ColtQuest Thread 5.2

File: 87.png (106KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

106KB, 640x600px

>>25287952

Emerald makes fake sounds of extreme pleasure. He wants to make sure that he distracts Stargazer for as long as possible. Though her technique is average, the attention to his member and the attractiveness of the mare he comes close many times, but manages to hold back. He still remembers the pain of the shock and restriction from the ring.

After a few minutes Stargazer says, "What is the meaning of this?" She then pushes Emerald off of her and shakes a cramp out of her hoof, "There is some trickery here!"

Pinning Emerald down, she scrutinizes the pendant closely. She seems to have missed the ring, which is all for the better. She says, "Whatever it is, it is anti-magic and bound to you, is it not?"

"Y-yes" Emerald says, and thinking quickly continues, "Why, do you n-need magic to get me off?"

Stargazer gives the colt a furious look, and then giving a fake grin says, "Alright then little colt, how do you want it? I've got a few holes and they are all enough to bring you to a mind-bending orgasm. I'll show you the power of a succubus!"

Emerald sees a shadow out of the corner of his eye. He saw something or someone lurking out of one of the barn windows. He just needs to hold on a little longer.

What does Emerald do?

HALLELUJAH

When I need to hold on a bit longer in sex, I usually do math in my head.

So, make it an intelligence roll by trying to do some algebra in his head.

>>25288070
Ask for oral so she will be distracted.

>>25288131
it doesn't matter, we pyshically cannot cum because of the ring.

>>25288164
with oral she'll be staring at the ring the whole time and might get the trick, vaginal or anal would be safer.

>>25288070

>>25288164
Having her eyes on our junk/ring is a bad idea. Let's take her from behind.

>>25288180
>>25288184
I was about to delete the post because I remembered.

inb4 Joyride is just going to wait for us to end up blowing our load and enjoy the show before she gets to it.

>>25288164
Maybe we go for vaginal instead? Try and get her off, fill another orb on the ring?

>>25288194
to be fair, she might know how to get it off to 'win' her bet.

so we'd only then have to escape her or stall until joyride shows up.

>>25288070
Vanilla sex so she isn't staring at the ring.

>>25288070
ask her if she can deepthroat. that way she will be distracted when rescue comes.

>>25288321
The ring m8.

>>25288334
what about it? maybe it will poke her in the eye and blind her.

File: Samuel Johnson is baffled by your post.jpg (20KB, 421x512px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

20KB, 421x512px

>>25288348

Anal, simply anal.

>>25288547
Agreed, go with anal.

File: 88.png (133KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

133KB, 640x600px

>>25288131
>>25288180
>>25288184
>>25288198
>>25288203

Emerald decides the vagina would be the best place. Oral may make her spot the ring, and also there is the chance that he may get her off and light another orb on his ring.

"Y-your, umm... Your..." Emerald says, but then blushes and looks away.

"Well aren't you a cutie." seh says, keeping him pinned. Stargazer points the colt's cock straight up and sits quickly down onto it, hilting and causing Emerald to throw his head back in pleasure.

She starts to move, and she is way better at this than the hoofjob. Bringing herself almost all the way off the colt before slamming back in again. Emerald can already feel his ecstasy welling up at the mare's merciless pounding.

"Please stop! P-please!" Emerald says, halfheartedly trying to push Stargazer off of him. Stargazer simply grins and keeps going. Emerald let's out a cry of pain and pleasure as he feels the ring tighten around him and give him a shock.

>Frustration increases to 100/100

Stargazer titters and attempts to get up, but Emerald holds onto her tight and says, "N-no, please let me cum. Please mistress!"

"What? You came, didn't you but... You didn't?" Stargazer says, forcing the grasping colt off her and looking down at both of their junk.

"Wait..." She says, after a second, and pulling Emerald up a bit she examines his junk more closely, and seeing the ring a light of understanding hits her eyes. Her horn lights up again and suddenly there is a shuffling from behind Emerald.

He looks around to see Giles walking towards them, a strange, unseeing stare in his eyes. Emerald can tell where this is going, and at the moment he'd be lying if he said he didn't want it. The bet he made... Losing doesn't sound so bad right now.

At the same time though he is quite sure he heard voices from outside. If he can hold out a bit longer maybe he'll get some help.

What does Emerald do?

>>25288812
Can't think of any other way to stall at this point. Frustration a maxed and she's very much in control.

>>25288812
is she going to get Giles to plow us until we cum?

Well, we have to keep her distracted. for the team.

>>25288812
Try and push her off you with your legs as she's distracted and break for it trying to get Giles out of there.
Obviously this is going to require a body check which is more than certainly going to fail, but it's all I can think of to do atm.

So the loophole states that we can only cum if we aren't touch our junk. I propose that we therefore grab our cock and start to 'bate.

>>25288812
Yell for help.

>>25288812
Try to run away, if we can't get away jerk while Giles ass fucks us as to not cum

Accept Giles dick

>>25289275
Dude, strategy is more important than lewd. The lewd will come, we just need to react reasonably.

>>25289315
At this point the difference is unclear.

>>25288812
All I know is if we get a mouthful of Giles, make sure to whimper and cry around that pistoning mouthful. Because my dick, that's why.

>>25289400
a mouthful wouldnt be that bad, we'd be unlikely to cum from that.

or we could beg him to resist her and get that mouthful later as a reward.

>>25289400
Unfortunately senpai I think Star intends to have Giles make us lose the best, which means he'll be using the other hole.

>>25289468
This. Which is why we keep hooves on our cock.

>>25289484
Pretty sue she won't allow that.

>>25289499
Well, this is really only a stalling tactic. It should be very short before the cavalry arrives.

>>25288812
>>Frustration increases to 100/100
not like he has much choice. he needs it and he needs it NOW!

>>25288812
Masturbate while being fucked.

>>25289484
>>25290030
This is the path to victory: fap and give Giles what he desperately wants. Maybe our boypossy can win us a new party member.

>>25288812
Stutter up at her "You're not Giles"

File: 89.png (169KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

169KB, 640x600px

>>25288904
>>25288925
>>25288950
>>25289029
>>25289275
>>25289484
>>25289542

(I'm about to pass out. I'll continue in the morning)

Emerald closes his eyes and spreads his legs, waiting for Giles. He moans as he feels a forceful press against his backside, and just as sudden as that Giles is in him. Giles wastes no time to start moving his hips, and Emerald can barely contain his sounds of pleasure. Emerald steals a few glances at the stallion. He is looking straightforward with a dim look in his eyes. He is obviously being manipulated.

"They are in here sir and-" Emerald hears a voice say, and glancing at the door he sees a shocked Praline as well as a shocked stallin wearing familiar looking armor.

Even through his haze of sexual frustration, Emerald recognizes the danger.

What does Emerald do?

>>25290498
If he's been hypnotized into fucking us any attempts to get away will be. Alas, we'll just have to let ourselves be fucked while telling them "There's a succubus controlling him!"

>>25290498
Uh, can they see Stargazer?
We need them to fight each other. Should be easy enough, considering they both want us.

>>25290498
warn the guard about stargazer and hopefully distracting the sucubus will release control of giles.

or not, both work for me to be honest.

