerk off over andy wanking in the group. death grips is not that interesting anyway
>>64489088
good one
>>64490179
yeah, it has their more interesting song writing present even if it's just kid b-sides
>>64490486
GWS is better than that
>>64492998
yeah
>>64493747
thanks
>>64493826
in rainbows sucks pretty bad. band not in their prime
>>64495435
Dead Cities >>> Before the Dawn >>>>>>>> Hurry Up >>>>>>>>>>>>> rest
>>64495580
bleh
>>64490486
>GodWeenSatan that low
>Quebec that high
>>64496238
quebec fuckin rules man
>>64496211
>>64495435
So we agree on their best 3 albums
>>64477447
>Black Antlers higher than The Ape of Naples
>>64479510
Amnesiac is like OKC-kind of Kid A. It's a good collection of great tracks but it's worse than Kid A as an album.
>>64476303
I get what you're saying 'cause that's how I felt it the first time I heard it. I liked it but felt nothing special. I liked 'Wish You Were Here' way better. Then, I decided to give it another try, and again, I felt nothing special. After a few months of giving it several tries and giving up, I saw the album at Target. So, I bought it and decided to give it one last chance. I inserted the Disk into my car's stereo and turned it up. It BLEW ME AWAY completely! Wow, how could I have missed it all those times. Now I can't get enough of it. I hear it all the time. I even downloaded the whole documentary and live versions into my iPod. Dark Side is like a fine dish, some people have to try it several times to get its FULL POWER. It's not noise, just really awesome sound effects that make the album unique. In my opinion, there is no better album, nor will there ever be, than Pink Floyd's 'Dark Side Of The Moon.'
>>64475937
>kerplunk not highest
PLEB
>>64490486
>pure guava over chocolate & cheese
>godweensatan being that low in general
Everything else I agree with.
>>64488865
what are the jane albums?
>>64485544
>Goblin over CB
>his worst over his best
nigga u hwat
>>64479513
this is accurate but maladroit should be higher.
>>64481530
it's clearly not.
>>64476969
kek
>>64474436
why did you even bother making this with your fucking cookie cutter taste? do you think this is individual expression? 75% of this board would make this exact same chart
>>64499553
why did you even bother making this reply with your fucking cookie cutter shitpost? do you think this is individual expression? 75% of this board would make this exact same shitpost
>>64488865
I'm not even gonna comment on the animal collective stuff because I haven't looked at it yet: Why does everyone put Automine so low? It's really pleasant kinda depressed-sounding slowcore, if they made an album, it would easily be top 50 for me, it's like a rainy Duster. I honestly think Paddington Band better than maybe my bottom two to four Animal Collective albums, and the only AnCo album that I'd give under a 7 is PW.
>>64499655
literally never see anyone make this same complaint, so while i know you're just making a lazy shitpost for the sake of it, i still gotta tell you that that's just incorrect
>>64499913
for you
>>64475937
All those albums are shit
>>64479246
>implying a real person sounds this pretentious
>go outside nerd
>>64475937
If you actually like the trilogy then you're a huge faggot desu.
>>64476672
>BP
>anything above B-/C+
Into the trash it goes
>>64479387
You made it worse anon
>>64475591
i think s/t is underrated
>>64500189
edgy meme kid
>>64476111
Imo Piper and Saucerful of Secrets should be a bit higher, but I'm not judging
>>64499797
Guy who made it here. While automine is pretty good and decent, when compared to the rest of the albums it doesnt stand out all that much except for being nothing like the rest of their discog. Some of my pics might seem kinda low as well, but its all in comparison to their own discography. Every project by them is like nothing ive ever heard before, even painting with. One of the reasons i love them so much.
>>64498782
Thats paradise and coconuts
I never see any discussion about Cop Shoot Cop
>>64477447
>MTPITD 1 higher than 2
End your life
>>64476051
>no Buddha
>>64481530
You're right, they're not.
>>64502956
>Buddha
>Album
>>64477264
Yeah
>>64479387
Absolutely correct
>>64480241
>the real list
>le contrarian meme xD
i get it xDDDD
>>64480549
>Magical Mystery Tour is not better than any these
>Abby Road is the best of these
>With The Beatles is better than Help
>Yellow Submarine is tied with MMT as the worst albums.
Your chart sucks and you should feel bad.
Massive Attack
>>64490486
>Chocolate and Cheese being that low
>GodWeenSatan that low
>>64487861
I like this, but I think Master of Reality should be a little higher than Paranoid
>>64504507
>1st album lower than 3rd
please stop
>>64501424
I personally disagree with this, Undertow and Aenima being my favorites, but I get it.
>>64475328
Solex v. Cristina Martinez is banging so far, nice.
>>64487313
Swap money store and d and you got yourslef a deal
>>64506241
yourself* JD*
>>64480549
ftfy
sgt peps is overrated and white album is better than that
>>64479743
This is by far, more accurate.
Tho I would rather put Ex at the same Height as No Love
>>64479587
lel
