[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
I don't know whether y'all seen this yet or not bu
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music

Thread replies: 132
Thread images: 11
I don't know whether y'all seen this yet or not but here's miley cyrus' new photoshoot, which is basically softcore porn http://dlisted.com/2015/11/13/miley-cyrus-bared-her-pussy-for-terry-richardson-and-candy-magazine/mileycandy6/

Do you guys think this is a huge step in the direction of pop stars becoming straight up pornstars? How long until they're the same thing?
>>
They've been the same thing for literally decades
>>
>>60371992
this was posted literally thousand times last night, shes super skinny and skeletical, i like grimes body type and thicky girls
>>
meh, miley has had her own 3edgy6u style for a while, i doubt it's anything larger. i'd say it's even too edgy for softcore porn.
>>
>>60372016
Yeah, but now we've reached visible nipple level.
>>
>>60371992
She just wants to be a slut but is too afraid to admit it. Women do this a lot nowadays. They hide behind some "freedom movement" bullshit in order to be complete whores and pretend they're somehow dignified.

No layer of irony or edgyness will change the fact that not a single person in the entire world respects Miley Cyrus anymore, and that is the true legacy she will carry for the rest of her live.

Also, shit body.
>>
>>60371992
So when she will go full sex change?
>>
>>60371992
She might as well go ahead and get BLACKED
>>
>>60371992
zachariah holte did it first and better
>>
>>60371992
I hope so, then we'll get some great Ariana fap material.
>>
File: Billy+Ray+Cyrus+5t-G2TQulfom.jpg (29 KB, 360x240) Image search: [Google]
Billy+Ray+Cyrus+5t-G2TQulfom.jpg
29 KB, 360x240
>>60371992
>mfw
>>
She's fucking hideous, god damn...
>>
>>60372093
>shit body
Have you ever seen a naked girl outside of porn? She's got a better than average body
>>
>Terry Richardson
What's the deal with this guy? There's literally a photo of him having sex with a 15 year old actor yet he's met Obama of all people.
>>
why cant anyone just say "no" to her? she is objectively the worst human being alive right now
>>
She looks real bad naked. : /
Also
>arm pits
>>
>>60371992
Disgusting degenerate.
>>
i would fuck her honestly
>>
File: empowered.jpg (22 KB, 364x457) Image search: [Google]
empowered.jpg
22 KB, 364x457
>>60371992
she looks sad. like, suicidally sad
>>
>>60372031
How is Grimes' body type any different from Miley. They're both skinny, "petite" girls.
>>
two words: zero tittage
>>
>>60373157
Grimes is fairy-like, lesbian-like, shes kinda ugly but shes hot, i'd fuck her, atleast shes talented
>>
>>60372150
mike will made it, rae srmurrders guys, rap crews, UK grime squad, Atlanta senpai everybody
>>
>>60372908
oy vey, it's artistic!!
>>
File: 1433423736508.webm (2 MB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
1433423736508.webm
2 MB, 1280x720
>>
>>60373226
They still have the same body type.
>>
>>60372908
Link?
>>
>>60372881
>Have you ever seen a naked girl outside of porn?

Pretty fucking ironic for you to say that. There's nothing in her to make her above average at all.
>>
>>60373321
miley more anorexic
>>
>>60371992
My gf has the same strap-on. That's pretty cool.
>>
terry richardson is a lucky guy
and a faggot
>>
Yeah you say that but Cosey Fanni Tutti was straight up performing in porn, so music was never alien to it.
It's more of an image Miley has built for herself although it seems that it spreads among the circle of artists that are within the same genre and target as miley, so yeah here's hoping for more risque photos of Ariana Grande
>>
pop and rock female stars get regularly naked since like 60s
>>
>>60372155
lmao
>>
>>60373798
that guy has fucked AT LEAST one hundred women and they're all models

lucky nigga
>>
>>60372031
What the hell are you talking about? Grimes is skinny af
>>
>>60372093
>She just wants to be a slut but is too afraid to admit it
Miley openly calls herself a slut all the time though?
>>
i think she's just really desperate to stay relevant desu
>>
>>60372881
pretty much.
>>
>>60372093
Yeah, but the thing is, people have every right to be whorish if that's what they like. Slut shaming is fucking stupid across the board. Sure, it's not the most productive thing to be doing with your time, whoring your body around, but people have the right to do it.
>>
>>60376898
>Slut shaming

That's the most retarded term that ever existed. You say someone who calls a slut a slut is slut shaming, yet the term itself implies she's a slut, you just shouldn't shame her for it.