>>25290521
will be met with him forcing us down*

>>25290498
What if we put our pendent on him?

>>25290536
Stargazer would probably jump in right after we dropped the amulet. Nah, we just need to touch our cock and the ring will keep us from cumming.

>>25290556
Why does that matter at this point?

>>25290556
The pendent will come right back, but it might break her control on him.

>>25290593
We don't know enough about the pendant to confirm that.

>>25290572
Don't fuck around with magic promises or deals. They tend to be magically binding.

>>25290609
There's nothing magic about it.

>>25290609
Would it hurt to try? If we fail it'll be back around our neck almost immediately.

>>25290654
Eh, I guess its worth a shot. Toss that pendant around his next.

Fap.

>>25290498
say "she's still here."

Warn the guard or we're toast.

>>25290498
scream in pain and cry >Rape

damned be civilian casualties

>>25290498
RAAAAAAAAAAAPE!

>>25290498
Try to move away from Giles.
Fail. Get pushed down and rutted harder.

>>25290498
FAP YOU STUPID HORSE.

Goddamn homos letting us get rutted by another stallion. ~unf~

Early bump for gay porn

>>25293049

>>25290498
>try to say something
>only thing that comes out of mouth is moans
>succubus takes over guard ponies mind
>guard pone rapes praline
>rape end

I say, good cyoa

File: 90.png (246KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

246KB, 640x600px

>>25290521
>>25290523
>>25290529
>>25290536
>>25290593
>>25290609
>>25290654
>>25290686
>>25290704
>>25291247
>>25291412

"Help!" Emerald says through his moans, "A witch is controlling Giles!"

A few things happen at once. Emerald disentangles himself from Giles, the soldier turns back and calls orders to something Emerald can't see, and there is an explosion of purple from Stargazer.

Then the Bat Creature rears up out of the fog, the soldier says, "Run, quickly child!" and Emerald attempts to do so before turning back and worrying about Giles. Luckily he is following behind him, still looking dazed, and when he gets close he attempts to mount Emerald again.

Emerald just steps out of his way, and the brown pony simply walks slightly forward and tries again. Well it's not ideal, but at least he is following.

Emerald runs out the door, Giles trotting purposefully after him and the transformed Stargazer reaching the door and letting out a loud roar. Outside the barn are a multitude of soldiers, all armed and standing at the ready.

"Out of here, children! Quick, to the main house!"

Praline and Emerald don't need to be told again, and leave the battle behind. As they rush to the house, Emerald stops short, causing Praline to run just slightly ahead and say, "W-what's wrong?"

There are soldiers standing guard outside the house. Emerald didn't realize it until now but the soldiers are wearing very familiar looking armor.

What does Emerald do?

>>25295338
Maybe try to sneak away for a sec, send a letter to joy to tell her about the situation, then pray that she makes it there in time

>>25295338
It's night right? They're preoccupied by the fight and they won't be able to tell who we are in the shadows as long as we throw down the necklace.

>>25295338
Should probably do something about Giles before trying to enter the house. Not sure what though, kinda awkward with Praline there.

>>25295612
I would first explain to Praline that Giles is being controlled by the bat monster, then try to suck him off. its the most non-commital way to get him to stop attacking us if he's been order to fuck us.

>>25295729
There's also the matter of our recently maxed out frustration.
I guess we could try telling her to go on ahead without us so we can take care of something, and see if she actually complies.

>>25295838
>rape

>>25295338
Tell her we need to find a way to free Giles. Also ask where all of these guards came from and how they got here so quickly.

>>25295974
Offering up our sweet sweet boypussy certainily sounds like the best idea right now.

>bump

>>25290498
I, uh... I need more of this.

File: 91_Censor.png (156KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

156KB, 640x600px

>>25295612
>>25295729
>>25295838
>>25295974
>>25296005
>>25296758

Emerald hears some shuffling from behind, and turns to see Giles trying to mount him again. Holding Giles back Emerald wonders what he is going to do with him. They can't go into the house like this, and Emerald isn't sure he wants to go into the house with soldiers around it at all. How can they make it so Giles will stop?

>Frustration is 100/100!

>Willpower Test
>Rolled 5, failed

"Erm, Praline, go on ahead without me. I'm going to do something about Giles before we go up." Emerald sees, dancing around the brown pony as he attempts to hop on him."

Even in the darkness Emerald can see the blush that comes over her face, and she says, "A-are you going to...? I err... Y-yeah of course I'm just going to... U-um!" and without another word runs up to the house.

Emerald leads Giles away from the fighting noises and from the house, and when he thinks they are far enough away he presents himself to Giles.

http://imgur.com/lZxD2qM

Barely a second after Emerald's climax finishes Giles dead weights upon the young colt. Struggling out from underneath him Emerald checks on Giles. He seems to be okay, just passed out.

Well, that's one problem solved.

What does Emerald do?

>>25296948
Scuff that cum around in the dirt. Wouldn't want any witches or succubi being able to use it.

How much time has passed since we made the bet with Stargazer? Does it really count if Giles was the one to make us cum?

>>25297088
Our bet was that she couldn't make us cum. I wouldn't count it.

>>25296948
Maybe now we should try and see if we can break his mind-control by putting our pendent on him.
It'll just teleport back to us, but it might be enough to break the spell.

Don't feel right to just leave him lying there, but I don't see how we can carry him away.
Maybe we should run back to the house, tell them were Giles is so they can get him, grab our stuff and get ready to bolt out of here.
Maybe try to get to that inn or pub or whatever it was that Joy told us to meet up if we didn't wait on the farm.

>>25296948
Either stargazer just beat us or we just got another orb.
Unsure which.

>>25296948
We need to leave him somewhere he can be found by the family, but not the succubus should she win.

>>25297269
Emerald climaxed, I don't think Giles did.

>>25297269
The two aren't mutually exclusive.

>>25297254
The magic seems to be specifically bound to us, so I don't know if it'll work. If there were ever a time to test this theory though, now's probably a good time since we won't get killed if it fails.
Or he could just simply be passed out without having anything to do with magic since he fulfilled his task, and will just wake up normally later. Which would mean we still wouldn't know if it works.

>>25297453
If he passed out normally we should try to wake him up. Give him a shake, a few slaps etc.

>>25296948
Spit in his mouth

>>25297595
What?

>>25297595
You can't catch us, horny gay thoughts!

Lets just wake him up and see how he's doing.

File: 92.png (173KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

173KB, 640x600px

>>25296980
>>25297546
>>25297693

Emerald looks at the small strands of his juices on the ground and quickly scuffs them into the dirt.

He then goes over to Giles and attempts to wake him. He calls his name a few times, and gives him a few pokes and prods, getting progressively stronger until he gives him a solid punch.

>Body Check
>Rolled 4, failed.

He doesn't respond. Giles doesn't seem to be waking up anytime soon. In fact, he seems to be rather comfortable if his snoring is any indication.

What does Emerald do?

>>25298024
Try to drag him back to the house. If we're not strong enough, then we grab Praline and ask for her help.

>>25298024
attempt to drag him near the house? hide in the bushes and see what the soldiers are doing and try to overhear what they're talking about.

>>25298062
Pretty much this

>>25298024
Check ring.

