[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Why has no other guitarist even came close?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music

Thread replies: 114
Thread images: 11
File: jimi-hendrix[2].jpg (26 KB, 306x306) Image search: [Google]
jimi-hendrix[2].jpg
26 KB, 306x306
Why has no other guitarist even came close?
>>
I'm much better
>>
>>60816644
because of faggots like you, duh
Fuckheads that admire Jimi that much tend to underrate other guitarists.
>>
>>60816657
this
>>
File: 1445655225197.jpg (21 KB, 568x440) Image search: [Google]
1445655225197.jpg
21 KB, 568x440
>there are people on /mu/ RIGHT NOW who diss Jimi Hendrix
>>
To being so overrated?
Because no other guitarist played in front of half a million drugged hippies desperately trying to convince themselves they were changing the world by attending a fucking concert.
>>
>>60816782
>not thinking jimi hendrix is literally the best guitarist of all time by a margin that could be described as "not even close" is "dissing him"

no
>>
>>60816815
who is as good as him?
>>
>>60816840

this >>60816657 guy duh, he just said he's much better
>>
>>60816914
xD
>>
File: image.jpg (42 KB, 563x374) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
42 KB, 563x374
>>60816809
Waynestock?
>>
>>60816840
>as good

try better
>>
>>60817057
Ok, who is better than him?
>>
blues guitar gets so old after awhile
>>
>>60817280
Holy shit you're cool
>>
john butler
>>
>>60817469
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jdYJf_ybyVo
>>
>>60817243
Robert Fripp
Alan Holdsworth
Steve Hackett
David Gilmour
Al Di Meola
John McLaughlin
Paco De Lucia

Not tough desu senpai
>>
>>60816840
John Fahey, John Williams, Robert Johnson, the list goes on...
>>
>>60817536
>>60817544
I'm still waiting
>>
>>60816644
One word: Kanye West
>>
>>60817556
You're still retarded
>>
>>60817556
too one-eyed to hold effective conversation
>>
>>60817556
This guy believes his own dogma. It's like trying to explain to a Muslim how good a pulled pork sandwich is.
>>
>>60817578
>>60817584
>>60817622
Nice!
>>
>>60817622
They're pretty good, but they're not worth the moral burden of murdering things to eat IMO.
>>
File: wtf.gif (906 KB, 340x173) Image search: [Google]
wtf.gif
906 KB, 340x173
>>60817683
>>
>>60816840
David Gilmour
>>
>>60817556
django reinhardt
andy irvine
robert fripp
john frusciante
robert johnson
wes montogomery
neil young
john lee hooker
chet atkins

listen to more music kiddo
>>
File: steve howe.jpg (49 KB, 600x779) Image search: [Google]
steve howe.jpg
49 KB, 600x779
>>60816644
u wot m8?
>>
>>60816644
This is now a carlos santana thread to illustrate how wrong you are
>>
>>60816840
slash
>>
>>60817725
>kiddo
I'm older than you
>>
>>60817761
this is now a corniest most overrated guitarists of all time thread to fit the santana theme

>bongos intensify
>>
>>60816644
Eric clapton did in a different way
>>
>>60817772
lol no I'm 64
>>
>>60817795
More like 69 lmao
>>
>>60817772
I'm 90 and my dad will beat your dad up
>>
>>60817622
Top fucking kek
>>
>>60817812
ahahahah mlao
>>
>bends on the minor pentatonic

bEST guITarist OF ALL TIME
>>
>>60817845
wrong
he did it while using a wah-wah pedal
>>
>>60817819
It's not that funny
>>
>>60816644
Dadrock general?
>>
>>60817942
radiohead is dadrock
hendrix is grandpa rock
>>
File: based.jpg (93 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
based.jpg
93 KB, 1920x1080
>>60816644
posted the wrong file OP
>>
>>60816644
Because you don't know shit about playing guitar.
>>
Voodoo Child (Slight Return) is literally the greatest rock song of all time
>>
>>60817988
I bet you like Steve Vai
>>
>>60817993
yeah if every other rock song didn't exist haha, jk
>>
>>60818023
haha
>>
>>60817993
yeah maybe if my poop couldn't write music haha lol jk jk jk
>>
>>60818034
haha
>>
File: 1498430935.jpg (11 KB, 200x223) Image search: [Google]
1498430935.jpg
11 KB, 200x223
tl;dr coming up, but I've heard the same things for years without anyone making a good case for "the greatest guitar players ever"

