Deafheaven: Sunbather or New Bermuda?

I still can't make my mind up which one I liked better honestly.

SNBTHR no doubt

New Bermuda is too typical and orthodox metal

And we know metal is trash

New Bermuda obviously

Sunbather, i like the beat

Sunbather but only by a little

I like New Bermuda better, but both are great imo

Sunbather

Sunbather easily.

New bermuda's generic supporting instrument interludes kill any momentum created by the black metal parts (which are alright).

Neither.

Sunbather

http://strawpoll.me/6365870/

>>61274540

snbthr because the pink cover, its so cool imo

Sunbather 6/10
New Bermuda 4/10

>>61274540

Why not both?

I'll go for New Bermuda, i liked Sunbather's sound more but NB has more memorable songs and doesn't feel like 4 tracks with a lot of filler.

>>61274554
Lmao
Typical Deafheaven fan

New Bermuda is a more concise album throughout

I love both, and they're pretty close quality wise, but right now I prefer Sunbather, because I love subtlety and while Sunbather might be a little too subtle, New Bermuda is a little more than a little too not-subtle. It sounds like they tried a little too hard, and the solos sound beautiful yet slightly generic at the same time.

New Bermuda has some things going for it though,

>no stupid in-between tracks (the only non-worthless one on New Bermuda is the one after the first song)
>more memorable songs
>a little less "wall-of-sound"y
>a better length

>>61277519
> a little more than a little too not-subtle

wat

>>61277519
>Irresistible
>stupid in-between track

Fair point for Windows though

>>61275356
This

Judas