>>25298024
Give him a kiss

>>25298024
Push the box further into the f- oh wait that was a while ago.

>>25298024
frustration is still 100. suck him hard and ride him.

>>25298839
No it isn't.

Why is emerald such a little faggot?

>>25298957
Because being a faggot is so much fun.

>>25298957
What are are ya, Dr. Seuss?

A faggot is, is a faggot no matter how small

>>25298024
If we can pick him up we can carry him into the house and use him as a cover from the guard pones.

>>25298860
i see no change in it.

>>25298957
Well that's not very nice. I'm sure we'll get taller eventually.

>>25299060
>Barely a second after Emerald's climax finishes Giles dead weights upon the young colt. Struggling out from underneath him Emerald checks on Giles. He seems to be okay, just passed out.
QM probably just forgot to give us the new value.

>>25299060
The frustration was last shown before sex.

>>25299086
still makes it 100

>>25299385
No. It means the QM forgot to give us the new value. If a game glitches and a value changes but it's not reflected on screen the value isn't what's shown on screen.

>>25299385
>being this autistic.

>>25299385
cumming resets it to zero, how you don't know that is beyond me.

Get the fuck outta there, make sure you can see it but they cannot see you

>>25299423
last time it went to 30.

beb

>>25300349
sleep

Early bump for sleep rape

File: 93.png (115KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

115KB, 640x600px

>>25298062
>>25298071
>>25298073
>>25298212
>>25299010

>Frustration is now 25/100!

Emerald tries to lift the passed out stallion but he simply isn't strong enough, instead he drags, pulls, and pushes Giles the best he can until he gets close enough to the house to call for help. Two guard ponies come, and while one lifts the unconscious brown pony the other ushers you into the house.

Inside you see Praline laying on the floor near where the two of you had practiced writing, she looks asleep, and her mother is petting her softly. The grandma is sitting at the table, and is eyeing the young colt.

"Giles!" Sweet Tea gasps as she sees him unconscious on the soldiers back.

"Don't worry!" Emerald says quickly, "Just passed out the... The thing in the barn got him, but he's fine!"

"Emerald, what happened? Praline was incredibly upset. All I managed to get was that there was a monster in the barn... I'm so glad to see the three of you safe!"

Emerald explains what happened, obviously leaving any mention of rutting out of the conversation.

"Lucky those soldiers were here." The grandma pipes up, nodding to them, who nod back.

Sweet Tea goes to her angrily and says, "Don't try to spin this around, it's not like you knew some monster would come attack us! I'm still angry at you for bringing the soldiers here!"

"You saw the wanted poster to Sweet Tea! Whatever this child did made him worth a wagon load of money."

"He's a sweet child, if you only got to know him."

The arguing continues. So the Grandma brought the soldiers here! Perhaps that's where she went on her walk? Emerald looks around. The only exit is covered by two guard ponies, and Emerald can see more outside. Through some of the windows he can still hear the sounds of the battle.

What does Emerald do?

>>25301604
Tell the the reason behind the money.

Ask where the bathroom is. Get the hell out of there after going to the restroom.

>>25301604
He writes a letter to joyride and tell her that she needs to get her ass over here right fucking now and explains what's going on.

Anyway that "wanted" poster is because of your evil step parents. They're evil because of this -point at ball clamp-
you ran away from home because you were a sex toy who got daily ass and throat rapes. Old bitch.

>>25301604
"Excuse me, must go to little colt's room."

Grab bag, cheese it out window. Quietly.

>>25301640
>>25301648
I really doubt they're that stupid.

>>25301604
Explain why you're wanted. Show them the ring.

>>25301604
If you really want to know why I'm valuable its because Sex Slaves are hard to come by, I assume.

I was trying to escape that life, but if money means that much to you I guess you should let them take me.

We're pretty screwed anyway, but I want to twist the screws on this old hag.

>>25301604
Yes, send us back to the ponies that put a ball clamp on us. I'm certain you can come up with a reason it's fine to put one of those on a child.

So much for drawing emerald getting the cock from Giles. Shit

I can't believe I'm back to hoping the succubus wins and kills everyone.

>>25301764
You should still do that.

>>25301604

>>25301732
>>25301740
this, if we can garner sympathy, we may be able to get to that town Joy is in, by way of cart rather than by hoof.

>implying the old mare would even care and doesn't just see the bits.

I bet Giles is going to do a 180, realize he's in love with us and try (in vain) to rescue us.

File: 94.png (90KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

90KB, 640x600px

>>25301633
>>25301644
>>25301682
>>25301732
>>25301740
>>25301790

Emerald turns defiantly to the Grandmother and stares her directly into her eyes. She stares back haughtily.

Emerald explains that his step-parents were horrible people, and that they put a ball clamp on him (which is proceeds to show). They only want him back presumably because they want to continue what they were doing before. If she wants to send them back to that it's on her conscience.

The Grandma shrugs and says, "I don't care. And even if I did it's too late now. The soldiers are here and we don't have any way of stopping them from taking you. All we can do is collect the reward."

This causes Sweet Tea to stare at the grandma and start arguing again.

While this is going on, Emerald strides over to his backpack and pulls out his dragonfire lantern. He scrawls out a note to Joyride about the situation and sends it quickly. The light of the flame draws the attention of everyone in the room, and one of the guards hurries over to Emerald.

"What was in that note, Emerald?"

Just as the pony gets those words out however a small slip of paper coalesces out of ash in the air and lands near Emerald. Emerald snatches it up quickly and reads it, and though it is quickly pulled from his hooves by the soldier Emerald saw the letters clearly.

---

Be there soon. Just hang on a little longer.

---

"Tell the other soldiers to be vigilant. Emerald, you will tell me who you sent a note to now." The soldier says upon reading the note.

What does Emerald do?

>>25302164
Someone even worse than that succubus killing your pals.

>>25302164
The pony that caught the succubus those idiots released

STALL FOR TIME.
Tell our whole story (except for the bits that get our allies in trouble) and embellish every detail, tell every tiny thing, and make sure that it takes a LONG time.

>>25302198
This but be vague about the friendly ponies.

>>25302164
I told you she was an old bitch.

tell the soldier that you don't know. Just that if you were ever in trouble to write a letter to PP. you don't know who they are or what they can do.

>>25302164
Emerald puts his hoof down

If any of these soldiers can have something its common sense.

Emerald tells him what his step parents would do to him.

>>25302198
This. Exaggerate the mistreatment and abuse you received.

>>25302198
>>25302395
Are we stalling for time? Aren't they already there until until the succubus doesn't gets beat?

>>25302416
The guardspony is already here and we don't want to get taken in custody.

>>25302427
... that doesn't answer the question.

>>25302444
Basically we need to keep the guard from, for example, handcuffing us or pinning us down.Stalling by telling our story will keep us in a position to run.

>>25302416
We're trying to keep them here at the farm long enough for Joyride to come rescue us.

>>25302452
As long as we don't look like we're going to run he's equally unlikely to handcuff us or pin us down.

>>25302467
>Aren't they already there until the succubus doesn't gets beat?

>>25302483
>Aren't they already there until the succubus gets beat?
There's a risk that a couple of guards will escort us away while the rest deal with Stargazer.

