one a these again
lessgo
>>51111850
>>51111850
self-titled is definitely underrated, and the fact that you didn't like loaded says to me that you don't really listen to the VU
>>51111730
i'd make one for current 93 but every album would be the god tier one except nature unveiled and maby dogs blood (only because of jesus wept)
>>51111850
not liking
>Oh! Sweet Nuthin'
>Sweet Jane
>New Age
or even
>I Found a Reason
>>51111805
>>51112016
Misdirect was 7/10
>>51112016
I support this.
>>51112041
Really? I think it's the closest to a 10 they've done.
This took me ages, I hope you appreciate the 15 mins
my opinion
>>51112212
>electriclarryland
>2
why
>>51112271
Why is 2112 so low?
I'd also bump up fly by night by a point or two too
>>51112299
That's a lot of god tiers
Tone down your ranking, there's no way Low and Ziggy Stardust are on the same level, or as good as monsters
>>51112351
2112 is a funny old album
2112 would be an 8/10 if it was an EP with just 2112 on it, but the second half really lets it down IMO
And 2112 (the track) is nowhere near as good as later "long songs" like Hemispheres
>>51112394
lol syro is better than the richard d. james album
>>51112373
Well the rating is a little more personal than objective but I think ballpark these are all around correct. I mean I liked Low and Ziggy a lot.
>>51112394
this is me except i think syro was actually really good.
>>51112428
have you listened to RDJ at 33 rpm? it turns into an entirely different album.
>>51112428
top lel
>>51112462
I haven't, what's it like?
>>51112409
Tears might be their worst song up until the 80s, but Lessons and Passage to Bangkok are great
>>51112599
>No Pablo Honey
why
>>51112599
just exclude PH huh.
Switch Amnesiac and OKC and I agree.
>>51112668
Because it is an unimportant album in both their discography and in popular culture.
That should be obvious.
>>51112687
ehhhh idk
>>51112660
And Unplugged in New York?
>>51112703
god tier
>>51112718
Mah nigga
>>51112703
shit I forgot, but yeah god teir
>>51112725
that being said, I prefer alice in chains'
>>51112695
It literally has their best known song on it. Not saying that makes it any better but saying its irrelevant in pop culture and to the band doesn't make much sense.
>>51112271
I'd put Permanent Waves and Grace Under Pressure higher, but other than that, pretty good. A Farewell To Kings through Moving Pictures is such a fucking good win streak.
>>51112785
It has Creep which has done nothing to change anything in pop culture.
It's a song people know. That's it.
Regardless, I don't think there should be a debate about why Pablo Honey isn't on a chart.
>>51112546
it has a really chill sort of hip-hoppy groove to it. it actually sounds like it could have been made this year when it's played at that speed. he designed it so that it could be played either fast or slow, and the slow one is sort of a hidden album exclusive to vinyl.
>>51112409
You're pretty much right. The 2112 title track kicks ass, but it's not to the level that they achieved in the next two albums. I like most of the songs off the second side, though. Tears fucking sucks, though.
>>51112599
>TKOL higher than In Rainbows
u fucking wot?
>>51112768
are the more recent albums good, I have not tried them yet/
>>51112919
TKOL is their best album you pleb
>>51112919
Yes. The composition on the album is much more Jazz-influenced and overall more interesting.
There's also the consistent atmosphere throughout the album to consider.
obv not his whole discog but w/e
>>51112965
Not him, but I love new Alice in Chains, their new shit is very doomy, especially their most recent album.
I understand if you disagree
>>51114097
Almost agree
NLDW needs NOTMs face
NOTM needs GPs
GP needs NLDWs
>>51112965
It's ok, I don't think you'd get more than a smile, though
>>51112965
>no sap
>no mtv unplugged
listen to that before their new stuff
>>51112965
junkhead is better than dirt
>>51114456
whats wrong with me? I meant facelift is better than dirt imo
Controversial opinions coming through.
>>51113979
i dont get why people dont like s/t. Its not much lyrically for the most part but its a great neo-psych listening experience. It just sounds really good to me and I appreciate it for that.
His newest album "Sauna" isn't out yet, but I heard it live and it's an 8/10
>>51112016
this
but parallax II deserves more love
Anyone listen to these guys?
>>51112660
>Incesticide better than Bleach and Nevermind
objectively wrong, anon
>>51115056
>not liking eureka
>liking newest albums more than eureka
are you some kind of a faggot?
>>51112297
Ive never heard of anyone else on /mu/ appreciating the magnetic fields! Yes man
>>51112599
>In Rainbows isn't God Tier
C'mon, anon.
>>51114097
I'd swap Ex with TMS and put NOTM higher.
