1. Zach Hill
2 Art Blakey
3.Phil Collins
4.Bill Bruford
5.Neil Peart
6. Max Roach
7.Keith Moon
8. Buddy Rich
9.Travis Barker
10. Brian Chippendale
Accurate?
1.Roland
jon theodore is better than all of them.
you forgot jaki liebezeit
>>62583932
Shit taste
>phil collins above neil peart
>phil collins above buddy rich
>>62583932
>Travis Barker
>no ringo
yikes plebeian master detected
>>62583932
>Zach Hill
>Travis Barker
Bad bait.
>>62583973
He's John Bonham-lite at best, and shouldn't be on the same list as the likes of Bill Bruford. Maybe best drummers of the 21st century instead.
>>62583932
>Bill Bruford below Phil Collin
fucking how?
seriously
>>62584065
Is Ringo really THAT good?
>>62584091
except he's way better than Bonham...
>>62583932
>1. Zach Hill
I honestly don't think Phil Collins is all that great, definitely not top ten worthy.
>he can sing and play
That's great, so could Ringo.
>inb4 implying Ringo can sing.
Zach is the only drummer with a good solo album. prove me wrong.
>>62584109
By inventive and outgoing standards, no.
By 60's pop standards, yeah.
>>62583932
Where's Meg White?
>>62584297
Oren Ambarchi exists. Charles Hayward exists.
>>62584297
that album put me to sleep.
jack dejohnette.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xYkRpJhO-DI
>No jimmy Chamberlain?
>fucking pleb
>>62584091
He has a completely different style of drumming than Bonham.
>>62583932
Billy Cobham didn't make the list ??? Zach Hill is definitely the best
>>62584522
>anything affiliated with Smashing Pumpkins
>good
>Max Roach
>Tony Wilson
>Dennis Chambers
>Louie Belson
>Bernard Purdie
>John Bonham
>Gene Krupa
>Chris Coleman
>Jason McGerr
>Christopher Bear
These are just my favorites in no particular order.
>>62584571
>pleb
>>62584620
they're not good just because you like them
>>62584297
Deantoni Parks has two good solo albums
>>62584654
And there not terrible just because you don't despite having critically/universally acclaimed albums
>this thread
>>62583968
leave, steve
>>62584707
despite all your rage
you are still
just
a
pleb
in a cage
>>62584738
>white drummer
>good
>>62584571
You're trying too hard man
Zach is all flash with no substance.
I'll never understand why you fags suck his dick so much.
/mu/ is really terrible in drum threads
>>62584845
because he works really hard!
>>62584845
You answered yourself. He's the new Neil Peart replacing precision and the kit of a man with a small dick with "le animal".
I once knew a kid in high school who thought Dave Grohl was the greatest drummer of all time. Lol
>>62584881
Couldn't agree more
>>62583932
>no Brendan Canty
>Zach Hill number 1
These are most immediate points of fucking up, still a shitty list.
>>62583932
1. Elvin Jones
>Chippendale that low
>no Saunier
you're fucking up, senpai
The most embarrassing thread I've seen in years, gg everybody, get euthanised thanks
bruh I love Zach Hill, but to say he is the best drummer of all is time is dumb
>>62584297
simon scott has at least a couple
why is ginger baker not getting mentioned
ginger baker is the goat
Matt Flynn
>>62583932
>Neil Peart
>Zach Hill
>>62583932
>no bonham
>>62584108
>>62584018
Have you even listened to this or are you thinking of In The Air tonight Collins?
>>62587534
Have you heard Crimson Bruford? or are you just thinking of Yes Bruford?
for every well-known, lauded rock/pop/whatever based drummer, there are at least 50 jazz drummers who are as good or better and will never be known or heard by anyone.
Hi
>>62585375
this
Add Rick Allen To the list i mean the dude played with one hand.
>>62584109
actually yea he is
>>62584297
>Who is Black Pus
>What are All Aboard the Magic Pus, Primordial Pus, Pus Mortem and All My Relations
lrn2noise
>>62587894
he's on the list friendo
>>62584573
>purdie
LEMMA SPLAIN TO YA
dude when I was working at a drum shop with these oldfag drum teachers, they were having a field day with old bernard. That day I found out that bernie probably wasn't the "most recorded drummer of all time" and he didn't record for le beetles so the dude is either senile or a liar
that said, his shuffle is bretty fun to play
>>62584845
>never understand
obviously death grips
even if zach hill dickriders dont like dg they most likely found him through dg
>>62585325
dude was a bretty cool rock drummer but not much beyond that
i'd still fuck him
>>62587672
T H I S
H
I
S
/thread
>>62584018
buddy rich is the zach hill of jazz and no jazz fan would seriously like him
>>62591603
why? because they're white?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NzhTA4m0Dw8
>Vicent Roseboom
>Billy Ficca
>John Wright
>Chris Thatcher
>Britt Walford
some of my favs
>>62583932
1. Vinnie Colaiuta
2. Terry Bozzio
3. Ralph Humphrey
4. Chad Wackerman
5. Chester Thompson
6. Aynsley Dunbar
7. David Logeman
8. Jim Gordon
9. Art Tripp
10. Jimmy Carl Black
>>62587672
John Clardy, but also this
Zach hill is overrated as hell.