>>25302452
Heaven help you guys. Exposition does no good here. Appealing to "their good nature" is useless. We need to play this like poker. We sent a letter to our secret griffon general lover who is on their way with a contingent of highly trained warriors to retrieve emerald. Maybe get a dex roll for a poker face. Traps are good at looking malicious.

>>25302515
>Appealing to "their good nature" is useless.
You lost me. This is a PONY cyoa, remember?

>>25302503
I doubt telling our story to this guy will cause them to change their mind.

>>25302515
This sounds like a fun alternative though.

>>25302515
That makes them more likely to run off with us.

>>25302614
It's not about changing their minds, it's about slowing them down.

And if even a single guard sympathizes with us it could pay off later.

>>25302515
>We sent a letter to our secret griffon general lover who is on their way with a contingent of highly trained warriors to retrieve emerald
Wow, are you trying to make them run away with us?

>>25302630
Add the amulet is a homing beacon

>>25302164
"i'm the one that gives orders around here."

>>25302660
Ah, I misspoke. I doubt telling our story would slow them down if one of them walked in and said 'time to go'.

>>25302630
But if they panic, Emerald may be able to slip away in the confusion.
>>25302587
Yes a pony CYOA with ass fucking, Succubi and horrible parents who put ball clamps on their children. If you're trying to say the ponies have good natures here then you have to be baiting like a motherfucker

okay, the grandma doesn't care, i get that.

Why doesn't the guard care about the ball clamp?

>>25302693
Because they had ponies like cloak and dagger on the payroll.

>>25302164
Tell them we're bringing a dragon then proceed to speak in the dragon language to scare the shit out of them.

>>25302660
Keep this in mind
"Be there soon."
If this story works, and he believes griffins are coming(from the air of course) ,how far does a soldier like this pony think he'll get with some of his troops fighting off some demon, and griffin soldiers coming? He's gonna panic for sure. The granny will definitely freak out at the thought of being caught up in a battle and not collecting her dosh. It's pure chaos. Surely if Emerald gets away he can meet up with Joyride before she possibly gets captured.

>>25302753
This is not a fucking sitcom. Keep our stories simple. Stick to the truth if we can.

>>25302753
>trained soldiers panicking because a kid says his super strong secret boyfriend is coming

>>25302738
That was a bounty hunter, that makes sense.

But these are presumably just regular old eastern kingdom lawponies. Our parents are wealthy but do they own the entire guard force? They've paid off every guard to the point that they're all complacent to childrape?

>>25302791
This. No matter how bad you think people are, you can't expect the average pony to think that childrape and such to be okay.

>>25302791
This.

The idea every guard knows about emerald being raped is so low it's laughable.

Also did we get another orb from indulging in faggotry with Giles? The QM never told us.

>>25302791
>They've paid off every guard to the point where they're unlikely to believe a kid's story
Presumably.

>>25302833
Then why do they even care we ran? save the money grabbing random foals off the street because the guard apparently will never prosecute them.

>>25302818
Read my fucking mind.

>>25302843
You're assuming the reason they want Emerald is just to rape him some more.

>>25302778
>>25302765
Are you serious? Tell the soldier we have someone coming to rescue us? That's retarded as fuck. Also what implications were there that this is a "Seasoned soldier"? We just know they're soldiers. And fucks sake have a sense of adventure you prude fags

>>25302791
Yes, how are you not understanding that? Everyone that wears a uniform is our enemy. NO exceptions.

>>25302903
No.

>>25302903
Adventure =/= Saying stupid shit just to see if it works out.

File: 95.png (158KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

158KB, 640x600px

>>25302190
>>25302197
>>25302198
>>25302209
>>25302210
>>25302229
>>25302395
>>25302416
>>25302427
>>25302452
>>25302467
>>25302483
>>25302503
>>25302515
>>25302693
>>25302752
>>25302753

(G'night!)

Emerald says it was a very powerful ally and their friends, who will be here soon to rescue them. Emerald quickly adds that it's a terrifyingly strong Gryphon as well as the dragon who gave him this fire.

"Hmph, we can handle it." The soldier says. He probably doesn't believe Emerald, but the colt thinks that he isn't willing to completely disregard what he said just in case.

At this second another soldier bursts through the door, panting.

"Sir! We have won the battle."

"Any casualties?"

"That creature was truly a beast sir, a majority of us are injured and a few killed. We are sorting it out now. We aren't completely sure because in the end we had to push the monster into the barn and torch it."

"What?!" Sweet Tea says springing up and looking at a window. Emerald can't see the window from where he is standing, but the look on the mare's face plus the light illuminating it tells him that it's true.

"No matter, with the money we get from the reward we could buy several barns!" The Grandma says,not even looking.

"Alright." The leader says, "We might have more company, get the injured teleported away and gather everyone who is still able to fight and tell them to get ready. We need to move."

Uh oh, they might get you away before Joyride can come.

What does Emerald do?

>>25302864
What other reason is there? Emerald isn't royalty.

They either want to rape him or they want to cover up what they did, but if the guard is in on it then they have no need to cover it up.

>>25302912
That's retarded even as a story convention.

>>25302947
>Unfounded assumptions: The post

>>25302927
So going into detail about a ball clamp isn't fucking dumb when the question is "who did you write to?" Holy shit. You are b8ing. I seriously can't even right now

>>25302947
to bad it's a fact.

>>25302955
>i assume there's another reason and i never have to present it because i actually have no fucking idea
Cool you're a moron.

I propose we just do the pony equivalent of flipping off the Grandma. What a fucking bitch.

>>25302937
Does this place have stairs? Time to run up them if so. Get to a room with a window, close and lock the door, open the window and try to get down without killing ourselves.

>>25302937
Find a distraction, run, hide. We just have to stall for time until the Calvary comes in.

>>25302974
>Y-you're stupid! There can't be another reason we don't know yet! I-I'm right!
Wew lad.

>>25302937
Run up stairs.

>Judge Dredd archetype guard would help us because kidnapping and child rape is against the LAAAAW
>Heroic "protecting the citizens" archetype guard would help us because it's the right thing to do
There's no reason not to tell them. We can't assume all guards are evil or corrupt.

Also, even if Joyride doesn't rescue us, don't forget that we're in the Witherwaters Kingdom. Our old home is in the Middle Kingdom. These guards don't work for our abusive family, and even if they capture us we probably won't be extradited straight away.
In fact, if we're cunning, we might be able to convince a Witherwater noble to use as a bargaining chip or political pawn. That wouldn't be ideal, but it could prevent the worst case scenario of us returning to our abusers.

>>25302833
We've got a ball clamp as evidence.

>>25302937
Tell the grandma she's an idiot and isn't going to get paid shit. What part of "BAD ponies" didn't you understand? You's got played!

anyway run away into any room and lock the door behind you. get out the window!

>>25302994
>Still got nothing
:^)

You have to have a rationale to back motivation 'what if its something else' is infantile.

>>25302937
>>25302515
>Emerald says it was a very powerful ally and their friends, who will be here soon to rescue them. Emerald quickly adds that it's a terrifyingly strong Gryphon as well as the dragon who gave him this fire.
>"Alright." The leader says, "We might have more company, get the injured teleported away and gather everyone who is still able to fight and tell them to get ready. We need to move."
Nice going, dipshit. Now they're ready for a fight and prepared to run away, just like we warned you they would.