People have the right to do whatever the fuck they want? Jesus, call the cops, this is unheard of.

Wait, people also have the right to say whatever the fuck they want about other people's decisions? I must be going insane.

Hold on a second, does that mean your post is completely useless? Ah well.
>>
File: why.jpg (32 KB, 288x499) Image search: [Google]
why.jpg
32 KB, 288x499
>Metal music considered by some as unholy devil worship shit that makes kids go killing spree
>Same people take their kids to watch some alcoholic and delusional naked mess of a person, rubbing her cunt on stage and singing about fucking
>>
>>60376930
Of course you have to right to say what you want about other people's decisions you inbred autist.
That doesn't mean you're free from repercussions or criticisms.
>>
>>60376995
>You have the right to say what you want, but you're not free from criticism
>HOWEVER, she should totally be able to be a whore without receiving any criticism for it

Please stop posting, you over-sensitive mongoloid.

You will never take away anyone's right to say anything about any given situation. This is a real right. More than the one to be a fucking whore.

I'm really sorry if this triggers you though.
>>
>>60374438
why though? he looks retarded as shit
>>
>>60377018
>You are over sensitive
Nice projection
>You will never blah blah blah blah
Okayhandsign

Stop replying to me retard.
>>
>>60376930
>you just shouldn't shame her for it.
Yeah, well, yeah.
>>
>>60377085
>no response at all
>n-nice projection bro......
>I'm like, soooooooo over it I'm not even gonna respond
>I'll still reply though
>But no respond
>Because I'm like suuuper over it
>But I'll reply
>But I'm over it though
>Make no mistake
>okay? please...

Did you visit your safe space today?
>>
>>60377112
You can't tell someone what they should or shouldn't do. That goes against the argument you set up for yourself, you fucking moron.

Someone shouldn't tell her not to be a slut, but you're alright in telling people how they should respond to her? Or that they should tolerate her? How is her right above anyone else's?

Sincerely, please, I beg of you, never reproduce, and also smash your keyboard.
>>
>Do you guys think this is a huge step in the direction of pop stars becoming straight up pornstars? How long until they're the same thing?

its like people dont even remember madonna form the early 90s
>>
>>60377114
A U T I S M
U
T
I
S
M

Keep giving me these yous though.
>>
>>60374438
You can safely add a 0 to that. He could fuck a new aspiring model every day of the week.
>>
>>60377062
$$$

i'd say the obvious answer but they're watching...
>>
>>60377144
>LOL! You're funny man!
>I'm so over it I'm not even gonna respond!
>But I'll reply again!
>I really don't care though!
>I mean, I care so little that you could keep doing it
>And I'll probably reply honestly, but don't think I care
>I don't! Ok?
>Y-you're autistic also (not that I care enough to respond)
>>
would you describe Picasso as a whore?

serious question
>>
>>60377177
Where's that picture of Picasso sucking a black strap-on?
>>
>>60377169
I love these yous
I live for the yous
Keep giving me these yous
>>
>>60377133
You should only criticize when you have actually something to criticize though. Otherwise you look like a petty child. There's nothing inherently wrong with being libidinous and shit. You just feel threatened due to your own insecurities regarding your sexuality, and you should get over them, you menial little person.

