The Great Debate
Morning Bell or Morning Bell/Amnesiac
Morning Bell for me.
>>63263608
Morning bell amnesiac is bad and I am a RH fsnboy who does not hate any song since the bends so this says a lot. Amnesiac would be 10/10 if it didnt have morning bell
Kid A version is much better imo
Kid a version is WAYYYYY better but I like the amnesiac one too
The Kid A version by a huge amount.
/Amnesiac is better simply because of the little vocal bit at the end of the last "cut the kids in half" at 1:48. That part literally makes the song.
>>63264672
I should add
Part of the charm of the Kid A version is how it's such a calm and flawless transition after the apocalyptic Titanic-esque Idioteque
It's all about those maddening, claustrophobic drums on the kid a version my man
>>63263608
Morning Bell/Amnesiac
I like how it's slow and filled with dread and than when it hits the "release me" section, it feels like the sky is opening up.
>>63264745
>morning bell
>calm
Bro what
It is a good transition but I don't think calm is the right word and /mu/ is the only place I get to be extremely shitty about semantic discrepancies
You piece of shit
I want to add that the Amnesiac version sounds better at 1.25x speed, I recommend trying it.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CPQfiH78XaE
>>63264782
Compared to Idioteque it is absolutely relatively calm
I never said happy or Optimistic but Thom isn't shouting his fucking lungs out with an electronic drum beat anymore and Phil's drumming seems super chill
>>63264811
it's funny cause the Amnesiac version sounds like a slowed down version of the original.
For me, Kid A version wins by a large margin, mostly for the second half of it.
>>63264817
>happy or Optimistic
>>63263608
kid a
I used to prefer the Amnesiac version by quite a bit, but now I prefer it by a smaller amount.