>>25303022
>It's this!
>What's the proof?
>It just is!
>But it could be something else.
>No, it is!
Wew, just going to keep going aren't ya?

We should also tell the solider that she's still not dead.

>>25303035
Yup. Ya dun goofed.

>>25303035
>Now they're exactly as prepared as they were going to be anyway
I'm sure that guy really regrets his post.

>>25303055
>Lets get a glass of milk
>Assuming its not poisoned
>You're retarded
:^)

>>25303082
Well they know a possible threat may becoming, so any stalling for time would not work anymore.

>>25303082
Our efforts should have been to make them less prepared, not more prepared.

File: image.jpg (19KB, 230x180px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

19KB, 230x180px

>>25303035
>disregarding the fact Emerald also mentioned a dragon
>pic related
To be honest family, my work here is done. Enjoy your hopeless situation

>>25303022
The assertion of proving it's true is on you isn't it? What proof do you have that they exclusively want Emerald just to keep raping him or whatever?

>>25303111
>To be honest family, my work here is done. Enjoy your hopeless situation
So you were only pretending to be retarded?

>>25303082
>argued for a post that achieved nothing
>was told it would achieve nothing

Why do porn quests get the most arguments out of any quest type?

>>25303172
The massive divide between lewdfags and strategy fags, honestly. Half the people want to run headfirst into every cunt and cock while the other half want to be as succesful as possible with a side of lewds.

>>25303172
Because people people care more about fapping than about characters or story.

>>25303189
>implying
This isn't even a lewd vs strategy debate.
There's no lewd to be had here.

>>25303207
Its nicer than the truth which is that the divide is between shitposters and storyfags.

>>25303189
Lewd vs strategy hasn't been most of the divides. It's mostly been strategy vs strategy. Just stupid arguments that are stupid on both sides. And a lot less willingness to compromise Maybe it's the way the QM structures the decision points in this quest.

Wow with how often we're having to explain our life story to people we should really pre write it on some flash cards or something. It'd really expediate the process.

Tell granny to fuck herself, book it, hide.

>>25303055
I am completely convinced they want him back for a reason that isn't the obvious one and Emerald, the very fucking pony they want back, has no clue why they want him back.
Sarcasm self-test complete.
Furthermore you're a damn hypocrite. Emeralds entire backstory is plentiful reason to believe they want him back so they can continue what they were doing, meanwhile YOU are the one with no proof to back up what you believe. Nothing as of yet has even implied they have another reason.

>>25302937
Wait, see if they try anything, no reason to get them uppity. If they do anything even slightly threatening, book it. If there are stairs, ignore them, height isn't going to do anything for us. Head for room on the side of the house you believe has the least soldiers. Lock door. Be prepared to dive out window and run.

Oh yeah and don't do anything to the grandma, no reason to give anyone there a reason to doubt your sweetness either.

>>25304826
>Assumes we know all that Emerald knows
>Assumes getting a little rape colt back is with all the money and effort they're putting into it.
>Assumes the reason they want him back that's never been stated.
Going all out aren'tcha? Might want to come back when you have something backing you up.

>>25302937
we should ask where we're going and why. ask what it takes to wear that armor. having honor is obviously not a qualification.

File: 1445140961832.png (43KB, 311x364px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

43KB, 311x364px

Gotta love the bickering in CYOA threads

>>25302937
Perhaps we should try and survey the area. Excuse yourself to the bathroom, try to find an opening in the guards' ranks and make our escape through a window.

But doing that means we'd have to leave our shit behind, otherwise it'd be real suspicious. Where did we dump that box? There's another guy inside there, perhaps we can get him out and use him as a distraction for the guards

>>25303122
Emeralds own thoughts on the matter and Occam's razor. When presented with two choices where we cant fully establish the facts you pick one based on the least amount of baseless speculation.

And given that your entire position is baseless speculation that there must be some unknown motivation that you cannot even conceive of, then you lose by default. You do not make a decision by pretending that every conceivable possibility is equally likely, you have to give a reason why your 'but what if' should be entertained.

All this arguing
I propose we become max-submissive to the grandma, let ourselves be taken away in the name of giving her a free payday, bad end, and cut the bickering bullshit.

Did we even get another light from Giles? Doesn't seem like he finished.

File: 96.png (143KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

143KB, 640x600px

>>25302979
>>25302983
>>25303001
>>25303021
>>25304611
>>25305091

While the soldiers are distracted Emerald rushes up the staircase. He can see three rooms up here, and he ducks into the nearest one, slamming the door behind him and blocking it with a nearby chair.

The room is rather bare save for a window, a chest, a nightstand, and a bed. Above the bed are drawings that appear to be a tree, Giles, and a pony.

If Emerald had to guess, this is probably Praline's room.

There is a shuttering of the doorknob and then three loud knocks that make the colt jump.

"Emerald! You get out of there this instant!" the soldier says sternly.

When this is met with silence there are a few more knocks, a couple more jiggles of the doorknob, and then he says, "If you aren't out of there by the time we are ready to move I'm breaking down this door and taking you. You, stand here and wait for him to come out."

There is then the sounds of hoof pounding down stairs.

What does Emerald do?

>>25305998
Check the window. Can we get out of it.

>>25305998
Tie bed sheets together and climb down. You just need two sheets. You will be fine with a small drop.

>>25305998
>>25306274
>try to climb out window
>slip and fall
>break neck
>death end

File: 97.png (186KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

186KB, 640x600px

>>25306122
>>25306274
>>25306326

Emerald checks the window, and seeing that it can open steps out onto what appears to be the porch overhang.

He gets the idea of maybe tying together the bed sheets and slipping down, but as he moves back towards Praline's room he hears voices from below his hooves.

"Hey, do you think what the kid said was true?" One deep, male voice says.

"What do you mean?" a different one says.

"Didn't you hear them from inside? Do you think the Jewels are... You know, doing stuff to the boy?"

"How should I know? It's not like it's our business either way."

"Yeah but-"

"Look, I'd rather be here chasing some kid around with the promise of a huge reward than be sent out west. Quit talking about it, you are going to get us in trouble."

After that there is silence. While he isn't sure exactly where the ponies are, Emerald is sure he couldn't climb down from this area without the ponies seeing.

What does Emerald do?

>>25306490
Go in the other window.

>>25306490
Maybe scurry around and try to find a safe spot?

Try climbing on the roof?

Try a different window, climb into another room?

find mom? She seems to like us.

>>25306490
throw something, make a noise and try to lure the guards away

>>25306490
>>25306705
i vote for this. also would give time to carefully climb down.

captcha is mountains, so head for the mountains afterwards.

>>25306490
Try another window.

>>25306490

How about we make it look like we actually escaped (aka having the sheets fashioned into a line from the window to the ground) but we don't try to escape... we hide in that huge chest and let the soldiers think we clearly escaped?

Might be a bit too simple though, i guess..

>>25307514
The ones below us will see the sheets.

>>25307564
Then distract them by throwing something in the bushes, then throw the rope of sheets down while they investigate?

