>mfw someone near me says something isn't music
>mfw it's clearly audible sound
Ok, so you're at a party. You go to a bathroom. There's a big fat guy emptying from both ends in a violent fashion.
Is this still music?
>>61911417
if you record it and put it on a CD it is
>>61911473
>>61911417
Yes thats highly patrician
>>61911381
if it is audible it isn't music, it has to be organized patterned sounds.
>>61911381
hello reddit
Dick
>>61911381
hey /u/yyy_laulU
>>61911499
how are the bottom 2 panels relevant?
>>61912041
>it has to be organized patterned sounds.
pleb
you probably don't consider indeterminacy and field recordings as music, do you?
>>61913272
>>61913293
bottom two panels ruin it
>>61911473
wong
art isnt art until declared so
recordings =/= music
>>61913435
How do they ruin it? They're the punchline.
>>61913435
Ching chang wangalang
You're opinions are that opinions. I happen to side with John cage in that all sound and lack of is music. Wether or not you the listener listen is another thing all together.
>>61913486
jokes not funny
>>61913513
I found the unfunny fuck guys.
>>61913435
well yeah, putting on a cd isn't the only way. but if you held a concert where a dude sat on the stage and took a shit, it could technically be a musical performace
>>61913533
heheheh look at me making fun of p4k heheehe 7.4
comic was doing great until those last two panels, i literally just removed them on paint and saved it
>>61913499
o yea field recorings, lowercase, modern classical, onkyo, the list goes on...
i too think that every sound produced is music, to it may not be to the person producing it
>>61913662
tho it may not be***
>>61913620
i agree
>>61913272
Pitchfork
>>61911417
idk, pretty shitty party, though
>TFW nobody likes your Musique concrète
Why live?
>>61913662
>i literally just removed them on paint and saved it
...what would the point of the comic be without that punchline? did you think it was deep or something?