I've listened to pretty much all definable genres of music including the /mu/ memes,
played many styles of guitar on many different types of guitars,
and tried many types of drugs while listening to and playing music,
and I'm not shitting on anyone's tastes but I think anyone who doesn't consider Jimi Hendrix and Eric Clapton to be in a world of their own, playing-wise and improvisationally, is missing out on some of the highest forms of musical appreciation

I've gone through tons of phases where I've thought half the guitarists people mention in these threads are "the best guitarist ever"
But I think if you don't eventually settle on one of these two, you're missing the potential of what a guitar can do

Every artist has some shit, but at their best these two musicians are irreplaceable, no one in a million years would have been able to create what they did with their instruments
>>
jimmy page desu
>>
tl;dr coming up, but I've heard the same things for years without anyone making a good case for "the poop ever"

I've listened to pretty much all definable genres of poop including the /mu/ poop,
played many styles of poop on many different types of poops,
and tried many types of poop while listening to and playing poop,
and I'm not pooping on anyone's tastes but I think anyone who doesn't consider poopy-doopy and the super poop to be in a world of their own, playing-wise and improvisationally, is missing out on some of the highest forms of poop appreciation

I've gone through tons of phases where I've thought half the poops people mention in these threads are "the best poops ever"
But I think if you don't eventually settle on one of these two, you're missing the potential of what a poop can do

Every poop has some shit, but at their best these two poops are irreplaceable, no one in a million years would have been able to create what they did with their poop
>>
File: Newman II.jpg (31 KB, 600x450) Image search: [Google]
Newman II.jpg
31 KB, 600x450
>>60818085
>Jimi Hendrix and Eric Clapton to be in a world of their own
You know what you low brow appropriation fucktard I'll pass with extreme prejudice on your "higher forms of musical appreciation."
>>
Well i think the key distinction is that jimi drew influence from non guitar sources because guitar wasn't a mythos yet. He's cited inspiration ranging from the ufo sound effects from twilight zone, to little richard's vox, to coltrane. oh and drugs too maybe(citation need)

Might sound inconsequential but i think it illustrates something. He more or less grew up before the concept of "guitar heroes". Chuck berry aside, his aspirations were never bound by the guitar in any imitative sense. Every subsequent guitarist had to mold himself in some way after jimi either in opposition or in allegiance. Either way it's a deterioration from the original source (insert echoes diminishing metaphor).

Anyway jimi was free from those dogmatism, I think that's the distinguishing feature of all "great" guitarists. They aren't bound by the guitar. Plus he was the first "great" so...auto-Beethoven status.
>>
File: why it's ol' robby fripp.jpg (42 KB, 432x424) Image search: [Google]
why it's ol' robby fripp.jpg
42 KB, 432x424
i mean hendrix is great but,
>>
>>60818276
I was right up with you until you said he was "the first great"

the first great what, cock-rock idol guitarist
>>
>>60816657
Can confirm, this anon shreds like a mf
>>
>>60818276
This is why I included Eric Clapton
He invented the "psychedelic guitar solo", no one was doing anything remotely close to what was and he turned it into a popular style of playing
Jimi Hendrix was getting booed off stages because people didn't consider what he was doing to be "music" until played with and got semi-endorsed by Eric Clapton

>>60818258
it's ok kiddo, you'll grow up someday
>>
File: 1369257342915.jpg (21 KB, 300x300) Image search: [Google]
1369257342915.jpg
21 KB, 300x300
>(then, far behind)
>>
>>60818352
First:
>cock-rock
It's rock and roll dude. Sex is inextricably linked to this music; in any case sex and artistry aren't mutually exclusive

Second:
note the quotations.
>>
>>60818583
your mom is inextricably linked to my dick
>>
>>60818460
>it's ok kiddo, you'll grow up someday
Has absolutely no worthwhile retort so resorts to memes.

>Eric Clapton
Music for old truckers. I bet you like Mark Knopfler too.
>>
this is the worst music forum on the internet
>>
Neil Young
>>
>>60816840
Jeff Buckley
real talk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GPrieDMB5Zs

and Jonny Greenwood
>>
Literally who?
>>
Lee Ranaldo
Kevin Shields

:^)
>>
>>60820207
it's him
>>
Eddie Hazel >>>>>>>>>>>> Hendrix
>>
Panda Bear desu senpai
>>
>>60817725
>neil young
>>
>>60816840
Hendrix HATED being called the best.
>>
>>60816644