File: 98.png (129KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

129KB, 640x600px

>>25306544
>>25306693
>>25307281
>>25307514

Emerald gets an idea. If he can make it appear he ran away he might be able to buy himself the time he needed.

Checking to see if one of the other windows was open first, he goes to Praline's bed, ties the sheets together to form a rope, and then very carefully lowers over the side of the overhang, hoping he won't attract the attention of any of the guards since it's much less noisy than him climbing down. Emerald gets it down successfully and then heads to the other window and goes inside.

The inside of this room is similarly sparse, containing only a dresser, and desk, and a bed. On the desk is a photo of Sweet Tea, Giles, and a third pony Emerald doesn't recognize. Perhaps a father?

What does Emerald do?

>>25307851
Hide under the bed and check in the box.

>>25307851
Look through the dresser for clothes (assuming this is Giles room). Also, what's in that suitcase under the bed? Maybe check some drawers.
Besides that I guess wait until they realize your decoy.

>>25307851
Under bed, and check the chest

>>25307851
Pass time by searching room for items like a jrpg protagonist.

>>25307851
What's in that box under the bed? I need to know.

>>25308092
Probably porn of stallions.

File: 99.png (125KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

125KB, 640x600px

>>25307879
>>25307997
>>25308042
>>25308092
>>25308171

Emerald has some time to kill, and so proceeds to quietly look around the room.

Emerald opens the drawers and finds piles of bandannas. This must be Giles room. Emerald toys with the idea of taking one, perhaps he could use it to cover his pendant, or even to keep the hair out of his eyes... But he shouldn't right? It's not right to steal...

After looking a bit more, Emerald finds a small box underneath Giles bed. Inside are some magazines and...

Oh dear... Giles really needs to be honest with himself.

>Frustration increases to 30/100!

Emerald hears some knocking, and quickly scrambles under the bed before realizing that it wasn't coming from his door.

Through the walls Emerald can hear a muffled, "I'm coming in you brat! You better be ready to go!"

There is a large slamming sound and a crack, followed by some stomping around. Then Emerald hears the soldier say, "He's escaped! Quick, gather the remaining guards and start a search! Do we have any pegasi left? Get them in the air!"

The soldier continues to bark out orders, and Emerald breathes a sigh of relief. For now at least, the trick seems to have worked.

What does Emerald do?

>>25308412
Is that fucking Aaron?

>>25308412
We're pretty much fucked, outside's gonna be swarming with guards. Let's just hope they don't decide to do a sweep of the house.

>>25308412
Return Giles' (or Sweet Tea's) porn, and search for more useful items.

>>25308465
I don't know, if someone finds emerald scavenging around they might think he's a thief

>>25308412
Giles owes you a bandana at the very least. He did get to have his way with you.

>>25308485
We don't have to raid the room for valuables, just something we can use to escape if the guard or grandma show up.

>>25308412
Look out a window to see which direction most of them are headed. Then hide in the closet since they have no reason to think that you're still there. Just need to keep waiting for joy, possibly write another note.

>>25308488
If anything we owe Giles a bandanna considering we got off and he didn't.

>>25308506
Saved him from the succubi woman tho

>>25308520
>>25308506
>>25308488
I don't think it even really counts for Giles as he wasn't in a position to enjoy himself.
We can help him with that later.

>>25304856
If Emerald knew another reason he would have brought it up at some point, you moron, and once again, you're the only one here with nothing backing you up.

>>25308776
So far all he's ever stated is his sob story to get sympathy, he's never given a reason why they're chasing him.
>I've still got nothing, but I can rely on insults!

>>25308800
While it is technically possible a fate other than rape and a living death awaits Emerald should he be captured, we have no reason to believe such.

File: AaronStaticBattle.png (2KB, 126x208px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

2KB, 126x208px

>>25308412
Nice.

>>25308800
That is the reason they're chasing him you dense little shit.

>>25308820
Sure. That's certainly a good explanation as to why he's running away. But that's, again, not a good explanation for why they're chasing him. The amount of resources being expended doesn't follow that they want him back /just/ to rape him and such. They could get some other little colt off the street if that's the only reason they care about him.

>>25308853
>If I keep saying it's true it'll be true!

>>25308893
This is a fair point, but again, I cannot in good consciousness recommend Emerald go back to them.
It's entirely possible they want him, specifically, for kink reasons (like they're into incest, or grooming), or for some horrible yet-unrevealed thing (they need a traumatized colt soul to do some evil magic bullshit or something).

>>25308893
The amount of hypocrisy that spews out of your mouth is disgusting.
All your shitty greentext applies to you and you alone.
You are the one with nothing to back up your claim.
You are the one that keeps insisting you're right with nothing to back it up.
Your resource argument is terrible as well. The Jewel family obviously has more money, power, and influence than they know what to do with. They have no reason to be concerned about resources. Plus just letting Emerald go free could easily bite them in the ass, and it's much easier to keep what they're doing secret if it's their own son and not some random colt they kidnap.

>>25308985
Oh, I've never said for Emerald to go back to them. Only that we probably don't know the central reason that they're chasing him, which Emerald may or may not know.

It could be as simple as the new step-mother hated the deceased actual mother with a fiery passion, takes that out on him, and is willing to move the heavens to make his life hell. But it's unlikely to be as simple as the mouthbreather keeps insisting against the evidence.

>>25309032
The non-existent evidence that you don't have.

>>25309032
The thing is all the evidence we have points to >don't ever go back to them holy shit.
We really only have
>they did horrible evil shit to Emerald
>they are trying very hard to get Emerald back
It doesn't paint a pretty picture.

But yeah, this arguing you're in with the other guy is dumb.
Dismiss his next post with a single word after not reading it. That's how I get out of stupid shit like this.

>>25309059
Exactly my point. And yeah, I'm done with him. He's never brought up anything useful so it's time to let the thread get back into a better mood.

File: bandana610.jpg (33KB, 610x343px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

33KB, 610x343px

>>25308412
Take that fucking bandana. It's time.

>>25309082
>makes claim with no evidence to back it up
>other guy gives plenty of evidence along with using logic to prove how stupid you are
>ignores evidence and continues claiming you're the one with evidence
>you have no evidence
>you never had evidence
>you're never going to have evidence
>you're wrong
>give up but try to make it look like you won
>Intelligence Check
>Rolled 1, failed

>>25309172
>maymay arrows

>>25309082
Holy shit, you actually think you won that didn't you.

I just remembered that both of his legal guardians are step-parents. Would that mean that Emerald the legitimate heir to the Jewel family and both of them just married into it? This could hint at some kind of murder plot.

>>25309354
They had all the time in the world to murder him during the raping, it's clearly not their priority.

>>25309382
I'm talking about in the past back when both his parents were still around.

>>25309354
Seems less likely to be a murder plot as much as they're the stewards while he's underage. A vanished or dead heir could result in the next in line, which could be an adult, coming into power and removing them. Just speculation of course.

>>25309354
The step-dad could be the Jewel family part though.

>>25309433
>>25309450
If his parents were the Jewel family then if one of them die then a step-parent can come in. If the other one dies then the first step-parent would become steward and the second step-parent can come in. If everything was left to Emerald than they could raise him as a slave while they control everything. When he's old enough they could either control everything through him or have him give them everything. That could explain why they're trying so hard to get him back.