I mean, it's seriously fucked up how you guys are always complaining how you are always lonely and woman don't talk to you and shit but the minute anyone takes the initiative in the whole sex thing, you go bonkers.
>>
>>60377190
he certainly had a lot more sex than miley

inb4 u try to suggest that being a whore has nothing to do with having sex
>>
>>60377152
what's your skype? I'm extremely interested in your extended answer.
>>
>pop stars
literally who cares
>>
>>60377231
/mu/ and/or /r9gay/ autists
>>
>Tags: Miley Cyrus, Terry Richardson, Why So Edgy?

haha
>>
>>60377212
>You should only criticize when you have actually something to criticize though

Maybe you should take your own advice and only try to stick your mangina when it's actually called for? The post you replied to didn't even say she should stop doing it, just that she obviously enjoys being slutty and should own up to it instead of hiding behind some MUH CHOICE shit. I mean, I'm just trying to help you, otherwise you look like a petty child. You wouldn't want that, would you?

>You just feel threatened due to your own insecurities regarding your sexuality

So, you're saying that, based on a discussion about rights to do and say anything, you're somehow aware that I'm sexually insecure? What was that I heard about projecting in this thread?

> it's seriously fucked up how you guys are always complaining how you are always lonely and woman don't talk to you

Oh shit, that's right. I forgot literally everyone on 4chan is the exact same person.

You have no point. You had nothing to respond to. You just felt the need to defend someone who wasn't even truly being attacked.

And also, no, "having something to say" isn't decided by your standards. People have the right to say something when they feel like it, regardless if Slut Defender here feels it's substancial or not. People are not the ones to judge what's appropriate? You're not the one to judge what's substancial for others to say. Fucking retard.
>>
I like sluts. I like sex without a hassle.
>>
>>60373798
>>60374438
ya im jealous af of this faggot. i dont even get it either all he is is a bad photographer or some shit
>>
>>60377329
>tfw live in the most liberal city in america
>tfw all women here are "sex positive" and major sluts
>still can't get laid
>>
>>60377353
Haha :)
>>
>>60377304
>The post you replied to didn't even say she should stop doing it
But whas obviously sending unwarranted criticism. Which mine isn't. The rest of your post is literally useless. We, hopefully, understand that the zeitgeist is looking for coy shy girls who are somehow as close to virginity as possible and share your impossible music taste and anything else is frowned upon.
Wipe your tears, you insecure manchild. There's no other way to interpret slut shaming except as a projection of sexual insecurity. Literally none, there's no other reason to be so fucking worked up about it. Literally. None.
>>
i'd like to point out at this point that miley cyrus is primarily an actress

enjoy the rest of the thread
>>
>>60377378
>unwarranted criticism

That is a meaningless term. No criticism is unwarranted. She did a bunch of nude pictures sucking a black dildo. What you're basically saying is that no one should express a negative view of it like the post did, because it gets you salty. Every post should be positive or neutral. That's the only thing it could possibly mean, since that post was simply negatively talking about her behaviour, in an open space of discussion and not a Miley Cyrus fan club.

>The rest of your post is literally useless.

Yet you spend the rest of your post making baseless meme jokes about virginity and insecurity and pure women? And you think you have ever debated anything in your entire life?

If you want a safe space, stick your head up your ass and eat your own shit. Otherwise stop trying to silence people because they make you reflect about how shitty you are.
>>
Poptimists will defend this
>>
>>60377433
>That is a meaningless term
Isn't that the most vapid comment of the year?

>No criticism is unwarranted.
We should stop being polite and just call it fucking idiotic, then.

>She did a bunch of nude pictures sucking a black dildo. What you're basically saying is that no one should express a negative view of it like the post did, because it gets you salty
Who's putting words on people's mouths now?

> since that post was simply negatively talking about her behaviour
Wait wasn't this about the picture? Make up your mind already.

What a useless piece of shit post, do continue.
>>
>>60376988
of course a metalhead would say this.

of course
>>
>>60377482
>We should stop being polite and just call it fucking idiotic, then

What are you even trying to express still? You got NO POINT at all. From the moment everyone is allowed to say whatever they want, which WE ARE, no point of view is "unwarranted" or "unecessary" just because you personally think so. That is literally trying to silence people because you don't agree with them. Which is literally equal to people trying to stop a slut from being slutty because they don't agree with her. You are what you criticize.

