dont understand why people take this contrarians meme reviews seriously

>>63184503
>>63184614
Seriously guys I wouldn't get too worried about it. He's a senile italian man and his music taste is the definition of contrarian.

The fact he gave AHM a 7 literally makes me feel sorry for him.

>>63184614
Because a lot of people on /mu/ are contrarians who got excited as fuck when they found a reviewer who shared their contrarian taste, even if his taste and way of justifying it are ridiculous.

Literally the Armond White of the music world

>>63184503
i'd say ummagumma is around the same level as wywh but it's miles better than the wall

>>63184503
I think he said in an interview somewhere once that the live half of ummagumma is a 7 and the studio half is at least an 8.

[spoiler]he's right[/spoiler]

>>63184759
The Wall is on about the same level as the album chris chan did so that's not hard anyway

>>63184503
>DSOTM: 6.5/10
>Piper: 8.5/10

haha nice meme

>>63184503
It's not. He's just stupid.

>>63185467
Good to see a chris Chan references

>>63185467
I haven't heard that album (although i'll check it out real soon now that i know it exists) but the wall isn't a terrible album, it's just.... weird i guess.
it's possible to enjoy if you get in a certain mindset.
it's a longshot from being even close to pink floyd's best album though

>>63184503
>muh piper
i don't get this meme

it's avangarde, i know, but this doesn't make it better than the wall

>>63185847
>it's avangarde, i know

not at all even, it's far less experimental than Saucerful or Ummagumma, most of it is bland psych-pop. people put Piper first because they somehow romanticize Syd, who added literally nothing of worth to the band. "muh mental illness" indeed

>>63184503
>Momentary Lapse of Reason being higher than The Division Bell
>rates Nick Mason's album the highest out of all of the PF solo albums
>Ummagumma higher than DSOTM, WYWH, Animals, Meddle, and Atom Heart Mother
>A Saucerful of Secrets higher than every other album in their discog except for Piper

Wew lad

For real:

Piper > Ummagumma Live > WYWH > Saucer > Meddle > DSotM > Ummagumma Studio > AHM > The Wall > Animals > More >>>>>>> POWERGAP (SHIT TIER) >>>>>>>>> Final Cut > Division Bell > Obscured By Clouds > A Momentary Lapse of Reason

>>63184503
ummagummma is their best

>>63186583
:^)

>>63184503
>how can Ummagumma be better than WYWH? or Wall?
Scruffy's point is that it is more experimental and less reliant on traditional songwriting.

>>63186611
it doesn't make it better though

>>63184503
I'm totally fine with his ratings. I'd have Dark Side at an 8/10 but everything elese is more or less alright

>>63186647
According to Scruffy, it does.

pink floyd is shit alltogether and scaruffi praising them in any way is y his shit ass well

>>63187996
Have a (You)

>>63184503
As I've said before, Scaruffi is probably the biggest hack of our age. Listen to what he said about Nietzsche.
>Full disclosure: the first time i read Nietzsche i felt that his books were just a ridiculous collection of nonsense, written in poor German, and largely based on an embarrassing degree of ignorance about anthropology, sociology, art and science; and i haven't changed my mind since then. I still have to understand why he became so famous. I am not sure that he also became influential because i think the century that followed had little use for his philosophy and/or his method (assuming he had one).

>>63188061

reading is for nerds

>>63188020
they dont have a single good album and dats a fact (actually my opinion but dat makes it a fact tbf)

pink floyd is entry level art rock

hes right, they're average

His score for The Wall is too high.