>>25308412
Take one (1) bandanna. It's not like they're anything more than fashion statements and we can get some legitimate use out of it.
Plus it might smell like Giles.

>>25309492
If.

We don't know who the Jewel family is, it could be step-mom married into it. The jewel family crest is a unicorn after all.

>>25309520
I know this is all speculation, but it is interesting and gives us a reason to go through the trouble of seeking revenge.

>>25309492
If that was the case wouldn't all these guards be technically loyal to Emerald first? The Stewards are just Stewards, there would be talk about a runaway lord not just some boy.

>>25309563
Not necessarily. They follow orders and the orders come from the steward(s). Or they follow who pays their paycheck. Or they think he's just a runaway and it's for the good of the house to get him back. There's various rationale for the guards to follow orders.

>>25309608
Of course, the primary reasons is
>we need bad guys and pursuers

Is Emerald bisexual? What happens that Emerald gets an increase in frustration for both guys and girls? Also does Emerald have a sexual preference? Outside of a frustration level of 100, which gender would he sleep with?

>>25309833
Emerald is whatever we want him to be.

>>25309833
That's all up to us.
He takes no action the players do not decide upon.

>>25309833
Honestly the sexual abuse he's gone through likely warped his sexuality bad enough to make that question null and void.

>>25309833
He's been turned on by both without fucking, so presumably he thinks both sexes are sexually attractive.

Player wise we have a large group of players that want to impregnate Hope and a large group that wanted to be fucked by Giles, so the players seem to be hitting bisexual square on the head.

>>25309889
>impregnate Hope

What exactly sparked this? Also, I haven't heard from their particular group lately. What exactly is the significance of knocking up Hope?

>>25309917
>Not wanting to cum inside your mare and have her carry your foal

We're all just focused on getting the ring off first, i don't care how many cocks we gargle to get it done as long as we get to plow hope before the end.

>>25309852
>>25309855
So does that mean all they gays in here want to see Emerald get abused and all the strict people want to have a bad end where Emerald dies?

>>25309917
Presumably someone said it and then a few others nodded along, liking the idea. I don't think anything in the ques itself really sparked it.

It wouldn't really come up much until the ring is off.

>>25309917
It's just kinda kinky for a grown woman to carry a small boy's baby.

>>25309933
No. It means if we want to fuck the pony then so does Emerald, regardless of gender.

>>25309833
The answer is that it doesn't matter. Whoever wants to fuck him can since he's a sex toy.

>>25309932
>ends justify the means

Why not have sex with more mares/fillies at least? Hell, if Emerald has repressed his sexual maliciousness as much as he supposedly has, her should be rutting with every young filly that winks for him.

With the ring, he'd be able to last long enough to make them cum. So why not? He can have an orgy, or at least get with two other fillies because that's be all he needs to light the ring and take it off.

>>25309933
I don't want Emerald to get sent back to his abusive parents. Though it'd be a waste if a cute trap colt doesn't gargle some dick here and there willingly.

>>25308412
Stop being such a faggot and steal already. You've already done worse to the family; the loss of some clothing isn't going to matter. We ran away for us, and we need to do everything we can to stay a run away.
Take some clothes, disguise yourself, and observe what the guards are doing from the window. Hopefully they don't sweep the inside of the house.

>>25309917
>>25309934
I said it jokingly as a reason to get the ball clamp off, so we could cum. It wasn't exactly a major goal for me specifically.

>>25309917
It was mentioned and found to be and agreeable long term goal. Hope needs to be punished for being a naughty mare. Punished with Em's donger.

>>25309970
That's a painful experience that leaves frustration high.

>>25309939
Isn't it normal enough? Evolution says she should want his young seed, and he'd live long enough to look after the foal.

What is Hope is actually evil?

>>25309970
Both painful and lack of opportunity unless we're going to rape. There was quite a bit of discussion of fucking the mother but an opportunity didn't come up.

>>25309987
Did you even read the orgy or three some part?

Fuck if Emerald really wanted the ring off, he'd be able to do it way faster. He could give stallions hoof jobs in a bathroom if the was desperate.

But still, it would need be hard to satisfy nearly any heterosexual mare or filly because of Emerald's stamina now involuntarily infinite.

>>25309970
OP has railroaded it to be a more homo quest by making the magic ball clamp not work on taking it up the bum.

Obviously this was his plan to keep us from rutting mares.

>>25310005
Because the QM is a faggot and didn't give us the option.

Maybe he can make up for it now that Emerald needs to be hidden in the house....

It's pretty sexy if all the mares in this story turn out to be colt cuddles.

>>25310023
A threesome is an unlikely scenario and we've generally lacked opportunity for anything you've mentioned so far. Do you remember what Joy was saying about what we could do once we got to town?

>>25310036
My hope is that Giles comes up to his room, we apologize and call out his colt cuddling, the sister comes into the room to investigate the aggressive humping and we make an incest sandwich.

>>25310028
Are you the same person who keeps bitching constantly about the gay stuff?
Like fuck dude this is the only instance of gay shit yet, the whole giles route.
If you hate it that much why stick around?

>>25310028
Fucking this.

QM clearly set this to be a homo centric story. Every attempt at hetero sex is obviously declined and meets nothing but excuses about the damn cock ring. Hurr durr, it's painful. So? He can't get fucking two mares off so he needs to jack off stallions?

Not to mention his obviously trappy persona. My money is that the straight crowd abandoned these threads long ago due to the amount of gay sex.

Even the gay sex scenes get the most splashes and detail when drawn. Fucking look back at it and prove me wrong.

>>25310045
We could fucking jack off stallions on the road! Also Praline obvious thinks Emerald is sexy (despite the fact that he looks like a faggot) so it'd be easy to get with her.

Are you retarded and just want to see this quest padded out into eternity? I swear, half these fucking posts must be from the GM because there's no way in hell this many people can be so unintentionally obtuse and vague of thought.

My money is on that the vast majority of this thread has become populated with nothing but fat homosexual men who desperately want to be sexy little traps and control Emerald accordingly.

>>25310066
This is the first time I've complained.

I don't mind it that much, but I just wanted to point out that it was obviously the OP's plan to get us to go gay when he revealed that the cockring isn't affected by butt stuff.

I stick around because I like the story and if all the straightfags leave then the gayfags win. Everytime a quests gets taken over because the Straightfags get too uncomfortable while the Gayfags bitch about oppression and shit.

>>25310067
Are you fucking retarded? How many times do I have to say this, We have had more intercourse with mares than stallions. That's an object fact.
We've had a total of one experience with a male.
With how much you're freaking out over this I have to wonder if you're being serious. if you are then holy shit just leave this CYOA obviously isn't for you so why stick around?

>>25310028
Bingo. There is no incentives for heterosexual activity. Even with mares, the QM makes it necessary to take it up the butt like a sissy bitch.

>>25310127
>t was obviously the OP's plan to get us to go gay
Even though the single first two characters we ran into were Mares who wanted to fuck us?
Yeah it certainly seems he has an agenda here.

>>25310067
We've fucked a mare and the only other opportunity was blatant rape. People have been wanting to fuck the mother since we got here.

