New version for Valentine's Day. I'm adding one more column and row for this chart. Suggestions? Replacements for any of the albums?
>>53590492
definitely this.
>>53590492
How is L&GWAFIS broken-heart core
I mean I guess he's broken-hearted about wanting more smack
>>53590492
How is Sing to God "broken heart-core"? I love it but it's not the sort of thing I'd listen to if my heart was broken.
As much as I like I See a Darkness, this album fits the heart break angle better
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9MLoY_zadsE
>>53590533
different people deal with heartbreak differently, soma.
it worked for me.
also hey they're called Cardiacs, it was supposed to be a pun, although i don't even think it's funny or clever myself :/
>>53590617
I suppose if you wanted to act all happy and bipolar about a breakup (like how Leland Palmer dealt with Laura's death in Twin Peaks) then Sing to God could work.
>>53590529
>>53590533
These suggestions were made in a previous thread for Broken Heart-Core. Suggestions? Replacements?
>>53590560
So replace I See A Darkness with that?
>>53590560
Finally, appreciation for I See A Darkness.
Captcha: llove
^ /mu/ what does it mean??
>>53590678
Avey Tare - Down There is a really depressing breakup album.
The Boatman's Call by Nick Cave.
Gentlemen by Afghan Whigs.
>>53590492
: The Narcissist II also
It's about Panda Bear's dad dying, and he recorded it in the room his dad died in...
>>53590735
Hnnnnggggggggggggggg
Alright guys. This is what I've got so far. Add more? Suggestions? Replacements? - OP
>>53590926
elliott smith - roman candle
>>53590926
Great list. Glad some of my recs got on there. If you add any more it might become overbearing. Maybe the first Codeine album over the second one. Also Jens Lekman is GOAT.
>>53590956
Elliott's second album might be more broken heart, even Elliott himself that it "can't get any darker". Just my opinion though.
>>53590956
>>53590981
Replace? Add more?
>>53590981
>>53590988
any elliott is good
and add, all the above I agree with or have never heard so couldn't say
thanks
>>53591015
>>53590988
Take off one of the Dean Blunt albums since you already have two, and add the 2nd Elliott Smith album.
>>53590492
Glad to see my Paul Baribeau rec make it. One of my personal favorites.
>>53590964
When I Said I Wanted to be Your Dog is a fantastic album. I absolutely love "Cold Swedish Winter" and "Julie"
>>53590926
>>53591057
well have to be the narcissist ii as I remember reading that the redeemer is about dean's break up with a gf
beach boys - pet sounds
>>53591079
Sylvia from his first record really makes me feel for some reason. Might be the chord progression.
>>53591080
Saw him live. Excellent stuff.
>>53591081
Yep. The redeemer should be kept.
>>53591100
OH CAROLINE NOOOOOOOOOOO. That fucking song makes me weep like a bitch.
>>53591079
replace with jens lekman other album?
add james is going to die soon by crywank
an essential
Do we need to list albums? If we can suggest EPs, "Icons, Abstract Thee" by of Montreal is the some of the most brokenhearted shit
>>53590926
how you gonna have Jens Lekman and no Sondre Lerche?
"I have no bags to pack, no suitcase waiting in the hall. You have no makeup, no stockings, in my drawer"
