Is this finally considered /m/?
I seem to recall this was tearing this board apart a few years back.
It was always /m/, it's just that some /m/en with strong homosexual tendencies picked the losing side on the war on pants.
It's /m/ but it's an alright to meh show all things considered.
Sky Girls has it beat in every category except for buttservice, for that is something Strike Witches can't be blamed for putting not enough attention into.
>>14107323
nothing is /m/
>Tearing the board apart
Seemed to be the usual batch of "not /m/" troll memes to me. Trolls were just trying to prove they could run shows off the board, and succeeded.
Granted some of them like
>Sky girls isn't mecha musume since planes aren't mech
tried to have an actual argument, but most just seemed to be doing it to shit on the board, and they thought it was funny.
>>14107359
Indeed. Sky Girls is just a better show.
>>14107359
>>14107397
I'm glad we can all come to an agreement on this.
This deserved the 2 seasons and a movie Strike Witches got
>>14107401
Hey, at least SG told a full story without having to rehash itself 2 and a half times like the Gospel of Miyafujesus.
>>14107417
Did anyone else notice how she did a complete 180 in personality between season 1 and 2?
>Season 1 Miyafuji
>"We can reach peace and coexistence with the Nuroi if we try UNDERSTANDING!"
>Season 2 Miyafuji
>"THE ONLY GOOD NUROI IS A DEAD NUROI! KILL 'EM ALL AND LET KAMI-SAMA SORT 'EM OUT!"
Which is a shame cause the Nuroi witch was cute as fugg.
>>14107422
Last I recall even the Neuroi were all FUCK THIS NEUROI HIVE IN PARTICULAR come S2 so yeah, no room for coexistence.
>>14107401
Strike Witches has better characters, setting, animators that care and most importantly a vast world and stroylines already set out for easy writing.
Brave Witches are coming.
>>14107323
now that you get banned for saying even tokushit isn't /m/ then strike witches is as /m/ as it can get
>>14107894
Yeah but animewise the 501st have been trapped in a narrative recursion field for two seasons and a film.
A narrative recursion field so strong that when it seemed like Strike Witches couldn't get milked harder in animation it went on to birth VividRed Operation as a temporary stand-in.
>>14107323
Please go away.
>>14107323
Tank Witches was better.
But then again, it's hard to beat AKIMBO BOFORS OF FRIENDSHIP.
So, is this a Black Knight summoning thread?
I watched Strike Witches for the in-jokes about various ace pilots.
Erika is a pretty accurate portrayal of the real Hartmann.
>>14107323
it's technically /m/ but we don't have to like everything just because it's /m/
Try this shit in /sgg/, they might buy into it.
>>14108568
No, not enough butts. That's what Strike Witches is for.
>>14108573
>the OP image of /sgg/ is literally a butt
you can see where one would draw the comparison
>>14108568
This, precisely. It's the same with Infinite Stratos or KanColle - it's /m/ enough that it could be discussed, but there aren't enough diehard fans of it on /m/ to force it into existance against the sheer number of people who hate it both for being a poor show, and on general principle for being 95% moeblobs and 5% tiny mechanized boots.
![latest[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/q55P6la.jpg "latest[1].jpg")
>>14108609
I don't think people hate it. I think people don't even know it exists or just plain don't care about it.
If people hate something, there are multiple threads every day about it.
>>14108619
It's different kinds of hate. There's hate where they won't tolerate something to exist and don't want to discuss it, and there's hate where they basically want to discuss it, but to socialize around the common hatred. Hating something merely for existing rather than just hating it for being disappointing.
>>14107366
While it's cogent point that they're girl mascots of WW2 aces and planes rather than ships or robots, people will argue up and down that the original mecha musume were exactly that. And thus that since mecha musume was explicitly allowed on /m/, all forms of mecha musume are.
>>14108624
That's deep.
Is Rocketeer /m/? Cause when it comes right down to it, it's basically the same shit.
>>14108548
I liked how the Neuroi designs were based on weird but real experimental and prototype German aircraft from WWII.
>>14108573
I also liked the butts.
>>14108609
KanColle only has the cool looking Abyssal and that's it.
It sucks balls and this is coming from a guy that's considering buying a Re figure.
>>14108797
>Rocketeer
Yes.
>>14107323
What does Yoshika smell like?
How about Mio?
It's /m/ enough to stand with the likes of Symphogear, Nanoha, Vividred and Twintails. It's just not as good as any of those.
>>14109073
It's not really comparable to three of those. Symphogear is an idol/magical girl show, Nanoha a straight magical girl show, and Twintails was all parody.
Vividred is basically the same thing as Strike Witches. I'll grant you it does have that two-episode opening battle where the redshirt fleet actually gets shit done, which was better than SW.
>>14109089
On the other hand VRO doesn't have Neuroi Battleship Yamato.
I want to see them in SRW.
Flying, barrier-using SS-sized support units.
Like Tekkaman and Eva Units had love children
>>14107323
Why is this young lady so eager to show us her nether regions?
>>14109073
none of those is good
unlike strike witches
>>14107323
slut bitches isn't /m/
despite what memefaggots like nigger knight say
>>14109147
>nocaps
>hurr niggers hurr slut
You're only managing to make us SWbros look good. :^)
>>14109089
>Nanoha a straight magical girl show
Season one was a long time ago, mate.
At least it has things like the propeller boots to make it sort of /m/-ish. Unlike GnP, which is literally cute girls driving tanks and in no way sci-fi or /m/.
>>14109089
Nanoha is anything but straight.
>>14109117
Me too.
So, top five witches from the main cast? Mine are Perrine, Trude, Minna, Eila and Shirley.
>>14109089
>Nanoha a straight
yuuno pls don't you have some books to shelve
>>14110841
Sakamoto
Bishop
Hartmann
Yeager
Litvyak
>>14108964
I wish every ship is designed by Shibafu. Every ship designed by him at least have some sorta sophistication feel to it. The rest is either token or just lewd exploitation.
>>14110896
They all suck.
>>14111390
Yeeeah, a lot of Kancolle (and Strike Witches to some extent) girls are kind of boring, repetitive, generic looking yamato nadeshiko. And a fair number are skinny-ass pedobait to boot. At least the likes of Touhou, Idolmaster, and Love Live try to make their girls more colorful than just browns and blacks and sameface.
>>14110887
I feel like Sakamoto is pretty underrated among the 501 girls.
>>14109043
Miso soup
>>14108626
The Warlock appeared and made everything else moot.
>>14109175
>implying your kind will ever look "good"
fuck off, cancer pedoshit.
>>14112682
>>14109147
Someone is clearly agitated
>>14110841
Only a top three really. Hartmann, Bishop, and Eila. Special mention to Marseille
>>14110841
Harmann
Perrine
Sanya
Eila
Barkhorn