1. Mark juliano
2. John Bonham
3. Art Blakey
4. Max Roach
5. Zach HIll
6. Buddy Rich
7. Billy Ficca
8. Steve Gadd
9. Dennis Chambers
10. fuk it ringo starr
>>62583932
>no Danny Carey
>>62585143
And yet here you are.
>>62583932
>no damon che
>travis barker
at least put Jimmy Chamberlin instead
>>62583982
Seriously.
>>62584433
Charles Hayward is amazing.
>>62592526
>damon che
my nigga
>>62591442
Regardless of the channels of discovery, people tend to praise his Hella or solo projects. It's not like we think Death Grips has the greatest percussion ever.
Zach Hill reminds me of a faster and more aggressive Ginger Baker - and I mean that as a compliment.
>>62592371
ringo is really fucking underrated honestly
>>62583932
Zach Hill is the drums equivalent of Buckethead. One or two releases that are actually of merit and a whole lot of playing-fast-so-people-think-I'm-good.
This is coming from a guy that has listened to his Drumgasm album more than any person should.
(BTW, Drumgasm is the prime example of playing-fast-so-people-think-I'm-good.)
>>62593628
As a fan of Astrological Straits, Face Tat, and Lil Scuzzy, did I fall for it?
>>62583932
Wheres Danny Carey fit in? He's pretty damn good.
>>62585004
I like his drumming on TCV and Songs for the Dead
>no damon che
What the fuck are you doing senpai?
>>62592642
>>62592526
>damon che
I've found my friends.
>>62584091
>>Zach Hill
>Bad bait.
kill yourself you dull faggot
>>62591442
I feel like more people knew him from Hella beforehand. Without him Death Grips would've had to start from the bottom, but they had his name attached to them to give them some credibility.
I'm not a drummer and desu I don't know much about what makes drummers good, but what does /mu/ think of John Stanier?
>>62593702
I don't listen to those for drumming, I just think they're good albums
>>62584333
Someone who knows nothing of drums spotted.
>>62586856
Ginger is my favorite, man.
>>62583968
the headless thompson gunner?
>>62597635
okay, just checking
>>62583932
Zach Hill just wails on the snare with his bad technique. Damon Che should be somewhere on this list over Rich, Peart, Chippendale, or Moon.
And where the fuck are Tony Williams and Elvin Jones?
>>62585325
fucking this
Brendan and Joe were one of the best rhythm sections of the 90s
>>62587534
Everybody and their mother has heard this, Bruford is still better.
>>62587589
Yes Bruford is just as good as Crimson Bruford
>>62598570
Crimson Bruford is significantly better
Bruford said so
>>62592406
this
OP is literal autistical
Curious as to what drummers think of Jeremiah Green?
>no lenny white in entire thread
>these people think they know what they're talking about
>>62583932
>Brian Chippendale on the bottom
He could out-improvise all the other drummers you listed
I like FM Einheit, Doktor Avalanche, Charles Hayward and Z'EV
>>62598274
warren zevon is my favorite, you rock anon
Chris Tsagakis
>>62583932
>no black people
try again you fucking racist
i bet all the best drumemrs in the world are in tribes in places you've never heard of
fuck outta here with your systemic racism
>>62599633
lmao tribal drumming is a completely different thing you fuck
>>62599409
This
More like pic related
>>62599633
art blakey and max roach are black you fuck
imo Elvin Jones is the best jazz drummer of all time
>>62599687
ever hear of separate but equal fuck outta here
>>62599871
did you edit the post and put them in there
they wasnt in there when i posted
1.Hellhammer.
>>62599863
>Larry Kilminster (Motorhead)
Gospel's drummer
toe's drummer
Proscriptor McGovern
>>62583932
Where the fuck is BILLY COBHAM AND MICHEAL SHRIEVE YOU FUCKING BAFFOON OP!!!
>>62583932
>art blakey
>neil peart
>max roach
>buddy rich
ok kid u have absolutely no idea waht youre doing here
>phill collins
die
>travis barker
why am i going on
who is ari hoenig, who is elvin jones, joe morello, like fucking TONY WILLIAMS. dude
dude
dude
go away
keep practicing kid
>10 drummers
kill yourself
>>62587305
>Your mom.