Mark Knopfler is the greatest guitarist to ever live
>>
>>60816644
The mother fucker pioneered so much shit guitsrist do now at current day, any guitarist people say is better will themselves tell you Hendrix was the best there ever was
>>
>>60820663
>wah pedal
everyone stopped using that by 1979
>>
>>60820686
>being this ignorant to the technical aspects of his playing and spouting "MUH EFFECTS MUH WAH"
>>
>>60820707
Cosigning this
>>
>>60820600
that's why he was the best
>>
>>60820707
>minor pentatonic scale
literally what else did hendrix do
>>
>>60820761
Hendrix married lead and rhythm guitar in a way nobody had before
>>
All you edgy faggots could never touch Hendrix. No one will ever come close.
>>
>>60820757
Cringed
>>
>>60820809
don't be a JERdk
>>
>>60820761
>Mixing of styles

He broke the boundaries of rock music at the time, the british kids where all just fucking around with penatatonic scales and here he comes not just mixing a heavy amount of modal playing he also implemented heavily from rhythm and blues diminished chords and rhythm patterns that opened up the vocabulary to what a rock song could have

>mixing of lead and rhythm

As the other anon stated he was able to do both at the time with his fretting of the 6th string with his thumb leaving the rest of the guitar open.

>Created new chord voicings

tracks like little wing and castles made of sand show how he pioneered the use of forgotten and neglected chords into music as well as taking heavily from jazz and funk

Oh and while were on funk

>he created and helped create new genres

The motherfuckers LP with the band of gypsys was the first true funk rock album where the styles were fused as one. There would have been no parliament funkadelic or other huge funk rock acts if it wasnt for him

Not just that the fucker pioneered the distortion you love so much, he was the first to integrate feedback and heavy distortion in a musical sense.

He lived and breathed guitar
>>
Tommy Emmanuel is the greatest guitarist who ever lived
>>
>>60820767
But it's been done better and in more unique and technically interesting ways since his time.

You can label him as a great due to how early in the game he appeared, but some things coming out in present time put him to shame, in the category of 'Great Guitar Playing'.
>>
>>60820862
examples?
>>
>>60816657
>technical ability = musicianship
>>
>>60820869
There are literally like 20 good examples of guitarists who have created great things in this thread.
>>
>>60820761
Get the easily found Kiss The Sky comp and hear the version of I Don't Live Today that's on there.

Shit will send you on one hell of a trip.
>>
>>60820880
so name one
>>
>>60816644
Lou Reed
>>
>>60820847
rekt
>>
>>60820242
THIS
and
Zappa
Fripp
>>
File: FZ_promo2012.jpg (16 KB, 200x206) Image search: [Google]
FZ_promo2012.jpg
16 KB, 200x206
Hey there how you doin people
>>
>>60820847
No funk if it wasn't for him ? You crazy ?

Now I understand your point and I'm sure you meant good. But you're a bitch.
Jimi Hendrix didn't touch shit on Funk, James Brown and African-influenced music did Funk, I guess Jimi Hendrix influenced everything in his time, rock psychedelic was everything at that time, so he must have some influenced to funk. But that doesn't mean shit in comparison to every other great influence.
Now don't be spreading bullshit homeboi you's a bitch.

Here's a gift for you
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HIakXEm4wPE
>>
>>60820626
Indeed.

He knew when to be flashy and when to restrain himself and he is effortless in his ability. Also a really cool, down to earth man. Met him in a pub while he was enjoying a pint of ale.
>>
this guy is better

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U0GXDRR-UUQ
>>
Because black people stopped being interested in playing guitar, so we've been stuck with mostly white people doing it, who are relatively musically-untalented by default.
>>
>>60823694
He said funk rock. Calm down.
>>
What's with rock people and being obsessed with who is better at one of these instruments, especially guitar? Like what does it even matter if Hendrix is better than everyone or not?

Jimi only really worked with electric guitar anyway, which is only part of the history of the guitar in general. I wouldn't even want to compare Eliot Fisk, Bill Frisell, Max Ochs, and Jimi Hendrix, although they're all considered skilled.
>>
>>60816644
Tbh who gives a shit, great guitarist but there is so much better music
>>
>>60816644
wayne and cudder tho
>>
The only guitarist that has come close is Marc Ribot
>>
>>60823279
good musician
mediocre guitar player
>>
>>60823902
nice
>>
>>60823694
Funk rock you fucking doofus
>>
>>60816840
Jad Fair
>>
>>60823728
He is the god of guitar. Far more talented than Hendrix desu

no one else on the planet can do shit as godly as this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OqOcaLof1Yk
>>
>>60824568
Oh look, a moron

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WKQXpwc97uw

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nTSBR7eHL_I
(solo at 2:20)
Thread replies: 114
Thread images: 11

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.