>Who's putting words on people's mouths now?

>>We, hopefully, understand that the zeitgeist is looking for coy shy girls who are somehow as close to virginity as possible and share your impossible music taste and anything else is frowned upon.

>>Wipe your tears, you insecure manchild. There's no other way to interpret slut shaming except as a projection of sexual insecurity.

>> it's seriously fucked up how you guys are always complaining how you are always lonely and woman don't talk to you

>Wait wasn't this about the picture? Make up your mind already.

Pretending to be dumb is not a valid arguing tactic. The post was talking about her behaviour in the pictures in which she appears sucking an enormous black dick. And here's the thing: That's totally, absolutely fine, even though it clearly triggered you.

You have nothing to respond with really. Now you're just desperately trying to sound smart and pulling the LOL KEEP GOING hoping I'll stop replying so you can feel like you've "won" or something even though you're probably realizing by now you're a fucking moron with no arguments.

Don't worry though, I'll keep going.
>>
>>60377566
I'm going to disregard the entire thing. I'm calling it "unwarranted criticism" because that's how it is. You've been posting extremely long passages while, not very carefully, avoiding the crux of the matter, if you haven't quite catched it, it's why is being a slutty a bad thing. We obviously haven't delved into it because
a) There's no rational reasoning behind it (hence "unwarranted" or on our most modern conception "fucking idiotic"
and b) If we probe it it'll have loads of what do you think of your own penis.
>>
I think Miley might actually be slightly mentally retarded.

She has always been a product but she seems to be so easy to control and get to do shit whoever the fuck happens to be pulling the strings of her career at that moment, almost like she has no common sense or will of her own.
>>
>>60377633
>I'm going to disregard the entire thing.

"I don't care at all, I'm like, over it. I'm not gonna respond. Let me reply though, but only because I really don't care."

>I'm calling it "unwarranted criticism" because that's how it is

Nice. By that logic people call her a slut because that's just what she is.

>avoiding the crux of the matter, if you haven't quite catched it, it's why is being a slutty a bad thing

Actually it wasn't talked about because not a single person said that at all. You took this as an opportunity to go on a little crusade about something NO ONE mentioned, which either makes me think you're a guy desperate for a fuck or a woman with questionable decisions. I do admit that is assuming a lot though, but it'd make sense.

The post said, "She likes acting slutty, she should own up to being a slut and not pretend it's some liberation cause." In other words, go be a happy slut, not a pretentious one. And you're the fucking moron out here, screaming his lungs out SLUT SHAMING! SLUT SHAMING! WHY IS IT BAD THO WHY U HATE IT!

No one expressed any opinion at all towards her behaviour. The opinion was, "she oughta own up to it" and also "she has a shit body."

> If we probe it it'll have loads of what do you think of your own penis.

"Who's putting words on people's mouths now?"
>>
>>60377482
>>60377566
>>60377633
>>60377703

BTFO OF THE YEAR
>>
to straighten things up:
1. people can live how they want
2. people can state their opinions about things
slut shamers are not denying any of the above freedoms. slut defenders deny the second freedom.
>>
>>60371992
>miley-cyrus-bared-her-pussy-for-terry-richardson

Is there anyone who hasn't?
>>
>>60377741
Perfect.
>>
>>60374438
he's fucked at least 100 men and trannies also
>>
>people acting shocked over Miley Cyrus doing nude shoots

where the fuck you niggas been the past 3 years
this is old old old news
even on disney you could see it coming
>>
>>60377741
i defend sluts because if i was an attractive celebrity grill i'd probably be having just as much sex 2bh
>>
ok so how long until she does a video where she's actually having sex?
>>
>>60377703
>By that logic people call her a slut because that's just what she is.
Yeah, and there's nothing wrong with it.

>Actually it wasn't talked about because not a single person said that at all.
> In other words, go be a happy slut, not a pretentious one

> They hide behind some "freedom movement" bullshit in order to be complete whores and pretend they're somehow dignified.
Yeah, if you read it like a fucking buffoon. The comment is, not even implying, it's pretty explicit, that whores either have or deserve no dignity.