>>51115614
>Flume by Flume
>Untrue by Burial
>Entroducing.... by Dj Shadow
>Thinking In Textures by Chet Faker
>>51111779
i'd put STG as a god tier too, and MPP probably a bit higher, but otherwise i agree with all of this
>>51114097
10, 10, 10, 6, 7
>>51114526
Meteora > A Thousand Suns >>> Hybrid Theory > Hunting Party > Living Things > Minutes to Midnight
>>51115923
This is actually completely true
>>51115874
>implying Gloss Drop wasn't a 10
>>51112373
Low and Ziggy are definitely near the same level
>>51115941
>Hvis Lyset Tar Oss god tier
My nigger
>>51114097
9, 7, 7, 5, 7
this picture is too big, but whatever.
Sorry for messing up the album order and having different sizes. I'm too lazy right now.
>>51111730
Does anyone have a version of the scale where they have numbers?
>>51111909
Hey, I'm working on one of those!
>every album would be the god tier one except nature unveiled and maby dogs blood
But this is one of the worst things I've ever heard.
>>51116605
>>51116649
Thanks
>>51114418
this is correct
>>51112126
man i went into this album expecting some sort of feel music (based solely on the album art) and i got something completely different but still good
>>51116882
I don't agree but I respect your opinion.
>>51117123
you sound like a gentleman
inb4
>TBK LE P4K DRONE
>>51112112
The Scale alone should of give OLTA a full on 10.
>>51117526
>Cop
>not at least an 8
>Greed
>not at least a 7
>TBK being better than The Seer
fullest pleb
>>51114526
THANK YOU
>>51117526
man, how do you not like early swans? it's cool if you don't, i just don't see what's not to like.
>>51112599
I agree with this guy>>51112687
>>51117526
>Great annihilator and white light not god tier
m8..
>>51115815
boring as fk
>>51117653
>>51114526
I mean seriously? You think THIS is fucking god tier?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDOkMSf-F14
>>51117818
Please
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFqCWf_X-HQ
>>51112271
Aw I actually liked Hold Your Fire, but Caress is the best imo
>>51117943
That sounded incredibly commercial I'm sorry
INDISPUTABLE TRUTH
>>51118168
lel
>>51117731
Fun fact: Gira himself is embarrassed about White Light because of how much reverb it uses
Personally I think it's a fantastic album, and he does as well really like the songs on it but has gone on record to say all the reverb ruined it.
>>51115673
i dont get it whats the connection?
>>51116131
pretty accurate for me. ive gotta listen to how to leave town a little more. i dont know how to make these charts so ill just use numbers
starving while living 7
my back is killing me baby 8
twin fantasy 10
nervous young man 9
how to leave town 5 or maybe 6
so pretty similar id just rate starving while living and how to leave town 1 or so higher
>>51115614
What would you rate Kindred? Best thing he's done in my opinion
Okay
>>51119433
overrated band
>>51119812
>band
>>51119845
isn't it steve albini and 1 other dude or something?
>>51119845
lol what about 1000 Hurts and Dude, Incredible?
>>51119399
Definitely a 7 or an 8. It's much more hard hitting than a lot of stuff he's done, so it's very unique. The vocals on it are catchy as hell too.
>>51119913
huh?
I think 1000 Hurts is great, not on the same level as Albini's previous stuff but great. I really love The Rude Gesture 7' from Shellac.. Billiard Player Song is the best thing that band ever did... Dude, Incredible is nice because, well... It just came out and is no bullshit rock (which the world needs)...
Also WE'RE RIDING BIKES
AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
>>51115673
flume and chet faker are shit
get back to triple j message boards pleb
>>51117726
Translanticism not a 10
Plans not a 10
Narrow stairs not a 9 at least
>>51117526
>thinking children of god is god tier
>thinking filth is a 5/10
>>51117771
>STGSTV and Danse Manatee lower than MPP
you just went full on pleb
too lazy to update but bump down WT to a 5 and YZ to a 7
>>51112299
God, Reality had such a shitty cover. I agree with you on everything though.
>>51117771
if stgstv was higher and danse manatee a bit lower id agree
>>51115887
>GP was better than a 6
>NOTM was better than a 7
>Exmilitary was not a 10
>NLDW was definitely not a 10
Yeah I like Arcade Fire.
>>51116574
What are these?
>>51112690
fully agree nice one anon
but what about heartbeat and il duce singles?
>>51117526
>not liking early swans
your plebness is plebalant
>>51115986
Frigid Stars should definitely be an 8-9 imo
>>51119962
The EP is a 10
>>51116828
Pygmalion is God tier
>>51125190
Muh total nigg (even when Discipline is 9-10 for me)
>>51115986
>white birch best
nice m8
>>51126169
>missing 808's
top pleb
