So where did it go wrong for Green Day?
I personally think it was pic related, Kerplunk, Dookie and Nimrod were golden, Warning was when it began to slip.
>>60969177
lmao it's one of their best, all Greenday fans are plebs so most don't realize.
>>60969177
American idiot came after warning...
But American idiot > Dookie >1,039 > kerplunk > nimrod > insomniac >21st > warning >dos > uno > tre
>>60969327
>1,039 & Kerplunk & Nimrod > Insomniac
nigga what
>>60969381
I like how Green Day experimented with different tones in Nimrod, King For A Day and Time Of Your Life were really refreshing.
>>60969407
Oh yeah don't get me wrong, Nimrod is pretty great, but I think Insomniac is better overall.
>>60969381
U wanna fite bout it nigga
American Idiot is their greatest work. they went wrong with that poppy tripple album that i didnt even listen to
>>60969807
The aren't that bad, the songs are ok, it's just that they sound like a mix between The Replacements and Buzzcocks without the attitude.
>>60969934
Which isn't bad if you're in the mood for it, it just lacked substance. 21st century was a mess as well
Is American Idiot the logical conclusion to pop punk?
>>60970291
Mayb
>>60970291
"no"
>>60970328
But most fans consider that their worst album.
I don't, I think it has some amazing tracks, but most do.
American Idiot was a banger mi familia, trying to redo it with 21st was a problem.
>>60969934
They*
>>60970095
Uno! is full of catchy song/singles-material and i find it decent, i only have a problem with the other two.
>>60970328
The first 4 tracks on that are GOAT, the rest are hit and miss.
>>60969327
>Insomniac that low
patrician ranking coming through
Insomniac > Dookie > 1,039 > Nimrod > American Idiot > Kerplunk! > 21st Century Breakdown > Warning
haven't heard the uno dos tre shits
>>60969177
American Idiot was very good. Dookie was good.
Ofcourse, if you are hipster or a post-teenager you may have a butthurt since your hipster friends won't approve it.
Green Day suck.
Pop Punk sucks.
>>60970950
and guess what, you suck too.
IMO
American Idiot= Insomniac > 1,039 > nimrod = dookie > kerplunk > 21st > trilogy
Haven't heard warning apart from the singles that appeared on superhits
Forgetting those I haven't listened to enough to make a proper assessment:
Dookie > American Idiot > 21st > Nimrod > Warning