>No one expressed any opinion at all towards her behaviour
Except that comment.

If you truly have no qualms about girls being slutty, then why do you keep replying so angrily?
If you DO have qualms, though, mind explaining them?
>>
>>60377738
seconded
>>
File: 3274927389547239546.webm (3 MB, 920x518) Image search: [Google]
3274927389547239546.webm
3 MB, 920x518
Was this ever answered?
>>
Do you think Billy Ray is ever embarrassed by her? Or does he get a portion of her profits so he doesn't care if she whores herself out?
>>
>>60377948
He did try to restart his career through Miley's success.
>>
>>60377856
>Yeah, and there's nothing wrong with it.

I really don't get what you're trying at all. You're replying to opinions that were never stated, that you made up for people. You're countering arguments that were never fucking argued. Can you wrap your head around that?

>In other words, go be a happy slut, not a pretentious one

I hope you realize that when you use the term "slut shaming," or in other words, "shaming the slut," you're already calling her a slut anyway, so I'd assume the term is neutral, unless you're admitting to be bigoted yourself. So yeah, go be a happy slut. It's really funny that you go to such lenghts to defend her, yet automatically take that as offense.

>it's pretty explicit, that whores either have or deserve no dignity.

And? I don't see what's wrong with that. How can you think about denying someone that opinion? Disagree with it. NEVER go around saying there's no right to say it.

>If you truly have no qualms about girls being slutty, then why do you keep replying so angrily?

I'd say you are most definitely off your balance since you so desperately try to paint everyone who disagrees with you (most of the thread by now) a lonely and insecure virgin. This desperation to prove to me you're over-secure in your sexuality tells me there's something deeper here than just a bloke fighting for a good cause.

But probably not, right?
>>
Slut shaming isn't about whether or not you should call someone a slut. Sluts know they're sluts. It's about the idea that it really matters if someone is a slut or not. If you devote the mental energy to disliking someone you don't know because they like to have a lot of sex, you are certainly entitled to your opinion, and other people are entitled on calling you out on being a puritanical busybody if you express it.
>>
>>60377898
this guy has a really bad melon head yo
>>
>>60377981
>And? I don't see what's wrong with that.
Nice. Either it's a slip or you are just happily admitting that you yourself don't value dignity, probably including your own.

>How can you think about denying someone that opinion?
It's not even an opinion, it's a judgement on action, something you yourself cried over and over that nobody was doing, yet here we are. It's also a pretty shit judgement. How is her right to dignity above anyone else's?

> NEVER go around saying there's no right to say it.
When did I say this? We are having this conversation, right? There's not even a janitor deleting the posts. Did you buy yourself into a bullshit strawman and you are desperately and pathetically hamfisting me into said stereotype, so then I can be like "all those irrational feeemales" that you've heard of on le reddit?
>>
>>60378134
>Nice. Either it's a slip or you are just happily admitting that you yourself don't value dignity, probably including your own

I'm admitting that everyone has the right to have any opinion, especially when it comes to such personal matters as this. You can't talk about rights and then ignore freedom of speech altogether except when you conveniently agree with it.

>It's not even an opinion, it's a judgement on action

Opinions are often both.

>How is her right to dignity above anyone else's?

This statement makes no sense. Some people think making pop music isn't dignified. Some poeple think being a slut isn't dignified. It's their own personal morals and values. You CANNOT, and will not, ever deny that.

>When did I say this?

>> I'm calling it "unwarranted criticism" because that's how it is

>>We should stop being polite and just call it fucking idiotic, then.

>>But whas obviously sending unwarranted criticism.
>>
>>60378207
>>>> I'm calling it "unwarranted criticism" because that's how it is

>>>We should stop being polite and just call it fucking idiotic, then.

>>>But whas obviously sending unwarranted criticism.

Hurr I deserve a free pass on shitting all over people over something as menial and personal as sex life but don't criticize my """""opinions""""" otherwise that's an attack on my freedumbs!