Jimi Hendrix
>>62601665
this
>>62583932
>Not Bonham
Shit list desu
>>62584109
Yeah he was incredible on Revolver especially. Otherwise he just kept a good rhythm, but on that album he did some interesting stuff
>>62584682
Just got Technoself the other day holy shittt is that album good
>>62595121
lol thanks
but the amount of times he's forgotten on this board is stupid, considering how many people like Don Cab on here
>>62583932
you were close until you started naming old farts like phil collins and travis barker
also thomas pridgen can outplay most of these guys
>>62599409
it's honestly not hard to improvise when you use 1 ride cymbal and have your toms set up like he does. you can be in lightning bolt if you have the endurance
>>62584738
Mastodon isn't even good by metal standards. If you want to listen to a good metal drummer listen to Thomas Lang.
>>62603673
Try doing all that while singing and playing bass pedals at the same time nigga
S H I N Y A
H
I
N
A
>>62603723
"singing"
shouting incoherent nonsesne into a mic strapped on your face, oh okay
"bass pedals"
he has one he hits constantly, it's not hard, it's endurance based. do you play drums?
i'm a fan of lightning bolt, i just honestly don't think what he does is hard
>>62583982
>jaki liebezeit
This, dudes insanely good
cringed hard
>No Bill Ward
>>62592406
>>62599161
>Danny Carey
>good
http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/8104-lateralus/
Does Matt Greiner count?
Buddy Rich higher
Bill Burford lower
Add Chris Cutler
Add Furio Chirico
Add Jaki Chan
Remove Peart
Remove Collins
No fucking clue about best, but the guy drumming for toe is a beast. And Bill Stevenson is a beast.
>nobody will ever appreciate Andy Ward's drumming
>>62583932
You are all faggots of the highest degree
in no paticular order
Bill Bruford
Damon Che
Keith Moon
Jaki Liebezeit
Zach Hill
Neil Peart
Flo Mounier
Ted Epstein
Charlie Ondras
Alex Cohen
>>62607582
>no blacks
what century is this
>>62583932
Deantoni Parks is on par with Zach Hill.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J70eAMG-OBI
>>62607616
>on par with Zach Hill.
Not really a compliment for any actual drummer
>>62600728
how can u possibly hate on Art Blakey and Max Roach? Have you heard Mosaic or Night In Tunisia by the Jazz Messengers?
Have you heard Saxophone Colossus or We Insist!
If you have and don't like the drumming you have really shit taste
>>62607625
Just because you don't like it and it intentionally sounds like a jumbled mess doesn't mean it's not technically impressive as fuck. Zach Hill runs his single kick pedal faster than most death metal guys with a double kick. It's like some kind of well-harnessed spasmodic condition.
>>62607605
It is the pure white future anon. You are welcome.
>>62605783
>Buddy Rich higher
>Bill Bruford lower
wew lad
>>62584297
HEY I DONT KNOW WHERE IM LOCATED
BUT IM UP FOR AN INITIATION
GREEN BRICKS
>>62584738
>mastodon
>2011
lol, ewww
>>62584297
Doesn't listen to jazz, confirmed for pleb
>>62587672
This
>>62583932
ctrl+f Pierre Courbois or Association PC and no results. Come on, /mu/
1.Ringo
2 > Who cares.
why is drumming so easy compared to guitar?
>>62597634
really good
>>62583932
>meme musician
>best
>>62603709
You can't actually believe this.
This is literally drummers whose names I know: the thread
>>62608351
he can and it's true. go to the metal general and mention mastodon.
thomas lang is goat
>tomas haake not mentioned once
>neither is mario duplantier
>brann dailor mentioned once and some faggot said he was bad afterwords
>no portnoy
>no rev
>no carl palmer
>no david weckle
>no gene krupa
At least no one is sucking George Kollias' dick for once.
>>62608424
>only best-or-nothing extremism faggotry
I'm not shocked, /mu/, but come the fuck on. Trying to argue that Mastodon "isn't good" is literal contrariansim. Trying to argue that Brann Dailor isn't a phenomenal drummer is fucking retarded.
>zack hill #1
>no elvin jones
please leave, op
you guys are all plebs who know nothing
here are some of the people who actually belong on the short list
Jack DeJohnette
John French
John Guerine
William Winant
Dale Crover
Sly Dunbar
Bobby Previte
Greg Saunier
Jim Keltner
Han Bennink
sorry to burst your meme-musician bubble, plebs
>>62591371
I like the fact that he plays himself up. It's super endearing and it gives him a unique confidence which allows him to groove harder than pretty much every other drummer.
I was about to post Dale Crover
Also not knowing of lesser drummers makes me more patrician dealwithit
