Seeing how everyone hates the EQG because of >no hooves meme. What if all the human characters were replaced with their pony counterpart but keeping the story, setting, and lore the same. Would that change people's opinion on the series?
>>27751149
you mean make the series pony related? no its still shit.
>>27751149
No, because the story, setting, and lore are all complete trash. >no hooves isn't a meme, it's just shorthand for 'everything about Equestria girls is irredeemably bad, it should never have been made, and it isn't worthy of discussion'
>>27751149
They'd still be shitty highschool movies, but at least the sirens would've been fuckable for the entire second film.
>>27751149
No, change the setting and lore back to the fantasy the rest of the series plays with, and make the story less horribly contrived. Maybe it would be passable after a major overhaul, but by then it wouldn't be EqG anymore - it would be regular pony.
High school movies are the worst kind of cancer, and everything that EqG spawned is a blight upon this fandom. Full stop.
This guy has the right idea. >>27751177
It's not because
>le no hooves
EqG really is several steps below FiM levels of quality in writing and setting.
That being said, you can enjoy the movies but just replacing the humans with ponies won't make people like them more.
>ITT: Summer
>>27753000
>he thinks a majority of the board likes EQG
Nice try summerfag, but you're going to have to do some more lurking.
>no hooves is just a meme
>>27751149
The biggest problem is that story is pretty bad, it's just generic high school shit. The characters being humans is the least of its problems
Like others have said, hooves aren't the problem. It's just not good lore.
>>27753216
Let's not get carried away, the fact that they're humans is still pretty shit. They should've always stayed pony no matter what
>>27751149
> Make a show about a unique and interesting setting
People like it
> Make a spinoff set in a generic, overused, shit setting that all your peers use
People fucking hate it
>>27753140
They just don't give a shit now, sunmerfag.
>going against numbers
Spend some time with friends instead of wasting it here.
>>27753167
fuck off memespouter you are fucking cancer
>>27753265
I agree wholeheartedly, but aesthetics are subjective, and thus a moot point to argue over.
>>27753333
check em
>>27753494
Ooh, 'memespouter', hey I got a summerfag bingo!
>>27753000
>>27753333
>these wasted numbers in a shit post
>>27753167
>bitching about a meme while posting a meme
Kill yourselves