You don't, you sexually insecure manchild. I'm done.
>>
>>60378288
That's absolutely correct, people have the right to value their morals as they please without being silenced. You're making progress.

I'm sure you're done like, totally for real, though. You wouldn't possibly come back even more buttblasted than before.
>>
>>60378351
+1
>>
>>60378351
>That's absolutely correct
No it really seems like I'm done.
>>
>>60378393
I'm sure he's just replying to reply.
Autistic tier behavior though.
I'm very sure he's going to reply again though.
>>
>>60378393
I believe you, friend! You certainly wouldn't say that and then keep making petty posts and never leave the thread. That'd be ludicrous.
>>
>>60378416
Who cares, he already said I'm absolutely correct.
>>
>>60378426
Lmao just keep giving him yous then.
>>
>>60373226
>talented
lol.
>>
>>60376988
you sound like you work for the MPAA
>>
File: o-TERRY-RICHARDSON-.jpg (432 KB, 2000x1000) Image search: [Google]
o-TERRY-RICHARDSON-.jpg
432 KB, 2000x1000
>>60373798
>>60374438
>>60377152
>>60377332
hasnt he been charged with rape or accused of it or something? also the fight in this thread is pathetic
>>
wouldn't bang desu senpai
>>
>>60377062

Women will fuck a high status male even if he looks like shit
>>
File: 1446914145541.gif (2 MB, 400x225) Image search: [Google]
1446914145541.gif
2 MB, 400x225
>>60371992
>Terry Richardson
>>
>>60379501
Go away, tripshit.
>>
Just zoomed way in on her pussy
>>
>>60377332
>>60377062
young models will do ANYTHING to do a photoshoot with Richardson...
he's the biggest portrait photographer in the world
it's like being a soundclound-tier rapper and then suddendly Kanye comes up to you and says "i will produce your album if you suck my dick"
what would you do?
>>
>>60379806
>letting kanye anywhere near my shit
>ever
>and then sucking his dick for the privilege

puh-leeeeease
>>
I thought one of the pc-artists were going to do something with porn. like, hiring a porn actress to sing and then promoting the music with explicit pornography. drawing parallels between pop music and porn or something in the way of how both industries fetishizes and commodifies women's bodies. seems like an obvious thing
>>
>>60379636
No
>>
who gives a shit
>>
File: dead petz.jpg (177 KB, 1035x1035) Image search: [Google]
dead petz.jpg
177 KB, 1035x1035
What's your favorite track from Dead Petz? Mine is probably The Milky Milk Milk.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xFlmvOyeww8
>>
>>60381714
I think dooo it is the best. But this is close. Also cyrus skies and i get so scared are incredible.
>>
>>60377378
Hey man I don't think you're using the word literally enough
>>
>>60381714
Same although
>>60381893
Dooo it has been growing on me and i'm terrified as to why.
>>
Looks like Justin Bieber without the dick or muscles. Gross.
>>
>>60372908

It's all name recognition and hype. In a just world, Richard Kern would be getting all the work.
>>
>>60382332
yeah she perfect. jb has literally the god tier face. miley has a womans body = perfect
>>
>>60382520

Biebs has a better ass
>>
>>60382235
it catches so much feeling and ideas in one song, The spirit of transgression juxatposed against the emptieness of its slogans, then the chorus describes the painful and desperate desire to transcend both.
>>
>>60371992

this girl used to be Hannah Montana, let that sink in while you're looking at the picture of her sucking on that baton like it's a cock
>>
File: sad miley.png (28 KB, 256x237) Image search: [Google]
sad miley.png
28 KB, 256x237
>tfw this is the closest we'll ever get to hq bieber nudes
;__;
>>
>>60383239
Exactly why i'm frightened desu.
>>
>>60376898
>slut shaming
do you mean standing up for decency, or do you mean being modest and appreciating it
>>
>>60383239
woah. this song really speaks to me in an uncomfortable post-ironic way wtf
Thread replies: 132
Thread images: 11

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.