>>25310098
Again, we have not had this opportunity. There have been no stallions on the road. People didn't want to fuck Praline because she's young and they didn't want to mess with the family. It's clearer now that she knows what we were doing with Giles, so I wouldn't be against it.

ITT: Straightfags stirring up drama again.

>>25310139
We've had sex with two mares "normally"
One of those was us getting raped, so that can't count.
One mare transformed stallion. I'd say that's gay, but I'll be kind to your side and call it even.
Then we got raped once by Giles, and then willingly fucked him.

So, being VERY generous to you it's about even.

>>25310147
We can still pleasure mares to get the ring off you dunce, we just can't orgasm if we do it. We got Hope off which counted as an orb.

File: 1330040655938.jpg (17KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

17KB, 250x250px

>>25310180
>One of those was us getting raped

>>25310187
Yes, being forced to fuck a Succubus is rape.

>>25310180
>One mare transformed stallion
She was wearing a strap on wasn't she? I thought she only transformed into a kid.
I don't know if pegging counts as gay.
>Then we got raped once by Giles
What no we didn't.
He TRIED to rape us but gave up when we cried.

>>25310187
"He's" from tumblr, they have a different standard of rape than reality. Gotta give him a little leeway while he learns to lurk moar.

>>25310172
It's all kindsa fags stirring up drama.
You morons know your arguing has no merit or value, right?

>>25310195
I'd argue we agreed to it, but I see your point.

>>25310195
>who is hope

>>25310207
I really don't understand why people are making such a big deal out of this.

>>25310207
It all started with >>25309833 and I'm pretty sure that's almost word for word the post that started drama last time.
The next time someone posts something like this everyone please just ignore it.
It's real fucking easy to see that we can't talk about sexuality without blowing the fuck up.
Christ, when did we become tumblr?

>>25310240
The gay vs straight argument brews in every quest where the MC is bi. People care a lot for some reason.

The problem is because sex isn't like a buffet. You can't have a cyoa and cater it to straights, gays, pedo, bi, scat, diaper, beast, rape fetish, etc. There needs to be a solid constant.

There is a massive fallacy that including more sexual preferences leads to a more satisfied crowd. It doesn't work that way. It ends up isolating everyone, because at the end of the day only a small percentage of people are into every sexual experience. Most humans are turned off by things that make them feel sexually uncomfortable, and since this is the same character throughout the cyoa, it should never be a surprise that as more gay events happen that more and more straights people leave. Just like if there were more and more rape events, anyone that couldn't get off to rape would leave.

This is why the gay voice is so loud itt. There isn't anything wrong with Emerald being gay. Or that this is a gay thread. Seriously. But marketing this as a true cyoa is a logical fallacy when any "hetero" version of Emerald was doomed to fail form the start. His looks, his demeanor, the fact that he can only cum from anal stim, and the fact that the QM was a primary figure in the Goldie threads (threads about gay trap horses) all point to that this quest has been railroaded from the start.

Nothing wrong with calling it as it is.

>>25310240
>>25310253
Seriously, it's classic-style trolling.
Bring up some divisive issue you *know* everyone else will argue over; killing the discussion and mood and shit.

>>25310256
It simple, really. Straightfags can't get over a MC whoa wants to take it up the ass and gayfags can't gey over the a MC who wants to hump a smelly axe gnash vagina. It's isolating and ends up pleasing nobody.

>>25310279
>tfw bifag just enjoying everything

>>25310201
I'm talking about the first mounting forced by Stargazer.

>>25310204
>>25310213
>>25310224
Ok let me spell it out clearly since you guys are too dumb to recall

>Sex with Hope +1
>Sex with Transformed Joy +0
>Rape by Coercion via Stargazer +0
>Rape by Giles under Stargazers control +0
>Sex with Giles to free him from said control -1
Where positive is Straight and negative is gay.
Transformed joy could go either way, so its a zero and non consensual encounters don't count

>>25310259
This was my point. I'll continue to vote for straight options but I know I'm likely doomed. It's ok though because gay is ok when one side is a trap :^)

>>25310168
Yet so many people wanted to have sex with the mother yet no opportunity arose, but you want to tell me exactly how many opportunities came up to have sex with Giles?

>>25310289
Bifag master race.
Seriously, we're better than you.

>>25310292
>>25310297
Stop. This discussion goes nowhere.

>>25310259
>any "hetero" version of Emerald was doomed to fail form the star
That's objectively false, we can still fuck mares to lose orbs we just can't cum.
And fuck at this point I think it's completely obvious he's Bisexual.

>>25310279
I've never seen the argument be against having straight sex though. It's always the opposite. As much as people would want to spread the blame equally, that doesn't really follow what happens.

>>25310292
Go shit up another thread.
I'd recommend SIM for the challenge. IME, they're surprisingly to really piss off.

>>25310259
This anon is right. It was gay from the start.

>>25310259
>a fucking blog post
gb2 tumblr where people give a shit about you or what you have to say

>>25310297
Because we collectively decided that we wanted to do a good job and finish the salad to secure our stay at the farm, we could've hit on her, gauged her reaction but we didn't.

>>25310345
I was more concerned with being excited for making a nice salad desu. Wouldn't have been against someone else suggesting hitting on her.

>>25310322
But no one is against having straight sex, there is only people against having gay sex here.
Also i'm pretty surprised that there are people here who after being subjected to years worth of clop and general internet deviancy haven't been turned Bi.

>>25310369
>But no one is against having straight sex, there is only people against having gay sex here.
That's what I mean. And it's the consistent point among every gay vs straight argument.

>>25310345
>>25310362
Personally, I was voting to become her sex slave the moment we encountered her.

>>25310362
I wouldn't have been against it either and was kinda suspecting it would happen, but no one did. I figured we didn't want to risk being kicked of the farm.
It seems like people here are expecting every mare they meet to be lusting over them instantly.

>>25310389
Sorry I guess I read your post wrong.

>>25310405
No worries, I likely phrased it wrong. Distracted atm.

>>25310393
>not having every female lust over within moments of meeting you
>being that beta

File: 1419536003539.jpg (6KB, 225x225px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

6KB, 225x225px

>>25310420
Are you saying Emerald is alpha?

>>25310310
>>25310310
Fuck you.

You're copping out of it when backed into the corner with Giles argument. There were do many times to has sex with him compared to any other mare or filly. It's all the QM.

Who cares if you don't like emerald being straight or bi? I guess you just want him to gargle cock all day.

>>25310437
I feel like he'll grow into it.
I'm seeing signs here and there.

File: 1445303966967.png (386KB, 667x670px) Image search: [Google] [Yandex] [Bing]

386KB, 667x670px

>>25310442
So where does the discussion go then? Go on, tell me what the end point is.

>>25310469
With you admitting that this quest was railroaded to favor gay over straight.

>>25310369
It's easy to say "nobody is against straight sex" when the chorus all agrees with having gay sex with a character and any dissent is shouted down with pathetically implemented excuses about Emerald's ball clamp.

It's like every rationale can only be apple to homosexual activity.

THAT is my problem. That strict sex is maligned from the start, and that gay sex is seen as an easier, more rewarding route.

Why's is this so?

Because the QM was against primarily heterosexual encounters from he start.